PDA

View Full Version : Where do you draw the line as a collector?


Floatingyeti
05-08-2012, 11:11 AM
I've been thinking about this a lot lately and this topic has come up quite a bit on this forum regarding variant covers or the Archie TPB reprint. I've been especially confused about whether or not I should purchase the new Color Classics.

I've decided I will pick up every issue of Color Classics and not because I prefer the new coloring or that I want to revisit the material. I will buy them for the same reason most collectors on this forum will (who already own the original series). I'll buy them because I have everything, I've come this far and my collection would not be complete without them.

When I first saw the new Archie reprint I hated it and left my lcs only to return the next day and buy it. Why? I invested so many years into collecting this property that I love to miss one printed release. I'm not saying I'm jaded with the process, absolutely not, I love TMNT and I love what IDW is doing with them. But I've decided to stop needing to justify repurchasing material that I already own.

My wife actually put this in perspective for me. She told me that if I choose not to purchase an issue when it was released, I was only choosing to postpone my purchase. As a collector (completionist might be a better term) I would seek them out later with increased difficulty and price.

So I will purchase all that IDW releases. I hope that the Color Classics series will have some additional material. Maybe a letters page, Q&A with Eastman about the original issues, or an occasional new backup story. Just a little something more than a few ads for IDW comics in the back. But if not that's OK.

Release all that you want IDW keep the franchise strong in whatever way you can.

DrSpengler
05-08-2012, 11:33 AM
When I started collecting TMNT comics I was of the "everything" mindset, but that quickly became expensive and the amount of stuff just started taking up too much space. And on a personal level, I just didn't get any enjoyment out of owning an exact duplicate of something I already had.

So I altered my collecting pattern. I'm mostly in it for the content, so I'm out to get one of every story. Some times this forces me to buy doubles, as a short might be published as a back-up in a reprint or trade, but it's pared down my purchased quite a bit. And going after reprints over first editions also saves even more money.

For the Color Classics, I plan on just getting the first issue because I already have the 2 previous color versions and would like to do a compare/contrast. Beyond that, though, I don't really need any of the other color issues because they don't really add enough "new" content to warrant my purchase (kinda like variant covers).

That's basically how I keep my TMNT spending and collecting under control.

Archon_Turtle
05-08-2012, 11:35 AM
I'm in the same boat. I buy everything. Now, that isnt to say that I dont have strong opinions about some of the stuff they release. And I'm sure I will continue to have strong opinions. But yeah. I'm a completionist. Gotta Catch 'Em All, as it were.

Master Splinter
05-08-2012, 11:39 AM
I'm mostly in it for the content, so I'm out to get one of every story.

This pretty much sums up my collection as well. I want the story, but not really all of the variants. If I want the other covers I will save a jpg on the computer. As far as toys and other merchandise, at first I was out to get any and all that I could, if it had TMNT on it I wanted it. Now after seeing that I was basically getting a pile of stuff that I really didn't need, I have changed my stance and will only pick up things that I really want. For example when the Nick toys are released I want the four turtles and the other main characters (Shredder, Krang, April, Splinter). Additional variants (ex. super kickin' raphael) or the fluff villians while cool in their own regards, I don't care too much for.

-ms

Venom
05-08-2012, 12:09 PM
I teeter back and forth on this. For the most part, I truly don't mind getting the variants because of the artwork, but sometimes it feels hollow double-dipping. I pretty look it this way: it's my money, and Turtles do bring me happiness, but then again I only have 2 people to support.

Originally, I wanted to collect everything, but like most, found that endeavor to be rather expensive the farther back you go. Some guys, like Steph and Danny, have been fortunate enough to be able to acquire and afford such rare works. Personally, the most I've spent on a single issue was 100 bucks for the misprint #4 and I'm fine with that. Does that mean at some point in the future I won't splurge and get a NYCC #3 or a #1 2nd print? Not at all, just not at this point.

It took me a while to realize that while my collection is quite large, there is always someone who has a larger one, and collecting something should not be a proverbial dick-swinging contest but rather about enjoying something you love.

CyberCubed
05-08-2012, 12:42 PM
I agree that I want every story but not every re-release. As long as I have every TMNT story that's what we're reading for, right?

That being said I never sell my old collections. I have the Mirage #1-11 reprint from the 1990's, the one from 2009, and now both Ultimate collections from IDW.

I think I own like 10 different versions of #1. (Original, 1990 collection, First comics collection, Deluxe 1992 reprint, Free comic book day 2009, the color reprint from Mirage in 2009, the Ultimate collection #1, and I will get the color classics of it too)

HotJuicyBurgers
05-08-2012, 10:12 PM
I just started collecting, but my philosophy has just been to read all the stories lol. It's hard not to double dip sometimes though, I have some of volume 1 in multiple forms already, (the actual issues plus the idw ultimate collections.)

I'm also trying really hard to read them in print order but it's getting hard. I've read 1-18 volume 1, I'm missing 19-21 (return to new York arc), have 22, 24-27, and other scattered thoughout and it's hard not to read them lol

Floatingyeti
05-09-2012, 12:22 AM
I of course try to be a completionist because I love the turtles. But I think one of the driving factors for the few of us trying for every printed issue, variant, reprint or appearance is because its relativity small in scope. we're not trying to collect 70+ years of x-men with an almost inconceivable amount of material. If you want all 25 years of TMNT its achievable and within reason. Sure we might never get a first print of vol1 #1 or the original googledygooks. But our collections can be damn near complete and that has pushed me to try for completetionism (i made up a word!).

Does anyone else relate to this?

CyberCubed
05-09-2012, 01:17 AM
Well its obvious TMNT comic collecting isn't as difficult as comics going for 70+ years like Batman, Spiderman, X-men, etc. Not to mention with Batman you have to account to all the spinoffs, like Batman appearing in Justice League, or Robin in Teen Titans, or the Batgirl comics, etc.

The Mirage run went 25 years but even so it didn't have THAT many issues. 62 + 4 micros for Vol. 1, 13 issues for Volume 2, 25 issues for Image, 31 issues for Volume 4, 7 issues for Tales, 70 issues + 16 mini's for Tales V.2, and under 30 crossovers and specials.

Archie had somewhere around 100 issues with everything combined, and IDW just started.

pannoni1
05-09-2012, 09:33 AM
Another thing to consider for some of the rarest titles is your budget. If it is in VG or Fine condition, that's a good "reading copy" grade as gently reading shouldn't lower the condition much more from what it is at that level. Still, I could definitely scan each of my issues for "free reading", while keeping the condition intact. But I feel that the most desirible variant is the only one that I'd prefer (first printing, gold edition, limited edition). After that its just a waste of money/space.

Redeemer
05-09-2012, 04:24 PM
Where do I draw the line??? when a butterfly flies out of my wallet

twopinacoladas
05-09-2012, 07:12 PM
I choose not to buy the archie reprints, I will buy the Kevin Eastman covers... I have the first 8 he has done and the completionist in me just orderered #5 about a week ago as I had all but one. Many of them were $8-$20 some more with shipping for the ones I couldn't get locally.

I was initially just going to get the first one or first couple but damn haha. All the other covers unless they are cool I wont bother I will likely almost have 2 of each of the released covers tho. At least so far, at some point I may not bother maybe after issue 10 wont bother getting the Eastman variants if I don't find them locally.

Powder
05-09-2012, 07:17 PM
I'm someone who want to collect it all, but really can't. I've done my best with the Mirage series, and I'm close to completion with that, but IDW makes it impossible. There's like 4 versions of every issue. Anyone who can afford that and actually does, is out of their mind.

The Fifth Turtle
05-09-2012, 07:21 PM
Where do I draw the line??? when a butterfly flies out of my wallet

AWESOME:tsmile:

Dirty Blond
05-09-2012, 08:20 PM
I draw the line at collecting food.

bloodmetaldonor
05-11-2012, 12:00 AM
i think it's also important to consider the length of time one has been collecting. us old-schoolers (i started collecting in 1987 myself) who have been buying issues all along will have a slightly easier time with the completionist method, whereas for the newbies (ones who started with say vol.4 or idw) are gonna find it more absurd to own everything. we all know how difficult some of those vol.2 and vol.3 issues can be to track down these days!!

i personally would love to own EVERYTHING, but for for the most part, i've bypassed the majority of the collected editions (i only own the 4 first graphic novels and the shellshock tpb, for now) and have been primarily focusing on the individual issues. that being said, i DO go for every reprint and variant cover, as i also enjoy all the different art along with the stories. plus, damn near every reprint of the early vol.1 issues has a different back-up short story and/or pin-up page(s). which as an issue completionist, i feel the need to own.

my follow-up question is this... as far as the comics you all are still missing: do you prefer to go for the "bigger" books first (say vol.1 #1 1st print), or do you spend that same money on a bunch of "lesser" issues first, to bulk up the collection as well as the reading experience?? my weak ass answer to this question is that i tend to ride the middle line. for instance, i got the entire run of vol.4 (with the exception of #29 & 30) in one purchase for a fair amount, and my very next comic buy was a near mint copy of turtlemania that i spent pretty much the same amount on!! just curious how others go about this...

thechris
05-16-2012, 04:10 AM
Whoa, I wasn't even aware that they reprinted the Archie series. I loved that series sooo much. I'd better start googling for sources... :teek:

CudleyCowlick
05-16-2012, 08:05 AM
I generally don't bother with reprints or variants, unless it is particularly striking new art to me, or if say there is some incentive to keep it as a collectible, say if it's signed/sketched by a creator, or just a super low and exclusive print run. And no, anything over 1,000 or even 500 isn't really low in my opinion.

So while I have 1 2nd printing of TMNT V.1 #1, and a couple third printings, I don't own any printings after that... I'm not interested in any of the other covers and none of the minor differences inside interest me. Redrawing or recoloring an issue never draws me in either, if it was done right the first time, why do we need a rehash? A second printing of #1 is always gonna be more sought after than some random cash grab convention bonus with a photoshopped logo on front and new inking on page #11, panel #6 or whatever. :lol:

I guess if I had enough money, I would buy every printing and every variant that goes with it, but I have a lot of other areas to collect aside from TMNT these days. 3-5 years ago, it was a bit of a different story.

rich
05-16-2012, 01:56 PM
...for the last 25+ years there's been no line for me...any and every TMNT comic variant, error, misprint, or whatever was my goal. Like Archon, I'm a TMNT comics completist (or completionist, as it's sometimes referenced).

With IDW, that goal hasn't changed for me but it sure has taxed the wallet in the last year. All these cover variants (which were not very common prior to IDW) are easily costing me at least 400-500% more than I used to spend per month.

With that said, collecting TMNT comics is in my blood and I can't stop (not that I've actually tried to stop though ;))...but I have had to get more creative with my methods of acquiring the variants to keep the costs as low as possible. I now use 3 or 4 different shops both local and online...previously, I had only one shop and it was local.

All these years of collecting TMNT have taught me one thing...if I don't get it when released I'll just end up wishing I had it and then have to pay much more (sometimes WAY more) to get it aftermarket.

Lampy
05-16-2012, 06:47 PM
...for the last 25+ years there's been no line for me...any and every TMNT comic variant, error, misprint, or whatever was my goal. Like Archon, I'm a TMNT comics completist (or completionist, as it's sometimes referenced).

With IDW, that goal hasn't changed for me but it sure has taxed the wallet in the last year. All these cover variants (which were not very common prior to IDW) are easily costing me at least 400-500% more than I used to spend per month.

With that said, collecting TMNT comics is in my blood and I can't stop (not that I've actually tried to stop though ;))...but I have had to get more creative with my methods of acquiring the variants to keep the costs as low as possible. I now use 3 or 4 different shops both local and online...previously, I had only one shop and it was local.

All these years of collecting TMNT have taught me one thing...if I don't get it when released I'll just end up wishing I had it and then have to pay much more (sometimes WAY more) to get it aftermarket.

and now you have enough material to make a whole museum of TMNT comics. i commend you and archon for that.

Jephael
05-16-2012, 08:52 PM
There's like 4 versions of every issue. Anyone who can afford that and actually does, is out of their mind.

I know, it drives me crazy as well. Up until now I've been going to the comic book store and they'd have a copy of each new issue ready for me, but it'd be a crap shoot. I had no way of knowing which cover I got until I got there. Just a few days ago I cancelled my subscriptions at Comics and More, which I've gone to for the past 10 years since my family and I are moving in the next few months, so until I start going to a new comic book store I'm just using eBay to order the variant covers I like. It may be a little more pricey, but atleast I can choose which variants I want!

Toby Barrett
05-16-2012, 10:28 PM
With the IDW series, I just worry about picking up Cover A for each issue and just "collect the story".
I was even lucky enough to find a cover A for TMNT #5! Took forever.

CyberCubed
05-17-2012, 12:58 AM
For alternate covers, why not just print out high quality versions of the art? That way you still technically have the art, but not a double of the same issue.

Although if IDW would release an "Artbook gallery" of all the covers in the IDW series in one big book, I'd gladly buy it. As much as I love all the different covers we're getting, I simply will not buy the same issue twice.

Floatingyeti
05-18-2012, 09:16 PM
It would be awesome to get an artbook with all the variant covers! It would be nice if the tpbs would include all the covers. The first trade ended with a good collection of variant covers but not all. i hope vol2 will include more.

Matches Malone
05-19-2012, 12:13 AM
The first TPB did a pretty good job in getting all the cover art from the different variants, though it would have been even better if they were all presented unaltered. Still, glad they were there in some form.

What I would really love is a TPB of just the collected covers from the Mirage issues since there's plenty to make a nice little book. Mirage, Image, Archie issues plus reprints plus pinups! It would make quite the nice little book. I'll see what Bobby has to say about it...

Turtle Freak88
05-19-2012, 05:06 AM
I buy what I can find and afford. I used to have a ton of comics but my father threw them all away when I left for college.:cry: Now im just sticking to buying the ultimate collections.:tlol: