View Full Version : TMNT #7 -- Preview/Discussion Thread
Andrew NDB
02-24-2012, 08:18 PM
Haven't got my issue. I might go tomorrow and get it. I'm really torn on this series. I like it and the new stuff, just not digging the whole OT feel it's starting to get.
I kind of feel like, in a way, a lot of us Mirage readers might be like... what's a good example... maybe like frogs in a pot of boiling water. You know, at first the water is cool and room temperature (red bandannas, the Turtles tangling with ordinary thugs, a unique but relatively grounded origin story)... then gradually the temperature starts rising in the water, but we don't realize it because it's happening so gradually (more and more animal mutants show up, here come the rainbow bandannas, and the OS elements and feel creeps to the forefront)... then eventually the water is boiling, and by that time it's too late to jump out of the water because we're dead (one day we'll open up an issue of the comic and it's like a full-on Fred Wolf reinactment).
But I hope not.
Donnie
02-24-2012, 08:23 PM
As long as it stays more 2k3 than OT, I'll be fine! Even if it does lean more toward the OT though, I won't stop buying...I'm definitely hooked.
CyberCubed
02-24-2012, 08:38 PM
It's basically the original cartoon reimagined into a more serious series.
I have no problem with that, but I do agree it shouldn't be *all* OT and little Mirage.
AquaParade
02-24-2012, 08:52 PM
I kind of feel like, in a way, a lot of us Mirage readers might be like... what's a good example... maybe like frogs in a pot of boiling water. You know, at first the water is cool and room temperature (red bandannas, the Turtles tangling with ordinary thugs, a unique but relatively grounded origin story)... then gradually the temperature starts rising in the water, but we don't realize it because it's happening so gradually (more and more animal mutants show up, here come the rainbow bandannas, and the OS elements and feel creeps to the forefront)... then eventually the water is boiling, and by that time it's too late to jump out of the water because we're dead (one day we'll open up an issue of the comic and it's like a full-on Fred Wolf reinactment).
But I hope not.
Scary analogy. I too have felt the rising influence of the Fred Wolf TMNT era.
My guess is that we are basically at the point where we can "feel" the vibe this book is going to maintain. Yes, it's gradually lightened up a bit, but we are still getting potent, interesting threads, that maybe interest Mirage fans. Stuff like Donatello's doubt in his father, the internal conflict this brings to the family, and the bittersweet ;) death and supposed reunion of Hamato Yoshi and his sons. As long as Tom and Kevin can keep delivering the goods, the zany side of the story stays in check, in my opinion.
Just one question....
Why Frogs?
Andrew NDB
02-24-2012, 08:54 PM
Just one question....
Why Frogs?
Because that's what really happens:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog
AquaParade
02-24-2012, 08:58 PM
Because that's what really happens:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog
Cool! Well, tragic, but still pretty neat.
Venom
02-24-2012, 09:08 PM
Speaking of frogs, when the hell do the Punk Frogs show up? We all know they moonlighted as the Battletoads. :twink:
Seriously, if we're going to have reimagined Fred Wolf elements, give us the one set of characters that could prove worthy antitheses to the Turtles. They were named after conquerers for chrissakes!!
Jester
02-24-2012, 09:19 PM
I was honestly thinking how weird it would be if the Mutanimals were created by Shredder or Krang or Baxter as an attempt to "DESTROY THE TURTLES!"
Powder
02-24-2012, 09:24 PM
Wouldn't be weird, it'd just be very OT. They fight for Shredder, turtles tell 'em the truth, they become good guys. Credits roll. Yawn.
AquaParade
02-24-2012, 09:33 PM
Speaking of frogs, when the hell do the Punk Frogs show up? We all know they moonlighted as the Battletoads. :twink:
Seriously, if we're going to have reimagined Fred Wolf elements, give us the one set of characters that could prove worthy antitheses to the Turtles. They were named after conquerers for chrissakes!!
Actually, I can personally imagine the Punk frogs being done in a cool way. Maybe bring an actual 'punk' element to it. There are a few ways I could see this being really neat, and many more ways I could see it being totally lame.
Venom
02-24-2012, 09:34 PM
I agree with Powder.
If IDW has a version of the Mutanimals, I would hope they were a ragtag team of mutant and alien misfits across the ethical spectrum who came together basically because no one else wanted them or they had no other place to go (perhaps have a fugitive, rogue soldier, thief, cop, naive bystander (thinke Sara in Vol. 3, etc.) and would be a companion mini or so focusing on how these individuals learn to trust one another and work as a team in the face of adversity.
Alopex could become a member, and probably would.
I dunno, just letting my mind wander...
Jester
02-24-2012, 09:34 PM
Wouldn't be weird, it'd just be very OT. They fight for Shredder, turtles tell 'em the truth, they become good guys. Credits roll. Yawn.
Not necessarily. Just because those mutants are heroes in the other universes, doesn't mean they can't be used as villains here.
oldmanwinters
02-24-2012, 09:37 PM
I kind of feel like, in a way, a lot of us Mirage readers might be like... what's a good example... maybe like frogs in a pot of boiling water. You know, at first the water is cool and room temperature (red bandannas, the Turtles tangling with ordinary thugs, a unique but relatively grounded origin story)... then gradually the temperature starts rising in the water, but we don't realize it because it's happening so gradually (more and more animal mutants show up, here come the rainbow bandannas, and the OS elements and feel creeps to the forefront)... then eventually the water is boiling, and by that time it's too late to jump out of the water because we're dead (one day we'll open up an issue of the comic and it's like a full-on Fred Wolf reinactment).
But I hope not.
Interesting analogy, Andrew.
Mirage-ites = Frogs, eh?
Well, then... I've got a 10-Speed Blender I think you'll really like!
:twink:
Venom
02-24-2012, 09:40 PM
Actually, I can personally imagine the Punk frogs being done in a cool way. Maybe bring an actual 'punk' element to it. There are a few ways I could see this being really neat, and many more ways I could see it being totally lame.
Yeah, they could live up to their namesakes and be extremely egotistical and their method of battle be strategically sound but perhaps a bit too brash and brutal.
They may see the Turtles as naive little pests, neither truly liking or disliking them, but occasionally sling verbal abuse when annoyed like, "Piss off shellback, or I may be inclined to split you like an oyster!"
Yeah, I'm bored...:tsmile:
CyberCubed
02-24-2012, 09:44 PM
Only characters that work well as both villains and heroes are Leatherhead and Wingnut/Screwloose.
Jester
02-24-2012, 09:49 PM
Dreadmon and Jagwar have never been villains, and I could see them done as such.
Mondo and Ray on the other hand, they would be hard to do as villains.
CyberCubed
02-24-2012, 09:51 PM
I still think its bizarre that Murphy never had Napoleon Bonafrog as part of the Mutanimals. He should have introduced him early on like where Mondo was debuted.
Venom
02-24-2012, 10:02 PM
Only characters that work well as both villains and heroes are Leatherhead and Wingnut/Screwloose.
Dreadmon and Jagwar have never been villains, and I could see them done as such.
Mondo and Ray on the other hand, they would be hard to do as villains.
The world is many shades of grey; they don't have to be either. They may have to steal something to survive, take the odd job as mercs, and yeah probably help a poor soul in need.
The Mutanimals main goal would be survival at all costs, which would inevitably put them in grey areas and have the effect of luring in more dangers.
Jester
02-24-2012, 10:14 PM
The Mutanimals main goal would be survival at all costs, which would inevitably put them in grey areas and have the effect of luring in more dangers.
I could get behind that...
Coola Yagami
02-25-2012, 04:15 PM
I don't see the prob with all the OT stuff. The OT had alot of awesome ideas that were never fully explored due to it being a kiddy show and 'status quo is god'. Even Andrew brought up a good point with a possible Dimension X version of the Turtles, and things like that.
I know people want to see Mirage stuff... but I kinda don't want to see the Shredder nearly kill Leo/Raph and trash April's place a THIRD time.... nor do we really have to see the Triceraton/Federation war again. We have the Ultimate collection books for that, as well as the 2K3 series if you wanna see those stories played out yet again. I feel the OT stuff was so wildly different from Mirage that incorporating elements from it help make it a fresh new take... rather than the same stuff we already (kinda/sorta) saw in 2K3. And if you want those Mirage stories again.... Ultimate Collections.... get em.
As for the issue, I liked it. I do wonder what exactly stops the Mousers from chewing Splinter and Don to bits though... As for the 'someone won't leave safely'.... as if it woulda been the heroes... it's either Hob or Baxter for somehow failing their mission.
Finally, the Mike scene didn't really bother me as much. Hey, he thinks the guy is cool. He gives free pizza and teaches him to talk surfer style, seems cool to me. I also liked how it was shown how Woody first met them. And no, it's not 2K3 Mikey. If it was... he'd be talking repeatedly about HIMSELF and not of someone else. I'm still liking Mikey here. The gaming is ok cause even though he talks about it alot, its still his hobby and not as bad as the 2K3 show. Plus, hey, this time we actually got to SEE where he picked up his lingo AND in the micro the party dude FINALLY GOT TO GO TO AN ACTUAL PARTY. Hopefully they can follow up and show what got Don so interested in science and what made Leo way much more into ninjitsu compared to his brothers.
I also liked how Woody brings up how they were busy looking for Raph all year. Shows him his brothers really cared and never gave up hope on him. I also do like the more mellow Raph. The temper stuff got old and most of the times it seemed he was mad just to be mad in the other versions cause 'being angry and rude is cool and edgey' or whatever. Nice to see Raph act alot more mellow. I assume the rage will show itself when its fight time or if Leo and Don push his buttons too much. But yeah, glad he's not a damn grouch 24/7 in this version. By the time the show got to Fast Forward, almost every line of his was some rude remark, insult or grouch crap.
Did anyone else think April was cute in this issue? She was drawn kinda so-so in other issues but she was kinda hot in this one. Plus, it's interesting to see they're making her into somewhat of an ass-kicker even before she ever met the Turtles.
And ironically enough... for everyone that complains the OT elements overtake the Mirage ones... we get people crying out for Slash, hoping Woody becomes Pizza Face and even Mutinanimals....
Mr._Mutant_Man
02-25-2012, 06:55 PM
Issue 7 is okay. There was a lot of promise, but it left me wanting more. I wanted to see more of the fight with the mousers, more interaction between April and Casey, and more of Krang. I hope a lot of this pays off in issue 8.
I'm glad to see that Krang is an alien brain/utrom/whatever it is in this universe. I think most readers would have been disappointed if he wasn't.
I like all of the OT elements in the comic book. I'm a big fan of the original Mirage comics, but if I want to read something that's like the original Mirage series...I can always go back and read the original Mirage series.
This new comic book series feels like it's a less goofy take on elements of the OT, which I think is great. I like the idea of being able to enjoy the same characters I liked as a kid, but in a way that is less like a Saturday morning cartoon and handled more...seriously? Maturely? I can't think of a good word, because a comic book about talking turtles isn't exactly "serious" in the first place.
My favorite panel from this issue has to be Michelangelo's face when he first sees a pizza. The introduction of pizza could have come off as really lame, but I think the IDW team pulled it off in a genuinely amusing way.
Venom
02-25-2012, 07:11 PM
It's not us "crying for Mirage" per se, and while I can't speak for anyone but myself, it's the feeling of the book increasing loses the feel the Mirage stories had. It's hard to put into words exactly but, when I read a Mirage comic, it's like visiting someone you really care for and when reading it is both a happy/sad occasion because you don't want the visit to end. With IDW, it's like I'm hanging with an acquaintence and I'm along for the ride. While enjoyable, there isn't that "thing" that hooks me into the world and captivates me into wanting to visit a little longer.
The things I miss from this iteration is the Foot stuff. Even into Volume 4, the Foot evolved and we saw factions rise up and truces formed and broken. The new titles lacks the "slice of life" moments that made Mirage great, at least to me. The Turtles would embark on the wild-ass adventures, yet it was somehow a believable world.
Ugh, I hate not being able to adequately express my thoughts ... I like the IDWverse, and do feel that Tom and company are doing a good job and crafting a compelling new mythos, but I suppose I just miss the atmosphere of the Mirage books. Every month (Tales) was another new visit to that universe. I want to feel that with IDW.
It's probably hard for IDW to do since they're working with 22 pages of story per issue, but the little characterizations the Turtles had was something that gave the Mirage TMNT a certain special touch. Donatello, the quiet, aloof genius with a calculating dark side; Leonardo striving for perfection in everything he does at the risk of alienating his family, Raph lashing out at just about everyone as a means to hide his insecurities about being a mutant, and Mike, the optimistic artist/writer who everyone thinks is a lot dumber than he is and never given enough credit.
Damn, that was long...
LeoNerdo
02-25-2012, 09:25 PM
Just read #7 and loved it as usual. I really think Duncan's artwork just continues to improve. There were some really really nice panels in this issue. Loved the story too. You can tell they are just having fun with it and I am too.
Cowabunga Carl
02-25-2012, 09:33 PM
Venom I think you started to nail it. I like Mirage and I miss it from time to time I go and revisit it. But those visits never seem long enough. They come to and end and leave me wanting more, looking forward to the next time I read them. The IDW stuff id fun and I enjoy them but they don't make me want to come back time and time again.
It's hard to put into words like you say. It's really hard to explain. I like all the different versions for different reasons. The OT is fun to sit down and just enjoy because of the sheer goofiness and light heartedness, the Mirage is a very gritty noir kind of feel, the Archie was a more serious OT, 2k3 was Mirage with a little goofiness. Right now I'm not sure what IDW.
I agree with Andrew though about his frog metaphor. I think we were baited into thinking this was going to be something else at first. I'm not saying what it is becoming is bad, just not what some of us thought we were going to get. It would be like being asked if you want your favorite flavor of ice-cream but then given a dish of chocolate. While not what you were expecting it's still good.
I read the issue tonight and have to say it wasn't bad. I enjoyed how they showed Krang. It makes sense that the Rock Soldiers aren't actually rock but soldiers who have undergone the terrapin armor enhancement. I like how things are being handled and that's why I keep coming back to this book month after month.
oldmanwinters
02-25-2012, 09:42 PM
I agree with Andrew though about his frog metaphor. I think we were baited into thinking this was going to be something else at first.
Like I said before, I've got a 10-Speed Blender I think you frogs will really like!
Seriously, though, I will almost always prefer the self-contained single-story comic book to the serialized "tune in next month!" philosophy that characterizes most comic book titles these days. Stories are written with the Trade Paper Back in mind. Multi-issue arcs are nice and exciting, but they generally don't fill me up on a monthly basis like the old Mirage Tales V.2 did.
CyberCubed
02-25-2012, 10:00 PM
The micros seem to be the best case of one and done stories. I think the days of one shots are long over otherwise.
I enjoy this series and am hoping the big payoff with Shredder and Krang is exciting.
Raven
02-26-2012, 08:38 AM
I don't know why but this has been one of my favorite issues.
I was shocked to see the neutrino world, now you have me wondering how they will play into this!
Krangs android body rocked, just like the Shredders new look I like how you guys are keeping it simple. Which I have to ask, how much does kevin help out with the designs? Are they all from him or is Duncan the source for them?
ToTheNines
02-28-2012, 04:19 PM
http://comics.ign.com/articles/121/1219275p1.html
They were pretty favorable, gave it a 7.5
TheFallen
03-04-2012, 03:06 PM
IDWverse TMNT = My favourite version of the TMNTverse
AquaParade
03-04-2012, 04:37 PM
IDWverse TMNT = My favourite version of the TMNTverse
You may be the first person I've seen outright state that on this forum. Congrats!
Not my favorite, but poised to be one of them!
Fin reading this issue very short in my opinion but loved it all the same.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.