PDA

View Full Version : Why the hate?


FlippytheMaster
06-16-2011, 10:12 AM
Why is it that the 2007 TMNT seems to get a lot of hate? It got mixed reviews at best and a lot of fans like to hate on it. The thing is, I don't think it deserves so much hate. In fact, I thought it was pretty good.
So... why? Is it because it's animated? Is it the mysticism of the plot? Is it that the tone was too different than 2 & 3? What is it about this movie that makes people hate on it?

Candy Kappa
06-16-2011, 10:17 AM
I think the answer lies in the threads dedicated to the film, just have to read a little

Powder
06-16-2011, 10:29 AM
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=34205

This thread sums up everything, believe me.

gobo
06-16-2011, 02:20 PM
I still think it's childishness. It wasn't bad. It just didn't meet the high expectations people had for it. Now, run along and make fun of Teletubbies or whatever it is you kids do for fun these days.

Luzmagica
06-16-2011, 02:26 PM
Just for the record....I dont remeber if I commented in any other thread! :tgrin: I LOVE 2007 CGI movie too!!! :D

ToTheNines
06-16-2011, 04:35 PM
I don't hate it, I realize it is what it is and there's no going back and changing things so I make the most out of it when I watch it. But without rambling, here's what mainly sucked about it.

Splinter was an ass-hole and sucked up to Leo.
Leo was kind of a jerk.
Raph dressed up as some corny superhero.
Mike was a total ****ing idiot.
Don got pushed aside.
The turtles had jobs...
The soundtrack sucked.
Bad plot with all the not-so-cool creatures.
Toned down violence.
They got Casey Jones all wrong.
The whole thing felt like they were just phoning it in as a set up to a potentially much cooler movie. That never got made.
The Beauty and the Beast moment at the end.
Some painfully corny lines. ("Good night, dark prince")

Candy Kappa
06-16-2011, 04:46 PM
Bad plot with all the not-so-cool creatures.

Better yet, we didn't even see all the creatures, and we only got to see the turtles fight the yeti and Raph solo the jersey Devil.

They should have picked a smaller number like 7 or 4, or even 3.

ssjup81
06-16-2011, 04:54 PM
I always felt that movie 3 was the one that got all the hate.

gobo
06-16-2011, 06:06 PM
I always felt that movie 3 was the one that got all the hate.
While I agree, the bashing of TMNT was a tad less reasonable. Painfully irritating dialogue is the only reason I need to hate 3, and that's being generous.

Jester
06-16-2011, 06:17 PM
While I agree, the bashing of TMNT was a tad less reasonable. Painfully irritating dialogue is the only reason I need to hate 3, and that's being generous.
I don't know:
TMNT looked pretty but had a crap story.
Turtles 3 looked like crap but had a pretty good story.
Maybe I also have the rose colored glasses of nostalgia coloring my opinion of Turtles 3...I dunna.

ToTheNines
06-16-2011, 06:33 PM
Turtles 3 looked like crap but had a pretty good story.

If by good story, you mean worthy of a two part comic book issue and not a theatrical film, then yes... I'll agree with that.

Spitfire
06-17-2011, 04:55 PM
If by good story, you mean worthy of a two part comic book issue and not a theatrical film, then yes... I'll agree with that.

A two part comic that managed to way more engaging then the movie. It wasn't limited by budget so the main villains could be a giant bad ass samurai T-Rex and Savanti. Not some generic cowboy and samurai dude. Raph being responsible for the Foot Clan, awesome twist. Wet willy time, not awesome not in the least bit.

I'd probably hate turtles 3 less if the story had at least somewhat stacked up to Masks but it doesn't even come close. Aside from having the production value of a Power Rangers episode all the dialogue is poorly written and poorly delivered. The movie should be forgotten like the 90's Fantastic Four film.

As for TMNT it isn't that bad but it isn't that great either. My issue with it is it's short yet it feels long because the pacing is horrible. The opening is engaging then in the middle it slows to a complete crawl until it picks up again for the finale. I also don't like the style it's done in at all. The turtles look awful and the humans look worse. The fighting looks really strange too. The movements some how manage to look choreographed even though it's animated and there's pauses in weird spots. Then when they move it looks like they sped the footage up.

The story is pretty eh. I get they wanted to do the whole family thing but it just doesn't flow. This too is a story that would have worked better as a comic.

Brodie
06-17-2011, 05:08 PM
Mike was a total ****ing idiot.


How is this different than how he always is?

Donnie
06-17-2011, 06:43 PM
I still think it's childishness. It wasn't bad. It just didn't meet the high expectations people had for it. Now, run along and make fun of Teletubbies or whatever it is you kids do for fun these days.

:thumbsup:

Coola Yagami
06-17-2011, 07:38 PM
How is this different than how he always is?

Mikey was more of a loveable goof in the other movies... the others were ok with it. here (and in 2K3) he's just an annoyance to everyone that knows him.

ToTheNines
06-17-2011, 11:24 PM
How is this different than how he always is?

I'm a reader of the Mirage/Image comics. And he was a pretty cool character in the live action movies.

CyberCubed
06-17-2011, 11:33 PM
Michaelangelo was also very laid back in the original cartoon, besides his cravings for pizza.

ssjup81
06-18-2011, 12:45 AM
Michaelangelo was also very laid back in the original cartoon, besides his cravings for pizza.OT Mikey came across as a stoner.:tlol:

Julie
06-18-2011, 08:40 AM
I also hate that 2007 movie. They made Leo act totally not his style and be hated by many fans plus it's mainly focused on Raph but Mikey and Donny didn't play a normal role in that film. And i didn't like the plot.

Xav
06-18-2011, 10:12 AM
Toned down violence. As opposed to the other films?

Ashangelo
06-18-2011, 12:38 PM
I liked the movie.

Sure, it may have had corny dialouge, a forgettable villian/s, and a not so great story, but I love it due to the fact that it brought the turtles back to the big screen, something we haven't had since 1993.

I felt like a little kid again, and that's more than enough reason for me to like it.

ToTheNines
06-18-2011, 12:43 PM
As opposed to the other films?

I thought the martial arts was pretty impressive in the first and third movies. Secret of the Ooze was a joke in the combat department.

I just feel like they could have done a lot of cool stuff with the fights in this medium and they didn't. It was too cartoonish for the most part.

Whitewolf89
06-18-2011, 01:17 PM
Better yet, we didn't even see all the creatures, and we only got to see the turtles fight the yeti and Raph solo the jersey Devil.
True dat, and I totally agree with you in that I also wish that we could've seen them fighting the other monsters, rather than having the cop-out of the Foot (and the Stone Generals, too, of course) rounding up the majority of them. But remember, the film was only like, what, an hour-and-a-half in length. Had to pare stuff down somewhere so they could move the rest of the movie along, story and pacing-wise, so I guess they came up with THAT way to condense the time-limitations down.

Sad, but probably true.

They should have picked a smaller number like 7 or 4, or even 3.[/QUOTE]
Well, those numbers would've been okay, I guess, but probably not as suspenseful as 13. Remember, 13 is the universal number for bad luck (example: Friday the 13th), which is probably why the script-writers, producer; etc.; went with THAT number as opposed to, oh, 7 (which is actually considered a LUCKY number by some), 6, 12, or whatever.

Food for thought.:twink:

PizzaPower
06-18-2011, 02:22 PM
i loved the movie when i first saw it in theaters, and i still love it. with anything i still wish things could have been added or changed. I do wish there where more scenes of donatello and mikey, and i deff would love to see more monster scene fights, and and the roof top training scene that i swear i saw in theater.

Logan
06-18-2011, 09:17 PM
I don't hate TMNT, but I find that every time I've seen it I've been unable to recollect more than two or three scenes. For being the first Turtles film to come out in years, I felt underwhelmed by it.

Another problem that I have with it, as well as Turtles III, is that the villains aren't from pre-existing material. It would've been nice to have someone like Baxter, the Rat King, or the Triceratons. Heck, I'd have been happy with The Shredder coming back! Compounding this issue is the fact that the new villains really aren't that interesting. There's nothing about them that makes them look or feel anything other than generic bad guys.

Kendamu
06-25-2011, 02:41 AM
Raph being responsible for the Foot Clan, awesome twist.

Wait. What? I don't remember this.

Coola Yagami
06-25-2011, 11:52 AM
Ironically... even if they went with Savanti, Renet and Chote, most of us would have been left scratching out heads as to who the hell they were and why they used 'generic villians' instead of Shredder or others from the old cartoon show. I can imagine if Mirage Baxter was in in the movie, most everyone would have been confused as to why he was black and more forminable.

Jephael
06-25-2011, 05:58 PM
Ironically... even if they went with Savanti, Renet and Chote, most of us would have been left scratching out heads as to who the hell they were...

Yea, but that would've been an awesome way to introduce them to us who who just casual fans who knew nothing about the source material!

ChetTurtle
06-25-2011, 06:20 PM
I don't hate it, I realize it is what it is and there's no going back and changing things so I make the most out of it when I watch it. But without rambling, here's what mainly sucked about it.

Raph dressed up as some corny superhero.
The soundtrack sucked.

These I can't agree with, I love the soundtrack personally, And you don't say Batman's corny.


Bad plot with all the not-so-cool creatures.
Toned down violence.
Some painfully corny lines. ("Good night, dark prince")

I can agree with these.

As opposed to the other films?

I just feel like they could have done a lot of cool stuff with the fights in this medium and they didn't. It was too cartoonish for the most part.
Right and Right.

.......It's hard trying to be a defender of TMNT when their were a lot of bad things about the movie.:D

discordiatookie
06-26-2011, 06:26 AM
Wait. What? I don't remember this.

Masks, by Mike Dooney, Mirage vol 1, issues 46 & 47. Also sets the turtles in feudal Japan. Wait why am I even telling you this, you probably know that already :P

ToTheNines
06-26-2011, 09:50 PM
One defense I do have for this movie: It's the only theatrical TMNT film that doesn't feature the turtles engaging in sychronized dancing. Or any dancing at all for that matter.

Fugitoid Jones
06-29-2011, 05:54 AM
One thing I found extremely annoying was how easy it suddenly became to find one of the monsters. During the final battle, the Turtles & Co. realize that they need to find the last monster, and moments later, said monster is chasing April, Casey, Karai and Foot in the Kowabunga Karl van through the city. Monsters that had been largely unseen for hundreds of years were suddenly around every street corner and ready to show themselves.





I, like many on these here boards, find that I dislike this movie less with every repeat viewing. I really liked the movie when I saw it in theaters, but I was watching it with fan eyes who had not seen a new TMNT movie since 1993. Revisiting the movie with a more critical perspective now, it doesn't hold up well and it's flaws are much more visible. I don't hate the movie, but I'd place it 3rd out of the 4 movies.

ToTheNines
06-29-2011, 07:11 AM
One thing I found extremely annoying was how easy it suddenly became to find one of the monsters. During the final battle, the Turtles & Co. realize that they need to find the last monster, and moments later, said monster is chasing April, Casey, Karai and Foot in the Kowabunga Karl van through the city. Monsters that had been largely unseen for hundreds of years were suddenly around every street corner and ready to show themselves.

The movie should have went out of its way to explain this, but the reason all the monsters were in New York was because they were instinctively drawn to the portal when ever it was about to open. Any other point in time, they were just scattered across the globe.

Revan
06-29-2011, 08:09 AM
They don't really come right out and say it but Winter's does mention that while he is talking to Karai about finding the monsters.

Anyway if there was a huge blundering monster in NY, it's not ridiculous to assume an organization like the foot made up of ninjas and tasked with patrolling the city could be able to easily locate it

ToTheNines
06-29-2011, 09:04 AM
They don't really come right out and say it but Winter's does mention that while he is talking to Karai about finding the monsters.

He says something like "I have some guest coming into town that I'd like to roll out the red carpet for... treat them warmly".

It still doesn't explain why these international freaks decided to show up to NYC all at once.

gobo
06-29-2011, 10:01 AM
The movie should have went out of its way to explain this
It didn't? O_o I guess I need to rewatch the thing.

Revan
06-29-2011, 11:11 AM
He says something like "I have some guest coming into town that I'd like to roll out the red carpet for... treat them warmly".

It still doesn't explain why these international freaks decided to show up to NYC all at once.

I suppose not but I never had any trouble understanding why the monsters showed up for the portal. You have to read a bit into Winters' comments but it's really not that difficult to determine they are indeed drawn to it, IMO

gobo
06-29-2011, 11:19 AM
I read Murph's novelization before actually seeing the movie, so maybe it's a scenario portrayed in the book that I'm thinking of.

Revan
06-29-2011, 11:42 AM
I read Murph's novelization before actually seeing the movie, so maybe it's a scenario portrayed in the book that I'm thinking of.

You would be correct. Those who read the novelization got a direct explanation but those who just saw the movie had to come the conclusion on their own, though I stand by my judgement that it isn't that hard to figure out

From the novelization regarding the reason as to why the monsters were showing up in NY. (p. 57)

"But why? Why here? Why now?" Karai asked.
"Instinct, mostly," answered Winters. "They're animals at their core. And they recognize something familiar in the air, in the stars."

EDIT: interesting side note. The novelization provides a bit more insight into Winters and his stone generals and their conquests 3,000 years ago as well.

cloud
07-06-2011, 11:02 PM
I for one wished that they would release the complete score of the film.
Love the soundtrack, got me to fell in love with the band Meg&Dia who performed Roses for TMNT.

Powder
07-06-2011, 11:04 PM
I for one wished that they would release the complete score of the film.
Love the soundtrack, got me to fell in love with the band Meg&Dia who performed Roses for TMNT.

It can be downloaded if you look in the right places...

gobo
07-07-2011, 12:53 AM
I for one wished that they would release the complete score of the film.
Love the soundtrack, got me to fell in love with the band Meg&Dia who performed Roses for TMNT.
They did... as a limited promo.

cloud
07-07-2011, 01:10 AM
They did... as a limited promo.

Now I'm sad.

And the hunt begins

Discogod
07-07-2011, 04:06 AM
I don't hate TMNT, but I find that every time I've seen it I've been unable to recollect more than two or three scenes. For being the first Turtles film to come out in years, I felt underwhelmed by it.


This. I didn't see TMNT until about 6 weeks ago, when it was on TV one sunday afternoon. Thought it was great to look at, and fairly enjoyable for the most part (and I'm one of those hardcore Mirage fans that automatically hates every other incarnation of the turtles). But other than the Leo/Raph fight, I don't remember a single thing about it.

I will say that I would happily watch it again, which I can't say about the 2nd live-action movie (and I've never even seen the 3rd). I don't think any TMNT movie will reach the level of the first one, but it wasn't as bad as everyone makes it out to be.

Candy Cougar
09-02-2011, 12:25 PM
TMNT was a good movie. The turtles behaved appropriately to match their character, there was a good deal of action, and I liked the subtle references to the old and more familiar. Still, gotta say that the enemies kinda bored me. They seemed like generic soldiers and generic monsters. They looked good sure, but I guess I'm a little spoiled from cheesy mutated gators, rhinos, warthogs, insects, etc. Maybe it feels like bringing something back that so many people have nostalgic affection and loyalty to in its cartoon form into this new and often overused realm of CGI makes it instantly set up to disappoint long-time fans...Like we can't accept it as being the same thing no matter how good it might actually be on its own merit.

Oh and I own the DVD, but have never watched it since I first saw it in theaters. When I get cravings to watch all things ninja turtles (like I am right now), TMNT never comes to mind. Odd, because I distinctly remember enjoying the movie when I first saw it. My allegiance is with the turtles I grew up with, I s'pose...Kind of a shame I guess, since again I say that TMNT was not a bad movie.

ToTheNines
09-02-2011, 05:49 PM
The turtles behaved appropriately to match their character

Eh... errrrr... uhhhh. I dunno.

Bauer536
09-02-2011, 09:54 PM
Eh... errrrr... uhhhh. I dunno.

Well I do believe that. Sure, Leo acted like a prick when he came home. He wasn't his normal self until the end. Someone on here even told me that he said, "I'm better than you!" to Raph because he felt broken hearted that his brother would say that the rest were fine without Leo.

Plus, I have to say: It didn't cringe me when he took out all those swords on a stone general.

"Come to daddy." That just makes him so awesome.:tsmile: I only wished we saw him use them all. That would be like Legolas against orcs at the mines of Moria.

oldschoolturtlesfan
09-03-2011, 12:57 AM
I didn't really care for it. I tried to make myself love it, but just couldn't.

herugrim
09-03-2011, 01:37 PM
Well I don't hate it, but I don't love it either. I don't care for the artwork (what's the point in making a HD CG movie if you're going with 'Toon artwork?)

It was worth it for the Leo/Raph fight, but otherwise it was somewhat forgettable. Also, I can't tell where it's suppose to fit. The ending with the relics makes me thing live action, but what about Karai? She was never in the live ation films. They literally just pull her out of no where and don't even bother to define her. Between that and the artwork, TMNT feels more like a follow up to the 03 series.

Bauer536
09-03-2011, 03:08 PM
Well I don't hate it, but I don't love it either. I don't care for the artwork (what's the point in making a HD CG movie if you're going with 'Toon artwork?)

It was worth it for the Leo/Raph fight, but otherwise it was somewhat forgettable. Also, I can't tell where it's suppose to fit. The ending with the relics makes me thing live action, but what about Karai? She was never in the live ation films. They literally just pull her out of no where and don't even bother to define her. Between that and the artwork, TMNT feels more like a follow up to the 03 series.

But it's not a follow up to the 2k3 series. The image of the Shredder in the very beginning is not the 2k3 Shredder. Besides, Casey was less of a bonehead, Apirl looked younger, and Splinter was brown and not gray. Plus, they don't introduce the Stone Generals or Max Winters in the 2k3 series. Although, when I saw the new look for BTTS, I thought they were going to do that. That would've made me mad since I don't like the 2k3 series that much.

I have to say: elements from all the incarnations were somehow put in the movie. So it's a mix.

My final thoughts on the film: I enjoyed reading the junior novel which made me psyched to see the movie. The movie is good, not great. I can remember some cool scenes besides the Leo and Raph fight, but also the scene where Leo takes down these thugs in the jungle. I mean, the turtles looked great, and I loved the voice actors. Plus, that year, Playmates made some cool action figures for the film. :tsmile: Is it the best: in 2nd place. The original is in 1st . . . so far.

Candy Kappa
09-05-2011, 03:11 PM
what's the point in making a HD CG movie if you're going with 'Toon artwork?.

Because it's easier to fall into the uncanny valley with a full CGI Photo Realistic Film. Just look at films like Final Fantasy Spirits Within, Beowulf, The Polar Express.

Toby Barrett
09-05-2011, 04:30 PM
The only problem I had with this film was the same problem I had with the third.
Instead of any of the great, interesting villains from the turtles' history, the writers felt the need to come up with new, "original", boring characters that no one cares about.

Why not Triceritons? Utroms? Baxter Stockman? Rat King? Krang? ANYTHING but Patrick Stewert and a bunch of statues...

Revan
09-05-2011, 06:12 PM
http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/tmnt/deadhorse.gif

Bauer536
09-05-2011, 10:28 PM
The only problem I had with this film was the same problem I had with the third.
Instead of any of the great, interesting villains from the turtles' history, the writers felt the need to come up with new, "original", boring characters that no one cares about.

Why not Triceritons? Utroms? Baxter Stockman? Rat King? Krang? ANYTHING but Patrick Stewert and a bunch of statues...

Yeah that kind of bothered me, too. Maybe there should have been a plotline involving Karai as the next Shredder, and the Nightwatcher trying to stop her. Or what if we actually had Tatsu now taking the place of the next Shredder. That would have been cool!:tsmile:

Powder
09-05-2011, 10:51 PM
New villains are welcome in my book when done right (like Tokka & Rhazar, they ruled) but they didn't get it right the last two times.

herugrim
09-06-2011, 03:17 PM
Tatsu vs Karai would've been good. What did they call it in the comics, the City at War storyarc?

Bauer536
09-06-2011, 05:25 PM
Tatsu vs Karai would've been good. What did they call it in the comics, the City at War storyarc?

Heck, it would be a precursor to a City at War storyline.:tsmile:

You have Leo coming back from a business trip, graduates from ninja training. His mission: bring his brothers back as a team. Mike tries to cooperate, even though he is lazy to work with his nunchucks again. Donnie is happy to see Leo home again, but is having a hard time being a ninja again. Let's say the conflict may be that he's obsessed with this social network he joined and is making friends on there constantly without focusing on his training. Then Raphael . . . well, I liked the Nightwatcher story. It was interesting. I just felt by the very end of their fight, they should've just forgave each other and told Splinter everything.

Still, I felt Leo's trip should have been like 6 months or so. Not a year. (My father went overseas for 6 months, and that kind of upset me a bit. But he came back). I don't know. A year is too long. Maybe he should have taken previous trips. 5 total. A year that long from his brothers is bad. I assumed he only went to Costa Rica in the film. Then April said, "Your training period ended a year ago." I was not that satisfied. But it didn't really bother me. I just don't think a year would work for a TV series. Sometimes, I hate it when TV shows skip a year for the next season. There's no consistency in that.

Anyway, it would have been cool if Leo faced times where he wasn't trying to train his brothers. He meets Karai for the first time after stopping her from stealing weapons. At first he feels infatuated, but by the very end, he won't be once he discovers she works with the Foot and she is Shredder's daughter. That would really tick him off.

Casey and April can have that same love triangle from the film, but I would perfer April as either a scientist or news reporter this time.

Overall, I liked the movie. I was hoping that if there was a sequel, Shredder would return, April and Casey would get married, and (please forgive me) and Splitner would die from the claws of his enemy.

Heck, then that could start the story of Karai becoming the next Shredder.:tsmile:

What do you think?

Jephael
09-06-2011, 07:31 PM
See now that plot sounds 100 times better than the crapfest we got stuck with! Though I have to admit, the idea of Splinter dieing would be kind of a downer.

Bauer536
09-06-2011, 11:09 PM
See now that plot sounds 100 times better than the crapfest we got stuck with! Though I have to admit, the idea of Splinter dieing would be kind of a downer.

You know, now that I think about it, it was good, but not great. I did find problems with it. But at least it's not the third film.:tlol: I did think Playmates made some cool action figures for the film, though. Even that Shredder that wasn't in the film was awesome.

Anyway, I'm glad you liked it.:tsmile: I was thinking about tweaking a lot from the fourth film to use it for a possible future fan fiction or television idea. I'm sorry you don't like the idea of Splinter getting killed. I know Leo wouldn't. He'd be sobbing for days. But, hey. The turtles got to move on some time.

Walkabout
09-27-2011, 02:17 AM
Im not a fan of Splinter dying :cry: