View Full Version : New trading cards are crud.
PWDESAI
04-22-2003, 08:45 PM
Sorry, but they're just overly photoshopped pieces of crap. I jsut really started to look at them, and most of them look like they took a screen shot, made it brighter in adobe photoshop and then rushed them out to production. :(
btw, I will scan this one really horrible looking card in for you to see so my opinion has a little bit of backing, it may take me a while to do it, probably tommorow
Stefano
04-22-2003, 08:46 PM
yeah they do kinda look crappy but i think there pretty cool
Kid Icarus
04-22-2003, 08:57 PM
I just got 5 packs of them today. Their okay... It would be nice, for series two, if they used comic book art (cover art, original art, dreamwave).
for a buck fifty each though, its not bad. I want one of the Ooze cards though.
Leo656
04-22-2003, 09:01 PM
Sigh. I remember when cards were like 75 cents back in the day.
I'm not collecting the cards, I just picked up a pack for the hell of it. They're alright I guess.
Krangfan
04-23-2003, 05:51 AM
the Ooze cards are cool, I was lucky enough to get one the other day. And I think the cards look just fine.
EZweasel
04-23-2003, 09:45 AM
i bought a pack and their too expensive for what they are...a dollar 50 for 5 cards and they dont even look cool, but who knows maybe i just got a bad pack.
Roseangelo
04-23-2003, 10:27 AM
Actually, $1.49 is quite cheap compared to other card packs. $1.99/pack is usually standard.
I think the new cards are awesome. Especially the Sewer Covers and Ooze cards. I'm only missing one Sewer Cover and two Oozes.. :)
EZweasel
04-23-2003, 11:41 AM
well ill tell you the cards i got when i bought the pack....Battle shell plans,a preview card for episode 3,Donatello, smitty's junkyard, and a piece of a donatello puzzle card...i just wasnt impressed with this pack
EZweasel
04-23-2003, 11:43 AM
Oh yea,, No 1.50 isnt bad for a pack with 10 or more cards, but for only 5???
HorseTechie
04-23-2003, 11:51 AM
Hrmm.. I'm not much of a card collecter. Haven't gotten these new cards yet either.
But I'm not too surprised if they say the quality is so-so. The first movie ones weren't the best either, nor were the orginal cartoon. Of course, my biggest complaint with those was the poor logic. In the TMNT1 set, there is a clear shot of Leo. You can see his swords and everything. But they say it's Don on the back. Oy! :lol: That's not the only card that they made goofs like that.
Eye of Sarnath
04-23-2003, 01:07 PM
Well, as far as cards go, I think they're okay. I'm not really big on cards or anything though, so I have nothing to compare them to. I like them anyway.
PWDESAI
04-23-2003, 05:10 PM
I'll scan this one inparticular card some time, i can still try to do it tonight. I got a donatello ooze card.
SavantiRomero
04-24-2003, 02:53 AM
My biggest gripe is the over use of very limited artwork on everything.
The TMNT merchandising ball is already deflating and they haven't even started yet really.
Doesn't anyone else get sick and tired of being sold 50 different items with only 3 unique peices of art?
It's the same principal as if they drew one turtle in a specific stance and just changed the weapon in the hand and tried to sell cups, napkins, cards, shirts, air freshiners, playing cards, lighters, watches, etc etc all with the same images.
When I buy TMNT memorabilia I expect to be buying different artwork on different items.
It seems to me like Mirage Studios has lost the vision when it comes to mass marketing.
I personally won't be buying alot repeat artwork this go around. I would love to support the cuase, but the cuase has to support my wants also.
I don't think it's so much that the cards suck, but that the artwork is overused and they need to comission more.
I mean comon, Look at the gallery for 2003 Turtles here
http://www.ninjaturtles.com/html/gallery.htm
Then look at the merchandise from the trade show here
http://www.ninjaturtles.com/html/merch.html
Same artwork, just different items. More variety would help, tremendously.
Eye of Sarnath
04-24-2003, 05:28 AM
You mean you weren't expecting that? If you look at the merchandise for the old series, you'll see that they had pictures that they used again... and again... and again...
Karpo_007
04-24-2003, 06:23 AM
And it is 4kids that does the licensing and merchadice, not Mirage. Im not reallu intrest in any, maybe a poster would be cool. But the toys are selling very fast, so it seems kids do like the TMNT merchadice. It was made for them in the first place.
Eye of Sarnath
04-24-2003, 06:31 AM
Yeah. So ya'll find something worth complaining about for once, okay?
Metal Head
04-24-2003, 06:32 AM
I collect some non sport cards as well as baseball cards.....so I might be in the minority here.....but I can't wait to pick up some of these cards. I enjoy piecing together sets of cards......
Karpo_007
04-24-2003, 06:35 AM
I have never really understood the trading cards. I think it is just another way to get money from kids. Things like Pokemon really made the "collect them all" go over board.
PWDESAI
04-24-2003, 07:21 AM
If you didn't notice already, almost every single card is taken from the first episode.
Since I don't feel like uploading the pics to my ftp to link them here i just submitted them onto my forums. I really wish thetechnodrome had this ability :|
http://forums.theninjaturtles.com/showthread.php?s=&postid=5081#post5081
There's a huge difference. Can you tell which is my pic and which is the card ;)
Metal Head
04-24-2003, 08:21 AM
I have never really understood the trading cards. I think it is just another way to get money from kids. Things like Pokemon really made the "collect them all" go over board.
Actually, sports cards originally were aimed at adults. In the late 1800's tobacco companies inserted all kinds of different sports cards in packages of tobacco. I used to own an 1887 Allen and Ginter boxing card.......but sold it years ago unfortunatly.
It wasn't until the early 40's that ball cards were projected towards kids.In the late 50's to early 60's non sport cards started popping up with all sorts of characters on them...wether it was Daniel Boone,Dick Tracy or Star Trek.......these cards drew in youngsters based on the images really.Kids had really been captivated previously though with the fun of collecting baseball cards of thier favorite players.......so it wasn't really a marketing ploy as it would seem originally.....
If you want to talk marketing ploy then let's discuss Pokemon,YuGiOh (sp?) and other related stuff......those types of cards are nothing more than a bottomless black hole for parents money to be sucked into ;) :lol:
SavantiRomero
04-24-2003, 09:14 AM
You mean you weren't expecting that? If you look at the merchandise for the old series, you'll see that they had pictures that they used again... and again... and again...
Not to the degree we have here, by any means.
But I can't truley prove that until I get home and can pull my collection out of storage. Going to be some long nights with the digital camera and scanner ahead I can see that for sure.
I'm also not limiting it to the cartoon either. I'm talking about ALL merchandising going on right now.
You have 3 major items.
The comic book (we have at least 2 comics now, one to be relaesed soon)
The TMNT Statuetes (we have 1 statue and another almost through production)
The Cartoon (this is the biggest portion right now and has the least variety)
The cartoon is the problem here. ALL the new merchandise is based solely off it.
All PRE 1996 TMNT merchandising was broken between the MANY seasons of the cartoon, the comic book (BOTH volumes and Archie), the movies, seperately commisioned works by both mirage and non-mirage artists, and there was alot more variety.
YES the merchandising is just getting off now and is in the early stages, but unless they add more variety there won't be much merchandising in the future. People just won't buy. I think this better explains why people don't like the cards. ALL cards are done in some form of media application now days. So that's not the limitation here. The limitation is the fact that most people already own the artwork on the cards before they even buy them.
How many people here can honestly say that you enjoy dumping money on something you already own? Unless it can change in some way.
Karpo_007
04-24-2003, 09:54 AM
Why would we need so much of TMNT merchadice? I can't see any reason. We want to have the show in the air, not TMNT cerials or tooth paste. Like said before, the toys are selling very well, and second season for the cartoon is almost surely coming. We do no need TMNT merchandicing go over board again.
Eye of Sarnath
04-24-2003, 10:01 AM
The cartoon is the problem here. ALL the new merchandise is based solely off it.
As opposed to what?
I mean, what else would it be based off of? You guys crack me up.
Karpo, you wonder why there's so much TMNT merchandise?
$$$$$
SavantiRomero
04-24-2003, 10:27 AM
Maybe you have short term memory, just don't get it or didn't bother to read my whole post. I don't know.
There is still comic art available, there's also the possability to commission new artwork to be used. They didn't have a problem with it in past, there shouldn't be one now.
And I wasn't referring to flooding the market with mass merchandising either.
They already have merchandise being produced right now, however they are reusing about a total of 12 images for everything. NO variety. I'm not asking for toothpaste, play money, clothing, food, juices, colorbooks, shaving creame, cookie cutters, cake pans, knitting books, etc. I'm asking that they throw in some more variety of artwork on the items they are producing.
Again the problem is they are only using a VERY limited assortment of images. It's the same turtle in the same pose on every item. Lets get some different poses, some different scenes, lets get creative like it "used" to be.
Karpo_007
04-24-2003, 10:53 AM
Well it seems the company who produced the trading cards choosed to do it the easy way. You shouldn't blame Mirage or 4kids for it, well of course 4kids has probably seen and aproved them... But these are targeted at kids, maybe they don't care.
Metal Head
04-24-2003, 11:18 AM
The thing to remember too is how many episodes of the cartoon is there right now? 10? How many of the new run comics are out? How can you expect a mountain of new art with a cartoon series that hasn't even been out for 3 months yet?
Let's all just be patient and wait for more stuff to trickle out....AND be thankfull that we can even BUY TMNT stuff right now ;)
Eye of Sarnath
04-24-2003, 11:40 AM
Why are they using the same artwork? Because they can most likely get it relatively cheaply (as opposed to getting all new artwork). They want to make a profit here, remember?
Roseangelo
04-24-2003, 12:28 PM
Sheesh.. this is such a rediculous argument.
See, there's this thing in the retail business called BRAND RECOGNITION. All the TMNT stuff is SUPPOSE to look the same. That way when people see the yellow/orange/green packaging they've come to associate with the new TMNT toys they'll take a closer look at it and then possibly buy some of it. This is the case with all brands. Walk down the action figure isle and see what's next to the TMNT. There's He-Man, Hulk, Power Rangers, Star Wars.. and each of these has its own distinct look.
Like it or not, it is only the new cartoon that is being marketed, NOT the comic books. The comic books are just comic books, and that's it.
So yes, please, find something worthwhile to complain about..
Brodie
04-24-2003, 01:07 PM
I bought 2 packs at the comic shop, expecting some well done cards, like the old Spidey cards with the Holograms, see through cards, foils, etc., but I got ****. They don't even look as detailed as they do in the cartoon. It's like someone took a shotty picture while watching TV.
PWDESAI
04-24-2003, 02:45 PM
not just that brodie, they also photoshopped it to death. Did anyone look at the link?
SavantiRomero
04-25-2003, 02:18 AM
Well if it's not important enough to you to argue about, don't. It is important enough to me.
Profit, Cheep, I call b**l***t. Anyone who's studied marketing enough and been successful in real life using it's applications will tell you that you must have variety. People get sick of the same old stuff. If it isn't neccessary for survival, people want new variations.
As for brand recognition, please. Look the same yes, be identical no. Even the pills berry dough boy changes his position and what he's doing on different types of cookie dough packages in the refridgerated section of your local grociery store. If he didn't you wouldn't be able to tell the difference between chocolate chip and peanutbutter dough rolls. But it is the dough boy on each package. Just like it's the turtles on each item, or even their supporting characters.
Happy that I can at least buy TMNT merchandise? Why? I can still buy stuff off of ebay, Yahoo auctions, and several other sites that have a few items I don't from the original merchandising era.
This is a legitamite gripe. Designed for kids. True and not true. The whole concept was that the show and the marketing would aspire to children and young adults, not just children. (Young adults covers Teenagers - early 20's).
Dooney's artwork is nice, and I'm sure we all love to look at it, but variety is going to be neccessary here if they intend to make anything marginally comparable to what this franchise is capable of.
Karpo_007
04-25-2003, 04:53 AM
Well Like I said before, to me only the cartoon matters. And the TMNT franchice has been proven succesfull again. And since it now seems 2nd season is coming, weather or not they took the easy way in doing the cards doesn't really matter.
Metal Head
04-25-2003, 06:57 AM
[quote="SavantiRomero"]
Happy that I can at least buy TMNT merchandise? Why? I can still buy stuff off of ebay, Yahoo auctions, and several other sites that have a few items I don't from the original merchandising era.
quote]
Man, you totally missed my point.......I'm a vintage collector also....and I'm buying older stuff from auctions also.......but man, are you not excited to see new TMNT on the shelves? True, I could be content with the vintage TMNT stuff.....but I'm thrilled that TMNT is back on store shelves for a new generation also.
I guess some people will complain about anything and are never content. :roll:
SavantiRomero
04-25-2003, 07:50 AM
Happy to see new stuff, yes. Content, more than ever.
This thread is about the card series sucking.
I'm bringing to the fore a reason why so many people percieve this to be true.
I take it a step further and explain that if they don't start adding variation to the equation, this new merchandising scheme is going to go down hill and may cost us, the fans, another long wait until we get to see the TMNT resurface again. If it would.
Maybe I like to look things a little more in depth. Maybe I like to actually debate.
I personally think it would SUCK to see the show canceled, the merchandising to stop, and for the comic book be pushed back to a quarterly or even a one issue per 4 month period item.
But that's very well what could happen if the merchandising doesn't go smoothly from the start.
And yes I this is my opinion of the situtation. But I'm also willing to back it up. :)
Karpo_007
04-25-2003, 07:54 AM
You talk like the whole frabchice would be failing... When in reality the only thing that you THINK is failing are the trading cards. You have any idea how the toys sell? And do you have any information how kids have taken the trading cards? Even if the cards would fail, that wouldn't really affect anything.
Metal Head
04-25-2003, 08:01 AM
Karpo, I agree.......
See, the truth is, there have been many succesful toy lines and movies in the past that also had trading cards done as a tie in......some of those cards fared well....others went down in flames....did it reflect on the entire product line? No.......I really don't think that the entire line hinges on a card set........look at all of the vintage TMNT......loads of that stuff was repetitive....yet people at that stuff up...........
SavantiRomero
04-25-2003, 09:42 AM
Nope I'm not just talking about the cards, that's what I referred to when I said I took it one step further.
If you look at the backpacks and the marker color sets, and all the other merchandise in those pics I linked above ^ you'll notice that every single image is taken from the set of Dooney art posted on the 2003 TMNT Gallery.
I didn't say that the franchise "WILL" Fail, I said it could. I also said that it could becuase of no variety.
As to seeing how "children" are reacting to the cards and toyline, no I can't see it. I'm in Bosnia. I'm not in the US or some 1st world country where these items are being mainstreemed.
I'm pretty sure that some kids are pretty happy with the cards, but then again, they don't worry about mainstreem marketing. They don't worry about the show's ratings. And they most certainly do not pay attention to how well the toys are selling or not.
As to the toys selling, I happen to know they are selling like hot cakes. I couldn't find a store with a single figure or vehicle in two states while I was going through mobalization training to come here, which was the time that the toys first hit stores.
Ebay has the new toys all over the place. And from what I see on sites like Wal~mart.com, KBtoys.com and toysRus.com they are all over the place.
Just remember the focus of this post was the cards and how crappy they are. I tried to keep that focus even though I tried to step the conversation up a notch.
Also don't forget that right now the TMNT aren't being marketed to children only. And the guys calculating sales and profits are counting on MORE than the childrens money as income. If these bean counters start pulling back and writing bad reports, the guys pulling the strings, will look at canceling whole products and that could hinder the re-emergence of the TMNT into society.
That and the quality of the product will also be a factor since many people won't buy subpar quality products. :/
Karpo_007
04-25-2003, 09:52 AM
Of course the franchice could fail, but that seems very unlikely. Because toys sell like they do, Im pretty sure they will make profit out of the other licenced products aswell. But Im not conern if the TMNT will become massmarketed again or not, If new show continues I will be happy. And right now it seems we don't have anything to worry about.
Tokka-B
04-25-2003, 10:36 AM
Well, I don't know about having trading cards that you can't really do anything with besides look at them. They had this mistake when the old cartoon was airing as well. I used to be a card collector, but that was for magic the gathering which is a trading card game, something where you can collect, trade, and use to play games with...it sounded practical for $2.5 to get 15 cards that you could use in so many ways. I stopped collecting though when the collecting got me addicted they were pretty much vacuuming up my bills...the game got stupid too. I think most trading card games are stupid, mostly pokemon and stuff, but my main point is TMNT should never have released cards to begin with...if I wanted to look at something I collect, it better be big like a poster, no 2 by 4's...
SavantiRomero
04-25-2003, 12:24 PM
:/ you don't get it.
Fox controls what's aired on their network like ALL networks. Fox has proven time and again that if something doesn't bring in the money, IE a show that sells commercial slots, it won't air long.
You sell commercial slots by how well a product sells. If the cards don't sell, and all that junk they have in those pictures on the mirage site don't sell, the company is going to start thinking that nothing but toys will sell. Do you realize what that will do? They'll start thinking the show isn't worth airing becuase it "Could" bring in more money if you could sell all the other merchandise. But it won't becuase the only thing selling like hotcakes right now is toys.
If Fox thinks for any minute that they can't sell commercial space during the TMNT cartoon, they'll stop airing it. Who does Mirage have in line to air the show if Fox can's it? Can they even air it on a different station? Probably not, becuase Fox probably owns rights to the cartoon as well as the production company.
Fox can do to the show what they did to NT:TNM. NT:TNM had good ratings, but NT:TNM didn't have much else selling. Not many companies tried to buy commercial time slots during the show. The ratings were high, but the sales weren't. Those toys also sold fiarly quickly.
I personally WANT the show to continue. And thanks to the generosity of another fan, I've seen 3 episodes, hopefully will see another 6 eps soon :)
It's a good show, I want to see it flourish, but you have to realize that the success of just the show or just the toy line is NOT going to stabalize either. The companies want more, and the heritage that the TMNT Empire has is what will decide what is failure and what is success.
Karpo_007
04-25-2003, 02:26 PM
When do you understand it is not up to Fox? On some areas Fox box is not even airing on Fox, but UPN. 4kids owns it and has total controll over it. How many times do have to repeat myseelf... FOX or Osama Bin Laden cannot cancell the show. 4kids can, and I doubt it will cancelling number one show anytime soon.
SavantiRomero
04-25-2003, 02:38 PM
I've sent a few emails out, to the parties in question and should be getting some information back soon to confirm the validity of your claim.
For ALL of our sake I hope your right. I'd hate to see the new show canceled.
Karpo_007
04-25-2003, 02:41 PM
Good, but a quick net search would have given you the same info.
SavantiRomero
04-25-2003, 02:48 PM
I don't trust quick net searches. I will verify through Mirage, 4 Kids and Fox. I don't expect a response from fox, but I was getting pretty good responses from mirage and 4 kids before I was mobalized.
Karpo_007
04-25-2003, 02:51 PM
Here is what I came up with the first search in google:
In January 2002, 4Kids Entertainment entered into a multi-year agreement with Fox Broadcasting to lease the television network's Saturday morning programming block. 4Kids launched the all-new kids broadcast network - the Fox Box - on September 14, 2002.
Now you should belive me when I say that Fox does not controll Fox box, but of course when "multi-year" contract ends, and Fox decides not to renew the contract, that could be possible. But then 4kids could just buy the time elsewhere.
SavantiRomero
04-28-2003, 10:36 AM
Sorry but I'll never trust what's published on the web as fact. I'll take it with a grain of salt.
However, here is what Dan Berger had to say in response to my inquiry.
__________________________________________________ __________________
Howdy,
> Does 4 Kids retain those rights as well or does one of the networks
> retain those rights?
4Kids retains the broadcasting rights.
They've leased the Saturday morning time slot from Fox for (I think) 5
years, so they can air what they choose to, and they can try to get the
shows they own on other networks if they wish.
> I ask becuase I'm becoming fond of the animated series, much like I
> was getting used to NT:TNM when it came out. I distinctly remember Fox
> canceling the show even though it was one of the highest rating shows
> on it's channel.
Yeah... we were pretty stunned when that happened. :(
Thanks for writing!
Cheers!
Dan Berger
Mirage Studios' Official Web Dude
http://www.ninjaturtles.com
__________________________________________________ __________________
I'm still waiting for a response back from Fox (HAHAHAHA Yeah right) and a response from 4 kids.
Even though this is good news, I'm not going to discount the possability that 4 kids will look at the $$ figures and not just the ratings. After all show biz is all about the benjamens.
Karpo_007
04-28-2003, 11:05 AM
If you font trust official 4kids site where I got that info, then I can't help you. Good luck with the emails.
SavantiRomero
04-28-2003, 02:01 PM
Pardon me, but you stated your official source as "Google" not http://www.4kidsentertainment.com.
I seem to recall a "TMNT Movie being done by John Woo" being blown way out of proportion a while back when Mirage was considering doing the 4th movie. This was totally rumor and speculation, which was totally way off the truth.
I'll let you know how the emails come out.
You also need to understand that many times a company may display symantics on their site to gain trust of the visitors.
Lets look at the NVidia.com and ATItech.com sites.
BOTH claim to be the leading graphics card designer. Both claim to have the fastest card available. So far from all articles considred the ATI Radeon 9700 Pro is still the absolute fastes card on the market overall. The Nvidia has a card that can surpass the 9700 in certain aspects and then again the ATI have a card that also surpases the Nvidia card in certain aspects. Both are right, but the truth remains, the ATI Radeon 9700 is the best card on the market for outright power, color and performance.
I'm not saying that 4kids is misrepresenting information on their site, however I am saying I'm going to double check before I get a sense of security. You don't have to beleive in conspiracy's but sometimes double checking can learn you alot of valuable information.
Tetsu Deinonychus
04-28-2003, 09:55 PM
What about the simple concept of quality product? Anything worth making is worth making right!
SavantiRomero
04-29-2003, 04:35 AM
True, and in my example above BOTH ATI and NVIDIA have QUALITY products. Each has a different method and application on how they render different technologies on the cards, which is where the difference comes in.
ATI has poor driver support but a powerful card, NVidia has a powerful card that is slightly outmatched by the ATI competitor but have excellant driver support.
But quality of product isn't what I'm trying to point out, yet at the same time it is.
It is becuase I want the quality artwork, I want quality merchandise, I want something I'm proud to spend my money on. So far the show and the toys are quality, but nothing else really is. Not to the same standard.
But it is what I'm trying to point out becuase without the quality, the products will fail, which can cuase companies to lose interest in the franchise, which in turn will be a deciding factor on if the show continues or not. $$$$.
If it's not quality the people won't buy, if they don't buy, you have no demand, no demand, no $$$ and therefore no more product.
Karpo_007
04-29-2003, 08:22 AM
Guess I should have told it was the official site. Well that info is as trustworthy as it gets, fox cannot cancell the show, and thats what is important.
As for merchandice, Some posters would be cool to see.
Twisted_Slash
05-10-2003, 12:17 AM
Savanti here's some advice: Take a friggin laxative, sit back, and enjoy the show!! You're gonna have a friggin breakdown if you keep this up!! Ninja Turtles are a beautiful thing made for ENJOYMENT. So just relax and ENJOY!! I personally was dissapointed with the cards too. Mikey's card looks like he's 50 pounds over weight. The thing is that you should enjoy this stuff while it lasts, dont spoil it with endlessly bitter debates with fellow fans.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.