View Full Version : Can we just agree...
AquaParade
06-09-2011, 02:11 PM
That City at War is the best Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles story ever?
I just re-read the thirteen part story this week, and was reminded just why I love this property. Casey's journey just feels so "human". The news he receives about his wife, in the doctors office, is such a surreal scene. The turtles act and feel like real teenage brothers, Splinters saga with the Rat King is haunting and beautiful, and the atmosphere of the story oozes of the time period of which it was written in.
Just wanted to share my love for this memorable story. I still feel like this is the quality that all future tmnt-related outings should strive to reach. What do you guys think?
FearlessLeader
06-09-2011, 02:15 PM
I completely agree. I just re-read this myself about a month ago and it never fails no matter how many times I read it that I am blown away each and every time.
It's just so well written and I love all of the character growth and interactions and I love the final show down between the Turtles and Karai and Shredder's Elite Guard.
discordiatookie
06-09-2011, 02:31 PM
But if everyone agreed on the same thing, then life would be boring!
S'much as I love City At War, I love Return To New York even more.
So no, we can't all agree :P
AquaParade
06-09-2011, 02:50 PM
But if everyone agreed on the same thing, then life would be boring!
S'much as I love City At War, I love Return To New York even more.
So no, we can't all agree :P
Great! Now the thread can get interesting.
I know I'm mostly alone in this, but I don't go back to Return to New York, very often. While there are some ideas I absolutely love, such as "Worm Shredder", I find the story to be a little more straightforward and typical with it's "infiltrating of an enemy stronghold and have the 'leader' face off against the baddie on one one." Yes, it was cool, but I feel like I've seen that a lot. To it's credit, it is one of the only 40 issues or so I kept when selling off my tmnt comics. I also kept a few other favorites such as "The River" (Which totally needs its own thread), "Souls Winter", and "Shades of Grey".
Andrew NDB
06-09-2011, 02:53 PM
Return to New York is pound for pound far superior. City at War, while awesome, could have been told in half the issues it took at no detriment to the story whatsoever.
AquaParade
06-09-2011, 03:07 PM
Return to New York is pound for pound far superior. City at War, while awesome, could have been told in half the issues it took at no detriment to the story whatsoever.
No way! ;)
City at War's storyline was much more fascinating. What are the turtles roles in society? What bonds them together? Casey and April get developed a bit as well. Not to mention the art in City at War had a certain "grime" to it that fit the turtles universe perfectly.
Of course, this is all just my opinion, Andrew.
Andrew NDB
06-09-2011, 03:11 PM
No way! ;)
City at War's storyline was much more fascinating. What are the turtles roles in society? What bonds them together?
Yeah, though they never really came up with any answers to those questions. And it didn't need to take 12 issues for them to ask them.
Casey and April get developed a bit as well.
Definitely.
I'm not saying City at War sucks, I'm just saying Return to New York is head and shoulders above it.
DrSpengler
06-09-2011, 03:24 PM
"Return to New York" is my favorite story arc, as well. I think the 3-part length makes it more rereadable and, despite only being three issues, it doesn't feel overly compressed at all. It tells a story that had been building up steadily for ten issues and feels suitably epic.
I love "City at War", don't get me wrong. It's perhaps more cerebral and emotional (particularly Casey's and April's segments), which is definately some major points in its favor, but it does feel a bit overlong and, in all honesty, the "Ninja rebellion" thing hadn't been gaining steam in the previous issues of TMNT all that much. We don't find out about the Foot civil war until #45, in a brief bit of foreshadowing, then #46-47 take a turn away from things for a time traveling arc and #48-49 acts mostly as a prologue to Casey and April's storyarcs than the actual City at War.
Whereas "Return to New York" hadd been fueled by the previous 10 issues of the series and the reckoning felt in that arc had tons of forward momentum going for it.
They're both fantastic story lines and two of TMNT's absolute best, but my favorite will always be "Return to New York".
AquaParade
06-09-2011, 03:27 PM
Yeah, though they never really came up with any answers to those questions. And it didn't need to take 12 issues for them to ask them.
Definitely.
I'm not saying City at War sucks, I'm just saying Return to New York is head and shoulders above it.
I did ponder the fact that they didn't give us answers to questions such as those. But, the fact that all the turtles were leaning different ways and the fact that it got the reader pondering those questions, was powerful enough for me. Just acknowledging the fact that the turtles aren't superheroes, but just four brothers trapped in a chain of revenge they were basically born into, really defines a huge aspect of these characters.
Seeing as I've been going through old issues this week, I'll read through Return to New York, and see if I feel any different. Good points, Dr. Spengler.
PizzaPower
06-09-2011, 03:32 PM
I'm not saying City at War sucks, I'm just saying Return to New York is head and shoulders above it.
city at war is FREAKING amazing, and i just read return to new york and it blew me away.
CyberCubed
06-09-2011, 03:42 PM
I think City at Wars greatness is why Volume 2 seemed like a disappointment coming right after it. Volume 2 was in good on its own, but it had to continue in the shadow of City at War.
azrael
06-09-2011, 03:45 PM
City at War including shades of gray are some of my favorite TMNT stories. RtNY the original story seemed like its missed different parts from being really great.
Can we just agree...
What do you guys think?
I think disagreement is the core of the human experience.
AquaParade
06-09-2011, 04:14 PM
Alright, alright, I gave the thread a crappy title.:lol:
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.