View Full Version : Hey Variant Buyers, How Much Can You Take?
Archon_Turtle
09-05-2011, 06:58 AM
I was just thinkin'... I like variant covers as much as the next completionisnt collector. They're neat. However, we seem to now be dealing with a number of variant covers per issue far beyond anything we've had in the history of the brand...
Issue 1 had 12 covers. Issue 2 has what...at least 3 or 4 so far (one of which is $20 again). So, as collectors, consumers, etc... How much can you take? If they continue with multiple variants per issue, will you keep up indefinitely? Or will you eventually say enough?
And what about your feelings toward IDW in regards to all the variants? Is there a line between satisfying the collector market and blatant greed?
Jester
09-05-2011, 07:21 AM
I think they'll eventually cut back...if not then they'll have drained the wallets of the fans and we won't be able to buy the new issues anyway...then again I've only bought 2 myself...so what do I know.
EDIT: Though the one variant I have is going for upwards of $45 dollars on eBay...cause it's the "ULTRA SUPER MEGA RARE" Hastings cover.
Toby Barrett
09-05-2011, 07:25 AM
I can't really say I understand the point in all the variant covers myself, or the reason someone would want to spend so much money purchasing them all. I got my Raphael variant, and that's all I'll need.
That said, I'm not much of a collector anyway, I'm more than satisfied collecting "the story" by just purchasing a single issue.
I'm hoping in the near future it doesn't bite IDW in the butt, I seriously do.
Jester
09-05-2011, 07:42 AM
I'm with you, the only reason I bought the 2nd Hastings copy was because A) I liked the look of the cover and B) it was probably the easiest to track down at cover price.
King Suck
09-05-2011, 07:58 AM
I know a lot of folks are glossing over the obvious but the only reason the first issue sold out was because of the variants.
I cheered then whimpered when i saw the issue 2 jetpack variant and its price. I'm a completionist but I have my limits. So far Ive either have in hand or on order every variant that has come out of issue one and two.
I'm hoping IDW backs off the gimmicks and focus on the art and story sooner then later or I could see myself dropping the floppy's all together and just waiting for TPB after the first story arc.
The hasting and the NECRA variant are ridiculously generic. Its just a boring Photoshop of the original Duncan art. :roll: At least the Jetpack exclusives have some pretty sweet artwork to tempt me with.
Jester
09-05-2011, 08:35 AM
True, and even that is creating a new "variant"...oye.
But yeah it doesn't hurt sales to have people buying 13 copies of the same book, if they can. Kinda a cheap way to do so...but what can you do. I just hope they continue to sell out despite the multiple covers...I mean how many people just when and picked up one copy just to see what the new Turtles were like...and how many won't if the story doesn't hook them. I hope that group is smaller that it might look.
And hey, don't dog the Hastings cover. Of the "generic Photoshopped Duncan art" it's the BETTER generic Photoshopped Duncan art...:D :P
IamtheNorm
09-05-2011, 08:45 AM
I must say that I will collect each variant cover that comes out, because I am a completionist and my collection wouldn't feel complete without them. However if we get to issue 10 and there are still four or five different covers then that would push my limits.
On another note do you think they have an idea of when the variant covers are going to stop? Or do you think they are watching to see how well they do, in which case we as the buyers are keeping the need of multiple covers going.
MrPliggins
09-05-2011, 09:16 AM
I can't believe variant covers are still popular today. Isn't that part of what almost killed comics in the '90s? X-men #1 anyone? I didn't know there were 12 for TMNT, and that does seem a little excessive. I used to be one who collected all the various covers back in the '90s, but now I just get one issue for the story, or better yet: get the collected book when it comes out. At least they're not doing holo-foil covers or bagging comics with a trading card.
CyberCubed
09-05-2011, 09:17 AM
I bought the Kevin Eastman cover for #1....but that was it. I doubt I am going to bother with any more variants.
Sabacooza
09-05-2011, 09:50 AM
Yes, please stop with the variants. It's a bit excessive. I mean it's okay to have two or three but twelve?
Spend more time perfecting the art and less with the variants. I know Duncan is new and God bless him for trying but I'd almost prefer Kevin's layouts in the back to what we got in the finished book.
thingy
09-05-2011, 10:59 AM
I've not read IDW Turtles yet but I imagine there will be more variants than normal until the first arc is done with. Are they doing arcs? Anyway 6 issues perhaps?
After that (if there's still interest) I imagine they'll go down to an A, a B and a Retailer Incentive with the occasional issue getting a con exclusive.
junkboy
09-05-2011, 11:23 AM
For first issue i bought A,B,C,D cause of the scene they make.
And as usual Kevin Eastman cover.
Was not going to buy Sam Kieth, did not like the cover , but cause of i like the man too much, i bought it while i could, too.
Did not try to hunt down the other covers for issue 1 and will not be buying even if i have the option from now on.
As for the upcoming issues, i do not think i will be buying as much as i did for the first issue.
since i will be buying the trades when they come also...
oldmanwinters
09-05-2011, 12:36 PM
If I have multiple options available in the comic shop, I'll just pick my favorite one... assuming the price isn't significantly different.
Donnie
09-05-2011, 02:02 PM
I bought a few Donny covers, one Mikey, the Eastman color variant, and the Sam Kieth variant.
For #2, I think I might get the Jetpack variant - it's just so awesome. But yeah, it's definitely getting costly.
Scanderson
09-05-2011, 02:10 PM
I purchased A-D, plus 2 Eastman variants. From now on, I will just get one plus any Eastman variants.
LeoNerdo
09-05-2011, 05:03 PM
I bought a Mikey cover for issue 1 and I'm happy enough with it. I liked the Eastman variant, but not enough to spend more money on it. I would have bought the gatefold cover instead of just Mikey if I could've got it for the same price, but personally there's really no incentive for me to spend a lot on variants of any single issue. With all the money spent on collecting each and every variant for just the first issue you could have bought each individual issue of the series for the next year and then some.
Venom
09-05-2011, 05:52 PM
How much can you take? If they continue with multiple variants per issue, will you keep up indefinitely? Or will you eventually say enough?
And what about your feelings toward IDW in regards to all the variants? Is there a line between satisfying the collector market and blatant greed?
I'm still on the fence about all the variants. At first I was gung-ho to get them all, but then with each new issue comes a list of variant covers.
As a company, I like IDW and understand the philosophy behind the variants, but I do feel a line should be drawn. Looking around at the industry-at-large, variants are quite common today, though.
Jephael
09-05-2011, 06:05 PM
I have the Raphael, Donatello and Michelangelo variants for #1, and as soon as I have the money I'm going to order the Leonardo one off eBay.
Powder
09-05-2011, 06:35 PM
I love variants, so of course when I first heard about them and saw a few, I was set to get them all. I never could get everything with other turtle runs so I figured this would be my chance. Then, there were 13 variants... At which point I said screw that plan. I find it quite annoying how much it would cost to attain all of them, especially considering 50% of them are LAZY cut & paste jobs of the same friggin' piece of art we've seen for the last few months. My plan has changed to getting only A. the regular cover & B. Eastman variants. I may down the line grab one or two others if there is something that really tickles my fancy, or is done by an artist I like, but other than those rare occasions, my new plan stays.
Yeah, WAY to many variants, but the count seems to drop by each issue, so by issue 8 we should be ok :D BUT the completest side of me can't help myself when it came to the variants. I managed to pick up covers A,B and D the Keith, Eastman and gate fold covers from my LCS, will have to hit up the Bay for the Jetpack covers which I think are pretty slick. The Hastings not so much, as Powder said they just look plain lazy! But as I said the TMNT completest won't be able to help myself.
Master Splinter
09-05-2011, 06:55 PM
I myself will only get 1 copy of each issue. Whatever cover is in my pull and hold will work for me. All of the other variant covers will do just fine as saved jpgs on my computer. Unless it's a different story I won't be getting it. I just can't afford it, or convince my wife.
-ms
twopinacoladas
09-05-2011, 08:02 PM
I didn't plan on buying many, I wanted the Eastman one but the shop I have been going to lately didn't have it. I got the Raph one and left it at that. I went to the shop I was getting the TMNT books from at one point my regular shop missed a few issues for whatever reason so they talked me into getting them from them and they would make sure they had them.
I went there a week later from release to see if they had any variant covers and it was 2 years since I bought a TMNT comic from them since Tales and he said he had all 4 set aside for me. The other comic place even called to try see if he had them but he had them set aside for me. Also had the eastman cover so I bought all 4. I really only wanted the Eastman one, but had the Raph one so got the rest.
I may have to keep getting my TMNT comics from them both good stores and good people. It was pretty awesome of them, I didn't think they would remember lol he said "of course your the turtle guy".
I'll add it would have to be pretty cool covers for me to buy multiple ones for the next few issues. If I can get the Eastman covers that would be good enough for me.
Abnormal Freak
09-05-2011, 08:20 PM
If I can get a cool variant at cover price, I'll get it. I plan on only getting one copy per issue and paying no more than cover price for it.
Samhain
09-05-2011, 08:24 PM
I don't really have a set ''plan'', I just buy what I like, simple as that. They can keep the variants coming, I'll buy what I like and the others can stay at the comic shop.
To many for me i was able to to get the Mike and Eastman cover. Wish i was able to get the Don cover but im happy with what i have.
STOP WITH THE VARIANT COVERS ALREADY!
RskimB
09-06-2011, 01:36 AM
i didnt realize variants were priced higher. the Jetpack #2 cover is 14.99, i think i'll still end up getting it though :ohwell:
Slap-Happy
09-06-2011, 02:00 AM
I don't think I'll be picking up any variants past the Simonson one next issue. At least not based on what I've seen.
The only reason for getting variants for me is because I think the cover art's better. I'm still gonna get both covers this month though. If there's a cover I like better, I'll get that one.
King Suck
09-06-2011, 09:14 AM
Jetpack just sent out an email saying they were the only ones to do a retail exclusive for issue 2. I like the Jetpacks the best out of all the variants but at current pricing if i get them all that's $75 + $5 an issue shipping just for the Jetpack editions. :(
From the Jetpack email -
"PS - We will also be doing exclusives for TMNT #3, #4 & the Raphael one-shot. Each one will be colored in a similar style to the corresponding original TMNT issues."
Ralph DiBernardo - Jetpack Comics
Rat A Tat
09-06-2011, 09:38 AM
Yeah, I'm technically not paying out of pocket for them, but this is getting to be a tad bit much. That Jetpacks #2 variant is outstanding, and the thought of them doing more covers of that style makes my inner fanboy squeal but my pseudo-wallet sob.
Ninja_Shoe_Repair
09-07-2011, 01:27 PM
is there a link to all the variant covers so I can be sure that I got them all? I always buy every variant since I'm a completist. I'm weird like that, I know.
Master Splinter
09-07-2011, 02:07 PM
is there a link to all the variant covers so I can be sure that I got them all? I always buy every variant since I'm a completist. I'm weird like that, I know.
www.ninjapizza.net has a great write up on the different variants.
-ms
King Suck
09-07-2011, 07:40 PM
is there a link to all the variant covers so I can be sure that I got them all? I always buy every variant since I'm a completist. I'm weird like that, I know.
http://www.ninjapizza.net and http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/ are done by fellow bordies and Ive found them to be the best ones out there.
Spitfire
09-07-2011, 07:45 PM
It's pretty out of hand. I spent 60 on my comics bin this week. 5 of the 9 books I got were turtles. My shop was nice enough to save me one of every variant they had. I got all the turtle covers, the Leo was the fold out cover, and the Eastman one.
GoongalaGoongala
09-08-2011, 12:54 PM
Having worked at a comic shop for 5 years (and still hanging out there past my employment) I can say that variants are still as popular as they once were back in the 90s. However, the companies are doing them with a little more tact nowadays as the covers are rarer and require the shops to order X copies of the regular cover (as I'm sure you all know).
Generally, the reason they are so expensive is that the shops jack up the price to match the difference in cost of what they would normally order and what they needed to order for the variant. I know that my store, with smaller books like TMNT, only order those numbers for the variant if someone expressly asks them to, and makes them aware of the price beforehand.
In the case of TMNT, the guy asking for the variants is me. I'm a fan of the different artwork, but I can certainly agree that a long stretch of 4+ variants for each issue is going to ruin my wallet.
hobcjm
09-13-2011, 08:45 AM
It sucks being a collector.
When the IDW series got announced I made a point of saying to myself "sure,
splurge a little. You've never been able to get an issue 1 before, so collect the
lot".
I regret that decision now.
As it stands, I'm missing the Eastman hand drawn cover (I shudder to think
what they'll be going for on e-bay) and the Detroit Fanfare (I'll have to e-bay
that one too).
I'm hoping that IDW stop the variants after the first arc, so issue 5 onwards
should be down to a manageable 2-3 covers.
But, without Playmates figures to collect, this is all my turtle fanboy has to
grab at the moment.
King Suck
09-14-2011, 03:06 PM
Having worked at a comic shop for 5 years (and still hanging out there past my employment) I can say that variants are still as popular as they once were back in the 90s. However, the companies are doing them with a little more tact nowadays as the covers are rarer and require the shops to order X copies of the regular cover (as I'm sure you all know).
Popular in what way? Sales, Total printed, fan popularity? Id say your statement is way off on all accounts. Even if you take away the market speculators there were still way more comic fans in the 90s then there are today.
i just looked up the sales figures to do a little caparison and the early 90s we were seeing 5 and 10 million total copies ordered by all comic shops for titles like X force issue 1, X-Men #1 and young blood #1 (the first 2 had variants). IDWs TMNT total copies sold (http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomicssales/2011/2011-08.html) for issue one were 34,803. Not even close to 90s variant sales.
Samhain
09-30-2011, 04:24 PM
As of right now, I'm getting 3 covers on average. I go for the regular, Eastman, and the Jetpack variants. I think I will do that for all of the coming issues unless other ones catch my eye.
Fantomex
10-06-2011, 03:19 PM
I personally like just getting the variant I like the best, then reading that one and storing it. I dont have the income to buy multiple copies of the same comic lol, only exception is I tend to buy 2nd printings of TMNT comics I already own the 1st printing to, as I enjoy having both covers like TMNT #7
Ninja_Shoe_Repair
10-06-2011, 03:40 PM
I'm a completist so I buy them all. I like knowing I'm one of the handful of collectors that owns every issue in great condition.
Fantomex
10-07-2011, 06:52 AM
Man you must have a great job then lol
DrVenkman
10-11-2011, 09:02 AM
I'm going with the same strategy as Powder.
Anyone up for petitioning IDW? :D
pannoni1
10-11-2011, 07:18 PM
Say what you will, but the hard truth is that this is the 5th (6th if you count Archie) series of TMNT comics, which means that they are far removed from the real, original covers that will always have a good demand. Don't expect a good return on some of these comics (unless if they are an exceptionally high grade like 9.8 or up) any time soon, as I won't expect many future fans of this series like the earlier counterparts. It's just crass consumerism where we just aren't getting any new material. I'm basically happy with what suits my needs as I always try to sell duplicates of things I have in my collections, TMNT and otherwise. It's all about style over substance. I want to enjoy comics for the STORY, not to waste extra trees!
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.