View Full Version : How do you feel about the new reincarnation origin?
Matches Malone
03-20-2012, 01:28 PM
I know this is kind of an old subject and that there has been some discussion, but I'm curious just how on board fans are with the new reincarnation aspect of the turtles' origin. I added a "mixed feelings" option solely because that's where I fall under. I think Splinter reincarnated as Hamato Yoshi is actually an improvement from the Mirage origin for several reasons:
1) It is a much more believable take on why a rat would be a ninja master, especially when using the psychotropic serum as a means to awaken his past memories.
2) Making Yoshi and Splinter the same person again streamlines the origin.
3) It allows for an epic rivalry stretching back to Feudal Japan. Love this aspect.
However, I'm not as excited about the turtles being his reincarnated sons for several reasons as well:
1) If and when the turtles ultimately identify themselves as former humans, it takes away from their feelings of being outcasts.
2) We lose the make-shift family of mutants that again, reinforces the outcast element of the turtles.
3) It's a more interesting "gritty ninja" story to avenge your master than to simply seek vengeance for yourselves. Plus avenging your own death is kind of weird... It's not as much of a crime if you received a second life, is it? But if Yoshi's wife was not reincarnated, he could be properly motivated to avenger her death. Obviously this last point is personal preference and "gritty ninja" story doesn't really mean anything, heh...
ToTheNines
03-20-2012, 01:35 PM
I can't really say it's an improvement, but I'm very glad they did something new. Overall, I like it. Hopefully they find a good way to bring Saki to present day.
1) If and when the turtles ultimately identify themselves as former humans, it takes away from their feelings of being outcasts.
But they're still mutant freaks who live in a sewer. And they were humans in feudal Japan, that alone makes them outcasts in the modern world.
FearlessLeader
03-20-2012, 01:38 PM
Thus far I am interested and intrigued but really can't commit to my full feelings on the matter until I see the plot played out completely. I mean we still don't know how modern Shredder will fit into all of this and how much in the end it will actually effect the guys.
Matches Malone
03-20-2012, 01:41 PM
But they're still mutant freaks who live in a sewer. And they were humans in feudal Japan, that alone makes them outcasts in the modern world.
That's a good point that I hadn't thought of, but it's definitely a different kind of outcast. I guess to me, as long as they identify themselves as turtles first, that's all that matters. But it will still feel kind of off to think of them as former humans. It just seems making the turtles reincarnated was an unnecessary detriment to what is an otherwise greatly improved Splinter origin, in my opinion.
Oculus Orbus
03-20-2012, 01:48 PM
I personally don't like it at all, to the point that it's nearly ruining the whole book for me. It's not the only issue I've got with it, but it's the main one. I consider the accidental origin to be an important part of what the TMNT are.
LeoNerdo
03-20-2012, 03:38 PM
I'm not crazy about it, and I still have my doubts about it being the true origin since we still don't know the whole story. Plus Don has brought up his own skepticism about their being re-incarnated. So I have hope that things will change once they discover the 'truth'.
Samhain
03-20-2012, 04:02 PM
To be honest, it doesn't bother me at all. At first I wasn't crazy about it. But, it does add another layer to the story and that can make things more interesting later on.
CyberCubed
03-20-2012, 04:03 PM
I think we don't have the whole story yet. I always said I think there might be a plot twist where the Turtles really aren't Yoshi's reincarnated sons at all, but simply have the memories implanted in them.
If that's the case, seeing how Splinter would react knowing his sons are truly dead would lead to quite interesting developments.
Matches Malone
03-20-2012, 04:07 PM
I think we don't have the whole story yet. I always said I think there might be a plot twist where the Turtles really aren't Yoshi's reincarnated sons at all, but simply have the memories implanted in them.
If that's the case, seeing how Splinter would react knowing his sons are truly dead would lead to quite interesting developments.
If that ends up being the case, then most of my concerns above would be addressed and this origin would end up being my favorite iteration. It would certainly be interesting to see Splinter deluding himself into believing the turtles are his sons. It was never explained how he knew anyway when he saw them. However, the Leo flashbacks kind of hurt this argument. The Leo & Splinter micros ought to shed some light on the subject.
Samhain
03-20-2012, 04:13 PM
I think we don't have the whole story yet. I always said I think there might be a plot twist where the Turtles really aren't Yoshi's reincarnated sons at all, but simply have the memories implanted in them.
If that's the case, seeing how Splinter would react knowing his sons are truly dead would lead to quite interesting developments.
That would indeed be a great twist. I'm sure we are in for a real treat. I still think there are a lot of new twists coming up.
MikeandRaph87
03-20-2012, 04:14 PM
It can actually work for Splinter but that's it. Its a hard pill to shallow knowing the turtles are human spirits inside mutated turtles but as longed as its not important to the plot and moved past I can deal with it.
Jester
03-20-2012, 04:21 PM
I'm mixed. It's an interesting way to do the family dynamic, but I always saw the TMNT as the ultimate example of family by adoption. This kind of undoes that, but it's a minor quibble.
My major gripe with the reincarnation angle is it unnecessarily complicates things, IMO. Wouldn't the Hamato Yoshi and his sons have been reincarnated several times since their days in Feudal Japan before they were re-reincarnated as the Turtles and Splinter. Why is Splinter calling them by the names April gave them and not the ones he gave them as Hamato Yoshi. I know he says that is what they would know...but it seems off. And is Shredder also reincarnated? Seems like a cop out and a way to introduce any threat that needs to be "BIG" by introducing it in a flash back and then having them be the reincarnated _________. Part of me hopes, sadly, that Splinter is actually wrong as mentioned before by others, and that they aren't the reincarnated sons of Hamato Yoshi. It'd make for an interesting twist.
MikeandRaph87
03-20-2012, 04:30 PM
I'm mixed. It's an interesting way to do the family dynamic, but I always saw the TMNT as the ultimate example of family by adoption. This kind of undoes that, but it's a minor quibble.
My major gripe with the reincarnation angle is it unnecessarily complicates things, IMO. Wouldn't the Hamato Yoshi and his sons have been reincarnated several times since their days in Feudal Japan before they were re-reincarnated as the Turtles and Splinter. Why is Splinter calling them by the names April gave them and not the ones he gave them as Hamato Yoshi. I know he says that is what they would know...but it seems off. And is Shredder also reincarnated? Seems like a cop out and a way to introduce any threat that needs to be "BIG" by introducing it in a flash back and then having them be the reincarnated _________. Part of me hopes, sadly, that Splinter is actually wrong as mentioned before by others, and that they aren't the reincarnated sons of Hamato Yoshi. It'd make for an interesting twist.
We have an opinion that matches exactly to the "t". I have already used three "like Jester
would say" remarks this week. Get out of my head dude! :tlol:
ToTheNines
03-20-2012, 05:18 PM
Why is Splinter calling them by the names April gave them and not the ones he gave them as Hamato Yoshi.
This is why I hate the multi-colored headbands. Why give them their favorite colors to wear, but discard their names?
ctt4lfecw
03-20-2012, 05:23 PM
I'll say so far so good, and stay tuned.
Jester
03-20-2012, 05:30 PM
This is why I hate the multi-colored headbands. Why give them their favorite colors to wear, but discard their names?
Never thought of that...despite reading about it in some of your past posts. Maybe it points to Splinter/Yoshi being unsure that the Turtles are actually his reincarnated sons...
ToTheNines
03-20-2012, 05:34 PM
Never thought of that...despite reading about it in some of your past posts. Maybe it points to Splinter/Yoshi being unsure that the Turtles are actually his reincarnated sons...
I mean, they had to get their names we all know and love somehow, so I don't think there's too much to be read into it. If they'd stayed with all red though, it wouldn't be an issue at all.... but then what would Leo, Don and Mike have gotten for Christmas!? :P
Oculus Orbus
03-20-2012, 05:47 PM
I think we don't have the whole story yet. I always said I think there might be a plot twist where the Turtles really aren't Yoshi's reincarnated sons at all, but simply have the memories implanted in them.
If that's the case, seeing how Splinter would react knowing his sons are truly dead would lead to quite interesting developments.
I said it before, but I'll say it again. If that actually gets to happen, it'll make me a very happy reader. If handled right, that twist could very well lead us to some of the best TMNT stories ever. However, things like Leo also having those flashbacks make me think that the reincarnation thing will remain as it is, with maybe some more depth add to it in future plots. It'd be a shame, in my opinion.
And is Shredder also reincarnated? Seems like a cop out and a way to introduce any threat that needs to be "BIG" by introducing it in a flash back and then having them be the reincarnated _________.
Exactly. If reincarnation was something that really existed in IDW TMNT, why would it be exclusive only to the Turtles and Splinter?
This is why I hate the multi-colored headbands. Why give them their favorite colors to wear, but discard their names?
That is a really good point. And one more reason why giving them rainbow bandanas is just a bad idea.
ToTheNines
03-20-2012, 06:11 PM
Exactly. If reincarnation was something that really existed in IDW TMNT, why would it be exclusive only to the Turtles and Splinter?
The idea, in certain beliefs, is that everyone is constantly reincarnated but you don't remember your past life. I guess psychotropic serum and super-soldier mutagen changes that.
Roseangelo
03-20-2012, 07:35 PM
My answer isn't on the poll.
"I'm fine with it."
Matches Malone
03-20-2012, 07:43 PM
My answer isn't on the poll.
"I'm fine with it."
Sorry, I kind of figured "I'm indifferent" would be in the same category as "I'm fine with it." And I don't know how to edit poll options. D'oh!
Roseangelo
03-20-2012, 07:46 PM
Sorry, I kind of figured "I'm indifferent" would be in the same category as "I'm fine with it." And I don't know how to edit poll options. D'oh!
Well, indifferent seems negative, which is not how I feel. But I also wouldn't weigh it as better or worse than previous origins. I like the story so far and I have no problem with the reincarnation aspect of it.
Jephael
03-20-2012, 07:47 PM
I always said I think there might be a plot twist where the Turtles really aren't Yoshi's reincarnated sons at all, but simply have the memories implanted in them.
If that's the case, seeing how Splinter would react knowing his sons are truly dead would lead to quite interesting developments.
Interesting theory. I do like how it gives Donatello something to debate with Splinter and the others about. He really speaks for the audience in this case.
Jester
03-20-2012, 07:50 PM
in·dif·fer·ent [in-dif-er-uhnt, -dif-ruhnt]
adjective
1. without interest or concern; not caring; apathetic: his indifferent attitude toward the suffering of others.
2. having no bias, prejudice, or preference; impartial; disinterested.
3. neither good nor bad in character or quality; average; routine: an indifferent specimen.
4. not particularly good, important, etc.; unremarkable; unnotable: an indifferent success; an indifferent performance.
5. of only moderate amount, extent, etc.
It's not negative, it's "I don't have a problem with it."
CyberCubed
03-20-2012, 08:11 PM
Now that a lot of OT characters/storylines are being brought back, its really no surprise Splinter is Hamato Yoshi again, just done in a slightly different way.
Granted he can't turn back into a human since he was mutated from a rat rather than a human body.
Killer Moth
03-20-2012, 08:44 PM
Well, indifferent seems negative, which is not how I feel. But I also wouldn't weigh it as better or worse than previous origins. I like the story so far and I have no problem with the reincarnation aspect of it.
This would be my take, as "I'm fine with it," as well. I actually now like it even though, I didn't exactly feel any outrageous outrage at the time. It might be because I'm no longer a comic book purist, as I used to be. 10 years ago, I was quite serious about comic canon, so this would have bent me out of shape somewhat.
Such a origin is not entirely unfeasible in the franchise, especially in light of TMNT Adv's Eastern World Tour arc. Or, I'm just trying to be more mellow, these days, as I'm definitely not an expert about Buddism or its practices. Whichever you prefer. Although, Peter Laird does present a convincing counterargument, so it all balances out.
I'm more concerned with IDW maintaining its now momentum after the events of issue 7, and hoping the payoff is worth it. Crossing my fingers, but so far, I am liking where it's going.
Matches Malone
03-20-2012, 11:36 PM
It's not negative, it's "I don't have a problem with it."
Jester here to rescue me and to salvage my semantic failures! Actually, I can understand that "indifference" while supposedly neutral, can have negative connotations. I realized that afterward, but hopefully people can see past that and still see that "I'm indifferent" and "I'm fine with it," while not entirely the same meaning, can at least be in the same camp for our intents and purposes.
CyberCubed
03-21-2012, 12:45 AM
Why do people think Shredder is reincarnated? He just probably never died since Feudal Japan.
Everytime I keep thinking about IDW's Shredder I keep having flashbacks to both Utrom Shredder and Demon Shredder from 4kids...as if we've sort of seen this before. I wonder...
Jester
03-21-2012, 12:56 AM
I really don't want another "ancient" Shredder. See....over complicates things.
Kendamu
03-21-2012, 01:35 AM
I think the origin is still sort of happening, in a sense. But, for what we know so far, I like how the modern time stuff has played out and I like how all the reincarnation stuff is still a question if you take Leo and Don's conversations about it into account. I was initially VERY skeptical about it but the story was executed so well in #5 that I bought right into it.
If it turns out that the reincarnation did happen, then cool. It'll make for a neat "500 years in the making" showdown before moving into new stuff not related directly to their origin.
If it turns out some weird genetic stuff made them think it was reincarnation when it wasn't, then that'll be a cool twist that makes us question everything as we move forward.
Why do people think Shredder is reincarnated? He just probably never died since Feudal Japan.
Everytime I keep thinking about IDW's Shredder I keep having flashbacks to both Utrom Shredder and Demon Shredder from 4kids...as if we've sort of seen this before. I wonder...
When Kevin Eastman was in Austin, I was talking to him about the new series I asked him about Shredder being incarnated, and he told me wait and see, but strongly hinted at that (full on nod while saying "I can't say anything")
CyberCubed
03-21-2012, 09:29 AM
Well at least the Turtles aren't aliens.
*wipes sweat from brow*
Toby Barrett
03-21-2012, 09:35 AM
Stop it. Stop it stop it. STOP IT.
Cowabunga Carl
03-21-2012, 09:41 AM
This doesn't need to be brought into every thing Cubed.
Well at least the Turtles aren't aliens.
*wipes sweat from brow*
:cry: Grab a tissue and deal with it
CyberCubed
03-22-2012, 01:43 PM
Without the reincarnation angle the series feels like a remake of the original cartoon.
I feel this new origin is the only major thing that makes it stand out compared to Mirage and the cartoons, at least this far.
ToTheNines
03-22-2012, 02:16 PM
Without the reincarnation angle the series feels like a remake of the original cartoon.
Yeah man, remember in "Turtle Tracks" when those two Foot Ninja broke into Baxter's lab and stole the the turtles? Then Splinter went after them in "Enter: The Shredder", and then Old Hob tried to eat pre-mutated Raph in "A Thing About Rats"...
Killer Moth
03-22-2012, 05:32 PM
Yeah man, remember in "Turtle Tracks" when those two Foot Ninja broke into Baxter's lab and stole the the turtles? Then Splinter went after them in "Enter: The Shredder", and then Old Hob tried to eat pre-mutated Raph in "A Thing About Rats"...
And then remember Krang had Traag and Grantior show up at Baxter's workshop in "Hot Rodding Teenagers", saying "Get back to work, stop stalling with the mutagen and do it NOW"?
Good times.
Toby Barrett
03-22-2012, 05:43 PM
And Raphael was a lovable, sarcastic hobo in the entire first season.
ToTheNines
03-22-2012, 06:27 PM
Heck yeah, then the Savate Ninja made an appearance in the climactic "Shredded and Splintered". That was so awesome.
oooo I got one, and remember when Casey Jones wasn't a complete nutcase smashing everything up. Instead, he was the one getting smacked up by a drunk called his father!
A little *too* Raph
03-25-2012, 05:57 PM
I chose indifferent but I'm with Rose.
I like that they are still mutated turtles and not humans, and this gives more weight to the TMNT/Shredder rivalry.
Donnie
03-25-2012, 06:11 PM
I think the reincarnation arc works just as well as the original. For sure! #5 sealed the deal, right after I read that issue I was just like...ddddaaamn.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.