View Full Version : TMNT #2 Preview/Discussion
azrael
09-20-2011, 01:56 PM
http://issuu.com/idwpublishing/docs/tmnt-ong-02-preview?mode=window
This looks so promising, Looks like a little more Raph and Casey.
azrael
09-20-2011, 01:58 PM
Just noticed this but I believe that is the foot above the logo on the inside page.
Donnie
09-20-2011, 06:04 PM
Tomorrow is the day!
***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-20-2011, 06:41 PM
How many covers does this one have? Five?
Roseangelo
09-20-2011, 07:00 PM
How many covers does this one have? Five?
Yup, five.
http://www.ninjapizza.net/2011/09/idw-tmnt-2-variant-cover-guide.html
junkboy
09-21-2011, 03:53 AM
Ordered the regular cover and the real nice Walter Simonson cover.
Will be ordering Eastman cover for sure but still not sure about the Hembeck one.
This cover of Hembeck does look nice ( or nice enough ) but i looked at the other covers of Hembeck for upcoming issue(s) and did not like a bit.
I am a bit of completist so when i buy this cover for issue 2, i will feel as if i have to collect all other upcoming Hembeck covers even i do not like.
junkboy
09-21-2011, 10:33 AM
As i said i had ordered Covers A and B.
I buy my comics from from mycomicshop.com but Covers C and D were never added to stock.
I mean they were listed last night. then the images were uploaded ( for those who know the style of mycomicshop site just before the new comic day ) covers A and B seemd in stock but not the same thing for covers C and D
I have been awake nearly all night here in Turkey checking out. ( It was evening at that time over there US that is 7 hours or so behind us ).
I slept for 2-3 hours till the morning and when i woke up quite early they still seemed as out of stock.
There is a possibility that very very limited amounts were added and they got sold out during those 2 hours but i really do not think so. The Retailer Incentive covers ( Eastman and Kieth ) for Issue 1 were quite easy to order. Did not even camp in front of the PC. Just opened my PC on Wednesday. They were there...and i ordered.
I asked the customer service there, but got the usual, non-specific, cold reply again making me feel the guy working over there hating me for no reason :)
"If they are not in stock you can click on the "add to wish list" and you will be notified when they are in stock. blah blah blah."
So anyone who buys from mycomicshop.com and got covers C and D from there?
Jester
09-21-2011, 11:18 AM
Home with #2. Bought 4 copies. 2 for friends and 2 for me, because they had the Simonson RI cover. Just about to read the thing. Will post comments as they develop.
Toby Barrett
09-21-2011, 11:23 AM
Aw, my Hastings hadn't recieved their shipment yet. =\ But it's alright, the lady there was really nice, they're going to hold aside two copies and contact me once they get there!
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 11:47 AM
So, barring some dramatic and "odd" explanation to say otherwise....this issue confirms that the TMNT have been mutated for exactly 15 months! Yay!
Personally, I don't like this. No matter what Tom tries to say re: the "Family" aspect of this version of the TMNT being intact, I just don't buy it considering this development.
Oh, and Raphael has been homeless during this entire point and was taken away after touching the ooze. He has never even been with his "family" at this point in the story.
Jester
09-21-2011, 11:53 AM
Finished with the issue...working through the seemingly Drome heavy letter's column. I mean the 1st 3 names I seem to recognize...especially some Cubedcyber guy...I could have that wrong.
Anyway to the issue proper. The pace has certainly picked up with regards to the origin. After picking back up with Raph and Casey, we flash back to the lab, where April is alone working on a paper, as Splinter, who is very VERY VERY intelligent, tries to give her a disc about the sinister goings on at Stock-Gen. Then the Foot break in and steal the Turtles and the "Ooze", but one is injured by April with a beaker (meep meep meep) and Splinter pulls the fire alarm (What, I said he was smart.). Splinter gives chase and scratches a Foot in the face, causing him to drop the bag with the Turtles and the mutagen inside, shattering the canisters and releasing it on the 4 Turtles, their rat savior, and an mangy old alley cat. Oh, and the cat snatches a Turtle, assuming from the fact that the lab invasion was 15 months prior and Mikey mentions they've been looking for him for "like a year now." I assume this is the case...so Raph has been lost since he mutated? The crap? I mean, when he's talking to Casey he mentions he doesn't remember his name. Is it because he Splinter, who seems very capable of retaining that information couldn't tell him because he's been missing for 15 MONTHS!!, or he has amnesia. I do like that the story's pace picked up, and when the comic ended with Casey donning the hockey mask, I wanted more, but even with the continued info dump, more questions come to mind than answers. I guess I'll wait another month and see what happens, thought I don't like it. :P All in all, it's good but I still can't get over the less than 2 year time line.
Uh...1984TMNT...you might wanna spoiler tag. Not everyone's read the thing...
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 11:55 AM
Yeah, just did....my bad.
Toby Barrett
09-21-2011, 12:01 PM
Reminds me of the 80's toon origin, in a way. Personally, I don't really mind the idea. Excited to see where this goes.
Jester
09-21-2011, 12:10 PM
Yes, but in the FW series, it's not not hard to say they weren't a family...they hardly ever called each other brothers, Splinter seldom called them his sons, but rather pupils or students. Of the incarnations, the OT is probably the least familial.
Toby Barrett
09-21-2011, 12:13 PM
I dunno. I havn't read the issue myself obviously, but what I've read from your thoughts
it sounds like they feel like a family for the most part already. The fact that they're still looking for Raphael a year later is certainly a strong dedication.
Personally, I don't really care all that much about the turtles' past and origin, I'm more concerned about the adventures they're going to get into.
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 12:15 PM
True, but even that makes sense. Being devoted students and learning skills that a guy learned over his entire lifetime makes sense.
Here, the "teacher" has only been in a position to apply skills he learned for the same amount of time as the "students". It just doesn't sound right. It stinks, quite frankly....and I don't know why they decided to go down this route. I don't know any other plausible explanation other than some sort of "combat ooze" that somehow magically changed the turtles into a human like form AND all of a sudden gave them ninjitsu skills - which I think sucks. It's almost like the writers are handcuffing themselves for no reason. In this case, why would Splinter be the teacher anymore than say, Donatello?
Jester
09-21-2011, 12:31 PM
Splinter, is considerably older...I assume. Not sure this needed that, but what the heck!
Toby Barrett
09-21-2011, 12:33 PM
I would suggest that Splinter is the one who taught the turtles how to talk and everything, since he was the one injected with that intelligence pychotropic drug, but Raphael himself sort of ruins that theory. I don't suppose the turtles were injected with the same substance?
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 12:36 PM
Splinter, is considerably older...I assume. Not sure this needed that, but what the heck!
But still, he is a rat. He can't be THAT much older (what, 2-3 years at most?). Plus, even if he had learned the skills of ninjitsu as a rat (whether by watching his master ala the Mirage origin, or a super serum/ooze), he wouldn't have been able to actually perform any of it until he mutated into a humanoid like form. He would be learning and practicing at the same time as the turtles.
Yes, I know I am poking holes in the Mirage origin as well, which admittedly I always thought was dumb for this reason.
Help me guys. I REALLY want to love this new origin. I really, really, really, really do. I just can't get on board with the 15 month thing. I too, am looking forward to new adventures and not caring about the origin. Maybe in time I can look past this part of the series and just enjoy the new adventures. Right now though, it's hard to.
Jester
09-21-2011, 12:38 PM
Who really knows. We're only 2 issues in. It's all very vague. I just kinda wonder how Shredder (has to be him, I mean...Foot Ninjas) knew about the experiments being preformed by Stock-Gen. Part of me wonders if he was at one point a follower of Krang's and found out his secret and decided to work against him... Then again (as people are oft to do) Yoshi WAS a member of the Foot Clan. Maybe this was his operation. Maybe he's the mysterious "boss" that one Foot spoke of. Maybe as, I think it was Andrew, jokingly said, maybe this universes Shredder IS Hamato Yoshi. MIND BLOWN!
As for the Master Splinter thing...yeah the Mirage origin was goofy, but that was the point. It was a one off parody comic that sort of blew up. I was wondering why "master ninja" Raph was having issues with a street toughened drunken thug like Casey's dad. Now I know...he ain't been training. Which kinda makes doe an odd thing too. Leo, Mikey, and Donnie have all been training with Splinter (however that works) for a year, while Raph's been missing. 1. Where do they find the time while hunting for Raphie and 2. that puts a heck of a learning curve on Raph.
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 12:42 PM
Who really knows. We're only 2 issues in. It's all very vague. I just kinda wonder how Shredder (has to be him, I mean...Foot Ninjas) knew about the experiments being preformed by Stock-Gen. Part of me wonders if he was at one point a follower of Krang's and found out his secret and decided to work against him... Then again (as people are oft to do) Yoshi WAS a member of the Foot Clan. Maybe this was his operation. Maybe he's the mysterious "boss" that one Foot spoke of. Maybe as, I think it was Andrew, jokingly said, maybe this universes Shredder IS Hamato Yoshi. MIND BLOWN!
Very interesting take....though, that is a bit of an extreme. I'm curious what people would think of that, if hypothetically it did happen. Are there other examples in comics that have been re-booted where such a drastic spin was taken on main characters?
TomWaltz
09-21-2011, 12:44 PM
Mwahahahahahahaha!
We've only just begun...
:twink:
Toby Barrett
09-21-2011, 12:45 PM
I think the main issue is we don't know the whole story yet. I'm certain that once we have the first completed arc in our hands, the origin will be easier to swallow.
Myself, as I said, I'm willing to let it slide, my suspension of belief has always been stretched to the brink with the very concept of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. And growing up with the 80s animated series, there's not all that much that will make me go, "NO, that just doesn't work".
Jester
09-21-2011, 12:46 PM
Mwahahahahahahaha!
We've only just begun...
:twink:
Curse you Tom! But seriously you know how to make a guy read "To Be Continued..." and then scream "NOOOO!! Already? Give me MORE!!"
TomWaltz
09-21-2011, 12:49 PM
Curse you Tom! But seriously you know how to make a guy read "To Be Continued..." and then scream "NOOOO!! Already? Give me MORE!!"
Heh. Believe me, I'm just as excited for all of you to see the story unfold even more. We'll have lots of answers, I promise... but first... we want you scratching your heads and asking tons of questions.
We're evil that way.
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 12:52 PM
Heh. Believe me, I'm just as excited for all of you to see the story unfold even more. We'll have lots of answers, I promise... but first... we want you scratching your heads and asking tons of questions.
We're evil that way.
Hey Tom, you certainly have us doing that! I know you can't say ANYTHING...but, but, but....do you think most of us fans will feel satisfied when all is revealed and the dots are connected on this origin?? :tgrin:
Jester
09-21-2011, 12:52 PM
I should totally write a letter...I've never had a letter printed in a comic before...:D
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 12:57 PM
I did in volume 4, and it was awesome! I should, too. ;) Let's do it.
Jester
09-21-2011, 01:06 PM
Just did. :D
TomWaltz
09-21-2011, 01:15 PM
Hey Tom, you certainly have us doing that! I know you can't say ANYTHING...but, but, but....do you think most of us fans will feel satisfied when all is revealed and the dots are connected on this origin?? :tgrin:
Well, Kevin said something along that lines that the fans are gonna crap purple bricks (or something awesomely goofy like that).
I can't speak for anyone other than the team and myself, but we are very happy with what we are doing and have no qualms about doing it and presenting it to fans, old and new alike. I will say this -- I've felt very good about these first four issues but can honestly say that issue #5, which I just finished and turned into editor Bobby Curnow, may be some of the best comic book scripting I've ever done.
We have definitely set a path in front of us and are following it... and we couldn't be happier to have you all joining us on the journey. Big things to come!
TomWaltz
09-21-2011, 01:19 PM
Oh, and one more thing...
Wasn't that last panel with Casey in his hockey mask kick-ass?!
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 01:25 PM
Well, Kevin said something along that lines that the fans are gonna crap purple bricks (or something awesomely goofy like that).
I can't speak for anyone other than the team and myself, but we are very happy with what we are doing and have no qualms about doing it and presenting it to fans, old and new alike. I will say this -- I've felt very good about these first four issues but can honestly say that issue #5, which I just finished and turned into editor Bobby Curnow, may be some of the best comic book scripting I've ever done.
We have definitely set a path in front of us and are following it... and we couldn't be happier to have you all joining us on the journey. Big things to come!
Awesome! Thanks for sharing. I'm sure you all have a plan and things will make more sense as time goes on. To borrow a line from the current (Chris Nolan) Batman movie series re-boot, I think we all just have to "Trust Waltz". Though you have to keep in mind that we are all super eager to know the story and only get snippets one month at a time, so we will all be quick to jump to conclusions until all is revealed. Also important to note: Nolan didn't get that trust until Batman Begins was released and his genius was available for all to see. This re-boot is different in that it's being applied to a comic and will take months to see the final results, rather than 2 1/2 hours :tgrin:
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 01:26 PM
Oh, and one more thing...
Wasn't that last panel with Casey in his hockey mask kick-ass?!
It was EPIC!!! There is no denying it - that was straight up kick-ass Casey Jones!
TomWaltz
09-21-2011, 01:31 PM
It was EPIC!!! There is no denying it - that was straight up kick-ass Casey Jones!
http://p.twimg.com/AXypfcXCAAEjU66.jpg:large
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 01:33 PM
http://p.twimg.com/AXypfcXCAAEjU66.jpg:large
Hahaha!! AWESOME! <goosebumps> .....seriously :tgrin:
Master Splinter
09-21-2011, 01:51 PM
Well, Kevin said something along that lines that the fans are gonna crap purple bricks (or something awesomely goofy like that).
I can't speak for anyone other than the team and myself, but we are very happy with what we are doing and have no qualms about doing it and presenting it to fans, old and new alike. I will say this -- I've felt very good about these first four issues but can honestly say that issue #5, which I just finished and turned into editor Bobby Curnow, may be some of the best comic book scripting I've ever done.
We have definitely set a path in front of us and are following it... and we couldn't be happier to have you all joining us on the journey. Big things to come!
So essentially what you are saying is...
"If my calculations are correct, when this baby hits eighty-eight miles per hour... you're gonna see some serious sh*t."
-ms
Jester
09-21-2011, 01:58 PM
Tom and Kevin built a time machine...out of a Delorian?
***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-21-2011, 02:25 PM
I'm confused... I thought this issue also had a black and white Kevin Eastman variant cover. I saw one on ebay.
DrSpengler
09-21-2011, 02:37 PM
Here's my review at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/09/tmnt-idw-2.html)
It may not be the popular opinion, but "Casey as a teenager" is something I think has been a long-time coming.
15 year olds hanging with 25 year olds is just creeeeeeepy.
Abnormal Freak
09-21-2011, 02:46 PM
Loved this issue. Perplexing but intriguing where things are going, and I've warmed up to Duncan's art and the colors a lot more.
As for the Turtles and Splinter mutating, the Turtles being teenagers, training, all in 18 months... Well, I'll reserve judgment for when it's all revealed. :p I'm just happy to see something NEW; I don't necessarily agree with some that the origin must strictly be the same as in the original comics, and I certainly don't agree that this ruins the close-knit family relationship that the Turtles and Splinter have. He's watching over them while they're in the tank, for crying out loud; close ties can develop quickly. We're also talking animals here, and not just animals but talking bi-ped animals who know martial arts. :p They're from both worlds, obviously, thus displaying human and animal characteristics.
I enjoy how things are going with Raphael. So he hasn't been with the others since the mutation. I think it helps in explaining his anger and somewhat misguided nature that he's always had in previous incarnations. And his brashness, since he'd be learning a lot of the fighting the way that street toughs would. Which is awesome.
Masked Casey Jones on a splash page as the final page of the book really got me excited for the next issue.
Man, next month is tooooo far away.
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 02:52 PM
Hey Tom,
Out of curiosity, have you guys seen this? http://www.caseyjonesthemovie.com/
Curious on your take/reaction to it.
TomWaltz
09-21-2011, 03:12 PM
Hey Tom,
Out of curiosity, have you guys seen this? http://www.caseyjonesthemovie.com/
Curious on your take/reaction to it.
I did see the trailer but haven't had a chance to watch the whole movie yet. Looks pretty sweet, though!
Bauer536
09-21-2011, 03:14 PM
I have not picked up my issue yet. All I have to say is, "What the heck is going on?":tgrumble: I swear, someone should tell Tom Waltz that those turtles and rat April saw were not the actual TMNT we know, but a bunch of duplicates that the Shredder is trying to recreate.
I'm not feeling this with Old Hob. Old Hob has got to go. He's not as menacing as the Shredder is.:tmad:
What's the deal? It may be doing well in sales, but is it really "doing well" to the fans? I could've thought of a better origin for the turtles and Splinter. I don't really like this at all.:tmad:
I'm still buying the comic, though. I need to read it to get a feel of it.:tgrumble:
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 03:23 PM
I have not picked up my issue yet. All I have to say is, "What the heck is going on?":tgrumble: I swear, someone should tell Tom Waltz that those turtles and rat April saw were not the actual TMNT we know, but a bunch of duplicates that the Shredder is trying to recreate.
I'm not feeling this with Old Hob. Old Hob has got to go. He's not as menacing as the Shredder is.:tmad:
What's the deal? It may be doing well in sales, but is it really "doing well" to the fans? I could've thought of a better origin for the turtles and Splinter. I don't really like this at all.:tmad:
I'm still buying the comic, though. I need to read it to get a feel of it.:tgrumble:
Hey Bauer,
Like Tom and others have said before, they have a plan. We only have a few facts at this point, and even then we don't know what to make of them or if they will somehow be turned on their heads. They also said that many of the classic characters will be back, so I would bet my house that Shredder will be back. Old Hob is just a new character that they will develop more as time goes on and I think has the potential to be an awesome villain! I wouldn't worry too much at this point......wait until we have all the info and then we'll see just how creative this new origin is.
Andrew NDB
09-21-2011, 03:30 PM
I kind of don't want to even venture an opinion on the 15 months thing until we know more of the bigger picture.
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 03:39 PM
I kind of don't want to even venture an opinion on the 15 months thing until we know more of the bigger picture.
Yep - I hear ya. Obviously, there is a big part of the puzzle we aren't privy to yet which makes all of this banter until we get the missing info. Still fun to discuss and bounce reactions/thoughts off each other.
VaughnMichael
09-21-2011, 03:49 PM
I've sadly not bought any of the issues yet (no time and crazy work schedule).
But with reading what I have on here I'm not sure I really want to just yet.
I've been a fan of almost every tmnt universe but something is just rubbing me the wrong way here..it could just be because I'm seeing mostly fans gripes but it seems as if things are being done a bit carelessly.
But I do hope things even themselves out and there aren't old toon sized plot holes large enough to drive a mac truck through.:P
The art from what I see could stand to be a little more refined as well but that's just me being a nit picky nerd.:)
Andrew NDB
09-21-2011, 04:00 PM
I think the best policy for something like this is to look at it through a kind of goggles where it's like, "Things are going to be different than in [insert your favorite TMNT universe]," not necessarily, "Things are going to be better than in [insert your favorite TMNT universe]."
My only hope is that they act as a legitimate (albeit, mini) ninja clan and don't pull any punches. I'm also not interested in seeing them becoming vigilantes or superheroes. Beyond this, I'm open to anything, but if either or these two things become negated along the way then I would wish it well, but it would be becoming a thing that would no longer interest me.
If they can find a way to sell me on the "we all became trained ninja killers in a year" then so be it. Or maybe that's the whole angle with the series... you know, they're "not quite there" yet as far as their training goes, and we're kind of on board for the ride of it. Making mistakes, learning from them, that sort of thing.
DrSpengler
09-21-2011, 04:06 PM
I think this is one of those stories that's better read in trade, where you get the whole thing at once isntead of piecemeal over 4 months. It's a very modern "written for the trade" storytelling approach, so it's best viewed under those terms.
oldmanwinters
09-21-2011, 04:25 PM
Got it. Read it.
My thoughts were about like Spengs just described. By the end of it all I could think was "I guess I'll just have to wait 30 more days until I get to see something happen [that advances the story anyway]."
Also, my guess is that sales of issue #2 will be far less than issue #1, as one might expect. Last month, I went to my LCS around 5pm and they only had about 3 issues left from about 20. This week they had about 10 issues of the regular cover with one copy each of Cover B and the Kevin Eastman sketch (priced higher than regular price).
Heh. Who knew that Raphael never met his brothers after they mutated?
EDIT: Glad to see Casey Jones has been at the vigilante thing for a while. I didn't really want to see the "birth" of Casey Jones as an event that occurred after meeting up with the Turtles.
Jester
09-21-2011, 04:43 PM
I agree with Spengs and Winters....isn't that bizarre. :P
TomWaltz
09-21-2011, 04:59 PM
Loved this issue. Perplexing but intriguing where things are going, and I've warmed up to Duncan's art and the colors a lot more.
As for the Turtles and Splinter mutating, the Turtles being teenagers, training, all in 18 months... Well, I'll reserve judgment for when it's all revealed. :p I'm just happy to see something NEW; I don't necessarily agree with some that the origin must strictly be the same as in the original comics, and I certainly don't agree that this ruins the close-knit family relationship that the Turtles and Splinter have. He's watching over them while they're in the tank, for crying out loud; close ties can develop quickly. We're also talking animals here, and not just animals but talking bi-ped animals who know martial arts. :p They're from both worlds, obviously, thus displaying human and animal characteristics.
I enjoy how things are going with Raphael. So he hasn't been with the others since the mutation. I think it helps in explaining his anger and somewhat misguided nature that he's always had in previous incarnations. And his brashness, since he'd be learning a lot of the fighting the way that street toughs would. Which is awesome.
Masked Casey Jones on a splash page as the final page of the book really got me excited for the next issue.
Man, next month is tooooo far away.
No too far away for a sneak peek at the artwork for issue #3, though. This is the last thing I can show until the actual issue comes out -- enjoy!
Thanks so much for your support and interest, folks! We'll see you all next month, same Turtle time, same Turtle station!
Jester
09-21-2011, 05:21 PM
YOU MONSTER!!
Thank you. :P
oldmanwinters
09-21-2011, 05:27 PM
I like that page! Thanks for sharing, Tom!
Slap-Happy
09-21-2011, 05:40 PM
Where does Raphael even get any skills to fight Casey's dad? Are we just supposed to believe that he got those from being on the streets?
This new origin is very confusing to me. If Raphael is taken away from the turtles right after they mutate, why do the other turtles have what seems like an extremely strong attachment to him? I don't think that they'd necessarily have any memories of him when they've only really had thinking brains since he'd been taken away.
oldmanwinters
09-21-2011, 06:01 PM
So, barring some dramatic and "odd" explanation to say otherwise....this issue confirms that the TMNT have been mutated for exactly 15 months! Yay!
Personally, I don't like this. No matter what Tom tries to say re: the "Family" aspect of this version of the TMNT being intact, I just don't buy it considering this development.
Oh, and Raphael has been homeless during this entire point and was taken away after touching the ooze. He has never even been with his "family" at this point in the story.
Here, the "teacher" has only been in a position to apply skills he learned for the same amount of time as the "students". It just doesn't sound right. It stinks, quite frankly....and I don't know why they decided to go down this route. I don't know any other plausible explanation other than some sort of "combat ooze" that somehow magically changed the turtles into a human like form AND all of a sudden gave them ninjitsu skills
Where does Raphael even get any skills to fight Casey's dad? Are we just supposed to believe that he got those from being on the streets?
This new origin is very confusing to me. If Raphael is taken away from the turtles right after they mutate, why do the other turtles have what seems like an extremely strong attachment to him? I don't think that they'd necessarily have any memories of him when they've only really had thinking brains since he'd been taken away.
It seems like James A. Davis foresaw this years ago...
The mutagen gave the turtles "Ninja Powers!!!" Muhahah!!!
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a56/slimer2erasmus/Screencaps/TheGangsAllHere.jpg
ToTheNines
09-21-2011, 06:03 PM
Saving my final opinion for when this arc is tied up, but as of right now I don't like the idea of Raphael never meeting his brothers until after he's been mutated for a whole year.
Regardless, my ass will be walking through the comic shop doors next month lol.
I thought the action was great, with the ninjas and all. And I guess you'd credit the colorist for this but I LOVE the blood spatter effect being used.
Andrew NDB
09-21-2011, 06:18 PM
Saving my final opinion for when this arc is tied up, but as of right now I don't like the idea of Raphael never meeting his brothers until after he's been mutated for a whole year.
I'm not knocking it (in fact, it's a sound enough way to explain where he gets his loner tendencies and all that), but it does kinda make him the Venus DeMilo of the group, doesn't it?
Just sayin'.
Jester
09-21-2011, 06:29 PM
I'm surprised Hob didn't eat him.
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 06:29 PM
I'm not knocking it (in fact, it's a sound enough way to explain where he gets his loner tendencies and all that), but it does kinda make him the Venus DeMilo of the group, doesn't it?
Just sayin'.
Let's not go there..... :tgrumble: lol
I don't have the issue in front of me, but I believe that Splinter scratched one of the ninja's in the right eye...? If so, I think it's clear that somehow that Ninja comes into contact with the alley cat post ooze and turns into Old Hob. Would be a good reason he's pissed at Splinter.
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 06:33 PM
I'm surprised Hob didn't eat him.
I don't think the cat we see is actually Old Hob himself. See my thoughts on this above. What do you think?
AquaParade
09-21-2011, 06:33 PM
It's too much to digest right now, but I like it.
I tend to have a tough time judging something that I have been looking forward to for a long time. I need some time to let it soak in. The first arc not even being halfway done, also contributes to my confused feeling about the new series,
Although I share many of the same concerns (the bond between the brothers and Raphael, while interesting, feels awkward. They've never met Raph as mutants?) and questions as the rest of you, I can't deny that I'm engrossed in these stories, and still totally on board to see where they go. The possibility of an awkward plot point that could
leave me with an uncomfortable feeling about the series, is however, still possible:lol:
Jester
09-21-2011, 06:36 PM
Let's not go there..... :tgrumble: lol
I don't have the issue in front of me, but I believe that Splinter scratched one of the ninja's in the right eye...? If so, I think it's clear that somehow that Ninja comes into contact with the alley cat post ooze and turns into Old Hob. Would be a good reason he's pissed at Splinter.
No no a thousand times NO! I really don't want FW mutagen here. It's too wacky....gah I'm starting to sound like Andrew.
1984TMNT
09-21-2011, 06:39 PM
Hey, just throwing out ideas. Not saying it's good or not, but right now it seems like nothing is out of the realm of possibility.
Jester
09-21-2011, 06:44 PM
Something just dawned on me...we're all questioning Raphael's fighting prowess despite not training with his brothers (another point against Foot Ninja Hob is he'd have been a better fighter against Splinter...then again he took out that Foot as a normal rat.), but HOW CAN HE SPEAK ENGLISH!? I'm sorry maybe I'm tainted by my chapters of Frankenstein I've read earlier, where the monster watches the blind man and his family, but can only know their emotions and not their language, until they start teaching it to a new family member who can't speak it. I mean does he remember April and Chet speaking English, but still...they'd have heard the words but not understood them.
Shreddhead
09-21-2011, 06:47 PM
All i can say is, hell ya we get to see the hockey mask!
In the first issue, i thought casey was a little young to be "goongala-ing" all over the city. But im digging this casey-raph brotherhood. since raph doesnt know his brothers (from what i can tell) it makes sense that him and casey would form a kind of vigilante bond. This could also help flesh out raph's stubbornness and love of action/violence, having him and casey feed off of each others' love for it.
cant wait to see whats next :tgrin:
pl212
09-21-2011, 06:53 PM
Something just dawned on me...we're all questioning Raphael's fighting prowess despite not training with his brothers (another point against Foot Ninja Hob is he'd have been a better fighter against Splinter...then again he took out that Foot as a normal rat.), but HOW CAN HE SPEAK ENGLISH!? I'm sorry maybe I'm tainted by my chapters of Frankenstein I've read earlier, where the monster watches the blind man and his family, but can only know their emotions and not their language, until they start teaching it to a new family member who can't speak it. I mean does he remember April and Chet speaking English, but still...they'd have heard the words but not understood them.
Didnt they mention something about Splinter being smart or more developed, reason why he was left to move around freely within the lab.
longbowhunter
09-21-2011, 08:01 PM
Ok...somehow managed to miss issue #1 when it hit,but managed to pick it and #2 up today....all I can say is WOW!!!! I havent been this excited about anything TMNT in a long,long time. Maybe its the Eastman influence,but this feels like the Mirage books of long ago. Loving April,the boys and Splinter all being Stockmans "lab rats",Old Hob....all of it. Like a lot of you,the timeline feels kind of off(Turtles and Splinter all grew and learned Ninjitsu in under a year?) but....I dig it. A lot. Especially liking Raph being lost and his meeting up with Casey. The only disappointment I felt was in knowing this is NOT the direction Nick is going with the new toon...since they've already said that Splinter was a human and April is a lot younger...kind of irks me that we're going to have two separate TMNT continuity's running at the same time,but maybe since the comic is such a hit the folks in charge of the show will steal a few ideas and retool a couple of things. All in all,I couldnt be happier-this has recharged my love of TMNT in a big,big way:tgrin:
Floatingyeti
09-21-2011, 08:23 PM
I understand changing Casey and April's ages to teenagers, they can much easier relate to the turtles being closer in age and i suppose have a much more open mind about the crazier situations they might encounter. Heck having Casey a teenager at least matches his maturity level from the mirage books and could make his rash childish decisions and temperament more believable. And as for April at least she would be the right age for Casey.
what really bothers me:
Raphael being nearly beaten by Casey's father I can accept now knowing that he has been separated from his brothers and trainer for presumably 15 months. But why does Casey or his father for that matter not freaked out that a giant talking turtle kicked down their front door! Yes, I know that this is a comic book and that comes with a certain suspension of disbelief, but their reaction (or lack of one) makes no sense.
Unless...For the last 15 months mutations have been common place in NYC and the general population is aware mutants. Or Casey's dad was too drunk to realize and Casey is just (i don't know there really is no excuse for it)
DrSpengler
09-21-2011, 08:45 PM
I understand changing Casey and April's ages to teenagers, they can much easier relate to the turtles being closer in age and i suppose have a much more open mind about the crazier situations they might encounter. Heck having Casey a teenager at least matches his maturity level from the mirage books and could make his rash childish decisions and temperament more believable. And as for April at least she would be the right age for Casey.
what really bothers me:
Raphael being nearly beaten by Casey's father I can accept now knowing that he has been separated from his brothers and trainer for presumably 15 months. But why does Casey or his father for that matter not freaked out that a giant talking turtle kicked down their front door! Yes, I know that this is a comic book and that comes with a certain suspension of disbelief, but their reaction (or lack of one) makes no sense.
Unless...For the last 15 months mutations have been common place in NYC and the general population is aware mutants. Or Casey's dad was too drunk to realize and Casey is just (i don't know there really is no excuse for it)
I figure being drunk is why the dad didn't bat an eye about it. "Pink elephants" and all that.
As for Casey, he explained why he wasn't surprised about Raph being a giant turtle in the issue itself.
Floatingyeti
09-21-2011, 08:55 PM
I figure being drunk is why the dad didn't bat an eye about it. "Pink elephants" and all that.
As for Casey, he explained why he wasn't surprised about Raph being a giant turtle in the issue itself.
seriously?
Casey: "You met my old man. Next to him, you're a friggin' teddy bear."
That's it! That's lazy writing! I much rather think there is a better explanation.
Oh well I'm just nitpicking but it actually got me yelling at my comic book like I was watching some cheesy plot-hole filled movie. Other than that I love the comic so far. I don't want to sound like I'm bashing it, I'm just obsessively pouring over ever detail.
Andrew NDB
09-21-2011, 09:03 PM
I understand changing Casey and April's ages to teenagers, they can much easier relate to the turtles being closer in age
How, though? Even if Casey is only about 17, that'd make him 16 years older than the Turtles by the current reckoning.
We have to be missing a huge piece of the puzzle.
Floatingyeti
09-21-2011, 09:11 PM
How, though? Even if Casey is only about 17, that'd make him 16 years older than the Turtles by the current reckoning.
sorry i thought of that but the title of the book still starts with "Teenage". So i think they are meant to be teenagers in actual turtle years then after mutating they become the equivalent in human years. At that point they might age by normal (human) standards.
sigh...this is the nerdiest I've ever felt.
Andrew NDB
09-21-2011, 09:17 PM
sorry i thought of that but the title of the book still starts with "Teenage". So i think they are meant to be teenagers in actual turtle years then after mutating they become the equivalent in human years. At that point they might age by normal (human) standards.
Though by our current reckoning (and I'd wager Mr. Waltz will flip things on us in an issue or two, drop another bombshell)... even if the Turtles almost immediately morphed into human teenager equivalent bodies... that doesn't negate the fact that their sentience would only THEN be activated. They would still mentally be one year old without the addition of A) Some major science fiction, or B) A Fred Wolf mutagen scenario. I could live with A, but I'm not in love with either of those options... I'm hoping for an option C.
Andrew NDB
09-21-2011, 09:25 PM
I don't have the issue in front of me, but I believe that Splinter scratched one of the ninja's in the right eye...? If so, I think it's clear that somehow that Ninja comes into contact with the alley cat post ooze and turns into Old Hob. Would be a good reason he's pissed at Splinter.
The ninja's left eye. Hob has his eyepatch over his right eye... so the ninja ain't Old Hob.
If anything, that Foot Soldier may go on to become The Shredder in the 15 month interim and what we're looking at in #2 is a movie Splinter/Shredder origin homage.
Jester
09-21-2011, 09:55 PM
April did get one in the face...which eye was that again?
oldmanwinters
09-21-2011, 10:01 PM
The ninja's left eye. Hob has his eyepatch over his right eye... so the ninja ain't Old Hob.
If anything, that Foot Soldier may go on to become The Shredder in the 15 month interim and what we're looking at in #2 is a movie Splinter/Shredder origin homage.
That's what I was thinking. Perhaps the ninja is Saki and "The Master" is...
Nagi?
Anything is possible, I suppose!
Andrew NDB
09-21-2011, 10:06 PM
April did get one in the face...which eye was that again?
That was the right eye, same as Old Hob, but that was just a glimpse, whereas the one that Splinter scratched in the other eye/side of face was afforded much more "dramatic impact" -- I'm betting for a reason.
Powder
09-21-2011, 10:41 PM
I'm not spoilering anything. The thread title says #2 discussion. If you haven't read it then fall back.
Got myself the standard edition, looking to purchase the Eastman variant in due time.
I enjoyed this issue very much. As usual I dug the art, (even more than I did last time), I'm pleased with the increased pacing speed, I was surprised by Hobs appearance as a normal alley cat, & seein' Casey don his mask provoked a "Hell yeah!". I'm happy we got our first glance at who I assume are members of the Foot Clan, and I really dig their ninja garb. The OG Foot Soldier uniforms are imposing and awesome and classic blah blah blah, but it's really rad to see them in something more traditional and historically relevant. My only gripes are with the idea that Raph hasn't seen his family since being mutated, as Tothenines said, (but I won't dismiss it until I know the full story) & the whole secret government project schtick... But again, I'm open-minded, it could play out as something I very much so enjoy. Time will tell.
15 year olds hanging with 25 year olds is just creeeeeeepy.
I hung out with a lot of older kids at that age, and even now at 21 have friends 30 & up.
I have not picked up my issue yet. All I have to say is, "What the heck is going on?":tgrumble: I swear, someone should tell Tom Waltz that those turtles and rat April saw were not the actual TMNT we know, but a bunch of duplicates that the Shredder is trying to recreate.
I'm not feeling this with Old Hob. Old Hob has got to go. He's not as menacing as the Shredder is.:tmad:
What's the deal? It may be doing well in sales, but is it really "doing well" to the fans? I could've thought of a better origin for the turtles and Splinter. I don't really like this at all.:tmad:
I'm still buying the comic, though. I need to read it to get a feel of it.:tgrumble:
You make me cringe & facepalm simultaneously. There is no way in hell you could do better. You wanna put the turtles in high school. Please.
Saving my final opinion for when this arc is tied up, but as of right now I don't like the idea of Raphael never meeting his brothers until after he's been mutated for a whole year.
Regardless, my ass will be walking through the comic shop doors next month lol.
I thought the action was great, with the ninjas and all. And I guess you'd credit the colorist for this but I LOVE the blood spatter effect being used.
Agreed, totally.
The ninja's left eye. Hob has his eyepatch over his right eye... so the ninja ain't Old Hob.
If anything, that Foot Soldier may go on to become The Shredder in the 15 month interim and what we're looking at in #2 is a movie Splinter/Shredder origin homage.
My thoughts exactly.
Jester
09-21-2011, 10:54 PM
You make me cringe & facepalm simultaneously. There is no way in hell you could do better. You wanna put the turtles in high school. Please.
wmzyYquMS2I
I mean I have my issues..te he...with the series so far, but I'm not writing the book...and I probably couldn't do any better...heck I tried to integrate Bebop and Rocksteady, Keno, Irma and the rest of the Channel 6 crew into the 4kids universe in my one TMNT writing outing...well that and an attempt to write a Behind the Music style biography of the Turtles.
AquaParade
09-22-2011, 12:19 AM
I'm with Andrew and Powder on that one. I immediately thought Shredder, when Splinter took out that ninja's eye.
Not quite sure if that's an interesting enough of a connection for me though. Sure, I'd be pissed too if a rat took my eye, but...
Kendamu
09-22-2011, 12:48 AM
My take:
I've seen someone go from an average guy to someone who can pretty decently hold his own in a fistfight by training for only a couple hours a day for a few months. I've also personally experienced familial feelings toward people after living with them for a year or so depending on how much we have to depend on each other to get by and survive some crazy happenings.
I'd say 15 months of combat training and fighting for your life (which is only what I assume has happened so far to Leo, Mike, Don, and Splinter) can create good fighters and familial feelings.
That, and four ordinary Turtles suddenly mutating into teenagers Fred Wolf style never bothered me so this doesn't really kick me in the pants, either.
That's just me, though. Some of you already know that I'm usually pretty optimistic in the face of new stuff.
Donnie
09-22-2011, 12:57 AM
Hey Tom!
I was thrilled to see my letter printed. Thank you very much for your awesome, detailed response pertaining to what you have in store for Donny! It made me feel at ease and I can't wait to see Donatello's character expanded upon as you described.
Did anybody notice the really cool white pupils the Turtles have on cover A? It looks great. The coloring really popped out at me with this issue, it's extremely well done, my favorite scene (coloring wise) is when we see the ooze, without a doubt.
Michelangelo once again stood out to me, maybe it's because he had the most lines out of the three, or maybe it's because we see his personality the best thus far. I can't help but hear Raphael's persona coming through with him, too.
Venom
09-22-2011, 01:17 AM
For those of you who do not visit the IDW Forums, Bobby Curnow posted this noonish Wednesday:
Regarding the 'abbreviated timeline'...
...this is hard to talk about without giving anything away, but this is all part of the master plan, and as of right now MAJOR pieces of the puzzle have not been revealed. The family and ninja masters aspect are the core of this series, and we're not going to ignore it, or gloss over it in relation to the origin. Things are not completely as they seem.
Issue #5 cover, which should be revealed very soon (like in the next week), will give some clues!
BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
09-22-2011, 06:32 AM
Is there any shop that i can buy it and pay in euros? right now all shops that have for preorder are accepting only dollars. is there any shop that i can but it online with euros instead of dollars?
Jester
09-22-2011, 09:06 AM
I have a spare copy I need to unload...would Paypal allow you to pay in Euros and me get American Dollars?
Shreddhead
09-22-2011, 10:22 AM
Hey Tom!
I was thrilled to see my letter printed. Thank you very much for your awesome, detailed response pertaining to what you have in store for Donny!
Haha, as soon as i read that i was thinking you might have asked that question.
The Big Bad
09-22-2011, 11:00 AM
[The sequence of events leading to the turtles falling on the ooze is] much tighter than the original origin which, classic as it was, relied on a string of coincidences. Taking all the disparate elements of the TMNT mythos and bunching them together to create a tighter bond between them all makes for a much more cohesive universe, as opposed to, “an Utrom trucker happens to be distracted by a young Daredevil and happens to spill some ooze down a manhole where some baby turtles happened to have landed and a rat who happens to have once been owned by a ninja master happens to find them and then sometime later they happen to stumble across a mad scientist with a bunch of robots". One of the nice things about doing an “Ultimate” style retelling of an established universe as opposed to creating one from scratch is that instead of coming up with mainstay ideas piecemeal over several years, you get to gather them all up and knit them together from the beginning to avoid so much melodramatic happenstance.
I would have to disagree here with you at a fundamental level, Spengler. I feel the events set up so far (particularly those in this issue) are in no way less reliant on coincidence than the original. Had April for some reason decided not to stay up in the lab; had the people at Stockgen been half-way competent scientists and kept Splinter under lock and key; had the turtles fallen just one foot away from the ooze, then there'd be no turtles as we know them. It's a somewhat more coherent sequence of events, true, but not less contrived--two different things, I feel.
As for the issue itself...we'd better get one hell of a payoff, is all I'm saying. As it is, I feel like I'd have given up already if these weren't familiar characters; the story itself feels lacking in the punch necessary for these early issues. As a fan, however, I'm intrigued. I'm not particularly ecstatic about the new origin story--so far it seems to want to put my willing suspension of disbelief on overdrive--but I wanna see how it turns out before I make final calls.
1984TMNT
09-22-2011, 11:31 AM
The ninja's left eye. Hob has his eyepatch over his right eye... so the ninja ain't Old Hob.
If anything, that Foot Soldier may go on to become The Shredder in the 15 month interim and what we're looking at in #2 is a movie Splinter/Shredder origin homage.
Ah, good to know. So, Shredder might possibly have only 1 eye in this series? I don't think they would do that considering Hob already is cruising around with an eye patch. If anything, I think this would be a homage to Mirage and the 1st TMNT movie where Splinter tears at Saki/Nagi's face, leaving the eventual Shredder with scratch scars across his eye.
Pretty awesome! :tgrin:
1984TMNT
09-22-2011, 11:42 AM
For those of you who do not visit the IDW Forums, Bobby Curnow posted this noonish Wednesday:
Yeah, I was really shocked that Bobby responded to my issue with the abbreviated timeline and actually gave us some fat to chew on. It seriously makes me feel much better about all of our current doubt/concern about the 15-18 month thing. In the end, it sounds like it will all make sense and they will fully develop the "ninjitsu masters" / "family aspects" of the TMNT. They are taking these critical pieces of the franchise to heart. So, it seems, right now they are just messing with us a bit to throw us off.
Coola Yagami
09-22-2011, 12:00 PM
The origin keeps me catching me off guard. I suppose Hob and Raph learned how to fight on the streets but Raph wasn't down with Hob's more evil ways? I don't know... but the fact that he was seperated pre-mutation makes for some awesome interaction whenever they find him again. Someone living on his own and making it isn't gonna suddenly fall in line and accept Leo as his leader... which finally explains some of the arguing between the two.
I'm enjoying it, but would wish some better care was taken to detail. Some panels with April and the ninjas looked pretty rushed and drawn kinda sloppy.
As for trades, c'mon guys, you're spoiling yourselves. Trades were collections of comics that, back then, were also released once a month with people waiting to see what happened next... so have some patience will ya? I have been waiting for a good comic to keep me on the edge of my seat, waiting for the following issue the following month... and I have found it.
Donnie
09-22-2011, 12:12 PM
Haha, as soon as i read that i was thinking you might have asked that question.
Yes, that's me!
My first printed letter in a TMNT comic! :D
marcelangelo
09-22-2011, 12:31 PM
I'm on that same boat with you coola yamagi!...I am happy to be witnessing something that keeps me wondering about from the start...patience is needed man...these are comic books!..
Nelson
09-22-2011, 01:34 PM
What all the opinions and reviews do is compare this book to what's come before. No one seems to be evaluating this story for what it is.
Meaning, if this was not about Ninja Turtles... would you still like it? Would you still buy it?
I think this new iteration is too focused on "how can we make this fresh/different?", instead of "let's just do an amazing story". Readers care about Raphael being on his own and all that because they ALREADY know Raphael from other sources and are intrigued. This is a wrong approach by the creators, specially considering that this is a reboot.
Just my opinion.
Bauer536
09-22-2011, 01:42 PM
You make me cringe & facepalm simultaneously. There is no way in hell you could do better. You wanna put the turtles in high school. Please.
Actually Powder, that was not my idea of an origin. The high school idea is just for a dream episode with a "What if . . .?" scenario. My idea for an origin would be similar to the original, but instead of a canister of ooze falling onto the turtles, let's say some lab had an experiment gone wrong causing this green ooze to spread around the city. There would be life-threatening mutations to the humans, but human-like mutations to animals. This may lead to how certain mutants were formed like Leatherhead or Mondo Gecko. That's really my idea of an origin. Still, I want to keep the blind man being rescued by the boy's dad concept, but just with a few tweaks.
marcelangelo
09-22-2011, 02:07 PM
yep, nelson has something there, too...but if you check out the interview with kevin eastman here we get to know that this whole story arch will deliver a good story and bobby curnow let us know that major puzzle pieces are yet to come...but a part of me agrees neither the less with you here, I like to read a book that gives me a great FULL story, too, usually(not counting longer story archs), but I guess that's just it...a story arch that is important to introduce these characters to the audience from a new stand...let's wait until we read issue 4...
oldmanwinters
09-22-2011, 02:32 PM
What all the opinions and reviews do is compare this book to what's come before. No one seems to be evaluating this story for what it is.
Meaning, if this was not about Ninja Turtles... would you still like it? Would you still buy it?
I am in a similar boat with you, Nelson, but I've just decided to hold off serious evaluation until after I've read the first four issues.
However, I was hoping more would happen in the 2nd issue to advance the current plot. In this issue, all we got was Raph talking to Casey in his house and Splinter talking with the turtles in their sewer lair; the real excitement occurs through flashbacks, which excites more out of curiosity to see how we got to the present than what is going to happen in the future.
So, to quote Budd (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QMI1uQBHUpA#t=03m07s) from Kill Bill, "I guess we'll just see, won't we?"
tmntman
09-22-2011, 04:49 PM
Though by our current reckoning (and I'd wager Mr. Waltz will flip things on us in an issue or two, drop another bombshell)... even if the Turtles almost immediately morphed into human teenager equivalent bodies... that doesn't negate the fact that their sentience would only THEN be activated. They would still mentally be one year old without the addition of A) Some major science fiction, or B) A Fred Wolf mutagen scenario. I could live with A, but I'm not in love with either of those options... I'm hoping for an option C.
From what I have gathered from the first two issues, it seems implied that the turtles and Splinter retained their memories from before they were mutated. (It would be the only explanation for why they kept the names given to them by April and why they remember Raphael who seems to have been separated from them from the group since they were mutated.) This still leave the question of why Raphael has amnesia. But it does explain why they didn't need time for further mental development.
Actually, this probably makes more sense in at least one way. If you assume that mental development started at the time of mutation, then Splinter should also be at the same stage of mental development. This model explains why Splinter who was an older rat, becomes a father figure while the four turtles who may have been much younger, became the equivalent of teenagers. It also seems to be the only way to justify Old Hob being portrayed both as their oldest enemy and as their best lead on finding Raphael. They retained the memories of Raphael and the family bonds from their time in the research lab and they remember Hobs as the one who took Raphael that day.
What all the opinions and reviews do is compare this book to what's come before. No one seems to be evaluating this story for what it is.
Meaning, if this was not about Ninja Turtles... would you still like it? Would you still buy it?
I think this new iteration is too focused on "how can we make this fresh/different?", instead of "let's just do an amazing story". Readers care about Raphael being on his own and all that because they ALREADY know Raphael from other sources and are intrigued. This is a wrong approach by the creators, specially considering that this is a reboot.
Just my opinion.
That's all part of knowing your audience. Sure, if this was aimed at a completely fresh reader that had no knowledge of the TMNT mythos, it would be a fairly boring read. But that isn't the audience that they are writing for. The first two issues have obviously been structured and paced such that instead of hooking the reader by what is happening in the story, they are doing it with what isn't happening, namely the sequence of events which fans have come to expect after seeing the same basic origin repeated multiple times in the past.
I have to say that for me, it worked. Had this been just another retelling of the same origin, I would have given the issues a quick read and probably not given the issues any further thought. By changing things up, I am interested. I do want to see where this is going. I would like to see a faster pace to the story. But I can say the same thing for most comics these days.
azrael
09-22-2011, 05:28 PM
I havent been this excited for an issue up until G-MO's Batman. This issue has everything to keep you on the edge of your seat. I am so enjoying this right now.
Casey's vigilante gear is on, I cant wait to see what drives him in this series. I notice Raph isnt the best fighter like he is known for I can wait for them to reunite and get training already. I love everything about this series so far. I believe its going to be better than Mirage (sorry guys). This makes the wait for PL to finish almost unimportant.
1984TMNT
09-22-2011, 05:31 PM
That's all part of knowing your audience. Sure, if this was aimed at a completely fresh reader that had no knowledge of the TMNT mythos, it would be a fairly boring read. But that isn't the audience that they are writing for. The first two issues have obviously been structured and paced such that instead of hooking the reader by what is happening in the story, they are doing it with what isn't happening, namely the sequence of events which fans have come to expect after seeing the same basic origin repeated multiple times in the past.
I have to say that for me, it worked. Had this been just another retelling of the same origin, I would have given the issues a quick read and probably not given the issues any further thought. By changing things up, I am interested. I do want to see where this is going. I would like to see a faster pace to the story. But I can say the same thing for most comics these days.
I have to disagree here. They are absolutely writing for people new to TMNT just as much (if not more) than they are for people who have a history/knowledge of TMNT - that has been well established by the folks at IDW.
ToTheNines
09-22-2011, 06:31 PM
IGN review http://comics.ign.com/articles/119/1195939p1.html
Venom
09-22-2011, 07:36 PM
Slightly off-topic, but Jetpack has their variant for #3 up already:
http://www.jetpackcomics.com/images/excl/tmnt3.jpg
pl212
09-22-2011, 07:58 PM
Daamn, those jetpack covers are awesome!
oldmanwinters
09-22-2011, 08:43 PM
In case you guys missed it, IDW Editor Bobby Curnow said this over in the IDW forums:
Regarding the 'abbreviated timeline'...
...this is hard to talk about without giving anything away, but this is all part of the master plan, and as of right now MAJOR pieces of the puzzle have not been revealed. The family and ninja masters aspect are the core of this series, and we're not going to ignore it, or gloss over it in relation to the origin. Things are not completely as they seem.
Issue #5 cover, which should be revealed very soon (like in the next week), will give some clues!
http://forum.idwpublishing.com/viewtopic.php?p=257870#257870
He's promising that a MAJOR piece of the origin has yet to be revealed, but some clues are present in the cover to issue #5.
And wouldn't you know it?
It's been posted! (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?p=877709#post877709)
Donnie
09-22-2011, 08:45 PM
It's been posted! (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?p=877709#post877709)
I like I said in the other thread, I'm thinking it has to be some sort of Yoshi figure...of course I could be wrong.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-22-2011, 08:46 PM
I have to say, I am LOVING this series even though it would be nice to see longer issues...I felt like the thing was over just as it began. The fact that IDW posted scans of the first couple of pages on their site (which were posted in a thread on here somewhere) might have contributed to that phenomenon.
I am honestly surprised to see any complaints whatsoever, but I can understand why some of you feel disoriented at this point, being that this universe seems to exist somewhere between Mirage, 2003 Cartoon/DreamWave, and even incorporates (just subtly enough) certain elements of the Fred Wolf cartoon. It will be very interesting to see where this goes...too bad we can't get a book a week like some series run. I'd take that any day to 5-15 different covers for each book.
Lot of thoughtful hypotheticals discussed here. One thing that really interested me was this idea of Casey's dad being an abusive alcoholic-- this is interesting because Casey was portrayed that way from time to time in the Mirage series but at this point I'll be surprised if the IDW team decides to take him down that road. The IDW Casey strikes me as more of a "sweet kid," not some delusional borderline sociopath who uses not wanting to see people bullied or taken advantage of as an excuse to be a bully himself. People have said in the past that Raphael and Casey are essentially the same character, and I think maybe IDW and Kevin are trying to move past that and create a stronger distinction between them (but this really already happened in the 2003 cartoon and in the 2007 movie, so it's not really anything new).
I'm not sure what to make of Raphael at this point, but those of you who are all insisting "well he couldn't possibly know how to fight, blah blah blah" are forgetting that all animals have a fight or flight response, you either have fighting in you or you don't. Raphael has always been the most animalistic of the boys, and even when he devolved in the Mirage Series (Old Man River story arc), he was still feisty and could hold his own when threatened. He hasn't had the benefit of a mentor or family like the others, and this was a GREAT use of motif on the part of the guys writing this, because Raphael has always been dedicated to his family but always seemed to want deep down to just call his own shots and not have to worry about anyone else, so it will be interesting to see how he adjusts. Can't wait for the team-up with this universe's version of Ninjara, either.
I personally like the idea of a substance that was created in a lab funded by the military to create super-soldiers, which is ultimately what the Mutagen seems to be in this universe: a substance that not only causes high speed evolution for animals, but opens up the very things in a creature's DNA that would be beneficial if one were wanting to create super-soldiers. I thought that the first issue made General Kraang's intentions very clear. I think certain plotlines are more than obvious at this point, some of you just seem to be having a hard time seeing the obvious...that's just me. No disrespect to any of you. I just wish that everyone were 100% behind these guys but apparently that's not a realistic expectation.
ToTheNines
09-22-2011, 09:19 PM
I have to say, I am LOVING this series even though it would be nice to see longer issues...I felt like the thing was over just as it began. The fact that IDW posted scans of the first couple of pages on their site (which were posted in a thread on here somewhere) might have contributed to that phenomenon.
Yeah, I had this problem with the first issue but I'm not peeping the preview pages ever again.
Donnie
09-22-2011, 09:42 PM
Yeah, I had this problem with the first issue but I'm not peeping the preview pages ever again.
That's actually a good idea...
The Big Bad
09-22-2011, 09:50 PM
I have to disagree here. They are absolutely writing for people new to TMNT just as much (if not more) than they are for people who have a history/knowledge of TMNT - that has been well established by the folks at IDW.
What people intend to do and what they succeed in doing are two different things, though--ask the people watching the new Thundercats. I totally believe the people at IDW when they say they're writing a book for potential new fans--they sort of have to, if they want sales above the three-figure mark. In order for them to have succeed, though, then the book needs to grab your attention, even if you know nothing about the turtles, and I don't think they've succeeded. Three of the four turtles have yet to become actual characters, with less than ten pages of development between them. The closest thing to a defined antagonist, Old Hob, has a cool design but he isn't exactly setting the world on fire. Casey, until the last page, is a boring character from an after-school special, and we have yet to be given a reason to care for Raph except that we're meant to. So far, the only particularly developed characters are April and the pre-mutation Splinter, which in a cast of ten is one fifth of the current cast. The only thing about it that makes this all interesting is the fact that it's so different from what came before, which is exactly the beat you don't want to play up if the point is to attract new readers.
Yes, I realize that we're two issues into an ongoing series: I don't care. Plenty of books manage to introduce new characters and catch people's attention in the first issue. Y: The Last Man. Morning Glories, Marvel's Mystic. They make me care about the characters, the situation, or both. So far this has not done so, and "trust us, we have a plan, and it's awesome" is not a line one can give much credence to without some evidence to back it up. If getting new readers in the goal, the series needs to be more than mildly engaging and rev things up right now, not at some undetermined future date. The clock is ticking, and given the slew of new books competing for the public's attention, the book needs to be something more than OK.
Venom
09-22-2011, 10:37 PM
http://forum.idwpublishing.com/viewtopic.php?p=257870#257870
Haha, way to skim the posts dude; you're almost a day behind. :P:twink:
Toby Barrett
09-22-2011, 10:42 PM
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree Big Bad. Considering I'm VERY invested in this book, as well as the customers of all the shops I frequent, which keep selling out of issues.
Kendamu
09-22-2011, 10:48 PM
The first issue sold out. I think it's getting people's attention.
Andrew NDB
09-22-2011, 10:52 PM
My review of #2:
http://www.firstcomicsnews.com/?p=32592
Floatingyeti
09-23-2011, 12:05 AM
My review of #2:
http://www.firstcomicsnews.com/?p=32592
nice review, thanks for including my minor quibble
***First of Two Latin Kings***
09-23-2011, 12:11 AM
Yeah, I had this problem with the first issue but I'm not peeping the preview pages ever again.
I mean, I didn't read the teaser until yesterday and I picked the book up today...so it wasn't like I'd memorized it or anything. I kinda feel that even if I hadn't read the teaser the book would have felt short, but then again, we not only got a teaser for the first issue...but we got one in print.
marcelangelo
09-23-2011, 05:36 AM
wow, cjj and the big bad..I think you are both spitting out some truth here...and want it or not you could be both a great aid for idw to use for this new series of ours....well explained points there....
Scanderson
09-23-2011, 12:50 PM
I am really enjoying this series. it was nice to see that Raph was fighting like an untrained streetfighter, just throwing punches. It seems a little odd that the turtles even have any memory of Raph since he was kidnapped before any mutation. I also found it a little strange that Splinter would understand the relevance of the data CD, bring it to April, understand the significance of the two foot soldiers (why would Splinter have any reason to fear them, as he wouldn't know whether they were good or bad), and know what the fire alarm would do. I can undertand Splinter being intelligent, but this is not book smart stuff, this is common world experience stuff that Splinter would not have. I still love it.
Venom
09-23-2011, 03:45 PM
I also found it a little strange that Splinter would understand...
What if Yoshi's memory IS the human part of Splinter, somehow transferred to the rat in some experiment so that even though he's a rat, he knows who the Foot are and who they represent, and even how to help April.
Toby Barrett
09-23-2011, 04:13 PM
Mayhaps Spinter is a reincarnation of a slain Hamato Yoshi?
Jester
09-23-2011, 11:16 PM
Since Spengler won't toot his own horn, here is his review of TMNT #2:
http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/09/tmnt-idw-2.html
Slap-Happy
09-23-2011, 11:35 PM
I'm guessing that Yoshi might have something to do with the experiments that made Splinter smart, like Venom suggests.
If anything, that Foot Soldier may go on to become The Shredder in the 15 month interim and what we're looking at in #2 is a movie Splinter/Shredder origin homage.
Just read #2 again (damn it's good), had this immediate thought after the whole Splinter scratching the Foot ninja's eye and him quite possibly becoming Shredder.
"VILE RODENT"
That just reeks of Shredder-ness!!
:D
Mr._Mutant_Man
09-25-2011, 02:33 PM
So, issue #2. Pretty good, but I'm trying to wrap my head around...
The turtle's ages. In the original, they are baby turtles who have aged 15 years. I guess in this comic, they were either already pretty old when they were in the lab, or the mutagen turns them into more mature mutants.
Anyway, we finally have an explanation for why Raphael has been separated from the group.
I hope April continues to play a pretty big role in the series, as opposed to kind of being forgotten about once the original series started getting passed around to other writers.
Mr._Mutant_Man
09-25-2011, 02:59 PM
15 year olds hanging with 25 year olds is just creeeeeeepy.
15 year old ninja mutant turtles hanging out with a 25 year old vigilante. Not exactly something you can draw real life comparisons to.
I've never thought about the age difference before. Since we are talking about mutant turtles, I've never really thought about them just being teenagers, even if it is in the title. I mean, they are former un-mutated animals who have spent their whole life living in a sewer receiving ninja training, you really can't make a comparison to a normal human teenager.
marcelangelo
09-25-2011, 03:20 PM
thank you mr mutant man!!finally somebody speaks my thaughts....there is more of the fantastic in there than to even bring anything abnormal into it...
Flitcraft
09-25-2011, 06:21 PM
I totally agree with Mr. Mutant man and marcelangelo about the age difference thing. I never really though about it before and saw the turtles and Casey and April on equal grounds. It's sort of like in Happy Days how the Fonz hung around the dorky kids even though he was older.
So here's me coming in a little late to talk about issue 2. We got some major things in this one: foot ninjas, Casey with hockey mask, ooze.
I wonder if the turtle that was taken away by the kitty (I guess we can assume that it's Raph) will be reunited with the rest before they are all fully mutated (Splinter looked like he was about to clobber that cat) and then got lost again shortly afterwords. Also, when Raph told Casey he couldn't remember his name and is homeless, one of my first thoughts was that he was lying to maybe because he doesn't totally trust him yet.
I can't wait to see how they get their fighting abilities. GEE WHIZ, this is exciting! I'm already "[pooping] purple bricks."
Great first two issues!
ToTheNines
09-25-2011, 06:26 PM
I wonder if the turtle that was taken away by the kitty (I guess we can assume that it's Raph) will be reunited with the rest before they are all fully mutated (Splinter looked like he was about to clobber that cat) and then got lost again shortly afterwords.
Well that kitty has an eye to lose yet, so anything could happen.
Donnie
09-26-2011, 09:49 AM
There's definitely something peculiar about Old Hob, especially because he thinks the Turtles are "freaks" - whereas he is just as much belonging to that title. Perhaps he's more human than they are, somehow.
Also, I wonder what could have happened between Hob and Raphael - if he took him from birth, wouldn't there be a more personal relationship between them, instead of just calling him "freak"?
Cowabunga Carl
09-26-2011, 05:02 PM
So I just read both the first and second issue. Just have to say wow. I'm floored. It is amazing. I'm going to have to just let everything sink in before really posting. So far though, love it!
LeoNerdo
09-26-2011, 07:08 PM
I just got/read Issue #2. It's great fantastic wonderful stupendous!
I actually do think the artwork improved in this ish over the first, so props to Mr. Duncan. I don't have anything to add that hasn't been discussed but I am very intrigued at this point. Issue #3 really has some splainin' to do.
Spitfire
09-26-2011, 08:03 PM
Read it the other day. I ignored what I hated about the first issue and let it go so I could try and enjoy this issue. It didn't happen. There's just too many issues of logic and things I refuse to accept. Maybe when this arc is all over I'll think it's great but as of right now I more dread each issue. And yes I could not read it but I want to like it.
Donnie
09-26-2011, 09:41 PM
I actually do think the artwork improved in this ish over the first, so props to Mr. Duncan. I don't have anything to add that hasn't been discussed but I am very intrigued at this point. Issue #3 really has some splainin' to do.
I don't think it's Duncan's art that improved, I think it's the coloring job that grabbed my attention. Truly beautiful coloring...especially the ooze scene.
LeoNerdo
09-27-2011, 12:41 AM
That's true. That whole shot really pops off the page with the cat and the turtles and Splinter. The ooze really glows.
Slap-Happy
09-27-2011, 01:58 AM
Reading throughout the issue again and I just can't help but love they way Dan draws a Pre-Mutated Splinter. Even though he's extremely smart, Dan manages to make him look like nothing's going on up there, which makes me like him even more.
I specifically like the panel where Splinter scratches the ninja's face. Look at Splinter's expression. It's priceless.
BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
09-27-2011, 05:19 AM
I read it. Finaly we saw the Foot Ninjas for the first time. I noticed that these foot uniform looks like more a traditional ninja uniform than any previous incramation. Also this series is much more violent as you saw. There was blood in that Foot Ninja eye when Splinter scratch him. There was never blood in any of the tv series or the previous comics so this means that this new series will be a lot more darker and serious than 2003 series and i like it.:):) It was very small only 30 pages just like issue1. Why they can not make them longer? We have to wait 1 month for each issue and 30 pages is finished before you understand that it started. I finished reading it in less than 10 minutes. So far i like it and i cant wait to see the Shredder!
Powder
09-27-2011, 05:41 AM
There's been plenty of blood in past comics, man.
marcelangelo
09-27-2011, 05:58 AM
also, blood alone doesn't indicate that something is dark, you know?....that's like someone arguing nightmare on elmstreet is a much more darker character than frankenstein's monster...it isn't in the gore but in the stories... and the atmosphere and so forth that something grows a tone...blood alone just indicates that there is violence...
TomWaltz
09-27-2011, 01:51 PM
Another sneak peek at art from issue #3, friends!
Leo's just dying to come out and play with you all in October!
azrael
09-27-2011, 01:54 PM
Love it, got any more :D
LeoNerdo
09-27-2011, 03:12 PM
Very nice. This is when they venture out to search for Raphael I'm guessing.
TheCollector
09-28-2011, 09:29 AM
God this is sooo unfair. The only comic store by me is real small and they didn't order the issue cause the first didn't sell well for them. They said the only way they'd order more is if the demand was high and so far it isn't which means I'm not able to get the issues! I'm going crazy wanting to read this....
kool75uk1
09-28-2011, 10:16 AM
^^^^^^^^^
Have u never heard of ebay?
TheCollector
09-28-2011, 11:09 AM
^^^^^^^^^^
Have you never heard of overcharging? Every issue on there is like ten dollars. And that's without shipping. I may be desperate, but I'm not crazy.
azrael
09-28-2011, 11:17 AM
pm me we could work something out I am sure.
try mycomicshop.com
kool75uk1
09-28-2011, 11:19 AM
^^^^^^^^^^
Have you never heard of overcharging? Every issue on there is like ten dollars. And that's without shipping. I may be desperate, but I'm not crazy.
There all not $10 an issue, http://www.ebay.com/itm/220842192563?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1497.l2649
TomWaltz
09-28-2011, 01:22 PM
Love it, got any more :D
I'd show more, but when Casey puts on his mask like this, I know I'm risking a butt-kicking for revealing too much...
marcelangelo
09-28-2011, 01:40 PM
this pannel looks really good!the color job is superb, too!!
1984TMNT
09-28-2011, 02:50 PM
I'd show more, but when Casey puts on his mask like this, I know I'm risking a butt-kicking for revealing too much...
!!! :tgrin: Can't wait to see what happens next.
azrael
09-28-2011, 04:39 PM
gotta love casey
soccerstud652
09-28-2011, 06:53 PM
Has the cover for 3 been released yet? Any synopsis? Release date?
LeoNerdo
09-28-2011, 07:02 PM
Has the cover for 3 been released yet? Any synopsis? Release date?
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=34622
I believe it's October 19th. Don't quote me on that tho..
Slap-Happy
09-28-2011, 07:19 PM
I'd show more, but when Casey puts on his mask like this, I know I'm risking a butt-kicking for revealing too much...
Damn, that looks awesome!
Matches Malone
09-29-2011, 09:33 PM
I'm just glad Casey doesn't have a mullet anymore. Unless that's yet another plot twist awaiting in the midst of all the others! The fist bump was a little too "bro-ey" for my taste, but no big deal. It works in its own corny way.
Powder
09-29-2011, 10:52 PM
Truthfully I love where the series is going so far, and I don't wanna be like everyone else who nitpicks for the sake of it, but I really don't care for how Duncan draws Casey. I think maybe it's the short hair that bothers me the most.
Bauer536
09-29-2011, 10:53 PM
:tmad:GRRRR! I still didn't get the second issue yet! This is driving me crazy! My comic book store said it was sold out last week and that they would be available on Wednesday this week. They didn't pick them up yet! What the heck?!:tgrumble:
BTW: I actually like Casey's hair short.
UPDATE: You know what, maybe what happend was destiny. I don't know, but after reading the synopsis for issue number 5, I don't know where this is going again. Plus, I've looked at Michele's review on Cowabunga Corner for issue #2. This does not seem to be a good sign. I think I should stick to the new series.
Raph's Girl
10-02-2011, 01:19 AM
Finally able to read issue 2 and I gotta say....I find it rather odd. I know everything will be explained eventually but still.
Maybe Splinter learned ninja skills when he bit the foot soldier?? He fell in the ooze emediatly after so maybe this ooze has memory retentian? Then again he was super smart to begin with.
Toby Barrett
10-02-2011, 10:23 PM
I really don't understand what everyone is complaining about.
Sure, in the original Mirage series, we were told the turtles and Splinter were a family, but honestly, I never felt as if I actually saw it.
Sure, they were together, and they were a ninja clan. But a family? It was all talk and no show.
Here, we have the oppertunity to see them work towards BECOMEING a family. Sure, they've only been mutated for a year, but there's still so much time for them to strive towards being a true family, and that sounds much more engaging to me.
Jester
10-02-2011, 10:51 PM
I really don't understand what everyone is complaining about.
Sure, in the original Mirage series, we were told the turtles and Splinter were a family, but honestly, I never felt as if I actually saw it.
Sure, they were together, and they were a ninja clan. But a family? It was all talk and no show.
Here, we have the oppertunity to see them work towards BECOMEING a family. Sure, they've only been mutated for a year, but there's still so much time for them to strive towards being a true family, and that sounds much more engaging to me.
I can see where you're coming from. Though with me, it's always the FW series that seemed like less than a family to me, sicne I've not read but a handful of Mirage stories. That said, other Turtles media seemed to demonstrate the family dynamic. I think the biggest reason I love the 1st live-action movie is because of the obvious family underpinnings. And it may be the rose tinted glasses of nostalgia, but the Turtles in the Archie books seemed like a family...but again, I may be missremembering.
And don't get me started on the "We're not brothers... We're pet shop turtles born and bred on a turtle farm" spiel in Next Mutation.
Slap-Happy
10-02-2011, 11:17 PM
When I read the above post, I didn't think that the Fred Wolf series was less family oriented, but now that I think about it, you're right. Unlike most other versions of the franchise, I'm pretty sure OT was the only one where splinter didn't call the turtles his "sons."
I'd say that the movies, specifically the first one, show the strongest family bond between the characters than any other incarnation.
TheCollector
10-03-2011, 12:27 PM
Yes! Finally got the issue, and I love it.
The art, while iffy in the first issue is really starting to grow on me, especially in regards to April, who if I may say so looks great with her hair down.
Though I gotta admit, seeing April all scared and all was weird for me, seeing as I haven't seen her like that since the beginning of the 2k3 show. Though the fact that she escaped death without the turtles help shows she's destined for badassdom like some other April's.
But I gotta wonder, in the present scenes, does she know them yet? And if not how long until she does?
Venom
10-03-2011, 03:07 PM
But I gotta wonder, in the present scenes, does she know them yet? And if not how long until she does?
That's what we're along for the ride to discover too! :D
TheCollector
10-03-2011, 03:14 PM
Y'know, I had an irrational fear earlier that April wouldn't be a main character in this and is only around for the origin. I know that's nonsense, but for the split second I thought that might be possible I wanted to cry at the thought. Lol.
Powder
10-03-2011, 05:35 PM
Though April has been an integral part of the turtles lives in virtually all incarnations, I'd have no problem if she took a back seat role this time.
I mean, yeah, I'd like her to be around, but if she wasn't it wouldn't be no hair off my butt.
TheCollector
10-03-2011, 05:39 PM
^^^^^^^^^^^^
Blasphemous! April O'Neil is needed in turtles! Just look at what crap TMNT3 That **** Time Travel One, and Fast Forward were.
What did they have in common? No April. Coincidence? I think not.
Powder
10-03-2011, 05:54 PM
I'm sorry, what was that? All I could see was your opinion.
Jester
10-03-2011, 06:03 PM
^^^^^^^^^^^^
Blasphemous! April O'Neil is needed in turtles! Just look at what crap TMNT3 That **** Time Travel One, and Fast Forward were.
What did they have in common? No April. Coincidence? I think not.
Um...April was very much in TMNT 3.
Spitfire
10-03-2011, 06:04 PM
^^^^^^^^^^^^
Blasphemous! April O'Neil is needed in turtles! Just look at what crap TMNT3 That **** Time Travel One, and Fast Forward were.
What did they have in common? No April. Coincidence? I think not.
So April wasn't essential to the plot of 3 and she wasn't in most of the film? I mean she was only the entire reason they were in Japan to begin with.
TheCollector
10-03-2011, 06:23 PM
So April wasn't essential to the plot of 3 and she wasn't in most of the film? I mean she was only the entire reason they were in Japan to begin with.
Sorry, was remembering the wrong thing, she was in it, my mistake.
Fast Forward still sucked though.
Powder
10-03-2011, 06:32 PM
That's irrelevant to the topic, and also a matter of preference.
Jester
10-03-2011, 06:39 PM
Sorry, was remembering the wrong thing, she was in it, my mistake.
Fast Forward still sucked though.
>> gets a bum rap. It has some good episodes and some crappy ones. To be honest, I wish they had done the 2nd season of it than BttS.
TheCollector
10-03-2011, 06:45 PM
>> gets a bum rap. It has some good episodes and some crappy ones. To be honest, I wish they had done the 2nd season of it than BttS.
Last off topic post from me, so no one jump on me because of this please.
One thing that always irked me to no end about that season, that purple girl was in the opening credits beside Splinter for the whole season, yet she only appeared once. What the hell?
Jester
10-03-2011, 06:49 PM
Starlee? She was in a few episodes. 3 at least. Can anyone get more specific?
TheCollector
10-03-2011, 06:52 PM
Starlee? She was in a few episodes.
Was she? Guess I missed a few eps. Didn't think I had.
Spitfire
10-03-2011, 07:49 PM
She's in
Obsolete
Playtime's Over
Fly Me to the Moon
Enter the Jammerhead
Turtle X-Tinction
Jester
10-03-2011, 07:55 PM
She's in
Enter the Jammerhead
Wasn't her family's visit the subplot of that episode?
Donnie
10-03-2011, 08:01 PM
Do you guys think Old Hob will be killed off, or will he be a lingering mystery threat? He's gotta have a demise at some point...especially when Shredder comes around. Unless of course there are plans for Shredder to use Hob as a Hun type of figure. Very possible, now that I think of it...Shredder using mutants to do his dirty work...sounds familiar. Heh.
Jester
10-03-2011, 08:03 PM
I think Hob will probably be a lingering "back burner" threat, especially once Shredder and Krang become more central to the plot.
That felt so weird typing "Shredder and Krang" especially since they aren't really connected to each other (yet) in the IDW series.
Toby Barrett
10-03-2011, 09:10 PM
I certainly hope Hob doesn't go anywhere. One major issue I had with the Mirage comics was that the turtles killed all of their cool enemies...
Matches Malone
10-03-2011, 09:21 PM
I think Old Hob will be around for a while. A good villain is usually a reflection of the protagonists in some way. Everything seems to hint that he has a strong connection to the turtles' and Splinter's origin and being (presumably) of the same mutagenic accident as them he is a good example of a "what if our heroes took the route as evil mutants" scenario, as well as the fact that obviously the cat is the natural predator of the mouse, at least according to our tv/movie history.
He probably won't be a major character at first, but he could become a breakout character. Very cool design too.
CyberCubed
10-05-2011, 09:07 PM
Its obvious Old Hob will stick around as a recurring villain. They didn't include him in the origin for no reason.
I dislike the idea of Raph never seeing the others after mutation, or the fact that they've all only been mutated for 15 months.
I assume there is no big mystery here, its exactly what it is, the mutagen probably advanced their minds very quickly.
Donnie
10-06-2011, 04:54 PM
Its obvious Old Hob will stick around as a recurring villain. They didn't include him in the origin for no reason.
I dislike the idea of Raph never seeing the others after mutation, or the fact that they've all only been mutated for 15 months.
I assume there is no big mystery here, its exactly what it is, the mutagen probably advanced their minds very quickly.
Nothing's obvious yet. He can be included in the origin and be killed off - where's the rule against that?
I like that Raph was separated. It's going to give his character fresh growth and now there's an explanation for his anger and his loner obsession. Not that he needed it in Mirage - it's feasible he was angry knowing he and his brothers were the only ones of their kind. But I like how IDW is adding this extra facet to Raphael's character.
You know what they say about assuming...
CyberCubed
10-06-2011, 05:01 PM
Yeah, but if Raph never grew up with the others (even if it was only 1 year), why would he grow attached to his brothers and Splinter? Why do the other turtles even care about him? They should not have any attachment to him.
Likewise the fast mutation is kinda lame for a comic. That means the turtles either learned ninjitsu really fast, in under a year, or the mutagen immediately gave them ninja skills...which makes no sense.
Slap-Happy
10-06-2011, 05:08 PM
Likewise the fast mutation is kinda lame for a comic. That means the turtles either learned ninjitsu really fast, in under a year, or the mutagen immediately gave them ninja skills...which makes no sense.
We don't know if they have even fully learned it yet. I'm betting that they have just enough skills to beat Old Hob's gang. More than that, I don't know.
I'm perfectly fine with it, though. It's not as if this is Christopher Nolan's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Not everything has to be realistic.
CyberCubed
10-06-2011, 05:09 PM
Yeah, but its something you'd expect for a kids comic, not for something that is supposed to be aimed at teens and adults.
Jester
10-06-2011, 05:09 PM
They all lived together in the lab...and Splinter seemed to be looking over them there. Heck, he made chase after the boys were stolen. He certainly cares for them, if nothing else.
Slap-Happy
10-06-2011, 05:15 PM
How do we know that the turtles weren't just as smart as Splinter when they were mutated?
I know people who were adopted at a young age and miss siblings they had before that. If they were given the same thing Splinter was given, they'd probably go through the same thing.
TomWaltz
10-06-2011, 07:54 PM
Yeah, but its something you'd expect for a kids comic, not for something that is supposed to be aimed at teens and adults.
Ah, yes, but aren't we all just big kids, to be honest? :)
Never fear, CyberCubed, many answers coming very soon... many more surprises! The one rule I had going into this that was the most important to me was that, as much as possible, things have to make sense. That said, I never planned on revealing all the answers from the start -- this is an ongoing comic book series, after all. But, as I mention above, look for some big reveals soon.
By the way, I did try to get Raph to share a few secrets with you all, but I didn't have much luck (as you can see).
Jester
10-06-2011, 08:02 PM
And a new forum meme was born!
Bauer536
10-06-2011, 10:31 PM
How is it that Raphael is separated from his brothers, and yet he knows about the phrase, "Cowabunga" from a t-shirt? This is bogus.
Besides, I may have to agree with the review I read on Cowabunga Corner. They really are the BMNT - Baby Mutant Ninja Turtles. There is no logic here. How did they learn ninjutsu that fast? Everything is rushed.
Plus, I've been thinking about Old Hob. He's gotta die. He's not doing anything to this franchise. Let's just bring Shredder in and go from there.:tgrumble:
Jester
10-06-2011, 10:39 PM
How is it that Raphael is separated from his brothers, and yet he knows about the phrase, "Cowabunga" from a t-shirt? This is bogus.
Besides, I may have to agree with the review I read on Cowabunga Corner. They really are the BMNT - Baby Mutant Ninja Turtles. There is no logic here. How did they learn ninjutsu that fast? Everything is rushed.
Plus, I've been thinking about Old Hob. He's gotta die. He's not doing anything to this franchise. Let's just bring Shredder in and go from there.:tgrumble:
Thus spake the utmost authority on all things Turtles...
Come on man...
Powder
10-06-2011, 10:41 PM
How is it that Raphael is separated from his brothers, and yet he knows about the phrase, "Cowabunga" from a t-shirt? This is bogus.
Plus, I've been thinking about Old Hob. He's gotta die. He's not doing anything to this franchise. Let's just bring Shredder in and go from there.:tgrumble:
Point 1: Cowabunga is a word. People know words.
Point 2:
pWdd6_ZxX8c
Donnie
10-06-2011, 10:41 PM
I love everything IDW has done thus far and I am confident I will be reading their TMNT title for its entire duration, which better be long!
CyberCubed
10-06-2011, 10:46 PM
I am glad to see we will get answers in the following issues.
I also get the feeling the ninja that Splinter clawed his eye off will be returning.
Matches Malone
10-07-2011, 02:02 PM
Nothing's obvious yet. He can be included in the origin and be killed off - where's the rule against that?
I like that Raph was separated. It's going to give his character fresh growth and now there's an explanation for his anger and his loner obsession. Not that he needed it in Mirage - it's feasible he was angry knowing he and his brothers were the only ones of their kind. But I like how IDW is adding this extra facet to Raphael's character.
You know what they say about assuming...
I didn't mean to assume, just voicing my feelings of relative certainty and expressing my reasons for them. I definitely knows that anything goes and you never know! But part of the fun is speculating! And I agree with you about Raph. So far, I am enjoying everything so far. Even things that seem a bit off now has potential. We should focus on the potential good rather than the potential bad, or we won't enjoy anything!
Donnie
10-07-2011, 02:17 PM
I didn't mean to assume, just voicing my feelings of relative certainty and expressing my reasons for them. I definitely knows that anything goes and you never know! But part of the fun is speculating! And I agree with you about Raph. So far, I am enjoying everything so far. Even things that seem a bit off now has potential. We should focus on the potential good rather than the potential bad, or we won't enjoy anything!
My post was directed at CyberCubed, who said it was "obvious" that Old Hob would be sticking around for awhile.
Matches Malone
10-07-2011, 03:05 PM
My post was directed at CyberCubed, who said it was "obvious" that Old Hob would be sticking around for awhile.
That's kind of what I figured, but just wanted to be clear in case I was lumped in! One thing's certain: we all have to wait and find out on the 19th!
LeoNerdo
10-07-2011, 07:19 PM
TMNT #2 came in at #113 in Diamond's List of top comics for September and again was IDW's top book for the month. Very well done, and not surprising to see it at a lower ranking compared to August with all the things that going on in comics, especially at DC.
http://diamondcomics.com/public/default.asp?t=1&m=1&c=3&s=5&ai=113704
Mr._Mutant_Man
10-08-2011, 05:29 PM
Plus, I've been thinking about Old Hob. He's gotta die. He's not doing anything to this franchise. Let's just bring Shredder in and go from there.:tgrumble:
The series is only two issues in. I think we should be patient before we judge whether Old Hob is any good.
I'm glad they aren't revealing Shredder right away. Gives the reader something to look forward to.
Cryomancer
10-08-2011, 05:41 PM
How to explain it all! (not to be taken very seriously)
step 1) they've could have been living in the lab for quite awhile, so they are already attached to each other due to proximity and possibly biology, compounded by time spent together. for all we know they've been there for years, right?
step 2) if Splinter can learn his moves by watching and mimicking Yoshi as a rat, maybe April has been watching martial arts flicks during downtime at work and they've been paying attention. That + whatever the lab is doing to them already maybe making them smart = them understanding how those moves could work with humanoid bodies. Alternatively, maybe they were somehow spectators to combat training going on in the lab, whatever works.
Step 3) They mutate into humanoid form with already accelerated minds (or if that isn't the case, just the standard "animals aren't as dumb as we thought" thing) and spend the year learning how to use their new bodies and acting out the stuff they saw in the lab, with the eventual goal of finding their lost brother.
PAAATE
10-10-2011, 05:04 AM
Just got the second issue. I just wanna say that now when I'm able to read both issues published so far back-to-back I'm much more forgiving on the first issue :P I'm looking forward to the next issue now! :P
junkboy
10-10-2011, 05:47 AM
The only lost thing for me is...
How Splinter got into ninjitsu and trained the boys. The other 3 seems more disciplined thanks to Splinter and Raph seems like a tough boy thanks to streets .
The origin is different but the atmosphere at their lair is just the same.
In the original run, Splinter was a rat, but a rat from Japan so he stuck to those traditions. Not just martial arts but his lifestyle and mood.
If i did not miss, so far i could not see anything that gives us a hint about why Splinter chose the Japanese tradition and lifestyle after mutation in IDW-verse.
Bauer536
10-10-2011, 06:31 AM
Okay. I'm sorry guys. I just don't particularly like where most of this is going. However, I'm just grumpy because I haven't got the issue yet. Forgive me.:tsad:
junkboy
10-10-2011, 08:36 AM
I do not know if i like the new origin or IDW-verse. But when i finished issue 2, i thought , damn now i have to wait 1 month.
and when issue 3 arrives to my home i shall probably put the other comics in the post box away and quickly read TMNT issue 3.
So at this stage i can at least say that i am more than curious and enjoying this.
but i hope i shall be getting answers to such questions i asked above in the upcoming issues. Than i shall be ok i guess.
The real origin was ofc much more better, it was classic and made more sense to me. ( yeah even an ordinary rat mimicking Yoshi's style inside the cage )
But i admit that cause of this different take, i want to read the book more at this stage thanks to that surprise feeling stuff.
TheCanadiandrome
10-10-2011, 04:32 PM
going to put in an order for issue two
Matches Malone
10-13-2011, 03:33 AM
Not sure if anyone else caught this, but in the beginning of issue #1 when the narration is describing the way each must face the "torrential storm," Splinter's caption accredits him with "the bittersweet experience of centuries." Even if he and the turtles have only been mutated for fifteen months, there is definitely more going on here than we are being shown... So to those who think a little over year isn't enough to learn the ways of ninjutsu, perhaps a few centuries ought to do it. Of course, let's hope the explanation behind it is sensible but I'm definitely intrigued by the implication here and wish #3 was here already!
Redeemer
10-19-2011, 11:49 PM
Not so sure about the origin it seems to simple to me, but I noticed the mention in issue one as well about "Centuries" with splinter make me wonder if a human mind was implanted into a rat body, but I will say there tie end with April is quiet interesting loving the art though
Oh and I talked to two different comic store owners and apperently tmnt is doing really well in terms of sales!!!!!!!In fact one of them was sold out of issue 1 entirely and almost issue 2:D
TheCanadiandrome
10-20-2011, 12:24 AM
Finally got issue two, now can't wait for issue three
ToTheNines
10-20-2011, 10:56 AM
but I noticed the mention in issue one as well about "Centuries" with splinter make me wonder if a human mind was implanted into a rat body
Well Centuries means hundreds of years, so I'm assuming he meant the age old battle between rats and cats.
Matches Malone
10-20-2011, 01:48 PM
Well Centuries means hundreds of years, so I'm assuming he meant the age old battle between rats and cats.
I suppose that's possible, but you know what they say about assuming...! I don't think it's irrational to acknowledge the possibility that possessing "centuries of experience" is not necessarily the same as an ongoing feud between families, though that is in itself pretty interesting. It seems more to me like this experience is meant to be literally applied to Splinter, especially when this caption doesn't apply to both Old Hob and Splinter, just Splinter. This definitely brings up more questions than answers because it's so vague, but I just wanted to point it out so we can all keep an open mind; perhaps the origin isn't exactly what it seems, as we have been reassured by Bobby and Tom.
Cryomancer
10-21-2011, 12:15 AM
Maybe they're going with the concept of genetic memory. Perhaps the genetic memory of animals turns into wisdom when mutated into a humanoid brain, or something.
Matches Malone
10-22-2011, 02:39 AM
Maybe they're going with the concept of genetic memory. Perhaps the genetic memory of animals turns into wisdom when mutated into a humanoid brain, or something.
Could be. After all, Splinter retained all his memories before he mutated in the Mirage origin. And something that goes unmentioned too often regarding this new origin is that we have no idea what happened to the turtles and Splinter prior to being held as lab subjects. I'm willing to bet that much of the answers lie there. Ahhh! The 26th is so close yet so far!
She-ruken
10-24-2011, 02:46 AM
I am really loving the new series. I've never really read TMNT comics regularly before, and feel like they are doing the perfect job for a reboot, with strong characterizations. With all the new comics series coming out lately (DC New 52, new Buffy and Angel), I feel like TMNT has done its job to stand out as perhaps the best new series of the year. The panel pacing is really good and the storytelling clear. I loved the reveal of Casey in full get-up at the end.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.