PDA

View Full Version : Raphael #1 synopsis


Pages : [1] 2

ToTheNines
08-20-2011, 12:16 PM
Found this at midtown's website

Following in the tradition of the original TMNT microseries comes the first of four stand-alone tales centering on each Turtle. Raphael's place in the world is uncertain and he can't shake the feeling that he'll always be an outsider. That changes when he finds another mutant, the arctic fox Alopex, who may have a new clue pertaining to the Turtles origin. Unfortunately she's too busy being hunted alive to share the info! Will Raphael and his new friend survive the night?

Raphael plus Fox-lady never ends well.

Slap-Happy
08-20-2011, 12:18 PM
Uh oh... I'm not sure I exactly like where this is going.

Venom
08-20-2011, 12:19 PM
:teek: Alopex = Ninjara?! I find myself somewhat excited about this, especially considering she's a mutant as well.

Xav
08-20-2011, 12:56 PM
From the IDW site Variant covers:
David Peterson black & white variant cover!
“Retro” variant edition, featuring a re-mastered original Kevin Eastman Raphael Micro-Series cover!

Bullet points:
Blockbuster Angel: After the Fall team of Lynch and Urru reunited!
New character Alopex designed by Kevin Eastman—his first new design for the TMNT world in over 15 years!
Cover by David “Mouse Guard” Peterson! So Eastman created Alopex? Interesting...

CyberCubed
08-20-2011, 01:02 PM
First a new mutant cat, now a new mutant fox?

It's like Scratch and Ninjara have been replaced.

pl212
08-20-2011, 01:03 PM
... too many mutants :/

CyberCubed
08-20-2011, 01:05 PM
... too many mutants :/

Already Old Hob, Alopex, and likely Leatherhead confirmed.

Perhaps Krang is experimenting with his mutagen again.

pl212
08-20-2011, 02:12 PM
Already Old Hob, Alopex, and likely Leatherhead confirmed.

Perhaps Krang is experimenting with his mutagen again.

I just hope it doesn't get out of hand, then being a mutant wouldn't be such a weird thing in this new tmnt world anymore.

Powder
08-20-2011, 04:04 PM
I share the mixed emotions... I like the idea of a ton of mutants for the show, but the comics were usually a break from that. We'll see.

Venom
08-20-2011, 04:33 PM
At least the mutants have all originally been animals, thus far anyway.

CyberCubed
08-20-2011, 05:21 PM
I just wish they'd reintroduce old mutants rather than make
new ones based on the same animal.

What's next, another mutant shark but this one isn't Armaggon? Or maybe another mutant bull?

Venom
08-20-2011, 05:57 PM
Hopefully they'll have a mutant mole man! :twink:

Samhain
08-20-2011, 06:40 PM
Meh, we'll see where this goes...

oldmanwinters
08-20-2011, 06:44 PM
As far as the Ninjara character goes, I'm not sure whether Murphy and/or Allan might still retain some legal hold over them. The technicalities of the Mirage sale to Viacom escape me. I know Viacom now owns most of the characters that were introduced in the TMNT-verse, but maybe not all of them.

Still, it sounds interesting.

Although, what's an "arctic fox" doing way down in New York?

joe-eyeball
08-20-2011, 07:10 PM
I hope they are careful with how many new mutants and charachters they introduce early on. Lets keep the Turtles unique. I would like them to focus on the Turtles' "new" origins and not try to make things too congested where they can't fully develop the primary characters properly. But, lets wait and see before passing final judgement.

CyberCubed
08-20-2011, 08:26 PM
We're barely two issues in and already we have two animal mutants. At this point the IDW series is feeling closer to the Archie series or
cartoons rather than the Mirage comics.

I suppose it can be a good or bad thing if you're not into animal
Mutants.

Jester
08-20-2011, 08:39 PM
Not sure what I think. I liked the Archie books, but I can agree with Peter Laird's old adage "too many mutants make the Turtles less unique." I agree with Adam that the new fox probably can't be Ninjara, because Allen and Murphy still own her (thought how the Archie reprints will work if that's the case is a question for another thread.) I'll just wait and see. I have faith in the creative team...until they do something to make that faith disappear.

pl212
08-20-2011, 08:52 PM
I can see how the whole cat & rat thing can play off with splinter and hobs being enemies even before mutation (atleast thats what im thinking its going to be all about), but a fox? lol I hope theres a good explanation to that and no more mutants after that besides Leatherhead :D

John Pannozzi
08-20-2011, 09:09 PM
I agree with Adam that the new fox probably can't be Ninjara, because Allen and Murphy still own her (thought how the Archie reprints will work if that's the case is a question for another thread.)

Actually Chris Allan pretty much told me that Murphy ultimately sold Ninjara to Mirage, so they should be able to use her.

Jester
08-20-2011, 09:49 PM
Actually Chris Allan pretty much told me that Murphy ultimately sold Ninjara to Mirage, so they should be able to use her.
Thanks. That clears up a lot.

Samhain
08-21-2011, 12:40 AM
Didn't see the part about the Eastman variant, damn, this is gonna get expensive. I like the new blood but all of the Eastman variants are must have's for me.

discordiatookie
08-22-2011, 12:42 PM
Well i'm glad they aren't just going for the 'Raph meets Casey' retelling, which to be honest is what I was expecting with this oneshot. A wee bit apprehensive with all the new mutant characters being introduced so early on, but i'm not going to be making any judgements until i've at least read the issues.

“Retro” variant edition, featuring a re-mastered original Kevin Eastman Raphael Micro-Series cover!Sounds kinda cool, look forward to seeing it!

BrianLynch
08-22-2011, 04:53 PM
Hey guys, wanted to introduce myself. My name is Brian Lynch, I'm the writer of the TMNT Micro Series, starting with RAPHAEL.

Been a HUGE fan of this world ever since I picked up the Mirage DONATELLO one-shot years ago. Dig every incarnation, love the characters, and am BEYOND honored to be writing these books.

Anyway, I hope you like my series. Alopex is gonna be pretty cool. The fact that I had Kevin Eastman (!) design the character made my year. I think it's really gonna be something special.

Any non-spoiler questions, feel free to ask, I'll check in when I can.

discordiatookie
08-22-2011, 06:52 PM
Hi Brian, welcome to the 'drome! I'm pretty rubbish at thinking up questions as it is, so just wanna say that i'm looking forward to what you've got in store for us :D

ToTheNines
08-22-2011, 09:15 PM
Hey guys, wanted to introduce myself. My name is Brian Lynch, I'm the writer of the TMNT Micro Series, starting with RAPHAEL.

Been a HUGE fan of this world ever since I picked up the Mirage DONATELLO one-shot years ago. Dig every incarnation, love the characters, and am BEYOND honored to be writing these books.

Anyway, I hope you like my series. Alopex is gonna be pretty cool. The fact that I had Kevin Eastman (!) design the character made my year. I think it's really gonna be something special.

Any non-spoiler questions, feel free to ask, I'll check in when I can.

Welcome!

So do the micro-series issues create one big story? Or will they just tie in to the monthly book as they're released?

Slap-Happy
08-22-2011, 11:16 PM
Welcome to the drome Brian!

Let me just say that I really enjoy your tweets, very funny stuff.

So after Raphael #1 comes out, do you think you'll be doing some more TMNT writing for IDW?

Coola Yagami
08-22-2011, 11:39 PM
So... does this explain where Rapheal was during the first 4 issues?

BrianLynch
08-23-2011, 12:30 AM
Welcome!

So do the micro-series issues create one big story? Or will they just tie in to the monthly book as they're released?

Thanks for the welcome!

Each Turtle's book tell single one-off stories. My goal is to have each issue (a) subtly reflect the original one shots while not at all doing the same story and (b) mirror the personality of the turtles. So, for instance, Raph's will be more intense and gritty, Mikey's will be more fun...

BrianLynch
08-23-2011, 12:31 AM
Welcome to the drome Brian!

Let me just say that I really enjoy your tweets, very funny stuff.

So after Raphael #1 comes out, do you think you'll be doing some more TMNT writing for IDW?

Well, I'm writing the outline for Mike's story as we speak. Hopefully I'll get to tackle each of the Turtles, and if you guys and IDW and Mr. Eastman and Mr. Waltz and Nick like what I've done, and I have more ideas for stories, I'll come back.

BrianLynch
08-23-2011, 12:32 AM
So... does this explain where Rapheal was during the first 4 issues?

Oh that'll be quite clear.

BrianLynch
08-23-2011, 12:32 AM
Hi Brian, welcome to the 'drome! I'm pretty rubbish at thinking up questions as it is, so just wanna say that i'm looking forward to what you've got in store for us :D

Thank you! Can't wait to read your reactions!

Samhain
08-23-2011, 12:35 AM
Welcome! I can't wait to read it and please stick around!:)

CyberCubed
08-23-2011, 01:12 AM
1. Is this female mutant going to become a possible love interest? We all know Raph had love interests in other series, like Ninjara or Mona Lisa...both female mutants.

2. The original one-shot was about Raph meeting Casey Jones. Do you think we'll see that happened in IDW's series later on?

Andrew NDB
08-23-2011, 11:32 AM
1. Is this female mutant going to become a possible love interest? We all know Raph had love interests in other series, like Ninjara or Mona Lisa...both female mutants.

Ninjara wasn't a mutant.

Venom
08-23-2011, 01:32 PM
Well, I'm writing the outline for Mike's story as we speak. Hopefully I'll get to tackle each of the Turtles, and if you guys and IDW and Mr. Eastman and Mr. Waltz and Nick like what I've done, and I have more ideas for stories, I'll come back.

Is it another story with a Christmass setting? Mike seems to get stuck with a yuletide tale. :)

It'd be fun to see a Shredder/Saki micro! :shredder:

Powder
08-23-2011, 01:39 PM
Is it another story with a Christmass setting? Mike seems to get stuck with a yuletide tale. :)

It'd be fun to see a Shredder/Saki micro! :shredder:

Definitely, Splinter too.

BrianLynch
08-23-2011, 04:00 PM
1. Is this female mutant going to become a possible love interest? We all know Raph had love interests in other series, like Ninjara or Mona Lisa...both female mutants.

2. The original one-shot was about Raph meeting Casey Jones. Do you think we'll see that happened in IDW's series later on?

These are both kinda spoiler-y. All will be revealed so, so soon!

BrianLynch
08-23-2011, 04:01 PM
Is it another story with a Christmass setting? Mike seems to get stuck with a yuletide tale. :)

It'd be fun to see a Shredder/Saki micro! :shredder:

Mike's is set in the winter-time, no doubt. Not a Christmas story, though.

And yes, it would be fun to see that micro!

discordiatookie
08-23-2011, 04:20 PM
Thanks for the welcome!

Each Turtle's book tell single one-off stories. My goal is to have each issue (a) subtly reflect the original one shots while not at all doing the same story and (b) mirror the personality of the turtles. So, for instance, Raph's will be more intense and gritty, Mikey's will be more fun...

Good luck with the Leo one shot, the original is pretty much the best thing ever :D

Joking aside, i'm proper looking forward to seeing fresh blood pumped into the TMNT mythos. I'm really hoping for something off the wall new, so i'm kinda chuffed already that the Raph one shot isn't the whole meets Casey Jones malarky all over again. Also, i'm digging how there's one team of people doing the main issues, and another team taking on the micros. Mixing things up a bit! I like...

Powder
08-23-2011, 04:56 PM
Shouldn't I be seeing a preview for this somewhere by now? I wanna make sure I can subscribe the mini...

discordiatookie
08-23-2011, 05:31 PM
Shouldn't I be seeing a preview for this somewhere by now? I wanna make sure I can subscribe the mini...

This what you after?

http://www.idwpublishing.com/news/article/1924/

Fourteenth thingy down...

Powder
08-23-2011, 07:13 PM
Yeah, that's good. Thank ya. Coulda swore it was originally slated for September...

Master Splinter
09-06-2011, 04:47 PM
Yeah, that's good. Thank ya. Coulda swore it was originally slated for September...

Variant for the Raph micro...

http://img835.imageshack.us/img835/1015/sep110282.jpg


-ms

Roseangelo
09-06-2011, 04:54 PM
Variant for the Raph micro...
-ms

Wait, so the b&w art of what's already a variant is another variant?

Powder
09-06-2011, 04:57 PM
Wait, so the b&w art of what's already a variant is another variant?

Apparently so. I dislike it. I wouldn't mind if it were so beautifully detailed that it deserved to be seen naturally... but it's not.

Master Splinter
09-06-2011, 05:00 PM
Wait, so the b&w art of what's already a variant is another variant?

I guess, it's what my lcs has listed on their site as a variant, along with the color version... But that was it for the Raph Micro...

-ms

Venom
09-06-2011, 09:51 PM
Wait, so the b&w art of what's already a variant is another variant?

I guess, it's what my lcs has listed on their site as a variant, along with the color version... But that was it for the Raph Micro...

-ms

The black and white version has been known for a few weeks. There's four covers for the Raph book thus far.

Jester
09-06-2011, 10:18 PM
I've said it before, and I'll say it again. I don't like the placement of Raphael. It should replace the Eastman and Laird's TMNT in my opinion...or at least TMNT.

Samhain
11-05-2011, 12:54 PM
So, has the ''retro'' Kevin Eastman variant cover for this issue been revealed yet? It will be out on the 16th of this month, I believe.

oldmanwinters
11-05-2011, 01:00 PM
So, has the ''retro'' Kevin Eastman variant cover for this issue been revealed yet? It will be out on the 16th of this month, I believe.

I would love to see another variation of the original Raphael #1. It's already been officially homaged at least three or four times(Archie #9, Division Comics #3, Dutch Hero Turtles #22, and maybe one other publication) that I can remember.

Raph's Girl
11-05-2011, 03:06 PM
*reads the synopsis* An Arctic Fox named Alopex... is her last name Lagopus? *lol* Cute that her name is the former genus name for the Arctic Fox's (which is really just Greek for Fox :P). Can't wait to see Ninjara er Alopex! :D I LOVE Arctic Fox's!! It's one of the animals I visit first at the local zoo. :D *looks on her wrist at her italian charm bracelet that just happens to have an arctic fox charm next to a turtle charm*

ToTheNines
11-05-2011, 09:27 PM
So, has the ''retro'' Kevin Eastman variant cover for this issue been revealed yet? It will be out on the 16th of this month, I believe.

Bobby Curnow told me the 30th.

rich
11-08-2011, 07:16 PM
I just posted all the covers for Raphael #1 (http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/?p=373) on my site.

Also, just found out that the Raphael Retailer Incentive Cover B (the Eastman Retro cover) has an error on it. It states "RI A" just like the actual Peterson B&W RI A cover instead of "RI B" like it's supposed to. There's pics on my site.

Matches Malone
11-08-2011, 07:25 PM
I'm really hoping that if they are using the Eastman variant cover, this means that Casey Jones will make an appearance somewhere! Otherwise, it would just bug me to have a cover that doesn't make any sense at all. A group shot of the turtles in all the other "retro" covers is one thing; at least it doesn't contradict the content of the issue.

Powder
11-08-2011, 07:32 PM
I'm really hoping that if they are using the Eastman variant cover, this means that Casey Jones will make an appearance somewhere!

He has already, twice.


Otherwise, it would just bug me to have a cover that doesn't make any sense at all. A group shot of the turtles in all the other "retro" covers is one thing; at least it doesn't contradict the content of the issue.

Yeah they do, the turtles have not been a group of 4 yet. Not since they mutated at least.

Matches Malone
11-08-2011, 08:00 PM
He has already, twice.

I know he's been in the main series so far, but I meant I'm hoping Casey will appear somewhere in the issue since he's on the cover and not simply there because it's the retro cover... but it probably is.

Yeah they do, the turtles have not been a group of 4 yet. Not since they mutated at least.

That's a valid point... I guess in my eyes I just consider it as iconic. I mean, who hasn't seen the turtles in these group poses? And who thinks they won't actually be a group of 4 for the majority of the series? It's what everything is building up to in #4 in this introductory arc, so I don't really think of it as contradictory so much as establishing what we're all expecting. I guess you could use the same logic for the Raphael retro cover, but it makes less sense since the issue is called "Raphael #1" and not "Raphael & Casey Jones #1." Plus, this is a microseries, meaning it is a self contained story, and it would seem a bit strange to see Casey Jones on the cover of an one-shot story in which he doesn't appear at all. In the end, it's no big deal. I'm really just trying to trick myself into hoping he'll show up!

Toby Barrett
11-08-2011, 08:16 PM
I suppose I just don't understand what's so awful about it, since I only plan on getting cover A anyway. Aren't collectors just going to bag these anyway? You could just read one of the other copies?

Bobby Curnow
11-08-2011, 11:15 PM
Casey is in the micro-series. He (or his relationship with Raph) isn't the focus, but he gets some nice moments, I think.

I want to start getting this out there... it looks like both this and TMNT #4 are going to come out the same day, Nov. 30th. (Highly annoying, and counters a lot of deadline work I did to avoid this! :tgrumble:)

Raph should definitely be read AFTER TMNT #4. In continuity, it actually occurs after TMNT #5 (and there's a note in the credits page saying as much). After #5 is out I'll talk about why this all is. But the boring and accurate version is that Raph micro was written before TMNT #5, but ended production after #5 was written. So we knew some things at the end of the process that we didn't at the start.

Man, I'm sure I'm sounding super confusing. Just remember:

read order:
TMNT #4
Raph
TMNT #5

In-story continuity:
TMNT #4
TMNT #5
RAPH

When it comes to the big picture, I'm a continuity hound, so don't expect much of this confusing stuff in the future. I'm doing everything humanly possible to avoid it.

Thanks guys!

-Bobby Curnow
TMNT editor

Jester
11-08-2011, 11:35 PM
read order:
TMNT #4
Raph
TMNT #5

In-story continuity:
TMNT #4
TMNT #5
RAPH

Still confused...will things in Raph #1 be made clearer when reading #5 after the fact? Will we be left thinking, "Did I miss something?" if we read Raph first?

oldmanwinters
11-08-2011, 11:52 PM
Thanks for stopping by to share some production nuggets with us, Bobby! November 30 should be a great day for Turtles fans!

Matches Malone
11-09-2011, 12:25 AM
I suppose I just don't understand what's so awful about it, since I only plan on getting cover A anyway. Aren't collectors just going to bag these anyway? You could just read one of the other copies?

It's really not that awful at all. Actually, it's still pretty cool! I was just hoping for something even cooler with new artwork or something. But that's just me being greedy. Plus, like I said, I was a little confused about Casey Jones because I cynically had a feeling the retro cover didn't necessarily have to match the contents, but Bobby has thankfully put my cynicism to shame!

Bobby Curnow
11-09-2011, 01:17 AM
Still confused...will things in Raph #1 be made clearer when reading #5 after the fact? Will we be left thinking, "Did I miss something?" if we read Raph first?

Ah, see I don't want to make things too confusing... definitely ignore everything I say if I'm confusing. Raph is accessible to anyone... Basically things are more akin to a 'normal' Turtles status quo. If you just take it as a stand alone story and not worry too much about when it exactly happens, you'll be fine.

Jester
11-09-2011, 01:27 AM
Ah, see I don't want to make things too confusing... definitely ignore everything I say if I'm confusing. Raph is accessible to anyone... Basically things are more akin to a 'normal' Turtles status quo. If you just take it as a stand alone story and not worry too much about when it exactly happens, you'll be fine.
I may have just been making it more confusing than it is...:P That and kinda "digging" for info.

ToTheNines
11-09-2011, 05:31 AM
I want to start getting this out there... it looks like both this and TMNT #4 are going to come out the same day, Nov. 30th. (Highly annoying, and counters a lot of deadline work I did to avoid this! :tgrumble:)

Raph should definitely be read AFTER TMNT #4. In continuity, it actually occurs after TMNT #5 (and there's a note in the credits page saying as much). After #5 is out I'll talk about why this all is. But the boring and accurate version is that Raph micro was written before TMNT #5, but ended production after #5 was written. So we knew some things at the end of the process that we didn't at the start.

Ok. So #5 takes place on Christmas, Michelangelo #1 takes place on New Years Eve, and #6 takes place sometime in early January right? So when exactly does Raphael #1 take place?

Powder
11-09-2011, 05:45 AM
Thanksgiving?

pannoni1
11-09-2011, 07:01 AM
Some interesting parallels with Mirage Vol. 1 in terms of story development, with the main exception being Shredder not yet present. But this time, the Raphael one-shot comes after #4 instead of #3. Like Mirage Vol. 1, Michelangelo is the second turtle to have his own issue, though this time it comes after #5 instead of #7. We also have Michelangelo's issue taking place on a different winter holiday (New Year's) than the Mirage Vol. 1 version (Christmas). In the original, Donatello came after #8 and Leonardo after #9, so I expect those two turtles, probably in that order to get their own microissues next year.

The main difference between the original 1985 Raphael and the IDW Raphael plot so far is that in the former, Raphael was forced into being alone from his brothers; this time it's Raph himself that feels alone and disconnected. And, BTW, an uncertified Raph Vol. 1 #1 recently sold for $50 on eBay (described as uncirculated but not pristine)!

ToTheNines
11-09-2011, 06:05 PM
Thanksgiving?

Honestly can't tell if you're joking or not lol.

Powder
11-09-2011, 06:24 PM
That would in fact be a joke.

Venom
11-09-2011, 06:29 PM
Guys, guys....leave the timeline analysis to Spengs. :D

On another note, I really hope IDW continues the micro-series with each character; it would provide a cool meanrs to spotlight the featured character and give more insight to the character's personality, etc.

Samhain
11-09-2011, 06:38 PM
Guys, guys....leave the timeline analysis to Spengs. :D

On another note, I really hope IDW continues the micro-series with each character; it would provide a cool meanrs to spotlight the featured character and give more insight to the character's personality, etc.

I'm sure they will. Given these sell well. Here's hoping.

Jester
11-09-2011, 08:46 PM
Venom do you mean a Splinter, April, Casey, Baxter and Krang #1 or just the other Turtles?

Donnie
11-09-2011, 09:03 PM
I assumed each Turtle at the least would get their own micro?

Samhain
11-09-2011, 09:12 PM
I assumed each Turtle at the least would get their own micro?

Well, that IS the plan. But, if these micro book don't sell good IDW might think twice. Though, I can't imagine them not selling well.

ToTheNines
11-09-2011, 10:37 PM
Splinter Microseries is an ace idea.

That would in fact be a joke.

And not a bad one lol. Hard to interpret tone over the internet some times...

Guys, guys....leave the timeline analysis to Spengs. :D

I've made at least 15 edits to that timeline. Suck it. :oops:

Venom
11-09-2011, 10:53 PM
Venom do you mean a Splinter, April, Casey, Baxter and Krang #1 or just the other Turtles?

:nod: And Shredder :twink:

CyberCubed
11-09-2011, 11:03 PM
Well, that IS the plan. But, if these micro book don't sell good IDW might think twice. Though, I can't imagine them not selling well.

Since the Mike one is already being written, its no surprise we'll get a Leo or Don one too.

Its being done to mimic the Mirage Volume 1 run.

Tuxedo Moroboshi
11-13-2011, 06:31 AM
Forgive me if this has already been answered, but when does this come out? I just want to make sure I don't overlook it, as I really want to get all the IDW TMNT comics as they come out, and that includes the micro-series.

Powder
11-13-2011, 07:05 AM
I think it's out on the 30th, alongside #4.

Venom
11-13-2011, 11:27 PM
That's been the latest word from Bobby, much to his chagrin. He wanted to have the book come out this week, then #4 next week.

Master Splinter
11-14-2011, 09:15 AM
Anyone have pictures of all of the covers for Raphael #1 without watermarks or anything like that? I would like to add them to my wiki site.

Thanks!

-ms

***First of Two Latin Kings***
11-23-2011, 12:16 PM
Anyone have pictures of all of the covers for Raphael #1 without watermarks or anything like that? I would like to add them to my wiki site.

Thanks!

-ms

There are plenty on ebay, I can link you if you want...

Apparently this book isn't coming out on the 30th...WTF.

Powder
11-23-2011, 12:52 PM
Apparently this book isn't coming out on the 30th...WTF.

:x

Where'd you read/hear that?

Toby Barrett
11-23-2011, 01:44 PM
Source? These supposed constant delays are getting aggrevating.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
11-23-2011, 03:43 PM
:x

Where'd you read/hear that?

I heard it from an ebay seller that I buy multiple copies from for members who don't have access to them otherwise.

The Raphael isn't coming out next week. It's listed as having that as a release date, but it must have missed it because it is not on my invoice, and it isn't on Diamond's master list either.
Thanks! Brandon.

Samhain
11-23-2011, 07:44 PM
Damn. Yep, my comic shop didn't have it up for order either, but they had # 4 ready. What's the deal?

Master Splinter
11-23-2011, 07:56 PM
Damn. Yep, my comic shop didn't have it up for order either, but they had # 4 ready. What's the deal?

Same here. I checked with them this afternoon.

-ms

Buffy
11-24-2011, 12:28 AM
Graham Crackers comic shop doesn't have this issue listed for next week.

Donnie
11-24-2011, 10:14 AM
These postponed issues are getting annoying. At least #4 will be there on the 30th...

***First of Two Latin Kings***
11-25-2011, 04:18 PM
Can anyone confirm what the distributor from ebay told me?

Powder
11-25-2011, 04:25 PM
Didn't 3 of the 4 posters above you basically do just that? Or do you mean one of the IDW fellas? I'm sure Bobby will pop in eventually...

***First of Two Latin Kings***
11-25-2011, 04:36 PM
It would be nice (or not nice, depending on how you look at it) to hear it from one of the IDW guys, yes.

Toby Barrett
11-26-2011, 09:07 AM
Looks like it's true...

http://forum.idwpublishing.com/viewtopic.php?p=263674#263674

I'm not seeing Raph on sale anywhere on the 30th. My only guess is Diamond shipping problem. I might be able to learn more on Monday.


So annoying. Hope it doesn't become a continuous problem.

AquaParade
11-26-2011, 11:01 AM
Bobby was also saying over on the IDW forums that Raphael #1 was best read after issue #5, but still makes good sense if you read it after #4. And that reading it before those will leave you "scratching your head".

Seem's like issue 4 may have some exciting revelations!

***First of Two Latin Kings***
11-28-2011, 08:29 AM
That takes a little bit of the sting out of the late release.

Master Splinter
11-29-2011, 02:50 PM
That takes a little bit of the sting out of the late release.

Thanks to Roseangelo for posting this over on Facebook! Looks like next week!

http://issuu.com/idwpublishing/docs/teenagemutantninjaturtles_microseries_01_raphael_p ?mode=window

-ms

Bobby Curnow
11-29-2011, 03:06 PM
Huh, curious how that preview got out. FYI, spoilers of #4 in that preview.

Over at IDW forums I just notedthat Raph is confirmed for 12/7. Apparently there was a delay in transit from our printer to Diamond Distributors, so Diamond wasn't able to get it out in time for 12/30. Ah well, I wanted Raph to be a week after #4 anyway.

Which is why you shouldn't read the Preview until at least after tomorrow's #4!

Master Splinter
11-29-2011, 03:11 PM
Huh, curious how that preview got out. FYI, spoilers of #4 in that preview.

Over at IDW forums I just notedthat Raph is confirmed for 12/7. Apparently there was a delay in transit from our printer to Diamond Distributors, so Diamond wasn't able to get it out in time for 12/30. Ah well, I wanted Raph to be a week after #4 anyway.

Which is why you shouldn't read the Preview until at least after tomorrow's #4!

I can remove the link if it should not be out yet... I see I share! I don't knows no better!

-ms

Matches Malone
11-29-2011, 03:18 PM
Whoa. I caved and read the preview. Not sure what spoilers I just read except... did you see who I just saw?!

Samhain
11-29-2011, 03:32 PM
did you see who I just saw?!

Yes, yes I did. And I'm PUMPED!

Raph's Girl
11-29-2011, 03:46 PM
OMG!! That preview! It's pre-mutation Rocksteady and Bebop!!! EEE!!! :o

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
11-29-2011, 04:00 PM
OMG!! That preview! It's pre-mutation Rocksteady and Bebop!!! EEE!!! :o

yes!:o:o It is Bebop!!:o but not the same Bebop from 1987 cartoon. Now Bebop is also confirmed for this series!:D Now it remain to be seen if he will be mutated into the pig we all know and love or if he will remain a human .:lol:

Now bring Rocksteady too!

Samhain
11-29-2011, 04:03 PM
Dude, c'mon. Use a spoiler tag.

CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 04:08 PM
*cries tears of joy*

Master Splinter
11-29-2011, 04:48 PM
Now bring Rocksteady too!

He was there too...

-ms

CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 05:56 PM
The guy in bandages reminds me of someone....kind of reminds me of the 4kids origin for Rat King...but I don't think that's him.

Jester
11-29-2011, 06:00 PM
The guy in bandages reminds me of someone....kind of reminds me of the 4kids origin for Rat King...but I don't think that's him.
pretty sure that's the arctic fox mutant.

CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 06:00 PM
pretty sure that's the arctic fox mutant.

Ah yeah, I forgot about that.

Matches Malone
11-29-2011, 06:04 PM
pretty sure that's the arctic fox mutant.

That's what I figured too. Now that I think about it, with Old Hob, Bebop & Rocksteady, and Alopex all in the mix, that's quite a few "extra" mutants in a short amount of time. I'm hoping this isn't going the Archie route where anthropomorphic animals are the only suitable ones for the turtles to interact with! I mean, I like my anthropomorphic animals, but they definitely went overboard with them... I also don't mind a moderate number as long as it happens gradually so there isn't a "coincidental" surge in mutants. Maybe they have some kind of connection between all of them which will seem more logical...

Venom
11-29-2011, 07:00 PM
with Old Hob, Bebop & Rocksteady, and Alopex all in the mix, that's quite a few "extra" mutants in a short amount of time.

Bebop & Rocksteady aren't mutants though, nor have they been revealed to indeed *be* Bebop & Rocksteady. They could easily be "Joe & Mac".

Bobby Curnow
11-29-2011, 07:03 PM
I feel the same way, Matches. You won't be seeing a whole bunch of other mutants. More over time, gradually, sure... but I do think Laird is right that it cheapens things a bit to have tons of mutants running around all over the place. Hopefully we strike a good balance between Mirage and various 'toons and movies in that regard.

Good point, Venom!

Matches Malone
11-29-2011, 07:10 PM
Bebop & Rocksteady aren't mutants though, nor have they been revealed to indeed *be* Bebop & Rocksteady. They could easily be "Joe & Mac".

True, it hasn't been verified yet, but it's pretty clear from the distinguishing characteristics (i.e. purple mohawk, sunglasses that haven't been in style since the 80's, etc.). While I reserve the right to be wrong, the evidence allows me some healthy confidence. A good writer wouldn't unnecessarily introduce such blatantly similar characters for no reason. That's actually something that bugged me about Wolverine: Origin with Joe Quesada because he went out of his way to make Thomas Logan (who is not related to Wolverine) a red herring by having him "coincidentally" look exactly like Wolverine will when he grows up. Rest of the book is killer though!

oldmanwinters
11-29-2011, 07:12 PM
Must. Own. Raphael Micro-Series #1.

AquaParade
11-29-2011, 07:15 PM
Wait...Fox...huh? What did I miss?

CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 07:20 PM
I feel the same way, Matches. You won't be seeing a whole bunch of other mutants. More over time, gradually, sure... but I do think Laird is right that it cheapens things a bit to have tons of mutants running around all over the place. Hopefully we strike a good balance between Mirage and various 'toons and movies in that regard.

Yeah, if any other mutants are introduced, it should probably only be the most important and popular ones with fans, like Slash or Rahzar/Tokka....and of course Leatherhead.

I mean the last thing we need is a whole bunch of mutant animals coming out of the woodwork. That's one of the few things I think the Archie series went a bit overboard with. It was like every issue or two another mutant animal was introduced.

Matches Malone
11-29-2011, 07:42 PM
Yeah, if any other mutants are introduced, it should probably only be the most important and popular ones with fans, like Slash or Rahzar/Tokka....and of course Leatherhead.

I mean the last thing we need is a whole bunch of mutant animals coming out of the woodwork. That's one of the few things I think the Archie series went a bit overboard with. It was like every issue or two another mutant animal was introduced.

Yup. Before I finally stop wasting time at work if I may just advocate one last time: SLASH! The most untapped potential since he was a goofball in the cartoon and painfully underutilized in Archie. Have him go down the Ben Reilly or Venom route where he has to sort out his own identity apart from the "established" turtles. Heck, Bruce Timm even did that with Bizarro in S:TAS and it would really fit, I think. A good archetype always works when appropriate. Just please, no aliens that "happen" to look exactly like mutated animals. I can see Baxter going down the lines to retry his "Terrapin Exo-Suit Armor" (or whatever pseudo sci-fi stuff it was) and Slash being the result. Let's do this!!!

CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 07:47 PM
IMO if they use any other mutants:

Leatherhead (being a Mirage creation, he is a must)
Slash
Rahzar/Tokka
Bebop/Rocksteady

I also would love to see Armaggon again.

Raph's Girl
11-29-2011, 07:50 PM
Wait...Fox...huh? What did I miss?

In the issue Raph befriends a female Arctic Fox named Alopex (which is Greek for Fox and was the old genus classification for the arctic fox's). :D

soccerstud652
12-05-2011, 08:41 PM
How many covers are there going to be for each issue?

Master Splinter
12-05-2011, 09:11 PM
How many covers are there going to be for each issue?

http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/?p=373

-ms

marcelangelo
12-06-2011, 07:55 AM
holy moses!!!it's THEM!!!!!!...I really love for them to be around!!!the combo is a legendary duo that I surely missed and was extremely glad to have back in turtles forever and the nowerdays released turtles cartoon dvd boxes from ksm....thank you, I have faith in that they are introduced into this rough backstreet turtles scenery that is being created in the idw series in these very issues;)....
that just made my day, really!

Cowabunga Carl
12-06-2011, 10:26 AM
It's awesome that we will be seeing at least homages to Bebop and Rocksteady. It would be even better if they were to become a staple of the series I think. I do have a soft spot for them, but would like to see them developed into proper threats to the turtles and not just the goofy bumbling lugs of the OT.

CyberCubed
12-06-2011, 01:54 PM
Is this issue out now?

Matches Malone
12-06-2011, 01:57 PM
Is this issue out now?

Not yet, comes out tomorrow, but there is a preview floating around the internets. Pretty sure there is a link to it somewhere on one of these threads, but not sure which one...

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 12:40 AM
I already saw the preview. I am pretty excited for this one, and I like that we already have a new artist on this special and its pretty different from Duncan's style.

Its funny that in Mirage the Raphael special was first before the other Turtles, and now in IDW the Raph special is first as well. I wonder if that was intentional as a homage?

TristanHuwJones
12-07-2011, 01:37 AM
Wow...! That's all I have to say about it ;)

Matches Malone
12-07-2011, 01:43 AM
Wow...! That's all I have to say about it ;)

Wow can mean only one thing... Fred & Willow cameo!

TristanHuwJones
12-07-2011, 04:28 AM
Sounds like wishful thinking, but I think this'll surprise people just as much.

ToTheNines
12-07-2011, 07:10 AM
Its funny that in Mirage the Raphael special was first before the other Turtles, and now in IDW the Raph special is first as well. I wonder if that was intentional as a homage?

It's definitely on purpose. They're going in the exact same order Mirage did (Raph, Mike, Don Leo).

Cowabunga Carl
12-07-2011, 09:23 AM
Didn't they say Mike's would also be Christmas related?

ToTheNines
12-07-2011, 09:31 AM
Didn't they say Mike's would also be Christmas related?

New Year's Eve. Close enough though lol.

Cowabunga Carl
12-07-2011, 10:09 AM
I knew it would take place in the winter months. I'm looking forward to the Don issue. I kind of want to see what they do with him. This version seems to actually getting some decent development instead of just being the "techno" turtle.

My big question is if this isn't supposed to take place tell after issue 5 why didn't they just wait another month to release it?

Jester
12-07-2011, 11:30 AM
Haven't read it. I did flipped through it though.
2 things, one bad one good:
Bad:
When we finally see the other brothers....color-coded masks. I wonder if this is for Raph's benefit, since he was AWOL all those months. Still seems kinda off, though.
Good:
At the very end we see a very familiar silhouette. :D

marcelangelo
12-07-2011, 11:52 AM
oh man, thank you jester for posting SOMETHING about raphael here...I only came here to read about the issue as I cannot wait to get it delivered to my door step in th enext few days;):..

Jester
12-07-2011, 12:03 PM
Just finished it.
Not sure what I think. There's a lot of stuff going on, some I liked some I didn't.
Likes:
Raphael uses his head, unusual for him, but a welcome change. It's nice to see him go toe to toe with another mutant. Something tells me we have a Catwoman-esque character in Alopex, maybe. I could see her becoming an anti-hero, or eventual reluctant ally to the Turtles...but that may be my preconceived Ninjara bias. Casey as a part of the family, as it should be.
Dislike:
This is gonna sound weird, coming from not only a fan of the Fred Wolf series, but as someone who gives Andrew loads of greif for his outright hatred of it, but the FW elements they are throwing in seem way to tacked on. I don't care for them. The thugs from the start are in fact Bebop and Rocksteady (The later even says he's a rhino before Casey knocks him out.). They even say they wanna become mutants, which we are told they will be, "When the Master wills it." *sigh* I guess I ought to wait and see how these dark and gritty Bebop and Rocksteady are used, but still seems really forced. Oh...and yeah...colored bandanas in 2 whole panels, not much but still a "Wait, wha?"

TomWaltz
12-07-2011, 12:09 PM
Some nice preview art for Raphael #1 along with a cool Kevin Eastman interview...


http://comics.ign.com/articles/121/1214129p1.html


Talk soon...

Tom W.

ToTheNines
12-07-2011, 12:19 PM
I haven't picked it up yet, but what the heck is going on here? The big stir a few days ago was the fact that Infestation was introducing colored masks, but now we have them months ahead of that?

What confuses me even more is that we've seen future covers (5 and 7 at least) and they have all red in those.

Andrew NDB
12-07-2011, 12:21 PM
As soon as all the interviews were popping up about "We're bring in a lot of elements, especially from the Fred Wolf cartoon" before #1 came out, there was never a doubt in my mind that Bebop and Rocksteady were going to show up and probably more sooner than later... so this isn't any kind of kidney punch that's going to make me go, "WTF?" (though I would admittedly, mentally still be asking -- rhetorically, of course: why would they want to put them in this beyond some kind of unabashed, blind nostalgia factor? They were dopey, sh*t characters that were only ever cool if you're about 5 years old when jokes about 'turtle soup' were funny to you and if the idea is to make them not dopey, sh*t characters, then why use them at all because that was their whole schdict?") The tale of the tape will be how organically they're implanted into the IDW universe and how they contribute to it in any meaningful way.

Unfortunately, nothing I've seen in the preview nor in this thread so far fills me with a lot in the way of hope to that end with them -- the opposite, it seems -- but I'm keeping an open mind about it when I pick it up. Art looks cool.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 12:25 PM
Andrew, most Mirage comic fans still like many of the original cartoon characters. Just take a look on this very forum, I think you've always been the only one against it.

Keeping them out of the Mirage series made sense as that was the original and didn't need characters from the cartoons. But the Archie and IDW series are completely different takes that should be allowed to choose whatever characters they like.

Andrew NDB
12-07-2011, 12:29 PM
Andrew, most Mirage comic fans still like many of the original cartoon characters. Just take a look on this very forum, I think you've always been the only one against it.

It's a board/website called "The Technodrome"... you think this is profound?

Keeping them out of the Mirage series made sense as that was the original and didn't need characters from the cartoons. But the Archie and IDW series are completely different takes that should be allowed to choose whatever characters they like.

I guess I'm missing the part in my post where I said, "IDW should keep their hands off of any and all Fred Wolf characters!" Characters like Krang can definitely be rejiggered in ways to make them compatible with what IDW is setting out to do while still maintaining the core of the character... but characters like Bebop and Rocksteady, you pretty much have to write them as entirely different characters (sharing only the name and likeness), and if that's the case the question is begged... what's the point?

If the only answer is "I dunno, nostalgia, kids used to kinda like'em" then I say that's not enough of a reason.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 12:33 PM
As long as they're not overused, I don't see the problem. This isn't going to be like the OT where every episode was Krang sending Shredder/Bebop/Rocksteady to Earth with a new scheme to either re-power the Technodrome or take over the world every week.

The Archie series didn't do that even when Krang was part of the book, (which was at the height of the old toon's popularity too, making it surprising they weren't used more), so I don't see the same thing happening here.

marcelangelo
12-07-2011, 12:48 PM
well, to me I always saw them as the two faces of the many untalented slugs and thugs that shredder had working for the foot clan in the very beginning of the cartoon...I mean with them we saw two of these dudes who had nothing better to do than to rack havoc for the shredder on the streets..and how their 'careers' went on...being part of a forced mutation and then giving the animal powers of a hog and rhino...you know I see a lot of great things to comce from that premise...and they really look cool...so, great to have them back in this, excited to how that story continues..

Andrew NDB
12-07-2011, 12:54 PM
well, to me I always saw them as the two faces of the many untalented slugs and thugs that shredder had working for the foot clan

In other words, two characters serving to underscore Shredder's incompetance as a leader and a villain. That's great. That's just what's needed.

marcelangelo
12-07-2011, 12:57 PM
hahaha...no, I mean, think about him keeping those as expendables...doing dirty jobs...kind of a brute force...you know real smart or evil people might keep less intellectual around for them to exploit(that is one thing that makes them evil...)
..okay, I think we would have to go away from the service(or dissservice) they did for the shredder in the old funny cartoon...this bebop and rocksteady would be punished with more serious consequences by the shredder I have in mind if they' mess up a job toon stlye..;)

Andrew NDB
12-07-2011, 01:06 PM
hahaha...no, I mean, think about him keeping those as expendables...doing dirty jobs...kind of a brute force...you know real smart or evil people might keep less intellectual around for them to exploit(that is one thing that makes them evil...)
..okay, I think we would have to go away from the service(or dissservice) they did for the shredder in the old funny cartoon...this bebop and rocksteady would be punished with more serious consequences by the shredder I have in mind if they' mess up a job toon stlye..;)

Well I'd be all for that. Shredder hires Bebop and Rocksteady as muscle, then they screw up... and he kills them. I think that's perfect, actually -- it allows the Fred Wolf fans their nostalgia fix without needing to make them internally different characters, it better sells the Shredder's bad-assery (you know, "Apology accepted, Captain Needa" and all that), and neatly removes them from the equation at the same time.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 01:26 PM
In the first ep of the OT, I always figured Bebop/Rocksteady and their gang were loosely based off the Purple Dragons.

In the 4kids cartoon, the Purple Dragons would eventually be recruited to join the Foot Clan. I believe that's why Hun was the leader of the Purple Dragons but also part of the Foot at the same time.

That being said, are these two even connected to Shredder this time around? If they are mutated most likely they'll be part of Krang and Baxter's henchmen than Shredder's.

Cowabunga Carl
12-07-2011, 01:39 PM
I'm with Andrew on this one. I mean the point of Bebop and Rocksteady was to make mutants that could stand against the Turtles but ended up being completely useless. To change them from such would change their characters. What made them such fun characters in the show is they were "evil" because they were to stupid to be other wise. I don't think that would translate well to what IDW is trying to do with the book. But I guess I'll wait and see.

If it is for the sake of having a Rhino and Warthog lackey for the main villains for nostalgia purpose alone then I'm against it also. I mean I'll have to wait and see where they take these characters.

However at the same time I really want a hard core Rocksteady. Ex-marine kind of character. But that wouldn't really be Rocksteady. Yet if you made such a character people would ask why you don't use Rocksteady. So it is a lose lose situation.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 02:25 PM
I'm with Andrew on this one. I mean the point of Bebop and Rocksteady was to make mutants that could stand against the Turtles but ended up being completely useless. To change them from such would change their characters. What made them such fun characters in the show is they were "evil" because they were to stupid to be other wise.

Not at the beginning. In Season 1 Bebop/Rocksteady were a threat to the Turtles and nearly beat them in their first few battles. They threw trucks at them, blasted the hell out of them, and Bebop even almost chokes Splinter to death in a scene.

The only reason they were dumbed down as the series progressed was because they had to be toned down once the old toon became a huge success.

Rocksteady/Bebop can retain street-punk level stupidity yet still be a threat in fights. There is no doubt in my mind they won't be shown as constant failures in the IDW series if they go the route that's implied so far.

DrSpengler
12-07-2011, 02:31 PM
Here's my review at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/12/tmnt-microseries-raphael-1.html)

I don't have time to talk at length right now, but I'll just say I really liked this and I'm really excited about two certain characters.

marcelangelo
12-07-2011, 02:32 PM
well, my point is just....so far, at least to me, the people at idw have not brought in anything just for the case of nostalgia(forget about pizza or cowabunga shirts, I am talking more important things)...AND I wouldn't want them to be dealt with immidiatelly...you know, I think they don't have to be idiots at all...I mean when I saw peter laird's sketches of them pre-cartoon I reckognized them as the characters I know yet I could totally appreciate another background or character strengths for them...to each his own, I guess..I for one love for them to be back..I always liked them the way they were in the toon, I could like them in the dark comic universe the way they turn out to be...

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 02:39 PM
I kinda half-expect to see the Roadkill Rodney's now...you know the robots who broke into the zoo to steal the rhino/warthog to mutate Bebop/Rocksteady with...lol.

Cowabunga Carl
12-07-2011, 02:52 PM
I'm not against them using Bebop and Rocksteady but against them just using them to use them. If they can make them fit the tone of the series then I'm all for it. It's just out of all the OT characters they always seemed the most cartoony to me. Maybe after I'm able to get the issue and read it I'll feel different.

AquaParade
12-07-2011, 03:08 PM
I really enjoyed the issue. This guy is a pretty good writer.

I really felt Casey's loneliness come through in this issue. I sympathized with him much more than I have in the first four issues so far. The last page was killer, but those color coded masks kinda deflated my spirit.

marcelangelo
12-07-2011, 03:14 PM
old hob, I feel we are on the same boat, I am only more assured that we're in for a good ride I think;)...hey, those rodney roadkills were the killer to me(still are, and those were not OVERUSED, so they are more than welcome to come back for me;)hahahahaI am just joking/I know that is a vulnerable point here)....and these little flying drones...you know basically flying cameras..I always thaught it was a waste to not see them more often in the cartoon..since they could have been an explanation for how the shredder and krang were able to observe various things in the city..or in the sewers..no matter where;)...

Matches Malone
12-07-2011, 03:20 PM
I'm not against them using Bebop and Rocksteady but against them just using them to use them. If they can make them fit the tone of the series then I'm all for it. It's just out of all the OT characters they always seemed the most cartoony to me. Maybe after I'm able to get the issue and read it I'll feel different.

I think sometimes a complete re-imagining of a character can work or even necessary to save a cool idea that was wasted when combined with other lame ones. Some may claim they become unrecognizable, which may be true, but that doesn't mean the character is any less compelling. Some could make similar arguments for the success of Chris Nolan's Joker who is no longer a comical psychopath but a calculating anarchist or when Mr. Freeze was re-conceptualized in Batman: The Animated Series where the only thing they kept was the ice motif and the name (maybe it only works for Batman villains?!).

I can see, and am seeing in this Raphael issue, a similar approach where Bebop & Rocksteady are reduced to street punks working for the Shredder, ditching the overly dimwitted aspect. If you have the Foot clan surreptitiously carrying out tasks for you, there could be a strategic advantage to having thugs who are more connected to the urban side of New York for certain duties as well; hence the Foot's employment of the Purple Dragons in the 4Kids series, which I thought worked fairly well. If you're going to use that idea, then why not make them Bebop & Rocksteady? Also, the idea that mutation can be a gift or a curse depending on how you approach it is interesting too, in my opinion. Perhaps we will see them seek out the mutagen only to regret being turned into freaks. Whether or not you can figure out exactly how the stories will play out, I think one can argue that there is potential.

Matches Malone
12-07-2011, 03:24 PM
I kinda half-expect to see the Roadkill Rodney's now...you know the robots who broke into the zoo to steal the rhino/warthog to mutate Bebop/Rocksteady with...lol.

I would LOVE to see Roadkill Rodney's! Perhaps with a different name, but I always loved that 80's sci-fi design to them. Again, even if there is nothing to keep but the design, why not? This is fiction, we can make things however we want. With a new IDW universe, it gives us a good opportunity to do so without it being too confusing.

plastroncafe
12-07-2011, 03:44 PM
My overall impression of the IDW series thus far is this:

- I don't fully understand the timeline. Everything just happens so quickly, and I'm not entirely sure what's going on most of the time. I realize that these "holes" will probably be filled as time goes on, but at the moment all I can do is be amused by the idea that it's an intentional call back to the questionable timeline of the Mirage Universe.

- Will a Ninjara by another name still kick as much ass? Only time will tell, but I'm hopeful. I think the only complaint I have about her is her mask. I just...don't see the point of it.

- Please continue to have seemingly competent bad guys. Please. For the love of all that is great and small, please.

Andrew NDB
12-07-2011, 05:04 PM
I think sometimes a complete re-imagining of a character can work or even necessary to save a cool idea that was wasted when combined with other lame ones.

The trouble is... Bebop and Rocksteady were never good ideas and I would challenge anyone here to make a case otherwise. "Two bumbling idiots that the Shredder recruits to act as his right hand men and act as comic relief" is all they were, and all they were ever conceived to be.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 05:27 PM
The trouble is... Bebop and Rocksteady were never good ideas and I would challenge anyone here to make a case otherwise. "Two bumbling idiots that the Shredder recruits to act as his right hand men and act as comic relief" is all they were, and all they were ever conceived to be.

Because the old toon was based on humor and aimed at kids. I don't see why you're applying it to another series with a more serious tone and with completely different writers.

They can be stupid, (as in, they're just street punks/gang members), but be competent at the same time. Not to mention there's no indication if they're going to be working for Shredder.

1984TMNT
12-07-2011, 05:30 PM
I guess I'm missing the part in my post where I said, "IDW should keep their hands off of any and all Fred Wolf characters!" Characters like Krang can definitely be rejiggered in ways to make them compatible with what IDW is setting out to do while still maintaining the core of the character... but characters like Bebop and Rocksteady, you pretty much have to write them as entirely different characters (sharing only the name and likeness), and if that's the case the question is begged... what's the point?

If the only answer is "I dunno, nostalgia, kids used to kinda like'em" then I say that's not enough of a reason.

To play devil's advocate here, why NOT use the characters names/likeness and give them a whole new take and make them gritty? What hurt does that cause? If they are written as new characters, does it really matter what they look like or are named? I personally loved those characters as a kid just the way they were, but would love to see a "gritty" version of them in this universe. I love the idea.

plastroncafe
12-07-2011, 05:46 PM
While I don't deny that it's possible to pull of good comic relief from a competent character, it's really really hard.

Evidence of this can be found in the many portrayals of Michaelangelo that we've had over the years.

These days when I think of competent comic relief I think of Bruce Campbell's "Sam Axe" character from the show Burn Notice.

Do something like that with Bebop and Rocksteady, and I'll be more than impressed.

DrSpengler
12-07-2011, 05:50 PM
I think its completely within reason to take two comedy relief villains and rework them to be harder edged threats without losing sight of their core characterization.

An example of this within the Mirage comics would be Savanti Romero. He was conceived as a goofy, dull-witted, ineffectual comedy relief villain in his first two appearances. Michael Dooney's "Masks" then reintroduced him as a darker and more competent threat and he still felt like Savanti Romero at his core. Even when later stories by Steve Murphy returned Romero to his bumbling comedy roots, Dooney's more serious interpretation still stood on its own as a perfectly authentic incarnation of the character.

The same can be done with ease for Bebop and Rocksteady. The real heart of the issue, which I alluded to in my review, is how a more competent Shredder meant to be taken seriously would deal with their inevitable defeats.

I don't think the answer should instinctively be "kill them", either. Otherwise, we would never, ever have ANY recurring villains within the Foot organization (or whatever's going on in IDW). Because the badguys are always going to lose and we can't have Shredder killing EVERYONE, I should hope.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 05:53 PM
I don't see them introducing new characters to kill them off either. Its why Old Hob is sticking around as well. Hopefully if they must change status quo they don't do so till quite some time. Its pointless to introduce new villains to kill them off quickly.

The Mirage comics had almost no rogues galley, lets see the IDW series build up a competent batch of villains for the Turtles to face.

I can't wait till we see Leatherhead and Rat King!

Donnie
12-07-2011, 05:59 PM
Because the old toon was based on humor and aimed at kids. I don't see why you're applying it to another series with a more serious tone and with completely different writers.


Because it seems like they are just writing these characters in at this point for the sake of writing them in because they want to either 1) please Nick or 2) boost sales. Geez, TMNT will never get out of the shadow of the OT. The overuse of OT names and characters in this new series is honestly becoming distasteful to me. Bebop & Rocksteady? C'mon...yeah yeah you can re-write them, make them darker, blah blah. I don't really buy it.

Matches Malone
12-07-2011, 06:05 PM
The trouble is... Bebop and Rocksteady were never good ideas and I would challenge anyone here to make a case otherwise. "Two bumbling idiots that the Shredder recruits to act as his right hand men and act as comic relief" is all they were, and all they were ever conceived to be.

Again, initial conception is not written in stone. If they were originally conceived as "bumbling idiots who act as comic relief," who's to say a writer can't change that? Like I said in my previous post, it seems like the only "good ideas" retained from Bebop & Rocksteady is the idea that street punks are employed by the Foot, their character designs, and the idea of using mutagen intentionally to one's own advantage. I think these are reasonably good ideas with potential, but of course everyone is entitled to their own opinion if they feel otherwise. Yes, some "good ideas" and potential are more obvious than others, but if they can pull it off, that just makes success that much more impressive. Does this shed much of what we remember of them in the cartoon? Sure, but who cares?

To further the point with the Mr. Freeze example again, he was also initially conceived as another "joke villain" fond of Schwarzenegger-esque puns. Yet Paul Dini saw that as a writer, you can make things however you want and not feel restrained by past interpretations. I'm not saying Bebop & Rocksteady will suddenly ascend to being first rate villains, but memorable ones that don't make you want to smash your head into a brick wall? My humble opinion is... uh... sure.

Donnie
12-07-2011, 06:32 PM
The trouble is... Bebop and Rocksteady were never good ideas and I would challenge anyone here to make a case otherwise. "Two bumbling idiots that the Shredder recruits to act as his right hand men and act as comic relief" is all they were, and all they were ever conceived to be.

Agreed, 100%.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 06:50 PM
Because it seems like they are just writing these characters in at this point for the sake of writing them in because they want to either 1) please Nick or 2) boost sales. Geez, TMNT will never get out of the shadow of the OT.

What is giving you this impression? They're using popular, well known characters because they want to bring them into the story.

We'll likely get Mirage characters such as Leatherhead, Rat King, the Triceratons, etc. eventually.

This is not the Mirage universe where mutants were kept to a minimum and Peter Laird didn't like using anything created for the cartoons. You guys keep thinking about the Mirage comics and applying them to the IDW series, and that's the problem.

This is not the Mirage series, its a new universe with a clean slate. These characters didn't belong in the Mirage comics, but this time around we're in a different continuity.

1984TMNT
12-07-2011, 07:36 PM
Agreed, 100%.

Disagree, 100% :tsmile: They served a purpose and most TMNT fans I knew growing up loved them for what they were. I'll be honest, I LOVE TMNT because of the original toon....yes, as an adult I discovered Mirage and the comics and now, love the gritty version of the franchise. But let's not kid ourselves (no pun intended), TMNT would be a tiny fraction of what it is now without the OT. I also believe that 95% or more fans of TMNT are so because they watched the cartoon growing up (whether that is the OT or the 2K3 series).

Point is, Bebop and Rocksteady are beloved by many, regardless that a few people think negatively about them. Pretty sure Tom and Co. understand this, and that's a big reason they are in the IDW universe. I don't expect that they will be exactly the same as they were in the cartoon, which is exciting for all the same reasons this whole series is! This, of course, is all just my 2cents on the matter. :twink:

TomWaltz
12-07-2011, 07:58 PM
What is giving you this impression? They're using popular, well known characters because they want to bring them into the story.

We'll likely get Mirage characters such as Leatherhead, Rat King, the Triceratons, etc. eventually.

This is not the Mirage universe where mutants were kept to a minimum and Peter Laird didn't like using anything created for the cartoons. You guys keep thinking about the Mirage comics and applying them to the IDW series, and that's the problem.

This is not the Mirage series, its a new universe with a clean slate. These characters didn't belong in the Mirage comics, but this time around we're in a different continuity.

I couldn't have said it better.

We've got plans for a lot of characters from across the TMNT board -- and not simply because they exist, but because they fulfill a defined purpose in the stories we wanna tell. And, as I said before, absolutely no goofy, over-the-top-idiotic, comedy relief characters. We'll have some that are more humorous than others, but no overtly bumbling fools because this ain't some little kid's cartoon we're trying to create here.

But, As CyberCubed so accurately states above, this is not the Mirage comic, either -- it is a whole new ballgame that we whole-heartedly invite you all to play with us!

Some new rules, some old rules... new faces, old faces... and always plenty of surprises!

DrSpengler
12-07-2011, 08:00 PM
I'll have to echo Cyber Cube's sentiments. IDW isn't mirage. It's not the same universe, it's not the same creative team, it's not the same publisher.

They're free to utilize every concept from every incarnation of the franchise and I think that's FANTASTIC. I love the idea of seeing a mix of new and classic ideas and I appreciate that they aren't relegating the Fred Wolf, Archie and Playmates characters to the dregs because "wah wah they were for kids and shouldn't count".

Some folks here really do need a reminded that this ISN'T Mirage and every incarnation of the TMNT is as legitimate as the other, particularly when it comes to pulling inspiration for the new creative teams of this NEW universe.


EDIT: And Tom beat me across the finish line by a nose.

1984TMNT
12-07-2011, 08:06 PM
"Every"??? I think we can all universally agree that 'the next mutation' doesn't apply, right?? LOL

Samhain
12-07-2011, 08:09 PM
I haven't gotten my issue yet but what's this I hear about colored bandanas? :ohwell: Anyone got a pic of that particular panel with the colored badanas?

DrSpengler
12-07-2011, 08:10 PM
I haven't gotten my issue yet but what's this I hear about colored bandanas? Anyone got a pic of that particular panel with the colored badanas?

They looked to me like they could have gone either way; it might have been the lighting of the scene that makes some look like a washed out dark purple.

Considering what Tristan's been saying in the Infestation thread, I figured they *could* be colored, or again, it might just be the lighting.

oldmanwinters
12-07-2011, 08:14 PM
Just read it.

I am now officially in love with the IDW Turtles series.

Donnie
12-07-2011, 08:18 PM
I couldn't have said it better.

We've got plans for a lot of characters from across the TMNT board -- and not simply because they exist, but because they fulfill a defined purpose in the stories we wanna tell. And, as I said before, absolutely no goofy, over-the-top-idiotic, comedy relief characters. We'll have some that are more humorous than others, but no overtly bumbling fools because this ain't some little kid's cartoon we're trying to create here.

But, As CyberCubed so accurately states above, this is not the Mirage comic, either -- it is a whole new ballgame that we whole-heartedly invite you all to play with us!

Some new rules, some old rules... new faces, old faces... and always plenty of surprises!

I'll be playing ball with this series for its duration (which is hopefully extremely long!) I was just expressing a concern because I didn't think Bebop & Rocksteady archetypes would be presented so early on, especially since we already have a "Krang". But your words give me comfort Tom! Time after time you confirm that this isn't a kids comic, and that's most important to me.

I don't want a regurgitated Mirage universe, I never said that. Even though my last few posts are anti-OT characters being written in IDW, it's ironic that I do favor colored bandanas. That being said, I'm just being a TMNT fan and nit-picking. It also doesn't help that I really can't stand Bebop & Rocksteady. Of course, I'm excited to see how it plays out...

Powder
12-07-2011, 08:25 PM
They're free to utilize every concept from every incarnation of the franchise and I think that's FANTASTIC. I love the idea of seeing a mix of new and classic ideas and I appreciate that they aren't relegating the Fred Wolf, Archie and Playmates characters to the dregs because "wah wah they were for kids and shouldn't count".


As usual I share Speng's thoughts.

"Every"??? I think we can all universally agree that 'the next mutation' doesn't apply, right?? LOL

Well... I think that an ancient Chinese vampire babe (Vam Mi) could be reworked in a cool way, same goes for Dragon Lord.

I'm gonna make a good point/bad point kinda thing this time around, rather than a little write up.

Good:
-Art is awesome, same goes for the coloring.
-Nice pacing.
-Good to see Raph with some intelligence.
-Happy that Casey is being brought into the family.
-Alopex has an interesting design.
-Silhouetted Shredder. Confirmation of his character is grade A in my book.

Bad:
-What seem to be colored bandanas out of f*cking nowhere.
-Upfront mutant overload. I like the idea of throwing in a bunch of mutants (not all at once, though), but the fact that every mutant we're going to eventually see will all likely be coming from this same test facility seems suuuuuuper cheesey to me. It's like Willy Wonka's bad guy factory. One gets beaten they pop out another. I may be wrong, but if that's how it turns out I won't spare anyone my "HOW CORNY!" comments.
-Bebop & Rocksteady. No. Yes. Well... Ok, here's the thing, bottom line I've always loved those guys. Like, a LOT. BUT, as Jester said 2 pages back, though Fred Wolf characters such as them are more than welcome, their popping up felt really forced or as he put it "tacked on". The "I'M A GODDAMN RHINOOO!" comment to me was an awesome homage, but from then on out it felt unnatural to me. Hopefully that was just a matter of timing, squeezing 'em in to establish the characters before there's no better chance to. If that's the case I totally excuse it. & let's be sure we're on the same page, I love them, I'm glad they're here, I'm just "meh" about the shoe-in.

Despite my lengthy quip about B&R, I feel the good outweighs the bad. I thought this was a fantastic issue, especially in it's visual appeal. I very much so look forward to the Michelangelo issue now (not that I didn't beforehand).

Slap-Happy
12-07-2011, 08:35 PM
Why do Bebop and Rocksteady have to be comic relief?

The way to do it is to make them giant mutant henchmen. Not comic relief or anything, just muscle for The Shredder.

EDIT: Loved the issue too, but why doesn't Franco put the lines on Raph's plastron?

Utromshredderhater
12-07-2011, 08:35 PM
I'm all for using OT characters. Let's face it, Mirage villains weren't all that interesting

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 08:42 PM
But, As CyberCubed so accurately states above, this is not the Mirage comic, either -- it is a whole new ballgame that we whole-heartedly invite you all to play with us!

Some new rules, some old rules... new faces, old faces... and always plenty of surprises!

Yep, just here's hoping you guys never add a 5th Turtle, aka Venus de Milo from the Next Mutation series. No girl Turtles, as that's officially shark jumping. There's a reason that show is viewed as the "black sheep" of the TMNT franchise, and its only really because of that 1 character. :lol:

Slash on the other hand is more than welcome.

Powder
12-07-2011, 08:53 PM
I'm all for using OT characters. Let's face it, Mirage villains weren't all that interesting

Let's face it, that's your opinion.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 08:56 PM
Its pretty much agreed the Mirage series didn't really have a rogues gallery though. Almost every villain was killed off quickly or became a friend of the Turtles.

I think Savanti Romero was really the only recurring villain they had.

Cowabunga Carl
12-07-2011, 09:06 PM
See I liked Venus, Silver, and Dragon Lord.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 09:10 PM
If they're willing to use more elements from OT background, might as well go the whole 10 yards and bring back General Traag and the Rock soldiers.

I severely doubt General Krang has a "human" army anyhow.

Donnie
12-07-2011, 09:24 PM
If they're willing to use more elements from OT background, might as well go the whole 10 yards and bring back General Traag and the Rock soldiers.

I severely doubt General Krang has a "human" army anyhow.

Now you want Rock soldiers? Soldiers made from rock. If they introduce an alien army, I severely hope it will be the Triceratons.

longbowhunter
12-07-2011, 09:25 PM
Just wanted to chime in and say that I am REALLY enjoying these new comics. I told someone today that these are the best TMNT comics to come out since CITY AT WAR. While reading the Raph one-shot today I was a little taken aback by the Artic Fox character,but she worked out fine and I thought it was cool to see BeBop and Rocksteady 2011...and I ALWAYS hated those characters. I'm excited to see how IDW is going to use them in this new and improved Turtle-verse.

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 09:42 PM
Now you want Rock soldiers? Soldiers made from rock. If they introduce an alien army, I severely hope it will be the Triceratons.

The Triceratons don't work for Krang.

If anything this, "war" Krang's talking about could already be an outer space conflict. I don't think we need to see a rehash of the whole Federation Vs. Triceraton story arc again that was done already in both Mirage and the 4kids cartoon.

However I would like to see Krang's army go up against the Triceratons.

ToTheNines
12-07-2011, 09:46 PM
If anything this, "war" Krang's talking about could already be an outer space conflict.

I dunno. Why would he be posing as a human then?

Andrew NDB
12-07-2011, 09:53 PM
I dunno. Why would he be posing as a human then?

Could be slumming it as either an exiled/disgraced Utrom warlord or just simply in hiding (or hatching some master plan of breeding a bunch of mutants for an army to take back to Utrom space and whup on them). That wouldn't even be too far from Krang's original background in the OS.

azrael
12-07-2011, 10:31 PM
I did not expect any of that from the Raph micro, such an amazing read and the art was wonderful. You know its xmas when we are getting 3 turtle books.

1 question though

Was that the shredder at the end or was the shadow suppose to represent the "Boss"

DrSpengler
12-07-2011, 10:46 PM
I did not expect any of that from the Raph micro, such an amazing read and the art was wonderful. You know its xmas when we are getting 3 turtle books.

1 question though

Was that the shredder at the end or was the shadow suppose to represent the "Boss"

My interpretation is that the scarred ninja is Oroku Saki, though he hasn't become the Shredder yet and is currently reporting to a higher authority. It could be that the Shredder is a title he will inherit whenever the current boss is usurped, or a title he'll forge for himself when he takes power (I'm saying "when" like I know for certain how everything's going to happen, ha).

Whatever the case, I think scarface is intended to be Oroku Saki.

Slap-Happy
12-07-2011, 10:54 PM
Really, the only memorable Mirage villains were ones that translated to other media, which is waht they are most recognized for. i.e. Rat King, Leatherhead, etc.

Redeemer
12-07-2011, 11:11 PM
Really enjoyed the Raph Micro series today, cant wait for the next issue :D

Beebop+Rocksteady= Awesomeness!!!!
Hopefully they jst wont make them complete retards now.

AquaParade
12-07-2011, 11:14 PM
Let's face it, that's your opinion.

"Well, that's just like your opinion man"

Andrew NDB
12-07-2011, 11:28 PM
My interpretation is that the scarred ninja is Oroku Saki, though he hasn't become the Shredder yet and is currently reporting to a higher authority. It could be that the Shredder is a title he will inherit whenever the current boss is usurped, or a title he'll forge for himself when he takes power (I'm saying "when" like I know for certain how everything's going to happen, ha).

Whatever the case, I think scarface is intended to be Oroku Saki.

Yeah. If I was on the fence about it before, the reminder of that particular Foot Soldier in the latest issue couldn't have been a coincidence.

Redeemer
12-07-2011, 11:49 PM
I do like how they r wrapping alot of the story in suspense I cant wait to read Mikey one shot. and issue 5.
especially with the shredder and krang still being unknown. When I saw raph and KC chasing after the artic fox I was anxious bc I thought it was Rat King, but then when I saw it was a mutant fox I was a little disjointed but still liked the character.

Powder
12-07-2011, 11:57 PM
I'm surprised people are surprised about Alopex considering we were told all about her and that she'd be appearing in this issue...

CyberCubed
12-07-2011, 11:59 PM
Did anyone at IDW make the connection between her and Ninjara?

I mean Ninjara started off as an enemy of the Turtles as well in her first appearance.

Andrew NDB
12-08-2011, 12:12 AM
Did anyone at IDW make the connection between her and Ninjara?

I mean Ninjara started off as an enemy of the Turtles as well in her first appearance.

I can't believe for one moment that that was coincidence.

But it's cool. I'm a big Ninjara fan. If one were to draw upon all universes of characters and (good) character relationships that stand out above all others, Raphael and Ninjara's would be impossible to ignore.

CyberCubed
12-08-2011, 12:28 AM
I can't believe for one moment that that was coincidence.

But it's cool. I'm a big Ninjara fan. If one were to draw upon all universes of characters and (good) character relationships that stand out above all others, Raphael and Ninjara's would be impossible to ignore.

True, which makes you wonder why they didn't just use Ninjara then instead of creating a new character who seems suspiciously similar.

I guess we'll see where this goes.

Matches Malone
12-08-2011, 12:32 AM
My interpretation is that the scarred ninja is Oroku Saki, though he hasn't become the Shredder yet and is currently reporting to a higher authority. It could be that the Shredder is a title he will inherit whenever the current boss is usurped, or a title he'll forge for himself when he takes power (I'm saying "when" like I know for certain how everything's going to happen, ha).

Whatever the case, I think scarface is intended to be Oroku Saki.

It's pretty clear the Shredder is being fore"shadowed" by the ninja on the last panel. Strangely, while I initially believed it was the scarred ninja from #2, on closer inspection, I'm not entirely sure I see a scar. It actually looks like it could be the "twinkle" drawn in both of his eyes. It most likely is him since he's the only ninja given any kind of extra attention so far, but can't seem to find that scar...

Also, while he probably does serve the current "master," my first instinct was that he was simply referring to himself in the third person, which certainly seems like something he would do.

Andrew NDB
12-08-2011, 12:33 AM
True, which makes you wonder why they didn't just use Ninjara then instead of creating a new character who seems suspiciously similar.

There might be aspects of her character/history that are markedly different than Ninjara's... in which case it makes sense to make it a different (if similar) character. This is kind of what I was arguing for in regard to Bebop and Rocksteady.

Or it might just be as simple as "Ninjara" being kind of a silly name. I love her, but it is.

Matches Malone
12-08-2011, 12:42 AM
There might be aspects of her character/history that are markedly different than Ninjara's... in which case it makes sense to make it a different (if similar) character. This is kind of what I was arguing for in regard to Bebop and Rocksteady.

Or it might just be as simple as "Ninjara" being kind of a silly name. I love her, but it is.

I was thinking the same thing. Ninjara is kind of silly name. Plus, Alopex is a mutant whereas I believe Ninjara was simply part of a "Fox Tribe."

With Bebop & Rocksteady, it probably is true that they could have created new characters to fill similar roles and that they didn't because they are fan-favorites from the Fred Wolf cartoon. There is certainly no denying that many fans are extremely excited by their appearance (I'm kind middle of the road about it; cautiously optimistic). In the end, the choices to create new or reinvent old characters is probably determined by something as arbitrary as what the writers felt like playing with, which is certainly a perk they are entitled to.

CyberCubed
12-08-2011, 12:45 AM
I was thinking the same thing. Ninjara is kind of silly name. Plus, Alopex is a mutant whereas I believe Ninjara was simply part of a "Fox Tribe."

Ninjara's real name was Umeko. That's what she was called by her fox people. Its just if you're going to use similar animals as mutants, feels odd to use a new one based on one that exists.

It'd be as if we got a new shark mutant, but he wasn't Armaggon. Reminds me of when people thought the shark at the beginning of the Image series was Armaggon.

marcelangelo
12-08-2011, 01:38 AM
hey, cybercubed, luck will have it that I coincidentally watched a tribute on ninja turtles the next mutation just yesterday and the character venus de milo was not at all the main reason why the show came of whacky.....;)I don't know if you wrote that ironicly, but to me that character was the least point actually why I cannot be true friends with the show even if there are things that are interesting...(or READ interesting)...
so excited, I should be getting raphael micro today or tomorrow!!!;)

Powder
12-08-2011, 01:41 AM
So anybody pick up variants? I wasn't going to but that Urru cover had me at hello. So I got that and cover A.

Andrew NDB
12-08-2011, 02:16 AM
So anybody pick up variants? I wasn't going to but that Urru cover had me at hello. So I got that and cover A.

I think I'll be fine with the main one this go-around. The Urru one is a great piece of art but something doesn't sit right with me about it, at least enough to pay extra for it.

hey, cybercubed, luck will have it that I coincidentally watched a tribute on ninja turtles the next mutation just yesterday and the character venus de milo was not at all the main reason why the show came of whacky....

Sounds like IDW agrees with you, if the lettercol of #4 is any indication. In any case, you're right... the show was horrific on almost every level, entirely of its own right. While Venus can't quite be considered the Typhoid Mary of NT:TNM as a lot of retrospectives would have you believe, though, she certainly didn't help things either.

marcelangelo
12-08-2011, 06:38 AM
couldn't agree more with you, andrew....man, I am eagerly awaiting the mailman with my comic books right about now...

plastroncafe
12-08-2011, 11:29 AM
With regards to why not use Ninjara:

I was under the assumption that she was never considered a "Mirage/Turtle" character, and thus wasn't part of the sale. Can someone confirm that?

oldmanwinters
12-08-2011, 11:31 AM
So anybody pick up variants? I wasn't going to but that Urru cover had me at hello. So I got that and cover A.

I went Cover B only, because I think the Urru art is just fantastic and fits the interior art style so well. It has a very Batman-esque/Spiderman-esque feel in my opinion. $4 is a lot to pay for an extra copy so I generally don't bother with them, especially when I planned on picking up Mega Man too!

Samhain
12-08-2011, 11:32 AM
So anybody pick up variants? I wasn't going to but that Urru cover had me at hello. So I got that and cover A.

I just got cover A this time. I wasn't into the others and I wasn't feeling the $22 price point on an rehashed ''vintage'' cover.

Cowabunga Carl
12-08-2011, 11:52 AM
$22 price point? I thought the variants were $7. Hmmm I'll have to call my comic shop cause that's the one I had pulled for me.

MattLawrence
12-08-2011, 12:04 PM
So anybody pick up variants? I wasn't going to but that Urru cover had me at hello. So I got that and cover A.

i picked up all the variants besides the jetpack. The prices at my lcs are very reasonable. They still have i think 4 of the 1/10 incentive B & W variants left. I can check if anyone wants, just let me know. i was going to head down there sometime today

Andrew NDB
12-08-2011, 12:19 PM
With regards to why not use Ninjara:

I was under the assumption that she was never considered a "Mirage/Turtle" character, and thus wasn't part of the sale. Can someone confirm that?

That was a thought that Murphy told me... but unfortunately when he dug further, he confirmed that Nick/Viacom owns her and there's nothing he can do about it.

DrSpengler
12-08-2011, 12:30 PM
That was a thought that Murphy told me... but unfortunately when he dug further, he confirmed that Nick/Viacom owns her and there's nothing he can do about it.

I had wondered if he and Allan had sold her to Laird or not. I recall that interview with Farley where he mentioned Laird's "aggressive" drive to reclaim all the rights and partial rights of TMNT characters and comics from other creators; guess I'm not surprised Ninjara was among those Laird bought back "for a pittance" as Farley put it.

Cowabunga Carl
12-08-2011, 12:43 PM
Still haven't gotten my copy. I called my shop and the one cover they got of the Eastman one was damaged so I have to wait for next week for it. But he has the basic cover so I'm going to double dip on this one. Hope to have it tonight.

plastroncafe
12-08-2011, 01:02 PM
This is the only IDW book of the run that I haven't picked up the Eastman cover. I opted for the Petersen this time around.

I'm a big fan of Petersen's Mouse Guard, and in 2009 got my chance to meet him at Comic Con. When ever I'm at a Con that Dooney is also at I always pick up his con specific print and use it as my autograph page. Petersen flipped when he saw it, not knowing that The Turtle Guys were also at the convention. He just gushed and gushed about how much he loved the turtles, and asked me if I thought they'd be receptive to him doing an issue of Tales.

I...honestly had no idea, and said so, but that I'd love to see it if it happened!

SO yeah, there was no way I wasn't going to pick up this cover.

Redeemer
12-08-2011, 01:09 PM
I'm surprised people are surprised about Alopex considering we were told all about her and that she'd be appearing in this issue...

I jst dont like reading "previews" of issues I like the twist and turns as I read is all. :D

Roseangelo
12-08-2011, 01:32 PM
This is the only IDW book of the run that I haven't picked up the Eastman cover. I opted for the Petersen this time around.

Same here. The biggest appeal of the Eastman covers on the on-going book is that they're new art. Since for this one it's old art, going with the Petersen cover was a no-brainer. It's an absolutely fantastic piece. And I had to get the regular color version, even though I could have gotten the "rarer" sketch version.

plastroncafe
12-08-2011, 01:53 PM
] And I had to get the regular color version, even though I could have gotten the "rarer" sketch version.

Me too, the coloring was just too good to pass up. A+ all around, well done IDW!

Cowabunga Carl
12-08-2011, 01:55 PM
I just like the idea of having the Eastman covers. But I'm not sure which other cover I'll pick up.

Donnie
12-08-2011, 01:57 PM
I'm surprised a lot of you are against the remastered covers from the Mirage micros. It's the variant I want most, actually. Those covers are great, in my opinion, and the nod to the past is cool.

Cowabunga Carl
12-08-2011, 02:04 PM
I'm with you Donnie. I think the throwback covers are amazing. I'm going to get each one and then a second copy that I can read.

Samhain
12-08-2011, 02:57 PM
I'm surprised a lot of you are against the remastered covers from the Mirage micros. It's the variant I want most, actually. Those covers are great, in my opinion, and the nod to the past is cool.

The problem is the fact that the so called ''remastered'' cover is it's the exact cover from the original issue, just with an IDW logo slapped on it.

Andrew NDB
12-08-2011, 03:09 PM
The problem is the fact that the so called ''remastered'' cover is it's the exact cover from the original issue, just with an IDW logo slapped on it.

If I had any problem with the "remastered" covers it's that they're a little bit misleading to people. There's all this fuss being thrown back -- understandbly -- about, "It's a whole new universe and anything goes in IDW TMNT!" Yet here's all these very iconic, very definitively Mirage TMNT covers on the fronts of the issues.

I'm not saying anything about it because, #1. More Mirage covers aren't something I think anyone should be complaining about (even if it's old art), and #2. For now, the IDW comics haven't strayed radically far from the Mirage comics.

Eventually, though, maybe a year from now, it's going to seem very, very weird to open up a copy of IDW TMNT with, say, a recycled Mirage "City at War" cover but when you open it up, it's TMNT with the rainbow bandannas and some kind of a big Krang, Bebop, and Rocksteady adventure.

Venom
12-08-2011, 03:47 PM
Yet here's all these very iconic, very definitively Mirage TMNT covers on the fronts of the issues.

When I originally read about the "remastered" retro covers, my initial thought was that Kevin (or Duncan) would use the original micro-series cover as a template to transpose artwork of the new versions, thus creating a true remastered "retro" version, or perhaps Kevin drawing a cover featuring Raph/Casey.

I just had a thought - the second printing cover of Raphael would have made a much better "retro" variant than a reprint of the first edition cover, especially since it depicts Raph and Casey on a rooftop, and the new micro begins with some rooftop fun.

Samhain
12-08-2011, 03:50 PM
When I originally read about the "remastered" retro covers, my initial thought was that Kevin (or Duncan) would use the original micro-series cover as a template to transpose artwork of the new versions, thus creating a true remastered "retro" version, or perhaps Kevin drawing a cover featuring Raph/Casey.



That is EXACTLY what I thought aswell.

oldmanwinters
12-08-2011, 04:17 PM
I'm surprised a lot of you are against the remastered covers from the Mirage micros. It's the variant I want most, actually. Those covers are great, in my opinion, and the nod to the past is cool.

Personally, I'd like to see new art homages to various classic covers in the TMNT lore as variants or retailer incentives. That way you could pay tribute to the older works yet still give a fairly accurate representation of the new content. Reprinting the old stuff under a new label just strikes me as a bit lazy and without creativity.

Venom
12-08-2011, 05:07 PM
Personally, I'd like to see new art homages to various classic covers in the TMNT lore as variants or retailer incentives. That way you could pay tribute to the older works yet still give a fairly accurate representation of the new content. Reprinting the old stuff under a new label just strikes me as a bit lazy and without creativity.

^Yeah, this, totally.

I'm on board with IDW's series in just about every way, but this one niggle just feels so devoid of any artistic merit. Fiscally, though, it's rather sound.

I can see the logic behind it though: it gives people the chance to own a version of the classic covers without having to search out and buy the classic comic. Plus, it's another variant for us completionists to buy which, in turn, will help the cash flow needed to continue the series.

Powder
12-08-2011, 06:51 PM
When I originally read about the "remastered" retro covers, my initial thought was that Kevin (or Duncan) would use the original micro-series cover as a template to transpose artwork of the new versions, thus creating a true remastered "retro" version, or perhaps Kevin drawing a cover featuring Raph/Casey.

I just had a thought - the second printing cover of Raphael would have made a much better "retro" variant than a reprint of the first edition cover, especially since it depicts Raph and Casey on a rooftop, and the new micro begins with some rooftop fun.

These 100%. Outside of these "retro" covers, I will always buy the Eastman variants.

I jst dont like reading "previews" of issues I like the twist and turns as I read is all. :D

It wasn't from a preview, it was in the ashcan interview which I assumed almost everybody read...

Abnormal Freak
12-08-2011, 07:21 PM
I actually thought by "remastered" they were going to take the original art and recolor it. Looks to be they just slapped the original cover on a new book and added an IDW logo.

That's an awesome cover, but I own the original issue, so I far prefer the standard art. I'm not a fan of the Jetpack variants because it's all rehashed artwork I've seen a million times before.

Ninjinister
12-08-2011, 09:40 PM
Why is "Bebop" bald on the second-to-last page?

Mr._Mutant_Man
12-08-2011, 09:42 PM
Raphael was easily the best issue yet IMO. The series has been okay so far, but after Raphael, I really do want to see where this is all going.

I thought the Rocksteady and Bebop characters were just supposed to look like them, so I thought it was really cool when they hinted at them mutating later. :)

I see nothing wrong with using characters from the old cartoon. If the only similarities are that they are a mutant rhino and warthog named Rocksteady and Bebop, that's just fine. The Turtles were goofy characters in the cartoon too. Just because Bebop and Rocksteady weren't a part of the original comics, I don't see that as a reason not to use them. You could argue that they should make original characters, but if that's the case, why not just make completely original characters and not try to use the TMNT brand at all?

I liked the tease with a Ninjara-like character, only to have her be an enemy.

As far as this series having a bunch of mutants, I say bring it. I think the Archie series shows that you can have good TMNT with a ton of mutants.

CyberCubed
12-08-2011, 09:54 PM
Makes you wonder if Leatherhead will be created by Krang's mutagen as well. It would be a homage to the way the Utroms found him in Mirage.

ToTheNines
12-08-2011, 09:58 PM
Makes you wonder if Leatherhead will be created by Krang's mutagen as well. It would be a homage to the way the Utroms found him in Mirage.

Um... no it wouldn't.

Andrew NDB
12-08-2011, 10:04 PM
You could argue that they should make original characters, but if that's the case, why not just make completely original characters and not try to use the TMNT brand at all?

Straw man (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man).

As far as this series having a bunch of mutants, I say bring it. I think the Archie series shows that you can have good TMNT with a ton of mutants.

I would need to temper my agreeing with you here by adding, "... while it also shows us the dangers of going too far into that direction."

CyberCubed
12-08-2011, 10:30 PM
Um... no it wouldn't.

Close enough. The Utroms waste product drifts into the sewers and mutates a gator. Same way in the old toon, the mutagen lands in a swamp and Leatherhead mutates that way.

As for too many mutants, that's actually one thing I didn't care for too much in Archie. Some of them were really cool but others felt pointless...like way too many talking animals.

Redeemer
12-08-2011, 10:31 PM
I wish I could get my hands on the eastmen covers but my comic book stores never order enough regular issues to recieve the eastman or jetpack covers....

Venom
12-08-2011, 10:51 PM
I wish I could get my hands on the eastmen covers but my comic book stores never order enough regular issues to recieve the eastman or jetpack covers....

You have to order the Jetpack variant from Jetpack Comics.

http://www.jetpackcomics.com

Redeemer
12-08-2011, 11:08 PM
You have to order the Jetpack variant from Jetpack Comics.

http://www.jetpackcomics.com

Thanks venom

Rooish
12-09-2011, 10:57 AM
I liked this comic. It's weird to me that Casey is kind of... calm and sweet compared to Raph. All that talk about "How does it FEEL, Raph?"

Wasn't he supposed to be the one that made Raph look calm and sweet? I hope we get more into Raph's mind about what it's like to have a family now.

Cool seeing the multi-coloured bandannas. Always liked them better.

Alopex was neat, although her boobies hanging out made me a tad uncomfortable. ANYWAY. I do wish we could have more, like, human ninja baddies, but I guess that's coming, and I don't mind a slow build up for a good pay off (I, for one, liked Volume 4 of Mirage).

ToTheNines
12-09-2011, 11:02 AM
Close enough. The Utroms waste product drifts into the sewers and mutates a gator. Same way in the old toon, the mutagen lands in a swamp and Leatherhead mutates that way.

No. Leatherhead was the pet of Dr. X for some amount of time before being exposed to the mutagen while living in the TCRI building.

marcelangelo
12-09-2011, 11:34 AM
hi gang!
so I got my issue #4 and raphael today and read through them in my comfortable comic book reading chair with a nice hot cup of tea(like splinter drank in # 2;)..)anyway, I feel the same love about these issues as you all seem to do...and like I ssaid I very welcome bebop and rocksteady into the comic book universe (apart from archie and teenage mutant hero turtles comics I mean)...I just noticed something today that I thaught would be good to share..the stealing ninja that splinter gashed his eye out was injured in the left part of his face...so his left eye..the ninja standing on the last page of raphael micro would have his scar on the right part of his face(but I think that's really just light and shading, no scar at all)...also of note, in issue two where this splinter attack happened the other ninja was stroken with glas by miss o'neill in the left eye or part of his face as well...so showing a ninja now with a scar on his left side could be both of those...

Venom
12-09-2011, 11:54 AM
For anyone who didn't notice, Bobby psted over on the IDW board that he "wasn't sure that we had seen the Shredder. A shadow does not a Shredder make."

Cowabunga Carl
12-09-2011, 12:25 PM
I got my copy yesterday and read it on my lunch break.

Apolex was a fun addition. I look forward to seeing her around more in future issues. I like that she isn't just a new version of an old character. It allows a little more freedom I think. I mean it could be argued that she is just Ninjara with another name but I don't think so. I think we are in for some surprises with her character.

Bebop and Rocksteady bother me a little in this issue. They seem a little more competent which is good, but they seem to be included just because. Maybe issue 5 will explain or give mention why who ever is doing this is using thugs. If they were part of Hob's gang it would make more since to me. But to be working with the ninja's we know nothing about bugs me.

Casey Jones is a favorite character of mine. When I was little and the first movie came out I went dressed as him for Halloween. I've pretty much liked him across all the different versions. This one is no different. I like how they are taking his character thus far. To show his anger is part of loosing his mom, having an abusive father, and feeling like he doesn't belong is realistic. It gives him some much needed space to grow as a character. I look forward to his interaction with the other Turtles, Splinter, and April.

Over all I think it was a good issue. I'm going to give all my issues a re-read later today.So far the series seems headed in a great direction.

Mr._Mutant_Man
12-09-2011, 09:01 PM
Straw man (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man).


I probably should have elaborated more. It was said earlier that if the characters aren't going to be portrayed in the same way, why include them? But aren't most remakes about shaking things up a little, telling a similar story but putting new spins? That would include possibly making changes in character behavior.

For instance, in the Battlestar Galactica remake, Baltar went from being supervillain evil in the original to being portrayed as narcissistic, self serving, and willing to do anything to save his miserable butt, while still having redeeming qualities and feelings of guilt over what he did. That is quite a change for the character between versions, but that's what remakes do. They take things the audience is familiar with, but add new twists to make things interesting.

I think that if someone is doing a remake of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, then all of the characters from the past should be fair game for being re-imagined. Especially characters that are as recognizable as Bebop and Rocksteady. I don't see why certain characters should be excluded just because of the tone of the old cartoon. Just because they were characterized one way, doesn't mean they can't be intimidating and bad ass in the comic. After all, we're talking about a giant rhino, that should be intimidating.

I don't see why the writers should have to come up with completely new characters to fit that role, when the fictional universe isn't even original in the first place. Nostalgia is what kept the TMNT going for so long, so I don't think the writers can be faulted for wanting to have more recognizable characters in their story.

My take is that the new comic's take on old characters should be judged by what happens in the comic, not necessarily how the characters were portrayed before. It's a sticky subject, because the whole reason the characters are there is because they are familiar. Really, in the end, it's just fiction, and it's not like the old comics or cartoons are going to go away because there's a new version we may or may not like. That's what I try to tell myself after every horror remake. :)

Andrew NDB
12-09-2011, 09:22 PM
I still don't have the issue. I'll have it tonight, I think.

Cowabunga Carl
12-09-2011, 09:37 PM
I probably should have elaborated more. It was said earlier that if the characters aren't going to be portrayed in the same way, why include them? But aren't most remakes about shaking things up a little, telling a similar story but putting new spins? That would include possibly making changes in character behavior.

For instance, in the Battlestar Galactica remake, Baltar went from being supervillain evil in the original to being portrayed as narcissistic, self serving, and willing to do anything to save his miserable butt, while still having redeeming qualities and feelings of guilt over what he did. That is quite a change for the character between versions, but that's what remakes do. They take things the audience is familiar with, but add new twists to make things interesting.

I think that if someone is doing a remake of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, then all of the characters from the past should be fair game for being re-imagined. Especially characters that are as recognizable as Bebop and Rocksteady. I don't see why certain characters should be excluded just because of the tone of the old cartoon. Just because they were characterized one way, doesn't mean they can't be intimidating and bad ass in the comic. After all, we're talking about a giant rhino, that should be intimidating.

I don't see why the writers should have to come up with completely new characters to fit that role, when the fictional universe isn't even original in the first place. Nostalgia is what kept the TMNT going for so long, so I don't think the writers can be faulted for wanting to have more recognizable characters in their story.

My take is that the new comic's take on old characters should be judged by what happens in the comic, not necessarily how the characters were portrayed before. It's a sticky subject, because the whole reason the characters are there is because they are familiar. Really, in the end, it's just fiction, and it's not like the old comics or cartoons are going to go away because there's a new version we may or may not like. That's what I try to tell myself after every horror remake. :)

I like this. And I can respect where you are coming from with it. I guess maybe I could have rushed into it not thinking enough. I mean the fan fic I'm working on has characters re-imagined. I guess my biggest problem is not fully understanding why the ninjas are using thugs in this verse.

Abnormal Freak
12-09-2011, 10:29 PM
Alopex was neat, although her boobies hanging out made me a tad uncomfortable.

I was a tad surprised by how subdued they were. Normally when there's some kinda furry female character, HUGE BAZONGOIDS are included.

CyberCubed
12-09-2011, 10:34 PM
I was a tad surprised by how subdued they were. Normally when there's some kinda furry female character, HUGE BAZONGOIDS are included.

You mean like Ninjara's?

(Its sad that this conversation is making people sound like furries)

Matches Malone
12-09-2011, 10:36 PM
I guess my biggest problem is not fully understanding why the ninjas are using thugs in this verse.

For the story being told, the attack on Alopex is completely staged and it is probably more convincing to utilize actual thugs than ninjas, yes? Plus, it is likely whoever is behind this staged attack would want to utilize their ninja force for more appropriate tasks. From there, it was probably seen as a good opportunity for the writers to incorporate Bebop & Rocksteady since they closely fit the story-need for thugs.

azrael
12-09-2011, 10:39 PM
I like this. And I can respect where you are coming from with it. I guess maybe I could have rushed into it not thinking enough. I mean the fan fic I'm working on has characters re-imagined. I guess my biggest problem is not fully understanding why the ninjas are using thugs in this verse.

Could be to hire local help as to not attract attention to themselves.