PDA

View Full Version : IDW's Turtles seem to be human height!


Donnie
12-11-2011, 01:33 PM
Has anybody noticed in Raphael #1 that Raphael is the same height as Casey?

Has IDW decided to make their Turtles human height? If so, does this increase the chances of that human connection we all fear? I believe it does...

Hermano Dyvas
12-11-2011, 01:46 PM
It's funny, I was looking at the pages with Raph and Casey earlier today and I noticed the exact same thing, in fact he even looked a bit taller then Casey, especially at the end. Then again when you look at the regular series Casey is clearly taller then Raph, not that much though. It might be a style thing.

However like someone else said in another thread, if there is one thing that makes me suspect we'll have Human turtles this time around it's the cover of #5. Those four human guys with the same expression as our green guys.

I have a feeling IDW's #5 is going to be a mindblowing issue.

CyberCubed
12-11-2011, 01:54 PM
Or a shark jumping issue. The turtles being humans in some form will certainly raise its share of criticism similar to April being a drawing in Vol 4.

But the Turtles are the main characters and to see them suddenly have a human past after 26 years of being plain ordinary Turtles is certainly going to have a mixed reaction from fans. Some might even abandon the series.

Hermano Dyvas
12-11-2011, 02:04 PM
Or a shark jumping issue. The turtles being humans in some form will certainly raise its share of criticism similar to April being a drawing in Vol 4.

But the Turtles are the main characters and to see them suddenly have a human past after 26 years of being plain ordinary Turtles is certainly going to have a mixed reaction from fans. Some might even abandon the series.

I agree, it could be a positive or a negative mindblowing. Personally I'm not too happy about them being humans either, but I will at least check it out.

oldmanwinters
12-11-2011, 02:07 PM
Or a shark jumping issue. The turtles being humans in some form will certainly raise its share of criticism similar to April being a drawing in Vol 4.

But the Turtles are the main characters and to see them suddenly have a human past after 26 years of being plain ordinary Turtles is certainly going to have a mixed reaction from fans. Some might even abandon the series.

The thing is, nobody really read Mirage Vol. 4, so that's a trivia fact known only by the most hard-core of TMNT fans. IDW is actually being read by a fairly large audience. It'll be interesting to see how the public reacts if the TMNT are indeed revealed to be of human-origin

Hermano Dyvas
12-11-2011, 02:18 PM
Issue 5 is going to introduce us to multi-colored bandanas and human origins. Some fans are going to get a heart attack! :lol:

Powder
12-11-2011, 03:21 PM
I like my turtles human height, so that's kinda neat.

Donnie
12-11-2011, 03:55 PM
I always preferred the smaller, Mirage sized Turtles. I thought it looked cooler, seeing them shorter than April yet able to deal so much damage.

AcidBurn30
12-11-2011, 04:36 PM
no, it was made by a different person who did the art..i'm shock you didn't bring up the shredder, bebop and rockstady..

Powder
12-11-2011, 04:43 PM
no, it was made by a different person who did the art..i'm shock you didn't bring up the shredder, bebop and rockstady..


I'm going to give you a second chance to make some sense.

Go.

Birdman37
12-11-2011, 05:53 PM
I dont get all this "r they human" did yall not see Raphael CLEARLY going from baby turtle to his mutated self in issue 4. how is this still in question?

Matches Malone
12-11-2011, 05:56 PM
I dont get all this "r they human" did yall not see Raphael CLEARLY going from baby turtle to his mutated self in issue 4. how is this still in question?

Beats me. No idea why cryptic and vague clues are stronger evidence than actually seeing a turtle mutate.

Toby Barrett
12-11-2011, 06:20 PM
Was just about to say the same thing. It's ridiculous.

Andrew NDB
12-11-2011, 06:31 PM
I'm still surprised no one is talking about what Eastman said in the back of the TMNT ashcan about them waking up as humans.

marcelangelo
12-11-2011, 06:31 PM
Issue 5 is going to introduce us to multi-colored bandanas and human origins. Some fans are going to get a heart attack! :lol:

oh yeah?I haven't read that anywhere, I think I see wher you're comming from...being that the raphael book is actĂșally to take place after issue 5 right and we saw them with multi colors in that book in one pannel...but to me that was only a micro series thing that wasn't considered too serious...after all tristan wrote here that he had a working idea for the different bandanas and so I don't think we'll get them in the comming issue...

Donnie
12-11-2011, 06:39 PM
I'm going to give you a second chance to make some sense.

Go.

:lol:

Beats me. No idea why cryptic and vague clues are stronger evidence than actually seeing a turtle mutate.

I dont get all this "r they human" did yall not see Raphael CLEARLY going from baby turtle to his mutated self in issue 4. how is this still in question?

Have you guys seen the covers to #5? There is clearly some sort of comparison or connection that we have yet to know about. Just because we saw Raphael mutate doesn't mean that the mutagen had nothing to do with human DNA or memory transplanting, or some other as yet unexplained connection with humans and Turtles. The mutagen was described as "super soldier" in #4. There is something we don't know yet.

Toby Barrett
12-11-2011, 06:43 PM
From the clues issue 4 gave us, it only seems as though Splinter and the turtles are reincarnations. That doesn't necessarily mean the turtles are human now.

Donnie
12-11-2011, 06:45 PM
From the clues issue 4 gave us, it only seems as though Splinter and the turtles are reincarnations. That doesn't necessarily mean the turtles are human now.

No it doesn't, but it doesn't mean you should just throw that possibility out the window simply because we saw Raphael mutate.

Toby Barrett
12-11-2011, 06:48 PM
I disagree. I believe seeing Raphael mutate with my own eyes is a perfect reason to disgard the theory that they're little boys turned turtle.

Donnie
12-11-2011, 06:50 PM
I disagree. I believe seeing Raphael mutate with my own eyes is a perfect reason to disgard the theory that they're little boys turned turtle.

The guys we see on #5 aren't "little boys"...they're teens. The human connection is still very much possible.

Plus, in Raphael's micro Bebop & Rocksteady are begging to be mutated, which means we know that humans-to-mutants are possible. The way they were talking made it sound like Alopex may have been mutated from a human, too. I have a hunch her origin is bogus.

Toby Barrett
12-11-2011, 06:56 PM
Bebop and Rocksteady mutated from humans in the OT as well, but I don't remember four teenagers turning into turtles in that series.

Andrew NDB
12-11-2011, 06:56 PM
From the clues issue 4 gave us, it only seems as though Splinter and the turtles are reincarnations.

It's gotta be that, or something close to that.

My first theory, based on what clues we can gather and what else we can discern: Hamato Yoshi in Japan had 4 sons, or otherwise 4 ninja pupils that he raised as sons. Something terrible happens (probably related to the Shredder) and all of them are killed. Hamato Yoshi is reincarnated as a normal rat, the four pupils/four sons of Yoshi are reincarnated as normal sea turtles. When Splinter is given the "psychotropic" serum, this enables him to be aware of his past life, and somehow enables him to see the Turtles' previous lives as well. After all 5 of them are mutated and after #4, how the Turtles are now reunited, it becomes a matter of Splinter helping the Turtles remember their past lives and in doing so, they remember the full extent of their previous ninja training. Probably in little increments here and there.

The biggest problem with this first theory of mine is... how did Stockman's company just happen to round up a rat and 4 sea turtles that were from the same family in their past life? I mean, it's easy to buy that they rounded up 4 baby sea turtles from the same batch of eggs... but then the same company just happens to stumble on the reincarnation of these turtles' former father/father figure too? This kind of makes me throw my theory out the window, unless this will be left in there as a contrivance.

So I'm not really sure what to believe is going to happen next. The other scenarios I play out in my head sound pretty messy... ones like, Hamato Yoshi and his children/pupils being abducted by Shredder or Krang, mutated into baby turtles and a rat, then shipped off to Stockman as some kind of punishment.

Donnie
12-11-2011, 06:59 PM
Bebop and Rocksteady mutated from humans in the OT as well, but I don't remember four teenagers turning into turtles in that series.

So what? Everybody is all "these are NEW interpretations of Bebop & Rocksteady, they are going to badass!" If this is a new take on B & R, then their origin relating to the OT shouldn't be associated with the TMNT's origin from the OT. This is a new breed of Turtles. Just 'cause B & R's origins are matching up doesn't mean the Turtles will.

Toby Barrett
12-11-2011, 07:01 PM
Except we saw Raph mutate, which is all the proof I need. It should be the proof anyone needs.

Andrew NDB
12-11-2011, 07:03 PM
Except we saw Raph mutate, which is all the proof I need. It should be the proof anyone needs.

That is only proof that the IDW TMNT grew into humanoid Turtles from baby Turtles directly. Where they something before they were baby turtles? <-- that's the question. Splinter in #4 and future covers seem to indicate a pretty clear "Yes"... we just don't know if it's literal or spiritual.

Donnie
12-11-2011, 07:08 PM
That is only proof that the IDW TMNT grew into humanoid Turtles from baby Turtles directly. Where they something before they were baby turtles? <-- that's the question. Splinter in #4 and future covers seem to indicate a pretty clear "Yes"... we just don't know if it's literal or spiritual.

Exxxxactly.

CyberCubed
12-11-2011, 10:48 PM
Wow, Andrew you might be spot on with that post. Its like Hamato Yoshi had 4 teenage sons. They might all get killed by Shredder or whomever and their souls were reincarnated into the normals animals.

This would explain why the Turtles are "teenagers" despite only being mutated for 15 months. I don't like this theory, but it fits the best.

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
12-12-2011, 09:44 AM
if the turltes was those 4 humans we see in issue 5 and then they mutated into turtles then they would have been mutated in teen turtles not babies. But as we saw they were normal baby turtles before mutation. now there is also the possibility that these 4 humans died and then they were born again as animals.... and that they remeberd they previous life.... i dont think something like this can happen

Cowabunga Carl
12-12-2011, 10:01 AM
I'm not against seeing what IDW does with the TMNT. I mean it is clear something more then them just being animals is going on. He even makes comment about them taking names that they are more used to now then their old names. So it's clear we are supposed to think something is up.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
12-12-2011, 10:07 AM
However like someone else said in another thread, if there is one thing that makes me suspect we'll have Human turtles this time around it's the cover of #5. Those four human guys with the same expression as our green guys.

Link? I don't believe I've seen this cover.

Cowabunga Carl
12-12-2011, 10:31 AM
Here is a picture I found of cover A and B side by side. These are the covers that everyone are trying to figure out what the images mean.

http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/TMNT-05_Cover-AB-Art-reflection.jpg

Venom
12-12-2011, 01:09 PM
Here is a picture I found of cover A and B side by side. These are the covers that everyone are trying to figure out what the images mean.

http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/TMNT-05_Cover-AB-Art-reflection.jpg

That's old, Hob; it was posted a couple weeks back. :twink:

Cowabunga Carl
12-12-2011, 01:27 PM
I know but Ch'rell was asking what people were talking about. Thought I'd give him a link to find it easier.

Venom
12-12-2011, 03:22 PM
I know but Ch'rell was asking what people were talking about. Thought I'd give him a link to find it easier.

Lol, I know man, I just wanted a reason to use your name in the post. :P

Cowabunga Carl
12-12-2011, 03:42 PM
I feel really slow now as I did not see what you had done there tell you pointed it out. Wow been a long week already.

Back on topic though after looking at the covers some more I can see why people would start thinking there is going to be a human dynamic to the TMNT.

1984TMNT
12-12-2011, 04:05 PM
I feel really slow now as I did not see what you had done there tell you pointed it out. Wow been a long week already.

Back on topic though after looking at the covers some more I can see why people would start thinking there is going to be a human dynamic to the TMNT.

Yeah, same here Hob. I'm waiting to see what "actually" happens, but so far I'm pretty nervous about a supposed "human" element to the Turtles origin...yuck.

Cowabunga Carl
12-12-2011, 04:59 PM
You know I don't know if I really mind that at all though. I mean if you think about it we have had Splinter as Hamato Yoshi before and that is the way Nick is going in the new toon too. We had Bebop and Rocksteady before also. So I mean they've done human to mutant before. I don't think the Turtles were like mutated from human to turtle, pretty sure if they do go that route it will be reincarnation. But that opens up another whole can or worms.

Funny that this doesn't bother me as much as having Bebop and Rocksteady back :-/

Powder
12-12-2011, 05:34 PM
I've still got my fingers crossed that these guys are reincarnations of the Mirage turtles. :trazz:

Candy Kappa
12-12-2011, 06:20 PM
They could go "Memories in DNA" route like Mirage and the Super Soldier serum contains Yoshi/Ninja Master and his Sons/Students DNA.

Could already be injected into the animals and the memories and mannerisms then gets activated when they mutate

pannoni1
12-12-2011, 06:53 PM
"Human height" can really be vague phrase as technically with the turtles around 5 feet is typical of a short woman, and some are even shorter than that. Remember, we don't know anything more than what has been officially released. There have already been some height variations of the turtles (and Splinter, Shredder, and April) over different incarnations in TMNT history. It would assume that these turtles just got the taller DNA genes!

Andrew NDB
12-12-2011, 06:55 PM
"Human height" can really be vague phrase

Yeah, no kidding. I mean, my mom is like 4'10" and she probably would take a bit of offense to being told she's not proper "human height."

marcelangelo
12-12-2011, 06:58 PM
if the turltes was those 4 humans we see in issue 5 and then they mutated into turtles then they would have been mutated in teen turtles not babies. But as we saw they were normal baby turtles before mutation. now there is also the possibility that these 4 humans died and then they were born again as animals.... and that they remeberd they previous life.... i dont think something like this can happen

hahahaha, you know that's a lota rubbish;)...you just mentioned a line of theories about a)reincarnation, b)wandering of the soul from human to animal, but exclude that they could remember anything from their past life since that IS NOT POSSIBLE?;):.....
hahahaha, that's a lot of tough to swallow stuff, too, you know?;)

Donnie
12-12-2011, 07:57 PM
"Human height" can really be vague phrase as technically with the turtles around 5 feet is typical of a short woman, and some are even shorter than that. Remember, we don't know anything more than what has been officially released. There have already been some height variations of the turtles (and Splinter, Shredder, and April) over different incarnations in TMNT history. It would assume that these turtles just got the taller DNA genes!

Everyone knew I meant the average height of a human male...an American male...one should assume I'm not including average female height in relation to the Turtles. They're dudes.

Birdman37
12-13-2011, 03:53 PM
The guys we see on #5 aren't "little boys"...they're teens. The human connection is still very much possible.

Plus, in Raphael's micro Bebop & Rocksteady are begging to be mutated, which means we know that humans-to-mutants are possible. The way they were talking made it sound like Alopex may have been mutated from a human, too. I have a hunch her origin is bogus.

Beepop and Rocksteady were humans turned into mutants in the cartoon too... seems like me just the same thing going there...

It just seems like some of u guys WANT to find a reason to hate the new comic. I know u love the old ones, great, just enjoy this one. IF something like that ends up happening and u hate it, stop reading it. Seems like some ppl wanna freak out over something thats not even close to being confirmed.

Donnie
12-13-2011, 08:29 PM
It just seems like some of u guys WANT to find a reason to hate the new comic. I know u love the old ones, great, just enjoy this one. IF something like that ends up happening and u hate it, stop reading it. Seems like some ppl wanna freak out over something thats not even close to being confirmed.

You know, I'm getting a little tired of everybody assuming people who express concern about certain characters (be it as "trivial" as attire or as deep as character development) or story-arcs are getting labeled as "haters" of the new comic. When has anybody "freaked out"? Give me a break. I own every issue IDW has put out, and I almost have all of the variants, too. I am totally behind this new series, and I'm loving every second of this new and refreshing ride. The writing thus far has been spectacular.

That doesn't mean we should just bow down and accept everything that comes our way. We're fans. We're allowed to speculate, allowed to draw conclusions to what evidence is so far given, and we are allowed to (dare I say) criticize something that we may not like. That's what fans do. That has absolutely nothing to do with liking or disliking a series as a whole. I am wholly behind this new series, and will be until Donatello is made cyborg. ;)

Powder
12-13-2011, 08:34 PM
My man. The nail has been hit on it's purdy 'lil head.

Kendamu
12-13-2011, 10:14 PM
They could go "Memories in DNA" route like Mirage and the Super Soldier serum contains Yoshi/Ninja Master and his Sons/Students DNA.

Could already be injected into the animals and the memories and mannerisms then gets activated when they mutate
I thought about that as well. Either way, I'm pretty excited to know what happens, but I'm not sure if human to animal to mutant is really the way I would've preferred things going.

CyberCubed
12-13-2011, 10:25 PM
I don't like the idea of the Turtles being anything related to humans, so I'll try to ignore it best I can once the whole "origin story" phase is over.

I know there will be good stories in the future, but I don't want to deal with any crazy origin so I'll just let it be and move on.

Cowabunga Carl
12-13-2011, 10:37 PM
While it wouldn't kill it for me at the same time it would be a big change. I've heard people talk about the IDW book in terms of what Marvel did with the Ultimate line and I had issues there too. I mean making Cable Wolverine was a big change to the character. It felt wrong and awkward to me. Also making Wolverine's blood a drug bothered me too. Sometimes change isn't good.

CyberCubed
12-13-2011, 10:39 PM
Sometimes "changing things just for the sake of changing things" doesn't always yield the best results.

I understand wanting a fresh take on things without re-treading old ground, but if you go too far out-there it feels like it strays too far from the source material.

Sometimes the risk pays off, (Shredder being an Utrom in the 4kids show got generally accepted as time passed), but others it isn't.

Cowabunga Carl
12-13-2011, 10:47 PM
Exactly my point Cubed. To change things for the sake of changing them is just insane. Sometimes things worked for a reason. Of course on the flip side something that worked once does not mean it will work again.

sdp
12-13-2011, 11:10 PM
I think that IDW is trying to cater to the people who grew up with the OT, so they are doing a re-imagining of the OT so to say with this universe, taking elements of the OT and writing for an older fan base. I think this is terrible idea though, since I think they'll be missing the point of what made the OT turtles great and what makes more mature turtles great. Who knows, what the future holds for the series though, to early to tell I guess.