View Full Version : Would IDW continue to put out the trades if the regular series ends?
CyberCubed
06-06-2011, 10:43 PM
Let's think of a hypothetical situation where the new IDW comics end for whatever reason, let's say they go on and end around issue 50 or something like that. The book ends because of so-so sales.
However, the hardcover trades of the old Mirage material sells pretty well in bookstores. Do you think IDW would continue to put out trades of the comics even if the new comic series ends?
FearlessLeader
06-06-2011, 10:56 PM
If they are making money and since they are a business I would hypothesize yes.
Once again though this seems like putting the cart before the horse and maybe we should actually allow the first issue and book to come out and see how they sell before we start speaking of cancellation!
Jester
06-06-2011, 10:59 PM
Fearless, CyberCubed is the king of "putting the cart before horse."
Roseangelo
06-06-2011, 10:59 PM
If they are making money and since they are a business I would hypothesize yes.
Once again though this seems like putting the cart before the horse and maybe we should actually allow the first issue and book to come out and see how they sell before we start speaking of cancellation!
Not to mention he's hypothesizing cancellation at issue #50, which would take at least 4 years to get to and that is a long time in comic book years.
This question/topic is ridiculous.
Jester
06-06-2011, 11:01 PM
These questions/topics are ridiculous.
Fixed that for ya. :D
CyberCubed
06-06-2011, 11:03 PM
We still don't know how much the IDW regular series will sell. Remember what happened with the Image series? Or Volume 4? Both started off decently but sales declined quickly throughout their run.
As much as I'd hope the IDW series to be a big hit, I'm not that naive into thinking it would sell that much better than any other TMNT series.
Yet if the trades sell well in bookstores, I would hope IDW continues to put those out even if they cancel the new monthly comics at some point.
Roseangelo
06-06-2011, 11:03 PM
Fixed that for ya. :D
By making me ungrammatical? :trazz:
FearlessLeader
06-06-2011, 11:08 PM
We still don't know how much the IDW regular series will sell. Remember what happened with the Image series? Or Volume 4? Both started off decently but sales declined quickly throughout their run.
As much as I'd hope the IDW series to be a big hit, I'm not that naive into thinking it would sell that much better than any other TMNT series.
Yet if the trades sell well in bookstores, I would hope IDW continues to put those out even if they cancel the new monthly comics at some point.
Then why did you need to start this thread as you just answered your own question right there. This is about all anyone can tell you, is we hope things will go well and they will continue selling us Turtles stuff.
Fearless, CyberCubed is the king of "putting the cart before horse."
I know, I just feel the need to point it out continuously for some odd reason whenever he posts. I can't stop myself :tlol:
Jester
06-06-2011, 11:15 PM
By making me ungrammatical? :trazz:
Fixed my fixing....:( :P
Poor Cybercubed must not get enough attention IRL. :( Cheer up, buddy.
Powder
06-06-2011, 11:31 PM
Sometimes I wonder if Mr. Cubed takes up a little trolling in his spare time, but honestly I think he just wants to keep discussions going. Though the latest flow has been a little nutsy, his productive threads far out weigh the ones in which we jest. Many a thread in the past got the ball rolling on conversation & were started by none other than roboticsquared.
oldmanwinters
06-06-2011, 11:31 PM
Poor Cybercubed must not get enough attention IRL. :( Cheer up, buddy.
Actually, that's my theory too.
I hope the IDW lasts a good long while... assuming the stories are good, of course.
Ninjinister
06-06-2011, 11:53 PM
http://img88.imageshack.us/img88/7267/krangtard.png
CyberCubed
06-07-2011, 12:35 AM
I hope the IDW series does go on longer than the Image series. Hopefully it at least makes it to 30 issues.
Perhaps its not a good idea to start a new comic series about a year before the new show and movie comes, mainly because new fans of the TMNT cartoons/movies would go and pick up the comics.
But this time the comic has at least a year head start.
So, when the show starts, new fans will already have some backlog to collect if and when it leads them to the comics.
CyberCubed
06-07-2011, 12:47 AM
But the show isn't starting till September 2012 at the earliest, by then at least 13 issues will be out and sales could already be hit or miss.
Wasn't the Image series funded out of Kevin/Peter's own pockets to keep it going after they got to #15 or something like that?
But the show isn't starting till September 2012 at the earliest, by then at least 13 issues will be out and sales could already be hit or miss.
Which may be a good strategic reason for starting this first series in 2011. If sales are dipping a year in, the attention brought by the new show will likely give the series a boost.
Wasn't the Image series funded out of Kevin/Peter's own pockets to keep it going after they got to #15 or something like that?
I don't know if it was that early, but I think Kevin did help keep the book afloat during those last few issues, yes (though Andrew or somebody can correct me if I'm wrong). This isn't an entirely uncommon thing for an independent book; many are kept alive for bit when they're floundering and losing money -- with the hope that sales will get better in the interim. In some cases, things do improve and the book is able to survive.
But I have no idea if IDW (or Viacom) would do this.
I swear I've read this topic from before Cybed. And I believe I replied with.....
Dude....If you really want this series to do well you will do your part like us other TMNT fans and pick up the issues when they come out. You gotta have faith my friend.
You gotta read your own sig "A world without TMNT is not a world I wish to live in." and act upon it.
So c'mon chin up champ no more silliness.
TristanHuwJones
06-07-2011, 03:19 AM
I hope the IDW series does go on longer than the Image series. Hopefully it at least makes it to 30 issues.
Perhaps its not a good idea to start a new comic series about a year before the new show and movie comes, mainly because new fans of the TMNT cartoons/movies would go and pick up the comics.
But this time the comic has at least a year head start.
The cartoon and the comic are two completely different things aimed at two completely different markets.
If you're worried about the comic being cancelled then go out and preorder it, the variants and the hardcover and tell everyone else to do it as well, rather than telling everyone how worried you are about it NOT doing well. You're honestly only doing the book damage by dwelling on the negatives. Start focusing on the positives and be excited for once dude!
^^^^^^^^^ couldn't have said it better myself buddy.
PizzaPower
06-07-2011, 04:55 AM
We still don't know how much the IDW regular series will sell. Remember what happened with the Image series? Or Volume 4? Both started off decently but sales declined quickly throughout their run.
As much as I'd hope the IDW series to be a big hit, I'm not that naive into thinking it would sell that much better than any other TMNT series.
Yet if the trades sell well in bookstores, I would hope IDW continues to put those out even if they cancel the new monthly comics at some point.
yea but they didnt come out on time either.
FearlessLeader
06-07-2011, 07:06 AM
But the show isn't starting till September 2012 at the earliest, by then at least 13 issues will be out and sales could already be hit or miss.
Wasn't the Image series funded out of Kevin/Peter's own pockets to keep it going after they got to #15 or something like that?
You also need to keep in mind that the Image comic series was released as the first bout of Turtles mania was starting to die down. This comic series is getting released as it is starting up again with a new series and film on the horizon.
TristanHuwJones
06-07-2011, 07:35 AM
IDW also launched Transformers LONG before any new film or show was up and running. If I recall, that Cybertron/Armada mess was winding down at the time, and the comic launched was based on an iteration that hadn't been seen properly in years. They launched GI JOE a year out from that movie, and it's still running strong. They launched Godzilla to some of the best sales figures seen in comics in years and we don't even know when that movie's hitting. They launched Angel after Buffy's popularity had been and gone and well before Dark Horse started moving ahead with Season 8... do I need to continue? :twink:
Sometimes I wonder if Mr. Cubed takes up a little trolling in his spare time, but honestly I think he just wants to keep discussions going. Though the latest flow has been a little nutsy, his productive threads far out weigh the ones in which we jest. Many a thread in the past got the ball rolling on conversation & were started by none other than roboticsquared.
Huh... I guess I need to give credit where credit is due. Props to you, Cybercubed. With all the crap we give you, you manage to put it to good use, making craponade.
:ohwell:
Though, how that's "good use" escapes me ATM.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.