View Full Version : So... were the fans at the NY Comic Con blind? (Turtles Forever)
Coola Yagami
02-26-2012, 11:07 PM
I remember one of our fellow Dromers went to the NYCC when Turtles Forever was shown in its entireiy and showed us a recording of the whole thing. ALl I heard were cheers and laughs. Not one boo, not one AW C'MON!!! or any complaints about how the OT bunch was mangled in this special. So... what gives?
Ninjinister
02-26-2012, 11:27 PM
Cool story, bro.
Donnie
02-26-2012, 11:39 PM
The way the OT bunch acted is the way I believe popular culture has come to recognize TMNT, regardless of how the characters actually were in the OT. Yeah it sucks, it's upsetting, but that's why we're on the Drome, right?!
FearlessLeader
02-26-2012, 11:41 PM
I think you mean SDCC not NYCC, because the preview party was actually there.
Having attended I can tell you that it was a lot of fun to sit and watch the film with a room full of other people that love the franchise as much as I do. It was a night that wasn't filled with nit picking and bitterness but instead was mostly just a lot of people meeting up, sharing some laughs and some love for the Turtles.
You can love or hate Turtles Forever I don't care but that party was probably one of the best things I have ever done at a convention simply because it was such a good time.
ctt4lfecw
02-26-2012, 11:47 PM
What Turtles Forever did to the OT was disgraceful, embarrasing and disgusting. I don't know where to begin with everything that they did wrong. They got nothing right about them, NOTHING. They slapped all of us fans right in the face with that garbage.
Jester
02-26-2012, 11:53 PM
What Turtles Forever did to the OT was disgraceful, embarrasing and disgusting. I don't know where to begin with everything that they did wrong. They got nothing right about them, NOTHING. They slapped all of us fans right in the face with that garbage.
Phelous? Nice to see you've joined our humble forums...
Ninjinister
02-27-2012, 12:04 AM
What Turtles Forever did to the OT was disgraceful, embarrasing and disgusting. I don't know where to begin with everything that they did wrong. They got nothing right about them, NOTHING. They slapped all of us fans right in the face with that garbage.
Those rose-tinted glasses are rather stylish.
Roseangelo
02-27-2012, 12:59 AM
I think you mean SDCC not NYCC, because the preview party was actually there.
Having attended I can tell you that it was a lot of fun to sit and watch the film with a room full of other people that love the franchise as much as I do. It was a night that wasn't filled with nit picking and bitterness but instead was mostly just a lot of people meeting up, sharing some laughs and some love for the Turtles.
You can love or hate Turtles Forever I don't care but that party was probably one of the best things I have ever done at a convention simply because it was such a good time.
Pretty much this. Yes, there are some fair critiques that can be given to Turtles Forever, but everyone at that party was pretty much just focused on having a good time. And there is a whole lot more good about the movie than there is bad.
And the recording you mention was mine, but it was audio not video.
I'm guessing the alcohol served at this adults-only event might have had something to do with the lack of outrage.
Jester
02-27-2012, 01:23 AM
I'm guessing the alcohol served at this adults-only event might have had something to do with the lack of outrage.
I knew some one was gonna say it. I thought it was gonna be me.... :D
Tuxedo Moroboshi
02-27-2012, 02:36 AM
Those rose-tinted glasses are rather stylish.
They're all the rage, and come in a fancy "I only remember season 1" fashion.
ToTheNines
02-27-2012, 07:47 AM
Why the hell did you start this thread? You could have made this pissy little remark over at the thread for Phelous' review.
BubblyShell22
02-27-2012, 07:54 AM
No, they weren't blind. I think they were just glad to get together, have some fun, and watch something they all love together. Yes, Turtles Forever may have flaws, but I think the fans who watched it were just happy to see it and to share it with fellow fans. I wish I had been there because I would've had a blast just being there. Not to mention the fact that Sam Riegal and Mike S. were also in attendance.
I simply love it. I'm glad I have the UK DVD which is uncut!! :D
I've watched it about 8 times now. Sure the OT Turtles don't act like they did back then. But I love the storyline, the Mirage Turtles, Classic Shredder, the action scenes! It's really a nice 25th anniversary gift to the fans!
Galactus
02-27-2012, 10:47 AM
What Turtles Forever did to the OT was disgraceful, embarrasing and disgusting. I don't know where to begin with everything that they did wrong. They got nothing right about them, NOTHING. They slapped all of us fans right in the face with that garbage.
Utter hogwash of course. They got the Fred Wolf characters bang on for the most part.
CyberCubed
02-27-2012, 11:15 AM
The only bad scene was the OT Turtles crying. Everything else was accurate.
Galactus
02-27-2012, 11:30 AM
^^^
I can cop to that. Showing their fear to that level did stand out although it did remind me of how the turtles sometimes when they were affected by weird personality changing rays or the odd episodes were a turtle had to conquer their personal fear.
I'd also say the noogie references were confusing as I can't remember that ever happening on the OT.
Master Splinter
02-27-2012, 11:55 AM
I remember one of our fellow Dromers went to the NYCC when Turtles Forever was shown in its entireiy and showed us a recording of the whole thing. ALl I heard were cheers and laughs. Not one boo, not one AW C'MON!!! or any complaints about how the OT bunch was mangled in this special. So... what gives?
If I was there and I heard boo's and aw c'mons! I would actually be kinda mad because I want to watch a movie, not listening to people bitch about it... That is what the Internet is for... If I ever go to a movie and people are talking through it I would not be opposed to getting them thrown out...
-ms
Jephael
03-02-2012, 09:52 AM
As a long time fan of the Ninja Turtles who loves and respects every incarnation, I can honestly say while I was somewhat dissapointed in 4Kids' treatment of the classic toon it gave me some clever ideas for fan fiction that sorta follows the events of Turtles Forever
ZariusTwo
03-02-2012, 12:05 PM
What Turtles Forever did to the OT was disgraceful, embarrasing and disgusting. I don't know where to begin with everything that they did wrong. They got nothing right about them, NOTHING. They slapped all of us fans right in the face with that garbage.
:lol:
Yeah, you can stop pretending you speak for all of us anytime now.
I remember one of our fellow Dromers went to the NYCC when Turtles Forever was shown in its entireiy and showed us a recording of the whole thing. ALl I heard were cheers and laughs. Not one boo, not one AW C'MON!!! or any complaints about how the OT bunch was mangled in this special. So... what gives?
Yes. Heaven forbid people arent allowed to sit back, understand the 80s Turtles were always complete goofs, get the joke, enjoy themselves and be entertained by a well thought-out movie that touched all areas of the franchise in a delicate and fairly balanced way.
Just remember who saved the multiverse.
plastroncafe
03-02-2012, 01:38 PM
You didn't hear any of those things in the recording because people are only that negative about things on the internet.
It was an awesome night of fan service and a whole lot of fun to be with that many turtle junkies in one room.
Leo656
03-03-2012, 01:38 AM
Just remember who saved the multiverse.
Yep. Booster Gold.
Right?
Powder
03-03-2012, 03:14 AM
What Turtles Forever did to the OT was disgraceful, embarrasing and disgusting. I don't know where to begin with everything that they did wrong. They got nothing right about them, NOTHING. They slapped all of us fans right in the face with that garbage.
Anytime I see comments like this it's from a new member with few posts, or from someone who isn't a member at all.
Kinda makes one wonder how well you really know the turtles... :trolleye:
Avatar Yuffie
03-03-2012, 07:10 AM
They're all the rage, and come in a fancy "I only remember season 1" fashion.
Do you actually watch the OT? You make it sound they're that immature and have no sense of responsibility after season 1.
I see the flaws and I think it's justified when they're pointed out, but I'm willing to not let it bug me in the same way the 2K3 Turtles tried so hard to sell their "It's ninja time!" catchphrase late in the series. Some people from the internet just didn't. It's as simple as that.
Tuxedo Moroboshi
03-03-2012, 12:12 PM
Do you actually watch the OT? You make it sound they're that immature and have no sense of responsibility after season 1.
I see the flaws and I think it's justified when they're pointed out, but I'm willing to not let it bug me in the same way the 2K3 Turtles tried so hard to sell their "It's ninja time!" catchphrase late in the series. Some people from the internet just didn't. It's as simple as that.
Of course I watch the OT. I realize that the OT were slightly exaggerated (emphasis on slightly), but really, the only one that I feel was misrepresented was Leonardo (and at some point, I was thinking Donatello, too, until I remembered all that he actually did in Turtles Forever).
But truthfully, most people only remember the first season. And it was in the first season that they were ever the most serious, if you're not counting Red Sky.
I'm not going to deny that Phelous made a few good points, but those few good points were the backbone of his review, and he just kept bringing them up over and over and over again to try and make his review stack up. Not to mention that the majority of the positive stuff about the OT characters is glossed over in favor of making his points stand taller (the only exception to this that I can see is that he acknowledged 87 Splinter being accurate).
I already wrote up something a slight bit more in-depth about this in the Phelous thread, btw.
Foot Soldier Clang
03-03-2012, 02:40 PM
I enjoyed the Turtles Forever movie enough. I'm completely unfamiliar with the 2k3 turtles so I found them rather dull, while the OT turtles were all personality. They were written kind of out of character, by which I mean they were goofballs who never took anything serious; but we who watch the OT know that they were goofballs who knew when it was time to fight. The guys they got to do the voices were ok, but I thought Leo sounded like a game show host.
You could really tell that whoever wrote the script were only familiar with the first few episodes of the OT, and filled in the blanks with whatever memories they had of the show. They also played up the goofball personalities of the turtles to show how serious the 2k3 turtles were.
I still lose it when OT Mike says "It's time to bust out our baddest rides!" and you see the turtle blimp start to inflate. :tlol:
Avatar Yuffie
03-03-2012, 06:05 PM
But truthfully, most people only remember the first season. And it was in the first season that they were ever the most serious, if you're not counting Red Sky.
Seasons 2 and 7 would like a word with you.
Season 1 nostalgia? whatever. I don't really even have that much nostalgia for the OT, for me the turtles as a kid was the videogames and the toys, I didn't get to watch the show that much. It really wasn't until the DVDs that I started watching, didn't think I was oging to like it but ended up loving the mood and charm the show had, now while the show was always goofy and got pretty goofy it never got to the levels that Turtles Forever did. Season 4 is considered the lowest point and the silliest and no episode no matter how wacky gets even close to their portrayal in TF. Now I get what they were going for, it was a 2k3 DTV and they wanted to show the contrast and they had to exaggerate but they went overboard and not only that but many times it was just disrespectful to the show, not to mention so inacurate at times that it doesn't even feel like they're teaming up with the OT and that was the point of the DTV. Heck they seem to act like more annoying versions of 2k3 Mikey than any OT personality. They wanted to show how cool the 2k3 turtles were but it doesn't work and in fact I think the movie will not age very well because of it as the 2k3 turtles will seem so cheesy in a few years in their portrayal in the dtv. I've tried many times but as much as I watch it I just can't get to feel that they're portrayed accurately, now I do appreciate this over nothing and some scenes did get some OT stuff right, but not enough.
The only bad scene was the OT Turtles crying. Everything else was accurate.
How can you say this and mean it?
Moonlight1102
03-09-2012, 07:52 PM
Oh dear......
Anima Gemini
03-09-2012, 09:27 PM
If you don't like the portrayal of the FW TMNT in Turtles Forever, then try looking at it like this: We are seeing the FW TMNT from the point of view of the 4Kids TMNT. The TMNT from the actual FW toon probably WOULD appear over the top and goofy to the 4Kids TMNT. Except for Mikey, who would probably think they are super cool, just like he does in the movie. After all, the 4Kids TMNT are the main characters of the movie, and the FW TMNT are the guest stars. Perhaps we are just seeing the FW TMNT through 4Kids colored glasses.
Avatar Yuffie
03-09-2012, 10:14 PM
Still a shame. I have no doubt FWs Leo and Mikey would have fanboyed over the 2K3 Turtles (hey, he fell in love with Lotus when she tricked him and Mikey has a thing for "edgier" superheroes) with FW Raph rolling his eyes.
Missed moments.
tmntgeoff
03-10-2012, 01:56 AM
i personally loved the movie. the only thing they could have done to make it better was use the original voice actors
Powder
03-10-2012, 03:26 AM
...Which unfortunately was not without effort. Just couldn't be worked out. Damn shame. The voice actors did a pretty nice job, though.
The Big Bad
03-10-2012, 05:02 AM
now while the show was always goofy and got pretty goofy it never got to the levels that Turtles Forever did.
So am I imagining that scene where Leo throws lipstick (that isn't his) at April's paintings (that aren't his) without permission, and calls it "target practice"? Or when Raph decides that he simply must take a bubble bath and doesn't know what "a capful" means? Or when Leo takes out his katana and slices somebody's table in half, unprovoked? Or when the turtles would breakdance in broad daylight for no damn reason? Did these not happen in the "more serious" Season 1? While one can make the argument that Forever didn't really replicate the original cartoon turtles' particular brand of silliness--a point I wouldn't particularly disagree with--it's much harder to argue that it took the silliness up to eleven--it's a difference in type, not degree.
CyberCubed
03-10-2012, 10:41 AM
So am I imagining that scene where Leo throws lipstick (that isn't his) at April's paintings (that aren't his) without permission, and calls it "target practice"? Or when Raph decides that he simply must take a bubble bath and doesn't know what "a capful" means? Or when Leo takes out his katana and slices somebody's table in half, unprovoked? Or when the turtles would breakdance in broad daylight for no damn reason? Did these not happen in the "more serious" Season 1? While one can make the argument that Forever didn't really replicate the original cartoon turtles' particular brand of silliness--a point I wouldn't particularly disagree with--it's much harder to argue that it took the silliness up to eleven--it's a difference in type, not degree.
That's all from the Turtles first experience with humans. That's from episode 3, right?
Watch any of the other seasons.
ZariusTwo
03-10-2012, 11:28 AM
Yep. Booster Gold.
Right?
If you ask Stan, it was 90s cartoon Spider-Man.
Andrew NDB
03-10-2012, 01:34 PM
I'm guessing the alcohol served at this adults-only event might have had something to do with the lack of outrage.
Alcohol can never, never hurt in the digestion of animated TMNT. In fact, it's absolutely required for me to even get through more than 2 or 3 episodes of the Fred Wolf series.
In the case of Turtles Forever, though, it wasn't necessary.
ZariusTwo
03-10-2012, 02:05 PM
Alcohol can never, never hurt in the digestion of animated TMNT. In fact, it's absolutely required for me to even get through more than 2 or 3 episodes of the Fred Wolf series.
:roll:
Ah well, it's probably a better alternative than taking drugs to remotley appreciate the mediocre comics. AMIRITE?
Leo656
03-11-2012, 03:17 AM
If you ask Stan, it was 90s cartoon Spider-Man.
Touche'. Good call. I guess in an infinite Multiverse an infinite number of people could have saved it. But Booster Gold comes with Skeets and awesome disco collar.
Jester
03-11-2012, 03:28 AM
Booster Gold comes with Skeets and awesome disco collar.
Skeets. Terrible name for a robot side kick. :P
The Big Bad
03-11-2012, 06:33 AM
That's all from the Turtles first experience with humans. That's from episode 3, right?
Watch any of the other seasons.
But I thought season 1 was the marginally more serious season. And it's not like this is a case of marginally out-of-sync writer--season 1 is written by David Wise and Patty Howeth.
CyberCubed
03-11-2012, 09:26 AM
But I thought season 1 was the marginally more serious season. And it's not like this is a case of marginally out-of-sync writer--season 1 is written by David Wise and Patty Howeth.
And this was still at a time when the show was discovering itself. The Turtles personalities themselves were still being developed in Season 1.
This is true for any show, you know this.
Tuxedo Moroboshi
03-11-2012, 04:11 PM
Seasons 2 and 7 would like a word with you.
Would they, now? I still felt that the first season felt more serious than either of those two, but you could probably still argue that those seasons were more serious than others. There did seem to be a fluctuation of sorts throughout the series' run. Heck, for that matter, even between episodes within the same season. The first season was more consistent with that, though.
While one can make the argument that Forever didn't really replicate the original cartoon turtles' particular brand of silliness--a point I wouldn't particularly disagree with--it's much harder to argue that it took the silliness up to eleven--it's a difference in type, not degree.
I think this is probably the best explanation I've heard for this, and I couldn't have said it better myself (if I could, I probably already would have). Yes, it's a case of type, and not degree.
Candy Kappa
03-11-2012, 05:29 PM
not to mention it's a movie special with eight main characters, at the end it's twelve. Sacrifices and simplicity is to be made
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.