View Full Version : Tell me about Vol. 3? (The Image Years)
prometheanworks
07-17-2011, 08:10 PM
Hi All,
Can anyone give me the "haps" on Vol. 3 of TMNT Comics? I know there were a number of dramatic changes across the board and Wikia had this to say:
Volume 3: 1996 - 1999
In June of 1996, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Volume 3 was published under the Image Comics label, thanks to Erik Larsen. A total of 23 monthly issues were written by Gary Carlson and illustrated by Frank Fosco. The comics returned to their black-and-white format,albeit without toning,but had a faster pace, more intense action, and surprising plot twists.Many of the turtles were injured and/or mutilated,this caused Donatello to become a cyborg,Raphael to wear an eye-patch due to loss of his left eye,and Leonardo to place his katana in place of his severed hand. Because the comic was being published by Image Comics, the Turtles crossed over to Savage Dragon a few times. The series ceased production in 1999 and is no longer considered "canon."
But was it "good?" Was it ever collected in any format?
Venom
07-17-2011, 09:40 PM
It was kick ass and yes, there is a trade but it's pricey and rare; the first five issue were collected.
It's a great series, packed with action and great pacing; each arc is five issues and they string together coherently. It's a shame it was cancelled.
azrael
07-17-2011, 10:01 PM
http://miragelicensing.com/comics/image/image.html
This tells you what happens to a point its up to you to connect the dots.
prometheanworks
07-17-2011, 10:13 PM
Awesome. Much appreciated. Is Bodycount considered part of this continuity, or a standalone TMNT adventure part of "canon?"
Donnie
07-17-2011, 10:16 PM
But was it "good?" Was it ever collected in any format?
One man's garbage is another's treasure. I'm not a fan of V.3 because of the senseless mutilation to Donatello. You just have to see if you like that sort of thing for yourself...this forum (generally speaking, not on the whole) is pretty Image-Happy, so you'll get a lot of positive opinions on it here.
Jester
07-17-2011, 10:26 PM
I finally read it after years of "Look what they did to (Put Turtles Name Here)!!" and was actually surprised by how much I liked it. It's not bad, if you can get past the "mutilations" and get into the story, which is actually very good...well, when it doesn't get to deep into the Savage Dragon universe and sticks to New York.
CyberCubed
07-17-2011, 10:34 PM
It's a direct continuation of the Mirage universe. Don't let anyone trick you otherwise.
IDW's series appears to be a reboot, the Image series was not.
Powder
07-17-2011, 10:50 PM
Vol. 3 is my favorite of them all, if that counts for anything. The art is really unique, the story pacing is excellent, there are some cool cameos...
Andrew NDB
07-18-2011, 02:34 AM
I'll spare my missives about Vol. 3 (my feelings for it are well known), but I'll shoot this out there: if you're a Michelangelo fan, within Vol. 3 he got more character development and a bigger character arc than he's received in any other TMNT volume including Vol. 1.
Jester
07-18-2011, 02:40 AM
I'll spare my missives about Vol. 3 (my feelings for it are well known), but I'll shoot this out there: if you're a Michelangelo fan, within Vol. 3 he got more character development and a bigger character arc than he's received in any other TMNT volume including Vol. 1.
Very true. If I had to pick a favorite Mikey, Image Mikey would be a lead contender.
Abnormal Freak
07-18-2011, 05:03 AM
Awesome. Much appreciated. Is Bodycount considered part of this continuity, or a standalone TMNT adventure part of "canon?"
Bodycount, I assume, is a story that takes place canonically somewhere in the Vol. 1 run—Eastman did a number of Raphael & Casey Jones stories, and this is just a full-fledged one (with extreme violence). The series was originally to be published by Mirage, before Image picked up the property, but only one issue was put out before it got canned.
I love Vol. 3, but there's one detail I don't like: there's a part that made me feel like Raph had never used a gun before, and then he uses one to fight off a horde of enemies, and he's impressed by its killing power. The exact same thing happened in Bodycount, albeit handled in Vol. 3 more sophisticatedly. It just strikes me as a weird inconsistency, if one were to consider Bodycount canon.
Powder
07-18-2011, 05:18 AM
Well in all fairness, didn't Raph use a (laser) gun in the Triceraton saga also? Maybe he's just consistently impressed?
Jester
07-18-2011, 05:25 AM
Different calibers, maybe?
"I'm am very impressed by this oozy! Ohhh, a hand pistol! Sweet, a laser rifle!"
DrSpengler
07-18-2011, 09:55 AM
The only thing Bodycount has to do with Volume 3 is that it's the first appearance of Casey's star-spangled hockey mask. Other than that, it's pretty inconsequential.
As for Volume 3, it is probably the best string of stories in regards to direction and purpose for many of the characters. As mentioned, Mikey gets to do more and develop more than he ever had. But I almost see it more as Raph's volume, personally. His arc in the latter half is fascinating and takes the character out of his rut and to new places and potential. After Vol. 3, Raph just becomes a totally dead end character.
Volume 3 isn't perfect; there are two arcs in the first half of the volume I positively loathe. But the series gets bette fast and the last half is some great reading.
Venom
07-18-2011, 12:16 PM
Well in all fairness, didn't Raph use a (laser) gun in the Triceraton saga also? Maybe he's just consistently impressed?
Different calibers, maybe?
"I'm am very impressed by this oozy! Ohhh, a hand pistol! Sweet, a laser rifle!"
Lol, well Raph does have a thing for chaos, war and bloodshed, so that wouldn't surprise me. :lol::tlol:
Donnie
07-18-2011, 12:56 PM
if you're a Michelangelo fan, within Vol. 3 he got more character development and a bigger character arc than he's received in any other TMNT volume including Vol. 1.
This I can agree with. If you like Michelangelo, Volume 3 is for you.
prometheanworks
07-18-2011, 01:29 PM
And 2k3's "Same as it never was" is loosely based on this concept. Yes?
discordiatookie
07-18-2011, 01:38 PM
And 2k3's "Same as it never was" is loosely based on this concept. Yes?
I've only ever seen that episode the once, but I can't recall it drawing any influence from vol 3. Maybe the fact that one of the turtles loses a hand?
Anyway, vol 3 is pretty awesome. Its certainly got some of my favourite covers also!
Leo656
07-24-2011, 05:33 AM
Missing a few issues (including #1, bummer) but I have almost all of them and first read them in one marathon read-through. Initially hated all the drastic changes, and still not thrilled with some of them to this day BUT as compared to Vol. 4... Vol. 4 was a sleepy, meandering mess that went nowhere, while the Image run actually told stories that had a beginning, middle, and an end. I know Laird defends his style by saying real life doesn't happen in chunks of story, but comics are for READERS and stories have to progress or it's pointless!
So basically, the stories are well-told in the Image run, and they had a lot of interesting concepts that, unfortunately, were not all finished. One's enjoyment of said run can depend on whether you can go with the flow, or if the changes from the "normal" TMNT are too much. I think it's aged better than expected, and I'll probably enjoy ity more when I read it again. There's a lot more TMNT stories than there were 10+ years ago, so some of the stuff that seemed bad back then probably works better now in context.
My biggest problems more than anything were A) No ending, and B) Some of the art was way too hard to decipher, the lines were way too thin for a black n white book in some issues.
EDIT: Oh, yeah, and then there was how I wrote my first fanfic before reading or knowing anything about the Image run and had Leo lose a hand, then grow it back, only to then discover that was a major plot point of the Image run. D'oh? I mean it was totally different anyway, but still, kind of embarrassing.
Jester
07-24-2011, 05:41 AM
Some of the art was way too hard to decipher, the lines were way too thin for a black n white book in some issues.
That was kinda explained...if I remember right the one of the letters columns says that vol 3 was intended for color, and was inked as such, but Image decided late in the game to make it Black and White, in keeping with Mirage's 1st volume...and to cut costs.
Leo656
07-24-2011, 05:51 AM
I buy that. I was actually gonna say before, "it looked like it was intended to be in color". Still, the earlier ones were the worst with that, if I remember correctly, and are a big reason my girl and I can't read the Image books together. BnW books mess with her eyes as it is, those issues were too much. They got better, though.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.