View Full Version : Why isn't Kevin as opposed to Fred Wolf characters like Peter is?
CyberCubed
08-20-2011, 12:13 AM
PL has made his dislike for most of the Fred Wolf characters many, many times. He of course prevented the 4kids writers from using them in the cartoon, and would not allow any of them to appear in the Mirage comics either. (although Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady got a brief cameo in one of the Cowboys of Moo Mesa issues...)
Kevin Eastman on the other hand actually seems open to the idea of old Fred Wolf characters. He's never shown any real obvious disdain for the cartoons (as far as I know), and he even approved of a female turtle, something Peter would never do.
Likewise now that we know Krang is appearing in the IDW series, which Kevin is co-writing, you really have to wonder. Why doesn't Kevin Eastman oppose the old mutant characters or Fred Wolf characters like PL does?
Jester
08-20-2011, 12:34 AM
Part of me wonders if Kevin sees the potential of those characters. Sure they were created for the "cheesy" kids show, but in the right hands, they could be more. Never discount a character because of their origin...but IDK. Maybe we should ask Kevin. :D
CyberCubed
08-20-2011, 12:36 AM
Part of me wonders if Kevin sees the potential of those characters. Sure they were created for the "cheesy" kids show, but in the right hands, they could be more. Never discount a character because of their origin...but IDK. Maybe we should ask Kevin. :D
I find it strange since Kevin likes the more gritty, realistic aspect of the Turtles, yet PL likes the more sci-fi aspect of it.
Yet most of the old toon/Archie mutants were more based on the sci-fi elements....
Powder
08-20-2011, 12:45 AM
Kevin sees the Turtles for what they are; a global phenomenon that is popular no matter what. He's obviously very opened minded, and is probably straight up flattered that people want to do so many different things with his creation. Pete has (as of the last decade at least) seemed to think of them as his sole property that should only be done his way, and any non-Mirage version should be swept away.
Peter = AndrewNDB lulz (Just poking fun at ya buddy)
Roseangelo
08-20-2011, 01:03 AM
Kevin isn't an ass.
Jester
08-20-2011, 01:04 AM
Kevin isn't an ass.
Oh, come on. That's a little harsh. I know you 2 have never seen eye to eye, but there's no need for that.
Donnie
08-20-2011, 01:10 AM
Leave it to C3 to start a thread like this, clearly calling out the anti-Laird wolves.
Kevin isn't an ass.
Completely uncalled for.
Oh, come on. That's a little harsh. I know you 2 have never seen eye to eye, but there's no need for that.
Seriously.
What, PL didn't like your "Ninja Pizza", Rose? :roll:
People are way too harsh on Peter Laird. He has done more for TMNT than Kevin ever has, and up until this new IDW series one would have put money on never hearing Kevin's name associated with the Turtles again outside of public appearances.
ToTheNines
08-20-2011, 01:12 AM
I think Eastman is simply a more open-minded individual.
Spitfire
08-20-2011, 01:58 AM
Peter tends to view what happened to turtles outside of the comics as complete rape. He basically sold his soul and it's obvious he regrets it now. The turtles he made are not what's well known, some goofy pizza eating surfers are.
Kevin seems to be able to make a separation of things. I think overall he takes turtles less seriously, Bodycount clued us in on that, and in doing so views the franchise like any other. Is turtles really any different then Batman or Spider-man? They've all had good and bad TV shows, both animated and live action. They've had embarrassing live stage performances and spent years being treated less serious then they were meant to be because of past media portrayal.
Slap-Happy
08-20-2011, 02:45 AM
I think Peter takes the turtles way more seriously than Kevin does. It seems to me, that Kevin has love for any and everything turtles related. Including Venus, Next Mutation, etc.
Bsically, Kevin hasn't forgotten that the turtles started off as a tounge in cheek parody, while Pete thinks of them as a little more sophisticated.
Jester
08-20-2011, 02:51 AM
I agree with Spitfire and Mr. Reilly. It seems that Kevin is a little more laid back in general, and sees the Turtles as fun characters to tell fun stories with. Peter seems more reserved (uptight, if you will) and he treated the Turtles very seriously, it seemed. Maybe Kevin's distance from the Turtles until recently made him excited to work with these characters he enjoys again.
It's odd that once Peter relinquished the property, Kevin came back. Is it a coincidence, or do you think Kevin didn't feel like he could tell the stories he wanted with Peter's hands heavy on the reins?
EDIT: It's odd typing Kevin so much...that's my name...:P
Abnormal Freak
08-20-2011, 02:51 AM
Kevin's more fun. :p
Slap-Happy
08-20-2011, 03:01 AM
It's odd that once Peter relinquished the property, Kevin came back. Is it a coincidence, or do you think Kevin didn't feel like he could tell the stories he wanted with Peter's hands heavy on the reins?
It's already better than when only Laird had the rights. The new comics and cartoon already look a helluva' lot more entertaining than the last 10 years of turtles cartoons and comics (excluding Tales).
Jester
08-20-2011, 03:11 AM
It's already better than when only Laird had the rights. The new comics and cartoon already look a helluva' lot more entertaining than the last 10 years of turtles cartoons and comics (excluding Tales).
I dunna, the 4Kids series was fine for what it was, a more serious cartoon adapting many of the early Eastman and Laird issues. Volume 4 was a little slow, but not the worst. Heck, I wish that Kevin and Pete could have figured out a way to work it out and both continue to work on the series until now. But maybe they were too much of an odd couple for that to have happened.
King Suck
08-20-2011, 08:58 AM
Peter is very controlling and Mirage purist in his views on his co creation. That has had both its good and bad results over the years. I think some of wolfs characters can be updated and incorporated into IDWs new TMNT and if done right will come off awesome (please no female turtle though:trazz:)
When Peter sold the property I was really pissed at him. After reading his explanation where he discussed his mental health not so much.
IDW offered Peter a chance to be involved in the new TMNT and he declined. Now after reading his blog where he said he he would be involved if Kevin asked him to be directly I feel sorry for him more then anything. Guy needs a hug.
I do secretly hope Peter and Kevin will work on TMNT together again someday. But if they dont I hope seeing what IDW does with his turtles relights his creative spark or puts the fire under Peters ass and makes him do his own thing again (His deal with Viacom allows him to Publish something like 18 issues under Mirage a year).
DrSpengler
08-20-2011, 10:06 AM
Laird still thinks of himself as a legitimate underground indie comics creator and the Turtles as a legitimate underground indie comics title, or at least he did for the last few years before he sold his creation to a multinational corporation for several million dollars.
While it was certainly a... noble mindset, it was also a bit delusional. He "sold out" decades ago and there's simply no changing history. Refusing to distribute your comic in major bookstores in order to "keep Mirage small" isn't going to erase the fact that you spent twenty years selling action figures, trapperkeepers and paper napkins with your creation's faces smeared on them to haul in a quick and easy payday of colossal proportions.
Whereas Laird was only interested in pleasing fans of "his" Turtles (not allowing Fred Wolf and Archie characters to appear in the 4Kids series, keeping them out of the toyline, etc) and has that strict "my way or the highway, don't like it then don't buy it" mantra, I think Eastman is a far more amicable individual.
He understands that there are different sects of the casual and hardcore Turtle fandom and he's no qualms when it comes to trying to please more than just the fans of "his original vision".
Whereas Laird would respond to requests with "if you don't like it, scram", Eastman's the kinda guy who'll respond with "lemme see what I can do".
Just two very different personalities.
I appreciate that, at the very end, Laird relented on his stance and let us have "Turtles Forever". I'm grateful for that. And I'm not of the exaggerated opinion that "if Eastman had bought out Laird instead of the other way around, the streets would be paved with GOLD".
However, I didn't care for Laird's years of marginalizing fans of anything other than what he created.
Venom
08-20-2011, 10:50 AM
Is it a coincidence, or do you think Kevin didn't feel like he could tell the stories he wanted with Peter's hands heavy on the reins?
It's funny you say tha because Kevin said almost those exact words a few years back in an interview. IIRC, it was SuicideGirls.
I hope that Kevin does get in touch with Peter and asks him to collaborate again. With the property being out of their hands the two could legitimately return to creating "Eastman and Laird's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" at a less stressful pace.
azrael
08-20-2011, 10:52 AM
Peter is very controlling and Mirage purist in his views on his co creation. That has had both its good and bad results over the years. I think some of wolfs characters can be updated and incorporated into IDWs new TMNT and if done right will come off awesome (please no female turtle though:trazz:)
When Peter sold the property I was really pissed at him. After reading his explanation where he discussed his mental health not so much.
IDW offered Peter a chance to be involved in the new TMNT and he declined. Now after reading his blog where he said he he would be involved if Kevin asked him to be directly I feel sorry for him more then anything. Guy needs a hug.
I do secretly hope Peter and Kevin will work on TMNT together again someday. But if they dont I hope seeing what IDW does with his turtles relights his creative spark or puts the fire under Peters ass and makes him do his own thing again (His deal with Viacom allows him to Publish something like 18 issues under Mirage a year).
I have always wanted Kevin and Peter to do a "this is how mirage tmnt end" whether they get killed, die or just go on would be a fitting end.
As Kevin said in an interview Peter was more of a purist and Kevin has less of an attachment to the Turtles than he did.
DrSpengler
08-20-2011, 11:57 AM
In regards to the perception of Laird being a "dick" or such, well, he's definately a guy with a very aggressive and critical personality. He doesn't mince words, he doesn't hide what he thinks beneath a masque of subtlety and he doesn't have patience for pleasantries.
I think Laird's always been that way. Steve Murphy tells the story of how he was considering quitting Mirage because of the pressure coming down on him from Victor Gorelick. He went to Laird looking for a sympathetic ear and what he got was a "don't let the door hit you on the way out".
Laird's a guy who has no time for what he perceives as "whining", regardless of circumstances.
Those attributes certainly do seem "dickish", but I'm sure they're neccessary for running a global franchise and trying to keep some semblance of creative control over the whole thing.
The last ten years or so have definately been Laird trying to steer the franchise back into the direction he wanted rather than let it get away from him like it did in the 80s and early 90s. While I don't appreciate the marginalizing of fans who preferred other concepts from the franchsie that he didn't approve of, I do acknowledge that he was operating under good intentions, even if his attitude was more than a little brusk.
But I don't like to villify the guy too much. I was rather shocked when he commented on my somewhat critical review of Fugitoid #1 (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2010/11/fugitoid-microseries-1.html) and was very polite and insightful. I had always thought that, if he should ever stumble upon my tiny little blog and deign to comment, it would be something vitriolic and aggressive. But he did and it wasn't. The experience caused me to rethink my view of Laird as a person, anyway.
But whether Laird and Eastman ever "make up" is their personal business and none of mine. If they never work together again, I'll understand. We've already seen what Laird's solo vision for the Turtles is like over the past ten years. I'm ready to see what some other creative minds can do.
cloud
08-20-2011, 06:26 PM
The way I feel is that Kevin seems more open minded with the Turtles. He is the co-creator but also sees it as something he create but not the only thing in his life. He has his Heavy Metal and he's happy with it.
Peter of the other hand still kept his responsibility for the Turtles and Mirage. He still works with the turtles crew and I've always felt that he takes the Turtles very personally which isn't a bad thing. Sometimes I would think if I'm the creator of Batman I would have really restricted him to stay a certain way, no campy TV shows, and no silly armors,etc. Just an example.
I don't think PL hates the Fred Wolf characters but rather just don't feel attached to them as his original creations. Sure you can get a physical appearance of Rocksteady and Bebop for the 4Kids show, they did dressed up Gen to look like Rocksteady and have a assassin to look like Bebop but at the end, it's a different show with a different direction. THere was no need to introduce either Rocksteady or Bebop in the new shop as Shredder's henchmen. The only really to do it would be to please the old toons fans. We all know what happens when you're adding elements to the story just to please the fan demand. (Spider-man3)
I respect both Peter Laird and Kevin Eastman for what they have accomplished, beyond that is just personal decisions from them that I as a fan have no control of.
CyberCubed
08-24-2011, 10:59 AM
Interesting enough Kevin designed the new mutant fox character for IDW.
Have we ever heard Kevin's stance on other mutants existing in the world with the Turtles/Splinter and Leatherhead?
Jester
08-24-2011, 11:47 AM
I dunna, but I actually agree with Peter on the "too many mutants takes away from what makes the turtles unique" issue.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-24-2011, 12:22 PM
I dunna, but I actually agree with Peter on the "too many mutants takes away from what makes the turtles unique" issue.
I don't, because Peter also had aliens populate earth so that the turtles could walk around among people like everyone else.
Jester
08-24-2011, 12:33 PM
True...and I wasn't a huge fan of that either.
Andrew NDB
08-24-2011, 12:35 PM
I don't, because Peter also had aliens populate earth so that the turtles could walk around among people like everyone else.
That was the premise he came up with for Volume 4 to change the status quo. It doesn't represent "How Peter Laird prefers to see the Turtles in earlier times."
***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-24-2011, 12:44 PM
Having a girl turtle, or the ability for them to reproduce with other humanoid reptile mutants/aliens would subtract from the uniqueness, not the presence of other mutant animals..."Sons of the Silent Age" comes to mind.
CyberCubed
08-25-2011, 01:01 PM
Anyone notice the double standard? The TMNT can meet aliens, monsters, or "mystical beings," but as long as they're not mutants, than the Turtles are still special.
Honestly, how does that make any sense? How many freaks have their been in the TMNT universe that weren't mutants?
Why isn't Kevin as opposed to Fred Wolf characters like Peter is?
Cuz watering down the concept for the sake of longevity was just something Kevin was always more comfortable with.
Donnie
09-07-2011, 11:40 AM
cuz watering down the concept for the sake of longevity was just something kevin was always more comfortable with.
Quoted for truth!
herugrim
09-07-2011, 12:06 PM
As I continue to watch the 03 series and read the old comics, I've found it interesting just how similar they are. At first I kinda thought 'Hey, I guess Peter really wanted them to stick to the script.' but upon reading the notes he'd written about the individual episodes from when he originally reviewed them, it seems he really didn't do that. Apparently it was the desire of the studio to basically make the series an animated adaption of the comics. Peter actually seems to make insightful feedback for the episodes and definitely kept certain episodes from getting too bad. Overall, I recognize that his control was very good for the series, however long it may have lasted (hard to believe he had any feedback on the last few seasons).
I can't blame the guy for being passionate about the series. Generally I'd consider it a good thing. However suggesting that he didn't hate the 87 series is just not true. If you read some of his more aggressive notes from the 03 series, he practically uses Fred Wolf's name as a swear. Dude hated it, and apparently blamed Wolf for it personally.
Personally I never understood purists. Fans love to quote source materials like bibles and diviations as strickly the worst thing that could possibly be done. However just because a movie is based on a novel doesn't mean that the novel no longer exists. It's just a different version, allowing fans to be able to enjoy each in their own way. Fans who prefer one over the other will always have whichever version they prefer. People who liked the original comics could always go back and read those issues, while watching films and television shows that adapt that story without altering it seem redundant to me. How many times must I watch that rooftop battle with shredder play out?
twopinacoladas
09-07-2011, 04:55 PM
My guess is IDW and Nick are calling the shots and Kevin is just happy to be a part of it and help make it as good as he can... maybe he didn't mind some of the old characers as much as Pete...
Toby Barrett
09-07-2011, 05:27 PM
I'm in the camp that feels bringing more mutants into the mix doesn't really ruin the concept of the TMNT.
Sure, in the Mirage comics it was a freak accident and effects the creature through a large timespan, so the same process happening over and over again wouldn't really work that well.
But in the 80s toon, Archie comics, and now the IDW series, where mutagen and the mutation process is more easy to accomplish, why the heck not? The turtles fighting punks and ninjas are great, but now and again it's great to see them fighting other freaks of nature as well. Loves me some Tokka and Rahzar.
And really, the turtles were fighting aliens and monsters all the time in the more serious versions of the franchise. That really isn't much different from fighting other mutants.
CyberCubed
11-30-2011, 09:15 PM
My only problem with the Archie series is it felt like there was a new mutant introduced in almost every issue. Some of them were pointless like Chameleon and even Scumbug/Wyrm who served little to no point in "filler" stories.
Then there was that 4-armed tiger guy and the Al'Falqa bird who were just animal beings for no reasons. Even guys who didn't need to be animals, like Chein Khan, were just made into animals for the sake of it.
It actually got kinda ridiculous after a while.
ssjup81
11-30-2011, 09:42 PM
My only problem with the Archie series is it felt like there was a new mutant introduced in almost every issue. Some of them were pointless like Chameleon and even Scumbug/Wyrm who served little to no point in "filler" stories.
Then there was that 4-armed tiger guy and the Al'Falqa bird who were just animal beings for no reasons. Even guys who didn't need to be animals, like Chein Khan, were just made into animals for the sake of it.
It actually got kinda ridiculous after a while.I agree with this. This is why I wasn't a fan of the whole Mutanimal thing. I felt that Archie definitely had way too many mutant characters. Ironically, seems the original cartoon series didn't, unless those characters in the Red Sky arc counted that were around for a bit...oh, and Carter. But anywho, yeah...Archie definitely had way too many mutant characters. I could barely keep up with them.
I wonder what Kevin thought about Archie's take on the franchise.
Andrew NDB
11-30-2011, 09:57 PM
The Mutanimal thing had its heart in the right place, though. Would be interesting to see such a thing now, reconceptualized into like a... DC Vertigo sort of way.
CyberCubed
11-30-2011, 10:49 PM
I was fine with the Mutanimals, I mean all the "extra" mutants:
- Chameleon
- Scumbug and Wyrm
- The Wooly Mammoth Caveman
- The Uncanny Trio
- Chein Khan (why couldn't he just stay human?)
- 4 armed Tiger
- Llama
- Al' Falqa
- Vid Vicious (does he even count?)
Of course we got some awesome ones, Armaggon and Verminator X were the best new mutants. I also loved Merdude, Slash and the regular Mutanimals.
As you read through the Archie series, almost every major story arc brings forth a new mutant.
twopinacoladas
12-01-2011, 10:07 PM
Edit: I totally didn't remember making my previous post, but it probably sums it up better, so no to waste any ones time reading my little rant. Select + delete :)
Andrew NDB
12-01-2011, 10:35 PM
My guess is IDW and Nick are calling the shots and Kevin is just happy to be a part of it and help make it as good as he can... maybe he didn't mind some of the old characers as much as Pete...
... or maybe he did and is just so much of a class act and, as others have pointed out, is so enthused to be a part of things going forward that he's more than willing to roll with things no matter how the chips fall and cards are laid out.
Vegita-San
12-06-2011, 12:19 PM
Peter tends to view what happened to turtles outside of the comics as complete rape. He basically sold his soul and it's obvious he regrets it now. The turtles he made are not what's well known, some goofy pizza eating surfers are.
.
+1 on this. This is how I always felt as well..He created something that was marginally successful, but it took someone else re-imagining of the idea for it to really take off... That, combined with how many hours and hours of frustration in dealing with Fred Wolf (who was rumored to rule with an iron fist and ignored just about everyone), would leave anyone bitter about the whole experience..
But, We also owe Peter a whole hell of a lot for giving us the coolest ever 4Kids show. As much as I love the original series, lets face it.. the new show was a 100 times better... Have you ever read some of the script proposals for the series on his blog? We have Pete to thank for keeping some kind of quality control on the series....and the characters in check.
I must have missed where Krang himself (not General Krang, a possible human character) is going to be in IDW.. where was this confirmed?
CyberCubed
12-06-2011, 12:22 PM
I must have missed where Krang himself (not General Krang, a possible human character) is going to be in IDW.. where was this confirmed?
Krang (as in, the evil brain) obviously is General Krang. The human body appears to be a robot.
Think of General Krang as a more realistic and less cheesy version of his android body from the old toon.
Vegita-San
12-06-2011, 12:22 PM
When Peter sold the property I was really pissed at him. After reading his explanation where he discussed his mental health not so much.
+ 1 on this as well.. I now feel guilty for taking it out on the guy, considering how tough handling a multi million dollar operation must have been. Not one of my prouder moments... But it's like the 5 stages of death...regret, acceptance etc ;o)..
Venom
12-06-2011, 02:01 PM
Krang (as in, the evil brain) obviously is General Krang. The human body appears to be a robot.
Think of General Krang as a more realistic and less cheesy version of his android body from the old toon.
Also, let us not forget that this series is melding various aspects from all versions; that being said, for those not too familiar with Mirage's earlier TMNT comics, the Utroms had human skin suits covering their robotic bodies.
Think Terminator piloted by a little squishy alien in the belly. :D
CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 05:41 PM
I guess its true what they say, remove Peter Laird from the equation and all of a sudden all the old toon characters are making their return to the franchise after over a decade of hiatus.
I bet when they told Kevin they wanted to bring back Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady, he probably said, "Sure, go ahead!" or something along those lines. Kevin Eastman doesn't mind the old toon stuff, so I think that says a lot.
ssjup81
12-07-2011, 09:32 PM
Personally, I like the fact that Kevin is so lax about the whole OT thing. I loved the OT series, but I also have an appreciation for the source material as well as other people I'm sure. I like the original Turtles comics, I just wish I would've read them earlier, but I was young when the OT series started, so no surprise there. Either way, seems that Kevin realizes this, but Peter doesn't or just refuses to. We can like more than one medium of the franchise.
Also, thinking about it, I wonder if the show would've started in maybe the early 90s as opposed to the late 80s, if it would've been more action-like from the get-go (like the Red Sky eps), like say shows like Spiderman, Batman: The Animated Series, Superman: The Animated Series, etc.
Mindy
12-08-2011, 08:26 AM
Kevin seems more open to new, and past, ideas. His personality is better suited for the spotlight. I see Laird being a fantastic novelist. I haven't checked out his blog lately.
pannoni1
12-08-2011, 11:44 AM
PL is more of a "I don't want this to be a total sellout, devoid of it's original meaning". However, he DID approve with Kevin back then of the Fred Wolf characters, so he had to have some laxness in order for it to succeed (of course this was before it was a cash cow). And of course Ryan and his crew met Kevin with the OT voice actors in 2009, with a picture of him with the cast proof of this. I also feel Kevin is more open to public opinion, meaning he would be more willing to accept what fans want. However, Peter of course created his own 4kids exclusive characters. Honestly, it was too soon in 2003 to have ALL the OT characters return as it would just seem like a rehash of the Fred Wolf series rather than creating a new one that feels distinct with just an occassional shout-out to various fans, such as in the episode Secret Origins. But it's been 15 years since we've had the Technodrome and Krang, and Turtles Forever marked Bebop & Rocksteady's first appearance in 15 years, which is a long enough time to build the nostalgia factor to woo the original fans.
CyberCubed
12-09-2011, 10:43 PM
It really makes you wonder though how different the 4kids series would be if Kevin was the one in charge instead of PL.
With Ch'rell being in the series, I don't think they would have used Krang. Two alien brains who were exiled from their homeworld and are warlords from another galaxy? Might be too much for one show.
Then again if they had planned to use Krang, then maybe Shredder would have stayed human from the start.
I think the 4kids writers really did want to use some old toon characters like Slash.
Konchadunga
12-23-2011, 11:42 PM
I must say, for all his apparent lack of social skills and disdain for a show that I loved, I feel sorry for Laird. Based on his statements and what's been obvious from the get-go, he's had an uphill battle for a long time. Apparently when he first authorized the deal with Fred Wolf, his background as an independent writer and artist hadn't given him a good grasp of how big business worked, so he probably figured he was doing what he needed to do to save the comic, and he may even have been right. Still, after the show began, the comic's Letters section was apparently filled with hate mail from fans calling them sellouts--as though Eastman and Laird were making anyone watch the cartoon or watering down the comic itself.
I also think maybe Peter Laird didn't hate the show initially, as the early episodes, though obviously altered for kids, still had action and adventure elements. However, once the franchise's new merchandise-driven direction just kept it going for quantity rather than quality, he probably felt the need to put the genie back in the bottle. By the time garbage like the "Coming Out of Their Shells" Tour and The Next Mutation was being made, it seemed like the fan enthusiasm for what the franchise had become was waning. Laird probably felt it was his duty to rein in the franchise and restore dignity to it. I don't blame him for that.
But then, when he tried to do a new cartoon with better adaptations, better action, and quality control, what was among the biggest reactions he got? More hateful backlash, because he wasn't being faithful to what they saw as the original. The show was eventually quite a success, objectively speaking much better than the original cartoon, and I liked it better (at least for the first few seasons), but a lot of people shunned it just because it wasn't nostalgic.
So Peter Laird certainly has a lot of reasons to be pissed off, and I can see why he resolved to just sell off the series. I loved the original show in spite of what Laird thought of it, and loved the 2003 show in spite of what many old fans thought, but at this point it shouldn't be about what any one person thinks. A pragmatic compromise is the best solution now that mainstream fandom has been broken into rival factions. To Laird's credit, in his blog about why he sold the franchise, he mentioned that although he prefers the more accurate 2003 series, he's aware that many fans prefer the 1987 series, so stop worrying about the Nickelodeon series because no matter how it measures up to prior incarnations, it will have it's own unique charm, gain the franchise new fans, and guarantee it's continued existence. It may have taken a long time, but it seems he finally got that his own ideas aren't the be-all and end-all of the series.
CyberCubed
12-23-2011, 11:49 PM
Peter Laird had a lot on his plate in the 2000's:
- He wrote every issue of Volume 4
- He had to approve all scripts for Tales before they went into production for over 70 issues.
- He had to approve EVERY episode script for the 4kids series. As you can see on his blog, he picked apart every single detail and line of dialogue until they got it right. This show ran for 157 episodes, so he definitely worked hard.
- He worked with Imagi on the 2007 movie.
- He approves/disapproved Playmates toy ideas and videogame piches
So yeah...to say the guy didn't work hard is an understatement, he truly had passion for the franchise and Mirage/4kids in 2001-2009 was only as good because of him.
Konchadunga
12-24-2011, 02:44 AM
No doubt about that, although there are certain episode scripts that I wish he rejected wholesale...
Hermano Dyvas
12-24-2011, 05:08 AM
I guess its true what they say, remove Peter Laird from the equation and all of a sudden all the old toon characters are making their return to the franchise after over a decade of hiatus.
I bet when they told Kevin they wanted to bring back Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady, he probably said, "Sure, go ahead!" or something along those lines. Kevin Eastman doesn't mind the old toon stuff, so I think that says a lot.
Yeah, no disrepect to Laird, but in a way he was holding back his own franchise. Of course it was his property and he had every right to do so if he wanted to. I'm just not too upset about him not making the key decisions anymore (he did a good job on 2K3 though).
I'm a bigger fan of Eastman's style then Laird's although I will say both were at their best when put together.
Donnie
12-24-2011, 10:27 AM
Yeah, no disrepect to Laird, but in a way he was holding back his own franchise. Of course it was his property and he had every right to do so if he wanted to. I'm just not too upset about him not making the key decisions anymore (he did a good job on 2K3 though).
I'm a bigger fan of Eastman's style then Laird's although I will say both were at their best when put together.
Not singling you out Hermano, but generally speaking I think to say that Laird holding back his own franchise at all is a misleading and mostly incorrect statement. He did so much for TMNT in the 2000s. Without his tremendous effort in the 2k3 show we may have received a terrible rehash of the OT which may have plunged the Turtles into the silliest time period we've ever seen them manifested in Nick. Laird's darker 2k3 show hopefully stopped that goofy possibility in its tracks, because the 2k3 gave the TMNT fresh breathe to a new audience. I think when the Nick show comes out, we'll see that it took some pointers from the 2k3. Maybe that's just wishful thinking. ;)
On the whole though, I can't see why anybody would dislike Laird's treatment with the TMNT. I can see initial feelings of despair toward him when he sold the rights (I was guilty of that, but got over it) but his mature direction is what kept the Turtles alive, in my opinion. His determination to not include the cheesy characters from the OT in Volume 4 and in the 2k3 was a blessing, at least for me.
Concerning the whole Eastman vs. Laird thing, like you said Hermano they worked best when they were together. Two great minds are always better than one. However, and most here like this about Eastman, in my opinion Eastman can be (not always) way too nonchalant and laid back about his characters. Laird at least had a checks and balances system firmly in place.
AcidBurn30
12-24-2011, 01:38 PM
PL has made his dislike for most of the Fred Wolf characters many, many times. He of course prevented the 4kids writers from using them in the cartoon, and would not allow any of them to appear in the Mirage comics either. (although Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady got a brief cameo in one of the Cowboys of Moo Mesa issues...)
Kevin Eastman on the other hand actually seems open to the idea of old Fred Wolf characters. He's never shown any real obvious disdain for the cartoons (as far as I know), and he even approved of a female turtle, something Peter would never do.
Likewise now that we know Krang is appearing in the IDW series, which Kevin is co-writing, you really have to wonder. Why doesn't Kevin Eastman oppose the old mutant characters or Fred Wolf characters like PL does?
Kevin didn't want to do the Venus turtle, but Fox lady wanted a female turtle for the female fans who want to watch it.. He just did, but he didn't really care much for it as well as Peter. So they had to do this for the show because the lady from Fox wants this...which she should never have any powers do make a idea or a thought on anything lol...
Hermano Dyvas
12-24-2011, 05:49 PM
Not singling you out Hermano, but generally speaking I think to say that Laird holding back his own franchise at all is a misleading and mostly incorrect statement. He did so much for TMNT in the 2000s. Without his tremendous effort in the 2k3 show we may have received a terrible rehash of the OT which may have plunged the Turtles into the silliest time period we've ever seen them manifested in Nick. Laird's darker 2k3 show hopefully stopped that goofy possibility in its tracks, because the 2k3 gave the TMNT fresh breathe to a new audience. I think when the Nick show comes out, we'll see that it took some pointers from the 2k3. Maybe that's just wishful thinking. ;)
Oh, I agree he has done more then a wonderful job on 2K3, if you take away the nostalgia element it's a lot better then the OT! The nicktoon will have to pull of some serious stunts to beat it and I'm not so sure it can.
On the whole though, I can't see why anybody would dislike Laird's treatment with the TMNT. I can see initial feelings of despair toward him when he sold the rights (I was guilty of that, but got over it) but his mature direction is what kept the Turtles alive, in my opinion. His determination to not include the cheesy characters from the OT in Volume 4 and in the 2k3 was a blessing, at least for me.
When I say things like Laird is holding his own franchise back I think of examples like the 2007 movie, while it's not really a bad movie it's nothing that stands out, it just sort of passed by almost unnoticed by the general audience. I really think it would have caught a lot more attention if it had more elements from the OT. Notably, the technodrome, Krang, Bebop & Rocksteady and of course Shredder!
They could've given the movie a darker tone then the Fred Wolf universe, that way they could have showed a darker version of the tmnt to the audience with elements they are familiar with.
From that foundation they could've worked on changing the general opinion "TMNT is for kids". Sort of like "Batman begins" did for Batman.
Concerning the whole Eastman vs. Laird thing, like you said Hermano they worked best when they were together. Two great minds are always better than one. However, and most here like this about Eastman, in my opinion Eastman can be (not always) way too nonchalant and laid back about his characters. Laird at least had a checks and balances system firmly in place.
True true, but then Laird's con is his storytelling can get a bit slow (v4) or too over the top with the sci-fi. Eastman is kind of the opposite. I guess that's why they work together so well. :D
Konchadunga
12-24-2011, 10:24 PM
Oh, I agree he has done more then a wonderful job on 2K3, if you take away the nostalgia element it's a lot better then the OT! The nicktoon will have to pull of some serious stunts to beat it and I'm not so sure it can.
When I say things like Laird is holding his own franchise back I think of examples like the 2007 movie, while it's not really a bad movie it's nothing that stands out, it just sort of passed by almost unnoticed by the general audience. I really think it would have caught a lot more attention if it had more elements from the OT. Notably, the technodrome, Krang, Bebop & Rocksteady and of course Shredder!
I agree. Peter Laird managed to create a show that went above and beyond filling the shoes of the classic one (although I also feel more lax censorship had a fair amount to do with it), but he never had the zest for making it a vast multimedia franchise, the way they did with the old show. I feel the toys and video games based on the OT are also better than the OT itself in some respects. The toys had a very thorough and artistic direction while the show had extremely flawed animation, and did more justice to some of the Mirage characters than the actual show did--Fugitoid and Panda Khan actually got toys made of them despite not appearing in the show. The video games did justice to the Turtles' reputations as tough warriors in a way the show rarely did, and the Tournament Fighter games were many people's first introduction to Karai, at a time when tough female characters were rare in the mainstream franchise. Then there's the movies, which, though more based on the comics than the OT, worked enough elements from it in to introduce iconic comic storylines and good action scenes to the masses.
Peter Laird vastly improved the core of the franchise but he didn't do as well on the fringes. The new show was likeable because even though it didn't use characters from the old one, it had a rich supporting cast of its own, but a large portion of that supporting cast didn't leave the show in many capacities. I attribute Mutant Melee's lack of a good roster to its early release (though I could be wrong about that), but there's no excuse at all for Smash Up's even worse roster. There's a rumor that Peter Laird blocked the inclusion of characters from the OT in that game, but that rumor seems kind of ungrounded when you remember that there were still plenty characters from the comics and the new show that could have been there instead, and weren't. I think that game's flaws were just Ubisoft being lazy, but you'd think that Laird could have put them back in line in delivering on their promises; considering how much control he had over the franchise as a whole. The lack of nostalgic elements in many of the other games also made their dated design a lot more apparent, and the fact that music and images were changed in the unlockable versions of the old games also reinforced the impression that there was a cultural revolution being launched against the OT. Again, those were probably just Konami's fault, but you'd think Laird could have intervened. The new Playmates toys also had some hicups in quality, although some of them were quite good. Finally, the 2007 movie had few of the larger-than-life qualities of the new show; lacking the involvement of many interesting characters and feeling too detached from continuity. It was the movie introduction of Karai, but I don't see why she actually had to be there, and while the past movies didn't have a broad scope or lots of characters either, they were adaptations of comic storylines so they had an excuse, sequels are supposed to be bigger than their predecessors, and simply calling the 2007 movie Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles with no subtitle created expectations it couldn't meet.
I think Laird's problem is that he's just too idealistic. His grand vision may have been good, but he doesn't seem to understand marketing well; you need to be able to compromise to make a grand vision appeal on a broad level. His staunch opposition to including so many iconic features the franchise had in its heyday not only didn't help the new series gain the respect that the old one had; I think it actually hurt his effort by gaining it a stigma that made old fans steer clear of it. Despite its different tone, I am quite certain more fans would go for it if only it included, say, a few characters original to the OT. My brother was a hardcore TMNT fan in its glory days, and I'm sure he doesn't know who Karai, Bishop, Renet, or the Utroms are, which is a shame considering they were good characters. Think of how many people like him would have learned of them had they just been courted over by the new show throwing some bones to them. That's why the first two movies worked so well, and why the new show didn't.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.