PDA

View Full Version : San Diego Comic-Con 2011 Ashcan cover


azrael
07-10-2011, 12:30 AM
http://a2.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/264225_10150257737712460_176472382459_7387295_2516 4_n.jpg

Nothing new except color but is anyone going to comic-con?

Powder
07-10-2011, 12:34 AM
Though it does make the turtles pop, they couldn't be arsed to color the rest of it?

Roseangelo
07-10-2011, 01:10 AM
Though it does make the turtles pop, they couldn't be arsed to color the rest of it?

Disagree. I think this is perfect for an ashcan.

Archon_Turtle
07-10-2011, 01:41 AM
So ****ing stoked for this.

Buffy
07-10-2011, 03:20 AM
Looks very cool!

discordiatookie
07-10-2011, 12:29 PM
Do want! Being A) Not attending SDCC as I am B) At the wrong side of the ocean, i guess I may struggle to get one, but try I shall! Bwahaha!

Loving the colour and black and white mix. Wonder what the contents will be. Sketches? Interviews? Layouts? The full issue?

Venom
07-10-2011, 08:58 PM
Loving the colour and black and white mix. Wonder what the contents will be. Sketches? Interviews? Layouts? The full issue?

From what I've read it'll be everything you mentioned minus the full issue, instead having a preview. :tsmile:

gbhq
07-10-2011, 09:03 PM
what does ashcan mean?

Venom
07-10-2011, 09:04 PM
An ashcan copy is a term that originated in the Golden Age of Comic Books, meant to describe a publication produced solely for legal purposes (such as trademark), which was not normally intended for distribution.[

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashcan_copy

:D

IamtheNorm
07-11-2011, 10:33 AM
The IDW booth will defiantly be one of the first places I stop

Donnie
07-11-2011, 10:49 AM
Notice how the coloring of the kneepads are dirty whitish/beige. Kinda like the wraps that take the place of the pads in the new book. Nifty.

Thorneyeagle
07-11-2011, 11:32 AM
This is a great design for a cover.Makes me sad i can not attend the con. Granted i will be honest i would go broke attending.

marcelangelo
07-11-2011, 03:12 PM
ah, so that's it...I didn't realize this was the sneak peak for iss #1....over at idw forums, bobby confirmed that this baby would feature interviews with every artist involved in the book and have interior art from the debut issue...already got my special contact on it looking for it;):.

papa_smurf73
07-12-2011, 10:35 AM
Wow. That's a KA cover.

So for folks who can't attend the comic con, do issues like these surface on ebay or is there any other way to get it? I bet if it hits ebay, the price will be ridiculous.

Samhain
07-13-2011, 12:48 PM
LOVE IT! Hopefully this will be available online somewhere since I can't go to SDCC. : (

adz
07-13-2011, 06:26 PM
That is certainly tremendous! It's such a nice sight to see Kev drawing the green lads again. Since I live in AUS would anyone be willing to grab me a copy and I'll pay for your troubles and postage?

gbhq
07-15-2011, 07:47 PM
I think there will be a lot of people trying to get that issue, including myself.

azrael
07-16-2011, 02:03 PM
Will the people going post scans??? or is that something we would have to do on our own.

TristanHuwJones
07-16-2011, 09:14 PM
Can the folks going give me a heads up? I have a favor to ask!

Venom
07-16-2011, 11:26 PM
Can the folks going give me a heads up? I have a favor to ask!

:tcouch::P

TristanHuwJones
07-16-2011, 11:29 PM
LOL! Does that mean you are or you aren't?!

Venom
07-16-2011, 11:30 PM
Sure dude, what's up? :)

cloud
07-24-2011, 01:42 PM
I should have checked this post sooner. I think there should be left over copies from the con. EIther there will be some promo later on or maybe it will be a freebie for future cons?

Roseangelo
07-25-2011, 12:27 AM
I'm pretty sure they saved thee last of them for the booth signing yesterday. I don't think I saw any sitting out since Friday.

cloud
07-25-2011, 01:38 AM
I'm pretty sure they saved thee last of them for the booth signing yesterday. I don't think I saw any sitting out since Friday.

I meant I saw a few stacks of the ashcan copies Saturday but that was before the launching party. Maybe they were all gone. I don't know.

Btw, I think I saw you that day Roseangelo. I was in front of you. I had to leave after the signing.

Powder
07-25-2011, 02:20 AM
I meant I saw a few stacks of the ashtray copies Saturday but that was before the launching party. Maybe they were all gone. I don't know.

Btw, I think I saw you that day Roseangelo. I was in front of you. I had to leave after the signing.

I lol'd @ "Ashtray".

Jester
07-25-2011, 02:24 AM
I lol'd @ "Ashtray".
Considering what I read about that one water color Murph saved from Peter, I'm sure if Laird smoked, he'd use one of these as such.

Kendamu
07-25-2011, 02:55 AM
Hey, guys. For those of you who weren't able to get the ashcan, I've provided a brief character preview (including a picture of Old Hob) setting everyone up for the first issue if you'd like to see it.

http://www.halfshellheroes.com/2011/07/idws-ninja-turtles-comics.html

This page will be updated as new issues come out as a "jumping on point" page for new readers.

Jester
07-25-2011, 03:09 AM
I wonder if Splinter took Hob's eye in a battle for his life pre-mutation...

Luzmagica
07-25-2011, 04:13 AM
Hey, guys. For those of you who weren't able to get the ashcan, I've provided a brief character preview (including a picture of Old Hob) setting everyone up for the first issue if you'd like to see it.

http://www.halfshellheroes.com/2011/07/idws-ninja-turtles-comics.html

This page will be updated as new issues come out as a "jumping on point" page for new readers.

.... So nice preview! ...

...Poor Raphael...He looks so sad!!! .... Cant wait for more news!

Thorneyeagle
07-25-2011, 06:09 AM
Thanks for the blog posting Goongasnootch. Been waiting for something of the sort in regards to the ashcan.

marcelangelo
07-25-2011, 06:54 AM
thank you so much for posting these images!gosh, I didn't realize how beautiful this book is colred!!it almost looks as if it was colred by hand like back in the days when people used to really have to understand what they were doing when working with colors...to me very often computer coloring looks uninteresting, not condemning every book that is done this way...
I am very looking forward to reading these, also I love old hob's suspenders;)got the same ones..

cloud
07-25-2011, 12:08 PM
Do you guys think I'll be hunted down by IDW if I scanned the pages and someone leaked it out?

Archon_Turtle
07-25-2011, 12:21 PM
These are all going to get given away at some point through GGM. Kevin was kind enough to sign them for us. Unfortunately another panel I had kept me from getting them signed by Dan and Tom.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v247/JNCOPosterboy/SDCC11/IMAG0186.jpg

Master Splinter
07-25-2011, 12:45 PM
These are all going to get given away at some point through GGM. Kevin was kind enough to sign them for us. Unfortunately another panel I had kept me from getting them signed by Dan and Tom.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v247/JNCOPosterboy/SDCC11/IMAG0186.jpg

Awesome! I can't wait to see what contest you have!

-ms

Archon_Turtle
07-25-2011, 12:51 PM
Awesome! I can't wait to see what contest you have!

-ms

There probably won't be any hoop jumping. I'll probably just give them out.

papa_smurf73
07-25-2011, 01:04 PM
Uhm... YAY!

azrael
07-25-2011, 01:14 PM
this might be dumb but what does GGM mean? goodnes cracious me?

Anyways what would I do to get one, signed or not I dont care. Thanks hooking the drome up though for real.

Master Splinter
07-25-2011, 01:21 PM
There probably won't be any hoop jumping. I'll probably just give them out.

Hey that's awesome of you and kind of Kevin for signing them.

Thanks!

-ms

Archon_Turtle
07-25-2011, 01:40 PM
this might be dumb but what does GGM mean? goodnes cracious me?

Anyways what would I do to get one, signed or not I dont care. Thanks hooking the drome up though for real.

http://www.GoGreenMachine.org

pl212
07-25-2011, 01:47 PM
There probably won't be any hoop jumping. I'll probably just give them out.

What needs to be done ?
I want one :D

Archon_Turtle
07-25-2011, 01:58 PM
What needs to be done ?
I want one :D

To Be Determined at a later date.

Chris
07-25-2011, 02:28 PM
Awesome! Thanks so much for the preview and for getting extras to give out! Gonna have to watch out for that!

pl212
07-25-2011, 02:40 PM
To Be Determined at a later date.

ok kool, looking forward to this.
Thanks!

Venom
07-25-2011, 04:41 PM
Do you guys think I'll be hunted down by IDW if I scanned the pages and someone leaked it out?

Nope, the 8 pages are going to be posted on their forums soon.

cloud
07-26-2011, 12:53 AM
Nice.

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=FE5D7BG5

I've uploaded a pdf file of the ashcan issue.

Thorneyeagle
07-26-2011, 07:35 AM
no ooooo my phone wont load the images. Damn lol,i tried thanks for the link I can now own a digital copy at the very least

azrael
07-26-2011, 12:48 PM
To Be Determined at a later date.

will u post here or are you going to keep everyone checking your site?

cloud
07-26-2011, 01:06 PM
no ooooo my phone wont load the images. Damn lol,i tried thanks for the link I can now own a digital copy at the very least

Phone ?_? What's the matter with you. Get a computer.
Just kidding. I'll try to upload an jpg ver.

Here you go.

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=8NX7P8Y3

You'll need win rar to open it, not sure if phones can open rar files.

Jester
07-26-2011, 01:16 PM
CBR! :D Sorry, but CBR is the official file type of online comics. ;)

Abnormal Freak
07-26-2011, 01:24 PM
Maybe there's something I'm missing, but I just change CBRs to RARs to open them. :p And honestly never saw the point and questioned where they're just not packed as RARs...

Jester
07-26-2011, 01:26 PM
True...I actually did just that when I tried to cut the pages apart from the PDF to make a working virtual comic, but the pics I copied were such low quality (and there were pieces missing from the last few pages) it's not a very good RAR or CBR.

Andrew NDB
07-26-2011, 01:38 PM
I actually picked up a lot of these from the convention and would be willing to part with some.

I liked it on the whole but one part gives me great concern: they appear to be fighting crime, cleaning up the streets... that sort of thing. That is strange. Why would they fight crime?

It's possible I'm misreading it and it's no more complex than them running into Old Hob and Splinter wanting him dealt with. But there's one line that gives me pause.

Jester
07-26-2011, 01:42 PM
Maybe Splinter feels responsible for Hob's crimes. Kind of like Leo for the vacuum left after they offed Saki.

Andrew NDB
07-26-2011, 01:43 PM
Maybe Splinter feels responsible for Hob's crimes. Kind of like Leo for the vacuum left after they offed Saki.

It's possible.

Jester
07-26-2011, 01:46 PM
Just had the weirdest thought...what if Hob is a turn coat? What if he used to be a 6th family member? Sorry...just a weird thought. I mean we know next to nothing about Hob.

Andrew NDB
07-26-2011, 01:47 PM
They definitely have history and there's definitely bad blood. That much is clear from the comic.

Jester
07-26-2011, 01:51 PM
True, and I kind like the secret, gives the book something to reveal.

Galactus
07-26-2011, 02:13 PM
I'm imagining or hoping they quasi-crime fighters like they've generaly been depicted as in almost every other incarnation. They fight when the have a personal stake or if it's right in front of them and feel an obligation to use their abilities to help.

Taking a more active role in crime fighting as hinted here while admittedly is a strech wouldn't be too much of one. I could imagine them fighting gangs out of a mixture of habit and a sense of...well else are people like us going to do.

What does bother me is Splinter's no killing policy that the turtles seemingly adhere to. That to me screams an edict from Nickleodeon. The idea that Splinter has taught them ways of using their weapons without harming anyone is a bit of an odd one too.

So far we've been sold on the idea that while not the classic Mirage Universe this would be the next best thing. We've got the logo, the all red masks and the overall look down that it seems odd that something that many would feel to be important is changed.

It would be cool if it was a part of the story. Maybe Raph isn't there because he disagrees with the policy or maybe Splinter changes his mind on the issue when faced with the guy who killed his master. That'd be an interesting road to take but so far it doesn't seem that way.

Jester
07-26-2011, 02:22 PM
Part of me assumes that Splinter doesn't want to kill Hob's men, because they're just henchmen, and not wholly at fault...I dunna.

Revan
07-26-2011, 02:38 PM
It's possible I'm misreading it and it's no more complex than them running into Old Hob and Splinter wanting him dealt with. But there's one line that gives me pause.

Which line? Are you referring to Splinter asking them to leave the neighborhood in peace?

Andrew NDB
07-26-2011, 02:43 PM
Part of me assumes that Splinter doesn't want to kill Hob's men, because they're just henchmen, and not wholly at fault...I dunna.

That's kind of what I assume. If it starts coming up again with other villains, this business about, "Don't kill'em!" then the head-scratching can begin. For now I chalk it up to, "There's more we don't know about Hob and his men and the history between him/them and the Turtles/Splinter."

Andrew NDB
07-26-2011, 02:44 PM
Which line? Are you referring to Splinter asking them to leave the neighborhood in peace?

Yeah, that one. Why would he or the Turtles be concerned with "the neighborhood"? They live in a sewer -- they're not a part of "the neighborhood."

Revan
07-26-2011, 02:47 PM
I see what you are saying.

There is so much we don't know at this point though.

I hope they aren't the neighborhood watch. Or if they are, there should be some reason why they concerned about the neighborhood.

Andrew NDB
07-26-2011, 02:56 PM
Or if they are, there should be some reason why they concerned about the neighborhood.

Right. There would need to be some kind of compelling storyline. i.e., (and this is just me spitballing, not something I'd want to see happen) Casey does his vigilante thing patrolling the neighborhood one day and gets killed, and his dying wish is that the Turtles pick up his beat. Or they have a human friend that gets killed by the increasing gang violence, and suddenly it becomes personal.

You know, something. Fighting mankind's crime is not something the Turtles would just do beyond the nonsense of the cartoons and all that.

Revan
07-26-2011, 03:03 PM
What does bother me is Splinter's no killing policy that the turtles seemingly adhere to. That to me screams an edict from Nickleodeon. The idea that Splinter has taught them ways of using their weapons without harming anyone is a bit of an odd one too.

That part interested me as well. My initial reaction? Stupid

You know, something. Fighting mankind's crime is not something the Turtles would just do beyond the nonsense of the cartoons and all that.

Agreed. What I think is going on: Either A) there is something significant about that particular neighborhood or B) Splinter simply doesn't want his feud with Old Hob to affect others, which might explain why he forbids the turtles from killing

Andrew NDB
07-26-2011, 03:11 PM
Agreed. What I think is going on: Either A) there is something significant about that particular neighborhood or B) Splinter simply doesn't want his feud with Old Hob to affect others, which might explain why he forbids the turtles from killing

What is somewhat reassuring is that in this story Splinter felt the need at all to remind the Turtles not to kill. That implies that ordinarily in this universe the Turtles just kill away under similar circumstances.

ToTheNines
07-26-2011, 06:34 PM
Right. He may not consider it fair to just slaughter a bunch of thugs with pipes and chains. A clan of trained ninja however...

But yeah, I LOVE the art. A lot more appealing on-page rather than on-cover, and I happened to like the cover art just fine. The whole mood the art gives off is just great. Can't wait to start getting this book monthly.

Andrew NDB
07-26-2011, 06:45 PM
The art is pretty good and I like Dan Duncan, but I do think they could do with some better coloring. It never quite "pops" on the page... and it kind of needs to, if even only on the covers.

Samhain
07-26-2011, 07:00 PM
Im in love with Duncan's art. This is what I've been waiting for! The book looks fantastic.

ToTheNines
07-27-2011, 04:51 PM
Another thought I had: Maybe Splinter told Hob to "leave the neighborhood in peace" because he and the guys are searching for Raph and he wants Hob to GTFO of their current focal point.

marcelangelo
07-27-2011, 05:06 PM
as far as the 'no killing policy' goes(not just a stupid word creation but exagerated in my opinion given that all we saw was one lousy pannel where splinter uttered something to the effect of no killing...)
taking a life is NEVER alright and digested easily for the survivor, how about splinter rules this out here for he wants his students/sons not to go through such grief that early in their lives....

azrael
07-27-2011, 05:21 PM
I dont think they are crime fighting at all I think he doesnt want any insult to the innoscent people.

As for the no killing thing, maybe its for this fight. Old Hob seems very prideful, maybe if they defeat him without killing it sends a stronger message.

Coloring seems to fit they are at night, so its not going to "pop" off the page I have to say this is better than what I was hoping for, so Im supa excited :D

Revan
07-27-2011, 08:44 PM
Old Hob doesn't seem to be much of a threat in hand to hand combat. Splinter took him down quite easily

ToTheNines
07-27-2011, 09:16 PM
He could probably jack up a turtle one-on-one pretty good.

Venom
07-28-2011, 12:47 AM
Old Hob looks like Sam Jackson's Nick Fury.

Kendamu
07-28-2011, 12:59 AM
Old Hob looks like Sam Jackson's Nick Fury.

Don't you mean... Nick Furry? :twink:

Andrew NDB
07-28-2011, 01:23 AM
taking a life is NEVER alright and digested easily for the survivor, how about splinter rules this out here for he wants his students/sons not to go through such grief that early in their lives....

That'd be pretty weird for a ninja master that's trying to raise them to assassinate a guy. You'd think he'd want to get them used to the idea by the time it's showtime for the main event.

Granted, we have no idea what the mission statement is of the IDW TMNT. It could be they're being raised by Splinter to take part in a bake sale on their 17th birthday, we have no idea.

marcelangelo
07-28-2011, 03:32 AM
;)hahaha, but yeah that's exactly the point, we don't know yet...well, we also don't know if all this revenge scheme of master splinter is retold the same way as in the original...also to prepare them to kill for regeining the yoshi honor without emotional hesitating and to forbid them to kill just randomly in a fight can very well be happinening in the same story I think...
I cannot believe that this book will be comming out in some weeks already!;)cowabunga!

Luzmagica
07-28-2011, 03:40 AM
:D:D lovely Michelangelo! :lol:

http://img6.imageshack.us/img6/2047/loltiw.jpg (http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/6/loltiw.jpg/)

:tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol::tlol:

Galactus
07-28-2011, 11:49 PM
What is somewhat reassuring is that in this story Splinter felt the need at all to remind the Turtles not to kill. That implies that ordinarily in this universe the Turtles just kill away under similar circumstances.

Certainly possible. Also possible that line was for the benefit of the reader to make them aware of the new status quo.

It wouldn't be unsuprising if Nick says good guys can't be killers or if creatively Tom Waltz feels the characters would work better if they have some kind of code of honour. Afterall this is a new universe with new rules. It doesn't have to adhere to what's gone on before.

But the fact that we're being sold on how this series is like the classic Mirage comic that removing one of the fundamental aspects of the Mirage turtles would feel weird.

ToTheNines
07-31-2011, 03:47 PM
Tothenines wrote:
Bobby,

Several fans, including myself, are worried about your "killing policy" with TMNT. As awesome as the ash-can was, Splinter telling the Turtles not to kill the thugs worries me. That's just not what I'm used to for my TMNT comics.

I don't need to see all out gore, but will the turtles be allowed to off any baddies in this book?


This is an unsatisfactory response, but I don't think I can answer this question without spoiling some story. It will be a subject that is addressed and explored, though.

Powder
07-31-2011, 06:06 PM
Eentorezting...

Jester
08-02-2011, 06:22 PM
Here's the Ashcan in a CBR file:
http://www.mediafire.com/file/1lkluuay6mnj6w8/TMNT%20Ashcan.cbr

Andrew NDB
08-02-2011, 06:59 PM
Tothenines wrote:
Bobby,

Several fans, including myself, are worried about your "killing policy" with TMNT. As awesome as the ash-can was, Splinter telling the Turtles not to kill the thugs worries me. That's just not what I'm used to for my TMNT comics.

I don't need to see all out gore, but will the turtles be allowed to off any baddies in this book?

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow
This is an unsatisfactory response, but I don't think I can answer this question without spoiling some story. It will be a subject that is addressed and explored, though.

That gives me a bad feeling.

oldmanwinters
08-02-2011, 07:44 PM
I've always wondered how the TMNT can get away with killing oodles of thugs and ninjas and not have to face criminal charges at some point. It's only right that the turtles should have to face justice after a while.

Jester
08-02-2011, 07:47 PM
And maybe that's why they didn't kill the punks. Dudes dressed in ninja duds might be more easily let "slip through the cracks" where as random street punks might bring undo attention...although letting punks who've seen you live could cause totally different yet equal problems.

ToTheNines
08-02-2011, 08:01 PM
That gives me a bad feeling.

Doesn't give me a bad feeling, I guess... but I wish it wasn't an issue at all.

But I'm not gonna freak until the actual book does something I don't like. Don't wanna let speculation get in the way here.

I've always wondered how the TMNT can get away with killing oodles of thugs and ninjas and not have to face criminal charges at some point. It's only right that the turtles should have to face justice after a while.

The Turtles don't kill "oodles" of anything. Well, Foot Ninja yes... but it was shown in Tales that fallen Foot Ninja are recovered and brought to the home of their family. And if that's not possible, most of them are probably illegal immigrants anyway.

Anyways, even though the Mirage Turtles normally kill with out question, they don't really have a massive body count.

oldmanwinters
08-02-2011, 08:07 PM
The Turtles don't kill "oodles" of anything .Well, Foot Ninja yes...

The way the turtles took out the Purple Dragons in that first issue makes me think they were well experienced with slicing and dicing hoodlums looking for trouble.

Mirage turtles oughta have their day in court!

twopinacoladas
08-02-2011, 08:08 PM
I've always wondered how the TMNT can get away with killing oodles of thugs and ninjas and not have to face criminal charges at some point. It's only right that the turtles should have to face justice after a while.

They did face criminal charges =)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_FABYGhzJ34&playnext=1&list=PL4A2D30E33EFE0982

ToTheNines
08-02-2011, 08:15 PM
The way the turtles took out the Purple Dragons in that first issue makes me think they were well experienced with slicing and dicing hoodlums looking for trouble.

I'm pretty sure that was their first big battle.

DrSpengler
08-02-2011, 08:18 PM
The Mirage Turtles are sort of questionable when it comes to their morality on killing. They do kills lots of thugs and Foot Soldiers, and they were trained from birth for the sole purpose of killing a particular dude, and they were shown killing without a hint of remorse as early as "The Passing" (where they were described as "pre teens").

But while they have no compunctions about killing in "self defense" (I use that term in quotations because they often kill after going out and looking for trouble, vigilante-style), they don't cotton to others killing in the same way.

Leo punished Cha Ocho for killing the murderer of his wife, even after Ocho pointed out the hypocrisy of his stance on the matter (which Leo was unable to counter, making him look like a total douche).

The Turtles were pretty judgmental toward Casey when he killed that teenager in "Shades of Grey", even though the Turtles had killed teenage Foot Soldiers (though they did keep Nobody from taking Casey to jail, so they at least did him that much of a solid).

The Mirage Turtles are inconsistent with their ethical stance on killing bad guys. Or, at the very least, they operate under a "do as I say, not as I do" philosophy.

oldmanwinters
08-02-2011, 08:22 PM
I'm pretty sure that was their first big battle.

Hmm... you might be right going by the actual dialogue in the first issue, but any such talk was quickly retconed away by issue 9.


The point I was trying to make was... Mirage turtles killed oodles of people in their life, thugs included.

And what's worse... they're hypocrites as well.

ToTheNines
08-02-2011, 08:23 PM
I remember them telling Leatherhead not to kill Marlin whilst in Australia, that always bothered me. Oddly enough, those 2 were written by Tristan and Dan.

Mr._Mutant_Man
08-02-2011, 08:33 PM
I've always wondered how the TMNT can get away with killing oodles of thugs and ninjas and not have to face criminal charges at some point. It's only right that the turtles should have to face justice after a while.

They're ninjas, masters of invisibility, so they've never been caught.:twink:

I'm not really bothered one way or another. On the one hand, they're ninjas, so it makes sense that they'd have no issue killing. On the other hand, it's a bit more heroic to have the Batman "no killing" stance.

ToTheNines
08-02-2011, 08:36 PM
On the other hand, it's a bit more heroic to have the Batman "no killing" stance.

They're not heroes.

Master Splinter
08-02-2011, 08:58 PM
They're not heroes.

In the UK they were!

:-)

-ms

Andrew NDB
08-02-2011, 09:00 PM
I've always wondered how the TMNT can get away with killing oodles of thugs and ninjas and not have to face criminal charges at some point.

Simple -- they don't live in our world. Urban legends at most.

Galactus
08-02-2011, 10:34 PM
If it's a case that Tom and/or Kevin think it'd make for better stories if the protagonists don't kill then I could go along with that, it could even lead to some compelling stories but like I said the fact that this is hyped as being like the classic Mirage comic ditching something which is fundamental to those early stories seems a bit odd. Odder still the turtles are trained in special skills of how to use bladed weapons in way that don't kill and apparently don't cut either.

Leo punished Cha Ocho for killing the murderer of his wife, even after Ocho pointed out the hypocrisy of his stance on the matter (which Leo was unable to counter, making him look like a total douche).

Well that story was written by Murphy who obviously had his issues with the mirage universe but even then I'd argue it's not out of character. Leo's stance on what he felt is an acceptable kill probably changed over the years. City at War made it clear that he almost regretted carrying out Splinter's mission as he was weary of the constant fighting it caused hence he was the most eager to accept Karai's offer of a truce.

Killing an unarmed opponent who seemed to be genuinly remorseful and begging for forgiveness might be a little outside his comfort zone.

I remember them telling Leatherhead not to kill Marlin whilst in Australia, that always bothered me. Oddly enough, those 2 were written by Tristan and Dan.

I'd say it's proof that each turtle has a different level of comfortabilty about killing an opponent especialy an unarmed one.

In both cases Marlin was subdued and in the second story wasn't Raph encouraging Leatherhead to kill Marlin? Obviously he felt that the guy deserved it, while Leo seemingly wanted to leave him to those authorities.

Mike and especialy Don would probably agree with Leo. Don might even feel a pang of sadness over it but the main thing is they're all willing to do the deed.

Andrew NDB
08-02-2011, 10:40 PM
If it's a case that Tom and/or Kevin thinks it'd be make for better stories if the protagonists don't kill then I could go along with that, it could even lead to some compelling stories but like I said the fact that this is hyped as being like the classic Mirage comic ditching something which is fundamental to those early stories seems a bit odd. Odder still the turtles are trained in special skills of how to use bladed weapons in way that don't kill and apparently don't cut either.

If the Turtles aren't killing anybody in the IDW comics it's pretty clear where that edict would be coming from.

Venom
08-02-2011, 11:03 PM
Mike and especialy Don would probably agree with Leo. Don might even feel a pang of sadness over it but the main thing is they're all willing to do the deed.

Mike, maybe, Don, no way. Mirage Don is one cold bastard.:tcool:8)

Andrew NDB
08-02-2011, 11:16 PM
Mike, maybe, Don, no way. Mirage Don is one cold bastard.:tcool:8)

He's killed without hesitation on plenty of occasions. Early on he rammed his broken staff into the neck of a Triceraton with only a terse "For honor" uttered, and most importantly... he is the one that dealt the deathblow to the "real" Oroku Saki.

CyberCubed
08-03-2011, 09:59 AM
The problem with the Mirage Turtles is the different writers all had different interpetations of them and if they should kill or not.

I could of sworn that while I was reading some of the Tales issues, the Turtles personalities felt more similar to the cartoons in some issues than their Mirage counterparts. Did anyone feel this way?

Andrew NDB
08-03-2011, 12:15 PM
The problem with the Mirage Turtles is the different writers all had different interpetations of them and if they should kill or not.

When in doubt, refer back to the ones written by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird. Always a safe policy.

Xav
08-03-2011, 03:48 PM
I've always wondered how the TMNT can get away with killing oodles of thugs and ninjas and not have to face criminal charges at some point. It's only right that the turtles should have to face justice after a while. I don't think you can charge giant talking turtles.

Mr._Mutant_Man
08-06-2011, 05:30 PM
They're not heroes.

That's how the general public sees them, and I imagine this comic is going to try to draw in new readers.

Even if they aren't going out of their way to try to be heroes, they fight criminals, which is a heroic act.

Jester
08-06-2011, 06:14 PM
That's how the general public sees them, and I imagine this comic is going to try to draw in new readers.

Even if they aren't going out of their way to try to be heroes, they fight criminals, which is a heroic act.
They don't look for crimes to fight. They only defend themselves when threatened (or enact revenge in the case of Oroku saki.) And sometimes to defend yourself and your family, you gotta do a little killin'.

TristanHuwJones
08-06-2011, 08:36 PM
I remember them telling Leatherhead not to kill Marlin whilst in Australia, that always bothered me. Oddly enough, those 2 were written by Tristan and Dan.

My rationale, at least for my part of that story was because Interpol were there. They could've had justice served, but Leatherhead gave him what Leatherhead felt he deserved.

Trust me, having them stop and tell him to "Do it." is way more bothersome when you actually read it (I know because I tried it), and having them say nothing is just as weird. Especially under the circumstances of that ending. That's why they tranquilize Leatherhead, because they've just watched him kill a man they're trying to apprehend. I wouldn't want that thing awake near me if I'd seen that.

Donnie
08-07-2011, 01:41 AM
He's killed without hesitation on plenty of occasions. Early on he rammed his broken staff into the neck of a Triceraton with only a terse "For honor" uttered, and most importantly... he is the one that dealt the deathblow to the "real" Oroku Saki.

Context just flies out the window on this issue, yet again. I suppose at this point we've debated it to no end, but Donatello is clearly the most reluctant to kill in any TMNT title and he has only killed without hesitation when he or his brothers/Splinter were in imminent danger at the hands of aggressors (or forced to fight because of pre-meditated violent intentions at the hands of the aforementioned), excluding the deathblow to Saki in which the Turtles were the aggressors.

If you want to check with Eastman & Laird on this issue (which you've stated is clearly the best source), just check out this interview, post #55 (mine) of The Donatello Thread (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=33475&page=3). Even the creators label Donatello the pacifist of the bunch. Given the fact that Donatello has killed, calling him a straight-up pacifist is slightly unfitting - but there is no doubt that he is the Turtle with the most pacifistic tendencies, as stated by E & L themselves.

Venom
08-07-2011, 01:38 PM
Context just flies out the window on this issue, yet again. I suppose at this point we've debated it to no end, but Donatello is clearly the most reluctant to kill in any TMNT title and he has only killed without hesitation when he or his brothers/Splinter were in imminent danger...

He's killed a dog for his experiments.
He killed a kidnapped Baxter-brain in his lab.

Revan
08-07-2011, 01:45 PM
He killed a kidnapped Baxter-brain in his lab.

I always thought that was strange that he kept that baxter-bot thing alive for so long and then just killed it. It seemed rather abrupt. Though I don't know which is worse, imprisoning him for so many years or simply killing him to not prolong suffering.

Powder
08-07-2011, 02:50 PM
blahblahblah

I've said it before & I'll say it again, I really think you're just making Don who you WANT him to be.

Donnie
08-07-2011, 03:39 PM
I've said it before & I'll say it again, I really think you're just making Don who you WANT him to be.

Okay, so disrespectfully insert "blah blah blah" where my valid points were written - what does this prove? I don't just spew nonsense, I validate my points, cite examples, provide links, etc. to get my point across so that people can understand how I've come to think what I believe on this issue. Yet again, instead of entering into a reasonable debate filled with appropriate responses and evidence to validate what you're saying you resort to childish banter and personal opinion that proves nothing, for it is backed up with nothing - as you can see we've gone nowhere. It's nothing new with this argument, I should be used to it. The "but he has killed" argument falls flat on its face when provided with the evidence I have cited.

Maybe this sort of response is because you simply don't have an argument outside of the fact that the Turtles were raised to kill Shredder. The proof (and it is proof) that I have given - the words from the video interview of Eastman & Laird themselves, creators of the Turtles - is largely ignored because people cannot refute it. Donatello is the group pacifist. As if the words of the creators aren't enough, in the past I've also provided numerous comic sources to issues that go beyond V.1 #1.

He's killed a dog for his experiments.
He killed a kidnapped Baxter-brain in his lab.

In the name of science. Plus, Baxter was a psycho-path. I think the context changes a bit when you're dealing with a murdering belligerent man.

Powder
08-07-2011, 04:02 PM
I didn't edit your post out of "disrespect", I respect you, we talk all the time! I just did it to avoid takin' up space. I don't really care what Kevin or Pete said at the time, they've also been quoted as calling Mikey a party dude & advocating Venus. But this isn't so much my arguement, I'm more against Donny being pinned as spritual more than anything else. & I don't see how my one small post with an opinion expressed sans humor is considered childish banter, but OK, be bitter. I'm not trying to make a rebuttal, I just simply feel like you really stretch Don's persona into your own personal dream character as opposed to taking him for what he is on paper. Maybe he has elements of some of these traits, but they certainly don't define him or serve use as labels.

Venom
08-07-2011, 09:31 PM
In the name of science. Plus, Baxter was a psycho-path. I think the context changes a bit when you're dealing with a murdering belligerent man.

Killing in the name of science is okay? I'm sure the victims of the Unit 731 experiments would have thought otherwise.

And at the point Don "relieved" Baxter of his suffering, he had been held captive for a number of years. He had been reduced to nothing more but a harmless, arrogant brain with a digital synthesizer for a voice.

Peaceful by nature, brutal by method.

Slap-Happy
08-07-2011, 09:40 PM
Mike, maybe, Don, no way. Mirage Don is one cold bastard.:tcool:8)

He's killed without hesitation on plenty of occasions. Early on he rammed his broken staff into the neck of a Triceraton with only a terse "For honor" uttered, and most importantly... he is the one that dealt the deathblow to the "real" Oroku Saki.

Jeez. I guess I haven't read enough of the Mirage Books.

The more I keep hearing about the mirage Don the more I keep thinking he's a psychopath.

Donnie
08-07-2011, 11:30 PM
I'm not trying to make a rebuttal, I just simply feel like you really stretch Don's persona into your own personal dream character as opposed to taking him for what he is on paper. Maybe he has elements of some of these traits, but they certainly don't define him or serve use as labels.

Let me start by saying I respect you as well, and no hard feelings. However, I don't think it's too much of a stretch to say replacing my words with "blah blah blah" denotes disrespect. It's pretty much communicating that you don't give a hoot about what I said. But all is well between us, friend.

To the subject matter, I will say a few things: if you think I romanticize Donatello's character, I probably can't sway to you to think otherwise, it's your opinion. I am an ardent debater when it comes to characters I love, especially Donny, so of course I like to discuss his character in depth - to me this means recognizing everything that he is (or has been written as), be it a great facet of his personality or a small one - and there is no doubt that Donatello is the group pacifist; like I've said before numerous times: he is the Turtle with the most pacifistic tendencies. It has been stated in the comics, by the creators themselves, and blatantly stated in his character profiles throughout Turtledom. There is no debating that Donatello's fabric as a character resides in his duality - being a ninja and having to (reluctantly) kill while being a peace lover and the most pacifistic at the same time. It is Donatello.

I'm not sure what you're referring to about spirituality - I never stated that Don was spiritual, we are talking about him being a pacifist here - I fail to see why the subject of spiritualism was brought up? In "The Donatello Thread" I noted that to say Donatello is void of what would be blanketed under a "spiritual dilemma" just because he is a Turtle of science is just silly, but I never stated he was spiritual. In fact, he's probably the least spiritual of the bunch. Maybe you're referring to that thread, but I'm not sure why it was brought up here. I never "pinned him" as spiritual by any means.

Killing in the name of science is okay? I'm sure the victims of the Unit 731 experiments would have thought otherwise.

Well now you're getting into morality and politics; and I'm not going to even touch those waters.

Peaceful by nature, brutal by method.

This sadistically made me chuckle.

Jeez. I guess I haven't read enough of the Mirage Books. The more I keep hearing about the mirage Don the more I keep thinking he's a psychopath.

Sigh. Why? Because of what he did to Baxter's brain, the brain of an ill-intented murderer? Donatello is calculating, introverted, and certainly a little sneaky, but he's definitely not a "psychopath".

gbhq
08-09-2011, 11:48 PM
Did anyone notice that Leonardo managed to slice a crowbar in half with his sword? I think that they should keep the realism in the artwork also.

Andrew NDB
08-10-2011, 12:11 AM
Let me start by saying I respect you as well, and no hard feelings. However, I don't think it's too much of a stretch to say replacing my words with "blah blah blah" denotes disrespect. It's pretty much communicating that you don't give a hoot about what I said. But all is well between us, friend.

To the subject matter, I will say a few things: if you think I romanticize Donatello's character, I probably can't sway to you to think otherwise, it's your opinion. I am an ardent debater when it comes to characters I love, especially Donny, so of course I like to discuss his character in depth - to me this means recognizing everything that he is (or has been written as), be it a great facet of his personality or a small one - and there is no doubt that Donatello is the group pacifist; like I've said before numerous times: he is the Turtle with the most pacifistic tendencies. It has been stated in the comics, by the creators themselves, and blatantly stated in his character profiles throughout Turtledom. There is no debating that Donatello's fabric as a character resides in his duality - being a ninja and having to (reluctantly) kill while being a peace lover and the most pacifistic at the same time. It is Donatello.

I'm not sure what you're referring to about spirituality - I never stated that Don was spiritual, we are talking about him being a pacifist here - I fail to see why the subject of spiritualism was brought up? In "The Donatello Thread" I noted that to say Donatello is void of what would be blanketed under a "spiritual dilemma" just because he is a Turtle of science is just silly, but I never stated he was spiritual. In fact, he's probably the least spiritual of the bunch. Maybe you're referring to that thread, but I'm not sure why it was brought up here. I never "pinned him" as spiritual by any means.



Well now you're getting into morality and politics; and I'm not going to even touch those waters.



This sadistically made me chuckle.



Sigh. Why? Because of what he did to Baxter's brain, the brain of an ill-intented murderer? Donatello is calculating, introverted, and certainly a little sneaky, but he's definitely not a "psychopath".

Well put, sir. My respect of you is beginning to blossom.

Bottom line in my eyes, though, is no matter what individual traits crept up in the four different Turtles as they grew up... all four of them were subjected to the exact same training regimen that Splinter was dishing out and all four of them were groomed equally for the task of assassinating Oroku Saki one day. It wasn't like Splinter ever went, "You seem to be rather pacifistic and introverted, Donatello... you can go sit and read while your brothers practice slicing the heads off of dummies" or whatever -- he was still bred to be a killer through and through like the others.

Powder
08-10-2011, 12:14 AM
Did anyone notice that Leonardo managed to slice a crowbar in half with his sword? I think that they should keep the realism in the artwork also.

There are swords that can cut through metal, my man. Especially when that metal is probably rusty.

Spitfire
08-10-2011, 01:38 AM
Bought this for 10 bucks on Ebay. A rip off no doubt as it was a giveaway but I wanted one. I wasn't impressed to say the least. Wasn't impressed with the writing or the artwork. The artwork is a huge problem in fact. I hate how he draws the turtles. He has no idea how the body works and moves and how he draws their teeth is almost offensive. They look like Isz from The Maxx.

The interview in the back is where I got worried but we'll wait and see I guess. It deeply concerns me that Nick has a say in anything involving the comics. The show and comics should be separate and if they want a dark comic it's gonna be hard when it's connected to a kids series.

Again early to make snap judgements but we'll see. As of right now they're going to have to work to seriously blow me away with the first issue. So far this 3rd rate Verminator X wanna be villain isn't doing much to give me faith.

Donnie
08-10-2011, 01:13 PM
Well put, sir. My respect of you is beginning to blossom.

Thanks Andrew.