View Full Version : TMNT #4 Preview and Discussion...
TomWaltz
11-28-2011, 05:18 PM
Let's get the party started folks!
http://www.newsarama.com/php/multimedia/album.php?aid=45001
CyberCubed
11-28-2011, 05:37 PM
Seems pretty interesting so far. If the ninja's are Foot Soldiers (which I assume they are) than Shredder and Krang might be rivals/enemies in this version. Considering the dialogue here of the ninja's stealing the mutagen.
One thing I wonder, does Splinter have any relation to Hamato Yoshi at all? Where does the whole Foot history tie in with Splinter in this version, if it does at all?
Andrew NDB
11-28-2011, 05:39 PM
All seems sound enough to me. What's the story with page 9 of 9, though? Did that belong here?
TomWaltz
11-28-2011, 05:45 PM
One thing I wonder, does Splinter have any relation to Hamato Yoshi at all? Where does the whole Foot history tie in with Splinter in this version, if it does at all?
For more on that, stay tuned for issue #5 (and beyond), my friend...
:tsmile:
TomWaltz
11-28-2011, 05:48 PM
All seems sound enough to me. What's the story with page 9 of 9, though? Did that belong here?
Just filler, I'm guessing. Won't be in the book.
Andrew NDB
11-28-2011, 05:58 PM
At first I was thinking "General Krang" might be our gateway drug into a cosmic storyline... but the more I see, the more I think he's maybe (at least at first) just going to be this opposing force to the Shredder with some kind of Island of Dr. Moreau of mutant baddies to throw around.
CyberCubed
11-28-2011, 05:59 PM
For more on that, stay tuned for issue #5 (and beyond), my friend...
:tsmile:
Cool, since Splinter having some history with the Foot and Hamato Yoshi is a big part of his character. After all, how could he teach the Turtles martial arts and have Japanese background if he was just a rat from New York?
Glad to see it being addressed in future issues.
I also like April's look more now, she looks better than in the first issue.
Jester
11-28-2011, 06:24 PM
I know other people use the word, but is Baxter "bloody" British?
TomWaltz
11-28-2011, 06:25 PM
I know other people use the word, but is Baxter "bloody" British?
Nah... when Baxter uses it, it's because he's being pompous. He's American.
Jester
11-28-2011, 06:30 PM
Nah... when Baxter uses it, it's because he's being pompous. He's American.
Thanks. My reading Baxter's dialogue with Scott Williams' voice can continue.
Master Splinter
11-28-2011, 06:50 PM
Let's get the party started folks!
http://www.newsarama.com/php/multimedia/album.php?aid=45001
Wow, this was great. Thanks for sharing with us!
-ms
Matches Malone
11-28-2011, 06:57 PM
At first I was thinking "General Krang" might be our gateway drug into a cosmic storyline... but the more I see, the more I think he's maybe (at least at first) just going to be this opposing force to the Shredder with some kind of Island of Dr. Moreau of mutant baddies to throw around.
That was pretty much what I was thinking. I remember specifically asking Bobby on the IDW forums a while back about Utroms/Triceratons/Fugitoid and he assured me that we will definitely be seeing one or more of those elements in the future; so Krang could still end up being the tie to more cosmic storylines though it seems like we'll be stuck on Earth for a while which is okay by me. Looks like with issue #5 and #6, we will be getting into the Japanese/Ninja background which definitely needs to be addressed. Still very excited about this series so far, though I do wonder if the issue of 15 month old turtles being referred to as teenagers will be addressed at some point...
Donnie
11-28-2011, 07:44 PM
Interesting...I was trying to hold out reading it, but my curiosity got the best of me. Looking forward to the full issue.
deadpoolRKO
11-28-2011, 09:06 PM
i can't wait , i'm loving this series. & my local comic shop has been selling out every week
Andrew NDB
11-28-2011, 11:38 PM
That was pretty much what I was thinking. I remember specifically asking Bobby on the IDW forums a while back about Utroms/Triceratons/Fugitoid and he assured me that we will definitely be seeing one or more of those elements in the future; so Krang could still end up being the tie to more cosmic storylines though it seems like we'll be stuck on Earth for a while which is okay by me. Looks like with issue #5 and #6, we will be getting into the Japanese/Ninja background which definitely needs to be addressed. Still very excited about this series so far, though I do wonder if the issue of 15 month old turtles being referred to as teenagers will be addressed at some point...
I'm sure all the Krang/Shredder/Hamato Yoshi/Japan stuff will be addressed and featured appropriately soon enough.
I got to say, and this is me being completely honest here, I'm a little torn about the whole thing right now. On the one hand, I want all the world/character building stuff that's going on (who's-who, and how familiar stories/characters are familiar but also very different) -- and a big part of the fun so far in the IDW book, perhaps the majority of it, stems from that -- to come to a close so I can have all the answers and see where we sit with everything and for things to move into whatever will more or less be the IDW TMNT "status quo"... but on the other hand, I'm afraid that when all of that is done and we/I get a complete lay of the land on the IDW universe of TMNT... that I might not like it.
Still, I believe in what Tom's doing so far and weaving together (to date, really nothing has thrown up any red flags) and will absolutely be giving it a chance for as long as I can.
CyberCubed
11-28-2011, 11:46 PM
I don't think status quo will be settled for a while. It doesn't seem like April even meets the Turtles for at least another few issues. There is also Raphael now meeting his brothers for the first time since mutation, which will be some getting used to.
I see things coming together fairly nice now, with enough to keep us still guessing what will happen next. The fact that we barely know Krang, his plans, or even Baxter...let alone whenever Shredder/The Foot come into the picture, will leave us wanting more.
Its really only Old Hob that's getting a lot of focus now, primarily because he's the only new character in the series so far.
Punix
11-29-2011, 07:47 AM
check it out. good Preview en review
http://www.freakinawesomenetwork.com/2011/11/tmnt4/
TomWaltz
11-29-2011, 12:33 PM
Higher resolution preview for TMNT #4 can be found at the following:
TMNT: Ongoing #4 - http://bit.ly/rKF1Fa
Thanks!
Tom W.
CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 01:18 PM
I like how Raph seemed to be regaining his memory with the flashback of Hob carrying him off.
Very eager to see how Raph reacts when he meets his brothers.
Samhain
11-29-2011, 01:24 PM
Can't freaking wait! I especially like this panel. Just LOVE it.
http://i41.tinypic.com/ften8x.png
CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 02:08 PM
Can't freaking wait! I especially like this panel. Just LOVE it.
http://i41.tinypic.com/ften8x.png
Man, the mutagen really does work fast, doesn't it?
Looks like the full mutation happened in a matter of seconds.
Andrew NDB
11-29-2011, 02:11 PM
Man, the mutagen really does work fast, doesn't it?
Looks like the full mutation happened in a matter of seconds.
Yeah, seems like Raphael is mutating there from a baby turtle to his full mutated form faster than Bruce Banner changes into the Hulk.
I'm still looking forward to reading the full story about this because for right now... there's a lot of cons and not very many pros for the mutagen working like that.
Samhain
11-29-2011, 02:12 PM
Man, the mutagen really does work fast, doesn't it?
Looks like the full mutation happened in a matter of seconds.
No where in that panel does it indicate exactly how long it took to happen.
Toby Barrett
11-29-2011, 02:20 PM
Yeah, seems like Raphael is mutating there from a baby turtle to his full mutated form faster than Bruce Banner changes into the Hulk.
I'm still looking forward to reading the full story about this because for right now... there's a lot of cons and not very many pros for the mutagen working like that.
In your opinion at least. I can think of several pros I believe in as a fan of mutant characters.
CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 02:23 PM
No where in that panel does it indicate exactly how long it took to happen.
Doesn't seem like he was there for more than a few hours at least. Otherwise he would have moved around.
junkboy
11-29-2011, 02:43 PM
In Mirage series, and especially in Tales of TMNT series 2, there were stories with kid turtles, right.
I mean , them running inside the sewers, with their all over the head type bandanas , trying to go to the far places forbidden by Splinter, etc.
The turtles' life before being "teenage" was an era i really like.
This faster mutation thing both in the first moment they touch the mutagen ( and also everything starts just 1 year later after that, right? They are adult-like in just 1 year )
Tho after seeing that panel up, being in that form in just 1 year did not seem weird to me.
It makes sense at least... but do i like it? No...
The panel looks wicked cool tho. I really liked it as well.
Btw i resisted myself and will not be looking at the preview. Big paper fan here and the best thing about the new series is the surprise factor even for old fans. Maybe more surprising for the old fans.
According to your posts tho, i am very very happy that there is finally some stuff ( or will be some stuff in the upcoming issues ) about why Splinter choosing an eastern philosophy to teach the guys other than it being cool.
That was my biggest concern since issue 2. I mean, not relating Splinter to Japan.
Andrew NDB
11-29-2011, 02:52 PM
In your opinion at least. I can think of several pros I believe in as a fan of mutant characters.
This is what I've got, you tell me what you've got:
(to plagiarize myself)
Pros:
* In this given universe in which the idea is to interwine April into their most humble beginnings, if they instantly mutate then there’s not a 15 (or whatever) year gap between when she first “meets” them and when she sees them next. Keeps things moving, organic.
* With the rule set that mutagen in the IDW TMNT universe is relatively instantaneous, the gates are opened for the IDW TMNT universe to freely, actively have new mutants being created via the same mutagen as opposed to taking years to grow naturally into the fully humanoid mutant state. Though I’m not entirely sure this is really a “pro” at all. While I don’t quite share Peter Laird’s longstanding embargo on, “Keep them unique, any other mutants make them less unique” I have no interest in things becoming a mutant-of-the-week affair either.
* Fred Wolf cartoon fans can feel a little more at home, I guess?
Drawing a blank on other pros, frankly.
Cons:
* We have to swallow that the Turtles’ entire state of sentience is strictly 15 months, yet they somehow possess the minds of teenagers (if I throw mutagen on my 10 year old cat and tomorrow he’s Cat Man, he wouldn’t be telling me about how 4 years ago I forgot to clean out his sh*tter… this is silly). 15 months. If this was the Fred Wolf cartoon, in which all kinds of wackiness and tom-foolery (no pun intended) was going on left and right it was easy to overlook… but it’s very difficult to understand how and why this take on the mutation was settled on by IDW if apart from it they seem to be bending over backwards to explain the science of things and grounding things in reality (at least at the base level).
* Everything else aside, we absolutely need to buy that the Turtles are ninja. I’m OK with seeing a little bit of a “they’re still learning the ropes” at this starting point, but I don’t know how long it’s going to make business or creative sense to still see them fumbling around with their weapons. And if the plan is to just kind of bury our heads in the sand and go, “It was a particularly strenuous 15 months of ninja training, they totally kick ass now!” then that’s not a plan at all. I’m sure more sooner than later we’re going to see the TMNT fighting fully training ninjas in battle and we’re going to be seeing the Turtles winning… and at this point the Turtles’ mere 15 months of training is going to be firmly in the back of our minds, sucking all the sense of realism the comic has been striving for right out of the room.
* The family bonds between the Turtles themselves (though I like what this means for Raphael, who is now, truly the outsider) and Splinter, while not thrown out the window, are greatly diminished. No matter what word balloons are shown, the bond forged over the course of 15 months is not the same as a bond forged over the course of 15 years of depending on one another.
CyberCubed
11-29-2011, 04:06 PM
TomWaltz keeps saying the Turtles only being mutated for 15 months will be addressed at some point...so I wonder what it is. Because as said they can't possibly be "teenagers" if they are baby turtles instantly mutated.
The only thing I can think of is some bizarre time warp where the Turtles get sent off to for 15 years while time passes slowly on Earth, so when the Turtles return April/Casey are still the same age or something like that.
Matches Malone
11-29-2011, 05:28 PM
TomWaltz keeps saying the Turtles only being mutated for 15 months will be addressed at some point...so I wonder what it is. Because as said they can't possibly be "teenagers" if they are baby turtles instantly mutated.
The only thing I can think of is some bizarre time warp where the Turtles get sent off to for 15 years while time passes slowly on Earth, so when the Turtles return April/Casey are still the same age or something like that.
I doubt time traveling will be a part of the turtles' origin, but hopefully it will be part of some future adventures (no pun intended)!
I get the creeping feeling the explanation will be more along the lines of "the turtles were already 15 years old (or some other teenage year) by the time they mutate" since the writers seem to be advocating the idea that their sentience and self-awareness predate their mutation; Raphael, Splinter, and Old Hob have all displayed recognition of memories that occurred before they were mutated. I'm actually okay with this since at least the logic will be consistent and I kind of like the idea that their lives did not begin with mutation. The teenage issue isn't even really a big deal for me, though I'm sure it is for others; I am simply curious how it will be addressed.
Also of note, the question was asked with Volume 4 about whether Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles would continue to be considered "Teenagers" since they were in their 30's in that series to which Peter Laird responded that he essentially just like the title and won't be changing it. Thinking of them as teenagers is an iconic part of their comic book identity, so even though they are now in their 30's, he probably just considered it a continuation of their adventures that begin with their teen years. That's how I'd like to think of it, anyway.
Andrew NDB
11-29-2011, 05:43 PM
Also of note, the question was asked with Volume 4 about whether Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles would continue to be considered "Teenagers" since they were in their 30's in that series to which Peter Laird responded that he essentially just like the title and won't be changing it. Thinking of them as teenagers is an iconic part of their comic book identity, so even though they are now in their 30's, he probably just considered it a continuation of their adventures that begin with their teen years.
I never liked that and always advocated a shortening to just "NINJA TURTLES" upon their 20th birthday.
What Vol. 3 was going to do was put a big "X" over the "TEENAGE" at that time.
Matches Malone
11-29-2011, 05:43 PM
This is what I've got, you tell me what you've got:
(to plagiarize myself)
Cons:
* We have to swallow that the Turtles’ entire state of sentience is strictly 15 months, yet they somehow possess the minds of teenagers (if I throw mutagen on my 10 year old cat and tomorrow he’s Cat Man, he wouldn’t be telling me about how 4 years ago I forgot to clean out his sh*tter… this is silly). 15 months. If this was the Fred Wolf cartoon, in which all kinds of wackiness and tom-foolery (no pun intended) was going on left and right it was easy to overlook… but it’s very difficult to understand how and why this take on the mutation was settled on by IDW if apart from it they seem to be bending over backwards to explain the science of things and grounding things in reality (at least at the base level).
* Everything else aside, we absolutely need to buy that the Turtles are ninja. I’m OK with seeing a little bit of a “they’re still learning the ropes” at this starting point, but I don’t know how long it’s going to make business or creative sense to still see them fumbling around with their weapons. And if the plan is to just kind of bury our heads in the sand and go, “It was a particularly strenuous 15 months of ninja training, they totally kick ass now!” then that’s not a plan at all. I’m sure more sooner than later we’re going to see the TMNT fighting fully training ninjas in battle and we’re going to be seeing the Turtles winning… and at this point the Turtles’ mere 15 months of training is going to be firmly in the back of our minds, sucking all the sense of realism the comic has been striving for right out of the room.
* The family bonds between the Turtles themselves (though I like what this means for Raphael, who is now, truly the outsider) and Splinter, while not thrown out the window, are greatly diminished. No matter what word balloons are shown, the bond forged over the course of 15 months is not the same as a bond forged over the course of 15 years of depending on one another.[/I]
Indeed, I think it is a little more realistic to have mutation be a slower process than with what we've seen so far in this series, but I'm also the type to let things like that go a little more. The fast mutation process definitely opens up for the possibility of more mutants, but it doesn't mean it will necessarily be abused to whacky proportions but we will find out in good time.
As for 15 month period of training and familial connections, I'm okay with considering this as analogous to when we would have typically seen "pre-teen" Mirage turtles adventures. I don't think if we saw little kid 15 month old turtles in a "Tales" type issue, we would have questioned the authenticity or strength of their family, would we? The moment you have your first kid, you don't feel like you have to "earn" family ties. You are a family from day one.
Also, as I've mentioned previously, in #1 of Vol. 1, Splinter says the turtles had grown to full size within a year but was retconned in #9 of Vol. 1 when we see the "pre-teen" turtles; so I would argue accelerated mutation doesn't necessarily go against the original source material if they couldn't even make up their minds at first between issues #1-#9. Also noting in the same vein, that the same issue #9 involved pre-teen turtles taking on and defeating fully trained ninja assassins when saving Gosei. I think, to the dismay of some comic fans, the creators have shown some flexibility when it comes to ironing some of these details out.
I think your points are for the most part fair and well thought-out. I just thought I'd throw in a few more things to consider to see what you think.
junkboy
11-29-2011, 06:12 PM
The turtles not being baby turtles ( more like a pre-mutated teen turtle, tho not sure about the turtle age type equivalent of that ) at their pre-mutated stage does not seem bad to me as well.
That "1 year ago , 1 year later" thing was really bugging me.
I guess and hope we will be seeing some stuff filling up the gaps between.
I look forward to issues 4 and 5.
Matches Malone
11-29-2011, 06:29 PM
That "1 year ago , 1 year later" thing was really bugging me.
Actually, I really like all the flashback style narrative Tom and Eastman have been using to tell the story, because it's almost like getting 3 different stories at the same time and it's fun to see how those 3 strands all parallel and converge to make one big story. It feels like a very modern storytelling device but it works really well in my opinion, but I guess it doesn't work for everyone.
Jester
11-30-2011, 11:30 AM
Well...got it read it...smiled because my letter got printed. :D
I'm not sure what I think about what I read from Splinter. So the Turtles and Splinter have been a family in the past and are now a family again, with new names? Is ninja mysticism the key? Reincarnation? Like Splinter himself said in the 4kids series, every answer just seems to raise more questions. I'm a little leery, but I'm growing to like Tom because of his hearty jests here so I'm willing to see where he's going with this...but I'm just so confused. :P
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 11:48 AM
Well...got it read it...smiled because my letter got printed. :D
I'm not sure what I think about what I read from Splinter. So the Turtles and Splinter have been a family in the past and are now a family again, with new names? Is ninja mysticism the key? Reincarnation? Like Splinter himself said in the 4kids series, every answer just seems to raise more questions. I'm a little leery, but I'm growing to like Tom because of his hearty jests here so I'm willing to see where he's going with this...but I'm just so confused. :P
Confusion is good! Many answers coming in #5... and more questions. Mwahahahahaha!!!!
Jester
11-30-2011, 11:51 AM
BLAST YOU TOM WALTZ!!!
I'm so having a love/hate relationship with the confusion hydra you create. :P
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 12:12 PM
BLAST YOU TOM WALTZ!!!
I'm so having a love/hate relationship with the confusion hydra you create. :P
As long as there's love in there, we're good...
:)
DrSpengler
11-30-2011, 01:29 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #4 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/11/tmnt-idw-4.html)
I don't get much satisfaction out of writing negative reviews, but I'm really losing my patience with the pacing of this series.
Still, I'm really liking Dan Duncan's art and Ronda Pattison's colors, so there's always something to enjoy in each issue.
The slow-burn storytelling of the TMNT ongoing has definately begun to wear on me, so I'm hoping the upcoming microseries and Infestation mini manage to tell some snappier plots to help take the edge off of the ongoing's snail's pace.
But as the last page of this issue pointed out, we're #16 bucks in and things still haven't "truly begun".
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 01:51 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #4 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/11/tmnt-idw-4.html)
I don't get much satisfaction out of writing negative reviews, but I'm really losing my patience with the pacing of this series.
Still, I'm really liking Dan Duncan's art and Ronda Pattison's colors, so there's always something to enjoy in each issue.
The slow-burn storytelling of the TMNT ongoing has definately begun to wear on me, so I'm hoping the upcoming microseries and Infestation mini manage to tell some snappier plots to help take the edge off of the ongoing's snail's pace.
But as the last page of this issue pointed out, we're #16 bucks in and things still haven't "truly begun".
Good review, DrSpengler -- thanks for taking the time to cover our books!
Only issue I had with your write-up was that you thought I might be "rubbing the decompression" in your face. I actually don't know you personally, so I don't have that sort of vendetta against you in mind as I write TMNT, nor am I the type of creator who'd do that to any of the readers I'm fortunate enough to have checking out my work.
That said, I really do enjoy your write-ups -- as I mention above, I feel very lucky to have fans (any fans) taking the time to scrutinize my stories, even when they don't necessarily agree with my approach. I spend a lot of lonely, isolated time writing, so it's always fun to come out of the dark and into the light, so to speak, and share my efforts with my fellow fans like yourself. I look forward to reading your in-depth reviews of issue #5 and beyond!
Talk soon...
Tom W.
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 01:58 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #4 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/11/tmnt-idw-4.html)
I don't get much satisfaction out of writing negative reviews, but I'm really losing my patience with the pacing of this series.
Still, I'm really liking Dan Duncan's art and Ronda Pattison's colors, so there's always something to enjoy in each issue.
The slow-burn storytelling of the TMNT ongoing has definately begun to wear on me, so I'm hoping the upcoming microseries and Infestation mini manage to tell some snappier plots to help take the edge off of the ongoing's snail's pace.
But as the last page of this issue pointed out, we're #16 bucks in and things still haven't "truly begun".
Oh... and I forgot to mention in my last response...
Your question in you review about Hob/TMNT blood versus Splinter's blood is an excellent one, and will be addressed in a future issue. Good catch!
Roseangelo
11-30-2011, 02:02 PM
My comic shop is claiming new comics don't come out until tomorrow "because of the holiday" - Has anyone else run into this, or is it just complete BS?
Andrew NDB
11-30-2011, 02:16 PM
My comic shop is claiming new comics don't come out until tomorrow "because of the holiday" - Has anyone else run into this, or is it just complete BS?
That's nonsense. Diamond has been shipping Tuesdays instead of Wednesdays to prevent Holiday delays for a long time now.
MattLawrence
11-30-2011, 02:18 PM
tom,
I am very and truly happy with yours and the teams work thus far on the turtles ! It has been fun with all the questions that pop up in my mind while reading. That being said I can't wait for those questions to be answered and i hope they will get answered soon.
just one question right now though....
will issue #5 or the raphael micro series answer this "past family" aspect splinter mentioned? or a later issue ?
thanks,
Matt
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 02:23 PM
tom,
I am very and truly happy with yours and the teams work thus far on the turtles ! It has been fun with all the questions that pop up in my mind while reading. That being said I can't wait for those questions to be answered and i hope they will get answered soon.
just one question right now though....
will issue #5 or the raphael micro series answer this "past family" aspect splinter mentioned? or a later issue ?
thanks,
Matt
Thanks, Matt! Here's my answer to your question:
Though many answers will still come in future issues, issue #5 does answer the lion's share of questions about the past family aspect. It's an issue I'm very, very proud of, too -- wait till you see the artwork Dan, Mateus, and the ever-awesome Ronda Pattison have put together!
Roseangelo
11-30-2011, 02:27 PM
That's nonsense. Diamond has been shipping Tuesdays instead of Wednesdays to prevent Holiday delays for a long time now.
That's what I thought. :tgrumble:
DrSpengler
11-30-2011, 02:29 PM
Only issue I had with your write-up was that you thought I might be "rubbing the decompression" in your face. I actually don't know you personally, so I don't have that sort of vendetta against you in mind as I write TMNT, nor am I the type of creator who'd do that to any of the readers I'm fortunate enough to have checking out my work.Tom W.
That bit of my review was rather vitriolic in retrospect and I apologize for it.
I hope you understand that I do appreciate the scope and direction of the story you are creating; my primary grievance is just with the pacing. And I of course mean no personal offense.
Andrew NDB
11-30-2011, 02:30 PM
Only issue I had with your write-up was that you thought I might be "rubbing the decompression" in your face. I actually don't know you personally, so I don't have that sort of vendetta against you in mind as I write TMNT, nor am I the type of creator who'd do that to any of the readers I'm fortunate enough to have checking out my work.
I don't think Spengler meant that as you, personally, rubbing it in anyone's face but more like... he feels that the storyline was very decompressed, and then here comes a comment from one of the characters in-story kind of underscoring that. So kind of an... unhappy coincidence?
I haven't read the latest issue myself yet so I can't comment on that, but the decompression factor hasn't really bothered me much so far... and I'm usually the kind of guy that's ready to burn effigies of Geoff Johns in protest whenever I read DC comics rife with that.
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 02:37 PM
That bit of my review was rather vitriolic in retrospect and I apologize for it.
I hope you understand that I do appreciate the scope and direction of the story you are creating; my primary grievance is just with the pacing. And I of course mean no personal offense.
:)
No offense taken, amigo. I can understand the impatience -- our primary goals for this first arc were to lay the new origin groundwork, intro important characters (Casey, April, Stockman, Hob, Krang), and get the four turtles back together, of course -- while showing some cool ninja action (and, man, you gotta admit those fighting scenes in issue #4 kick ass!). Splinter's remark about being able to truly begin was very deliberate on my part for many reasons -- one being that the family was impotent to move forward without the missing piece that was Raph -- two being the proclamation that the origin foundation has been laid out, the players revealed, the formalities are out of the way and it's time to kick this sucker into an even higher gear -- issue #5 does just that!
So, all good! Keep reading and keep critiquing -- keeps us honest!
:)
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 02:38 PM
I don't think Spengler meant that as you, personally, rubbing it in anyone's face but more like... he feels that the storyline was very decompressed, and then here comes a comment from one of the characters in-story kind of underscoring that. So kind of an... unhappy coincidence?
I haven't read the latest issue myself yet so I can't comment on that, but the decompression factor hasn't really bothered me much so far... and I'm usually the kind of guy that's ready to burn effigies of Geoff Johns in protest whenever I read DC comics rife with that.
Just don't come after me with one of those friggin' Highlander swords. Those things are scary!
:teek:
CyberCubed
11-30-2011, 02:41 PM
I think its that the Mirage and Archie series usually told whole stories in the span of a single issue, and at most were spread out over 3-parters.
I've been re-reading the Mirage and Archie series myself, and most stories were told in single issues. Then of course we had the usual 2 or 3 parters.
I think the only exceptions were City at War which spanned 13 issues, and Volume 2, which also spanned 13 issues.
MattLawrence
11-30-2011, 02:52 PM
yea i'm used to the 1 issue stories from mirage as well.
Though it has yet to be seen just yet, I am confident the new team could produce 1 issue stories if they wanted and whats to say they haven't already thought of some ! We can only ponder until told otherwise
Andrew NDB
11-30-2011, 02:57 PM
Just don't come after me with one of those friggin' Highlander swords. Those things are scary!
:teek:
I can't promise anything -- if you see a guy in your line at a ComiCon with a sword (that isn't dressed up like Naruto, or whatever the kids like these days), it's probably a sign that: 1) You've done something wrong in the comics, and 2) It might be a good time to take a lunch break.
I kid, I kid. :)
I think its that the Mirage and Archie series usually told whole stories in the span of a single issue, and at most were spread out over 3-parters.
I've been re-reading the Mirage and Archie series myself, and most stories were told in single issues. Then of course we had the usual 2 or 3 parters.
I think the only exceptions were City at War which spanned 13 issues, and Volume 2, which also spanned 13 issues.
But don't forget that the Mirage issues were often times 35, 40 pages an issue... or more. I'm pretty sure even the Archie books were a little longer than 20 pages, too.
CyberCubed
11-30-2011, 03:28 PM
True, but it makes you wonder how long:
1. When will Shredder finally make his debut, or at least have a cameo?
2. How long till Krang gets a "full" debut?
3. Where are the Foot Clan? Were they the ninja's in the first issue?
4. When will April meet the Turtles?
5. When will we see the debut of the main secondary villains in TMNT history, like Rat King, Leatherhead, etc?
There are so many characters in the TMNT universe, but it does feel like it'll take a while before everything comes together.
azrael
11-30-2011, 04:41 PM
I think a minor problem for most people is we are the "elite" TMNT fans hence why we are on technodrome and a few other TMNT sites. So for the introduction to characters may seem long to us it isnt if you are New or have been out of the loop for a while.
Samhain
11-30-2011, 04:47 PM
Iwe are the "elite" TMNT fans hence why we are on technodrome and a few other TMNT sites.
LMAO. ''Elite'' fans? What the hell does that even mean?
azrael
11-30-2011, 04:50 PM
I dont want to say stupid crap like "true" fans.. I thought elite would be better. I guess I could have used committed fans.
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 05:22 PM
I dont want to say stupid crap like "true" fans.. I thought elite would be better. I guess I could have used committed fans.
But, I get what you're saying and that does bring up a good point. From the very beginning, I've said that IDW's TMNT is going to be a mish-mash of all the iterations of TMNT that have come before -- comics, movies, TV, etc. -- along with all-new stuff. To directly compare what we are doing to the original Mirage run is really apples to oranges, at least as far as plot/storyline are concerned... and, as Andrew mentioned in an earlier post, formatting (we always only have 22 pages each issue to work with). I mean, there will obviously be similarities, but there will be plenty of differences, too -- very deliberate differences. If folks are looking for us to walk down the same exact roads that have been travelled before, honestly, they are better off getting the original comics.
That said, comparing the quality of our stories to the original stories is fair and really comes down to individual tastes. We're gonna keep doing what we love and hope you will all stick around to see how things pan out. Big plans!
I will share this, though, as far as mish-mashing is concerned... in issue #7, we're bringing in something from the 80's TV Toon in an all-new and exciting (and dare I say, gritty) way that I know will surprise folks and I think a way folks will dig -- old and new, novice and elite fans alike.
Samhain
11-30-2011, 05:28 PM
I will share this, though, as far as mish-mashing is concerned... in issue #7, we're bringing in something from the 80's TV Toon in an all-new and exciting (and dare I say, gritty) way that I know will surprise folks and I think a way folks will dig -- old and new, novice and elite fans alike.
This puts a very big grin on my face! :D
CyberCubed
11-30-2011, 05:52 PM
I will share this, though, as far as mish-mashing is concerned... in issue #7, we're bringing in something from the 80's TV Toon in an all-new and exciting (and dare I say, gritty) way that I know will surprise folks and I think a way folks will dig -- old and new, novice and elite fans alike.
Cool. Krang was from the 80's show, but since he's already been debuted, I can only think of a few other characters from it that we could be seeing.
Rat King and Leatherhead originated in the Mirage comics, so it can't be them. April isn't a reporter, so its not any of the Channel 6 news crew. It is unlikely to be obscure characters like Pizzaface, since he never even appeared in the old show and only got a toy. Rahzar/Tokka originated in the movies, so its not them.
Although I must say, I am curious if Krang does have an army from Dimension X in this version. I wouldn't mind seeing the return of General Traag.
Andrew NDB
11-30-2011, 06:11 PM
I will share this, though, as far as mish-mashing is concerned... in issue #7, we're bringing in something from the 80's TV Toon in an all-new and exciting (and dare I say, gritty) way that I know will surprise folks and I think a way folks will dig -- old and new, novice and elite fans alike.
Don't get too excited, folks... he's talking about the letters on the belts. ;)
If I could ask just one question of Mr. Waltz:
(and you can answer this or interpret this question however makes sense to you)
When all is said and done and the status quo (or whatever will resemble "status quo") of the IDW TMNT is more or less established -- you know, origin told, the players, supporting cast, bad guys, key motivations, all of that is pretty well known -- what will we be looking at in terms of percentages of other universes at the core of this universe?
For example, someone might describe/breakdown what we've seen of the IDW TMNT so far as:
30% Mirage TMNT
45% Fred Wolf Cartoon TMNT
10% 4Kids Cartoon TMNT
10% Archie Comics TMNT
5% Movie TMNT
How would you similarly breakdown [the influences/inspirations/derivatives of] the IDW universe when things get a bit more settled?
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 06:23 PM
Don't get too excited, folks... he's talking about the letters on the belts. ;)
If I could ask just one question of Mr. Waltz:
(and you can answer this or interpret this question however makes sense to you)
When all is said and done and the status quo (or whatever will resemble "status quo") of the IDW TMNT is more or less established -- you know, origin told, the players, supporting cast, bad guys, key motivations, all of that is pretty well known -- what will we be looking at in terms of percentages of other universes at the core of this universe?
For example, someone might describe/breakdown what we've seen of the IDW TMNT so far as:
30% Mirage TMNT
45% Fred Wolf Cartoon TMNT
10% 4Kids Cartoon TMNT
10% Archie Comics TMNT
5% Movie TMNT
How would you similarly breakdown [the influences/inspirations/derivatives of] the IDW universe when things get a bit more settled?
Dude, I'm a writer. Math? GAH!!!
Seriously, it's hard to put a number on these things, but I will say that whatever we use from the past, whatever iteration, it'll be for a specific reason (not just because) and it will be done in a way that fits into the story we are telling and in the mood we are establishing.
This much is certain -- we will always lean toward gritty and mature as much as possible, without losing the fun (the sales numbers show us we're bringing in new, younger fans and we would be foolish not to keep that in mind). That said, we will never get goofy or cartoonish. Action/drama/humor/fun? Definitely. Silly? No. Never.
Powder
11-30-2011, 06:57 PM
I've just finished #4 and I was as excited reading this issue as I was during #1. Lots of questions were brought up, really intriguing ones.
Fantastic art as usual, maybe even some parts looking better than ever. The shot of our 3 boys at the rescue, for example... Wow.
This whole theme of remembering has got me really worked up too (in a good way), it's quite a thought provoking thing we got goin' on here.
Are these the mirage turtles starting from scratch courtesy Renet? A new beginning? Did these fellas have a normal TMNT life for a while & then get reverted to their animal states by a Shredder character before eventually ending up as lab specimens? Is there more to Hob & Raph, was he a surrogate parent to him for some time? Many more questions follow. I can say this of the IDW series, I've never looked forward to their next issue as much as I am right now. Gonna be great to have some of these things unfold finally.
CyberCubed
11-30-2011, 07:33 PM
I'd lol if these Turtles are somehow the Mirage Turtles re-incarnated into a new universe. But...that's too crazy.
TomWaltz
11-30-2011, 07:37 PM
I'd lol if these Turtles are somehow the Mirage Turtles re-incarnated into a new universe. But...that's too crazy.
Well, technically if you think about it, ALL TMNT incarnations since the original Mirage days are a reincarnation of sorts...
CyberCubed
11-30-2011, 07:47 PM
Is there more to Hob & Raph, was he a surrogate parent to him for some time? Many more questions follow. I can say this of the IDW series, I've never looked forward to their next issue as much as I am right now. Gonna be great to have some of these things unfold finally.
I think one of the upcoming summaries said Baxter and Hob try to re-capture the Turtles again. Also curiously we've seen nothing about Baxter's Mouser robots, which has been a staple of his character in every incarnation. Before Baxter gets turned into a cyborg/mutant fly/whatever, he always has his Mousers first as a normal human.
Powder
11-30-2011, 07:54 PM
We have too, though, you see! There's a picture of him with a mouser drawn by Dan somewhere, I think the end of the first issue...
It was his final design pieces, but the fact Stockman is paired with the 'lil bot that needed a new look, clearly they plan to make use of 'em.
Slap-Happy
11-30-2011, 08:20 PM
Just read the issue today and loved it. Brings up a lot of questions hat will all hopefully be answered.
Also, I concur with Powder, that shot of Leo, Don, and Mike when the fight starts is amazing.
Another question, when can we expect to see the cover and synopsis for #6?
Redeemer
11-30-2011, 08:20 PM
Well...got it read it...smiled because my letter got printed. :D
I'm not sure what I think about what I read from Splinter. So the Turtles and Splinter have been a family in the past and are now a family again, with new names? Is ninja mysticism the key? Reincarnation? Like Splinter himself said in the 4kids series, every answer just seems to raise more questions. I'm a little leery, but I'm growing to like Tom because of his hearty jests here so I'm willing to see where he's going with this...but I'm just so confused. :P
how do u get ur letter printed!!!! lol that be so awesome, and I do have some Q
Like are splinter and the turtles actaully blood????? Were they humans before hand??Bc at the end when Splinter refers to being a family again makes me wonder in all honesty. I do really enjoy the work you guys r putting into this series and I gotta know when r we gonna get to see some shredder??????
Powder
11-30-2011, 08:32 PM
how do u get ur letter printed!!!! lol that be so awesome, and I do have some Q
Like are splinter and the turtles actaully blood?????
Many think that due to the red bandanas the turtle wear, as well as Splinter being seen in a red robe on occasion.
Truth is, however, that they're Crips. Rumors imply April was once a Latin King.
Venom
11-30-2011, 08:49 PM
I will share this, though, as far as mish-mashing is concerned... in issue #7, we're bringing in something from the 80's TV Toon in an all-new and exciting (and dare I say, gritty) way that I know will surprise folks and I think a way folks will dig -- old and new, novice and elite fans alike.
:teek: The Turtle Van's coming back!! :D
jk;)
CyberCubed
11-30-2011, 09:02 PM
We have too, though, you see! There's a picture of him with a mouser drawn by Dan somewhere, I think the end of the first issue...
It was his final design pieces, but the fact Stockman is paired with the 'lil bot that needed a new look, clearly they plan to make use of 'em.
I remember those, but they didn't quite look like Mousers to me. They had no big mouths, but I realize they could be redesigned.
Matches Malone
11-30-2011, 09:06 PM
:teek: The Turtle Van's coming back!! :D
jk;)
But it will be brought back in a gritty way. The origin will include its car manufacturers being murdered in a backalley drug deal and the van taking an oath against crime at their gravestones.
Andrew NDB
11-30-2011, 09:08 PM
Just a random guess: the Technodrome.
I wouldn't be against it, really. We already have Krang... and a Krang without his Technodrome, folks would be constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop anyway. I've never really had a problem with the Technodrome on paper... it's a sound idea, but just never realized. Turtles Forever gave a glimpse at how a fully realized, weaponized Technodrome could be and that was pretty cool.
ToTheNines
11-30-2011, 09:26 PM
Great stuff in this issue. I'm certainly interested in this past lives thing, except it makes me wonder why Mike and Don were so willing to forget about Raph in issue #3.
That big panel of Leo, Mike and Don after they hit Hob with the shuriken was epic. As was the following spread page. Then the fight with Raph and Hob was intense, loved when Raph bit him on the arm.
The last panel was very touching. Can't wait for next months book.
AquaParade
11-30-2011, 09:40 PM
I've just finished #4 and I was as excited reading this issue as I was during #1. Lots of questions were brought up, really intriguing ones.
Fantastic art as usual, maybe even some parts looking better than ever. The shot of our 3 boys at the rescue, for example... Wow.
This whole theme of remembering has got me really worked up too (in a good way), it's quite a thought provoking thing we got goin' on here.
Are these the mirage turtles starting from scratch courtesy Renet? A new beginning? Did these fellas have a normal TMNT life for a while & then get reverted to their animal states by a Shredder character before eventually ending up as lab specimens? Is there more to Hob & Raph, was he a surrogate parent to him for some time? Many more questions follow. I can say this of the IDW series, I've never looked forward to their next issue as much as I am right now. Gonna be great to have some of these things unfold finally.
Ah! It's nice to see that I am not the only one speculating that a former tmnt universe has something to do with this - basically what you suggested with
Renee and the mirage turtles. Definitely some awesome potential in that possibility.
ToTheNines
11-30-2011, 09:47 PM
Ah! It's nice to see that I am not the only one speculating that a former tmnt universe has something to do with this - basically what you suggested with
Renee and the mirage turtles. Definitely some awesome potential in that possibility.
I hate to burst your creative bubbles, but when Splinter tells them their names, he says that they are new names.
AquaParade
11-30-2011, 09:54 PM
I hate to burst your creative bubbles, but when Splinter tells them their names, he says that they are new names.
Good point. Must have slipped my mind, but I remember reading that today and considering the same thing.
Matches Malone
11-30-2011, 10:17 PM
I hate to burst your creative bubbles, but when Splinter tells them their names, he says that they are new names.
Good point! Though it was more a passing thought than a real theory, the idea that they were the mirage turtles reincarnated did enter my mind. Though my bubble has now been promptly and thoroughly burst.
I enjoyed #4 and it was a satisfying conclusion. There are some unanswered questions, but that's what keeps you hooked. I know this discussion is regarding #4, but I'm taking this opportunity to kind of feel out my impression of the story arc overall now that it has concluded. While the pacing is good throughout, there indeed wasn't a whole lot of plot, but it made for a compelling introduction. The only real driving plot in this arc was finding the long lost brother Raphael, which is an interesting idea, though it did start to falter a bit by #3. Art is great and the writing is steady enough, even though I felt Splinter scratching out TWO eyes in one incident was a bit unnecessarily redundant.
I only have two real complaints. First is the fact that Casey is such a... goody two-shoes. The dialogue in #3 about keeping his promise to his mom was a bit hammy, but "nice boy" Casey isn't so bad, just not my preference. Even if he is such a good guy, I hope there is still opportunity to delve into his character a bit darker since he does beat the daylights out of criminals for fun. What was intriguing about his character in the beginning was that he gave Raph a real bond through their struggles with their anger. True they have their similarities in this series (they are both loners), but it hasn't really come through in Casey's personality yet since he has been so cheerful and optimistic.
My only other disappointment and side effect of the accelerated mutation is that their relationship with humans isn't all that jarring for the turtles; they no longer seem like true outsiders. In the original Mirage story, they were hidden isolated for 15 years and then meet April, a member of a human race that they've never really encountered. Now we have them running away from ninjas to beating up gangs and making friends scarcely a year later. It's not going to ruin the series, but it is disappointing. Hopefully they can work the "freaks unaccepted by society" angle into the story at some point. Starting even with the first issue, I've always really liked Raphael's longing to be part of a world that would never accept him (TMNT clearly had a lot of themes derived from Marvel). Overall, I'd say this first story arc is pretty solid and I would give it an overall "B" or "B-".
Abnormal Freak
12-01-2011, 12:36 AM
I will share this, though, as far as mish-mashing is concerned... in issue #7, we're bringing in something from the 80's TV Toon in an all-new and exciting (and dare I say, gritty) way that I know will surprise folks and I think a way folks will dig -- old and new, novice and elite fans alike.
Just a random guess: the Technodrome.
I was thinking maybe Dimension X, but the Technodrome coinciding with Dimension X makes more sense. ;) I strangely find the idea of another dimension more pleasing than aliens populating the vast regions of space, regardless of how cheesy "Dimension X" kind of is. And hopefully Krang will be the mass-murdering, planet-wiping villain that he is in the earlier Archie issues.
So the Utroms would be from this other dimension, supposing Krang is an Utrom (since the basic components for the mutagen came from him). I dunno. :o I think it's kind of a cool idea. Interested to see where things go.
I'm still not diggin' the idea of the Turtles once being humans, so...I dunno... I'll try not to rip my hair out if that's one of the big reveals next issue.
But the first thing that popped into my head when Splinter said something like, "there are many things you don't yet remember," was that maybe they were once previously regular turtles, but having bumped into Krang somehow were mutated, but being formidable foes, Krang "got rid of" them by using them as test subjects for the super soldier serum or whatever, being the source where the serum came from...and so they were reduced to regular, small animals again—except Splinter retained some level of memory and intelligence throughout the whole ordeal.
Farfetched? :D Heck, I dunno.
Whatever. I've enjoyed the story so far, so I'll probably dig whatever has been thought up.
Powder
12-01-2011, 01:17 AM
Farfetched? :D Heck, I dunno.
I was thinking along those same lines...
Slap-Happy
12-01-2011, 01:51 AM
If the origin goes the way I think it does...
Splinter somehow spiritually transferring his son's souls into the turtles (I'm not sure why)
Then I'm pretty fine with that.
Matches Malone
12-01-2011, 02:15 AM
I was thinking along those same lines...
Seems a little too wacky of an idea to have the turtles go from normal to mutant back to normal and back to mutant yet again. The turtles mutation is certainly a lot less extraordinary when they keep switching back and forth like a light switch... Which is why I'm not too crazy about too many "extra" mutants if there isn't a reasonable explanation for it...
ToTheNines
12-01-2011, 06:52 AM
I also loved the moment where Raph was about to kill Hob, then Leo stepped in and stopped him as per Splinter (not that I liked him not wanting to kill, just that he obeys Splinter to a T), then Donatello, being the turtle of logic points out that Hob is just going to keep attacking them and should be put down.
Andrew NDB
12-01-2011, 10:35 AM
All of the possibilities I'm hearing, whether it's from human to baby turtle to mutant turtle or soul transfer from human to baby turtle to mutant turtle... all of these sound like they're running the risk of adding an unnecessary layer of convolution to the origin. I'm not saying it can't be done, but it would take some real doing to balance the scales right.
I mean, in a year if someone were to ask, "Hey, what's the origin of the IDW TMNT?" the answer would have to be something like, "They began as human boys and then their souls were transferred into baby turtles and then those baby turtles were caught and used for top secret experiments and then ninjas tried to kidnap them and they were exposed to a mutagen that grew them into full-sized humanoids" -- it seems like a lot of "and thens."
CyberCubed
12-01-2011, 11:18 AM
Where does the idea of Turtles have anything to do with humans come from? That issue #5 cover?
ToTheNines
12-01-2011, 12:14 PM
Where does the idea of Turtles have anything to do with humans come from? That issue #5 cover?
Have you read this issue?
TomWaltz
12-01-2011, 12:35 PM
The last panel was very touching. Can't wait for next months book.
Yep, ToTheNines, that last panel really is nice, isn't it? When Dan sent in the final art for that page, both Bobby and I were gushing over it in the IDW offices.
Thanks for your support!
Tom W.
TomWaltz
12-01-2011, 01:56 PM
Okay, folks, my uber-editor, Mr. Bobby Curnow, is telling me to get my butt back to writing, so I may be quiet for a bit. Just wanted to thank you all again for your continued support, excitement, and well-written and honest criticism of our IDW TMNT comic book. Really appreciated and look forward to talking to you all about issue #5 at the end of the month.
Before I go, though, want to leave you with a sneak peek at issue #5 artwork. All I can safely show, my friends -- every page chock full o' spoilers!
Take care and have a great holiday season!
Tom W.
Master Splinter
12-01-2011, 02:10 PM
Okay, folks, my uber-editor, Mr. Bobby Curnow, is telling me to get my butt back to writing, so I may be quiet for a bit. Just wanted to thank you all again for your continued support, excitement, and well-written and honest criticism of our IDW TMNT comic book. Really appreciated and look forward to talking to you all about issue #5 at the end of the month.
Before I go, though, want to leave you with a sneak peek at issue #5 artwork. All I can safely show, my friends -- every page chock full o' spoilers!
Take care and have a great holiday season!
Tom W.
It all makes sense now! I love breaking necks!
8)
-ms
Andrew NDB
12-01-2011, 02:14 PM
It all makes sense now! I love breaking necks!
Hm. It's that or a sleeper hold, and so far Splinter's been kind of a pacifist about killing...
Master Splinter
12-01-2011, 02:15 PM
Hm. It's that or a sleeper hold, and so far Splinter's been kind of a pacifist about killing...
Why must you ruin my dark and twisted fantasy! :-P
-ms
CyberCubed
12-01-2011, 02:26 PM
My guess is Splinter is taking out thugs and stealing their clothes for the Turtles. They need their trenchcoat disguises.
AquaParade
12-01-2011, 02:28 PM
Anyone else read Alan Moore's run on Swamp thing?
If they are going to throw the human aspect in there, I think it would be best if it was similar to Alan's run on swamp thing.
Basically what you have is the Swamp thing discovers that he is not Alex Holland, turned into a swamp creature, but instead a swamp creature that thinks he was once Alex Holland. The discovery that he never was human, but just retains the memories of a dead human was totally brilliant.
marcelangelo
12-01-2011, 03:39 PM
I wanted to say it's great to read about all your thaughts on the current issues eery month..I only get them about three weeks after your posts...so I cannot really comment much and when I can you're all looking forward to the next issue already;)...but it entertains me to read this and tom's answers and sneak peaks(even the funny ones)..I don't mind spoilers that much...It feels new and thrilling no matter what I have already heard about...
Matches Malone
12-01-2011, 03:52 PM
Hm. It's that or a sleeper hold, and so far Splinter's been kind of a pacifist about killing...
I remember after issue #1 came out that Tom made it a point to tell us that Splinter instructed the turtles not to kill for "tactical reasons" as opposed to "pacifistic reasons," implying that perhaps he's not a pacifist after all. We'll find out in a due time, I suppose
oldmanwinters
12-01-2011, 04:11 PM
I would have expected an onomatopoeia SFX if that was indeed a neck snap. But perhaps the text will be added in later?
ToTheNines
12-01-2011, 04:17 PM
Nice lookin page, it's nice to see Splinter kick some ass.
I really like the winter breath affect, too.
Matches Malone
12-02-2011, 12:52 AM
Does anyone else think that maybe the "past lives" remark isn't about reincarnation at all but that Splinter and the turtles simply had a life together, perhaps as pets, maybe even Hamato's pets, prior to being brought to StockGen? That certainly sounds more straightforward and plausible. Memories were woozy simply because they had recently undergone mutation? I dunno... Thoughts?
CyberCubed
12-02-2011, 12:59 AM
I figure something like that is possible, which is why Splinter was so protective of the turtles pre-mutation.
The fact that the only way the Foot history will make sense is if Splinter is somehow connected to Hamato Yoshi in some way. Perhaps he was Yoshi's pet in the past before somehow being brought to StockGen?
Andrew NDB
12-02-2011, 01:10 AM
I figure something like that is possible, which is why Splinter was so protective of the turtles pre-mutation.
The fact that the only way the Foot history will make sense is if Splinter is somehow connected to Hamato Yoshi in some way. Perhaps he was Yoshi's pet in the past before somehow being brought to StockGen?
Some kind of spiritual reincarnation would probably be the most sensible route, I think.
Jester
12-02-2011, 01:14 AM
Does anyone else think that maybe the "past lives" remark isn't about reincarnation at all but that Splinter and the turtles simply had a life together, perhaps as pets, maybe even Hamato's pets, prior to being brought to StockGen? That certainly sounds more straightforward and plausible. Memories were woozy simply because they had recently undergone mutation? I dunno... Thoughts?
It's a good thought...I mean, if they were Yoshi's pets, all 5, then they would assuredly have different names than the ones they received at StockGen.
azrael
12-02-2011, 08:43 AM
Krang sent his top assassin (the Shredder) to kill Yoshi and gain the ultimate weapon. Krang got what he came for the ultimate weapon "Ninjitsu". The ultimate weapon would be the blood of a supreme ninja master [Yoshi]. That is then infused that with ooze. Krang then gives Baxter the pets of Yoshi to use as test subjects. Explains there knowledge of ninja arts needing to be awaken and former lives message.
Thats my theory...
@Tom are any of the theories close on here? Of course without revealing to much.
CyberCubed
12-02-2011, 10:54 AM
Some kind of spiritual reincarnation would probably be the most sensible route, I think.
Perhaps Hamato Yoshi's soul is inside Splinter's body? This would again make Yoshi/Splinter one and the same once more, and we know in the upcoming Nick cartoon Splinter has a human origin again. Perhaps its being carried over here too, just in a slightly different way.
Yoshi's human body is dead, he somehow transfers/reincarnates his memory into his pet rat...
Andrew NDB
12-02-2011, 10:58 AM
Perhaps Hamato Yoshi's soul is inside Splinter's body? This would again make Yoshi/Splinter one and the same once more, and we know in the upcoming Nick cartoon Splinter has a human origin again. Perhaps its being carried over here too, just in a slightly different way.
Yoshi's human body is dead, he somehow transfers/reincarnates his memory into his pet rat...
That would be reasonably consistent with the cover we saw of Splinter looking an awful lot like the old guy.
And I'm not sure the Nick thing is a coincidence...
CyberCubed
12-02-2011, 11:03 AM
Yeah, although I don't like the idea of Yoshi being THAT old. The guy on the cover looks like he's about 70. If that's the case Shredder would be like 35-40 years younger.
Andrew NDB
12-02-2011, 11:05 AM
Yeah, although I don't like the idea of Yoshi being THAT old. The guy on the cover looks like he's about 70. If that's the case Shredder would be like 35-40 years younger.
I don't have a problem with that.
Slap-Happy
12-02-2011, 12:43 PM
Yeah, although I don't like the idea of Yoshi being THAT old. The guy on the cover looks like he's about 70. If that's the case Shredder would be like 35-40 years younger.
What does that matter? He's in a new mutated body.
Redeemer
12-02-2011, 12:57 PM
:teek: The Turtle Van's coming back!! :D
jk;)
You wish Technodrome time bitches!!!!
Matches Malone
12-02-2011, 02:12 PM
It's a good thought...I mean, if they were Yoshi's pets, all 5, then they would assuredly have different names than the ones they received at StockGen.
Yup. It makes more sense, I think. Even at the end of the arc, Splinter proclaims that having found Raph, their new lives can truly begin. If their new lives were meant to be taken literally as reincarnation, wouldn't their new lives have begun the moment they were reincarnated, not when they found Raph?
But if "past lives" were to be taken more figuratively, it makes more sense since their new lives as mutated beings are probably vastly different than the "past lives" they were living prior to StockGen. Either way, judging by the covers of #5, we are going to find some Japanese back story whether it be to their literal or figurative past lives, and I think we're all excited about that!
Andrew NDB
12-02-2011, 02:15 PM
Either way, judging by the covers of #5, we are going to find some Japanese back story whether it be to their literal or figurative past lives, and I think we're all excited about that!
I'm going with "cautious optimism" more than any outright excitement.
Matches Malone
12-02-2011, 02:22 PM
I'm going with "cautious optimism" more than any outright excitement.
How about curious? We're all curious! Just looking for common ground here... :twink: What'd you think about my theory? Not ruling out reincarnation completely, I just think the simplest answer can sometimes be the most sensible.
Andrew NDB
12-02-2011, 02:25 PM
How about curious? We're all curious! Just looking for common ground here... :twink: What'd you think about my theory? Not ruling out reincarnation completely, I just think the simplest answer can sometimes be the most sensible.
I don't like it, but it's probably just as likely to be true as the other theories here. I don't like the lack of distinction between sentient lives and animal lives... animals do not store or comprehend stimulae or memory in the way we do, and throwing some ooze on them one day doesn't/can't reverse engineer them into always having been that way/always having been able to process memories and stimulae in that way.
CyberCubed
12-02-2011, 05:04 PM
I still can't see how the human origin could work for the Turtles. I can understand Splinter having a human origin given its been done before in the old cartoon, Archie, and upcoming Nick cartoon, but why the Turtles?
What would the turtles possibly gain by being human? If its a quick way to explain them being teenagers, I'd rather them just be 15 months old to be honest.
Andrew NDB
12-02-2011, 05:12 PM
I still can't see how the human origin could work for the Turtles. I can understand Splinter having a human origin given its been done before in the old cartoon, Archie, and upcoming Nick cartoon, but why the Turtles?
What would the turtles possibly gain by being human? If its a quick way to explain them being teenagers, I'd rather them just be 15 months old to be honest.
If I had to guess, it's because Nick is making IDW and Tom, et al are having to come up with a -- I'm sure -- creative way of appeasing their directives.
Matches Malone
12-02-2011, 06:03 PM
I don't like it, but it's probably just as likely to be true as the other theories here. I don't like the lack of distinction between sentient lives and animal lives... animals do not store or comprehend stimulae or memory in the way we do, and throwing some ooze on them one day doesn't/can't reverse engineer them into always having been that way/always having been able to process memories and stimulae in that way.
That's true, but it is something that we've had to live with since the very first issue way back in 1984 with Splinter learning Ninjitsu by observation as a normal rat... at least what you're talking about isn't an unprecedented notion.
ToTheNines
12-02-2011, 06:42 PM
IGN review: http://comics.ign.com/articles/121/1213713p1.html
Kind of a terrible review, if you ask me. He sorta knows what he's talking about, but he's uneducated in a few aspects. Plus he bitches about Raph not being "angry and reckless", but neglects to mention that Raphael still has a lot of catching up to do due to his separation from his family.
Andrew NDB
12-02-2011, 07:49 PM
That's true, but it is something that we've had to live with since the very first issue way back in 1984 with Splinter learning Ninjitsu by observation as a normal rat... at least what you're talking about isn't an unprecedented notion.
I think the general consensus is that Splinter wasn't a normal rat in the Mirage material, as Peter Laird has alluded to on his blog (a story was to be told, but then they never quite bothered to tell it). The thing that impressed me about the early IDW stuff so far with Splinter was that, unlike the Mirage material, it looked like they were giving a scientific basis for why Splinter wasn't a normal rat... but now considering them compounding things even further with, "Oh, he's also the reincarnation of a ninja master" or "he was also a human mind-transferred to a rat" or "he was also a human mutated into a normal rat" then it is kind of retarding all of that progress they seemingly made, in my book.
TomWaltz
12-02-2011, 07:56 PM
IGN review: http://comics.ign.com/articles/121/1213713p1.html
Kind of a terrible review, if you ask me. He sorta knows what he's talking about, but he's uneducated in a few aspects. Plus he bitches about Raph not being "angry and reckless", but neglects to mention that Raphael still has a lot of catching up to do due to his separation from his family.
Hey, ToTheNines -- here's a fun review!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXu7Rl2vV-c&feature=player_embedded
CyberCubed
12-02-2011, 08:36 PM
That guy should do YouTube reviews of the whole series.
Andrew NDB
12-02-2011, 11:34 PM
So I finally read #4. Submitted my review to firstcomicsnews.com.
It's pretty cool.
Cowabunga Carl
12-03-2011, 01:34 AM
Picked up #4 today and I liked it. Of course it feels a little off on it's own but when read with the first three it feels complete. I'll probably pick up the trade too when it comes out and keep the single issues all nice and neat.
CyberCubed
12-03-2011, 10:07 AM
Read all 4 issues back to back, the story is much more cohesive and entertaining now. Of course I imagine this is the way they're meant to be read, hence that TPB coming out in Feb. which collects these first 4 issues.
I suppose this is how this series will always be, you will need to read it chunks at a time to appreciate the full story. I wonder if there will be one-issue "filler" stories in this series....separate from the multi-part arcs.
ToTheNines
12-03-2011, 10:10 AM
I'm fairly certain the next one will be a good read as a single issue, and I'd also wager that the Microseries issues will be satisfying on their own.
Plus the next arc is 3 issues, so that should help things. Then we got 2 issues of Infestation that are coming out within the same month.
TomWaltz
12-03-2011, 10:52 AM
So I finally read #4. Submitted my review to firstcomicsnews.com.
It's pretty cool.
Look forward to reading your review, amigo!
Donnie
12-03-2011, 06:05 PM
Finally read #4. As usual, IDW keeps you wanting more. I loved when the Turtles came on the scene to save Raphael. It's interesting to me that IDW is really focusing on (as evident in #3) Donnie's "coldly analytical" side. He would have let Raphael finish Hob.
Matches Malone
12-03-2011, 06:57 PM
Anyone else think Baxter Stockman looks like he colored his hair with a sharpie this issue? Especially the panel where he is talking about Krang?
Powder
12-03-2011, 07:07 PM
I dunno, but there's a good chance that that is exactly how his hair is colored.
Ya know, 'cause he's a drawing. :trazz:
Matches Malone
12-03-2011, 08:06 PM
I dunno, but there's a good chance that that is exactly how his hair is colored.
Ya know, 'cause he's a drawing. :trazz:
Baxter's not bad... he's just drawn that way.
CyberCubed
12-03-2011, 10:46 PM
So where exactly is Krang getting the mutagen from? Does he make it himself? Is it stolen from his, "competitors?" Is it from Dimension X?
Donnie
12-03-2011, 11:03 PM
Two things that still need some explaining in my opinion is this apparent relationship between Raphael and Old Hob. Hob just left baby Raph behind, it seems as though he has had absolutely no relationship with him - yet he acts like Raphael would remember him. How would a baby, no matter what mutagen you're crawling around in, recognize or remember anything?
The fight scene when the Turtles came into the fray was great. I notice Leo's weapons are taking a more passive approach thus far, but Mikey and Donnie's weapons are seeing full blown action.
Andrew NDB
12-04-2011, 01:16 AM
So where exactly is Krang getting the mutagen from? Does he make it himself? Is it stolen from his, "competitors?" Is it from Dimension X?
I would be surprised if an actual alternate dimension of "Dimension X" ever shows up in IDW... I don't know of anyone who really thought that was a good idea in any universe (even the Archie folks, who quietly just made it another galaxy).
Other side of the galaxy/universe/Utrom territories? Sure.
Two things that still need some explaining in my opinion is this apparent relationship between Raphael and Old Hob. Hob just left baby Raph behind, it seems as though he has had absolutely no relationship with him - yet he acts like Raphael would remember him. How would a baby, no matter what mutagen you're crawling around in, recognize or remember anything?
The IDW universe seems to be indicating that as soon as you get exposed to mutagen, you remember everything from when you were a normal animal -- everything -- just as if you were a normal sentient the whole time.
I don't like it and I don't think it holds up to any kind of scientific scrutiny, but it seems to be the way they're proceeding.
The fight scene when the Turtles came into the fray was great. I notice Leo's weapons are taking a more passive approach thus far, but Mikey and Donnie's weapons are seeing full blown action.
So far. The Turtles were given very strict "no kill" orders about Old Hob and his gang for some reason early on. The general hope is that when the Turtles go on to fight "real" battles with fellow ninja and all that, the kid gloves will be suitably off.
Donnie
12-04-2011, 10:44 AM
The IDW universe seems to be indicating that as soon as you get exposed to mutagen, you remember everything from when you were a normal animal -- everything -- just as if you were a normal sentient the whole time.
I don't like it and I don't think it holds up to any kind of scientific scrutiny, but it seems to be the way they're proceeding.
I have to agree with you here Andrew. I guess we'll see where they take it.
azrael
12-04-2011, 11:19 AM
The IDW universe seems to be indicating that as soon as you get exposed to mutagen, you remember everything from when you were a normal animal -- everything -- just as if you were a normal sentient the whole time.
I don't like it and I don't think it holds up to any kind of scientific scrutiny, but it seems to be the way they're proceeding.
Why wouldnt they remember?
The Mirage-verse mutants remember. How else would Splinter teach them Ninjitsu?
Matches Malone
12-04-2011, 12:09 PM
Why wouldnt they remember?
The Mirage-verse mutants remember. How else would Splinter teach them Ninjitsu?
Yeah, I believe normal animals have memories too. Perhaps they can't process them in the same complex fashion as humans or share them with us, but they do have memories.
Matches Malone
12-04-2011, 12:14 PM
So where exactly is Krang getting the mutagen from? Does he make it himself? Is it stolen from his, "competitors?" Is it from Dimension X?
The "competitors" were the ones who broke in to steal the mutagen so I think we can safely rule them out.
I just hope mutagen actually is hard to come by in this series. Archie Krang said the same thing yet every issue had mutagen being thrown away left and right. Plus all the aliens and gods who happen to be athropomorphic animals rendered that "plot point" of the rarity of mutagen completely meaningless.
Andrew NDB
12-04-2011, 02:06 PM
Why wouldnt they remember?
The Mirage-verse mutants remember. How else would Splinter teach them Ninjitsu?
Because they'd already been exposed when he was doing the teaching.
The only kicker is "How did Splinter memorize ninjitsu as a normal, un-exposed rat from his cage?" The answer, according to Peter Laird's blog, is that he wasn't supposed to be a normal rat... we just never got the story (or even a story) on that.
Yeah, I believe normal animals have memories too. Perhaps they can't process them in the same complex fashion as humans or share them with us, but they do have memories.
Tests conducted at the University of Michigan and the Department of Animal Behaviour at the American Museum of Natural History have concluded that while canine memory last no more than 5 minutes, a cat's recall can last as long as 16 hours, exceeding even that of monkeys and orangutans. Though cats have a memory that can be up to 200 times more retentive than a dog's, they will only remember what they consider to be useful, and therefore their memory can be quite selective. And turtles' and rats' brains are many times smaller than all of these.
The article "Do Cats Have Intelligence" has lots more information that you might find interesting.
http://www.messybeast.com/intelligence.htm
Andrew NDB
12-04-2011, 02:07 PM
My review is up:
http://www.firstcomicsnews.com/?p=35527
Donnie
12-04-2011, 02:23 PM
My review is up:
http://www.firstcomicsnews.com/?p=35527
Nice review. As I was reading, I began thinking that there is something else to this "psychotropic serum" that we don't know yet. Could this "serum" be somehow extracted from Hamato Yoshi (pertaining to his memory, perhaps)? If so, did Hamato have students that also had their memories extracted? This seems unlikely though, as the Turtles weren't being tested with the serum (as far as we know).
CyberCubed
12-04-2011, 02:32 PM
I feel the next issue will make or break the origin for me. It really depends on what the Turtles actually are. As I said I don't mind Splinter/Yoshi being connected in some way, but the Turtles have never had any relation to humans before.
Shockdingo
12-04-2011, 06:25 PM
Personally I'm liking the slower pace and drastic changes to the origin. I don't know why, but all this freshness is genuinely making me excited for every new panel. By going against the grain I'm speculating more than I usually do with comics, and it's more fun that I've had in a long while.
I really think the psyochotropic drug has a bizarre role to play into this. I'm looking at how it could be of use to Krang and I'm thinking it has some "derivitive memory" or "past life" element to the whole thing. (I've been going with horrendously disfigured man wanting to get his life back theory, thus him looking at body transferrence) Splinter knows more than he's letting on and he was the one getting the drug, not the boys.
TomWaltz
12-05-2011, 12:05 PM
My review is up:
http://www.firstcomicsnews.com/?p=35527
Good stuff, Andrew! Thanks!
Tom W.
Andrew NDB
12-05-2011, 01:26 PM
Good stuff, Andrew! Thanks!
Tom W.
My pleasure. Keep it up, sir.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
12-05-2011, 01:47 PM
I can't wait to order this book. I'm just waiting on Raphael to hit the shelves so that I can order both books at once.
TheCollector
12-05-2011, 07:27 PM
Finally got #4, pretty good issue, just as good as the others.
And big mystery of the issue, what's Splinter talking about about them being a family before and him being their sensei and father before as well. Really wondering what that's all about. Were they not always turtles this time around? Who knows, and I can't wait to find out.
pannoni1
12-05-2011, 08:06 PM
A nice, fair and unbiased review by Tom W. At least we don't have to wait three months as opposed to several weeks between issues in the old days. But having only 22 pages and having a decent shot really means that you must say a lot in just a short span in order for the issue to be satisfying.
And the "family" concept is nothing new; the turtles of course are the Sensei's adopted "sons/students!" I'm enjoying these reviews and get the story just from these threads, but I'd rather wait until I see a lot of issues on eBay for a better value (that's how I collected my earlier comics).
CyberCubed
12-05-2011, 08:12 PM
Hamato Yoshi may have had real human sons in the past. How they are connected to the Turtles is beyond me. Seems like it runs the risk of complicating the origin story and causing a mixed reaction depending on what it is.
Since Nick has to approve story ideas I suppose it is something not too strange that would alter views on the franchise.
Venom
12-05-2011, 11:31 PM
I wonder just who the hell sits at Nick approving story points anyway.
Donnie
12-06-2011, 12:43 AM
I wonder just who the hell sits at Nick approving story points anyway.
Nick led on that they weren't really too involved with IDW's title, but I have a feeling that was all too good to be true...I love IDW's TMNT thus far though, so I just hope Nick doesn't get TOO involved, that's all.
CyberCubed
12-06-2011, 01:31 AM
I asked Bobby about Nick's involvement over at the IDW forums, here's what he replied:
Hey Cubed,
As with any license holder (at least that I've had to deal with at IDW), Nick has to approve everything. That includes proposals, finished scripts, and art work.
That being said there are no directives, nothing we must do. (Well, at the start we had a mutual discussion about general tone and direction, but we all happened to be on the same page). We're free to come up with whatever we want, and nothing has been forced on us because of the upcoming 'toon or whatever.
There have been a couple ideas, and some art work that I thought was pretty cool, that was either been rejected or a substantial tweak was asked for. So I don't agree with them 100% of the time, but that's to be expected in any creative relationship. By and large, I've agreed with the large majority of what they've had to say, and in a couple instances they've come up with a good fix on something we were stumped with.
I hope that answers the question.
So yeah, it does seem like Nick does have a say on the series. Thankfully they seem to be giving Tom Waltz and IDW much freedom to do what they want so far. So all seems well.
Andrew NDB
12-06-2011, 01:42 AM
So yeah, it does seem like Nick does have a say on the series. Thankfully they seem to be giving Tom Waltz and IDW much freedom to do what they want so far. So all seems well.
Well that's great to hear. Definitely one of those times where I'm happy to be wrong.
Donnie
12-07-2011, 09:26 PM
I asked Bobby about Nick's involvement over at the IDW forums, here's what he replied:
So yeah, it does seem like Nick does have a say on the series. Thankfully they seem to be giving Tom Waltz and IDW much freedom to do what they want so far. So all seems well.
That's definitely good news that they still have most of the freedoms we figured they had. With Nick approving everything, I guess I don't have to worry about a Cyborg Donatello. :lol:
Andrew NDB
12-07-2011, 09:42 PM
With Nick approving everything, I guess I don't have to worry about a Cyborg Donatello. :lol:
No, you just have to worry about a whole bag of other things.
TomWaltz
12-09-2011, 03:47 PM
No, you just have to worry about a whole bag of other things.
Whole bag of other things, Andrew? You mean like this?
http://engrishfunny.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/engrish-funny-it-even-comes-in-a-handy-bag.jpg
Heh!
Andrew NDB
12-09-2011, 04:35 PM
Whole bag of other things, Andrew? You mean like this?
http://engrishfunny.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/engrish-funny-it-even-comes-in-a-handy-bag.jpg
Heh!
Hah! Hey, you said it, not me. :)
Matches Malone
12-09-2011, 05:28 PM
Whole bag of other things, Andrew? You mean like this?
http://engrishfunny.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/engrish-funny-it-even-comes-in-a-handy-bag.jpg
Heh!
I like that the lady is holding a bag of the chips creating an endless loop of chips within that one bag! You're on the other side of the looking glass now, Tom...
TomWaltz
12-09-2011, 05:51 PM
I like that the lady is holding a bag of the chips creating an endless loop of chips within that one bag! You're on the other side of the looking glass now, Tom...
Like the "Last Visible Dog" from one of the greatest children's stories ever put to print: http://www.ocelotfactory.com/hoban/mouse.html
1984TMNT
12-09-2011, 06:01 PM
Whole bag of other things, Andrew? You mean like this?
http://engrishfunny.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/engrish-funny-it-even-comes-in-a-handy-bag.jpg
Heh!
I literally just LOL'ed! Haha :)
Anyone received their copy of the Hembeck variant (Cover RI B; 25 copy Retailer Incentive) for #4? I just picked up my LCS order and it wasn't in the stack...they said it hadn't come in yet. That seems odd...
Donnie
12-17-2011, 04:02 PM
Anyone received their copy of the Hembeck variant (Cover RI B; 25 copy Retailer Incentive) for #4? I just picked up my LCS order and it wasn't in the stack...they said it hadn't come in yet. That seems odd...
I got mine. I'm looking to sell it though, I hate it.
I got mine. I'm looking to sell it though, I hate it.
Thanks for letting me know it is at least out...sorry you hate it.
Toby Barrett
12-17-2011, 04:34 PM
Can't say I'm a fan of it either. Can't understand why a turtle would need to wear a loin cloth.
Donnie
12-17-2011, 05:23 PM
Thanks for letting me know it is at least out...sorry you hate it.
No need to apologize! It's just personal taste.
Venom
12-17-2011, 07:02 PM
I got mine the day #4 hit! I was pleased to learn I had a comic shop relatively near that ordered that many TMNT books because I had been previously paid 8 bucks for #2, and 21 for #3 on mycomicshop, and only paid ~10 for #4 thru the LCS! :D
I really enjoy the Hembeck covers, it's goofy in a fun way and reminds me of the silly covers during the Hedden & McWeeney run of Mirage's comics.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.