View Full Version : Each film in its own universe?
Donnie
08-21-2011, 12:40 AM
I know the films (the three live action and TMNT) are supposed to be tied together, but does anybody like to think of each film as a separate TMNT universe in and of itself?
I like to personally think in my little world that the first film's Turtles were featured in just that, the first film - we never saw them again. Those Turtles in Turtles 2 were different, and so on.
Obviously us core fans favor the first film and do not see the other three as up to par...but what I'm asking is beyond acknowledging that the first movie was superior.
Jester
08-21-2011, 12:51 AM
Can't say that I do, Friend...
Donnie
08-21-2011, 12:52 AM
Can't say that I do, Friend...
It's okay, I still love ya. ;)
Powder
08-21-2011, 12:55 AM
I have my own personal realities for the films, like that Norinaga is a descendant of Shredder & stuff like that, but I see the three as they were meant to be, timeline-wise.
Jester
08-21-2011, 12:55 AM
It's okay, I still love ya. ;)
Ditto.
The only movie I may say is "it's own universe" is TMNT, if only because it's a "soft sequel".
Donnie
08-21-2011, 12:59 AM
I have my own personal realities for the films
That's a good way to put how I think of the first film, it's a personal reality of mine to think of it as separate - but that personal viewpoint differs from the actual reality of it all!
The only movie I may say is "it's own universe" is TMNT, if only because it's a "soft sequel".
"Soft sequel"...I like that.
Cowabunga Carl
08-21-2011, 01:29 AM
Two me the first three movies work well together. I enjoy them as a whole, and think that the third movie gets a rather bad reputation it doesn't deserve. Then to me there are two separate timelines that emerge after the third movie. I view The Next Mutation as one time line and TMNT as another. To me they are both just as valid and depending on my mood depends on which way I watch them. I tend not to be able to just watch one Turtle movie when I sit down to watch them.
Zog the Equalizer
08-21-2011, 03:24 AM
I've always like to think of the first movie as it's own thing where Shredder actually dies at the end. And that the second movie is like an alternate timeline where Casey didn't pull that lever. I think the third movie and TMNT both work either way
Slap-Happy
08-21-2011, 03:38 AM
I've always like to think of the first movie as it's own thing where Shredder actually dies at the end. And that the second movie is like an alternate timeline where Casey didn't pull that lever.
Hmm. Never thought of it that way, but it works.
Donnie
08-22-2011, 12:50 AM
I like that approach, Zog!
Luzmagica
08-22-2011, 01:14 AM
To me the first three movies work well together. I enjoy them as a whole, and think that the third movie gets a rather bad reputation it doesn't deserve. Then to me there are two separate timelines that emerge after the third movie. I view The Next Mutation as one time line and TMNT as another. To me they are both just as valid and depending on my mood depends on which way I watch them. I tend not to be able to just watch one Turtle movie when I sit down to watch them.
Heya! What a coincidence! I feel so similar too!!!! So I "steal" your answer as my opinion too... :tgrin::tgrin::tgrin: :twink:
Discogod
08-22-2011, 03:50 AM
Growing up, I always felt that the first movie was an adaptation of the Mirage comics, whilst the second movie was an adaptation of the original cartoon - that's how I reconciled the differences in tone and look, the different actors, lack of Casey...
I know that's not the case, but it's the only way I could really enjoy the second film.
And here I thought people discussing the 2k3 seasons as different shows was nuts.
Bauer536
08-28-2011, 10:28 PM
Donny,
I must say, the first movie was the best. Just taking a look at those screen caps of Leonardo gritting his teeth fighting a Foot Ninja was breathtaking. Sorry for the dramatic language.:tlol:
I do believe that the first movie was almost as accurate to the '84 comics. But, I also believe the second film was a continuation of the first film. The Shredder did come back. Was that one the best? No. But it was fun to watch. Besides, Super Shredder was awesome.:tcool:
Now, I will say that I don't count the third film as an actual TMNT flim because it was silly, and all the turtles seemed to get out of character for a lot of scenes.
I enjoyed the CGI animated film. It seemed to be a continuation of the first two films. There were some of those classic elements shown in the film. Example: Shredder's helmet in the trophy room (or closet - I don't know what it really was).:tlol: Plus, I never considered it a 2k3 meets OT film. This seemed to be something new. Now that I think about it, it might have been just a test. It seemed that Mirage was floundering with Fast Forward so they had to think of something fast to keep TMNT in the public eye again. I enjoyed reading the junior novel of the film. But I realize, I would have LOVED for the Shredder to come in. They made an action figure of him in armor that he never wore. That's a cool figure by the way.:shredder:
I'm hoping the new TMNT film will be like a Batman Begins kind of story. That would be great. Maybe the film could be a mix of the new 2k12 Nickelodeon series meets the IDW comics. What do you think?:tgrin:
Jester
08-28-2011, 10:33 PM
You know Bauer, I'd never considered that...with the new IDW series and it's origin story and a new twist coming from the Nick series (that we as of now don't know what will be changed) which origin will they use for the next live action flick?
Donnie
08-28-2011, 10:39 PM
And here I thought people discussing the 2k3 seasons as different shows was nuts.
And here I thought people wouldn't waste their time posting if they contributed nothing to the discussion at hand.
You know Bauer, I'd never considered that...with the new IDW series and it's origin story and a new twist coming from the Nick series (that we as of now don't know what will be changed) which origin will they use for the next live action flick?
This is definitely a good question...since we know Nick is involved with IDW, are they really going to want to confuse origin stories? I wish we knew the direction Nick was going with the toon's origin...
Fugitoid Jones
09-01-2011, 11:44 AM
:trazz:
I do believe that the first movie was almost as accurate to the '84 comics. But, I also believe the second film was a continuation of the first film. The Shredder did come back. Was that one the best? No. But it was fun to watch. Besides, Super Shredder was awesome.:tcool:
IMO, Super Shredder was awesome......looking, but really, he was just a big dope. HE KILLED HIMSELF! I was expecting a huge, epic fight with all 4 Turtles and Super Shredder. Instead, he knocks over a couple pillars and the dock falls on him. If they'd given him a brain, he'd be dangerous. :trazz:
I've always looked at the first 3 films as a single universe. As for the 2007 film, I look at that as a possible continuation, but I don't commit to it being in the same universe.
Andrew NDB
09-01-2011, 01:55 PM
Each film in its own universe? I don't know about that, but I wouldn't mind seeing each one in unique little circles of Hell.
LeoNerdo
09-01-2011, 03:53 PM
For me the first two movies go together like pb & jelly. I know the 2nd one is a little goofier and they don't use their weapons really, but the costumes are the same and are awesome. Another part of that is that I'm fairly sure the 2nd film was the first one I ever saw. We hardly ever went to the movies when I was a kid.
The 3rd & 4th ones can be in their own universes. In fact I would prefer to think of them that way.
Spitfire
09-01-2011, 07:39 PM
Obviously us core fans favor the first film and do not see the other three as up to par...but what I'm asking is beyond acknowledging that the first movie was superior.
"Speak for yourself dude."
Donnie
09-01-2011, 09:31 PM
Each film in its own universe? I don't know about that, but I wouldn't mind seeing each one in unique little circles of Hell.
Oh Andrew. I can understand dislike for the second and third films, but do you dislike the first as well?
I know the 2nd one is a little goofier and they don't use their weapons really, but the costumes are the same and are awesome.
Donatello's costume is completely different. I prefer the look of the first film's Donny.
"Speak for yourself dude."
My apologies, you're right, I was generalizing. Although I must admit, I'm surprised that you favor one of the other 3 over the 1990 film. May I ask which one you prefer?
By the way everyone, just to make sure you don't get the wrong idea - I know that these films cannot really be viewed as different universes as far as "film canon" is concerned because they are clearly linked in references throughout. My original thought (and my own personal belief) was just that if one wanted to, you could think of each movie separately and of its own accord and continuity if you so desired because they are so drastically different.
Spitfire
09-02-2011, 01:51 AM
My apologies, you're right, I was generalizing. Although I must admit, I'm surprised that you favor one of the other 3 over the 1990 film. May I ask which one you prefer?
Ah it's cool I'm just goofing. I don't prefer all 3 to one. 2 is my personal favorite followed by 1. 4 is rather meh to me and 3 virtually doesn't exist as far as I'm concerned. I always liked 2 because I enjoyed the voice acting more, liked the costumes better, and while it was sillier I felt the tone overall worked better. 1 flops around a lot between slap stick humor and seriousness and it doesn't always mesh with me. I also didn't like how Don was benched as comic relief and Corey Feldman is my all time worst Donatello voice.
Donnie
09-02-2011, 11:37 AM
Ah it's cool I'm just goofing. I don't prefer all 3 to one. 2 is my personal favorite followed by 1. 4 is rather meh to me and 3 virtually doesn't exist as far as I'm concerned. I always liked 2 because I enjoyed the voice acting more, liked the costumes better, and while it was sillier I felt the tone overall worked better. 1 flops around a lot between slap stick humor and seriousness and it doesn't always mesh with me. I also didn't like how Don was benched as comic relief and Corey Feldman is my all time worst Donatello voice.
Thanks for the explanation! It's interesting to see the varying opinions of each movie. I must say I'm in the opposite camp concerning Feldman's Donatello (and I know at the 'Drome especially, that makes me a minority) - the first film housed my favorite Donatello, although Donny from "Ooze" is a close second. Without gearing away from the thread's focus, I would like to say that although Donny did have more character development in the second film he was still comic relief a lot of the time.
Spitfire
09-02-2011, 02:20 PM
Thanks for the explanation! It's interesting to see the varying opinions of each movie. I must say I'm in the opposite camp concerning Feldman's Donatello (and I know at the 'Drome especially, that makes me a minority) - the first film housed my favorite Donatello, although Donny from "Ooze" is a close second. Without gearing away from the thread's focus, I would like to say that although Donny did have more character development in the second film he was still comic relief a lot of the time.
True but in that respect they were all on the same level which is why the movie works better for me overall. 2 is like a live action version of the cartoon, while 1 is obviously more like the comic. But for the kiddies they still had to inject some of that OT humor into the first movie which is what causes the issue for me I mentioned. As awfully corny as the jokes in 2 are they still make me laugh. I also think the gag fights fit better with the overall set up we're given.
Coola Yagami
09-06-2011, 12:35 AM
I don't care what they say, movie um... 4? was not in their continuity, even if they put Shredder's movie-style helmet in the background. There was no indication the Foot was around in movie 3 and the Turtles were just way too different and mature in TMNT to be the same goofy guys from the first 3 movies.
I can't see the Leo from the early movies be mature enough to embark on a journey to South America on his own... nor Raph to become a vigilantee and be that violent... nor April to somehow become an ass-kicking ninja (Paige Turco as a ninja...? nope, not buying it). And they can't be that mature from the trilogy to this CGI movie since they're still supposed to be teenagers still....
I just can't watch any of the 3 original movies and see those same guys as the ones in the 4th one. The 4th one is a kinda/sorta Mirage TMNT movie, expect with a goofier Mike and the different color-bandanas.
Stingray69
09-25-2011, 09:19 AM
I thought that tmnt is actually suppose to be set in between the second and third live action films, or so I have been told.
Jephael
09-25-2011, 09:49 AM
I thought that tmnt is actually suppose to be set in between the second and third live action films, or so I have been told.
There's just one problem with that theory: You can clearly see the time scepter in Splinter's trophy case.
Donnie
09-25-2011, 10:18 AM
There's just one problem with that theory: You can clearly see the time scepter in Splinter's trophy case.
That actually confused the hell out of me when it first came out, because I read somewhere that the director stated the film's timeline was in between the 2nd and 3rd films. When I saw the scepter, I was like...okay, I guess not? It's pretty clear with the clothing style of the humans and the choice of the soundtrack that TMNT (4) is definitely set in today's world. I wonder why the director said that statement, if he did at all?
Toby Barrett
09-25-2011, 10:27 AM
I don't ever recall reading about the director saying anything about the movie taking place before or omitting the third film. But if he did, he's probobly just like most directors and talking out of his ass. Xp
pannoni1
09-25-2011, 11:04 AM
It's a shame that the crew couldn't get a more cohesive storyline for the sequels, especially given that the OT had better continuity at many points! Still, TMNT: The Movie and SOTO meld together, even if the ending of SOTO failed to live up to expectations, and III is still good for the "deep fans", protecting Splinter's ancestors and all which kind of serves as a pilot for The Next Mutation; plus Shredder was pretty much gone.
And, anyone who things that the TMNT CGI movie is in the same universe should think again; it's not even live action and it's a whole new origin; just an attempt to bring back some fans from the "golden age of the Turtles".
Toby Barrett
09-25-2011, 11:17 AM
Heads examined? Well, that's not very nice. I don't see anything wrong with thinking TMNT is in the same continuity as the three live action films. =p
Stingray69
09-25-2011, 11:48 AM
That actually confused the hell out of me when it first came out, because I read somewhere that the director stated the film's timeline was in between the 2nd and 3rd films. When I saw the scepter, I was like...okay, I guess not? It's pretty clear with the clothing style of the humans and the choice of the soundtrack that TMNT (4) is definitely set in today's world. I wonder why the director said that statement, if he did at all?
Yea I heard the same thing about the director. Never noticed the time septor though, have to watch the movie again and look for it.
Cowabunga Carl
09-30-2011, 10:17 PM
I think it was more the Director said it was a loose sequel to the first three. That is followed the first one and parts of the second and third.
Herald7
10-09-2011, 08:06 AM
I must say I'm in the opposite camp concerning Feldman's Donatello (and I know at the 'Drome especially, that makes me a minority) - the first film housed my favorite Donatello
Same here, lol. That's why I have trouble thinking of the first film and the second film as continuous because Donatello is so different and I really preferred the characterization from the first film.
Plus the first film overall was a masterpiece. Whereas the second film to me is just your basic silly sequel. And I don't mind Donny being the technology guy (obviously I like the OT), but in the second film I thought he was just too bland.
I liked that Feldman Donatello is back in the 3rd film, but obviously it's not quite the same since the writing on that film was so....::shivers:: ;)
lethrhd
11-02-2011, 07:39 PM
i kind of like the 2nd movie i didnt for a long time, but when i finally embraced the fact that it was a live action cartoon i started to dig it. The first was a great film but the 2nd is just a stupid, fun movie. That being said i hate the third iv given it every chance i could, iv tried to watch it with fresh eyes and i can hardly get past the scene where the turtles shout "SWIIING" when they notice aprils legs by the lake... ugh! its garbage, but thats hardly a unique perspective.
Herald7
11-02-2011, 11:17 PM
i kind of like the 2nd movie i didnt for a long time, but when i finally embraced the fact that it was a live action cartoon i started to dig it....the 2nd is just a stupid, fun movie. That being said i hate the third iv given it every chance i could
Exactly, the 2nd movie is silly, but harmless. If it was on TV, I might watch it for awhile. But I too have given the 3rd movie several chances and there's just no getting around the fact that the writing is all over the place and the jokes just aren't funny. It was the prime example of a jump the shark moment.
Donnie
12-25-2011, 09:45 AM
I had a dream last night, and it wasn't your typical Christmas morning dream.
In my dream I discovered that my library had VHS tapes that featured episodes using the first movie Turtles & first movie Shredder/Foot (in their own universe!) in dark, made-for-tape episodes. My mind projected a good five minutes at least of this episode, and man, I woke up so upset that it wasn't really in existence.
It featured the first movie Turtle suits to a "tee" and it was very gritty like it was filmed when the first movie was. In it, the Turtles fiercely battled tons of Foot in a much more aggressive manor than they did in the first film. Let me try to describe it scene by scene...
So, the Turtles are in an abandoned warehouse and the Foot start coming in droves. Donatello and Raphael jump into the fray and are taking on tons of Foot encircling them. When Donnie finishes taking out his lot, he quickly escapes to find something to rig that's going to help the Turtles get out of there alive. Raph continues fighting. The camera went to Leo who was taking out an incredible amount of Foot, then to Mikey who was doing the same. Suddenly Shredder (in his classic red garb) came onto the scene and started pushing through towards Leonardo. Before Leo heard Mikey's warning, Shredder came down with an axe right in Leo's shell. Leo yelled in dismay and Mikey immediately started facing Shredder in a one-on-one.
...then I woke up. So upsetting. So much for Christmas wishes! What I saw in my dream reminded me of a reworked "City at War"-style arc. It was dark, gritty, and violent. Ah, the pangs of being a Turtles fan knowing nothing like this will ever see release - only in my head. :P
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.