View Full Version : Five years later, how do we feel about TMNT (2007)?
Cipher
07-30-2012, 08:37 PM
I know it's had threads in the past, but I just watched it the other day and haven't seen much discussion of it lately. It definitely doesn't receive as much attention as the '90s trilogy (maybe that says something).
So, it's been five years since TMNT hit theaters. How's it holding up?
On the whole, I'm actually a lot more entertained by it now than I once was. The quick 'n' dirty:
Pros:
The animation is beautiful. Everything is extremely detailed, and it's aged incredibly well. In fact, I can't really picture it aging badly; everything seems to look as good as it could. I think most people will agree this is the movie's strongest point.
Great design for the Turtles (your mileage may vary).
Good casting and acting all around (Karai's Chinese accent not withstanding).
Family-centric arc for the Turtles is well done
The best version of Raph and Leo throwing down in the franchise
Brings Karai and a Shredder-less Foot to the screen, which is ballsier than it should be.
Moments of subtle character humor work well
Feels like a decent issue of Tales
Cons
Dat plot
Dat name-zipping-across-the-screen thing ("It's a comic-book movie. It's what you do." -- Kevin Munroe, commentary track)
Dat is-it-a-sequel? thing
Seriously, the plot; why are there thirteen monsters if we barely see four?
"J.D., our editor, and I are both big fans of wipes." -- Kevin Munroe, commentary track
"When it came back PG, I think we all cheered." -- Kevin Munroe, commentary track
(Not listed because it wasn't the "adult" Turtles movie I wanted, but because the studio deeming a PG movie would be more marketable than PG-13 in the peak of PG-13 comic-book movie hype is indicative of the back-assward decision-making that seemed to be going on behind the scenes.)
For every subtle bit of character humor, there're two juvenile burp jokes.
Human characters use extremely derivative, Pixar-styled designs that both date the movie and look out of place against each other and the realistic backdrops.
Feels like a decent issue of Tales
Is absolutely not the movie we should've gotten in 2007
That's pretty much it. It's objectively the second best (you could probably make an argument for best) Turtles movie, but that's almost damning with faint praise.
It's enjoyable as a fan, but kind of leaves you scratching your head as to why it was made. And would I ever come back to it if I weren't a fan? It's decent fun, so I don't know; maybe in an if-it-happens-to-be-on-TV sense.
It's alright. I agree that it makes me wonder why it was made, but it was OK nonetheless. I just wish it had more Mikey and Donnie.
Slade
07-30-2012, 08:48 PM
While my favorite is the first movie and unless this new one comes out and changes it, always will be. That being said, I end up watching the 07 movie a ton. My 2 year old (when I get him to actually watch anything Ninja Turtles) always picks it. So, I do like the movie. I haven't watched the commentaries so I can't speak on that, but I do agree with all of your pros and cons. Best part of the movie and I'm sure a good bit do agree, is the Raph and Leo fight. I do have to add to some cons though, and that is the fact that Mike and Don just don't have enough development at all.
Edit: forgot this.
Going along with the is this a sequel thing. Is it? Is it supposed to tale place after 3? Also it almost feels like it could be a 2k3 movie.
CyberCubed
07-30-2012, 09:02 PM
It felt like it could have been a 3 part episode of the 4kids series. The monster plot in the movie fit right in with the typical 4kids mutants and monsters arcs.
I like it still. The animation and the way the Turtles are handled are the strongest aspects, IMO. However, when I look back on it now, I do see it as a bit of a cop-out by the studio, WB. If they really wanted to resurrect TMNT they should have done so in live-action. Instead, they went for the cheaper alternative. It didn’t pan out. Also, I still think the actual story itself is way too juvenile. Almost childish, actually.
Coola Yagami
07-30-2012, 09:38 PM
Same thing I thought back then.... other than the cool designs for Ninja April, Casey and Karai (wardrobe-wise anyway), and the Raph VS Leo fight... the rest of the movie was a big waste of time.
Mr.Turtle
07-30-2012, 09:59 PM
i like the storyline. i don't care wut some ppl think abt it. i just like the plot its fun its cohere its awesome.
It didn't feel like a movie, it felt like a DTV or multi-parter, there was too much plot like you mentioned why go into the story of monsters if they hardly appeared and only took time, any other plot device would've worked better, if it had been a season arc then yeah the 13 monsters thing might've been a good idea but they take a lot of time setting the monsters thing up for it to become something rather irrelevant. The actual plot is just ok, and that's not what the turtles needed, they needed something big to make a big comeback. It felt like "another" adventure for these turtles but we needed something different, most people needed something different.
The movie was CG and had no shredder, it dealt with aztec stone leaders and monsters. It had been over a decade since the last turtles movie, most were turned off including me by it being CG, and while some were happy Shredder wasn't in it, I can understand when he just appeared but this was a reboot we wanted to see a new version it had been a long ass time since he appeared in movies. The CG alone turned off most adults being nostalgic about it and dismissing it as a kids movie which to their defense it was.
Other than that I loved the movie, even with the lackluster plot it was still a fun adventure for them even if it didn't live up to it being a movie. While the Leo/Raph grudge might be overdone in most turtle media I absolutely loved their take here. The CG is indeed beautiful, a shame we'll never see these characters or CG with the turtles again, I would've loved a sequel, hell if it had made just a bit more money we would've likely gotten a third Imagi TMNT movie by now.
The movie was definitely handled badly and filled with missed opportunities but overall it's a good entry into the turtles franchise and doesn't deserve the recent hate it gets.
Mr.Turtle
07-30-2012, 10:18 PM
i liked the monster plot. i think the reason why shredder's not included is that the story is set at the point where the turtles r retired long after shredder'd been gone.
CyberCubed
07-30-2012, 11:32 PM
Shredder is gone because it was a loose continuation of the past films and cartoons. The movie prequel books Mirage put out also have the Turtles mention they've fought the Triceratons and Utroms.
Mr.Turtle
07-30-2012, 11:57 PM
I like it still. The animation and the way the Turtles are handled are the strongest aspects, IMO. However, when I look back on it now, I do see it as a bit of a cop-out by the studio, WB. If they really wanted to resurrect TMNT they should have done so in live-action. Instead, they went for the cheaper alternative. It didn’t pan out. Also, I still think the actual story itself is way too juvenile. Almost childish, actually.
its actually alot better than lots other animated movies these days... talkin abt cgi moives these days, give me a headache...:tgrumble:
Powder
07-31-2012, 12:20 AM
My feelings have not changed. It's meh. Too much going on at once plotwise. Great animation, poor designs.
Jo Dawn
07-31-2012, 12:27 AM
It's been quite awhile since I've watched it, but (that's never stopped me before!)...
The biggest Pro I have for this movie is the voice-over acting. Anyone who knows me (which seems to be NO ONE in this place anymore) knows that voices in animated movies are really important to me. I thought they were great in this movie.
It was a 'safe' movie. No pushing any boundaries, nothing breathtaking, nothing like that. I like the movie. I could've done without it being so much of a kids movie, what with the influx of great adaptations of former 'kids' franchises (which I think we desperately deserve).
Not enough Don or Mike, but they were good while they were in it. Love the 'Black Betty' song scene with Raph; always will. A teeny bit too much emphasis on the Leo/Raph thing, but that'll never change so it didn't bug me too awful much.
Candy Kappa
07-31-2012, 04:37 AM
My feelings have not changed. It's meh. Too much going on at once plotwise. Great animation, poor designs.
pretty much this.
I would only re-watch it for the animation, some of the jokes are kinda funny though, like Don's tech support.
ToTheNines
07-31-2012, 06:36 AM
This movie is such an oddball in the TMNT multiverse. Other than the main cast and Karai, no one else in the movie is familiar. There are too many TMNT characters with untapped potential (Shredder included), so it bugs me that they were creating (lame) original characters/ideas like Max Winters, Nightwatcher, etc.
Donnie did nothing, Mike wasn't really funny, Leo was a self-contradicting turd, Raph was too hellbent on fighting crime. Casey's "growing up" storyline was mega lame, they totally got him all wrong. Don't even get me started on Splinter.
And the whole "loose sequel" thing just came off as laziness, to me.
Great design for the Turtles (your mileage may vary).
For the most part yes, but their faces looked a little too lizard-like and I HATE how the headbands are rigid and don't hug the shape of their heads.
The CG was great though. Watch this on blu-ray and it's even more evident. The weapons and shells look almost real.
And casting was good.
pannoni1
07-31-2012, 08:26 AM
First of all, in 2007 when I was still in my dark fandom phase and saw some reviews that the new movie "brings nostalgia and a great reintroduction to TMNT", I felt turned off when I saw the CGI since I was used to either live action or 2D animation for the most part. Still, this movie feels like an orphan compared to the rest of the expanded universe, and I just don't see it as canon with anything else, including the '90s films, given the difference in the Turtles/April's character designs as well as having Karai coming out of nowhere without an introduction with the Foot. In fact I could better see NTNM as canon to the first three films than this movie is to them. That said, it is still relevant in that the animation is better than what Nick has provided with its new series, James Arnold Taylor has perhaps the best Leonardo voice, and the other Turtles and Splinter are also very well voiced, though I'll admit Chris Evans and especially Sarah Michelle Gellar as Casey and April aren't the best voices for those characters, sounding too bland at times. Overall, TMNT 2007 can pass as a well-done fan creation, much like the Casey Jones movie that is a good watch if you don't want a long canon to follow. Every fan should have a copy in their collection.
FoxZerro
07-31-2012, 08:30 AM
The story I always tell about TMNT is that I saw it four times on the day it came out. Four times and I loved it every single one of them not once did I walk out saying I had been wrong, it wasn't as good as I thought it was. I legitimately walked into and out of that movie at the same level of excitement each time.
That being said even though I saw the movie that many times there are only a few things that I actually remember about the movie and all of them include Raph. The diner scene with the Jersey Devil, Kevin Smith, and the cover of Black Betty; A beautifully animated scene where Leonardo and Raphael come to blows (seriously having it raining was pure genius); The fact that the "13th Monster" was already shown as captured; and the subtle reveal that this was actually a sequel to the first three movies. That is what I remember, brief moments of the film.
The unfortunate thing is that even though it might not be memorable to me. I have to admit that it was a very good Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movies. It will never replace the first movie as my favorite, but when it comes to a representation of what the Turtles actually experience in the comics the stories of this and TMNT 3 hit the nail squarely on the top of the head.
The TMNT are not heroes, they are just these guys trying to make it in the world who are thrust into insane situations and have the ability to overcome them. This movie demonstrates that perfectly. They aren't actively looking to solve a milleniums old mystery regarding Monsters and Immortals, but when it comes down to it they are willing to lend a hand.
I think what might be the issue the movie really feels more like Max Winter's story and the Turtles just happen to be there. Which is acceptable in an issue of Tales but just doesn't work as the plot of a major motion picture.
Cipher
07-31-2012, 08:47 AM
This movie is such an oddball in the TMNT multiverse. Other than the main cast and Karai, no one else in the movie is familiar. There are too many TMNT characters with untapped potential (Shredder included), so it bugs me that they were creating (lame) original characters/ideas like Max Winters, Nightwatcher, etc.See, I actually don't mind Nightwatcher as an addition to the Turtles mythos. I just wish the movie were more clear about the fact that Raphael is going way outside family protocol by doing what he does. (Again, listening to Munroes' commentary, it seems this was the intent.)
Most of the conversations in the movie give the impression that these Turtles were always patrolling the streets, fighting crime, then suddenly stopped, and are for some reason angry at Raphael for doing the same thing solo and in a costume.
CyberCubed
07-31-2012, 09:23 AM
I do wonder why they came up with Max Winters and the Stone generals when instead they could have done a movie about Baxter, Leatherhead or Rat King...or all 3 together.
Karai and the Foot being the only familiar villains was indeed odd. Funny thing is Peter Laird put Volume 4 on hiatus to work with Kevin Munroe on the script for this movie.
DarkLightDragon
07-31-2012, 09:48 AM
I still enjoy the film, it's a guilty pleasure for me, but I do see some of the criticisms as some here have already pointed out.
-The plot was definitly all over the place.
-Winters and the 4 Generals were kinda weak as villains and characters. My biggest beef was how the film supposedly builds up to Winters being the big bad guy and him still wanting to rule the world by re-gathering the monsters when it was obvious from the start of the film he was trying to atone his mistake.
-Mikey and Don definetly got the short end of the stick in terms of screentime and relevance in favor of the Leo vs Raph dynamic the film was going with.
-Leo was a bit self-contradictory during his time in South America. It's said he was sent there to do training so he'd be a better leader for his brothers and how he can't can't go back a failure. But as soon as he says this, he then brings up how the villagers need him more than his brothers do. Well, that just beats the whole point of you being here to begin with, isn't it?
Anything else was good. The animation, dialouge and fight scenes were above average. I still think it holds up fairly well after 5 years.
TheBlueTurtle1
07-31-2012, 10:43 AM
I just cant make my mind up about this movie. Mind you when you compare it to TMNT 3......
TMNT_Guy
07-31-2012, 04:52 PM
It would have made a better Direct-to-DVD movie then a theatrica one, but at the same time if it wasn't for the movie I wouldn't be a Turtles fan.
A friend of mine mentioned one day in High School about how a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movie was coming out next week and we both decided to go see it. The only memory I had of the Turtles besides the toys was the scene from the second intro of the original series where the group shove a Pizza into the screen and it turns into the logo. Because of my limited knowledge of the series, I did some brief research via the old Mirage TMNT website. I mean, the movie itself would explain everything for new viewers, right? Mostly I just read the character bios, but the site also had the first issue online. I thought it was fantastic and couldn't wait for the movie.
The day finally came, the movie started and...I was instantly confused. Unstoppable generals? Portal to anonther universe? Thirteen monsters? Even those who could be considered human TMNT encyclopedias were more then likely confused. This scene shouldn't have been included at the begining of the movie, it should have been saved until April tells the Turtles about the generals. That way their at least could have been some mystery as to what was going on. That scene, even in repeat viewings, just comes out of no where and take me right out of the movie. The concept itself is interesting, but the movie hardly even talks about the monsters. Heck, I don't even think the monsters were given names in the movie. I know Bigfoot and the Jersey Devil's names...because I read about it online. Wasn't there even a recent thread asking what the monsters names were? Even if you wanted to look up their names you'd be in a pickle, because some of the monsters names were never officialy revealed.
The movie wasn't good, but it wasn't bad, either. Without a doubt it's the second best TMNT film yet and it did interest me enough to get the first season of the original series on DVD, solidifying my intetrest in the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles forever.
Jephael
07-31-2012, 05:24 PM
I almost got rid of my DVD copy, but then I decided to give the movie another watch. It's nowhere near as epic as the original live action flick, but it still has its charm.
Logan
07-31-2012, 05:28 PM
I find it largely unremarkable. I remember when I first saw the teaser trailer and I got so pumped. I was thinking, "They could really do something with the Turtles in this style", and then it fell short.
I also didn't like that the movie didn't really have any strong ties to any of the other incarnations. Munroe's idea allegedly was to have it be sort of a sequel to whatever franchise you followed, but then I also read it was supposed to follow the previous three movies. You get the little nod with the Shredder helmet, canister, and time scepter, and that's it. It didn't allow me to connect with the characters, if that makes any sense.
Lastly, and I know I'm going to catch hell for this, but I wanted the Shredder back. If you're going to make a movie with the Foot as a major part of the story, the Shredder is almost a requirement. It's like having a Star Wars movie without lightsabers.
TMNT_Guy
07-31-2012, 05:33 PM
It's like having a Star Wars movie without lightsabers.
More like a Star Wars film without Darth Vader, because we all know how great those movies were.
ToTheNines
07-31-2012, 05:37 PM
More like a Star Wars film without Darth Vader, because we all know how great those movies were.
He was in all 6.
TMNT_Guy
07-31-2012, 05:40 PM
Anakin Skywalker dosen't count.
oldmanwinters
07-31-2012, 07:00 PM
I liked it then; I like it now.
I wish we'd gotten a sequel, but not that 100% Mikey sequel teased in the preview poster.
Spitfire
07-31-2012, 07:04 PM
Honestly I don't think the film is bad, it has a few pretty well done scenes, but it's boring. Everytime I watch it I lose steam around the middle somewhere and I feel like falling asleep. It's not paced very well either. It feels a lot longer then it is, which is pretty funny considering it's barely feature length.
Donatello19
07-31-2012, 07:19 PM
it wasn't a BAD Movie, but it think the story was generic and boring, and it focused WAY too much on Raph and Leo. Donatello And Michelangelo felt like they were only there to make cameos, which is sad.
TurtleTitan97
07-31-2012, 07:22 PM
It's still okay in my book. I liked it back when it came out, but now I don't care for it as much as before.
CyberCubed
07-31-2012, 09:46 PM
I think had the 4th movie come out at the start of the 4kids era, like around 2004 or so, and we got two sequels around 2006 and 2009...this whole new movie trilogy would have fared better.
milesflex
07-31-2012, 10:41 PM
You can see props from the live action movies as Splinter puts Winter's helmet on his trophy wall. That was the only reference to them that I saw. Watched it 2 weeks ago. Animation still beautiful on Blu Ray, Raph and Leo fight great, sewer lair was sweet like 2k3. I loved Splinter watching soap operas and IT Don. Definitely needed more Mike and IT tech support Don. Monsters and Foot Clan and stone generals are a let down. I still enjoy it and will actively show it to my future children and nieces/nephews.
hitmonkey
08-01-2012, 01:10 AM
I'm so torn on it. I love the animation and art direction, and the voice cast is superb. My main gripe is the stone monster storyline. It's not that it doesn't work as a Turtles story, because it definitely does. I just feel like it could have been told in a 22-minute episode of 2K3. It just didn't seem film-worthy. On top of that, regardless of their choice to loosely tie it to the original films, it felt different enough that it would have been nice to see some classic Turtles villains interpreted in that style.
Donnie
08-01-2012, 01:36 AM
it wasn't a BAD Movie, but it think the story was generic and boring, and it focused WAY too much on Raph and Leo. Donatello And Michelangelo felt like they were only there to make cameos, which is sad.
This was always my main gripe with the 2007 film. I thought Donatello was portrayed well in the scenes he was actually in. Mikey, not so much.
My second biggest gripe would be the boring villains. Stone warriors and weird monsters? Really? When you have the plethora of Mirage, 2k3, and even OT villains to choose from?
The best part of the movie was when Leonardo and Raphael came to blows, and another positive aspect of the film I enjoyed was it's relatively darker story-line...Leo leaving his brothers, them going their own ways keeping busy, dissension at home.
Genesis
08-01-2012, 04:41 AM
I thought Donatello was portrayed well in the scenes he was actually in.All two of 'em, you mean?
Mike at least got a fun skateboard scene. Donatello gets to deal with tech support and hand a stone weapon to April.
ZariusTwo
08-01-2012, 05:46 AM
TMNT 2007 isnt a bad film, in fact it's downright enjoyable, but it made the mistake of following the blueprint of Superman Returns and tried to be as uninviting as possible to a casual viewer, and for these sort of franchises, that's crucial. It didnt work for SR, it didnt work for this, and it's why you rarely see movies of their type in theatres now.
Leo656
08-01-2012, 08:31 AM
I kinda agree/disagree with the Superman Returns thing, if only for the fact that movie made assloads more money (both in theaters and on DVD/BluRay) than people think/remember, so obviously it WAS successful on some level. I do agree it's not very "casual-friendly", as in it's not a movie that works well in the random "Hey, you wanna hang out and watch _______?" sort of way, and it might not convert any non-fans. To that end I'd agree it's similar with TMNT, also in the "It's a sequel to another film sort of, not really but if you want it to be" thing they both have.
Visuals for TMNT were mostly awesome, though I wasn't thrilled with the stylized humans. Agree with those who feel the story felt more like an issue of Tales or something made for TV/DVD. I liked what was there, but I think it says something that I've seen this one the least, even though I liked it more than 2 or 3. It's not bad, just would have been better if they'd used characters and plots people were familiar with rather than what they cameup with.
What many people dislike about it is what I find one of its biggest strengths: It's not very firmly connected to any TMNT universe, but if you use a little imagination it could sort of fit in anywhere as a sequel. I thought it felt more like an offshoot of 2K3 than anything else, and since that show was still on at the time that was probably no accident, even though there are visual cues that tie it to the earlier films. I think it's more fun to say it fits in where you want it to.
They definitely dropped the ball when it came to making it a kids' movie. I went opening night and if memory serves, most of the theater was teenagers and people in their early 20s.
Donnie
08-01-2012, 12:21 PM
All two of 'em, you mean?
Mike at least got a fun skateboard scene. Donatello gets to deal with tech support and hand a stone weapon to April.
Well I particularly enjoyed Don's interaction with Raph in the beginning of the film: "well look who woke up!"
With Leo gone, Donatello was pretty much the default second-in-command, as evidenced by Leo telling April that Donnie probably had things under control. So seeing Don question Raph's contributions to the current family predicament was cool.
This movie is amazing muted. So damn good. Like, it is good, but really good. So good... I just can't say good. It is damn good. So good. But damn. It is good. It is good muted, because I don't have to listen to all that **** about abotu about about the iron soldier dudes that have crumbles on their shoulders. It is.... odd this feeling. I was thiat. but mp/ I. oh god. Ho shu7sh no shcvu alright. THis movie is good muted ok? Jzytu bruze in me.
Itz igodd
Darth Knuckles
08-13-2012, 09:49 AM
I actually like this movie quite a bit. I'm a little surprised of how people seem to have turned on it over the years. I thought on this forum, because I trolled it back when it came out, that people were happy with the movie but now it seems most don't like it as much anymore. For me as a kid, my favorite movie was Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret of the Ooze because I was originally brought in by the 1987 cartoon and I feel that that movie is most like the cartoon. As I grew up, I definitely think the original movie is the superior movie on every level.
But I think TMNT is the second best movie of the four. And I may admit, I'm biased and my main turtle is Raph and he gets the most screen time in this movie. That may be part of the reason but I liked the story enough. I agree with a lot of you that I would have liked to have seen all thirteen monsters on screen though. I just really enjoyed the Raph scenes and I felt that that is what Raph would do if Leo left. I liked Raph's talk with Casey on the roof towards the beginning. I felt the brothers and family feel to the movie was dead on. I enjoyed the teases of the past movies at the end of the movie too. One of my favorite parts was the discussion that Raph shares with Splinter as he realizes why Splinter chose Leo over him to be their leader. He actually understands for the first time why he isn't quite ready to be leader himself. And the response that Splinter gives him is very emotional to me too. My favorite part was, of course, the Raph vs. Leo fight! I thought that was great and it was wonderful to see it happen in a movie. I thought it was an overall nice blend of the comic book, cartoon, and movie universes. :tcool:
TurtleMaster4
08-13-2012, 11:26 AM
It wasn't perfect, but i still loved the movie!
Cryomancer
08-13-2012, 11:30 AM
Just watched it again about a week ago, on bluray this time. I think I like the movie a little bit more everytime I watch it. It has it's flaws for sure, but I think it's very well made and has some very good ideas in it.
LeoNerdo
08-13-2012, 12:27 PM
I need to watch this one again. I watched it in theaters and again when it was first released on dvd, but I've had the blu-ray for a while now and just haven't popped it in. Based on my previous experience though I feel mostly the same. The first time I saw it I was disappointed because I wanted to like it so much more than I did. It's certainly not necessary viewing imo, but if you're in the mood for another TMNT story on a rainy day it's a pretty fun little story.
Newton Gimmick
08-13-2012, 07:33 PM
I kinda agree/disagree with the Superman Returns thing, if only for the fact that movie made assloads more money (both in theaters and on DVD/BluRay) than people think/remember, so obviously it WAS successful on some level. I do agree it's not very "casual-friendly", as in it's not a movie that works well in the random "Hey, you wanna hang out and watch _______?" sort of way, and it might not convert any non-fans. To that end I'd agree it's similar with TMNT, also in the "It's a sequel to another film sort of, not really but if you want it to be" thing they both have.
Visuals for TMNT were mostly awesome, though I wasn't thrilled with the stylized humans. Agree with those who feel the story felt more like an issue of Tales or something made for TV/DVD. I liked what was there, but I think it says something that I've seen this one the least, even though I liked it more than 2 or 3. It's not bad, just would have been better if they'd used characters and plots people were familiar with rather than what they cameup with.
What many people dislike about it is what I find one of its biggest strengths: It's not very firmly connected to any TMNT universe, but if you use a little imagination it could sort of fit in anywhere as a sequel. I thought it felt more like an offshoot of 2K3 than anything else, and since that show was still on at the time that was probably no accident, even though there are visual cues that tie it to the earlier films. I think it's more fun to say it fits in where you want it to.
They definitely dropped the ball when it came to making it a kids' movie. I went opening night and if memory serves, most of the theater was teenagers and people in their early 20s.
You pretty much hit it all there.
The only other thing I would say is that it was a CGI movie entirely and although some CGI movies make big bank, the truth is those tend to be "family" flicks like the stuff Pixar does. This wasn't that, even if they were trying to get that same audience. I know a lot of people who skipped it because it was a "cartoon movie" and there's a pretty big segment of folks who don't go see that stuff.
Getting the kids is one thing, but you have to get the teens and adults. TMNT didn't do that well enough.
I recall seeing it in the theater and although there were quite a few kids, it was a good mix. Crowd seemed to enjoy it too, but it just didn't have enough push in the media and the villain(s) weren't interesting enough to make people want to really get invested in the film. Great movie about the TURTLES themselves, but not much else.
Disjointed and weaker than some films in a lot of ways but stronger in others. But definitely fun. Still probably the second best Turtles flick IMO.
Ecto Jedi
08-13-2012, 10:35 PM
I wish we'd gotten a sequel, but not that 100% Mikey sequel teased in the preview poster.
The what now?
cartoonistaaron
08-13-2012, 10:37 PM
I felt like this movie was more wasted opportunity than anything else. You have the huge TMNT universe - your pick of anything, from Triceratons to Utroms to Krang to Bebop, Rocksteady, Leatherhead, etc - and you go with some new, hackneyed, cliched characters and story?
It confused the hell out of me, because your perfect TMNT movie is already in the Mirage comics. Just use the TCRI / Fugitoid / Triceratons story. Pad it as you need to, throw in the Raph vs Leo fight scene, and there you go. Or, do an alien invasion thing, with Krang and the Stone Warriors as the evil group, who are trying to open up a portal to Dimension X. All kinds of weird monsters could make it thru that portal, if they're hung up on the "monsters" thing.
When a strong creative vision is involved, the Turtles always seem to fall victim to someone else's ideas, and never (except for parts of the 2k3 series) do the original creators' ideas make it thru unscathed. But I guess that's true with all comic-to-film adaptions.
oldmanwinters
08-13-2012, 10:38 PM
The what now?
Steve Murphy posted about it on his now-defunct blog. Fortunately for us, tOkKa preserved it in some form:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/terrible2z/2753533100/
Ecto Jedi
08-13-2012, 10:40 PM
Huh. Cool.
Walkabout
08-14-2012, 04:56 AM
As others have said it is surely the second best TMNT film (with the original live action movie being #1)...its just dissapointing that they used the monsters/stone generals instead of...well pretty much any pre existing TMNT nemesis.
Powder
08-15-2012, 01:38 AM
Second best? Pfffffft. Nope. That's like, your opinion, man.
Walkabout
08-15-2012, 03:10 AM
It is that :oops:
CrazySquirrel
08-16-2012, 04:39 AM
I love it and think its highly underrated. I agree that the worst part of it is also the best part. The fact that its an all new story with new villians etc. The only thing i hate is Caseys design. His character is ok but he looks horrible way too skinny and should have longer hair.
shezcrafti
08-21-2012, 08:12 PM
I love it, but I'm not in love with it. :tlol:
TMNT's parts are better than its whole, if that makes sense. The plot was a mess, but I can appreciate that it was ambitious. They were at least trying; they just overreached.
I'm a Raph fan and Leo is my second favorite, so there was plenty in TMNT for me to enjoy. (I've said it many times before, I could watch an entire movie of just Raphael.) But it does suck about Mike & Donnie; those fans definitely got shafted.
I really didn't care for Splinter in this version. I liked Casey and his interactions with Raph, but April was pretty blah. Even SMJ couldn't save her for me, and I'm a huge fan of hers.
The first Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles film will always be my favorite, but I don't think I could ever put TMNT above SOTO, even if it's "technically" a better film. Sometimes nostalgia and pop culture status trumps everything else.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-21-2012, 08:20 PM
I agree with you, I too could watch an entire movie of just Raphael.
Drose18
08-21-2012, 09:38 PM
Today my little brother came up to me when I was watching secret of the ooze and said hey i didnt know you had the 2007 movie.
Yeah well I have it.
Lets watch it its better than this old turtle crap.
(I just stare at him for two minutes than finally say)
what the hell is wrong with you?!?!?!?!? These "old" turtles are awesome. (I pick up the first movie dvd and tmnt.)
Which do you like better?
(He points to TMNT (2007))
Watch through these two movies one more time dickshit.
I tell him to go away.
Drose18
08-21-2012, 09:41 PM
Steve Murphy posted about it on his now-defunct blog. Fortunately for us, tOkKa preserved it in some form:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/terrible2z/2753533100/
I would love that.
Toby Barrett
08-21-2012, 09:41 PM
Wow, you sure showed him.
Andrew NDB
08-21-2012, 09:44 PM
As others have said it is surely the second best TMNT film
I agree... but you realize that's not saying much at all?
Andrew NDB
08-21-2012, 09:46 PM
Steve Murphy posted about it on his now-defunct blog. Fortunately for us, tOkKa preserved it in some form:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/terrible2z/2753533100/
I would love that.
Oh, thank Christ we didn't get that. Good lord. If I recall what I read, it was just to be some kind of madcap "gotta re-mutate the guys!" thing starring Dude Mikey™/AKA "The one Turtle they can't actually show using his weapons on-camera." And look at Shredder there... he looks like Judge Doom from Roger Rabbit.
No ****in' thanks.
Leo656
08-21-2012, 11:37 PM
Kinda agree, probably sounded better on paper than it would have been in execution. A terrific concept for an issue or three of a comic or a cartoon storyline, but the way it would have been done as a movie would have been pretty weak, I feel.
As far as TMNT I agree if you're a big fan of Leo and/or Raph, a lot of the rest is forgiveable.
CyberCubed
08-26-2012, 01:15 AM
If it was made into a 4 part episode of the 4kids series, it would have been fine.
MoreCowbell5263
08-26-2012, 11:50 AM
It's a decent movie and probably better than 2 and 3. But obviously, as a Don and Mike fan, I get tired of seeing Leo and Raph argue, and I hate how Raph has had a big role in all of the movies. Heck, the beginning of TMNT starts off like it's gonna be a Leo-centric movie for a change, which I would've been all for. It quickly became all about Raph. Raph got the most focus in the first movie, Don in the second, Mike in the third, then they went back to Raph for TMNT, as if having Raph and Leo argue is basically like them having equal time to shine.
I feel Nightwatcher is very corny, but given the fact that they're forbidden from fighting crime while Leo's away, I forgive it. I feel like they could've explained a bit more in detail why Leo doesn't like the idea of Nightwatcher, because a lot of people see the movie and see Leo as a hypocrite, since he protected the people in Latin America.
Don and Mike pushed into the background. Sucks. At least in the first movie, they got to make a lot of jokes and lighten the mood. Don, although very well portrayed and voice-acted, rarely ever says anything, and never does anything really cool in the movie. Mike was a little too kid-friendly, but eh, TMNT does seem to aim more for the kids, so I forgive that.
Winters and Stone Generals and monsters...yeah, I would've just had a Karai and Foot-centered plot-line. With like Karai just vowing vengeance for them killing Shredder.
If anyone's jokes were pandering to little kids more than Mike, it was Casey. Did not like Casey Jones in this movie. His jokes were annoying.
Humans looked too Pixar-esque.
Despite all of this though, I felt the Turtles were very aesthetically pleasing. The fight scenes were great (too much focus on Raph) but whatever. I just wish they extended the end fight scene more. In the background you see Don facing the biggest of the Stone Generals, yet they focus on Raph fighting the main one. I wanna see how Don beats the big guy, dammit! We saw Raph fight thugs and Leo, give the other Turtles time to shine.
The story's blah, but the family dynamic is nice. The emotional scenes are emotional. This was probably the version of Leo I liked the most. And I've never been a huge Leo fan. It's a good portrayal of Raph, but I wanted to see more Don and Mike. The voice-acting was perfect. PERFECT! Admittedly, a more serious Casey Jones voiced by Chris Evans would be better, but whatever. All in all, if they had made a sequel to TMNT in CGI, I wouldn't have minded. I don't feel live-action is necessary for a Turtles movie, and despite my problems with TMNT, it's not irredeemable. Make Leo the focus, since he IS the leader of the team, give Mike and Don a pivotal role in it, and yes, show Raph being a badass at times to appease the Raph-fans, but dammit, don't screw the Mike and Don fans over just because Raph is Wolverine in turtle-form and popular.
sgtfbomb
08-26-2012, 12:08 PM
I watched it again last night. It had been roughly five years since I watched it. It's decent, but...
1) The story sucks. 13 monsters? It's not about believability or realism. It just sounds stupid.
2)The teenie-bopper soundtrack sucks. I hated every song in this movie, except for Ram Jam's Black Betty. I almost preferred the MC Hammer songs over this stuff.
3)The dialogue was fairly unimaginative. "It's the ghost of the jungle." So generic! At the very least, couldn't they have gone with a Spanish translation to that. That would have to sound cooler than that. And then there's the "familiar faces from the past" line at the end. Facepalm!
4a) The movie plays like a video walkthrough for a video game. Almost all of the dialogue/one liners sound exactly like they would if you were controlling the character on an XBox game. That whole battle outside Winter's tower looks exactly like a video game..
4b) Even the animation looks like video game FMV scenes. Even at the time of its release, the animation in this film seemed out of date. Often, it just looked too clean. This is probably the smallest complaint I have about the film. It's actually more of an observation.
The movie has heart, I'll give it that. But nowhere near the heart of the the first film. Overall, I feel like the movie was a decent, yet superficial cash in (for lack of a better description) of the TMNT franchise. It felt more like a tease than anything, on par with those Marvel/DC animated DTV films.
plasticturtle
08-26-2012, 01:07 PM
I think it still holds up fairly well. I'll never hold it in the same regard I do the first movie however. But let's be fair. The first movie has a level of nostalgia and happy memories surrounding it for me that TMNT could never hope to match. Even if it was the better film ( though I don't think it is ) I'd still enjoy the first more due to the memories attached.
Walkabout
08-27-2012, 04:42 AM
I agree... but you realize that's not saying much at all?
I do, I do.
Leo656
08-28-2012, 05:12 AM
I think I've failed to mention it before, but I didn't like the human characters's CGI either. I dug the TMNT themselves (aside from the freakishly-thick calves), but April and Casey were barely recognizable.
chrisdude
08-30-2012, 07:20 AM
I still appreciate it.
It was the most anticipated movie of my life (possibly rivaled by Superman Returns). I was hoping that when the brought the turtles back, it would be with CGI, and not costumes. I wanted the turtles to be able to move like ninjas, and run on rooftops.
I sent ninjaturtles.com a long-winded email about it. They sent me a message back, saying that they had nothing to do with movies.
But it ended up happening. The premise was... I won't say it was weirder than what I've seen in the comics, but the scale was just so big...
I liked the animation and the design of the turtles. Which is cool, because I didn't care the for the look of the 4Kids show. And I was very impressed by the choreography - although it rarely got the attention it deserved. I hate that most of the fight scenes were zoomed out, overhead views of two or three fights at a time.
I thought they made Michelangelo a little... dumb? Irritating (to his brothers)?
I was just happy to have my turtles back, but in retrospect, I guess I understand why it didn't get a sequel.
tmntpower1988
08-31-2012, 09:31 PM
I watched this movie earlier, thought it was ok. Not the worst movie but not the best either, liked it better than Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3 anyway.
prophecy718
09-01-2012, 11:03 AM
to be honest, when i first saw the movie it was better than i expected. I honestly had low expectations for the movie.
I'll give it another watch sometime in the near future
Pros:
-voice acting
-some of the animation
Cons:
-character design (esp. humans, and the turtles were a little too froggy)
-convoluted childish plot with too many characters
-focus on characters that are not turtles/april/casey/splinter
They could have made this whole movie about the family losing Raph to the Nightwatcher and it would have been a hundred times better.
Filespit
09-04-2012, 02:46 PM
I think TMNT is a totally okay movie. It's no masterpiece, nor is it a disaster. What it lacks is a real villain and a more interesting plot. The whole legend-thing is kind of lame and the monsters/generals doesn't really fit into the TMNT universe if you ask me. Would've been better with Shredder or another classic villain. I don't think too much about that though, as the good parts even it out. First of all, I love the music, the movie has a great score that I could easily see be used in a future TMNT movie. Second, I think the animations are great except for the humans, which I think look just stupid. Third, I really like how the turtles are portrayed and how they've gone their own ways. I like the idea of Don being an IT-specialist, Mike working as a birthday clown, and Raph fighting crimes on his own. Fourth, the Leo vs Raph scene is the best in the movie. I love how they confront each other while they still care for each other. The movie has strong parts but also some low points that I think evens it out in the end. My rating is 3/5.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-04-2012, 06:31 PM
Bad with a silly plot, when it was a chance to introduce some other characters (Krang, Baxter Stockman, Triceratons or whatever)
Bad with a silly plot, when it was a chance to introduce some other characters (Krang, Baxter Stockman, Triceratons or whatever)
Triceratons would be sweet in a tmnt movie.
n-zero
09-05-2012, 11:26 AM
It was decent. The a-plot was what in comics would pass as a two issue filler story that was clearly written to sell monster toys, but the fight scenes were good and the Leo/Raph rooftop confrontation was excellent. There was some good humor and strong, if unevenly distributed, character development. Seeing Karai was good, even if she was played by an actress who was clearly struggling with her lines. Not as strong as Turtles 1 or Turtles Forever, but nowhere near the bottom of the barrel where Turtles 3 and the leaked script lie.
zkarlette
09-05-2012, 11:57 AM
If they had included the extras,made the guys a little less froggy and minus all the Leo/Raph drama,it would have been Amaizing. I guess the major gripe was the fact that they used CGI instead of suits, Anyways it was a good movie and I liked it.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-05-2012, 01:18 PM
The story sucks. 13 monsters? It's not about believability or realism. It just sounds stupid.
I also didn't like the monsters, but realism, four talking turtles and one talking rat..
koenne
09-05-2012, 01:32 PM
I still like this film , never disliked it really .
Cowabunga!
Vegeta
09-12-2012, 02:12 AM
It didn't help boost the franchise....nor did it get a sequel. It was a failure for a reason, it is not good.
Andrew NDB
09-12-2012, 02:24 AM
2)The teenie-bopper soundtrack sucks. I hated every song in this movie, except for Ram Jam's Black Betty. I almost preferred the MC Hammer songs over this stuff.
The soundtrack/score was actually the only thing I liked about the film. I think it even holds up now. A good blend of orchestral and traditional modern music, even with a few throwback cues to the excellent score to TMNT 1.
4a) The movie plays like a video walkthrough for a video game. Almost all of the dialogue/one liners sound exactly like they would if you were controlling the character on an XBox game. That whole battle outside Winter's tower looks exactly like a video game..
4b) Even the animation looks like video game FMV scenes.
I don't disagree with this.
Method101
09-12-2012, 04:16 AM
I liked the film as well, but seeing as to how I forgot the movie storyline and a lot of the details of the movie, must not have had enough interest in the storyline, but I did love the animation and the voices in the movie.
Floyd91
09-23-2012, 11:38 PM
I caught part of it the other night on HBO. I couldn't really get into it. The animation looked great, but yeah that's about it.
Chris
09-24-2012, 04:00 PM
Watched it the other day. The animation holds up really well (especially the Leo/Raph fight) but the plot just isn't good enough for a feature film. As others have said, it would have been better as a multi-part 2K3 episode. I appreciate they didn't want to re-tread old ground and use Shredder again, and I loved the idea that they were a bit older, had drifted from each other a bit and needed to come together again as a team (though they needed way better story balance between the Turtles), but the whole monsters plot just didn't cut it. This could have (should have) been City at War or Triceratons or any one of a dozen comic based story ideas.
Again, not bad, but certainly not as good as it could or should have been. 2K3 was miles better.
Heather Breckel
09-25-2012, 12:17 AM
It's a fun movie and it looks nice, but definitely no cinematic masterpiece. I definitely don't dislike it, but it's not my favorite. I was surprised by how well it aged. (5 years isn't a long time, but it is when it comes to improvements in CG)
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
09-25-2012, 08:03 AM
I don't care anymore.
Plasticplayhouse
09-29-2012, 07:44 AM
it was ok, i own it for tmnt love sake, but i was never a real fan of it.
Jahwabunga
09-30-2012, 02:04 PM
I think i liked the trailer better than the movie. Was really siked about it, think it just disappoined me a little bit. Storyline wasn't that interested to though.
Oculus Orbus
09-30-2012, 05:04 PM
I still feel the same about it. I watched it again a few months ago and I don't think that script is worth a movie. As it's been said before, it felt a lot like just an episode of the 2K3 series.
Foot Soldier Clang
09-30-2012, 05:53 PM
I really disliked the CG TMNT movie. I'd sooner watch TMNT 3 or the Next Mutation series over it.
cACHI
09-30-2012, 06:35 PM
it was ok. It was odd that they tied the first 3 movies with this one at the end.
The plot was very weak.
CyberCubed
09-30-2012, 07:44 PM
I really disliked the CG TMNT movie. I'd sooner watch TMNT 3 or the Next Mutation series over it.
You'd rather watch Next Mutation over it? Wow.
I can understand not being crazy about the movie, but in no way did it ever come across as insultingly awful.
actionnate
10-01-2012, 10:58 AM
You'd rather watch Next Mutation over it? Wow.
I can understand not being crazy about the movie, but in no way did it ever come across as insultingly awful.
yeah going to have agree +1
Time Mistress
10-03-2012, 12:08 AM
I still love this movie as much as I did the day it came out. Raph vs Leo is still one of the best fights ever put to animation and SO emotionally charged. And now that I've become a Avatar: the Last Airbender fan, my love of Mako's performance of Splinter has only grown to the point I think he's my favorite VA for Splinter period.
This is easily one of my favorite versions of TMNT of all time!
Funny thing - I watched the movie quite recently and thought about it in comparison to how I liked it in 2007.
It's an alright film. To me it's not as good as movie 1 or 2, but it has it's own charm.
The CG was gorgeous, the fight scenes were great - heck to me even the choice of voices for the film was good. But I think the one thing I love about it is the overall emotions used in the film - quite a lot of powerful moments.
However, the one thing that always stuck with me was the plot. I couldn't get over how that plot was so rushed for a movie. The plot it used would have been better if it were used for a mini series.
TheBlueTurtle1
10-26-2012, 10:46 AM
I think its alright, Like peeps have said here, its not as good as the first 2, but still not a bad film by any means. Its better than 3, without doubt.
zodiac brave
10-27-2012, 01:41 AM
i just look at it like i do every other incarnation. its its own thing, with some similarities/overlaps with details from other versions, but ultimately unique. i can understand some points about the shallowness of the plot, but to say it's horrible, or even just bad...that's insane troll logic.
and i know every other reply here invokes the greatness of the first flick and i will too. other than the '90 movie, this is the only film in the four that actually has emotion deeper than "beat the bad guy, cowabunga, dudes!". Yeah, leo and raph's troubles are pretty played out, but if it had to be shown again, this is an example of how to do that...and well!
the animation is great. the designs, i thought, were pretty good for the most part. casey looks very much like he does in 2k3 and i think april is perfectly fine. i mean, other than white girl with red hair, what other defining physical characteristics are there for her? though i did think max winters' legs were distractingly thin, but only the first time i saw it.
i think the plot is good for what they were trying to do with the movie. it was a departure from the norm with an ambitious plot, as others have said, and you gotta give imagi props for trying. if i had seen this flick as a kid, i woulda flipped my lid over how cool it was! as an adult, i can appreciate that they had a line to walk, not just in the tone (kid vs adult), but in execution (die hard vs casual/new fan).
i dunno...i think it was a good addition to the overall franchise.
Garfield
12-01-2012, 01:22 AM
I only saw it once. I remember being kind of critical of it. I want to see it again, just to see what i'd think of it upon another viewing.
eoireitum7
12-02-2012, 03:25 AM
I guess I'm just glad they did something with the turtles. I'll take anything over nothing! Eh, maybe not but still
DonatelloNinja82
12-02-2012, 01:41 PM
I love this movie, honestly. I think that yes, the monsters plot was rather weak at times, and I wish there was more of Donnie and Mikey in the movie, but I think it delves into the characters. It shows them growing up and how family relationships change over time. I really like the dynamic of Raph and Don not getting along very well in Leo's absence when Don was leader.
Donatello_ftw
12-04-2012, 04:21 AM
I just watched TMNT last night and I got to say I liked it a lot more than the first time I saw it. Perhaps seeing the end of the 4kids show and the starT of the nickelodeon show has opened me up to the odd storyline the film uses but tome TMNT seems like a really good 3 parter of the 4kids show. Not spectacular, but not bad. I definitely enjoyed Turtles Forever more, however I think TMNT holds up as a pretty good entry, especially after the disaster that was the third movie.
Jephael
12-04-2012, 10:42 AM
I'm actually planning to watch the movie tonight, as it's part of my ongoing Ninja Turtle marathon. It may be my least favorite movie, but there are still some parts of it I really enjoy!
Andrew NDB
12-04-2012, 11:25 PM
I guess I'm just glad they did something with the turtles. I'll take anything over nothing!
Horrible, horrible attitude.
Donatello_ftw
12-09-2012, 05:36 AM
I'm actually planning to watch the movie tonight, as it's part of my ongoing Ninja Turtle marathon. It may be my least favorite movie, but there are still some parts of it I really enjoy!
Really? You like 3 better than TMNT?
Powder
12-09-2012, 02:25 PM
A lot of people do.
jaymq
12-09-2012, 04:27 PM
I'm actually planning to watch the movie tonight, as it's part of my ongoing Ninja Turtle marathon. It may be my least favorite movie, but there are still some parts of it I really enjoy!
Really? You like 3 better than TMNT?
A lot of people do.
I'm one of them.
zodiac brave
12-09-2012, 04:39 PM
im not. at least TMNT seemed to wanna try. pt 3 was just milkin, milkin, milkin dat cash cow. :lol:
DonatelloNinja82
12-09-2012, 05:56 PM
im not. at least TMNT seemed to wanna try. pt 3 was just milkin, milkin, milkin dat cash cow. :lol:
I'm not, either...I love TMNT.
liugeaux
12-09-2012, 06:03 PM
TMNT has some issues like, Casey's dialogue, Donny being a supporting character, a plot that seems to come together magically at the end of act 2, a giant plot hole regarding the monsters being captured, and horrid human character models, but I really enjoyed it.
Its one of the most gorgeous movies I've ever seen and the Leo/Raph fight was amazing. There are times I put my Blu-ray in to just watch that part. The intro sequence for the turtles was quite clever and well executed and I like really like the look of the turtles and NYC. Its has a good pace and most of the jokes play well even on subsequent viewings. Everytime I watch that silly movie I find myself grinning through most of it.
Outside of the original movie, I would say TMNT is my favorite. Also, the first three movies suffer really badly from being movies from the 90s. Rather than being seminal timeless movies, they are a product of their generation and it makes them hard to watch at times, especially 2 and 3.
CyberCubed
12-09-2012, 08:44 PM
TMNT III had a better plot than TMNT IV, regardless of anything else.
twopinacoladas
12-09-2012, 10:56 PM
When I first saw the film I didn't particularly like it, I wanted to like it but it just left a bad taste in my mouth. I saw it a second time and tried to enjoy it and I think I enjoyed it a bit more.
Part of the problem was likely that all of the screen shots that were leaked or released before the film essentially showed every single scene in the movie (same goes with the trailers). I felt I knew exactly what was going to happen and that didn't help. Another problem I thought it felt more like Ghostbusters and not like a TMNT film.
It had some good parts, the voice acting but the whole bunch of statues, monsters etc I just didn't enjoy it. I think later viewings after being desensitized to it I enjoyed it more. I actually enjoyed the behind the scenes stuff on the dvd.
What was done well was when Leonardo got taken and the camera sunk down to below street level with Raph running afterloosing him with the music was actually pretty effective.
The movie wasn't terrible just didn't feel like I was watching a TMNT film if that makes any sense.
kzekedaurus
12-10-2012, 01:48 AM
I've been thinking about whether or not I should leave a comment, since everything has already been said, but what the hay. TMNT is a good movie, but not a great one.
The movie has multiple plot points it has to juggle, but the trouble for me was that it never seemed to mesh cohesively or evenly. It plays a kind of pass the baton running game, where its jumping between the family drama and the 13 monsters stuff, but neither is getting ample breathing room. And the pacing, yikes. The slow beginning sacrifices a lot of the running time, so that the action-packed side has to do crunch time as it gets closer and closer to the standard Big Finale™. The end product feels stagnant, bland.
What it definitely needed was some editing. Simplify the 13 monsters/ stone soldiers plot, since it wasn't very interesting in the first place. Surprise!Karai could've been removed without losing anything. There were parallels that could be drawn between the turtles and Winters and his immortal soldiers; more emphasis would've added to and enriched the story. Brotherly loyalty v. Individual wills, mortality and being left behind, separation from the world/one another, all these things are there. They're just not unified or focused enough to feel meaningful. The thing is, it tries. You can see that it does.
It does a lot of things right; the characters have a lot of nuance in their interactions and dialogue. The set pieces are beautiful, from the rain-slicked rooftops and alleyways to the Xanatos-esque castle/skyscraper that Winters owns. Fight scenes are exciting; love how they never stay on the ground level.
I'd compare it to the Incredibles, which also stars a family of outcasts, who must deal with crises on a world and family level, dealing with some deep-seated emotional problems. They come out on top, becoming more unified as a family, and changing the world's perception of them, even if slightly. I guess I rag on TMNT because, while I think it's a mediocre film, I liked the possibilities it had.
Bjarni
12-14-2012, 11:01 PM
I really like it. Everything about it.
The only thing that slightly bothers me is the lack of screentime Donnie and Mikey get but of course they going to focus more on Mikey in the sequel that was never made, so it's a lot more understandable when you look at the big picture.
So, I basically love everything about it. It's a great installment in the saga.
us_sofcskey
12-20-2012, 03:04 PM
I thought the movie had a great opening and decent action throughout but it just felt like they rushed the last 10 or so minutes of the movie just to end the movie....... not to mention the CGI was great throughout the movie however those last 10 or so minutes just felt like I was watching somebody play a video game not an actual movie just my .02
Bjarni
12-20-2012, 05:15 PM
those last 10 or so minutes just felt like I was watching somebody play a video game
I've heard this before but I never got that feel with the end battle. Although I understand where it's coming from.
I liked all the action scenes and I found them well executed. The only one I had a problem with was that one small red creature that cartoon-ishly handled Raphael. I know the movie was targeted for kids and probably need more light moments due to some of the heavier scenes, but it was the one thing I could do without.
Matches Malone
12-20-2012, 05:30 PM
Just watched this again today. Agree with some; I really liked the recap of the turtles. Again, like most, the plot is pretty dismal. It's incoherent, contradictory, and doesn't tie in with that nice little intro at all. Why bring up the Shredder at all as background, if it has nothing to do with this story?
As with the rest of the 2000's turtles, it's got the tone right, more or less. A little more serious and character-oriented, but the execution is definitely lacking, with most of the conflicts feeling very forced. The animation is great, though.
It always drives me nuts to see the stone generals "turn" on Max Winters at the end when they "realized" that hunting these monsters would break the curse. What did they think they were doing?? And the Nightwatcher thing is pretty silly. I didn't know Raph could build something like that. Or that they were superheroes whose mission was fighting crime. Why would they retire from that if Leo went away, anyway? And how can you quit your family?! Okay, now I'm just rambling... Basically it just felt like the writer, I guess in this case Kevin Munroe, did not understand the characters at all and just substituted every superhero cliche he could think of. Either that, or the studios injected all of that stuff to make the turtles easier to understand. Overall, a pretty movie with some nice moments, but one that falls apart pretty early on and continues to do so at an accelerating pace.
Bjarni
12-20-2012, 06:09 PM
And the Nightwatcher thing is pretty silly. I didn't know Raph could build something like that. Or that they were superheroes whose mission was fighting crime.
It's explained in the prequel comic books released alongside the movie that the Nightwatcher was a real crimefighter that died in Raphael's arms and he took over in his memory. He didn't build anything.
And their mission isn't to be superheroes, because Leonardo scolds Nightwatcher in the movie with no idea who it is.
I think the Shredder recap was just to showcase that we weren't getting the origin again. That the audience could tie the film either with the first 1990 movie or the 4Kids show (even though it wasn't meant to follow the 4Kids show, I could see that kids could totally interpret the movie like that).
Matches Malone
12-20-2012, 06:35 PM
It's explained in the prequel comic books released alongside the movie that the Nightwatcher was a real crimefighter that died in Raphael's arms and he took over in his memory. He didn't build anything.
And their mission isn't to be superheroes, because Leonardo scolds Nightwatcher in the movie with no idea who it is.
Ah, that makes more sense. Never got around to reading those prequel comics. But is it a good idea to leave important info like that out of the movie? Maybe it wouldn't fit with the movie, but then, maybe they should have dropped it for an idea that was a little more straight forward. As for the superhero thing, they don't mention it, but they make plenty of allusions to it. The standout line being, "Crime never took a break. You did." This definitely implies that they took a break from stopping crime, but when did they ever do that? And multiple references to "getting this team back together." They could just be talking about getting back into practicing martial arts, but like I said, the lines altogether imply the cliched idea of a "retired superhero team." And Leo scolds him, sure, but isn't Casey Jones a vigilante too? That's what I mean by contradictory. There are lines that seem to say the turtles used to fight crime and need to get back into it, and others by Leo saying vigilantism is wrong.
I think the Shredder recap was just to showcase that we weren't getting the origin again. That the audience could tie the film either with the first 1990 movie or the 4Kids show (even though it wasn't meant to follow the 4Kids show, I could see that kids could totally interpret the movie like that).
I understand that, but it just feels a little pointless to make an effort to tie it in with the movie continuity but not do anything with it. "We fought and defeated the Shredder, but this story's not about him at all." and then you get to the end of the movie where it goes, "OR IS IT?" Just feels a little thrown together and incoherent that way.
Spitfire
12-24-2012, 01:39 PM
Really? You like 3 better than TMNT?
The fact anyone likes 3 at all shocks me. But then again people like and actively defend Troma movies too. I know opinions and taste but there's a difference between liking garbage and admitting it's garbage and liking garbage but acting like it isn't.
CyberCubed
12-24-2012, 02:10 PM
The fact anyone likes 3 at all shocks me. But then again people like and actively defend Troma movies too. I know opinions and taste but there's a difference between liking garbage and admitting it's garbage and liking garbage but acting like it isn't.
The actual plot of TMNT III is on par with many comic storylines and the cartoons.
I fail to see how the Turtles being trapped in Feudal Japan and having to deal with waring warlords and defending a village is out of place for the TMNT franchise.
Spitfire
12-24-2012, 05:00 PM
Never did I say the premise is bad. All my comments are clearly directed at the execution.
Bjarni
12-24-2012, 07:36 PM
The fact anyone likes 3 at all shocks me. But then again people like and actively defend Troma movies too.
I would say the third film has a lot of obvious problems. But I do like it - I of course liked it a lot more when I was a kid.
I guess I should mention that I love Troma movies and I'm probably one of the few people out there that see nothing wrong with them. I would actually plays Lloyd Kaufman as one of my all time favorite directors alongside Stanley Kubrick and John Hughes and directors like Fellini, Welles, Lang and Hitchcock.
While there are obviously gags and goofs that don't work - a lot of the critics don't seem to notice that the movies are satire. My favorite Lloyd Kaufman picture is probably The Battle of Love's Return from 1971 which I would say is very similar to the early works of Woody Allen and Harold Lloyd.
Andrew NDB
12-24-2012, 08:15 PM
Troma movies are awesome. And they make no illusion of being anything that's supposed to be taken seriously.
Combat Shock was great.
Garfield
12-25-2012, 10:49 PM
those last 10 or so minutes just felt like I was watching somebody play a video game not an actual movie just my .02
I feel like it has more to do with how today video games are becoming more like moves than that part of the TMNT movie being too much like a game. Lots of games today have these cinematic cut scenes that are very much like movies.
Avatar Yuffie
12-26-2012, 12:12 AM
Well, it made me watch the 2K3 series. So I will give credit for that.
Voices and the artwork's beautiful.
Again mentioned by everyone, the weakness is the story. Sure the Leo/Raph thing is the stuff of legends, and at least put to rest the "if these two fight who'll win" rhetoric but I wish Leo gets something out of this as much as Raph did. Leo came off pretentious and preachy and contradictory judging Nightwatcher when he does the same thing as the Ghost in the Jungle. Don and Mike felt like minor characters (and I am disappointed Donnie and Raph's brief aggression went nowhere), the movie injects Casey/April drama when they shouldn't and Karai/Winters/13 Monsters/Stone Generals felt like an afterthought and wasn't build on a solid foundation. A shame since they're supposed to drive the plot.
Still, I like the movie.
Theli
12-26-2012, 06:26 AM
To be honest i saw the 07 movie this week the first time and i don't like it.
Several reasons.. Don't like the design of the turtles (the nick series have done that much better). Then i dislike the story .. At the end all gets much too fast also...theres no time for story growing.
And of course i hate the voice-job. I watched it in german and the voices are terrible. Here we have the german voice of heath ledger for leonardo... That sounds really akward.. And Raph sound even more ******, listen this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yBHHPO6pKnE This is the voice of Raph in german... (the guy is doing the voice of roger in american dad in the german version)
I think the 07 movie was bad but as so many re-releases of the turtles it gave new impulse to the franchise.
Icebot
12-29-2012, 04:37 PM
I would have rather seen Shredder lead the Foot than Karai but I'd still say it was a good movie.
Vi11AiN6
01-15-2013, 01:31 PM
I enjoy the first ( I was one of Shredder's kids in the warehouse) However I really didn't like Judith Hoag as April.
I love the '07 movie because it wasn't a rehash. It was an original story. I liked how it was a kind of " where they now?" types of story. Also I liked how The Foot was in it but not Shredder.
The score wasn't the best but it's my favorite TMNT movie. Too bad it never will get a sequel.
FoxZerro
01-15-2013, 01:37 PM
I enjoy the first ( I was one of Shredder's kids in the warehouse)
Do you also post on the IMDB board... I swear I've read that in the exact same syntax before?
Keroscene
01-18-2013, 02:54 PM
I still think it's the best of the four movies that have been released in the cinema. It's the funniest, it's has the best action scenes and it's the only time in TMNT history that Leo and Raph's rivalry hasn't bored me. I've seen a lot of people saying they feel the characterisation of Leo is "off" but I feel that movie actually got to the heart of what is really going on between those two. I thought Leo's line "I'm better than you" was actually brilliant, not because I agree with him but because I love the directness of it.
On the other hand, Mike and Don were hardly in it and that sucks. Cutting those two deleted scenes was particularly unforgivable because they were the only scenes in the movie that focused on those two. The plot was a little over-convoluted - they should have had the monsters or the statues (not both) and I don't really see why April and Casey needed to be in it.
Shark_Blade
01-28-2013, 03:54 AM
The turtles still look good, I mean the best they ever looked. I love it.
Pros:
- beautiful cgi
- Leo vs Raph scene. Bloody and teary.
- Karai - Her look. Her voice. Her movements. Pure elegance.
- some funny parts: "You still here? Back to your jungle"
Cons:
- cheesy 13 monster plot with alignment of planets ala Hercules. April retelling the story is just redundant and tiring.
- Raph being the main thing the camera focused on. Gimme more Donnie and Mikey scenes dammit. It's called TMNT for a reason, not Raphael Solo Turtle movie.
- ending looked rushed.
- Mikey's nunchakus barely seen in the whole movie.
- April kicking Karai's ass. Wth?
- Casey looked skinny average joe.
- boring "normal" life stories of the turtles at the beginning.
Bauer536
01-28-2013, 08:58 AM
The turtles still look good, I mean the best they ever looked. I love it.
Pros:
- beautiful cgi
- Leo vs Raph scene. Bloody and teary.
- Karai - Her look. Her voice. Her movements. Pure elegance.
- some funny parts: "You still here? Back to your jungle"
Cons:
- cheesy 13 monster plot with alignment of planets ala Hercules. April retelling the story is just redundant and tiring.
- Raph being the main thing the camera focused on. Gimme more Donnie and Mikey scenes dammit. It's called TMNT for a reason, not Raphael Solo Turtle movie.
- ending looked rushed.
- Mikey's nunchakus barely seen in the whole movie.
- April kicking Karai's ass. Wth?
- Casey looked skinny average joe.
- boring "normal" life stories of the turtles at the beginning.
I'll tell you what the negatives were to this film (even though I enjoyed it): no Shredder, anorexic April, Patrick Stewart as a character that looks like Craig T. Nelson, the 13 monster plot, Mako as Splinter (thank goodness we have Hoon Lee now), and Mikey sneezing from the magic dust. Those weren't so good.
I still like the fight between Leo and Raph. I didn't mind who would win. Leo's my favorite, but Raph did teach him a lesson there. However, they were both wrong. Leo's only better than Raph temper wise. I don't think people always see that.
Vegeta
01-28-2013, 03:00 PM
Recently tried to watch this one again to get a fresh take on it.its just too boring and badly done. The score certainly doesn't help.
TheCanadiandrome
01-28-2013, 11:32 PM
Haven't seen it all the way through yet, but what bits I've seen it's not bad
hated it, only laughed twice from mike and mask jokes.
zodiac brave
02-17-2013, 08:36 PM
hated it
...how come?
jmfoxfire
02-18-2013, 02:15 AM
i liked it because it came on my birthday when it came to theaters and i still have the movie ticket
http://ic.pics.livejournal.com/jfoxfire/12501064/16777/16777_600.jpg
Testudo
02-18-2013, 04:53 AM
As a fan of the turtles ever since the Mirage comics, I have to say that (nostalgia for the first movie aside) this is not only the best, but probably my favourite movie of the franchise as well. It's much more faithful to their roots, I love the animation and design of the characters, and the voice acting is great.
Still, I think they should have pitched a reboot instead of a sequel. Fortunately it works as a standalone.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.