PDA

View Full Version : The new movie should be made like X-men: First Class


CyberCubed
06-16-2011, 07:27 PM
X-men: First Class was probably the best comic book movie since "The Dark Knight." The themes of mutant isolation and fear from humans has always been X-men's strong points especially dealing with real life parallel's such as racism, sexism, and homosexuality.

The TMNT franchise has similar themes with the Turtles hiding from the outside world out of fear of rejection and hatred. While the Turtles are definitely more, "easy going" with not fitting in with the outside world, it has a similar set up.

Who thinks TMNT should have similar themes to X-men first class?

Jester
06-16-2011, 07:42 PM
The Turtles and X-men are waaaay to different. Yeah, they're mutants, isolated from society, but it has never had the parallels between mutants and racism/homophobia. It won't work that well.

CyberCubed
06-16-2011, 07:50 PM
Yeah, the Turtles being outcasts doesn't seem to bother them THAT much. They only ever bring it up once in a while. Mainly because they meet creatures as strange as they are and have human friends.

Candy Kappa
06-16-2011, 07:50 PM
as Jester said they are way too different, but as for quality work. I do hope TMNT get a film that can be in the ranks of Dark Knight, Watchmen and First Class

ToTheNines
06-16-2011, 08:02 PM
This franchise is due for its "Batman Begins", so to speak.

Koi
06-16-2011, 08:21 PM
The difference between xmen and tmnt is pretty much what Jester said. I wouldn't want to see the TMNT go the direction of X-Men. I don't think the turtles would work using the same "parallels" as X-men. They are mutant turtles that live in the sewers come up kick butt go back down, TMNT looks stupid when it gets any dark/edgy treatment of any sort. Keep it campy, it seemed to work really well in the past and should work still using the same shtick.

This franchise is due for nothing.

I'd personally like to see an animated/cgi TMNT film made by Disney/Pixar. But that crap ain't happenin'.

ToTheNines
06-16-2011, 08:33 PM
This franchise is due for nothing.

The f*ck does that mean?

Koi
06-16-2011, 08:40 PM
It is just fine and doesn't have anything that it is due for. It is a different franchise from Batman/xmen/whatever and won't go through the same cycles because it will go through it's own separate cycles as time goes on.

ToTheNines
06-16-2011, 08:44 PM
Mmmmmkay, I realize that... I'm just saying that TMNT needs to bust out with a really great theatrical film that revitalizes interest in the franchise and shows everyone what it's all about. Like Batman Begins did for Batman.

Jester
06-16-2011, 08:54 PM
I dunna Orangey.
Batman started as gritty comic, got a campy TV show and was reborn with a dark movie and later serious animated series, and 3 movies that people think got progressively worse. Then came Batman Begins
TMNT started with a gritty comic, got a campy TV show, and eventually a slightly darker movie, 3 squeals that people think got progressively worse, and much later an serious animated series.

Maybe we are due a TMNT Begins...

Koi
06-16-2011, 09:07 PM
The big difference though is that edgy works better for Batman, and campy works better for TMNT. These franchises are total frinkin' opposites.

Going with your timeline, The batman begins for TMNT was the 2007 film. Which blows, but looks pretty.

Jester
06-16-2011, 09:24 PM
The big difference though is that edgy works better for Batman, and campy works better for TMNT. These franchises are total frinkin' opposites.

Going with your timeline, The batman begins for TMNT was the 2007 film. Which blows, but looks pretty.
I think we need a movie like the 1st Turtle flick, maybe a little more dark.
I'm sure there are people who would disagree that the Turtles work best as camp...I'm looking at you Mr. Modeen.
And I count TMNT as one of the 3 "squeals." See:
...a slightly darker movie, 3 squeals that people think got progressively worse...

Andrew NDB
06-16-2011, 09:31 PM
This franchise is due for its "Batman Begins", so to speak.

Maybe the next time around.

Jester
06-16-2011, 09:33 PM
Maybe the next time around.
Who knows...the script ain't written yet. We might just get the best TMNT flick yet.

Andrew NDB
06-16-2011, 09:34 PM
Who knows...the script ain't written yet.

You mean the script isn't set in stone yet. There's been at least three TMNT Part 5 scripts written so far already.

sdp
06-16-2011, 09:40 PM
Many great movies come out of last minute/shaky developments, Iron Man and the new X-Men are recent examples. I think Viacom realizes TMNT can be the next transformers Box Office wise, we won't get the super gritty version Andrew wants but we also won't get another TMNT (2007), a PG13 movie that can be enjoyed by kids who buy the toys as well as older teens and adults.

edit: hmm thought this was the other topic, oh well for a more in topic discussion X-Men and TMNT have totally different themes not to mention theres plenty of franchises that have copies the X-Men formula and I wouldn't want that to be done with TMNT.

Revan
06-16-2011, 09:41 PM
They are different. Humans know the mutants exist in X-Men. Only a select few humans know the tmnt exist (volume 4 notwithstanding). And I think Jester is right, the tmnt occasionally express regret about their lot in life but it is quite rare. They are just a family trying to make their way in the world. They're not heroes.

CyberCubed
06-16-2011, 09:51 PM
You mean the script isn't set in stone yet. There's been at least three TMNT Part 5 scripts written so far already.

Doesn't the fact that they keep turning down scripts prove they don't just want to throw any crap movie out in theaters and just go with it? They seem to want to make a decent movie here, or else they would have just run with the first script they got.

Andrew NDB
06-16-2011, 10:10 PM
Doesn't the fact that they keep turning down scripts prove they don't just want to throw any crap movie out in theaters and just go with it?

Not at all. The financiers' concerns are ones of issues besides, "What would be the best story?" ("what will maximize toy profits"/"it's too dark for 9 year olds to watch!"/"somewhere, somehow, someone MIGHT get offended so it all needs to be reworked!!" etc etc)

Koi
06-16-2011, 10:23 PM
And I count TMNT as one of the 3 "squeals." See:

You may count it as one, but it ain't.

Jester
06-16-2011, 10:39 PM
You may count it as one, but it ain't.
Ok, it's an imperfect analogy...

Andrew NDB
06-16-2011, 10:44 PM
You may count it as one, but it ain't.

The writer/director does. That's good enough for me.

gobo
06-16-2011, 10:46 PM
The new movie should be made like X-men: First Class
You mean it should be a glorified made-for-TV movie? No effin' thanks, dude.

CyberCubed
06-16-2011, 10:55 PM
X-men: First Class was easily the best X-men movie. Granted I haven't rewatched X1 or X-men 2 in a long time, but I'm sure I only think they're as good because of nostalgia goggles.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-16-2011, 11:15 PM
X-men: First Class was probably the best comic book movie since "The Dark Knight." The themes of mutant isolation and fear from humans has always been X-men's strong points especially dealing with real life parallel's such as racism, sexism, and homosexuality.

The TMNT franchise has similar themes with the Turtles hiding from the outside world out of fear of rejection and hatred. While the Turtles are definitely more, "easy going" with not fitting in with the outside world, it has a similar set up.

Who thinks TMNT should have similar themes to X-men first class?

As others have said, it wouldn't work. The mutants in X-Men work as an analogy of oppressed "minorities" in society. The TMNT aren't an entire group of people, they're just four beings (well, five, if you include Splinter). The mutants in X-Men are different and such, but they are normal (as in, there's many of them all around), but the TMNT are unique and don't belong to society. There are no parallels when it comes to this topic. It just can't and won't work. If there's anything that needs to be highlighted about how the TMNT are different, it should be in the same way that they did it in volume 1, issue 28.

TMNT looks stupid when it gets any dark/edgy treatment of any sort. Keep it campy

Uhhh...

http://img716.imageshack.us/img716/2701/01coverw.jpg

It should go without saying, as a fan of the original comics, that I disagree with your statement.

I dunna Orangey.
Batman started as gritty comic, got a campy TV show and was reborn with a dark movie and later serious animated series, and 3 movies that people think got progressively worse. Then came Batman Begins
TMNT started with a gritty comic, got a campy TV show, and eventually a slightly darker movie, 3 squeals that people think got progressively worse, and much later an serious animated series.

Maybe we are due a TMNT Begins...

Man, oh man, I can only hope we get a "TMNT Begins" (for lack of a better term). Honestly, one of the things that made so many people love the first movie is BECAUSE it was more dark/serious than the cartoon that was out at the time, so I'm sure the average TMNT fan would appreciate that kind of treatment for the TMNT.

You mean it should be a glorified made-for-TV movie? No effin' thanks, dude.

That's... not a very accurate description of First Class at all.

X-men: First Class was easily the best X-men movie. Granted I haven't rewatched X1 or X-men 2 in a long time, but I'm sure I only think they're as good because of nostalgia goggles.

I feel weird to be agreeing with CyberCubed on something, considering I usually don't and he seems to have a bit of a bad rep, but I will admit that First Class really was better than any of the previous X-Men movies. Granted, with X3 and Wolverine, there's not much competition...

Redeemer
06-16-2011, 11:38 PM
I think TMNT 2013 should be made as TMNT 2013

gobo
06-16-2011, 11:40 PM
I think TMNT 2013 should be made as TMNT 2013
:lol: That'd never work.

Jester
06-16-2011, 11:50 PM
I think TMNT 2013 should be made as TMNT 2013
Come again?

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-16-2011, 11:50 PM
I think TMNT 2013 should be made as TMNT 2013

It's so crazy that it just might work!

Andrew NDB
06-17-2011, 12:05 AM
I think TMNT 2013 should be made as TMNT 2013

There's times when I think it maybe shouldn't be made at all. But I'm curious enough to see what kind of take Bay & co. are interested in... but I'm not even cautiously optimistic about it.

Jester
06-17-2011, 12:09 AM
There's times when I think it maybe shouldn't be made at all. But I'm curious enough to see what kind of take Bay & co. are interested in... but I'm not even cautiously optimistic about it.
I'm beginning to think nothing short of a straight adaptation of the Mirage comics will make you happy....what am I saying, it's obvious that's so.

gobo
06-17-2011, 12:15 AM
^ State the obvious much? :P

Jester
06-17-2011, 12:17 AM
^ State the obvious much? :P
I had to get to 11,000+ posts some how...

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-17-2011, 12:19 AM
I'm beginning to think nothing short of a straight adaptation of the Mirage comics will make you happy....what am I saying, it's obvious that's so.

Then I doubt he'll EVER be happy with any TMNT movie that comes out. As awesome as a straight adaptation of the original comics would be, I doubt it'll ever happen. There's still bound to be stuff like multi-colored headbands and such, and while I don't think a PG-13 TMNT movie is out of the question (I'm hoping that's what TMNT 2013 will be), how many comic book movies are EVER really, REALLY faithful to the source material? It's a rarity, to say the least.

Andrew NDB
06-17-2011, 12:19 AM
I'm beginning to think nothing short of a straight adaptation of the Mirage comics will make you happy....what am I saying, it's obvious that's so.

A pretty true-to-form kneejerk reaction to jump to as any. Expecting or hoping for a straight adaptation is pretty absurd, but from my perspective -- and in this comic-to-film day and age, seems to make business sense -- a relatively faithful adaptation is the one avenue they've never really explored.

They oughta.

Jester
06-17-2011, 12:23 AM
A pretty true-to-form kneejerk reaction to jump to as any. Expecting or hoping for a straight adaptation is pretty absurd, but from my perspective -- and in this comic-to-film day and age, seems to make business sense -- a relatively faithful adaptation is the one avenue they've never really explored.

They oughta.
The best Turtle movie to date was a wonderful mix of the "known" elements of the Turtles (April's a reporter, multi-colored head bands) and several Mirage issues. Something similar in tone to the Barron flick would be awesome.

gobo
06-17-2011, 12:32 AM
^ State the obvious much? :P

Jester
06-17-2011, 12:38 AM
^ state the obvious much? :p
echo!! echo!! echo!

Donnie
06-17-2011, 01:16 AM
:lol:

Oh you guys, you're all a very humorous bunch, you know that?!

I actually for once agree with CyberCubed in the off-topic side note of X-Men FC easily being the best of the X-Men movies. Hands down.

TMNT Begins? Sounds amazing to me, and I would belong to the camp that agrees it's needed and deserved. I really think we may get something good from Bay & co. But sometimes I'm overly optimistic!

Ville Leskinen
06-17-2011, 02:40 AM
A dark, gritty version might not always work:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDX1m0Y2Vkg

as one can see in this fan-made pokemon trailer (although it's campy but in a different way) but surely the TMNT have always had a darker edge to them (compared to pokemon)? And for those whose say the x-men are totally different; in the first movie even Splinter states: "Even those who would be our allies, would not understand. Our domain is the shadow." Now that goes with the ninja theme but anyway.

Powder
06-17-2011, 02:44 AM
Might not always work? You use that as an example? Read the comments, everyone wants a film like that.
Nearly 8 million views, hardly any dislikes compared to likes...

Jester
06-17-2011, 02:55 AM
And for those whose say the x-men are totally different; in the first movie even Splinter states: "Even those who would be our allies, would not understand. Our domain is the shadow." Now that goes with the ninja theme but anyway.
Then the Turtles are the Morlocks....they aren't mutants who are basically normal except for their powers...they are "monsters." The point of the X-men allegory is that "they look just like you, but..." The Turtles is very different. The X-men "hide in plain sight."

PizzaPower
06-17-2011, 04:46 AM
oh oh oh i know i know!! Time Shares!!! Bring the x-men and tmnt togather!

Jester
06-17-2011, 04:49 AM
Leave the jokes to the professionals, Double P.

Ville Leskinen
06-17-2011, 07:14 AM
Might not always work? You use that as an example? Read the comments, everyone wants a film like that.
Nearly 8 million views, hardly any dislikes compared to likes...

If only the "how many views you get on youtube" was the indicator of good stuff...but I guess to some it is. Whatever, never mind me yapping :tgrumble:

Powder
06-17-2011, 07:16 AM
It isn't usually, but most Pokemon fans I know want to see a film like that. Besides the likes speaks for it.
Just 'cause ya don't think it works doesn't mean that's the case.

sdp
06-17-2011, 11:30 AM
Wait, are you suggesting the gritty Pokemon movie is a good idea? Its awesome for a fan trailer but this is hardly what I'd ever want to see Pokemon become.

CyberCubed
06-17-2011, 11:31 AM
Its times like this I am glad Pokemon is owned by Nintendo, because they would never allow their franchise to be turned into something like that.

1984TMNT
06-17-2011, 12:50 PM
Mmmmmkay, I realize that... I'm just saying that TMNT needs to bust out with a really great theatrical film that revitalizes interest in the franchise and shows everyone what it's all about. Like Batman Begins did for Batman.

QFT. The TMNT definitely need their version of Batman Begins. We should only be this lucky. I agree with most above - I think the X-Men characters are much different than the Turtles. I see where Cyber is going with his idea, but I think the themes of persecution, cleansing the Earth of the TMNT's existence, etc. doesn't quite seem to fit in their world (Unless we're talking about Shredder or the other Villain's perspective). They are basically an anomaly in their world, while the Mutants in X Men are a race of people...much different scale.

FearlessLeader
06-17-2011, 01:53 PM
While I won't say I agree that the characters or plot points in the two franchises are similar in anyway.

I would, like pretty much like everyone here for Turtles to get a genuine, intelligent (for a comic book film), fun script written that would really draw new and old fans into the theater, like pretty much every good comic book film has been doing lately.

Coola Yagami
06-17-2011, 04:27 PM
They're not the same... The Turtles live in sewers and apart from an occasional romp for pizza, don't mingle much in the outside world unless it involves an adventure... which is mostly at night lurking in the shadows anyways... And most of all.. there are only 4...

X-Men is about more than just them, it deals with mutants everywhere where 1 out of every 5 human can be a mutant and how the world rejects them and the battle between Xavier wanting mutants and humans to work together... and how Magneto wants to wage war on humans.

So... unless New York city is sharing their population with mutant turtles and other animals all over the place and have to deal with hate groups that just want normal humans and to get rid of this sudden outburst of animal-people.... no... TMNT doesn't work as a X-Men thing...

The Stryker
06-17-2011, 07:09 PM
I agree. It should be set in the 60s.

Venom
06-17-2011, 07:14 PM
TMNT looks stupid when it gets any dark/edgy treatment of any sort.

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAAAAA*gasp*ohgod, ohgod...:goof:*smirks*:goofygri: AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA :evilgrin:

Leonardo87
06-18-2011, 01:30 AM
Orangey has much to learn; training by reading comics you must! Mirage is your friend.

ChetTurtle
06-18-2011, 03:29 AM
The big difference though is that edgy works better for Batman, and campy works better for TMNT. These franchises are total frinkin' opposites.

TMNT issue 1, a parody of Batman, X-men and Daredevil.

That said, X-men is pretty different to tmnt in themes, in X-men mutants are outcasts in society, whereas the turtles aren't even in society.

That said, I haven't seen X-men. EDIT: X-men, FC

Revan
06-18-2011, 07:53 AM
TMNT issue 1, a parody of Batman, X-men and Daredevil.

"Parody" being used loosely. PL doesn't seem to think so despite the obvious resemblance to Daredevil and Ronin. Though I have never heard anyone claim it was a parody of batman or x-men; that's a new one on me.

I'm not sure I like the term parody when being used to describe vol 1 #1; whether it is or not. I suppose it depends on how you read it; meaning if you take it seriously, it can be a serious comic. But if you step back and think about what you are reading (walking, talking, anthropomorphic turtles) it is quite goofy. There are obvious aspects taken right from Frank Miller's stories (the foot, splinter, and even Chet)

gobo
06-18-2011, 11:16 AM
It's more of a satire. But, because a lot of elements were derrived from that one source, Daredevil, they figured "parody" was a more descriptive term.

Spitfire
06-18-2011, 05:40 PM
Those themes only work in a world where there's more then just 5 mutants. The impact of them would only be seen fully if the turtles were to be discovered.

What the next turtles movie needs is for them to act like ninjas.

shuriken
06-18-2011, 06:20 PM
I agree. It should be set in the 60s.

I thought the same thing when I read the topic too :lol:
Anyway, No.

ChetTurtle
06-18-2011, 07:14 PM
It's more of a satire. But, because a lot of elements were derrived from that one source, Daredevil, they figured "parody" was a more descriptive term.

I suppose you're right, I was just trying to point out that Batman and TMNT aren't too different.:D

Xav
06-19-2011, 05:26 AM
Though I have never heard anyone claim it was a parody of batman or x-men; that's a new one on me. Well not Batman but Eastman did say X-Men was one of the comics they stole ideas from.

Revan
06-19-2011, 08:40 AM
Well not Batman but Eastman did say X-Men was one of the comics they stole ideas from.

http://i207.photobucket.com/albums/bb94/kalaneutrino/pics/x-turtles.jpg

gobo
06-19-2011, 10:47 AM
^_^ Whose art is that?

Revan
06-19-2011, 11:54 AM
not mine. I have no idea. Found it while doing some x-men to turtle research for this thread

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-19-2011, 02:14 PM
Well, so long as we're sharing crossover art, here's a neat pin-up from the 2nd printing of vol 1 issue 7 of the original comics:

http://img709.imageshack.us/img709/3496/18585930.jpg

Jo Dawn
06-19-2011, 02:20 PM
as Jester said they are way too different, but as for quality work. I do hope TMNT get a film that can be in the ranks of Dark Knight, Watchmen and First Class

I hope so too, but I don't think it will happen. For some reason, they refuse to do anything TMNT that isn't 'kiddish', at least in some aspect. It would be beyond awesome if we could get a great grown up TMNT.


The big difference though is that edgy works better for Batman, and campy works better for TMNT. These franchises are total frinkin' opposites.



I disagree totally. Batman had great success as 'campy' with the Adam West version, and still made an awesome gritty movie. Campy does not work better for TMNT, unless you are strictly a fan of the 80's cartoon.
TMNT looks stupid when it gets any dark/edgy treatment of any sort.

Ok, that answered that question.

I, personally, do not like the turtles as campy at all. But you can't say campy works better for TMNT because they've never done a gritty treatment of them on par with, say, The Dark Knight. You need equal things to base it on to come up with a statement like that. It doesn't even need to be gritty, just more adult, like Transformers or something. But they've never tried it, and if they don't, I feel like they are missing a huge chance and wasting a lot of potential.

I would, like pretty much like everyone here for Turtles to get a genuine, intelligent (for a comic book film), fun script written that would really draw new and old fans into the theater, like pretty much every good comic book film has been doing lately.

Exactly. So, when do they start listening to the fans that aren't in the 5 and under set? Or with the mentality of it?

Koi
06-19-2011, 04:43 PM
Orangey has much to learn; training by reading comics you must! Mirage is your friend.

I thought the comics sucked... I can't see how actually anyone could like that crap to be totally honost. I really do think the comics have nothing to them.

Campy does not work better for TMNT, unless you are strictly a fan of the 80's cartoon.

That explains why the OT TMNT show bombed in comparrison to all other reincarnations of the franchise.

Revan
06-19-2011, 05:31 PM
That explains why the OT TMNT show bombed in comparrison to all other reincarnations of the franchise.

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/rb8a894tua.jpg

What? The OT was the MOST successful of them all. It's not what started everything but it is what carried the franchise to amazing popularity. TURTLE MANIA!

Koi
06-19-2011, 05:34 PM
I was being sarcastic, to prove a point.

CyberCubed
06-19-2011, 05:50 PM
I thought the comics sucked... I can't see how actually anyone could like that crap to be totally honost. I really do think the comics have nothing to them.

That explains why the OT TMNT show bombed in comparrison to all other reincarnations of the franchise.

Which comics did you read? There's like 300 of them.

ChetTurtle
06-19-2011, 05:59 PM
What? The OT was the MOST successful of them all. It's not what started everything but it is what carried the franchise to amazing popularity. TURTLE MANIA!

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/rb8a894tua.jpg

Koi
06-19-2011, 06:09 PM
Which comics did you read? There's like 300 of them.
Mostly volume 1, and quite a few Tales volume 2. Glanced through some others. Seriously though, the artwork is crap to mediocre for the majority of the comics. The comics were made as a satire and it shows, and they are boring satires at that. I don't see how people can really like the comics. It just seems really overglorified to me when reading through the forum.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-19-2011, 06:38 PM
If nothing more, this certainly does explain why you think the TMNT should always be campy and nothing more, but I'm afraid that I greatly disagree with your opinion and point of view, Orangey. :ohwell:

I should mention that the original comics being successful in the first place is why there was a cartoon afterward. Perhaps you can't see why people ever liked the comics, but the fact that people did and still do like them is enough to warrant that there's more to them than what you might perceive.

Koi
06-19-2011, 06:45 PM
I should mention that the original comics being successful in the first place is why there was a cartoon afterward.

It was successful because of the cartoon, the only people who like the comics are "hardcore" TMNT fans. Which is why I am guessing people like the comics, because they like the franchise enough to not care.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-19-2011, 06:58 PM
It was successful because of the cartoon

The cartoon didn't come out until 1987 (and even then, it wasn't quite the gigantic success that everyone remembers it as until 1989, when the franchise became a phenomenon). The comic started in 1984 and was the most successful indie comic of its time. It may not have been the juggernaut that the 1987 cartoon ended up as, but it was still pretty darn successful, and yes, prior to the existence of the cartoon. There was a successful TMNT RPG before the cartoon (in fact, if anything, the cartoon ended up hurting the sales of the RPG, and was the sole reason Palladium never renewed their license), and there were miniature figures by Dark Horse before the cartoon.

To reiterate, the comic didn't need the cartoon to be popular. Sure, it wasn't mainstream, but it was popular among comic book readers, and the first issue alone was reprinted several times before the cartoon had ever seen the light of day.

FearlessLeader
06-19-2011, 07:00 PM
Mostly volume 1, and quite a few Tales volume 2. Glanced through some others. Seriously though, the artwork is crap to mediocre for the majority of the comics. The comics were made as a satire and it shows, and they are boring satires at that. I don't see how people can really like the comics. It just seems really overglorified to me when reading through the forum.

Personally I don't understand how you can't like the comics. I love a lot of the art, the characterizations of guys are the best and I really enjoy how thought provoking and interesting the stories are.

This is why it's awesome that everyone is different and we can all like a variety of things.

Koi
06-19-2011, 07:06 PM
Sure, it wasn't mainstream, but it was popular among comic book readers.

TMNT would of died...

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-19-2011, 07:07 PM
If I could just add one thing, though: I'm not condemning you for not liking the comics, Orangey. But I am calling you out for thinking that the comic never stood up on its own two legs. You may not understand why people like the comics, but to jump to the conclusion that everyone who does, likes it solely because of the cartoon is flawed logic. If the comic hadn't have had any success, there wouldn't have been a point in producing a cartoon/action-figure line at all.

Koi
06-19-2011, 07:16 PM
but to jump to the conclusion that everyone who does, likes it solely because of the cartoon is flawed logic.
My logic was that only tmnt nerds liked them...

The Stryker
06-19-2011, 07:24 PM
Yes. Everyone loved the comics! That's why when anyone mentions Ninja Turtles people respond with 'AW YEAH! Remember when they fought Savanti Romero?! AH LOVE DAT ONE!' Also why Mirage is still making all of those great books right no- Wait.

TMNT did start as satire and it was fun as that for an issue or two but then they got their heads up their own asses with these 'deep' and 'emotional' arcs that could put a room full of insomniacs into a coma.

Don't give me a happy meal and try to sell it as fine dining.

FearlessLeader
06-19-2011, 07:40 PM
I get that some of you don't like the comics.

Some of us do.

There really is no reason for one side to need to be sarcastic or rude to the other side just because we have a difference of opinion.

I personally do not agree with the last two comments in this thread before mine, but it's just my opinion and I respect that both of you are entitled to yours also.

Jo Dawn
06-19-2011, 08:27 PM
That explains why the OT TMNT show bombed in comparrison to all other reincarnations of the franchise.

No, see, the OT cartoon was good for it's time. In that era. We all realize that. But it's not 1987 anymore. They need to move on from that, because that will not fly at this time. Did you ever think that continuing to try to be like your precious 80's cartoon might be why the cartoons we have of them are bombing now? Thus far, the second it gets campy, people stop watching. Maybe the inability to move on from what worked almost 30 years ago is hindering growth ability today?

Time to move on and try something new.

My logic was that only tmnt nerds liked them...

I find it interesting that you consider having a well-rounded background and education of the franchise a bad thing, and put people down that actually do. Please try to look past this one-note argument and see other people's opinions for what they are, and we can have a great discussion as adults.

Revan
06-19-2011, 08:36 PM
It was successful because of the cartoon

I have always felt this way as well. I would never have been a fan were it not for the cartoon.

Personally I don't understand how you can't like the comics. I love a lot of the art, the characterizations of guys are the best and I really enjoy how thought provoking and interesting the stories are.

There are more interesting and just better all around comics out there than tmnt. I can understand how an avid comic book reader would feel the way Orangey does. Though I do not share that opinion, it is not that difficult to understand how someone wouldn't like tmnt comics.

TMNT would of died...

Possibly. The OT definitely gave the franchise a shot of adrenaline and regardless of how PL felt about the OT's silliness, he got RICH!

Years after the OT ended, tmnt comics stopped making money. Mirage was losing money on the books and they died. The OT was huge for tmnt.

There were tmnt fans before the OT but there were far more after it came out.

Koi
06-19-2011, 08:54 PM
Did you ever think that continuing to try to be like your precious 80's cartoon might be why the cartoons we have of them are bombing now? Thus far, the second it gets campy, people stop watching.

I find it interesting that you consider having a well-rounded background and education of the franchise a bad thing, and put people down that actually do. Please try to look past this one-note argument and see other people's opinions for what they are, and we can have a great discussion as adults.

So that is why the majority of cartoons today aren't campy and no one is watching them...

Way to read way into **** bro.

Jo Dawn
06-19-2011, 09:35 PM
No, you edited what I posted. My point is being missed. I'm talking about growth over time, for this particular show. Not every show out there.

Koi
06-19-2011, 09:41 PM
No, you edited what I posted. My point is being missed. I'm talking about growth over time, for this particular show. Not every show out there.

I like turtles.

Jester
06-19-2011, 09:51 PM
I loved the Fred Wolf series, still do. But as I grew up I wanted the Turtles to grow with me, and that's why I watched the 4Kids aeries and even read some of the comics (I'll admit, I think I've only read up until issue 4, but I have lots of stuff I'm doing.) I try to take every thing Turtles with a grain of salt, and give it all a fair shake. I like to see different interpretations of these characters.

The Stryker
06-19-2011, 10:19 PM
So you want them to do something new by doing the same thing they did in the comics. Not exactly new.

Oh Jo.

CyberCubed
06-19-2011, 10:45 PM
How ironic, since the first Turtles movie was loosely based on most of the early Mirage comics. And yet people loved that movie.

Koi
06-19-2011, 11:00 PM
Loosely being the word.

Jo Dawn
06-19-2011, 11:01 PM
So you want them to do something new by doing the same thing they did in the comics. Not exactly new.

Oh Jo.

No, I never said that I wanted it to follow the comics exactly, nor did I say it had to be 'new'. I never even really mentioned the comics. Again, I was speaking in terms of growth of a franchise as times change and the multitude of possibilities that might be missed if said growth does not occur.

Though if full circle must occur... ;)

Not that the comics are even my favorite medium of the group.

I just always like to think of new possibilities and a way to better things.

CyberCubed
06-19-2011, 11:07 PM
Loosely being the word.

It was almost exactly the same plots as those early issues, the only thing they excluded is Shredder being killed early on so they could clone him like the comics did, and that was obviously cut because they couldn't fit that all into one movie and have it with good pacing. Anything else they didn't do was obviously because of time restraints and this movie was also an origin story.

The first movie was actually a very good adaption of those early Mirage comics, and that's what people want to see more of.

Koi
06-19-2011, 11:23 PM
The first movie was actually a very good adaption of those early Mirage comics, and that's what people want to see more of.

What people?

Watching people like Doug and James TGWTG/AVGN make me think that people went to the movies thinking it would be based on the OT show. Also kids will watch anything that is loud and has colorful crap going around on the screen. Really, anything will work on screen as long as they have those two consisting things.

Revan
06-19-2011, 11:31 PM
What people?

I believe he is referring to Mirage comic book fans

Koi
06-19-2011, 11:54 PM
I believe he is referring to Mirage comic book fans
k

I also get that you guys would like a mirage-esc movie since it is what you guys like. I just don't think the entire idea of a dark movie with mutant turtles in their teenage years that know ninjitsu would work to well. Not everything is better when it gets the edgey treatment, and I do believe TMNT is just one of those things that wouldn't work mainstream rebooted into an edgey adult movie.

Powder
06-20-2011, 12:17 AM
You only say that because you refuse to like turtles that aren't party dudes.
They've been dark, edgy, & even adult in the comics & obviously there are a lot of people who like it.

For 25 years the public has really only seen those cartoony turtles, & I think they'd like a change of pace provided the turtles had personalities that could fit in any of the different versions.

Slap-Happy
06-20-2011, 01:04 AM
If a TMNT film is as dark and gritty as the first few issues of Vol. 1, then it needs to be so dark and gritty that it becomes self parody.

The tone should be like Iron Man, a comedy with action a few bits of drama.

Spitfire
06-20-2011, 01:11 AM
What it needs to be like is Hellboy, 2 specifically. It had great costume effects, a sense of humor, and the kind of sci-fi/fantasy material turtles is known for. it would work perfectly as a base formula. It's not all bright and colorful but the material is still light hearted enough to be fun with a frame work that leaves room for serious when necessary.

As for the popularity of the comics you can't really question them. Turtles is one of the biggest independent comic success stories of all time. Mirage halting production on the books means nothing but the creator is tired of dealing with them. If there was no money to be made IDW wouldn't be releasing a new series and Viacom would have let TMNT comics die all together.

Candy Kappa
06-20-2011, 09:01 AM
there is a golden middle way...


People make the comics sound like it was just Reptile Sin City

Jester
06-20-2011, 09:08 AM
Why is it so hard to appreciate the franchise as a whole, and not just segments like the Fred Wold series or the Mirage comics? Yes, there are Turtle things that are painful, like NM and the post-Getting Down live action stuff but I still give the Turtles a shot regardless.

And why do we also give kids so little credit? They're smarter and more discerning than we think.

gobo
06-20-2011, 12:21 PM
Why is it so hard to appreciate the franchise as a whole, and not just segments like the Fred Wold series or the Mirage comics?
Just because.

shuriken
06-20-2011, 01:09 PM
I just want a decent or awesome/entertaining movie made about 4 mutant teenage turtles that happen to know Ninjitsu and live in a damn sewer under the watchfull eye of their mutant rat sensei. Is that so much to ask for? If it's campy and it works then by all means go with it. If it's dark and edgy and it works, then go with that. If there's a happy median that works then go with that. I agree about the Hellboy movie and it's tone, I think it'd fit well for the TMNT.
I like a lot of different versions of the TMNT (I also dislike quite a few). But it's the ridiculous range that the TMNT have that makes them awesome to me. Is the 1st Volume of TMNT amazing? No. Do I enjoy it for what it is more than a lot of mainstream Comics? Hell yeah. Now I don't think the TMNT should be classified soley as campy or solely as dark and edgy, but a happy median as I have stated (and many others have) time and time again.

Koi
06-20-2011, 02:45 PM
You only say that because you refuse to like turtles that aren't party dudes.
They've been dark, edgy, & even adult in the comics & obviously there are a lot of people who like it.

I refuse to like the turtles that aren't party dudes? Seriously though, no one really cares for the comics besides turtle fans and some others. Nothing wrong with that. It just ain't as big as I think you guys are thinking it is...

And why do we also give kids so little credit? They're smarter and more discerning than we think.

They are, but it is pretty damn true that kids will zone into the most colorful, loud, rambling, shows on tv. You need to watch more kids if you don't think so.

I am not talking about what I like or not, I am talking about what mainstream people liked and what has worked. The light hearted OT show worked freakin well and worked a crap load better then any other stuff that has came out of this franchise.

Jester
06-20-2011, 06:19 PM
The lighthearted OT show worked freakin well and worked a crap load better then any other stuff that has came out of this franchise.
And the movie that was a "happy medium" of the comic books and the cartoon was one of the highest grossing indy flicks of the year...heck one of the highest grossing films of the year period.

That's really all I ask for, a movie that can keep the "Barron Balance," so to speak...

ToTheNines
06-20-2011, 06:26 PM
And the movie that was a "happy medium" of the comic books and the cartoon was one of the highest grossing indy flicks of the year...heck one of the highest grossing films of the year period.

That's really all I ask for, a movie that can keep the "Barron Balance," so to speak...

It was the highest grossing independent movie ever until Pulp Fiction came out 4 years later.

Jester
06-20-2011, 06:38 PM
It was the highest grossing independent movie ever until Pulp Fiction came out 4 years later.
Thanks for the fact check, Nines. I wasn't sure where it rated as an Indy flick.

Andrew NDB
06-20-2011, 06:51 PM
Why is it so hard to appreciate the franchise as a whole, and not just segments like the Fred Wold series or the Mirage comics?

Because a lot of aspects of the franchise suck.

Donnie
06-20-2011, 07:08 PM
The light hearted OT show worked freakin well and worked a crap load better then any other stuff that has came out of this franchise.

Seriously? I didn't know these kind of fans even existed. Oddly enough, I can see people just liking the comics and not the OT or other mediums. But I'm not being sarcastic when I say I never thought I'd see an OT-only fan on here!

Jester
06-20-2011, 07:18 PM
Seriously? I didn't know these kind of fans even existed. Oddly enough, I can see people just liking the comics and not the OT or other mediums. But I'm not being sarcastic when I say I never thought I'd see an OT-only fan on here!
I'm not so much. Now a Next Mutation only fan...that'd leave me scratching my head.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
06-20-2011, 07:18 PM
Because a lot of aspects of the franchise suck.

To put it another way, I think it's just that most of the aspects of the franchise differ so greatly from one another, that some people (like our friend, Orangey) find it jarring.

Personally, though, while the original comics tend to be my favorite version of the TMNT, I really am open to any and every aspect of the franchise. I will admit that the 87' toon is what got me into the franchise to begin with (well, actually, it was the action figures that got me interested, but the cartoon sealed the deal), but in all honesty, it was the action that I loved about it, as a kid (I got into it back when Michelangelo was still allowed to use his nunchakus in the cartoon), so I can safely say I'm not a hypocrite for preferring something a little more mature, as I honestly never noticed the goofiness of the cartoon as a kid (I only noticed it watching it again as an adult). I think there's a lot of "casual" fans that probably don't remember the goofiness as much, either, judging by what I've seen/heard, but my observations could be flawed.

I am not talking about what I like or not, I am talking about what mainstream people liked and what has worked. The light hearted OT show worked freakin well and worked a crap load better then any other stuff that has came out of this franchise.

What worked in several decades ago isn't necessarily guaranteed to work today. Each new generation that comes along has different tastes than the one before it, afterall. A telling example is what hot sellers the Playmates TMNT toys were when they first came out, and yet the 25th anniversary re-issues of those same exact figures sold so poorly that not only can you find bargain bins full of them, but not all of the ones that were planned to be released even were. Times change, and so, too, do the things that kids like. It's the reason Batman & Robin failed so horribly, despite trying to be like the highly successful 1960's Batman in tone.

And this is part of the reason that I don't think TMNT, in general, should be marketed to kids as much as it seems to be. A new TMNT movie needs to catch up to the ages of those that want to see it most, rather than try to pander to a generation of children that couldn't give two craps who the TMNT even are. If you make it overly goofy, I guarantee it'll turn off most of the mainstream, regardless of how fond their memories of the 87' toon are.

If you really, REALLY want to turn away from the fact that TMNT is a comic property, and negate comparisons to Batman Begins, then let's forget about that for a moment, and think about it as a Saturday morning cartoon property, just for the sake of argument. What other 1980s cartoons have become successful Hollywood movies lately? Transformers and G.I. Joe. Now, regardless of what you think about the quality of those movies, the facts are clear: They made movies with a PG-13 rating that are aimed at a young adult audience, rather than children, and ended up being highly successful with the mainstream. Although there were stupid things in those movies, they still took themselves seriously, rather than being a campfest. And that's what I think needs to be done with this upcoming TMNT movie.

Koi
06-20-2011, 07:30 PM
And this is part of the reason that I don't think TMNT, in general, should be marketed to kids as much as it seems to be. A new TMNT movie needs to catch up to the ages of those that want to see it most, rather than try to pander to a generation of children that couldn't give two craps who the TMNT even are. If you make it overly goofy, I guarantee it'll turn off most of the mainstream, regardless of how fond their memories of the 87' toon are.

If you really, REALLY want to turn away from the fact that TMNT is a comic property, and negate comparisons to Batman Begins, then let's forget about that for a moment, and think about it as a Saturday morning cartoon property, just for the sake of argument. What other 1980s cartoons have become successful Hollywood movies lately? Transformers and G.I. Joe. Now, regardless of what you think about the quality of those movies, the facts are clear: They made movies with a PG-13 rating that are aimed at a young adult audience, rather than children, and ended up being highly successful with the mainstream. Although there were stupid things in those movies, they still took themselves seriously, rather than being a campfest. And that's what I think needs to be done with this upcoming TMNT movie.

Alright, I get all that.

I think it's just that most of the aspects of the franchise differ so greatly from one another, that some people (like our friend, Orangey) find it jarring.
Seriously? I didn't know these kind of fans even existed. Oddly enough, I can see people just liking the comics and not the OT or other mediums. But I'm not being sarcastic when I say I never thought I'd see an OT-only fan on here!

I am not just an OT only fan... If you were reading you would of known I wasn't talking of me but of the actual mainstream of people.

gobo
06-21-2011, 08:45 PM
I'm not so much. Now a Next Mutation only fan...that'd leave me scratching my head.
Wasn't that even foretold inthe book of revelations?
If you were reading you would of known I wasn't talking of me but of the actual mainstream of people.
Would this stream be the same bunch who wouldn't dare spend their own money on the show they claim to admire?

The Stryker
06-21-2011, 08:51 PM
Why would someone spend money on a TV show?

Cure
06-21-2011, 09:07 PM
Would this stream be the same bunch who wouldn't dare spend their own money on the show they claim to admire?

Uh...what does this even mean?

gobo
06-21-2011, 10:05 PM
Why would someone spend money on a TV show?
Because it's not on tv. Anymore stupid questions you need answered?

Leogeddon
06-23-2011, 11:21 PM
I understand it's another reboot with the mousers added in there, the only thing I know other than how the turtles' head will look like. I will be absolutely pissed if Michael Bay makes the Turtles tank in the box office when he was able to reboot the Transformers to the overall mainstream with great success, it'll definitely make me wonder if he even cared about the Turtles. Here's hoping... here's hoping... :(

Powder
06-23-2011, 11:31 PM
I understand it's another reboot with the mousers added in there, the only thing I know other than how the turtles' head will look like. I will be absolutely pissed if Michael Bay makes the Turtles tank in the box office when he was able to reboot the Transformers to the overall mainstream with great success, it'll definitely make me wonder if he even cared about the Turtles. Here's hoping... here's hoping... :(

Who said anything about it being "another reboot with the mousers added in there"? I doubt they're going to remake the first movie... They'll just make their own "origin/fight Shredder" movie as Barron did. Nobody ever mentioned mousers, though. Where you pull that from is beyond me.

& I feel like we've had to say this 1000 times but Michael Bay is A producer, not a director. He's one of many producers, not the only dude. It's not like he has final word over anything (to my knowledge)*. If it sucks, blame Viacom for letting it happen with their property. & even so, I doubt he cares about the TMNT, they're just another franchise with which to bank.







*Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but that's what I've read...

Leogeddon
06-23-2011, 11:55 PM
Who said anything about it being "another reboot with the mousers added in there"? I doubt they're going to remake the first movie... They'll just make their own "origin/fight Shredder" movie as Barron did. Nobody ever mentioned mousers, though. Where you pull that from is beyond me.

& I feel like we've had to say this 1000 times but Michael Bay is A producer, not a director. He's one of many producers, not the only dude. It's not like he has final word over anything (to my knowledge)*. If it sucks, blame Viacom for letting it happen with their property. & even so, I doubt he cares about the TMNT, they're just another franchise with which to bank.







*Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but that's what I've read...
I read that's what Peter Laird wanted.
The new movie will be a Batman Begins-style reboot, showing the origins of the team of crime-fighting mutant turtles. Legendary Pictures will be producing the film, and co-creator Peter Laird is on board as executive producer. Laird says that the new movie “will remain true to the spirit of the original comic books. ” Laird mentions that the new movie might also use a new face replacement technology, which would allow the turtles to be much more expressive. Unless I’m reading the statement wrong, I think this also may confirm that the turtles won’t be completely computer generated.
http://www.slashfilm.com/peter-laird-wants-baxter-stockman-and-mousers-in-live-action-tmnt-movie/

http://www.slashfilm.com/peter-laird-talks-about-using-hybrid-turtles-in-live-action-tmnt-reboot/

http://www.slashfilm.com/hybrid-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-movie-in-development/

Jester
06-23-2011, 11:58 PM
Those are 2 years old and Laird no longer has any say due to the Viacom buy out...so...yeah.

CyberCubed
06-24-2011, 12:17 AM
The project has changed considerably since then, at this point it has new writers and no finished script.

Leogeddon
06-24-2011, 01:16 AM
I figured they would at least listen or throw a little memento to Peter like those who make Marvel movies always do with Stan Lee (even though Peter Laird sold the rights regardless) because he is still the Co-creator.

If not, well then, stinks how Peter is out of the position. :(

Powder
06-24-2011, 01:20 AM
I figured they would at least listen or throw a little memento to Peter like those who make Marvel movies always do with Stan Lee (even though Peter Laird sold the rights regardless) because he is still the Co-creator.

If not, well then, stinks how Peter is out of the position. :(

They're on their 4th script right now. One's too dark, one's too violent, one's not good enough... etc.

The original map-out that Pete worked on was to be the first issue on film. Since then, new directions, new scripts.

The only nod to Pete & co. you might get is something like "We ordered a pie from that joint off Eastman & Laird".

Donnie
06-24-2011, 02:41 AM
They're on their 4th script right now. One's too dark, one's too violent, one's not good enough... etc.


Just curious, where was this confirmed as reasons for scrapping? I haven't read it anywhere but I probably just missed it.

Jester
06-24-2011, 02:42 AM
Indeed, I've just heard that they are on the 4th script and that they have the Mission Impossible guys working on this...impossible mission.


Man, I need to work on my puns.

rufus
06-24-2011, 10:13 AM
I hope its good with all these re writes. Found this today.
http://dvd.ign.com/articles/316/316936p1.html
Peter Laird back in 2001 wanted a dir cut of TMNT 1990.

gobo
06-24-2011, 11:20 AM
I signed that petition. ^_^

The Stryker
06-24-2011, 02:23 PM
I may be alone here but I don't think Laird deserves any kind of cameo or tribute. I think the franchise as a whole needs to get away from the stain of his run on top.

Spitfire
06-24-2011, 08:20 PM
I may be alone here but I don't think Laird deserves any kind of cameo or tribute. I think the franchise as a whole needs to get away from the stain of his run on top.

I think Kevin needs a cameo. More people would recognize him anyway. Not many more but he does more Cons and at least heads a popular magazine.