PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #10 Preview and Review


strugler
05-29-2012, 03:19 AM
10 pages preview of Issue 10:

http://www.tmntlair.com/2012/05/29/teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-10-preview/


A Review will be posted later today.

But here is a tease: Shredder....Identity....Revealed ?

Edit: Review is up! http://www.tmntlair.com/2012/05/29/review-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-10/ Definitely the best issue the series has given us so far

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
05-29-2012, 04:10 AM
very good preview! only 1 day left!

Lampy
05-29-2012, 04:13 AM
thanks for the preview. Im loving the leo-don conflict a lot. But donnie is kind of annoying me. Looking forward to what happens when he does see the foot and the imminent "i told you so" from leo.

strugler
05-29-2012, 06:26 AM
Review is up!

Link in original post.

Toby Barrett
05-29-2012, 06:39 AM
Love how Raph, Mikey, and Donnie's micro issues are referenced! And I see Alopex! :D

Donnie
05-29-2012, 07:40 AM
donnie is kind of annoying me. Looking forward to what happens when he does see the foot and the imminent "i told you so" from leo.

Gotta agree with this. Donatello has been coming off really pompous and kind of just...mean. I think they are taking this ballsy thing of his too far. He immediately goes for Leo's throat if he disagrees.

Lampy
05-29-2012, 08:10 AM
^ good to know i'm not alone on the don thing.

also... has anyone noticed that shredder does not have the scar over his eye? does this mean that the scar-faced ninja is NOT shredder? i'm looking forward to this.

strugler
05-29-2012, 08:14 AM
Actually, i dont mind the Don/Leo arguments. I'm pretty sure it will pay off and play a big role in Don's character development.

Lampy
05-29-2012, 08:29 AM
i actually like the conflict between the two [im assuming] oldest of the brothers. it makes sense... donatello relies more on logic and facts as any scientist. and it's something entirely new that hasn't been explored in any other incarnation. so i'm open to the leo-don conflict. but the way he comes off is a bit annoying. it almost makes you wish that leo would just drag him to a foot gathering and say "SEE?!". and what happens after he discovers the foot? does this argument just dissolves?

corvus
05-29-2012, 08:35 AM
I think Donatello is speaking for a good share of the readers, and sort of making the sudden transition from science fiction related bad guys to mystic ninja bad guys less awkward. If it weren't for donatello we'd have to listen to some hipster douche talk about how they suddenly changed direction and nobody said anything about it. He is a bit different than his mirage counter part whereas he's not passive at all but he's still the smartest turtle who has trouble relating to the others. The idw tmnt are all a little different(besides mike), I mean has there been any Leo vs. Raph testosterone battles yet?

Toby Barrett
05-29-2012, 08:47 AM
Only in issue 6, and that was more to do with the fact that Raphael, who had been seperated from the others for a year, doesn't give two corncobs about being a ninja, and wants to use his abilities to help others and do what's right, sorta making him a Teenage Mutant Hero Turtle.

Lampy
05-29-2012, 09:13 AM
i dont really think he's all that different from his mirage counterpart... just way more vocal. and like i said... the conflict makes sense. but why is it so hard to believe that there is a ninja clan out there called the foot? aren't they ninja? besides... i would assume that four walking talking turtles trained ninjitsu by a walking talking rat would be more unbelievable than recognizing the fact that leo did fight a ninja clan... is it that far of a stretch that they could have been called the foot?

corvus
05-29-2012, 09:19 AM
The way they describe shredders identity makes me think he'll just be Oroku Saki, and the questions we'll be left with are how he's still alive. So that rules out the reincarnation and descendant theories. It'll probably be science mixed with magic.

Jephael
05-29-2012, 09:31 AM
Man, Don's really getting in Leo's face on that last page. I can't wait to get this issue!

corvus
05-29-2012, 10:28 AM
Dons my favorite turtle, Leo is my least favorite. So Don finally questioning his leadership in a non-Raph sort of way is something I've waited for for awhile.

DarkLightDragon
05-29-2012, 12:36 PM
Looks great so far.

Though seeing Alopex again makes me wonder about where Bebop and Rockseady are. Could they be in the process of being 'changed' already?

Regarding Leo and Don fighting again. While I do like this dynamic mostly because it's never been done before and it makes sense that they collide more than Leo and Raph, Don really is starting to be more presumptous mostly because I get a "I'm questioning what I can't understand nor do I want to understand" vibe from when he talks to Leo. Gee, Donnie, if you think you're so smart and Leo's so dumb, why don't you be the leader? It kind of makes me curious to see the look on his face when he sees that there is some mysticism to the Shredder and making the reincarnation idea feel more possible to him.

Donnie
05-29-2012, 05:21 PM
Maybe Donatello will mellow out after he realizes that Leo really is right...while that would be excellent character development (and more than Donnie has received in awhile) I still have to say I'm starting to like him less in IDW than any other universe. He started out cool and edgy, but like has been stated he just comes off pompous at this point, and it seems that he doesn't really want to learn anything, just preach everything.

That's kind of the opposite reason I always liked Donatello in the first place.

CriticalThinker
05-29-2012, 09:09 PM
New member, first post and the first thing I have to say, beside hello, is that I seem to have quite a different opinion on this Leo/Don relationship.

Leo and Don both have very strong, set and unmoving ways of thinking. And while that does and will cause a few clashes, the few conservations I’ve seen between them I took as just a casual back and forth throwing of thoughts/opinions. I consider it both constructive and intriguing seeing how the same circumstances can be interpreted differently by different people, I enjoy such conservations; they make people think. The problem I see is that at the end of such conservations Leo and Don don’t really flex out with each other, they just conclude the other is wrong. As I said both stubborn in their opinions. Maybe that will change in time.

As for the last two pages of the preview, in my opinion, they are both right. While we, as the readers, know that Leonardo is right in regards that it is the Foot Clan, the Shredder, etc, etc, the turtles themselves have little knowledge on what is going on and who is/isn’t involved. Leonardo was being just a little presumptuous, rash, in his conclusion of what and why, and who is responsible. A correct assumption; but an assumption all the same. Donatello wants to go through all possibilities, specifically ones that make more sense to him, which I can somewhat understand. Can’t really say much more on that. Donatello seemed sharper tongued than what I expected, but that could be because they’re all riled up from the stress of the situation. I can’t really be conclusive until I’ve seen the whole issue.

And my final note; with the hints that the identity of the Shredder is meant to be somewhat of a surprise my first thought was could he be Hamato Yoshi. Don’t know where that one came from.

CyberCubed
05-29-2012, 11:42 PM
That 10 page preview was awesome, although I find it odd that Shredder hasn't even spoke.

Donnie
05-30-2012, 10:21 AM
I also just realized that Donnie has been basically calling Splinter a dillusional old man behind his back.

DrSpengler
05-30-2012, 01:12 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #10 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/05/tmnt-idw-10.html)

Loved this issue; probably the best since #5. The three simultaneous narratives were paced really well and lots of new threads were dropped in each. What I dug most, though, was Waltz's handling of the Turtles. They act more like teenagers than just about any other version I've seen; it annoys me when they're written like "miniature adults". The Don/Leo rivalry continues to be one of the best things about the book and real breath of fresh air regarding characterization.

Just a good, good issue.

1984TMNT
05-30-2012, 01:54 PM
Wow...great issue. I will point out, though, that I couldn't help but notice the obvious similiarity between this issue (esp. Splinter/Shredder/Karai) and a certain seen in Batman Begins with Bruce/Ras Al Ghul/fake Ras Al Ghul..... it was pretty uncanny. Even if this seen felt a bit familiar and re-used, it was still great nonetheless.

Tom - was this just a coincidence or were you taking some sort of inspiration from Begins? (which, is one of my all-time favorite "comic" movies - as was TDK).

TomWaltz
05-30-2012, 02:01 PM
Wow...great issue. I will point out, though, that I couldn't help but notice the obvious similiarity between this issue (esp. Splinter/Shredder/Karai) and a certain seen in Batman Begins with Bruce/Ras Al Ghul/fake Ras Al Ghul..... it was pretty uncanny. Even if this seen felt a bit familiar and re0used, it was still great nonetheless.

Tom - was this just a coincidence or were you taking some sort of inspiration from Begins? (which, is one of my all-time favorite "comic" movies - as was TDK).

Honestly, as much as I love Nolan's Batman work, any similarity must've come to me at a subconscious level as I wasn't deliberately riffing on the movie story. Still, if my writing is being compared to something, it could be something far worse than Nolan's fine storytelling, so I'll take it as a compliment, my friend. :)

And... thanks to everyone for the many kind words about issue #10. I CAN'T WAIT for you all to see what's coming in #11, #12... and beyond!

You guys rock!

Tom W.

1984TMNT
05-30-2012, 02:08 PM
Honestly, as much as I love Nolan's Batman work, any similarity must've come to me at a subconscious level as I wasn't deliberately riffing on the movie story. Still, if my writing is being compared to something, it could be something far worse than Nolan's fine storytelling, so I'll take it as a compliment, my friend. :)

And... thanks to everyone for the many kind words about issue #10. I CAN'T WAIT for you all to see what's coming in #11, #12... and beyond!

You guys rock!

Tom W.

Gotcha. Next time you watch Begins, pay close attention to the events and dialogue inside Ras's compound at the top of the mountain and then compare it to your scene in this issue. Pretty sweet!

Seriously though, this is certainly one of my favorite issues thus far. Love the interaction with all of the characters. You seemed to pack a ton in this issue without sacrificing quality, which is fantastic. Can't wait to see what happens next, but am reveling in the suspense you're creating from one issue to the next. I feel like things are percolating pretty heavily now and the lid is about to blow off this thing! GREAT WORK!!!

The cartoon guys now have a really high bar they will have to reach for when attempting to match what you're team is putting out there! I can only hope it doesn't disappoint.

TomWaltz
05-30-2012, 02:13 PM
Gotcha. Next time you watch Begins, pay close attention to the events and dialogue inside Ras's compound at the top of the mountain and then compare it to your scene in this issue. Pretty sweet!

Seriously though, this is certainly one of my favorite issues thus far. Love the interaction with all of the characters. You seemed to pack a ton in this issue without sacrificing quality, which is fantastic. Can't wait to see what happens next, but am reveling in the suspense you're creating from one issue to the next. I feel like things are percolating pretty heavily now and the lid is about to blow off this thing! GREAT WORK!!!

The cartoon guys now have a really high bar they will have to reach for when attempting to match what you're team is putting out there! I can only hope it doesn't disappoint.

Thanks again!

And, if the episode scripts I've read are any indication, though it's very different than our IDW TMNT, the new cartoon is gonna be a blast!

And, after getting a bit of a hands-on sneak peek, so will the new toys!

:tsmile:

1984TMNT
05-30-2012, 02:16 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #10 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/05/tmnt-idw-10.html)

Loved this issue; probably the best since #5. The three simultaneous narratives were paced really well and lots of new threads were dropped in each. What I dug most, though, was Waltz's handling of the Turtles. They act more like teenagers than just about any other version I've seen; it annoys me when they're written like "miniature adults". The Don/Leo rivalry continues to be one of the best things about the book and real breath of fresh air regarding characterization.

Just a good, good issue.

Excellent review, Dr. I agree with your summary 100%. :tgrin:

DarkLightDragon
05-30-2012, 03:10 PM
I was kind of suprised that Chet was a double agent for the Foot.

Killer Moth
05-30-2012, 06:36 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #10 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/05/tmnt-idw-10.html)

Loved this issue; probably the best since #5. The three simultaneous narratives were paced really well and lots of new threads were dropped in each. What I dug most, though, was Waltz's handling of the Turtles. They act more like teenagers than just about any other version I've seen; it annoys me when they're written like "miniature adults". The Don/Leo rivalry continues to be one of the best things about the book and real breath of fresh air regarding characterization.

Just a good, good issue.

Good review, and I'm certainly grateful, as I don't have the issue yet. (I should get it by tomorrow.) I was rather amused by your jab at Greg Horn. I'm wondering which "porny" cover artist you'll take on, next. Truth be told, I like said covers, but I have no love lost for Campbell or Horn. Well, maybe for Horn, as I did like his one Mega Man cover.

Anyway, as for the issue itself, it's more dialogue/plot/talking head-based, which is fine. As the previous issue showed and, hopefully, the next two issues will have plenty of action. (And Shredder and Krang actually doing something, besides looking awesome, and, they do awesome.)

Additional thoughts with certain plot details in the Spoiler tags, etc.

As for the Leo/Don clash, from the preview, Don has a stronger case. Over the course of the year, the Turtles faced many enemies, and not necessarily connected with the Foot or with any major supernatural themes. (True, Apolex is now definitely with the Foot, but the Turtles didn't know that, at the time, and still don't.) Besides clashing with Leo, what is more refreshing is Don's critique of Splinter. Whether Don will have the nerve to voice his criticisms to Splinter openly after this arc ends, one can hope.

Lastly, anyone else feel sorry for the manriki gussari-garbed Foot Soldier? Seeing Splinter for the first time, he might have thought, "oh, man, I have to fight a mutant rat or die?" And while Splinter won't execute him, does this mean the Foot will, since he failed? Oh, dear.

More to say after I read the issue, tomorrow or the next day.

Raph's Girl
05-30-2012, 07:26 PM
Loved this issue!! The conflict between Leo and Don makes sense to me. People fear what they don't understand and to Don mystical stuff is just jibberish to him. While Leo seems to be the one to take it all in and seems to have SOME memories of the past.


Alopex!! Yay!!

Silver Sentry mention! Yay!!

So was Shredder reincarnated too or is he a clone with full memories?? And how is Karai related in all this??

Also, mysterious lady! Who is she? Teng Shen?? Lotus Blossom?? (who had to deal with reincarnation in the original series)

DrSpengler
05-30-2012, 07:38 PM
I was rather amused by your jab at Greg Horn.

Nononono. I said Greg LAND. Not that I care that much more for Greg Horn, mind you, but Land is in a territory all his own when it comes to Terrible Art.

Master Splinter
05-30-2012, 07:46 PM
You guys rock!

So what team was the jersey for? St. Louis Blues? Very nice touch.

:D

-ms

Killer Moth
05-30-2012, 09:07 PM
Nononono. I said Greg LAND. Not that I care that much more for Greg Horn, mind you, but Land is in a territory all his own when it comes to Terrible Art.

I re-read your review, and you're right. I apparently misread it, and whoops. It doesn't help I often get the two names confused. (The only Greg I kinda sorta care at the moment ends with "House," so.) Apologies.

What you said about Duncan's art is true. He gets the job done (IMO), and anymore, anyone meeting a comic deadline, these days, should be cherished or appreciated.

Conversely, there is a nugget of wisdom in Kevin Smith's "Clerks: The Lost Scene," in which Jay basically said, "there are comic people who do meet their deadlines, but you wish they hadn't." It was in reference to John Byrne and his late 90's Spider-Man works, and, back then, it was also self-deprecation at Smith. I'm not saying that about Duncan, but there is some truth to it in the modern comic scene. (Everyone can decide to whom it applies.)

To get back on-topic, I just want to read the issue for the snark on Baxter (both by Krang and Hob). As any snark directed at IDW Baxter is long overdue.

oldmanwinters
05-30-2012, 09:28 PM
So, was that "Ravena (http://turtlemania.ru/pictures/news/2012/rough_idw_tmnt_11_cover_2.jpg)" hanging out beside April's junkshop?

Killer Moth
05-30-2012, 09:44 PM
So, was that "Ravena (http://turtlemania.ru/pictures/news/2012/rough_idw_tmnt_11_cover_2.jpg)" hanging out beside April's junkshop?

Nice use of a corset, as everyone is criticizing Harley Quinn's current one. Heh. Speaking of quasi-fan-service, well, someone has to fill that role until Renet ever shows up. With Karai showing up so early in the game, everything is up in the air on who will show up when in the narrative.

Ninjinister
05-31-2012, 01:14 AM
So um... why is the Shred dude's helmet and muffler back on in the last panel?

Powder
05-31-2012, 01:44 AM
Dope issue. Really solid. Great pacing. Finally getting the whole 'blend all of the universes' thing done properly too. Love the art.

BAXTER STOCKMAN 19
05-31-2012, 04:44 AM
great issue! As many of us were suspecting the Shreddder is the same Shredder that killed turtles and Splinter in Fedual Japan. He also said that he was dead for long which means that he might be a clone. Cant wait until next issue!!

Dirty Blond
05-31-2012, 02:59 PM
Does this Shredder not have a metal mask?

Toby Barrett
05-31-2012, 03:07 PM
No, he wears a cloth over his face.

corvus
05-31-2012, 07:16 PM
So, was that "Ravena (http://turtlemania.ru/pictures/news/2012/rough_idw_tmnt_11_cover_2.jpg)" hanging out beside April's junkshop?

Could also be the mystery purple dragon from cover B of #11. But trench coats seem more superhero in civilian garb. than gang member.

Toby Barrett
05-31-2012, 07:38 PM
Maybe this Ravena is the ally mentioned in issue 11's solicitation.

corvus
05-31-2012, 07:47 PM
May have something to do with the Savate guy we all forgot about.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
05-31-2012, 08:10 PM
Can't wait to read this issue. Hoping it will come in the mail Monday...

SS_Turtle
05-31-2012, 08:34 PM
Can't wait to read this issue. Hoping it will come in the mail Monday...

Same here, mine just shipped yesterday so hopefully I get it tomorrow :D

ToTheNines
05-31-2012, 10:08 PM
Chet pretty much has to be working for the Foot after reporting to his "master".

And my new theory is that the sai ninja from #2 and #3 realized he is the reincarnation of Oroku Saki after Splinter cut his face and introduced a dose of the psychotropic serum into his blood stream.

Gotta agree with this. Donatello has been coming off really pompous and kind of just...mean. I think they are taking this ballsy thing of his too far. He immediately goes for Leo's throat if he disagrees. All I hear when he talks is blah blah blah theory blah blah science blah.

They're actually both being pretty stupid.

I mean, Leo is right... but he's really stretching things when he says stuff like "Baxter Stockman and Old Hob are all signs that our ancient enemies are back".

Don's wrong, and I can totally see why he wouldn't believe all of that... but it's weird that the events of Infestation 2 went unmentioned and even weirder that he totally discredits anything that might be supernatural after that.

So what team was the jersey for? St. Louis Blues? Very nice touch.

:D

-ms

Looked more like a football jersey. Knowing Tom and looking at the colors, I'd have to guess Detroit Lions.

May have something to do with the Savate guy we all forgot about.

Yeah... the dead guy. It's totally the dead guy.

Lampy
06-01-2012, 03:11 AM
incredible issue. very suspenseful and the reveal at the end with shredder is just amazing. it makes you impatient for the next issue. and i gotta say, for an old rat, splinter kicked that foot ninja's butt so fast it must've just been a 5 minute fight. very embarrassing.

as for the don/leo scene... i still am not liking this donatello. leo is also very gullable but donatello is just flat out annoying to me. it's like he just can't get over the fact that leo COULD be right. i have to admit... both leo and don are a bit stubborn though. looking forward to his reaction to the foot.

Andrew NDB
06-01-2012, 06:13 PM
I mostly dug the issue but I find it difficult to get that wrapped up in Splinter's moral dilemma ("I'm a ninja but I won't kill! I refuse it!") when his moral dilemma and the reasons behind it still don't make a lick of sense to me.

Jester
06-01-2012, 06:18 PM
That's you're Hardcore Mirage Bias shining through...

corvus
06-01-2012, 06:21 PM
He wouldn't kill the guy cause he didn't need to. He had already beat without having to.

Andrew NDB
06-01-2012, 06:23 PM
That's you're Hardcore Mirage Bias shining through...

Really? I tend to think it's simple logic.

This just in -- ninjas kill... ergo, if you're a ninja that does not, that's kinda weird. And if the only reason behind why you're a ninja that doesn't kill is because you swore some kind of oath in another life to not avenge the killing of your wife (even though if you'd done so, you would have not only saved the lives of all four of your children but your own!)... well that doesn't make any sense either.

Maybe somebody (Tom?) can explain it to me a little better but right now it's difficult to digest. And I understand the "no killing" thing will be a topic of discussion in the next year of IDW TMNT comics (though I'm almost wondering if by putting the whole thing under the magnifying glass that's only going to succeed in making the issue even more laughable, because as-is I'm not sure it's a topic that's going to hold up under scrutiny).

Toby Barrett
06-01-2012, 06:33 PM
I don't really see why it's hard to understand... Splinter spent an entire lifetime as Hamato Yoshi killing people, and now he doesn't want to do that anymore.
He just wants to live peacefully with his reincarnated turtle children.

corvus
06-01-2012, 07:12 PM
@Andrew NDB I'm pretty sure he's not a pacifist and your confusion is understandable. After all he kept his promise to Teng Shen, he didn't take revenge during his life. But he just didn't the circumstances were honorable. It's like in thunder dome she when max wouldn't kill blaster or an episode of samurai jack I vaguely remember, its kind of a cliche scene actually.

Kendamu
06-01-2012, 07:50 PM
All I hear when he talks is blah blah blah theory blah blah science blah.

http://chicagoreporter.typepad.com/.a/6a00e554ce2daa88340133f32646f1970b-800wi

"Here's what I heard: blah blah blah, science science science BIGGER."

Matches Malone
06-01-2012, 08:21 PM
Really? I tend to think it's simple logic.

This just in -- ninjas kill... ergo, if you're a ninja that does not, that's kinda weird. And if the only reason behind why you're a ninja that doesn't kill is because you swore some kind of oath in another life to not avenge the killing of your wife (even though if you'd done so, you would have not only saved the lives of all four of your children but your own!)... well that doesn't make any sense either.

Maybe somebody (Tom?) can explain it to me a little better but right now it's difficult to digest. And I understand the "no killing" thing will be a topic of discussion in the next year of IDW TMNT comics (though I'm almost wondering if by putting the whole thing under the magnifying glass that's only going to succeed in making the issue even more laughable, because as-is I'm not sure it's a topic that's going to hold up under scrutiny).

I can understand this to an extent. On one hand, there's definitely some getting used to going from Mirage where killing was never really a question. Heck, if I recall correctly, the Tales of the TMNT issue "Temps" was all from a sympathetic POV of a Foot soldier who gets killed and there are basically no consequences for Raphael offing him.

On the other hand, I can accept if Tom wants to write a TMNT with a "no-kill" morality. Sure, historically ninjas kill, steal etc. But this is obviously a fictionalized version where Eastman acknowledges that they made up this "honor code" about ninjas. If Tom wants to take that to the next step where Splinter and his clan take on a "no-kill" policy, I'm okay with that, but ONLY if it makes sense and is compelling.

So at this point, does it? Is it? The jury is still out for me. I agree that logically, the transition from Yoshi being Foot soldier who is morally okay with "honorable killing" to a "no killing whatsoever" policy has not been overly clear.

His family was killed because he didn't want to kill, so the lesson is... don't kill? I'm not saying it should lead to the opposite attitude, I'm just saying the dots need to be connected a little better.

The only explanations I've heard that we could infer, is that he believes that Karma is the true reason his family was murdered; a punishment for his life as an assassin and ninja. A second possible explanation is that he has become so embittered by the cruelty of killing in general (as witnessed by his family's deaths), that he no longer wishes to kill at all. They are now ninjas only in the sense that they are skilled in the art of ninjitsu and martial arts, but they live by a different code than the Foot. I'm okay with either of those explanations, really, but I'd like that to be a little clearer since these are just inferences at this point. I think Tom is leaving a little too much unsaid, if we are to really understand Splinter's motivations right now.

Or maybe some or all of the above are exactly what they are going to be exploring in year two.

corvus
06-01-2012, 08:41 PM
^ you really don't think its simpler than that and splinter just didn't want to kill a guy in a way he considered dishonorable for a group he considers dishonorable?

SS_Turtle
06-01-2012, 09:32 PM
Just got my issues in the mail, I am loving CVR A.
It looks like Shredder is in 3D, his arms just pop out from the cover.

Lampy
06-01-2012, 11:28 PM
splinter's moral dilemma is nothing new actually. we've seen versions of the Turtles not wanting to kill. however, i do believe that when the time comes, splinter will eventually allow them to kill. and so will he. my guess... i may be wrong... is that splinter wants his first kill to be shredder. his oath was to destroy Oroku Saki... and i doubt he will ignore that and take it back. so with that in mind... maybe the only person he is set to kill is Saki.

Powder
06-02-2012, 12:30 AM
^ you really don't think its simpler than that and splinter just didn't want to kill a guy in a way he considered dishonorable for a group he considers dishonorable?

Yeah I'm with this... That's how I read it. If it continues to happen, then maybe we'll talk.

Matches Malone
06-02-2012, 04:26 AM
^ you really don't think its simpler than that and splinter just didn't want to kill a guy in a way he considered dishonorable for a group he considers dishonorable?

Regarding the scene in #10 specifically, it certainly can, and probably is as simple as that. I'm commenting more generally on the numerous mentions from Splinter about how they now walk the "path of peace," making it a real possibility that it means they will not kill under any circumstances. He's alluded to this in #1, #5, the Leonardo Micro, and #10. If this is the case, I just think it needs to be made clearer the reasons and motivations why. If they are willing to kill when necessary, then that definitely isn't clear either. Still, like I said, maybe this is all meant to be addressed in year two.

corvus
06-02-2012, 08:31 AM
He probably just wants to live peacefully with his sons as opposed to his former life in the foot clan where killing was a big part of his life.

Lampy
06-02-2012, 08:58 AM
He probably just wants to live peacefully with his sons as opposed to his former life in the foot clan where killing was a big part of his life.

While i agree this to be true somehow... I dont think he will let shredder live. Once he and the Turtles are reunited... He will change things up a bit. Their mission will change... So will their oath to avoid killing. I doubt splinter will just forget about what swore to do once he and shredder meets again. They will kill eventually. My guess...

corvus
06-02-2012, 01:13 PM
I think in issue four when Raphael wants to kill Hob and Don doesn't think its a horrible idea when.Leonardo says something like "he's beat, not like this" pretty much sums it up. The mirage turtles/splinter probably wouldn't have killed someone when they were on the ground beaten either.

The Big Bad
06-02-2012, 05:19 PM
I think in issue four when Raphael wants to kill Hob and Don doesn't think its a horrible idea when.Leonardo says something like "he's beat, not like this" pretty much sums it up. The mirage turtles/splinter probably wouldn't have killed someone when they were on the ground beaten either.

I disagree: I feel they would have, if it made tactical and/or strategic sense--and the situation in issue #4 was one of those. The fact that Old Hob is beaten doesn't make him less of a threat. He'll still be out there trying to kill them, and he only needs to be lucky once, while the turtles have to be lucky every time. And it's not like Hob is like the 4Kids Shredder--killing him isn't likely to have obvious harmful long-term effects.

Powder
06-02-2012, 05:48 PM
He probably just wants to live peacefully with his sons as opposed to his former life in the foot clan where killing was a big part of his life.

The whole point of their existence as it is now is to get revenge. So... I dunno about that.

Redeemer
06-03-2012, 10:46 AM
Another good issue!
I have mixed feelings about shredder only being resurrected.., I was hoping he was immortal somehow.....I thought it would be awesome if he was... I was glad to see Alopex again, I was also hoping to see Beebop and Rocksteady, but maybe in the near future... I was hoping to see TMNT fight the shredder, but seeing Splinter whoop some ass :lol:, I am glad to see he is not jst some feeble old man., I have to say the Leo and Don fights are little refreshing compared to the classic Leo,Raph fight.

Can't wait for issue 11 and the new micro series!!

Matches Malone
06-03-2012, 01:47 PM
The whole point of their existence as it is now is to get revenge. So... I dunno about that.

Yep, and that's kind of why I was talking about when I said it was confusing when Splinter tells his sons that they must use violence only as a last resort. He says he learned this the hard way, but I don't really see how his use of violence led to a tragic lesson. If anything, like Andrew said, it was his failure to use violence against Oroku Saki and the Foot to protect his family that arguably led to their demise. Just seems to be a bit of a disconnect in logic there... It feels like there must be more to his reasoning that has been left unsaid.

corvus
06-03-2012, 01:58 PM
Or it was his whole involvement in the foot(life of violence) that got hid family killed.

Lampy
06-03-2012, 10:03 PM
it wasn't his life of violence that got his family killed. Ironically... it was his refusal to dishonorably kill people. This was considered betrayal against the foot according to shredder. Yoshi then deemed the foot a dishonorable clan under the shredder's command. That got his family killed.

Matches Malone
06-03-2012, 10:48 PM
it wasn't his life of violence that got his family killed. Ironically... it was his refusal to dishonorably kill people. This was considered betrayal against the foot according to shredder. Yoshi then deemed the foot a dishonorable clan under the shredder's command. That got his family killed.

But I see his point. You could argue that if Yoshi had never associated himself and joined the Foot to begin with, he never would have had anything to fear from them.

Lampy
06-04-2012, 12:03 AM
if you're talking karma... and the whole thing to begin with... then yes.

corvus
06-04-2012, 06:13 AM
I think that, like most comics these days, IDW moves very slow and especially with one issue a month. This is the reason that fans over-think theses things. It makes sense to me, splinter doesn't like dishonorable or unnecessary killing, he thinks Hob is mislead and that's why he's still alive, he understands the ridiculously muscular foot ninja was being forced into the fight as well and that he was knocked out thus killing him was dishonorable.

Lampy
06-04-2012, 08:43 AM
I think that, like most comics these days, IDW moves very slow and especially with one issue a month. This is the reason that fans over-think theses things.

Ahhh... the magic of decompressed story arcs.
Very true..:tconfuse:

TomWaltz
06-04-2012, 12:15 PM
Really? I tend to think it's simple logic.

This just in -- ninjas kill... ergo, if you're a ninja that does not, that's kinda weird. And if the only reason behind why you're a ninja that doesn't kill is because you swore some kind of oath in another life to not avenge the killing of your wife (even though if you'd done so, you would have not only saved the lives of all four of your children but your own!)... well that doesn't make any sense either.

Maybe somebody (Tom?) can explain it to me a little better but right now it's difficult to digest. And I understand the "no killing" thing will be a topic of discussion in the next year of IDW TMNT comics (though I'm almost wondering if by putting the whole thing under the magnifying glass that's only going to succeed in making the issue even more laughable, because as-is I'm not sure it's a topic that's going to hold up under scrutiny).

Oh, we'll explain it all right -- starting with the Splinter micro-series issue and continuing in the ongoing. This is a very important topic for us and one we've thought about quite a bit, trust me. Splinter has his reasons for not killing... and killing... as you will see.

Oh... and to answer someone else's earlier question, Ravena does not show up in TMNT. She's a character I created for the iHero Universe (www.ihero.net) and Kevin was goofing around when he drew that. You'll meet the real special guest(s) in issue #11.

Toby Barrett
06-04-2012, 06:31 PM
One thing I just noticed thumbing through my copy...

At the end of the book, Karai and April's noses get HUUUUUUGE. XD

Rooish
06-04-2012, 10:05 PM
I'm kind of getting sick of Don, frankly. He's acting so nasty and mocking to Leo. I'm worried that Leo is going to just be constantly fighting with others--first Don, and then Raph later, I'm hoping. You can't have a TMNT story without a Leo-Raph disagreement! But here, it makes sense that Don is challenging Leo's authority. Although I don't know when Leo was actually given the title of "leader." Don alludes that Leo should act like a real leader, and I thought it was odd that Leo already had that official and kind of lame title.

Other than that, the issue is great. I am cool with the Turtles and Splinter not being killers in this. In Mirage and Image they may have killed more, but I still could imagine Mirage Splinter sparing that muscley ninja, or Mirage Leo stopping Raph from killing Hob, given the context.

Seriously though, I think it's time they actually killed Hob when they find him incapacitated again. The guy is super annoying.

Lampy
06-05-2012, 01:57 AM
Oh, we'll explain it all right -- starting with the Splinter micro-series issue and continuing in the ongoing. This is a very important topic for us and one we've thought about quite a bit, trust me. Splinter has his reasons for not killing... and killing... as you will see.

Thanks for the reassurance Tom. Looking forward to the issue... we fans are kinda getting edgy each issue hoping for answers. :tsmile:

Coola Yagami
06-05-2012, 02:05 PM
I'm kind of getting sick of Don, frankly. He's acting so nasty and mocking to Leo. I'm worried that Leo is going to just be constantly fighting with others--first Don, and then Raph later, I'm hoping. You can't have a TMNT story without a Leo-Raph disagreement! But here, it makes sense that Don is challenging Leo's authority. Although I don't know when Leo was actually given the title of "leader." Don alludes that Leo should act like a real leader, and I thought it was odd that Leo already had that official and kind of lame title.

Other than that, the issue is great. I am cool with the Turtles and Splinter not being killers in this. In Mirage and Image they may have killed more, but I still could imagine Mirage Splinter sparing that muscley ninja, or Mirage Leo stopping Raph from killing Hob, given the context.

Seriously though, I think it's time they actually killed Hob when they find him incapacitated again. The guy is super annoying.

Krang might kill Hob (and Baxter?) before the Turtles do....

corvus
06-05-2012, 04:01 PM
Maybe they're gonna try to extract the mutagen from Hob and in doing so get a really unstable version of it. But am I the wondering if they'll mutate Baxter, turn him into a cyborg or what? Cause to my knowledge there's never been a version of him that stayed normal.

Andrew NDB
06-05-2012, 09:36 PM
Oh, we'll explain it all right -- starting with the Splinter micro-series issue and continuing in the ongoing. This is a very important topic for us and one we've thought about quite a bit, trust me. Splinter has his reasons for not killing... and killing... as you will see.

Well that's good enough for me. I have faith.

TonySiegel
06-06-2012, 12:14 AM
i dunno dudes, for the price tag were paying for each issue is it really paying off? Issue 10 was cool, but it still feels like were getting a stable amount of quality while the interest in the books wain slightly after each issue.

Andrew NDB
06-06-2012, 02:06 AM
i dunno dudes, for the price tag were paying for each issue is it really paying off?

I say yeah. I mean I hope when the dust settles a bit and something resembling a status quo can be established we get more in the way of standalone stories and shorter arcs and less in the way of "written for trade" type of fare, but there doesn't seem reason to complain yet.

corvus
06-06-2012, 06:11 AM
It's pretty much like every other comic in that way, the slow build in big story arcs. But I don't see the sins of the father arc being more than two or three issues. After that they'll probably have something with the fugitoid.

Donnie
06-06-2012, 09:57 AM
So I never got around to posting thoughts on this issue, I've been partying it up for my birthday! :D

This was my favorite issue since #5. Honestly I was beginning to worry where the series was going since #5, but now it's totally picking up. Although the Turtles didn't see any action per se, the character development is really shining through.

Michelangelo as peace keeper and voice of reason was awesomely done. Very true to his Mirage nature! Although I'm luke-warm on Donnie (he has since issue #6 striked me as obnoxious), the rivalry with Leo is nonetheless refreshing and new. You can tell how Raphael's anger is going to start showing really soon, cause it has been strangely absent since his re-joining the group.

I also am liking Splinter more than I have in other incarnations. He was always a likeable character, but IDW's take on him is, thus far, my favorite.

Pretty crazy that there was no trick - the Shredder is Oroku Saki. I didn't see that coming actually, I thought we were going to get a twist there.

Also really liked DD's art, which is uncommon for me!

CHERRY ON TOP --- Silver Sentry!!! Raph's line was hilarious about Don and Mike...two nerds in a geek pod or something along those lines...I LITERALLY laughed out loud. Funny stuff! A lot of people forget that Mikey is totally a comic nerd. Donnie's a nerd in a different way. It's cool that Raph (and thus Tom Waltz and co.) realized that!

Great issue, can't wait for #11!

Donnie
06-06-2012, 10:07 AM
Don's wrong, and I can totally see why he wouldn't believe all of that... but it's weird that the events of Infestation 2 went unmentioned and even weirder that he totally discredits anything that might be supernatural after that.


That's a great point, Nines. The Donatello of Infestation was totally different than this one in many ways. Will Infestation ever be brought up again, or is it accepted as a "sub-universe"?

Redeemer
06-06-2012, 10:25 AM
Oh... and to answer someone else's earlier question, Ravena does not show up in TMNT. She's a character I created for the iHero Universe (www.ihero.net) and Kevin was goofing around when he drew that. You'll meet the real special guest(s) in issue #11.

Usagi!!!!!?????????? Beebop????RockSteady????????????????
Usagi is a long shot, but that would be awesome!

TomWaltz
06-06-2012, 12:22 PM
It's pretty much like every other comic in that way, the slow build in big story arcs. But I don't see the sins of the father arc being more than two or three issues. After that they'll probably have something with the fugitoid.

"Sins of the Fathers" will be a 2-issue arc (#13/14), followed by another 2-issue arc (15/16) tentatively titled "Blood Brothers".

CyberCubed
06-06-2012, 12:30 PM
I am surprised Casey's father is going to have a bigger role, I thought he was just going to be a throwaway character to explain why Casey decided to wear the hockey mask.

Matches Malone
06-06-2012, 12:55 PM
I am surprised Casey's father is going to have a bigger role, I thought he was just going to be a throwaway character to explain why Casey decided to wear the hockey mask.

Did I miss something? Someone said something about Casey's dad? Or is that just a guess based on the title, "Sins of the Fathers"? It's a good guess, I'm just wondering if someone specifically mentioned it.

Powder
06-07-2012, 01:04 AM
"Sins of the Fathers" will be a 2-issue arc (#13/14), followed by another 2-issue arc (15/16) tentatively titled "Blood Brothers".

Oh rad, sounds refreshing. Looking forward to 'em!

corvus
06-07-2012, 06:16 AM
Did I miss something? Someone said something about Casey's dad? Or is that just a guess based on the title, "Sins of the Fathers"? It's a good guess, I'm just wondering if someone specifically mentioned it.

It's based on the description of issue 13. On the cover of 14 it looks like it could be him in the reflection of splinters sword.

Andrew NDB
06-07-2012, 02:58 PM
Yes, very pleased that -- apparently -- Oroku Saki/The Shredder is, in fact, Oroku Saki/The Shredder and not some kind of robot body inhabited by an alien or other science fiction oddity.

Though clearly something is up with him if he's still kicking in 2012... if it's some kind of anti-aging miracle or suspended animation of some kind that's done the trick, then I'm OK with those. Just keep him human, that's all I ask.

Toby Barrett
06-07-2012, 03:17 PM
He says he came back from a very long death, so yea, my bets are still on Zombie Shredder, which is badass.

Andrew NDB
06-07-2012, 03:19 PM
He says he came back from a very long death, so yea, my bets are still on Zombie Shredder, which is badass.

Not unprecedented, I guess. Perhaps he worm-cloned himself or something?

corvus
06-07-2012, 03:42 PM
All I know is Chr'll was the beginning of the downward spiral for the 4kids show, interesting concept but did they have to do it with shredder? and reincarnation would be a bit redundant. He's Oroku Saki IN THE FLESH(as splinter points out) and I'm freakin glad.

TheCollector
06-07-2012, 04:08 PM
I personally think that maybe this Oroku Saki isn't and is the original Oroku Saki. Is in the same way as Splinter is Yoshi and isn't in the same way as well.

Meaning, he's the Foot Ninja that was scared by Splinter in the beginning of the series and something about that, or just Spinter and the Turtles being reborn as they were, activated Oroku in that Foot Ninja's body, causing him to take over.

Toby Barrett
06-07-2012, 04:31 PM
Splinter recognized him though, and he still has the same face as the original Oroku Saki.

corvus
06-07-2012, 07:14 PM
And splinter recognizes his voice and actually says "my ancient enemy had indeed returned alive and in the flesh" and That ninja doesn't have a scar on his face later on when they try to kill splinter in the alley.

Donnie
06-07-2012, 08:28 PM
All I know is Chr'll was the beginning of the downward spiral for the 4kids show, interesting concept but did they have to do it with shredder? and reincarnation would be a bit redundant. He's Oroku Saki IN THE FLESH(as splinter points out) and I'm freakin glad.

Idk, that's pretty subjective man. Ch'rell was pretty badass to others. I liked the whole angle.

corvus
06-07-2012, 09:07 PM
I liked Chr'll and I liked Shredder. I just didn't like Chr'll being shredder.

Powder
06-07-2012, 09:19 PM
Idk, that's pretty subjective man. Ch'rell was pretty badass to others. I liked the whole angle.

Beat me to the punch, haha.

strugler
06-08-2012, 04:17 PM
Check out this mini interview with Tom Waltz i did regarding Issue 10 whats coming after:

http://www.tmntlair.com/2012/06/07/pimi-for-issue-10-with-tom-waltz/

Thanx to Tom, i will, hopefully, be doing a PIMI (which stands for Post Issue Mini Interview) everytime a new TMNT issue comes out.

I hope you enjoy it!

corvus
06-08-2012, 04:54 PM
Hmm. Interesting. I'm pretty sure that mysterious figure is the purple dragon chick shown on cover B of issue eleven and those new characters are purple dragons. I'm guessing bebop and rocksteady won't show up for awhile. Sins of the father doesn't seem like a bebop and rocksteady type of story, blood brothers might though and the one after that is probably a fugitoid story which I don't see the foot being involved in.

thelouisguy
06-09-2012, 09:02 PM
Best issue of the series so far. Really intrigued by the mysterious woman.

Mr._Mutant_Man
06-10-2012, 12:34 PM
This has been my favorite issue of the IDW series yet.

We get to see Splinter in action. We get a good scene of brothers arguing. Raphael really sounded like Raphael. I could imagine the voice actor from the first movie when I was reading. The introduction of the antique shop is great. Almost to the point where I don't want to see it destroyed this time around.

Venom
06-11-2012, 01:31 PM
The introduction of the antique shop is great. Almost to the point where I don't want to see it destroyed this time around.

How about the second time around? :trazz:

thelouisguy
06-11-2012, 01:49 PM
How about the second time around? :trazz:

Ha ha! Actually, they should save it for a long time and destroy it almost by surprise. The way the IDW series is being written, you almost expect that as soon as you are introduced to the antique shop, that it will be burned down based on the events of the Mirage issues. If they kept it around longer than expected, we would think that it would not be burned down. Then, when it did get burned down, it would be a surprise, even though we all expect it.