PDA

View Full Version : Why do some people complain about Ch'rell even after watching season 5?


TurtleFan2012
06-30-2012, 06:45 AM
Geez, they finally gave us a real human Shredder and some people still complain/whine about Shredder being an utrom :roll:

I think the entire lost season was created just to shut some angry fans up about the utrom twist.

ToTheNines
06-30-2012, 08:15 AM
Season 5 sucked eggs.

Ch'rell was cool though.

CyberCubed
06-30-2012, 09:25 AM
Season 5 showed us the true Shredder.

Most people liked Ch'rell so I don't know where this comes from.

zkarlette
06-30-2012, 01:56 PM
Ch'rell seemed a little far fetched to me...but it's ok I guess.

gobo
06-30-2012, 02:30 PM
Humanoid mutant turtles that do martial arts aren't as far-fetched. No way. :P

Jester
06-30-2012, 02:59 PM
Humanoid mutant turtles that do martial arts aren't as far-fetched. No way. :P

Ch'rell seemed a little far fetched to me...but it's ok I guess.
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/Farfetched.jpg

Andrew NDB
06-30-2012, 03:14 PM
Humanoid mutant turtles that do martial arts aren't as far-fetched. No way. :P

Ah, Crisler's Law (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler's%20Law)...

Icebot
06-30-2012, 06:00 PM
This true Shredder was dead for 1,700 years, to me he seemed just as weird as Utrom Shredder.

Jester
06-30-2012, 06:16 PM
Ah, Crisler's Law (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Crisler's%20Law)...
Still not sure who this Crisler is....

Xav
06-30-2012, 06:30 PM
Geez, they finally gave us a real human Shredder and some people still complain/whine about Shredder being an utrom :roll:
Because the human Shredder was only in like one season. Than they went to a Cyber clone of Ch'rell. An impostor of an impostor if you will.

Season 5 sucked eggs. Those were some damn good eggs.

Cipher
06-30-2012, 06:32 PM
Yeah, I don't really buy the whole "it can't be too farfetched because the serious is about mutant turtles" thing. You can certainly accept fantasy in the foundation and still have later elements shatter suspension of disbelief.

For example, how many of you accepted all the time-travel, Lovecraftian monsters, aliens, mutants, ninja mafias, etc., and still rolled your eyes whenever Donatello invented a new flying car or when they went into the ... ugh, cyberworld? That's totally fair.

But what amazes me is no one ever says the obvious thing in these discussions: "How can you accept the presence of exo-suit-wearing brain aliens and then say it's too farfetched that Shredder is one of them?"

Like, I don't get how you can be totally fine with a bunch of these aliens landing in ancient Japan, but then be shocked and horrified that one of them happens to be the Shredder.

Mr.Turtle
06-30-2012, 11:41 PM
why do ppl even call shredder ch'rell... they never call him that in the show, why do ppl even call him like that.

Jester
06-30-2012, 11:46 PM
Just to BLOW YOUR LITTLE MIND!

Andrew NDB
06-30-2012, 11:48 PM
why do ppl even call shredder ch'rell... they never call him that in the show, why do ppl even call him like that.

Any one of a number of sound reasons, I suppose.

1. The same reason people refer to Bruce Wayne in conversations about Batman. Or Oroku Saki when talking about Shredder in any other universe.
2. "The Shredder" is a moniker that Ch'rell adopted and did not even create or originate.
3. To delineate between the alternate universe versions of Shredder when referring to 4Kids Shredder. There is no Ch'rell in any universe but the 4Kids universe.

Or many others.

Mr.Turtle
06-30-2012, 11:53 PM
i dont remeber when did they call him that in the show?

Jester
07-01-2012, 12:12 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZaWZt9FEeL0&t=5m41s

Mr.Turtle
07-01-2012, 12:28 AM
so they only called him ch'rell once or so in the the entire season and all of a sudden everybody call him ch'rell now? wow.

Jester
07-01-2012, 12:39 AM
http://tmnt.wikia.com/wiki/Ch'rell
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WKWVLmDWYm8&t=1h6m5s

zkarlette
07-01-2012, 12:45 AM
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/Jesterangelo/Farfetched.jpg

Thanks :D

But what I mean is that it was really weird how even without his suit armor he was able to fight and be super powerful being so little.

Mr.Turtle
07-01-2012, 12:54 AM
2 times he's called ch'rell in the show and now everybody call him ch'rell...pff..

zkarlette
07-01-2012, 01:04 AM
2 times he's called ch'rell in the show and now everybody call him ch'rell...pff..

How do you call him?

Cipher
07-01-2012, 01:54 AM
How do you call him?Try using the Ch'rell-o-phone.

gobo
07-01-2012, 06:26 AM
try using the ch'rell-o-phone.
:lol::lol::lol:

ToTheNines
07-01-2012, 06:52 AM
2 times he's called ch'rell in the show and now everybody call him ch'rell...pff..

Shut the **** up already.

Jester
07-01-2012, 09:11 AM
2 times he's called ch'rell in the show and now everybody call him ch'rell...pff..
Well, we could always call him "The Utrom Shredder" but Ch'rell is a lot shorter...isn't it?

gobo
07-01-2012, 09:30 AM
Obvious troll isn't obvious? O_o

Jester
07-01-2012, 09:36 AM
Obviously not...he's still here. :P

Xav
07-01-2012, 02:07 PM
2 times he's called ch'rell in the show and now everybody call him ch'rell...pff.. He was also called that in the shows concept art. http://www.flickr.com/photos/terrible2z/2892930838/
Since there is more than one Shredder in the 4Kids universe, I think people call him that so you know which Shredder they are talking about.

Jester
07-01-2012, 02:10 PM
But, Xav, that's LOGICAL, and thus far beyond Mr. Turtle's comprehension.

gobo
07-01-2012, 02:23 PM
So mean... :evilgrin:

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
07-01-2012, 02:58 PM
Karai is the most human "Shredder" in the 2003 show.

Keldor1578
07-01-2012, 03:52 PM
so they only called him ch'rell once or so in the the entire season and all of a sudden everybody call him ch'rell now? wow.

Doesn't really matter if they call him Ch'rell,

Keldor1578
07-01-2012, 07:06 PM
At least They kept the Oroku Saki persona after he was revealed to be an utrom.

Mr.Turtle
07-01-2012, 09:26 PM
But, Xav, that's LOGICAL, and thus far beyond Mr. Turtle's comprehension.

So mean... :evilgrin:

o boy, someone's in love again...:roll:

Jester
07-01-2012, 10:05 PM
Gobo and I have had a bromance since way before you joined this forum.

It's a fact. We've been pals pre-Drome.

Mr.Turtle
07-01-2012, 10:07 PM
i knew it!

TurtleFan2012
07-02-2012, 09:25 AM
so they only called him ch'rell once or so in the the entire season and all of a sudden everybody call him ch'rell now? wow.

Ch'rell is supposely his real name. He even calls himself that in the Turtles Forever movie.

Shredder's line in Turtles Forever:
"You speak my name, but you do not know me. I am Ch'rell, Oroku Saki, Duke Acureds, the one TRUE Shredder! I am a destroyer of worlds, and I FEAR NO ONE!

pannoni1
07-02-2012, 12:15 PM
This was the first time in TMNT history that a series featured multiple Shredders (separate personalities, not phantoms like in Shredder and Splintered/the Arcade Game). They just don't understand that The Foot in this version is allowed for "The Shredder" to be a mantle that can be controlled by multiple people, and after having Karai as Shredder in Season 4 should have made people understand by this point that there are multiple Shredders in this universe. I just wonder how the name "Ch'rell" has caught on so well despite only being called that twice, rather than "Utrom Shredder" which sounds a lot more recognizable as being the turtles' arch-nemesis.

Jester
07-02-2012, 12:29 PM
It's shorter...and you're talking to the most die hard of the fan base, it may have been only mentioned twice, but if any one would catch it it'd be us.

Mr.Turtle
07-02-2012, 12:31 PM
im a die hard but i dont call him like that.

Jester
07-02-2012, 12:39 PM
im a die hard but i dont call him like that.
No...no you're not.

Cipher
07-02-2012, 02:12 PM
im a die hard but i dont call him like that.How do you call him?

Jester
07-02-2012, 02:16 PM
How do you call him?

Don't start that again! :P

Cipher
07-02-2012, 02:23 PM
Don't start that again! :Phttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/6/66/Fozzie-bear.jpg

Mr.Turtle
07-02-2012, 02:40 PM
do u really think ch'rell is easier to type than utrum shredder???

Cipher
07-02-2012, 02:50 PM
Does it really matter? That's his name. You can call him whatever you want; no one's stopping you.

Jester
07-02-2012, 03:45 PM
do u really think ch'rell is easier to type than utrum shredder???
Oh, sweet irony. :P

Xav
07-02-2012, 03:45 PM
This was the first time in TMNT history that a series featured multiple Shredders (separate personalities, not phantoms like in Shredder and Splintered/the Arcade Game). But didn't the Image series have Raph as the Shredder and the Lady Shredder?

Mr.Turtle
07-02-2012, 04:41 PM
Does it really matter? That's his name. You can call him whatever you want; no one's stopping you.

true, but still, just think it's stupid that they call him that way because he only mentioned it 2 times.

Jester
07-02-2012, 04:44 PM
If we found out your name was really Bob would you expect us to continue calling you Mr. Turtles all the time and wonder why we called you Bob?

Mr.Turtle
07-02-2012, 04:53 PM
actually, i'd prefer u call me mr.turtle coz not everybody knows ur real name but when u say utrum shredder everybody knows who ur talkin abt.

even shredder himself rarely call himself ch'rell at all. why do ppl call him like that?

Xav
07-02-2012, 05:18 PM
Because Ch'rell is a shorter word than Utrom Shredder.

zkarlette
07-03-2012, 02:05 PM
actually, i'd prefer u call me mr.turtle coz not everybody knows ur real name but when u say utrum shredder everybody knows who ur talkin abt.

even shredder himself rarely call himself ch'rell at all. why do ppl call him like that?

Maybe because he rarely is without his armor suit and when he has it on he is supposed to be the shredder, you never saw people calling shredder Ch'rell it would be confusing, to the children of course...

Tuxedo Moroboshi
07-03-2012, 03:25 PM
Why do people call Superman "Kal-El"? Pfft, he's only been referred to like that a handful of times; I don't see why anyone would ever call him that. Besides, isn't Cluck Kent easier to type than Kal-El?

http://25.media.tumblr.com/avatar_6feb8634e3d0_128.png

Jester
07-03-2012, 03:30 PM
Obvious troll is...actually quite funny.

corvus
07-04-2012, 12:29 PM
I kind of wish Ch'rell didn't turn out to be an impostor in this universe. Like he just creates that identity for himself and took over the foot. I really didn't like the Tengu shredder and that whole turtles turning into dragons thing.

AT-Man
07-05-2012, 12:37 PM
Ch'rell is his real name and that's what I call him. Though Kal-El is Superman's real name, everyone knows who I mean when I talk about Superman, but there are several "real" Shredders.

Vincent
07-23-2012, 10:31 PM
Geez, they finally gave us a real human Shredder and some people still complain/whine about Shredder being an utrom :roll:

I think the entire lost season was created just to shut some angry fans up about the utrom twist.

First of all, Season 5 was a mess. Human shredder, yes, but far in the past, which completely defeats the purpose. Season 1 Shredder should have been human, and was clearly supposed to be until they retconned it.

Secondly, here are a few reasons why Ch'Rell was a bad idea:
The idea that Saki (the one we saw in season 1) is just a man who has lost his "humanity" and gained a lot of power has dramatic impact. Being anything but human completely deflates this.
The idea that he has trained himself to be an almost unstoppable fighter is interesting. The idea that he's just a mechanical husk being controlled by an alien blob completely deflates this.
If they wanted an evil Utrom as the big bad of season 2, they should have just reinvented Krang and left the Shredder out of it.

And here are signs that Ch'Rell was a retcon:
Shredder being desperate to fish a broken Utrom exo suit out of the water for reverse engineering purposes, even though he supposedly already had a fully working one according to the retcon.
Shredder Clones...clearly human-based. How can Utrom Shredder have clones that don't look the least bit Utrom? The answer of course is that they hadn't thought of the Utrom Shredder idea yet.
Pretty much everything building up to his head getting cut off (which was probably originally going to be dealt with some other way, possibly through some kind of sorcery) played out with great impact specifically because this guy, a man, not a mutant, not a vampire, not an alien, but a man, was the monster, in contrast to the turtles, who would otherwise be considered monsters and yet behaved with much more humanity than Saki did.

Let's not call Ch'Rell a twist. It wasn't a twist. It was a retcon that sucked the dramatic impact and philosophical implications out of the character to turn him into no more than a generic "evil space monster".
It's like if it turned out at the end of the new Batman movie that Batman was a robot all along. The whole point of Batman is that he's just a man who has pushed himself to become something else. Robot batman wouldn't be impressive, because a decent robot is expected to be good at whatever it's built for. A human has to overcome a bunch of stuff in order to be the best. The same goes for the Shredder, except he took a different path than Batman.

That's why Ch'Rell was an ill-conceived retcon.

CyberCubed
07-23-2012, 10:44 PM
Wrong. Ch'rell was planned from the beginning.

Genesis
07-24-2012, 01:43 AM
Why do people call Superman "Kal-El"? Pfft, he's only been referred to like that a handful of times; I don't see why anyone would ever call him that. Besides, isn't Cluck Kent easier to type than Kal-El?

http://25.media.tumblr.com/avatar_6feb8634e3d0_128.pngSee, that's doing it properly.

Ch'rell was planned from the beginning.He's right, you know.

Vincent
07-24-2012, 04:34 AM
Wrong. Ch'rell was planned from the beginning.
According to what sources? And where was the foreshadowing? And why were the Shredder clones never mentioned again after the Ch'rell reveal? And why would Ch'rell want to study a broken exo suit when he already has one that works?

This sounds to me a lot like George Lucas saying the Star Wars prequels were written decades before production just to make it sound like he had a plan all along.

Candy Kappa
07-24-2012, 04:40 AM
According to what sources? And where was the foreshadowing? And why were the Shredder clones never mentioned again after the Ch'rell reveal? And why would Ch'rell want to study a broken exo suit when he already has one that works?

This sounds to me a lot like George Lucas saying the Star Wars prequels were written decades before production just to make it sound like he had a plan all along.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/terrible2z/3202927934/

Vincent
07-24-2012, 07:25 AM
http://www.flickr.com/photos/terrible2z/3202927934/
"During preproduction" doesn't necessarily have to mean before any episodes were written. It could be that they had broken, scripted and perhaps even storyboarded several key episodes before coming up with the idea that the Shredder could be an Utrom. It's possible that they had a near-final draft of Return to New York written before the idea of Utrom Shredder came up. Preproduction encompasses a lot more than just character design. I'm not sure exactly where the line is drawn between preproduction and production in television animation, but if it's anything like live action filmmaking, the line is probably drawn at the animation stage, and a lot of work is done before that. I also don't know in what order the episodes were produced, nor in how large chunks at a time.

Allio
07-24-2012, 08:40 AM
I just call Ch'rell 03'Shredder... I mean, you think of the 2003 shredder, you instantly think of the Utrom Shredder... the other two I still call Demon Shredder and Cyber Shredder


And here are signs that Ch'Rell was a retcon:
Shredder being desperate to fish a broken Utrom exo suit out of the water for reverse engineering purposes, even though he supposedly already had a fully working one according to the retcon.
Shredder Clones...clearly human-based. How can Utrom Shredder have clones that don't look the least bit Utrom? The answer of course is that they hadn't thought of the Utrom Shredder idea yet.
Pretty much everything building up to his head getting cut off (which was probably originally going to be dealt with some other way, possibly through some kind of sorcery) played out with great impact specifically because this guy, a man, not a mutant, not a vampire, not an alien, but a man, was the monster, in contrast to the turtles, who would otherwise be considered monsters and yet behaved with much more humanity than Saki did.


I always thought the idea was that they attempted to make just regular human clones (like take dna from a normal foot ninja) and combine it with Ch'rell's dna in order to make soldier that could also work as scapegoats for Shredder... but the mixture of Utrom Dna and human dna created the mutations...



Ch'rell is supposely his real name. He even calls himself that in the Turtles Forever movie.

Shredder's line in Turtles Forever:
"You speak my name, but you do not know me. I am Ch'rell, Oroku Saki, Duke Acureds, the one TRUE Shredder! I am a destroyer of worlds, and I FEAR NO ONE!

http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z32/Gangsta_Videl/shutupdecade.jpg

Genesis
07-24-2012, 11:47 AM
In regards to the Shredder getting the exo-suit from the sea, bear in mind that he stole the exo-suit he uses - the only one he has, at that point. Also remember that the purpose of fishing it out was to let Baxter Stockman use it for the Foot mechs and stuff. It's safe to say that Ch'rell isn't very technologically capable (otherwise, why would he have needed Stockman at all, besides as a connection for equipment?), and anyway, it's not like Saki could have just gone, "Oh, here, use my body!"

There's one thing that's always puzzled me. What do Utroms eat? I would assume liquids or jelly-like substances, but they have sharp teeth. Like, piranha teeth. I doubt Eastman and Laird were doing any more than make them seem initially menacing, but I like to ponder what sorts of animals Utroms naturally eat, if one were to assume as I do that they're actually carnivores.

Vincent
07-24-2012, 02:14 PM
In regards to the Shredder getting the exo-suit from the sea, bear in mind that he stole the exo-suit he uses - the only one he has, at that point. Also remember that the purpose of fishing it out was to let Baxter Stockman use it for the Foot mechs and stuff. It's safe to say that Ch'rell isn't very technologically capable (otherwise, why would he have needed Stockman at all, besides as a connection for equipment?), and anyway, it's not like Saki could have just gone, "Oh, here, use my body!"
I suppose that's kind of plausible. I still don't think the Shredder was ever as interesting outside of Season 1, and I think it's part of what ultimately killed the show. It failed to move on where it should have, and instead overcompensated by basically trying to become other shows (magic dragon avatar show, happy future show, and The Real Adventures of Jonny Quest AKA Tron). There was plenty of material to make a solid second season without having to involve the Shredder, and as the show continued, there were plenty of things going on, and any time Ch'Rell turned up, it just felt like "Really? This guy again? ...Why?". Like they were afraid of what the TMNT would be without the Shredder, even though they had so many other things going on, with Stockman, Karai, Hun, Bishop, the Rat King, et.c., and if they needed an evil utrom with a familiar identity, they could have just called it Krang (if Peter Laird hadn't been too stubborn to realize that just because an idea began in the Fred Wolf series, doesn't mean it can't be played straight in a new incarnation) and not tried to connect it to the Shredder (and if they had to tie it in with the Foot, they could have just had Karai build the Technodrome to power a portal to wherever this version of Krang would emerge from). I know it's over and all that, but it just frustrates me a bit to know that the things that ultimately ended up weakening an otherwise great show could have been easily prevented by taking the risk of not bringing the same villain back for season 2. And 3. And 5. And 7. At some point, a show has to realize that you can't have the same big bad over and over again and just keep changing his backstory. You have to move on to the next thing. Batman the Animated Series did keep bringing the Joker back, but he was never the big bad of a season (they didn't have those on that show), he only showed up every once in a while to shake things up, and that's really the only way to have a villain keep coming back season after season without getting stale. If a villain is the focus of a whole season, culminating in his defeat at the end, he has most likely been used up, and it's usually time to go to the next big thing. In my opinion, that's what this show should have done, and it would have been stronger for it.

There's one thing that's always puzzled me. What do Utroms eat? I would assume liquids or jelly-like substances, but they have sharp teeth. Like, piranha teeth. I doubt Eastman and Laird were doing any more than make them seem initially menacing, but I like to ponder what sorts of animals Utroms naturally eat, if one were to assume as I do that they're actually carnivores.
Maybe they don't eat. They may have evolved in such a way that that's not how they sustain themselves. After all, where would their stomachs be? The teeth might just be for self defense, since they don't have much in the way of limbs.

CyberCubed
07-24-2012, 04:11 PM
I don't get your complaints at all. The cartoons have to keep Shredder around as long as possible because otherwise kids lose interest. They were never going to kill off Shredder early like the comics.

All the changes 4kids made were for the benefit of the cartoon so it wouldn't be a copy of the comics besides not being allowed to do the violence. The Season 5 mystic powers made total sense and I didn't have a problem with them turning into dragons either. Demon Shredder also was written well into the backstory and all the loose ends were filled.

While the last two seasons aren't essential, they still have enough good episodes in them to outweigh the bad.

Vincent
07-24-2012, 05:37 PM
I don't get your complaints at all. The cartoons have to keep Shredder around as long as possible because otherwise kids lose interest. They were never going to kill off Shredder early like the comics.
I can't say much else than that I disagree. I think that's underestimating kids. There's nothing about the Shredder that makes him more capable of keeping kids' interest than any of the other major villains of the show, including a couple of the new ones. Bishop had great "big bad" potential, for example. And they could have gone some really interesting places with Hun and Karai with Shredder out of the picture (as evidenced in part by season 4, which I thought was a strong season specifically because Ch'rell wasn't hogging the limelight).

All the changes 4kids made were for the benefit of the cartoon so it wouldn't be a copy of the comics besides not being allowed to do the violence. The Season 5 mystic powers made total sense and I didn't have a problem with them turning into dragons either. Demon Shredder also was written well into the backstory and all the loose ends were filled.
Again, I can't say much else than that I disagree. All the mystic stuff got in the way, and detracted from the whole ninja thing that's at the core of TMNT. Once you shift the focus from ninja stuff to anime magic, it becomes something that's just trying to be something else. I'm not saying there should never be magic in TMNT - there have been some great magic-based TMNT stories over the years - but once you start adding superpowers to the turtles themselves or sending them to a future where they can walk around in the daylight for a full season, the core is gone, and it loses itself. The TMNT already have a superpower - being anthropomorphic. They don't need more than that. It's like giving Batman the ability to turn into a swarm of bats. That's just forgetting what Batman is. He's not Dracula. He's a dude in a mask. And the TMNT are mutant turtles who fight with ancient weapons in the shadows. They can be subjected to magic, but they shouldn't be able to do their own tricks, because that's too big a gimmick, and at that point you might as well create a whole new show with new characters, because it's not TMNT anymore.

While the last two seasons aren't essential, they still have enough good episodes in them to outweigh the bad.
They have enough decent episodes to be watchable, but you could take the turtles out of those seasons and replace them with one human character, and it would only be improved by it, because it would remove the element that doesn't have anything to do with what's going on. They're just "generic future show" and "generic cyber show" with the turtles only in there to serve as a reminder of what's been lost. Back to the Sewer was an improvement over Fast Forward, but they both reeked of executive meddling. "Can we make the stories simpler and less dramatic? And it needs more slapstick and stupidity gags, so make the orange one dumber, like he's immune to character development. Great. Oh, wait, hang on, we've got these two failed show pitches from last week that we think could be merge into the show. Don't worry, I think it'll be completely seamless. Yeah, one's in the future with some kid and his robot thing, so let's put the turtles there and give them glowing weapons for some reason, and just say the kid is related to someone they know or whatever, you'll figure it out. And then for next season we've got this Tron ripoff we wanna do something with, so come up with some excuse for that and draw that out for the full season. And bring back the cheese grater guy, I'm sure nobody's tired of that guy yet. Put big orange bits on him and call him Cyber Cheese Grater Guy, so the kids'll buy a new doll, it'll be great! Oh yeah, and try to have less of the rat, the rat doll's not selling well. Also, we're expecting some new viewers to jump on. Can you make the lady look more like she does in the new movie?"
I just personally liked the show better when it was all about the story. When the story started being shaped around central gimmicks, the show just felt cynical and like it was trying to imitate other shows in order to ride their popularity, which must not have worked, since the show was cancelled after three attempts to be something else followed by no attempt to return to the core.
You're entitled to your opinion, of course, but I can't say I feel the same way. My feeling is that it jumped the shark in season 5 and then just went looking for more sharks to jump. That's not to say that there weren't good episodes or good moments after that, but the show as a whole was a mess in seasons 5-7, simply because it kept trying different ways to be like other shows when it should have been focused on progressing the story naturally within the established framework. I wouldn't have minded Fast Forward much if it had been a three episode arc. I wouldn't have minded Ninja Tribunal if it had been a three episode arc ending with the magic backfiring and the turtles swearing never to meddle with it again. I wouldn't have minded Cyber Splinter if it had taken one episode to get him out. That doesn't mean I'm against season arcs, but it's one thing to have a season arc and another thing entirely to spend three seasons trying desperately not to make a show that's about mutants fighting in the shadows with ancient weaponry.

Candy Kappa
07-24-2012, 06:18 PM
Shredder rising after he was decapitated and set his head back on his shoulders should be an easy indicator he wasn't human, or that the next time they, it wasn't a clone.

Galactus
07-24-2012, 06:45 PM
According to what sources? And where was the foreshadowing? And why were the Shredder clones never mentioned again after the Ch'rell reveal? And why would Ch'rell want to study a broken exo suit when he already has one that works?

This sounds to me a lot like George Lucas saying the Star Wars prequels were written decades before production just to make it sound like he had a plan all along.

Saki clearly had a connection to the Utroms, it's established as early as Darkness on the Edge of Town through to The Shredder Strikes. The fact that he handled the sword of Tengu without a glove and he had bandages covering his torso everytime we saw him were pretty decent clues.

The Shredder Elite is a puzzler but it's just one of those continuity gaffes that can be easily be explained. Don just made an assumption and it strikes me that they weren't actualy clones of the Shredder in the comic but Foot guys combines with other creatures via the worms, this could be the same. In the show the could have been attepts to clone the original Shredder or attempts to geneticaly engineer a body for Ch'rell. If you look at Same As It Never Was it looks like Ch'rell has a physical body underneath his exo suit, if not it looks like he has a much bigger mass.

CyberCubed
07-24-2012, 08:57 PM
I can't say much else than that I disagree. I think that's underestimating kids. There's nothing about the Shredder that makes him more capable of keeping kids' interest than any of the other major villains of the show, including a couple of the new ones. Bishop had great "big bad" potential, for example. And they could have gone some really interesting places with Hun and Karai with Shredder out of the picture (as evidenced in part by season 4, which I thought was a strong season specifically because Ch'rell wasn't hogging the limelight).

I don't know about you, but when I was 7 all I wanted to see was Shredder, Krang and some mutants that I had as toys.

I am sure kids who grew up watching the 4kids series only cared about Shredder, Karai, Hun, Baxter and maybe Bishop. There's a reason the cartoons keep Shredder around till the grand finale, and I imagine the Nick show will do the same.


As for the rest of your post, the Turtles were still ninjas and despite doing a few new things its similar to what happens in every TMNT universe. No different then Don being turned into a cyborg, the Turtles mutating to new forms, the Turtles becoming CyberTurtles in Archie, etc.

Genesis
07-24-2012, 10:05 PM
I still don't think the Shredder was ever as interesting outside of Season 1No way. Gotta disagree with you, there. Season 3 made everything and everyone involved that much more badass. Especially in regards to the Shredder. I didn't care for his final exo-suit in "Exodus," but I loved how that season really explained how he was able to get away with all his nefarious shenanigans.

Also, for the love of god, use line breaks, would you please?
Maybe they don't eat. They may have evolved in such a way that that's not how they sustain themselves. After all, where would their stomachs be? The teeth might just be for self defense, since they don't have much in the way of limbs.That's possible, but I'm almost certain that Utroms have been seen drinking some sort of substance from a straw. Anyone wanna help me out, there?

Vincent
07-25-2012, 08:57 AM
Shredder rising after he was decapitated and set his head back on his shoulders should be an easy indicator he wasn't human, or that the next time they, it wasn't a clone.
Not necessarily. He could have been a human, who had made certain preparations to make himself temporarily immortal. But even better for the story would have been if he had just stayed down (although the censors wouldn't have allowed it, because for some reason it's not okay to show the consequences of violence, but the intent of violence is perfectly fine to show).

Saki clearly had a connection to the Utroms, it's established as early as Darkness on the Edge of Town through to The Shredder Strikes. The fact that he handled the sword of Tengu without a glove and he had bandages covering his torso everytime we saw him were pretty decent clues.
Okay, that's fair. I'm willing to accept those as foreshadowing. But I still think it made the character less interesting and subsequently more annoying for every appearance after season 1.

or attempts to geneticaly engineer a body for Ch'rell.
I'm willing to accept this explanation. However, this changes nothing about my opinion that the Shredder got really annoying as he kept coming back over and over again and trying to be taken seriously in spite of having been defeated an increasing number of times.

I don't know about you, but when I was 7 all I wanted to see was Shredder, Krang and some mutants that I had as toys.
The Fred Wolf series was a different kind of show. I didn't really have season arcs, and it wasn't trying to make the Shredder seem like a genuine threat. It wasn't as focused on telling a story, and was more built around getting to the next gag. It was basically structured like an action sitcom, and when the villains are played for laughs, it's fine to keep them around, because you can just keep going "Shucks! Foiled again! I'll get you next time!".

If you're trying to tell a story where the villain is supposed to be genuinely intimidating, there's only so many times you can defeat them before they start looking incompetent, which again, you can afford on a show that purposely plays the joke that the villains are incompetent.


I am sure kids who grew up watching the 4kids series only cared about Shredder, Karai, Hun, Baxter and maybe Bishop. There's a reason the cartoons keep Shredder around till the grand finale, and I imagine the Nick show will do the same.
The big bad of season 2 could easily have been the city at war (which includes Hun and Karai). And if they had to have the Shredder in the grand finale, they could have kept him out of the show and then brought him back in the final season using those worms from the comics or whatever they used to keep Stockman's head alive, or some kind of sorcery. That way he wouldn't have been reduced to a running gag by the time of the finale, and his presence would have been felt much more after having been away for years.

As for the rest of your post, the Turtles were still ninjas and despite doing a few new things its similar to what happens in every TMNT universe. No different then Don being turned into a cyborg, the Turtles mutating to new forms, the Turtles becoming CyberTurtles in Archie, etc.
Yeah, it keeps happening, and it keeps being a bad idea.

No way. Gotta disagree with you, there. Season 3 made everything and everyone involved that much more badass. Especially in regards to the Shredder. I didn't care for his final exo-suit in "Exodus," but I loved how that season really explained how he was able to get away with all his nefarious shenanigans.
I thought season 3 was really good, but I still think it would have felt less stuck without having Ch'rell around. I just find the Shredder less interesting while knowing that he's nothing without that suit.

Which is also why I prefer the original design of the character, since he wasn't wearing a big bulky suit of armor, just a helmet and a few bladed pieces, thus relying more on skill than junk. Of course, in the comic he was more easily defeated, but imagine the design and backstory of the Shredder from the comics, with the personality and power of the Shredder from season 1 of the 4Kids show. That, to me, is the epitome of what the character could be.

I like the idea of the Shredder being just a guy with very little "stuff" to rely on, who has managed to make himself very powerful through sheer ruthlessness. If he's just an evil alien blob inside a powerful high-tech weapon, that's not the Shredder, it's Krang. Or a Dalek. It takes something away from what makes the character work.

The Daleks work because they are unshakeable in their ideology of "everything that is not Dalek must be exterminated", which is a nazi parable, and the fact that they're blobs in tanks plays into the story as well as the metaphor. With that in mind, what is Ch'rell's motivation, exactly, and what part of his plan does controlling the criminal element of NYC fill? And why does he stay in NYC, knowing that that's where there are four turtles who are on to him and keep defeating him?

Also, for the love of god, use line breaks, would you please?
I usually do; sometimes it just slips my mind how long I've written without one. No love of god necessary.

Xav
07-25-2012, 10:09 AM
That's possible, but I'm almost certain that Utroms have been seen drinking some sort of substance from a straw. Anyone wanna help me out, there?Yeah they have, it was from one of the RPG books.

CyberCubed
07-25-2012, 11:34 AM
What can I tell you, Vincent? You seem to think the Turtles should only remain in the shadows and face realistic enemies. From day one that's not what the series is about.

Whenever they go into space they walk freely among aliens, they use giant robots or laser beams or flying cars or whatever. They fight in huge alien tournaments like the Battle Nexus or Triceraton arena.

There is nothing wrong with the Turtles doing new things as long as it isn't a permanant change.

Genesis
07-25-2012, 02:56 PM
Yeah they have, it was from one of the RPG books.I meant in the comics, when they were first introduced. I just don't have that issue.

Which is also why I prefer the original design of the character, since he wasn't wearing a big bulky suit of armor, just a helmet and a few bladed pieces, thus relying more on skill than junk. Of course, in the comic he was more easily defeated, but imagine the design and backstory of the Shredder from the comics, with the personality and power of the Shredder from season 1 of the 4Kids show. That, to me, is the epitome of what the character could be.I can see where you're coming from.

On a side note, I really liked the final battle against Oroku Saki in the first game based on 2k3. I thought it was a really cool idea to have him kick even more ass without his armour, even though the concept is made moot by him being an Utrom. Still, I like the Ch'rell idea. I don't expect it to ever come back, but I for one would appreciate references to it in the future.

No love of god necessary.I hear that.

Vincent
07-25-2012, 04:09 PM
What can I tell you, Vincent? You seem to think the Turtles should only remain in the shadows and face realistic enemies. From day one that's not what the series is about.
I never said that. I do think they should remain in the shadows for the most part, but I never said anything about only facing realistic enemies. However, it helps if the enemies make some internal sense.

If Ch'Rell spent hundreds of years on Earth, trying to get power, shouldn't he be in charge of more than just New York's criminal element? Shouldn't he be emperor of the world after a couple of centuries of being a competent conqueror stuck on Earth?

And why does he cling on to a false identity that his enemies (first the Guardians, then the Turtles) know about, when he could just make himself a new face and start over in secret? This is the old "why doesn't Superman use his super speed more?" problem. If you write a character with a huge advantage, there's a chance he'll just end up seeming lazy and stupid for not utilizing it more effectively.

I never said a thing about thinking that the turtles should only face realistic enemies, but it'd help if the enemies act according to their motivations, and it seems to me that there's a huge disconnect between Chrell's backstory/advantage and the things he does.

Whenever they go into space they walk freely among aliens, they use giant robots or laser beams or flying cars or whatever. They fight in huge alien tournaments like the Battle Nexus or Triceraton arena.
Yes, And then they come back home after a few episodes and get right back into the shadows. I never said I was against the turtles going on adventures. You're building a straw man.

There is nothing wrong with the Turtles doing new things as long as it isn't a permanant change.
Changing the theme song and title of the show to fit the "new things" (see: Fast Forward) is a little too permanent for my taste. As is spending a whole season doing astral dragon projection. As is doing a full season of one core gimmick, then a full season of another core gimmick, then another full season of another core gimmick, with no space inbetween of gimmick-free TMNT.

Turtles in Space was great, but if they had stretched that story out to a full season (and, worse, renamed the show "Turtles in Space") and have them fight different generic space-villain-of-the-week characters, it would have gotten pretty annoying, especially if the following season had been a full 26 episodes of Battle Nexus. These were multi-episode arcs, but one was five episodes and the other was three, and there was plenty of other stuff inbetween, and that's why it worked.

If they had taken the ideas of Ninja Tribunal, Fast Forward and the Cyber arc, boiled them down to their essential elements and shortened them to a few episodes each and stuffed them all into one season, with a few "grounded" episodes inbetween, I wouldn't have had any problem with it.

I've got nothing against the show trying different things, but changing the show's premise for a full season, and then doing it again for the next season and the season after that, was just too much. Part of what was great about seasons 1-4 was that even though they did go on excursions like hanging out at the farm house, going to space, going to the battle nexus, being split up by Drako, et.c., there was always a balance between that and the more grounded stories.

Season 5 was when the show decided it wanted to be more like, I don't know, Naruto or something. Then in season 6 it decided to be The Jetsons. Then in season 7 it looked like it was going to go back to being itself, but instead it sprung the Tron on us for a whole season.

You're free to disagree with me, but my personal feeling is that changing the core of the show for a whole season is like crashing the Enterprise in the Old West for a year. The idea of putting Kirk or Picard in the Old West isn't inherently wrong, but spending a whole season there just seems like a desperate attempt not to make Star Trek. Especially if the title of the show changes to "Old West Trek" and the theme song is replaced with some hokey faux-country music with lyrics desperately trying to convince the viewer that it's an improvement.

TurtleFan2012
07-26-2012, 10:41 AM
And why does he cling on to a false identity that his enemies (first the Guardians, then the Turtles) know about, when he could just make himself a new face and start over in secret? This is the old "why doesn't Superman use his super speed more?" problem. If you write a character with a huge advantage, there's a chance he'll just end up seeming lazy and stupid for not utilizing it more effectively.

My guess is that Ch'rell is so in love with his Shredder persona, he refuse to give it up. Plus, he has a king-size ego. He runs/hides from no one.

Rule #1: Never underestimate the little guy.
Ch'rell is still dangerous without the suit.

Vincent
07-26-2012, 04:10 PM
My guess is that Ch'rell is so in love with his Shredder persona, he refuse to give it up. Plus, he has a king-size ego. He runs/hides from no one.
Pride goeth before the fall. And after a couple of falls, you'd think Ch'rell should be smart enough to come up with a new, less idiotic plan. There's a point at which a "king-size ego" becomes laughable, and that point was reached by the second or third time he said "None of you will leave here alive!" to the same characters in a new location.

Xav
07-26-2012, 06:00 PM
Turtles in Space was great, but if they had stretched that story out to a full season (and, worse, renamed the show "Turtles in Space") and have them fight different generic space-villain-of-the-week characters, it would have gotten pretty annoying, especially if the following season had been a full 26 episodes of Battle Nexus. These were multi-episode arcs, but one was five episodes and the other was three, and there was plenty of other stuff inbetween, and that's why it worked.Battle Nexus was four episodes.

TurtleFan2012
07-26-2012, 06:50 PM
Pride goeth before the fall. And after a couple of falls, you'd think Ch'rell should be smart enough to come up with a new, less idiotic plan. There's a point at which a "king-size ego" becomes laughable, and that point was reached by the second or third time he said "None of you will leave here alive!" to the same characters in a new location.

1.) Even if Ch'rell comes up with a new identity, the turtles will still know it's him. You can change your face and name, but not your personality. In other words, if there is a new badguy who is obsessed with the utroms, the turtles will get suspicious. If he dress his foot ninjas in different clothes and change their name, Splinter will still recognise their fighting style.

2.) I hate to say it, but you do have a point about Shredder wanting to take over one meezly city back in season 1. You would think he would had conquered the earth hundreds of years ago with all the advanced technology, warriors, mystics, and foot ninjas at his disposal. The turtles weren't even born yet when he first arrived on earth.

Also, it is odd he decides after the year 2003 to take over the world. :ohwell:

Vincent
07-27-2012, 05:07 AM
Battle Nexus was four episodes.
Indeed it was. Sorry, I misremembered.

1.) Even if Ch'rell comes up with a new identity, the turtles will still know it's him. You can change your face and name, but not your personality. In other words, if there is a new badguy who is obsessed with the utroms, the turtles will get suspicious. If he dress his foot ninjas in different clothes and change their name, Splinter will still recognise their fighting style.
Sure, if he stays in New York. If he goes to Washington and infiltrates the US government, or goes to China, it'll be a bit harder for the turtles to keep track of him.

2.) I hate to say it, but you do have a point about Shredder wanting to take over one meezly city back in season 1. You would think he would had conquered the earth hundreds of years ago with all the advanced technology, warriors, mystics, and foot ninjas at his disposal. The turtles weren't even born yet when he first arrived on earth.
Exactly my point.

Also, it is odd he decides after the year 2003 to take over the world. :ohwell:
Yes, with the amount of ambition he projects, and with the time and resources at his disposal, you'd think he would have gotten further than being a glorified mob boss by the time his progress was halted by the turtles.

CyberCubed
07-27-2012, 08:44 PM
Ch'rell was fine for what he was. To be honest Ch'rell really was just a more serious take on Krang. They had almost the same origin of being alien brain warlords exiled from their homeworld and tried to conquer Earth.