PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #6 Synopsis


Pages : 1 [2]

TomWaltz
01-25-2012, 03:15 PM
Or as he's known, the "Hey Dude Mikey" version of Michelangelo. Tom has been pretty outspoken about exploring multiple sides of the TMNT so I'm not too worried... but still, it does kind of give me pause that so far, that's pretty much the only side we've seen of Michelangelo.

Mikey says, "Let me introduce you to my little spinny friend, DUDE!"

:tgrin:

(Another sneak peek image from issue #8, by the way. Shhh... don't tell Bobby.)

Donnie
01-25-2012, 03:53 PM
Mikey says, "Let me introduce you to my little spinny friend, DUDE!"

:tgrin:

(Another sneak peek image from issue #8, by the way. Shhh... don't tell Bobby.)

Awesome! Thanks for the sneak, Tom :)

MattLawrence
01-25-2012, 04:07 PM
what sneak peak ?

marcelangelo
01-25-2012, 04:07 PM
no problemo baby!;)...oh oh-mike sees something really terrifying off camera there...wonder what'll it be..

marcelangelo
01-25-2012, 04:35 PM
hey!nobody commented so far on who this secret guy might be that the police officer in michelangelo micro was reffering to all the time...someone with an afinity for radiated material..I know it sounds obvious, but who do y'all think it is?I immediatelly thought of general krang...but baxter(as a man working on krang's interest of course) could be possible, too...or the shredder?...in mirage he was this feared underworld boss leading his foot division through new york's world of crime...

Abnormal Freak
01-25-2012, 04:42 PM
(Apologies if this was brought up in a spoiler or something; I just did a page search for the past few pages and came up with nothing.)

What's with Donatello's line about, "My French isn't as good as my HTML"? HTML's pretty basic, so if Don's such a genius, why isn't he studying other coding languages? :D And...well, why HTML at all? That would imply website work. Is he making fan sites or something? ;) I thought he'd be coding programs or something.

Cowabunga Carl
01-25-2012, 05:07 PM
So I just got done reading issue 6 and have to say another great issue. It's awesome to see an overreaching story arch and then the smaller arches inside it. Looking forward to the Baxter/Hob relationship. Also love the cover for the next issue, can't wait to learn some more about General Krang.

AquaParade
01-25-2012, 05:34 PM
I also enjoyed the issue. No surprise there at this point.

After the intensity of issue 5, sure it felt like a bit of a slowdown, but by now we know Tom will end up delivering the goods by the end of the arc, as everything comes together. Right?

Love the tension between the brothers. Love it.

Cowabunga Carl
01-25-2012, 05:41 PM
Trying to figure how issue 5, Raph Mico, Mikey Micro, and 6 fit together. Has there been any word on when those issues take place?

Toby Barrett
01-25-2012, 05:44 PM
I assume exactly in the order you've listed.

Raphael takes place after issue 5, which takes place sometime during the Christmas season. Michelangelo takes place on New Years Eve, which would happen sometime after Christmas. And the solicitation of TMNT #6 mentions it's a brand new year.

DrSpengler
01-25-2012, 07:53 PM
I assume exactly in the order you've listed.

Raphael takes place after issue 5, which takes place sometime during the Christmas season. Michelangelo takes place on New Years Eve, which would happen sometime after Christmas. And the solicitation of TMNT #6 mentions it's a brand new year.

Yeah, that's how I figured it, too. Seems intuitive enough, barring any contradictions once Donatello #1 comes out or something.


Didn't have time to post my review on TMNT Entity before I had to leave for work, but I'll have it up by 10pm tonight. Good issue even if it was mostly set-up. I was just happy to have the Turtles interacting with each other in a group for a change.

Rooish
01-25-2012, 08:34 PM
Yeah, Tom, you should know by now--fans have no patience for set-up!

I'm kidding, because I am fine with the pacing after TMNT Vol. 4. Even then I was willing to enjoy the grand story being set up.

I love this series, but I want to ramble about minor gripes!

I like your interpretation of the characters to a degree, Tom... but it is odd for Leo and Don to be bickering. Or, at least, for that to be their only real interaction thus far. I hope this isn't "instead" of Raph's and Leo's conflicts. I mean, those are basically canon. A new interpretation of it is cool, but it has to be there to some degree!

Actually I'm a little surprised at how much they are getting at each other, in general. Leo says that all Mike does is eat pizza and play video games, Don and Leo pick fights, Raph whines about Leo and Don. I guess it's "realistic" but I do want to see them as a more solid, caring team!

Hob: is growing on me.

Casey: Has he never seen a girl? What's with the "woah" when he encounters April? ;)

This issue was pretty cool, and I love the mouser design!

Jester
01-25-2012, 08:51 PM
I liked the issue. My only gripe is I wish the parkour ninja had been someone we knew a little better. Loved the Turtles interaction, the Casey/April plot thread I was kinda "Really?" about last time is growing on me. Like the idea that the Mousers have military application as IED disposal robots. The M.O.U.S.E.R acronym seems a tad forced, but whatever. :P
Other than that, a great setup issue, can't wait to see how the arc progresses. Now that the origin is, for the most part, out of the way, we can get down to business.

DrSpengler
01-25-2012, 08:55 PM
My review of TMNT #6 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/01/tmnt-idw-6.html)

I felt it was a good issue with only a few irritations that got under my skin. The bandana coloring confusion is something IDW's copy editors need to pay better attention to, as it is a legitimate downside to the multi-colors over the all-reds. Also, I'm really sick of the cliche' cliffhanger splash page that "reveals" something painfully obvious to the read ("Baxter Stockman has MOUSERS!!??").

Other than that, I dig that there may be other ninja factions out there besides the Foot and I think teh whole rivalry between Leo and Don is a breath of fresh air.

Also, "holy guacamole", Mike's lesser-known catchphrase from the Fred Wolf cartoon. Waltz has done his research (just refrain from Mike's OTHER lesser-known catchphrase, "mondo tubuloso", please).

Toby Barrett
01-25-2012, 09:00 PM
I really have to admit, it's hilarious that only one issue in, and the colorist has already screwed up on coloring the turtles' bandanas. Seriously, no one spotted this before print? XD

DrSpengler
01-25-2012, 09:02 PM
I really have to admit, it's hilarious that only one issue in, and the colorist has already screwed up on coloring the turtles' bandanas. Seriously, no one spotted this? XD

I point it out in my review, yeah.

Honestly, I'm indifferent to "rainbow vs. red", but coloring confusion is an UNDENIABLE downside to the multi-colored bandanas and possibly the best argument for their exclusion.

I'm fine with IDW's series using the multi-colors, but if they're going to go that route, they NEED to have their colorist pay closer attention and they NEED to have their copy editors do the same.

Samhain
01-25-2012, 09:10 PM
I really have to admit, it's hilarious that only one issue in, and the colorist has already screwed up on coloring the turtles' bandanas. Seriously, no one spotted this before print? XD

It's either the fans getting confused or the colorist's.:lol:

And I agree, it wasn't just once they screwed that up. It was a few times, I think, in this issue.

Jester
01-25-2012, 09:16 PM
Doc, I asked on TMNTEntity, but I figured I'd ask here: Where are the color errors? The only one I saw was in a panel so small, that I had to really look to find it.

EDIT: Oh...and favorite moment: Baxter explaining to Hob what an IED is. "A booby trap that goes 'BOOM!'" "Ah, gotcha."

Powder
01-25-2012, 09:20 PM
Rather than be a sheep and tell you how much I like the book I'm gonna do the good/bad list thing again.

Good:

-The Art, as usual.

-New mouser designs. They're neat. Having different models for different jobs is an awesome concept I hope to see used fully.

Bad:

-For starters, this.

I'm really sick of the cliche' cliffhanger splash page that "reveals" something painfully obvious to the read ("Baxter Stockman has MOUSERS!!??").

-Further personality pigeon-holing. Leo's remark about Mike eating pizza/gaming all day, the comment on Don's alleged genius... Can I have a barf bag, please? I thought there would be a little bit more depth to their development. I wasn't aware David Wise was writing this book. At no point whatsoever did we see Don get established as a tech guy, nor have we seen Mike buy/find a Sega Game Gear at any point (For that matter I've never seen him eat pizza either). Are we going to have a Tales Of The TMNT vol. 3 to fill in all of the blanks? I'd love to read the issue where we see Don LEARN FRENCH. Gimmie a break.

-The Pacing. I really appreciate what you're working at Tom, trying not to jip us out of the other storylines, but it kills the mood for me. I hate how it keeps bouncing around like that, especially considering it bounces to pages of unnecessary/obvious stuff sometimes. Seems a waste of space to me. I dunno about anyone else but I'd rather see the books cut between 2 plots at a time rather than 4-5. First half turtle situations, second April (replace either with Baxter, origin, whatever), or even switch off every 2 pages. Doing things this way actually makes me feel like I AM getting jipped 'cause I feel like I'm not seeing the turtles enough. I know it's setup and everything but 6 issues in that method of story telling telling is already stale to me. (Weird I just had deja vu hardcore typing those last two words.)

-Turtle colors. Is it me or are their different skin tones slowly starting to seem less and less considerable? What, is it cool now to make them all the same color since they have the rainbow swag? Meh, maybe that's for the better. As it is I feel like this is becoming the 2k3 universe. The skin colors paired with the all the bros and freakins really smells like 4kids. Could just be me though.





I really do like this book, I look forward to it monthly. I don't want you to take any of this personally Tom. If I ever get to meet you at a convention or something you'll get nothing but respect from me. It's just that I (like others, I assume) thought the book was going to be a lot more Mirage/Image than Fred Wolf/4kids and it's put me in a weird place. I love all versions of the TMNT and had I been told IDW's comic was gonna be a darker re-imagining of the cartoon universes I'd of shown much more excitement about everything. But since I went into it expecting something a little more sophisticated, I keep getting disappointed. Perhaps if/when I come to terms with the fact that the turtles of this series will not be much different (personality wise) from the majority of them, I will see less flaws in it.

ToTheNines
01-25-2012, 09:20 PM
Amazing issue.

I love the first arc, but disliked waiting a month for 4 "decompressed" issues. That hasn't been the case since #4 though, this issue was jampacked with some action, some interactions, Baxter being a pompous ass, and what I though was actually a very cool reveal at the end due to the 3 sweet new designs we have for the Mousers.

Can not wait for #7!

DrSpengler
01-25-2012, 09:27 PM
Doc, I asked on TMNTEntity, but I figured I'd ask here: Where are the color errors? The only one I saw was in a panel so small, that I had to really look to find it.



Page 5, Leo has a red bandana in panel 1.

Page 9, Don has a blue bandana in the last panel

Page 12, Don has a blue bandana again on the second to last panel.

The Raph/Mike switch-ups were my mistake; I got the shade of orange confused for red.

The Don/Leo thing could be that under certain "lighting", Pattison changes the shade of purple to make it "bluer", but that comes at the expense of making Don look like Leo.

Samhain
01-25-2012, 09:30 PM
Page 5, Leo has a red bandana in panel 1.



Well, at least they got Leo right. :D

Powder
01-25-2012, 09:32 PM
Page 5, Leo has a red bandana in panel 1.

Page 9, Don has a blue bandana in the last panel

Page 12, Don has a blue bandana again on the second to last panel.

The Raph/Mike switch-ups were my mistake; I got the shade of orange confused for red.

The Don/Leo thing could be that under certain "lighting", Pattison changes the shade of purple to make it "bluer", but that comes at the expense of making Don look like Leo.

Dons Bandana is obviously purple. In every panel.

CyberCubed
01-25-2012, 09:33 PM
They said this is only going to be a 3-parter, so by issue #8 I believe the Mouser storyline will be done. I don't mind 3-part issues as its something Archie did all the time.

Also the original cartoon stuff has been handled well so far. We're not having Bebop/Rocksteady shoved in our faces every issue (they haven't re-appeared since the Raph micro), and Krang definitely appears a lot more competent than old toon Krang.

Baxter is pretty similar to both Mirage and 4kids Baxter so far, not much new to say about him.

As for the bandana mistakes, was I the only one who thought of the old toon? So many episodes had bandana mistakes...I hope this is better checked in the future.

Samhain
01-25-2012, 09:36 PM
They said this is only going to be a 3-parter, so by issue #8 I believe the Mouser storyline will be done. I don't mind 3-part issues as its something Archie did all the time.

Also the original cartoon stuff has been handled well so far. We're not having Bebop/Rocksteady shoved in our faces every issue (they haven't re-appeared since the Raph micro), and Krang definitely appears a lot more competent than old toon Krang.

Baxter is pretty similar to both Mirage and 4kids Baxter so far, not much new to say about him.

As for the bandana mistakes, was I the only one who thought of the old toon? So many episodes had bandana mistakes...I hope this is better checked in the future.

Yeah but, Krang really hasn't ''appeared'' yet. Only, his suit. Or whatever it is. I have a feeling we will be seeing a lot more of him once comes his reveal.

And yeah, I was reminded of the old toon. Bleh.

DrSpengler
01-25-2012, 09:36 PM
Dons Bandana is obviously purple. In every panel.

I'm looking at it and it appears the same shade as Leo's blue and not the same shade as Don's purple used in other panels, to me.

EDIT:

I scanned the pages where I made the Don/Leo confusion and looked at them in Gimp. Used the eye-dropper to identify the colors to make sure it wasn't just my eyes not differentiating well-enough.

Don's bandana on page 9 is blue and a totally different shade from his other panels where they're clearly purple.

Page 14 is a toss up, as they're more lavendar and stratling the line close to blue.

I think with Don, Pattison is changing the shade of purple/lavendar to accomodate the lighting and shadow, which is fine, but she treads too close to blue in the cited panels.

CyberCubed
01-25-2012, 09:43 PM
Yeah but, Krang really hasn't ''appeared'' yet. Only, his suit. Or whatever it is. I have a feeling we will be seeing a lot more of him once comes his reveal.


Which is why I said they're handling it well. This isn't, "Shredder and Krang come up with a new scheme to conquer the world," every month, its being handled much like a more serious storyline should be handled.

I am pretty excited to see many old characters revitalized like this. If Krang still has his Rock Soldiers I will be quite pleased.

Venom
01-25-2012, 09:56 PM
At no point whatsoever did we see Don get established as a tech guy

Dude, again, briefly: #2, page 18.

Jester
01-25-2012, 10:07 PM
Thanks, Doc. I think it's all shading and not intentional mistakes...well except the one with Leo on page 5.

EDIT: Sadly Venom, one page of reference doesn't much establishment make, but then again, we're still only 6 issues in, there's a lot of character development to come.

Powder
01-25-2012, 10:14 PM
Thanks, Doc. I think it's all shading and not intentional mistakes...well except the one with Leo on page 5.

EDIT: Sadly Venom, one page of reference doesn't much establishment make, but then again, we're still only 6 issues in, there's a lot of character development to come.

Right.

Right. And that establishment will have to be flashbacks.

Toby Barrett
01-25-2012, 10:25 PM
We may learn more about how Donatello became Mr. Wizard in his micro issue.

Redeemer
01-25-2012, 10:42 PM
Pretty cool issue, I felt a little bored now bc the turtles didnt get much action, but I think it was an important issue. I like the regular mouser design and the smaller mouser design, but not the large mouser. Old Hob needs new pants to I think:P

Toby Barrett
01-25-2012, 11:11 PM
Looking through the book again... I'm gonna have to say that maybe Donatello's "miscolorings" actually were just the tone of his purple being altered for the situation.
They look more blueish in those panels, but they still look purple at the same time.

Hmm..
The only actual miscolor I can see now is Leonardo colored red, but it's so small, you have to really squint to see it anyway.

Turtle colors. Is it me or are their different skin tones slowly starting to seem less and less considerable? What, is it cool now to make them all the same color since they have the rainbow swag? Meh, maybe that's for the better. As it is I feel like this is becoming the 2k3 universe. The skin colors paired with the all the bros and freakins really smells like 4kids. Could just be me though.

The only time the turtles' skin tones look the same to me is when they're out in the dark. When they're in the sewer den, their skin still differs the same way it has the past five issues. Raphael isn't as dark as he was, but just a tiny bit darker than Leo. Mikey and Donnie still look the same though.

Andrew NDB
01-26-2012, 12:16 AM
I'd just as soon them rubbish the different skin tones if they're doing the rainbow bandannas -- I can accept them in an all-red affair grudgingly (in a kind of "OK, the three guys who can't figure out who's who every month, you can have one additional visual aid, fine" way), but realistically different skin tones don't make much sense if they're supposed to be brothers that came out of the same batch of Momma Turtle eggs. And if they've got the rainbow bandannas on top of that, kind of this "We don't trust you to know who's who, even though they're a ninja clan, so we're gonna color code them for you!" thing (penultimate in absurdity -- to me -- only to literally having the letters on their belts which, in turn, is only about one thumb in the butt away from nametags), then there's really no point in continuing that.

About the Kevin Eastman variant cover, I love this one most of all. This is the first place he's actually doing a story-relevant cover and it's kick-ass.

Powder
01-26-2012, 01:39 AM
About the Kevin Eastman variant cover, I love this one most of all. This is the first place he's actually doing a story-relevant cover and it's kick-ass.

Definitely. & it's a treat to see a human character as well as foot from him too!

marcelangelo
01-26-2012, 03:51 AM
hey, where's all the team red people with me here?if leo was 'misscolored' red wouldn't that mean his subconcious wants to wear red bandanas?;)....

ah, and why is it absurd(I realize you didn't use that word yourself) for the turtles to be brothers AND have slightly different skin colors?...now, I am no expert with reptile dna coding but with humans it can differ quite a bit..it depends on whose dominant genetical input an individual gains at birth(for example you can have a different eye color than BOTH your parents, or be as tall as your grandpa and and biger as both your parents and such)....so I think you can have slightly darker or lighter skin colors...also we don't know if their technically REAL brothers...you know they may have the same mother but she might have been one attractive turtle who had many lovers...;)

Keno
01-26-2012, 09:20 AM
Well I've never been much of a Raph fan (Weird, I know, sorry) but I like how they're developing his character here...how he wants to join the battle out of a sense of justice and not just a typical brute "I wanna fight everyone and everything rawrrrr!"

Also what someone mentioned about the toning...I was reading this issue in a dimly-lit place (subway train) and by mid-book my eyes started to really hurt and I had to stop.

I know it's just a set-up issue but when I finished I put it down and thought "...that's it?"

Otherwise I enjoyed it, of course

Toby Barrett
01-26-2012, 09:25 AM
Actually, that's a very good point!
This Raphael, having been seperated from the others so long, is still rather new at being a ninja. So it makes sense that he really has no interest in this hiding in the shadows stuff, and would rather use his abilities to help others!
This works well with the characterization in the Raphael micro issue.
I can see this being something he and Leonardo will never see eye to eye on, something to take the place of the same old Cyclops vs. Wolverine type of relationship the two characters have had since the beginning.

pihb
01-26-2012, 10:08 AM
Actually, that's a very good point!
This Raphael, having been seperated from the others so long, is still rather new at being a ninja. So it makes sense that he really has no interest in this hiding in the shadows stuff, and would rather use his abilities to help others!
This works well with the characterization in the Raphael micro issue.
I can see this being something he and Leonardo will never see eye to eye on, something to take the place of the same old Cyclops vs. Wolverine type of relationship the two characters have had since the beginning.

You bring up a very good point. Leo has always been my favorite, but in this series, he is very much like Cyclops. Leo is becoming arrogant and cocky know it all leader that you almost hate. I find myself not being able to relate to Leo anymore and taking more side in Raph and doing what is right. I do not quite understand the Don/Leo relationship. Don is usually so passive that is strange Leo is at his throat. I am cursious to see where that goes.

Bobby Curnow
01-26-2012, 11:01 AM
I'll take the blame for the Leo red mask on page 5. The other stuff I think is well within the wheelhouse of shadowing though.

What I find funny is people noticing the mask color but not the fact that the Turtles' positions completely switch from page 5, panel 1 to page 7, panel 1!

But you know, maybe they are moving around, staying limber. Also switching masks to... create confusion. Yeah, that's it. Classic ninja techniques.

marcelangelo
01-26-2012, 11:02 AM
I think every now and then in life you have to be a stinker, you know, act like a real fool, in order to develope and to learn...so, there are probably some great moments in store for us all in the brothers' growing together/up...

Toby Barrett
01-26-2012, 11:03 AM
I'll take the blame for the Leo red mask on page 5. The other stuff I think is well within the wheelhouse of shadowing though.

What I find funny is people noticing the mask color but not the fact that the Turtles' positions completely switch from page 5, panel 1 to page 7, panel 1!

But you know, maybe they are moving around, staying limber. Also switching masks to... create confusion. Yeah, that's it. Classic ninja techniques.


Pure genius.

AquaParade
01-26-2012, 11:18 AM
Actually, that's a very good point!
This Raphael, having been seperated from the others so long, is still rather new at being a ninja. So it makes sense that he really has no interest in this hiding in the shadows stuff, and would rather use his abilities to help others!
This works well with the characterization in the Raphael micro issue.
I can see this being something he and Leonardo will never see eye to eye on, something to take the place of the same old Cyclops vs. Wolverine type of relationship the two characters have had since the beginning.

I think it'll be interesting when we start to see who's decisions turn out for the best.

For instance, Leo wants to stay in the shadows while Raph wants to lend a helping hand. Will Raph's decision be good or bad for the brothers? We may see that while Leo comes off as a 'coward' in these situations, it is his decision that saves the family. Raph's determination to help may be seen as both admirable yet foolish, if it gets them in a rut.

DrSpengler
01-26-2012, 11:26 AM
Incidentally, Infestation 2 #1 (http://www.tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/01/infestation-2-1.html) also came out today and had a 1-panel TMNT cameo.

IamtheKnight
01-26-2012, 11:35 AM
Incidentally, Infestation 2 #1 (http://www.tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/01/infestation-2-1.html) also came out today and had a 1-panel TMNT cameo.

I wish I knew that before I bought the issue. The cover led me to believe that the TMNT would be meeting Optimus Prime and Snake Eyes.

TomWaltz
01-26-2012, 11:53 AM
You bring up a very good point. Leo has always been my favorite, but in this series, he is very much like Cyclops. Leo is becoming arrogant and cocky know it all leader that you almost hate. I find myself not being able to relate to Leo anymore and taking more side in Raph and doing what is right. I do not quite understand the Don/Leo relationship. Don is usually so passive that is strange Leo is at his throat. I am cursious to see where that goes.

Keep reading, my friend -- the brothers have a lot of growing and evolving to do yet. They're all gonna surprise us as time passes in the series. For what it's worth, I love Leo -- it ain't always easy being the big brother.

TomWaltz
01-26-2012, 11:55 AM
ah, and why is it absurd(I realize you didn't use that word yourself) for the turtles to be brothers AND have slightly different skin colors?...now, I am no expert with reptile dna coding but with humans it can differ quite a bit..it depends on whose dominant genetical input an individual gains at birth(for example you can have a different eye color than BOTH your parents, or be as tall as your grandpa and and biger as both your parents and such)....so I think you can have slightly darker or lighter skin colors...also we don't know if their technically REAL brothers...you know they may have the same mother but she might have been one attractive turtle who had many lovers...;)

Well, I think you're on to something, marcelangelo, because my sisters all ended up gorgeous and I'm a bit of a big, ugly toad.

:tgrin:

TomWaltz
01-26-2012, 12:00 PM
Casey: Has he never seen a girl? What's with the "woah" when he encounters April? ;)

Ha! I'm glad you mentioned this, Rooish, because that was one of my favorite moments in issue #6. I love Casey and April and was so excited to have them finally meet in person that I lobbied for a splash page for the moment... and am very happy I got my way. Dan and Ronda nailed the moment with their fantastic artwork, no doubt about it.

Thanks for reading!

Tom W.

AquaParade
01-26-2012, 12:37 PM
Well, I think you're on to something, marcelangelo, because my sisters all ended up gorgeous and I'm a bit of a big, ugly toad.

:tgrin:

This explains Tom's writing of Casey's "Woa". He's probably had a rare few encounters with girls throughout his years.

I kid, Tom! I've seen your little rectangle avatar enough at this point to believe you are a good lookin dude!

This is getting weird.

marcelangelo
01-26-2012, 12:46 PM
I am tempted very much to invite your sister all to the technodrome in this case, but don't want to be too offensive/impolite;)....

TomWaltz
01-26-2012, 01:03 PM
I am tempted very much to invite your sister all to the technodrome in this case, but don't want to be too offensive/impolite;)....

Ha! My sisters are all cool ladies -- I'm sure they'd be honored.

Matches Malone
01-26-2012, 01:20 PM
I really liked this issue! While I still really enjoy the pacing (steady balance between giving things enough screen time without dwelling to the point of boredom), it flows even better now that we can move on with the origin behind us, and start paying off on all the set-up. As many suspected, the psychotropic serum was what awoke Splinter to knowledge of his previous life. I was hoping for a more solid explanation on how he knew the turtles were his sons, but then again, it leaves it open to the possibility that the turtles are not actually his reincarnated sons, which is what I would prefer :D If they weren't, it would strengthen the idea that Oroku Saki is Splinter's rival. Plus, it just remains more interesting if they were his adopted sons. With Yoshi having sons in the past though, it would be really interesting tie to have the turtles simply remind him of his sons. Heartbreaking and tragic = good drama!

Some of the dialogue is still a bit hammy, but that's probably just Waltz's style that I will have to get used to. All the "big picture" stuff is wonderful and definitely this series' greatest contribution so far. Also love the different subtypes of Mousers which makes a lot of sense. Plus, it's just cool to see bigger mousers. Hopefully we can keep going down that route and see some more badass robots with Kevin Eastman designs (he and Peter Laird designed some cool robots).

Keno
01-26-2012, 01:30 PM
I find myself not being able to relate to Leo anymore and taking more side in Raph and doing what is right. I do not quite understand the Don/Leo relationship. Don is usually so passive that is strange Leo is at his throat. I am cursious to see where that goes.

This is true too...I find Leo's personality to be a bit offputting which is weird because he's usually my favourite and Raph is usually my least-favourite so it's just strange to me. But I think that is kinda awesome too...I'm guessing it opens up a lot for future issues, like something to cut him down and stuff.

marcelangelo
01-26-2012, 01:31 PM
I agree with you on eastman/laird robots....
hey-can someone post the picture where we see these different versions of the mousers?thanks in advance..

Matches Malone
01-26-2012, 01:37 PM
The most exciting part of #6 was actually in the letters column. Anyone else notice Bobby hinting strongly at Kevin Eastman drawing a story for a TMNT Annual?!

AquaParade
01-26-2012, 03:17 PM
The most exciting part of #6 was actually in the letters column. Anyone else notice Bobby hinting strongly at Kevin Eastman drawing a story for a TMNT Annual?!

best part of the issue!

Mayhem
01-26-2012, 03:18 PM
Now that I have a sub up with a shop here in the UK, hopefully they'll get the issue in tomorrow, and I'll have it early next week...

Andrew NDB
01-26-2012, 03:31 PM
My review:
http://www.firstcomicsnews.com/?p=37372

TomWaltz
01-26-2012, 03:53 PM
My review:
http://www.firstcomicsnews.com/?p=37372

Nice! Thanks!

marcelangelo
01-26-2012, 04:14 PM
woah!for real!??!?that's why he said kevin is busy and cannot do any lay outs at the moment...great!I wanted to advice you over to idwpublishing, there in the tmnt section bobby laid out a release plan for 2012 and onward for the reprints of the original turtles issues including vol 2, 3 and 4 and the archie series...(plan still subject to change though, nothing official mind you)...
worth checking out, lotsa good news this year!(man, I am going to be broke by next christmas...)

ToTheNines
01-26-2012, 06:23 PM
-Further personality pigeon-holing. Leo's remark about Mike eating pizza/gaming all day, the comment on Don's alleged genius... Can I have a barf bag, please? I thought there would be a little bit more depth to their development.

You're being a little too hard on the book here. Just because Leo tells Mike he eats pizza and plays videogames all day doesn't mean he does. If I go out 2 times or more over the span of a week, my parents will tell me I party too much.

Leo just wants everyone to train as much as him, and Mike does things that Leo sees as a waste of time instead.

Also, I didn't see anything wrong with the comment about Don either.

Powder
01-26-2012, 06:41 PM
You're being a little too hard on the book here. Just because Leo tells Mike he eats pizza and plays videogames all day doesn't mean he does.

What is Mikey doing the second they get home?

A hint- He's playing video games.

ToTheNines
01-26-2012, 06:45 PM
Just pretend he's stuck in the Shadow Temple :P

Samhain
01-26-2012, 06:57 PM
I think they will eventually dig deeper into each personality of the turtles. It's still too early to know who they are and there just isn't enough time to tell that in a single issue.

FearlessLeader
01-26-2012, 08:43 PM
I haven't read #6 yet so my comment here is tempered by that (I still need to get a chance to go pick it up) but I'm just not getting the massive amount of Leo hate here.

I mean frankly he hasn't even done enough yet in the plot line to warrant such strict dissection of everything he has done. (Which I'm not complaining about we are only 6 issues in and I know Leo takes time to develop because he is kind of an introvert and expresses himself better in monologue type situations then he does in conversation, I'm eagerly awaiting his micro-series)

So he has made a few comments about his brothers training, frankly (and please anyone correct me I am wrong) I do think that training right now is currently the focal point of Leo's life and it doesn't surprise me that, that is what he is talking about. The guys horizon hasn't been expanded too much yet, give him a little time to grow.

Also I loved the nods to his strategic brilliance in the Raph micro it made me smile.

So much ground work is being laid out right now that the guys are developing slowly, which I like because it seems realistic. One has to remember Raphael has been out in the real world a lot, Leo on the other hand has been stuck in the training room probably antagonizing over every piece of advice Splinter gives him. I am adoring the writing so far in this story line and have complete faith Leo will blossom as time goes on! :tgrin:

Abnormal Freak
01-26-2012, 10:07 PM
I wish I knew that before I bought the issue. The cover led me to believe that the TMNT would be meeting Optimus Prime and Snake Eyes.

While at the store, I flipped through the issue a few times just to make sure that one teensy-weensy panel was really the only place the Turtles appeared other than the cover.

And, yep, that was it. I put it back on the shelf. :D

Toby Barrett
01-26-2012, 10:08 PM
Sad to say, I did the exact same thing! =p
I really don't have any interest in the characters that starred in the issue..

I'll definately be picking up the two TMNT Infestation issues however, you betcha!

Andrew NDB
01-26-2012, 10:11 PM
Reminds me a lot of Image's Mars Attacks event. I think Raphael showed up in one panel of the whole mini series.

I've perused Infestation 2 #1 a couple of times. Artwork is very lush, very inviting and story seems interesting enough. The whole concept of a crossover-that's-not-a-crossover-at-all like this still kind of flies over my head, but I'm willing to give it a chance.

Well, I think you're on to something, marcelangelo, because my sisters all ended up gorgeous and I'm a bit of a big, ugly toad.

Who are you trying to kid, Tom? Bobby already told us about the pictures of you in the dress... we already know you're a show-stopper. ;)

ToTheNines
01-26-2012, 10:22 PM
Artwork is very lush, very inviting and story seems interesting enough.

I don't know if this has been discussed yet, but the guy who penciled the first 4 pages (Schiti) is doing the Donatello Micro.

Powder
01-26-2012, 10:33 PM
I haven't read #6 yet so my comment here is tempered by that (I still need to get a chance to go pick it up) but I'm just not getting the massive amount of Leo hate here.

I mean frankly he hasn't even done enough yet in the plot line to warrant such strict dissection of everything he has done. (Which I'm not complaining about we are only 6 issues in and I know Leo takes time to develop because he is kind of an introvert and expresses himself better in monologue type situations then he does in conversation, I'm eagerly awaiting his micro-series)

So he has made a few comments about his brothers training, frankly (and please anyone correct me I am wrong) I do think that training right now is currently the focal point of Leo's life and it doesn't surprise me that, that is what he is talking about. The guys horizon hasn't been expanded too much yet, give him a little time to grow.

Also I loved the nods to his strategic brilliance in the Raph micro it made me smile.

So much ground work is being laid out right now that the guys are developing slowly, which I like because it seems realistic. One has to remember Raphael has been out in the real world a lot, Leo on the other hand has been stuck in the training room probably antagonizing over every piece of advice Splinter gives him. I am adoring the writing so far in this story line and have complete faith Leo will blossom as time goes on! :tgrin:

Where is all of this alleged Leo hate?

FearlessLeader
01-26-2012, 10:42 PM
Where is all of this alleged Leo hate?


Maybe hate was too strong of a word and dissatisfaction is better??

You bring up a very good point. Leo has always been my favorite, but in this series, he is very much like Cyclops. Leo is becoming arrogant and cocky know it all leader that you almost hate. I find myself not being able to relate to Leo anymore and taking more side in Raph and doing what is right. I do not quite understand the Don/Leo relationship. Don is usually so passive that is strange Leo is at his throat. I am cursious to see where that goes.

This is one and I have seen similar sentiment in other threads, kind of like I said in my post I just wish people would give the character more time before they start to lump generalizations on him.

Powder
01-26-2012, 10:47 PM
Still dunno where it is...

oldmanwinters
01-26-2012, 11:06 PM
Heh, when I first saw the Eastman Cover, I thought the Parkour Ninja was supposed to be the Rat King.

CyberCubed
01-26-2012, 11:59 PM
Personally I don't think we'll be seeing the likes of Rat King, Leatherhead or others for quite some time...unless they show up in one of the micros.

We haven't even had a full debut for Shredder or Krang yet....let alone any secondary villains down the line.

Venom
01-27-2012, 01:00 AM
Thanks, Doc. I think it's all shading and not intentional mistakes...well except the one with Leo on page 5.

EDIT: Sadly Venom, one page of reference doesn't much establishment make, but then again, we're still only 6 issues in, there's a lot of character development to come.

Right.

Right. And that establishment will have to be flashbacks.

In this issue he's seen tinkering with another gadget. Then the Mikro as well.

AquaParade
01-27-2012, 01:56 AM
Personally I don't think we'll be seeing the likes of Rat King, Leatherhead or others for quite some time...unless they show up in one of the micros.

We haven't even had a full debut for Shredder or Krang yet....let alone any secondary villains down the line.

I dare Tom to pass up Rat King for 24 issues! (wait, I take that back). He's just too cool of a character to resist!

Sue me, but I never got into Leatherhead. It's not that I don't like the character - I have a soft spot for him. I just don't think he has brought much to the table in the past - not enough to warrant a fifth mutant reptile hanging around. I'm for the most part with Peter L. on the whole "more mutants make the tmnt less special" idea. I actually think Old Hob has potential to be awesome. Mutant characters besides the tmnt have the potential to be great, just like any other idea. I just think it's a thin line to tread.

Andrew NDB
01-27-2012, 02:06 AM
I think Leatherhead easily earns his place on any short list of "mutants we ought to see at some point." And between Vol. 1, Vol. 3, Vol. 4, and Tales Volume 2 he brought plenty to the table.

Of course no matter what, his origin would be very different than any we're accustomed to. And Leatherhead's whole basis is very intertwined with his origin... so he'll be fundamentally a very different character.

AquaParade
01-27-2012, 02:15 AM
I think Leatherhead easily earns his place on any short list of "mutants we ought to see at some point." And between Vol. 1, Vol. 3, Vol. 4, and Tales Volume 2 he brought plenty to the table.

Of course no matter what, his origin would be very different than any we're accustomed to. And Leatherhead's whole basis is very intertwined with his origin... so he'll be fundamentally a very different character.

Sure. I don't think fans should have to miss out him, if Tom has a clever way to write him. I'd hate to have a list of "mutants we ought to see at some point", for nostalgia's sake. I'm honestly a little scared of this so far, with all the Fred Wolf/Archie character's we've seen. If the character doesn't fit in an organic way, toss him out of the picture.

ToTheNines
01-27-2012, 06:50 AM
Tom's a very good writer, and I loved how he gave the Mousers name a new meaning, so I'm hopeful that he does something intuitive about Leatherhead's train wreck of a cheesy name.

Metropoliskid41
01-27-2012, 08:23 AM
The most exciting part of #6 was actually in the letters column. Anyone else notice Bobby hinting strongly at Kevin Eastman drawing a story for a TMNT Annual?!

Yep that was awesome and the best part about it was that was my letter! Yay me Kyle Benning! :trazz: Bobby or Tom had hinted about Kevin working on something and I'm guessing that's definitely it! :tgrin:

pihb
01-27-2012, 09:56 AM
Keep reading, my friend -- the brothers have a lot of growing and evolving to do yet. They're all gonna surprise us as time passes in the series. For what it's worth, I love Leo -- it ain't always easy being the big brother.

Oh trust me, I will keep reading I will love to see how these guys continue to develop. I think my previous post was misunderstood. If Leo keeps up with his tone, then he will cause a lot of headbutting with his siblings. If that happens, then I can see a sibling rivalry/encouter like what we saw with Raph in tmnt.

CyberCubed
01-27-2012, 11:03 AM
Sure. I don't think fans should have to miss out him, if Tom has a clever way to write him. I'd hate to have a list of "mutants we ought to see at some point", for nostalgia's sake. I'm honestly a little scared of this so far, with all the Fred Wolf/Archie character's we've seen. If the character doesn't fit in an organic way, toss him out of the picture.

Leatherhead has appeared in just about every TMNT universe to date, (aside from the movies), so I am sure he'll appear.

I hope he stays lizard though. I always hated how in the Archie origin he was the human Jess Harley instead of just a normal gator like in every other series.

Powder
01-27-2012, 12:06 PM
In this issue he's seen tinkering with another gadget. Then the Mikro as well.

You really don't get the point do you?

We've never seen how that aspect of him was established. I've used this word several times.
The history of his behavior, not a sudden "oh here's a screwdriver so you know he tinkers".
When did he decide he wanted to get into the stuff? When did he find technology floating around? etc.

AquaParade
01-27-2012, 01:58 PM
Leatherhead has appeared in just about every TMNT universe to date, (aside from the movies), so I am sure he'll appear.

I hope he stays lizard though. I always hated how in the Archie origin he was the human Jess Harley instead of just a normal gator like in every other series.

Well yeah, I'm pretty sure he will appear too. I was more-so debating his value as a character.

TomWaltz
01-27-2012, 02:00 PM
You really don't get the point do you?

We've never seen how that aspect of him was established. I've used this word several times.
The history of his behavior, not a sudden "oh here's a screwdriver so you know he tinkers".
When did he decide he wanted to get into the stuff? When did he find technology floating around? etc.

We will have YEAR ONE stories eventually, Powder, never fear.

Coola Yagami
01-27-2012, 02:25 PM
Better be careful with those Tom... As far as I know... year 1 is Splinter training the Turtles and them looking for Raph. Don't throw in too many things that might contradict what is already happening in what is essentially 'year two' of the Turtles...

And I don't see what's with the fear of 'all these Fred Wolf/Archie characters'. The hell??? All we've seen is Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady. And that's it. Saki, the Foot, Baxter and the Mousers are from Mirage (and if they bring in Leatherhead and Rat King they are also Mirage), and Hob and Apolex are brand new characters. The colored bandanas have been used everywhere else, even in the more Mirage-ish 2K3 show...

Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady are the 'basic' Fred Wolf characters anyway. We haven't seen any hint of Mondo Gecko, Mona Lisa, Dreadmon, Jagwar, Man Ray, Wingnut, Mutagen Man, Metalhead, Burne Thompson and etc etc to the **** etc yet, so don't worry.

And for everyone that doesn't want another FW/Archie character... there are ten more asking for Slash... I would honestly not be surprised if IDW does bring out an evil mutant ninja turtle designed to seek out and kill the others..... but his name won't be Slash (similar to how many people asked why Apolex wasn't just named Ninjara)... Wouldn't be surprised if it was a Savate Ninja Turtle... which could be awesome...

ToTheNines
01-27-2012, 02:31 PM
We will have YEAR ONE stories eventually, Powder, never fear.

Wow, that's awesome news! I'd love to get a few stories about Raphael's life as a lonesome green skinned wanderer in NYC.

Powder
01-27-2012, 02:38 PM
We will have YEAR ONE stories eventually, Powder, never fear.

Thanks for that, I appreciate the acknowledgment and look forward to reading those. Just wish there was more "year one" content up front.

TomWaltz
01-27-2012, 03:03 PM
Better be careful with those Tom... As far as I know... year 1 is Splinter training the Turtles and them looking for Raph. Don't throw in too many things that might contradict what is already happening in what is essentially 'year two' of the Turtles...

Actually, Year One will consist mainly of the Turtles and Shredder looking high and low for an affordable apartment in NYC, only to finally settle on the comfy (if a bit putrid) confines of the sewer.

Jester
01-27-2012, 03:54 PM
So, Powder, when has Donatello's intelligence (or Raph's anger issues, or Mikey's happy go lucky nature, or Leonardo's leadership qualities) been explained? I mean, which Turtle universe ever said, "And THIS is how Donatello came to 'do machines.'"?

Powder
01-27-2012, 04:18 PM
So, Powder, when has Donatello's intelligence (or Raph's anger issues, or Mikey's happy go lucky nature, or Leonardo's leadership qualities) been explained? I mean, which Turtle universe ever said, "And THIS is how Donatello came to 'do machines.'"?

I feel that they're being pigeon-holed as you know, and I think that if that's the route they're going to go they should at least give reason.
Besides, they've been mutated for what, a year? I don't know anyone who gained Donny's intellect in one year of life IN THE SEWER.

Jester
01-27-2012, 05:03 PM
Besides, they've been mutated for what, a year? I don't know anyone who gained Donny's intellect in one year of life IN THE SEWER.
I'll give you that. But that's a suspension of disbelief that has always plagued the TMNT, especially 4kids. I mean how the heck does Donnie build a portal to the internet with stuff a Turtle would find in a dump? How'd he get that smart living, as you said, in a sewer? Internet correspondence? How does he get the internet? Is the lair leaching off of someones wi-fi?

That and the Feudal Japan origin don't mesh either, kinda. I mean being smart by those standards won't make it easy to pick things like that up. Then again, people do bring up Lexington from Gargoyles, but I don't even remember him making vehicles and knowing multiple languages.

ToTheNines
01-27-2012, 05:07 PM
I feel that they're being pigeon-holed as you know, and I think that if that's the route they're going to go they should at least give reason.
Besides, they've been mutated for what, a year? I don't know anyone who gained Donny's intellect in one year of life IN THE SEWER.

... I don't know anyone who's a product of super-solider mutagen and also was a teenage boy from feudal Japan in a past life.

There's going to be a degree of "pigeon-holing" no matter what, but Tom hasn't made their basic characteristics annoying or stereotypical.

Mike's funny without being annoying or dimwitted. Don's smart without being a one-man assembly line. Raph's "troubled" without being a perpetual grouch. And Leo's a full-on student of ninjitsu without being a total square.

AquaParade
01-27-2012, 07:32 PM
I can see Powder's point when it comes to Donatello. The new one-year origin doesn't really fit with the normal "donny is a tech-genius" status quo. Thus, it feels contrived. When it come's to Donny being the "smart one" I prefer the more subtle touch of something like Donatello being the only one able to read, ala City at War.

Toby Barrett
01-27-2012, 07:35 PM
I always preferred more practical Donnie as well.

Someone who'd be able to rig up a truck, know the structural bounderies of the weight applied to an apartment's floor. Just a smart guy, not a super genius who can build portals to other dimensions in his free time.

TonySiegel
01-27-2012, 07:36 PM
Finally got to read issue #6! No real complaints here, it was a very potent issue. I agree with Donatello as well, their origin still seems very farfetched (would like to see it fleshed out and better defined). If I were to try to explain to someone what's going on with the series, I would like to have it sound believable. The same goes for the questions of how did they learn karate and develop their personalities in such short time after mutating? I'm sure these issues will be resolved soon enough. Wish I could speed it up and read the entire future run :lol: Hopefully there will be more peaks than valleys.

Final Grade: a strong B

(didn't notice the color swap mistake in my first run through, will have to go back and check)

Wish List: Old Hob micro series? Ancient/past life origin issue? Bee-Bop & Rocksteady!

Andrew NDB
01-27-2012, 10:04 PM
I think the only thing that really disappoints me with #6 -- and it's not a fault of the issue, just my own built-up expectations based on preview art and such -- is that we didn't get to at last see some Turtles vs. ninja action. I've been waiting patiently to see what the verdict would be on how that's going to go and I thought this would be the issue to settle the matter... I guess we still have to wait a bit longer.

I'll give you that. But that's a suspension of disbelief that has always plagued the TMNT, especially 4kids. I mean how the heck does Donnie build a portal to the internet with stuff a Turtle would find in a dump?

At the risk of turning things into a "Andrew's saying the cartoons suck again!" argument, he wouldn't.

CyberCubed
01-27-2012, 10:33 PM
Well they can always say Don found a magic crystal that let's drawings come to life and opens dimensional portals. I wouldn't be surprised if that's where they got the idea from for the old show.

Andrew NDB
01-27-2012, 10:36 PM
Well they can always say Don found a magic crystal that let's drawings come to life and opens dimensional portals.

But magic is an established part of TMNT lore, and by its very nature it's not bound by any rules of logic or reason.

Donatello living in a sewer for 15 months and being tech savvy in any way greater than, say, being able to fix the hot water heater for his brothers? That might require a little bit of explanation down the line.

Kendamu
01-27-2012, 11:55 PM
At the risk of turning things into a "Andrew's saying the cartoons suck again!" argument, he wouldn't.

Not saying I was a fan of much beyond Season 4, but I think "the cartoons suck" should be somewhere in your signature. :trazz:

Donnie
01-28-2012, 01:50 AM
Really enjoyed this issue, I agree with those that thought the pacing was a little slow, and I will admit that I was disappointed with the constant flipping between stories. I'm not really into the whole April/Casey thing, I wanted more Turtles. I mean...it's a Turtles book, and while I accept that there is a plethora of characters to be explored, let's do the Turtles & Splinter first - as seen from this thread since the issue came out, seems like the personalities of the Turtles are most important to many fans (& the coloring, apparently!) Don't worry Tom, I know you'll deliver some fleshed out Turtle personas!! I'm just saying I want more Turtles, is all. :D

Best part of the issue was the opening sequence showing us glimpses into the Turtles personalities, for sure. Love the Don/Leo rivalry brewing, as well as the Mike/Raph coupling as a consequence. I will agree to an extent with Powder that Don's tech-saviness is seeming a bit forced because we get no explanation to why or how he's so brainy. I know Tom has said it won't be so, but I do hope Mikey isn't pigeon-holed as this type of ultimate gamer...it worked for the 2k3 but I didn't think it would be so pounded-home that he was a gamer in this series. I mean, couldn't they show him with a notebook or something? Will he get to be a writer?

Not sure if we made any progress with the origin. Didn't we already know that Splinter knew in his heart the story as related in #5? We already knew he was given the serum...

All in all, a good book besides those small gripes, and I can't wait for #7!

Matches Malone
01-28-2012, 02:05 AM
I know Tom has said it won't be so, but I do hope Mikey isn't pigeon-holed as this type of ultimate gamer...it worked for the 2k3 but I didn't think it would be so pounded-home that he was a gamer in this series.

It didn't really work in the 2K3 series, in my opinion...

ToTheNines
01-28-2012, 07:04 AM
Ya know what's hilarious? A lot of people complain about the first movie because "Donatello isn't smart enough", and here's a totally different sect complaining that "Donatello's too smart" in IDW.

I guess the main gripe is that he's about 16 months mutated at this point, but still... its funny.

It didn't really work in the 2K3 series, in my opinion...

Agreed. Mainly because he was just so annoying about it.

Donnie
01-28-2012, 10:19 AM
Ya know what's hilarious? A lot of people complain about the first movie because "Donatello isn't smart enough", and here's a totally different sect complaining that "Donatello's too smart" in IDW.

First movie Don is my favorite version of the character, BECAUSE he's not a total brainiac.


Agreed. Mainly because he was just so annoying about it.

Or mainly because practically this entire board doesn't like 2k3 Mike. I strongly disagree, he was one my favorite interpretations. Sure, I wished they toned down the video-game stuff, but it worked at many points throughout the series, in my opinion.

AquaParade
01-28-2012, 10:44 AM
Ya know what's hilarious? A lot of people complain about the first movie because "Donatello isn't smart enough", and here's a totally different sect complaining that "Donatello's too smart" in IDW.



Interesting. I haven't much heard the arguement that Don was not smart enough in the first film, but I don't often visit the movie section of the forum. I thought they nailed it. Fixing up a car is just the right kind of "smart" donatello to me. Basically, I feel like his extended-knowledge should consist of "outside-world" type's of things to the rest of the turtles. Reading english, reading a map, fixing a car. It keep's things believable and helps define that line between the turtles and the outside-world.

ToTheNines
01-28-2012, 11:05 AM
Interesting. I haven't much heard the arguement that Don was not smart enough in the first film, but I don't often visit the movie section of the forum. I thought they nailed it. Fixing up a car is just the right kind of "smart" donatello to me. Basically, I feel like his extended-knowledge should consist of "outside-world" type's of things to the rest of the turtles. Reading english, reading a map, fixing a car. It keep's things believable and helps define that line between the turtles and the outside-world.

This thread has some discussion on the matter: http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=34220

ToTheNines
01-28-2012, 11:16 AM
IGN gave TMNT #6 an 8 out of 10.

http://comics.ign.com/articles/121/1217289p1.html

IveyAngelo
01-28-2012, 11:25 AM
I got around to writing up some reviews on Cowabunga Corner for the IDW Comics, was out of it for a bit (Went through a surgery and wasn't up for writing reviews during recovery).

Wanted to share my review for issue 6:
http://www.cowabungacorner.com/reviews/review-idw-tmnt-6

It was an ok issue, but I had a few issues with it. Mainly with Leo, not sure how I felt with how he was treating Mike and Don.

oldmanwinters
01-28-2012, 12:22 PM
IGN gave TMNT #6 an 8 out of 10.

http://comics.ign.com/articles/121/1217289p1.html

Hooray! That's about the highest score they'll give to a good Sonic the Hedgehog game nowadays!

Venom
01-28-2012, 05:19 PM
I really enjoy seeing Mike and Raph as buddies again. I've stated many times that was an element of the early books that became absent in later issues.

Mr._Mutant_Man
01-28-2012, 05:58 PM
Pretty good issue, it's the setup to better things in issue 7.

Looking forward to seeing how the April and Casey relationship pans out.

Looking to see the eventual Turtles vs. mousers fight.

I've got a feeling Shredder is going to be saved for much later down the line, but I'm okay with that. It gives readers something to look forward to.

I agree that Donatello's level of know-it-all-ness seems out of place. Realistically, they probably should have toned it down a little, or had it develop more over time. I could see Donatello maybe finding an old French textbook down in the sewer though and deciding to study. :)

Jester
01-28-2012, 06:49 PM
Or mainly because practically this entire board doesn't like 2k3 Mike. I strongly disagree, he was one my favorite interpretations. Sure, I wished they toned down the video-game stuff, but it worked at many points throughout the series, in my opinion.
Many of us who don't like 4Kids Mikey tend to not like what he became. I think Turtle Titan is a true test of how much poor Mikey got the shaft in the series. in Unconvincing Turtle Titan Mikey realizes he can do as much good from the shadows as Silver Sentry does in the light. It was a character arc in less than a half hour. Mikey felt the Turtles should be superheroes (which his brothers scoff at. Makes me wonder if this was a barb at the Fred Wolf series...but whatever), he goes out and teams with Sentry and has to save him using his ninja training and in the end he learns his lesson...which is totally undone by the subsequent Titan episodes. And they get worse as they go on.

Mikey started out fine in the 4kids universe, but it seems they always wrote him as a goof, and never let him be serious and that all the time goofiness made him irritating, in my opinion. And reading back over some of the Laird production notes, he has a lot to do with that, sadly.

marcelangelo
01-28-2012, 07:05 PM
Pretty good issue, it's the setup to better things in issue 7.

Looking forward to seeing how the April and Casey relationship pans out.

Looking to see the eventual Turtles vs. mousers fight.

I've got a feeling Shredder is going to be saved for much later down the line, but I'm okay with that. It gives readers something to look forward to.

I agree that Donatello's level of know-it-all-ness seems out of place. Realistically, they probably should have toned it down a little, or had it develop more over time. I could see Donatello maybe finding an old French textbook down in the sewer though and deciding to study. :)

as haven't gotten the chance yet to read this book I have to assume from your post that don is speaking or understanding french?is that correct?
..well, if so then I wouldn't put that on the table to the really-weird stuff, because after all he is a perfect english speaking humanoid turtle who has had a real life before speaking japanese...so if he can adapt to the english language that quickly he pretty much should be able to learn french in about the same time..
and, if you say so already that donatello knowing so much allthough we haven't wittnessed him being especially gifted for techno stuff yet, then thi step is done deliberately I think...bobby curnow already mentioned on the idw forums that after issue 12 hits the streets we will be returning to everything that happened inbetween the first year....you see...answers will come in the near future...

Bobby Curnow
01-28-2012, 07:34 PM
Err, no, I just said that I'm going to post a continuity timeline, so everyone will know exactly where the different micros etc. fall into place on the timeline. That being said, I'm sure we'll check in on 'year one' stuff sometime, though my inclination is to keep things moving forward.

I hear what you guys are saying about Don. To me, I don't think it's necessary to have a formal scene that says 'hey, here's how Donatello became so smart'. I see it as something that can be inferred, shown rather than told. There's a panel in I think issue #2 where we see Leo training, Don tinkering with a machine, and Mike hanging out. To me, that was where we show what these guys do with their off time, and I didn't think much more needed to be said than that. Don's naturally smart- i'd say a genius- and he spends a lot of time working with technology. For someone truly gifted, you can pick up a lot in a year. As much as he has? Hard to say, probably not, but I think we can bend believability a bit in comic books. Bend, but hopefully not break.

But I think that's a matter of personal opinion, and I don't think anyone who's wishing to see more of a backstory to Don's smarts is wrong. It's a valid storytelling point, I just think there's a couple different ways of looking at it.

As with most everything with this series, we're going to fall somewhere in between Mirage and the cartoons. So is our Don more of technical genius than he was in Mirage? Yes. Is he going to be building blimps and dimensional portals? No. The question is, have we made it believable? The aim is yes, but I'm sure we'll fall short in execution some times. Hopefully not too much.

Powder
01-28-2012, 08:28 PM
As with most everything with this series, we're going to fall somewhere in between Mirage and the cartoons. So is our Don more of technical genius than he was in Mirage? Yes. Is he going to be building blimps and dimensional portals? No. The question is, have we made it believable? The aim is yes, but I'm sure we'll fall short in execution some times. Hopefully not too much.

Sounds like it'll become what Dreamwave was hoping to be a bit.

Donnie
01-28-2012, 09:19 PM
The Eastman cover is epic, beautifully done.

Andrew NDB
01-28-2012, 10:00 PM
Err, no, I just said that I'm going to post a continuity timeline, so everyone will know exactly where the different micros etc. fall into place on the timeline. That being said, I'm sure we'll check in on 'year one' stuff sometime, though my inclination is to keep things moving forward.

I hear what you guys are saying about Don. To me, I don't think it's necessary to have a formal scene that says 'hey, here's how Donatello became so smart'. I see it as something that can be inferred, shown rather than told. There's a panel in I think issue #2 where we see Leo training, Don tinkering with a machine, and Mike hanging out. To me, that was where we show what these guys do with their off time, and I didn't think much more needed to be said than that. Don's naturally smart- i'd say a genius- and he spends a lot of time working with technology. For someone truly gifted, you can pick up a lot in a year. As much as he has? Hard to say, probably not, but I think we can bend believability a bit in comic books. Bend, but hopefully not break.

But I think that's a matter of personal opinion, and I don't think anyone who's wishing to see more of a backstory to Don's smarts is wrong. It's a valid storytelling point, I just think there's a couple different ways of looking at it.

As with most everything with this series, we're going to fall somewhere in between Mirage and the cartoons. So is our Don more of technical genius than he was in Mirage? Yes. Is he going to be building blimps and dimensional portals? No. The question is, have we made it believable? The aim is yes, but I'm sure we'll fall short in execution some times. Hopefully not too much.

I guess that's fair.

CyberCubed
01-28-2012, 11:05 PM
You know I can't help but wish each issue was 40 pages like the old Mirage comics. I think that's why people feel the stories are too short, but on the other hand it does leave you wanting more.

And I know today's comics would never be above 22-26 pages, but I can dream.

AquaParade
01-28-2012, 11:53 PM
You know I can't help but wish each issue was 40 pages like the old Mirage comics. I think that's why people feel the stories are too short, but on the other hand it does leave you wanting more.

And I know today's comics would never be above 22-26 pages, but I can dream.

Sure would be nice. Perhaps the annuals will remind us what it's like to read a new 40 page tmnt story. I'm not too familiar with how IDW usually handles annuals.

Andrew NDB
01-29-2012, 12:29 AM
Sure would be nice. Perhaps the annuals will remind us what it's like to read a new 40 page tmnt story. I'm not too familiar with how IDW usually handles annuals.

I'm not familiar either. But the prospect of a 40 page TMNT story all by Kevin Eastman has me feeling as giddy as a kid all over again.

Samhain
01-29-2012, 12:33 AM
I'm not familiar either. But the prospect of a 40 page TMNT story all by Kevin Eastman has me feeling as giddy as a kid all over again.

Oh yes. Please, if there is a turtle god...

Powder
01-29-2012, 12:35 AM
I'm not familiar either. But the prospect of a 40 page TMNT story all by Kevin Eastman has me feeling as giddy as a kid all over again.

Oh yes. Please, if there is a turtle god...

Wait, what are we talking about here? Did I miss something?

Andrew NDB
01-29-2012, 12:43 AM
Wait, what are we talking about here? Did I miss something?

The lettercol of #6 indicates that Kevin Eastman may be working on some kind of IDW TMNT annual. To what extent is unsure, but it sounds like possibly to a very heavy degree.

Samhain
01-29-2012, 12:44 AM
Yep, and on the IDW forums Bobby did mention he has big plans for Kevin. So something is going down.

Powder
01-29-2012, 12:49 AM
Oh, that's fantastic to hear. I actually skipped the letters section this time around, go figure it'd be when something neat was hinted at.

Hermano Dyvas
01-29-2012, 06:16 AM
Donatello learning as much as he did in 15 months probably requires a degree of suspension of disbelief but think of it this way, Donatello is probably like those gifted kids/people who read something and remember it for the rest of their lives. There are people like that out there in real life.

He's like the Sheldon Cooper of the TMNT universe. :P

TonySiegel
01-29-2012, 06:37 AM
who knows their mutations probably accelerated their learning and cognitive skills. the reincarnation aspect is kind of leaning on me, need to learn more to discover what these turtles are about.

marcelangelo
01-29-2012, 09:10 AM
Err, no, I just said that I'm going to post a continuity timeline, so everyone will know exactly where the different micros etc. fall into place on the timeline. That being said, I'm sure we'll check in on 'year one' stuff sometime, though my inclination is to keep things moving forward.

I hear what you guys are saying about Don. To me, I don't think it's necessary to have a formal scene that says 'hey, here's how Donatello became so smart'. I see it as something that can be inferred, shown rather than told. There's a panel in I think issue #2 where we see Leo training, Don tinkering with a machine, and Mike hanging out. To me, that was where we show what these guys do with their off time, and I didn't think much more needed to be said than that. Don's naturally smart- i'd say a genius- and he spends a lot of time working with technology. For someone truly gifted, you can pick up a lot in a year. As much as he has? Hard to say, probably not, but I think we can bend believability a bit in comic books. Bend, but hopefully not break.

But I think that's a matter of personal opinion, and I don't think anyone who's wishing to see more of a backstory to Don's smarts is wrong. It's a valid storytelling point, I just think there's a couple different ways of looking at it.

As with most everything with this series, we're going to fall somewhere in between Mirage and the cartoons. So is our Don more of technical genius than he was in Mirage? Yes. Is he going to be building blimps and dimensional portals? No. The question is, have we made it believable? The aim is yes, but I'm sure we'll fall short in execution some times. Hopefully not too much.

oh, sorry bobby, sorry folks, I guess I read something wrong then;(didn't recheck first, that was foolish of me...;(...well, incline with your view point I would also like to progress with the story and not turn back into the past each issue to doctorize about these things...to me the scene in issue two already indicated that donatello likes to work with electronics and such things, so to go from there and follow him in the present tackle technical problems now with his technical understanding and experimenting works fine with me....