View Full Version : Has anyone else lost interest with the IDW series?
Samhain
08-19-2012, 04:40 PM
I am sad to say, I have. When # 1 was released last year, I was really excited about this book. It had that old school, comic Tmnt 'feel'. Started out with a street fight, with the turtles wearin' the good ole' red bandanas. It felt right. But the last few months I have really lost interest.
I dunno, maybe because of all the toon references coming in the book. When they switched the bandanas, I will admit it left me with a sour feeling, that I still kinda have to this day. Don't get me wrong, I still do very much enjoy the book, I get it every month. But I am just not as excited month to month as I was with the first 5 issues. Anyone else share the same feelings?:tconfuse:
CyberCubed
08-19-2012, 05:17 PM
Not at all. You're just experiencing the usual comic book lull of only one issue coming out a month besides one shots.
I reread all 12 issues, the 6 micros, and Infestation story in the span of one sitting and I enjoyed it even more the second time around. The whole year one story and how everything tied together to the end of #12 was very well done.
I also like the fact that Shredder is sticking around, and that IDW isn't afraid of using old toon or Archie characters. This isn't Mirage and it shouldn't be a copy of it.
So if you lost interest, reread all 12 issues and the 6 micros, you'll probably get right back into it.
DonatelloFan
08-19-2012, 05:53 PM
I have. I don't like the whole 'reincarnation' angle, I still haven't gotten used to Dan Duncan's art (which I guess doesn't matter now), and it just seems to be going by too slow (I'm not a regular comic reader aside from TMNT and The Walking Dead).
I mean, The Walking Dead is only once a month, and I'm never bored with it, and am excited for each and every issue. The IDW TMNT, not so much.
Since I haven't read Volume One yet, I'm also excited to read each issue of the Color Classics. I love the series so far. I just can't really get into the IDW. I'm going to keep buying the issues, because it's only what, $8 a month for the ongoing and micro's? I've already gotten all the back issues, so why stop now? Who knows, maybe my interest will pick up one day.
Zulithe
08-19-2012, 06:18 PM
While I have not lost interest just yet, If your biggest complaint about the IDW series is the bandana color then I consider you fortunate.
At least things like that make sense. They have different bandana colors in EVERY iteration so why should it really matter?
However, other things like April being the one to name the turtles, the reincarnation stuff, and other major changes to both the origin and characters are actually things worth complaining about, IMO.
DonatelloFan
08-19-2012, 06:30 PM
While I have not lost interest just yet, If your biggest complaint about the IDW series is the bandana color then I consider you fortunate.
I forgot to mention that. Yeah, I don't see why people care about bandana color. This isn't Mirage TMNT, so who cares? There are plenty of other things wrong (in my opinion) with the IDW storyline, but I'm not a writer, so I can't complain much about it.
Jester
08-19-2012, 06:39 PM
I forgot to mention that. Yeah, I don't see why people care about bandana color. This isn't Mirage TMNT, so who cares? There are plenty of other things wrong (in my opinion) with the IDW storyline, but I'm not a writer, so I can't complain much about it.
My thoughts on the matter, which I've stated elsewhere as well, is that the main TMNT comic, be it Mirage or IDW should keep the red bandanas. Any spin-off comics, like Archie or Dreamwave I have no problems with, they spun off from colored masked roots. Also, it felt like a bait and switch or a cheat. They started in all red, got us excited for Mirage level grit, then gradually added in the FW stuff with the bandanas and the character nods.
Samhain
08-19-2012, 06:45 PM
My thoughts on the matter, which I've stated elsewhere as well, is that the main TMNT comic, be it Mirage or IDW should keep the red bandanas. Any spin-off comics, like Archie or Dreamwave I have no problems with, they spun off from colored masked roots. Also, it felt like a bait and switch, or a cheat. They started in all red, got us excited for Mirage level grit, then gradually added in the FW stuff with the bandanas and the character nods.
Exactly. Like I said, the first 4 issues felt like classic gritty Tmnt comic goodness. Now, with all the cartoon aspects already in the comic, plus what's coming, they are losing me. It's turning into the 80's cartoon for grown ups. At least that's what it feels like to me.
ToTheNines
08-19-2012, 06:57 PM
I did for a little while early in the summer , but ever since the Splinter micro I've been back.
MikeandRaph87
08-19-2012, 07:01 PM
Exactly. Like I said, the first 4 issues felt like classic gritty Tmnt comic goodness. Now, with all the cartoon aspects already in the comic, plus what's coming, they are losing me. It's turning into the 80's cartoon for grown ups. At least that's what it feels like to me.
I think its how do we like our turtles? I will never like a red mask killer comic. It will lose my interest as quick as you lost yours. I need '87 cartoon elements and other aspect of the other media for it to feel like Ninja Turtles to me. For you its staying close to the original depiction. I can understand that while I can't agree with it.
The pacing is a pain and I would like an answer if the turtles are willing to kill or not. At this point I like what is being attempted. Mr. Waltz is trying to taking many elements that the large number of us like from the other media and taking a few elements from the comics for those that actually perfer the black and white comics while adding in its own original stuff like Old Hobb and the reincarnation bit. The whole reincarnation really bothered me but 8 months later I can accept it for this version and see that it works....at least for what Tom is trying to achieve. If its not your cup of tea hold on to about #15 then you have your back issues to retreat to. That is always a nice fallback spot. :)
CyberCubed
08-19-2012, 07:05 PM
Exactly. Like I said, the first 4 issues felt like classic gritty Tmnt comic goodness. Now, with all the cartoon aspects already in the comic, plus what's coming, they are losing me. It's turning into the 80's cartoon for grown ups. At least that's what it feels like to me.
The first four issues weren't any more gritty than the rest of it. The color of bandanas does not change the story or violence level.
DonatelloFan
08-19-2012, 07:24 PM
The first four issues weren't any more gritty than the rest of it. The color of bandanas does not change the story or violence level.
Exactly. Again, I don't see the point of worrying about bandana color. But I guess 'to each his own'.
Samhain
08-19-2012, 08:07 PM
I will never like a red mask killer comic.
What the hell are you talking about?
The first four issues weren't any more gritty than the rest of it. The color of bandanas does not change the story or violence level.
It may have not changed the story, but visually it changed the way I looked at it as a whole.
MikeandRaph87
08-19-2012, 08:15 PM
What the hell are you talking about?
I shouldn't have to spell it out for you. Just having a friendly conversation with you,dude. I don't like seeing all red mask and I don't like them to kill. It turns me off while it increase your interest. We both like TMNT but different types of the same thing. That is all I am saying. I can't get into it if it is the way you like it more than likely but will try it out and you can't get into what I perfer but will try it out is all.
Samhain
08-19-2012, 08:19 PM
I shouldn't have to spell it out for you. Just having a friendly conversation with you,dude. I don't like seeing all red mask and I don't like them to kill. It turns me off while it increase your interest. We both like TMNT but different types of the same thing. That is all I am saying. I can't get into it if it is the way you like it more than likely but will try it out and you can't get into what I perfer but will try it out is all.
When did I say the turtles need to kill in order for me to enjoy the book? That's right, I didn't. I certainly don't MIND them killing, if they have to. They are ninja after all.
MikeandRaph87
08-19-2012, 08:28 PM
When did I say the turtles need to kill in order for me to enjoy the book? That's right, I didn't. I certainly don't MIND them killing, if they have to. They are ninja after all.
I know. I said it will effect it for ME when desciribng my interest level and really the only thing that could effect it for me at this point . Like you I do associate the mask with the tone. I think a good analogy with tone can be found in Batman. There is Frank Miller, Adam West, and Denny O'Neil. Each name represents a certain way of portraying Batman. I like mine with Denny O'Neil and that is the kind of tone I like seeing in Ninja Turtles. Not gritty yet not silly. You on the other hand perfer Frank Miller, dark and deep storytelling where a hero or perhaps those around him or more willing to take a violent approach.
Heather Breckel
08-19-2012, 08:40 PM
I've been enjoying it quite a bit, but I didn't read any of the Mirage comics until recently. I grew up with the old cartoon and the Archie series so for me I appreciate that some things feel familiar. Even seeing the Mirage comics as an adult, I don't really feel like they were ever that dark or gritty. But I'm also a big Berserk fan, so a lot of things are going to feel pretty tame compared to that.
Ninjinister
08-19-2012, 09:01 PM
S**t's just getting real, guys. There's no way I'm losing interest now.
Donnie
08-19-2012, 09:03 PM
The pacing is the only thing I would complain about. Once a month is a dragging pace; and while others disagree with that statement I cannot help but feel that way. However, that hasn't really dampened my interest in the book, no. I prefer the color bandanas, so that was never an issue for me.
The reincarnation angle may be "out there" but it's no more farfetched than 4 baby turtles randomly coming into contact with a breaking TCRI canister of alien ooze. The only other issue I ever had was the characterization of Donatello being overly aggressive, but I've grown to appreciate it as a new and (in retrospect) refreshing take on him.
Zany Orange Dude
08-19-2012, 09:14 PM
I definately lost interest in it, and I don't precisely know why. I didn't really care for the way the characters were portrayed.:ohwell:
Bauer536
08-19-2012, 10:18 PM
By the time Donnie got obnoxious, I was starting to lose interest, but I gave it another chance. However, by the fifth issue (a. k. a. reincarnation origin), I slammed the book onto the floor. I felt, "What's the point? If you're not going to stay true to their origins, don't call it Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles because that's not what this is.":tgrumble: To me, if Splinter was the only one reincarnated and NOT the turtles, I would've been fine. I just think that the 18 month mutation of the turtles is what caused the reincarnation thing to begin. Tom Waltz, to me (even though he's nice), copped out. Either this idea was in his mind before he worked on the comics, or he didn't know what to do to make it "new." There are ways to make things new without completely changing things for the sake of it. To me, this comic does not have heart. Hoping the Nickelodeon based ones will be better.
So to anyone who may think this pays tributes to the OT, I don't remember Don being that rude to Leo in the OT . . . or for one thing, April naming the turtles and working for Stockman. This is not OT for the adults. And if it is, it needs to start over because, I feel it's just not working. Still, that's my opinion. There have been times where I've exploded on here about this, but that was before I began clearing my mind and thinking about it a little. Still, my opinions really haven't changed.
Plus, Old Hob. Very weak villain. Wasn't needed. Even during the whole reincarnation thing, I feared he would be Oruku Saki. Alopex? Wasn't needed. Karai coming in instantly? They should have waited on her. Everything, I felt, just made this lack magic that TMNT carries. In fact, it makes the 2k3 series better for what it was . . . even during those last cheesey seasons.:twink:
Also, hate Dan Duncans artwork. At least Kevin Eastman's turtles look lean, green, fighting machines. Duncan's appear . . . I don't know . . . mean, like the turtles can't stand each other.:tsad: Plus, I found their look to be ugly. Ross Campell is a better artist than him.
Ninjinister
08-19-2012, 10:20 PM
"What's the point? If you're not going to stay true to their origins, don't call it Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles because that's not what this is."
My take: why keep it the same in every incarnation? You might as well just watch/read the old s**t over and over again.
Bauer536
08-19-2012, 10:34 PM
My take: why keep it the same in every incarnation? You might as well just watch/read the old s**t over and over again.
To me, messing with the origins and characters make it wrong for it to be the franchise people love.
Still, there are ways to change things without making it too drastic. I mean, Nickelodeon is changing a few things in the cartoon, but at least the turtles are the ones we know and love and that they were still mutated as infants.:twink:
That's what should be left untouched: the way characters are born. What's the point in reading Batman then if it seems someone decides not to kill off his parents? Something so essential that makes the franchise should never be taken away.:tsad:
Zulithe
08-19-2012, 10:40 PM
Samhain has a picture of Leo with a BLUE bandana (not red -- sacrilege!!!!) as his avatar. Clearly it is not so important to him as he claims :)
TonySiegel
08-19-2012, 10:41 PM
The Splinter & Casey issues have been a breath of fresh air for the series. The main line has been slowing down for me to the point of feeling very lull.
I agree with the poster that mentioned how good the first issue felt... Personally the highest peek for me was when the brothers finally reunited.
[And no it wasnt the bandana thing]
I'm loving this series I'm enjoying it more than Mirage. Mirage is the book i lost interest in the story's where sometimes quite boring.But IDW love the reincarnation and April naming them. and Splinter facing the foot and Shredder on his own was well..... AMAZING!. the micros are also great.
Samhain
08-19-2012, 10:57 PM
Samhain has a picture of Leo with a BLUE bandana (not red -- sacrilege!!!!) as his avatar. Clearly it is not so important to him as he claims :)
I do hope you're joking. Like many others, I have no issues wth the turtles wearing colored bandanas. Except in the comic books.
LeoNerdo
08-19-2012, 10:58 PM
If it was any other series but TMNT I don't know that I would still be picking up the book every month. IDW hasn't done anything so egregious that I've wanted to drop it, but to me everything from the beginning has felt lackluster, especially after the new-ness wore off. The pacing from month to month is one thing but the pacing within each book I think is terrible. None of the character personality traits are that well defined. This series is supposed to stand on it's own but I find myself projecting more conventional character traits onto the series instead of those things being clearly outlined.
There are probably more people that know and remember TMNT because of the FW series than from any other incarnation. I was one of those people once, and I think it's great to throw them a bone now and then if it's something worthwhile. But if that becomes an overpowering factor in the series it will seriously turn me off. There have been high points along the way(micro ish's mostly), and I'm certainly looking forward to the next story arc, the annual, and the foot clan mini. I think this thing has so far failed to really stand on it's own and has been played pretty safe(lame). Maybe that comes down from Nick/Viacom, I dunno.
Cipher
08-19-2012, 11:15 PM
Well, count me in the other camp on all accounts. I only recently got into the series and have been pleasantly surprised by it. Not stopping any time soon.
Grimlock
08-19-2012, 11:20 PM
The pacing is horrible in this series. You gotta grab me, and keep me wantin' more. Sadly, it has not. And someone tell Kevin he needs to practice drawing because most of the time his ''covers'' blow.
Samhain
08-19-2012, 11:25 PM
The pacing is horrible in this series. You gotta grab me, and keep me wantin' more. Sadly, it has not. And someone tell Kevin he needs to practice drawing because most of the time his ''covers'' blow.
I agree on the pacing. Kevin's covers are a hit or miss for me. Sometimes they just looked rushed, but his cover for issue # 14 is FANTASTIC! :tcool:
CyberCubed
08-20-2012, 12:05 AM
There are probably more people that know and remember TMNT because of the FW series than from any other incarnation. I was one of those people once, and I think it's great to throw them a bone now and then if it's something worthwhile. But if that becomes an overpowering factor in the series it will seriously turn me off. There have been high points along the way(micro ish's mostly), and I'm certainly looking forward to the next story arc, the annual, and the foot clan mini. I think this thing has so far failed to really stand on it's own and has been played pretty safe(lame). Maybe that comes down from Nick/Viacom, I dunno.
That's why this series is actually interesting. If IDW didn't use original cartoon characters it would simply be, "Mirage-lite," which is essentially what the 4kids series already was.
The 4kids cartoon was already a loose adaption of Mirage material with new twists added like Ch'rell and so forth to make a new spin on the old stuff.
IDW on the other hand can take characters we would never see in Mirage/4kids like Slash and Krang and do something amazing with them. That's what makes this series have potential, to re-invent all these older characters that we haven't seen used in YEARS.
LeoNerdo
08-20-2012, 12:42 AM
I don't disagree. I like Krang. I think he could be a cool character in IDW. He hasn't been borne out one way or the other yet. There's a very short list of FW/Archie characters I would be interested in seeing re-vamped and Slash is certainly among them. Bebop and Rocksteady? Not so much really, unless they can imagine up something meaningful for them. Nostalgia can only go so far before you realize it's kinda weak.
CyberCubed
08-20-2012, 12:56 AM
I don't disagree. I like Krang. I think he could be a cool character in IDW. He hasn't been borne out one way or the other yet. There's a very short list of FW/Archie characters I would be interested in seeing re-vamped and Slash is certainly among them. Bebop and Rocksteady? Not so much really, unless they can imagine up something meaningful for them. Nostalgia can only go so far before you realize it's kinda weak.
True, but I am sure we're not going to see characters just for the sake of it.
With the strong hints that Slash is making his debut in the IDW series soon, I honestly can't wait to see what they do with him.
Coola Yagami
08-20-2012, 01:11 AM
How can anyone possibly lose interest when it's just starting to kick off and getting good? That's like walking out of an action movie before the epic climax.
Matches Malone
08-20-2012, 02:14 AM
S**t's just getting real, guys. There's no way I'm losing interest now.
Not really sure how things are getting real... Except for maybe Old Hob and Baxter. But for the turtles, the story so far is about how they met the Shredder and found absolutely no reason to be afraid of him. I understand there's plenty of reasoning for it, but it doesn't make the story any more eventful, or "real," as it may. The only thing the Foot have done competently is kidnap and already kidnapped Splinter.
I'm still enjoying IDW turtles, but it is waning as everything definitely seems to be slowly declining in quality with each subsequent issue, both in artwork and writing. I'm hoping that with a new artist, and one year under Tom's belt to improve the execution overall, my interest will pick back up. I still have high hopes, but they really gotta take the kiddy gloves off. I don't mind a safe all ages approach necessarily, but that doesn't mean the story has to be safe. See Mask of the Phantasm for how you can push the boundaries of multi layered storytelling with an accessible yet sophisticated approach.
FoxZerro
08-20-2012, 09:30 AM
As long as they keep up the quality that has been present in the Micro-Series then I will still have interest in the IDW. Those stories are great and self-contained and give me the greatest joy of the new issues. I'm really looking forward to the arcs that have been hinted at for issues 13-14 and 15-16. I like an over arcing story but I think that having things wrap up in two issues instead of four will be great for the overall storytelling aspect of the series and I hope this turns out to be the case.
CyberCubed
08-20-2012, 09:39 AM
Not really sure how things are getting real... Except for maybe Old Hob and Baxter. But for the turtles, the story so far is about how they met the Shredder and found absolutely no reason to be afraid of him. I understand there's plenty of reasoning for it, but it doesn't make the story any more eventful, or "real," as it may. The only thing the Foot have done competently is kidnap and already kidnapped Splinter.
The Mirage Turtles killed Shredder the first time they met him. The 4kids Turtles (or rather Splinter) defeated Shredder the first time he attacked them.
Shredder losing once doesn't mean he's going to always lose.
I'm still liking it. Granted I'm a little behind all the stories, what with reading Trades only, But I'm still liking what they're putting out.
I'm usually pretty easy going with comics. I appreciate different artistic styles, some I like, some not. I don't mind Duncan's at all.
As for the story lines, I like seeing a different twist on a story. My thought on that is do you really want to pay money only to read the exact same stories?
As long as it still fits the overall feel of the subjects, and not something carzy coming out of left field (or outerspace :twink:)
~S~
Samhain
08-20-2012, 10:22 AM
How can anyone possibly lose interest when it's just starting to kick off and getting good? That's like walking out of an action movie before the epic climax.
It's been over a damn year and it's ''just starting to kick off and getting good?''
Yeah....:roll:
Matches Malone
08-20-2012, 10:58 AM
The Mirage Turtles killed Shredder the first time they met him. The 4kids Turtles (or rather Splinter) defeated Shredder the first time he attacked them.
Shredder losing once doesn't mean he's going to always lose.
I've made and recognized that point myself before, but 40 pages of buildup hardly compares to 8-12 issues of buildup. Even so, Mirage was able to build up more tension and suspense within those 40 pages than IDW has in all this time. I'm not trying to say the whole series is a letdown, but I'm acknowledging a legitimate one for myself. Like I've said before, it's not the fact that he lost so much as the way he lost.
Plus we all know the Vol. 1 #1 was meant to be self-contained story. If the Shredder is meant to stick around to terrorize the turtles but ultimately lose, he's got to do something competently or else he just looks like a chump who talks big. Krang is talking big too with no actions to back it up, but hopefully when the time comes, he won't disappoint as well. I understand they aren't meant to succeed in destroying the turtles, but it's up to the series to convince us they could, otherwise what's the point?
Genesis
08-20-2012, 11:13 AM
There should be a "meh" option. Like, I continue to pick up the trades, and I'm digging it for the most part, but the books haven't done anything to really wow me. So far, I've enjoyed the micros more thoroughly than the ongoing, but that may or may not change as I continue them both.
SS_Turtle
08-20-2012, 09:40 PM
I haven't lost interest but I am a few issues behind right now. I think I left off at issue 10.
CyberCubed
08-21-2012, 12:15 AM
Despite the posts in this thread, I find the poll results quite interesting.
Only 5 people have voted that they "lost interest" in the IDW series, whereas 20 say they haven't. So despite some negative comments here, the overwhelming majority is still quite interested in the IDW series. I think that says a lot.
I'll say it again, I think its just the usual comic book lull of only one issue coming out a month and taking too long to get through a story arc. Read them all in one sitting and everything flows much better.
Andrew NDB
08-21-2012, 12:18 AM
Waned of late, to be honest, but I'm not closing the gate on things yet. And I think the results of this poll become useless every new issue that arrives... I'm easily swayed if a killer new issue drops, for example.
Lampy
08-21-2012, 05:26 AM
i think my only gripe here - like the majority of people posting - is the pacing. are we really supposed to believe that all this happened in a matter of hours? that's kind of hard to imagine. aside from that... i'm still interested in this series... especially the micros. i'm used to the bandannas... nothing new there. the fight sequence with shredder... despite the shortness of that battle, the fight sequence is somewhat similar to the Mirage fight. the reincarnation thing is... new. but i find that it works.
however... i would much prefer if splinter finds out that the Turtles aren't really his sons. then he'd have to accept that truth and accept them as his sons, reincarnate or not. then the question "then why are we HERE?" can again be implemented and the randomness of their origin can once again be established and all the mirage fans are a little happier. yay!... oh wait. (one can only wish... sigh)
***First of Two Latin Kings***
08-21-2012, 08:31 PM
the reincarnation thing is... new. but i find that it works.
however... i would much prefer if splinter finds out that the Turtles aren't really his sons. then he'd have to accept that truth and accept them as his sons, reincarnate or not. then the question "then why are we HERE?" can again be implemented and the randomness of their origin can once again be established and all the mirage fans are a little happier. yay!... oh wait. (one can only wish... sigh)
I don't think I would like that at all, but I suppose it is still a slim possibility. I don't understand why so many people want this to be "more Mirage." It's its own universe and clearly draws on influence from all of the others.
Jephael
08-21-2012, 10:18 PM
It's funny, I had my fears about this new comic book when the news first came out about the reboot. Hell I even had a bad feeling about the Micro specials, but I was pleasantly surprised by everything they've done, and every month I look forward to getting the next issue in the mail!
Andrew NDB
08-21-2012, 10:31 PM
It's funny, I had my fears about this new comic book when the news first came out about the reboot.
What reboot?
Jephael
08-21-2012, 10:34 PM
This new series is basically a reboot, isn't it?
Samhain
08-21-2012, 11:00 PM
I guess for me, Slash eventually showing up is what is bothering me. I'm just not liking this direction. Alopex, Slash, Bebop and Rocksteady, ''Krang'', Rock soldiers, just not digging it. Call me crazy. I dare ya.
It's its own universe and clearly draws on influence from all of the others.
To me, seems like they are drawing a lot from a specific universe.
CyberCubed
08-22-2012, 12:13 AM
I guess for me, Slash eventually showing up is what is bothering me. I'm just not liking this direction. Alopex, Slash, Bebop and Rocksteady, ''Krang'', Rock soldiers, just not digging it. Call me crazy. I dare ya.
If that's what's bothering you it sounds like you were expecting a Mirage rehash. Its amazing that 1 year into the series some of you cannot let it go that this series is NOT and shouldn't be Mirage 2.0.
IDW using characters from all universes is probably the most promising thing about this series. Its a modern comic designed with a rogues gallery in mind, not Mirage's random storytelling where nothing really happened until a big Foot Clan arc.
Mirage is pretty much done at this point besides if PL ever finishes Volume 4. Seeing IDW just be "Mirage-lite" its pointless, we already have the 4kids series for that.
To me, seems like they are drawing a lot from a specific universe.
Why do you keep saying that? We have a handful of OT characters (Krang, Bebop/Rocksteady and Traag's Rock Soldiers), a 4kids character (Angel and arguably this version of Karai), an Archie character (Slash is mostly associated with the Archie series), and Mirage influence for Shredder/Baxter/April, etc.
Seriously, WTF are you making a big deal out of nothing?
FearlessLeader
08-22-2012, 12:25 AM
I am still reading and enjoying the series but find myself generally buying the comics in groups of 4 or so and then reading them in one sitting and I am actually enjoying them more that way.
Maybe doing the same would help some others that are having pacing issues?
Andrew NDB
08-22-2012, 12:43 AM
I guess for me, Slash eventually showing up is what is bothering me. I'm just not liking this direction. Alopex, Slash, Bebop and Rocksteady, ''Krang'', Rock soldiers, just not digging it. Call me crazy. I dare ya.
To me, seems like they are drawing a lot from a specific universe.
If that's what's bothering you it sounds like you were expecting a Mirage rehash. Its amazing that 1 year into the series some of you cannot let it go that this series is NOT and shouldn't be Mirage 2.0.
IDW using characters from all universes is probably the most promising thing about this series. Its a modern comic designed with a rogues gallery in mind, not Mirage's random storytelling where nothing really happened until a big Foot Clan arc.
Not to speak for Samhain, but it seems like the driving point here is more "We're just clearing year one of IDW TMNT, and all we've arrived at is a lot of Fred Wolf type of stuff." I tend to agree... the evidence is kinda piling up in the corner over there and yeah, while we can pretend and ignore it, it's still there.
But now I'm curious. In your mind, CyberCubed, what is "Mirage 2.0"? Because to me, "Mirage 2.0" suggests, "A comic that learns from the mistakes and pitfalls of the original Mirage material and makes a better, leaner, more poignant comic book"... which doesn't necessarily preclude borrowing elements or characters from other universes as long as they "fit." I see nothing wrong with such a direction, even objectively.
Mirage is pretty much done at this point besides if PL ever finishes Volume 4. Seeing IDW just be "Mirage-lite" its pointless, we already have the 4kids series for that.
Whether or not the Mirage universe and/or Volume 4 is "done" right now is hardly the topic of conversation at the moment. You're twisting things.
Why do you keep saying that? We have a handful of OT characters (Krang, Bebop/Rocksteady and Traag's Rock Soldiers),
And Neutrinos. And the (previously) Fred Wolf-exclusive instant mutation. And human origins for all the Turtles and Splinter. And the rainbow bandannas that the OT began. And non-killing, heroic Ninja Turtles that the OT propagated. And party-lovin' Dude Mikey™ who debuted in the OT.
a 4kids character (Angel and arguably this version of Karai),
We don't know what she'll resemble at this point. And Angel was largely only a footnote in 4Kids TMNT.
an Archie character (Slash is mostly associated with the Archie series)
While not incorrect, you're putting the cart before the horse -- we haven't even met IDW Slash yet. Who's to say he won't be closely patterned after Fred Wolf Slash? Or basically just be a Slash in name only, and otherwise be a completely new iteration?
and Mirage influence for Shredder
"Mirage influence" is a non-statement. Technically, everything TMNT that's ever come out at any point, ever, has "Mirage influence"... Mirage is the source material. As far as Shredder goes, his earliest origins bare no resemblance to his Mirage origins (though personally, I kinda dig where IDW appears to be going with Shredder from the ground up... even if they kind of completely squashed his value as a supervillain in his debut arc). As far as how he gets to the present and his current status quo? We have no idea yet. In fact, we know next to nothing about Shredder at this juncture.
Baxter
OK, I'll give you Baxter. As of this moment right now, yes, he's fairly grounded as pre-cyborg Mirage Baxter.
April
Not really.
etc.
Etc.? You might elaborate. I can't think of much else.
CyberCubed
08-22-2012, 12:58 AM
But now I'm curious. In your mind, CyberCubed, what is "Mirage 2.0"? Because to me, "Mirage 2.0" suggests, "A comic that learns from the mistakes and pitfalls of the original Mirage material and makes a better, leaner, more poignant comic book"... which doesn't necessarily preclude borrowing elements or characters from other universes as long as they "fit." I see nothing wrong with such a direction, even objectively.
When people say they want it to be like Mirage, I assume they're taking Peter Laird's stance of little to no other mutants besides Leatherhead, because it makes the Turtles more special.
Old Hob and Alopex are not Fred Wolf characters, but simply because they're animal mutants people tend to associate them with the old type of mutants from the 90's.
Aside from that, I also assume they don't want Shredder to stick around (which I have no problem with, as long as he doesn't become a supervillain), and they want the series to stay away from characters from the cartoons. I have no problem with that either, I think Krang has a lot of potential in the IDW series as does Slash.
What it SHOULD be more like Mirage is actually contact between human opponents and their blades, more visible scars during the fights, and the Turtles not being able to take out the entire Foot Clan in a single fight. But we'll see how that progresses. I won't touch the color bandana issue.
And Neutrinos. And the Fred Wolf-exclusive instant mutation. And human origins for all the Turtles and Splinter. And the rainbow bandannas that the OT began. And non-killing Ninja Turtles that the OT propagated. And party-lovin' Dude Mikey™ who debuted in the OT.
Well yeah...but you're still exaggerating on Mikey's persona. Splinter wasn't a reincarnated human in the old show as we know. And since #5 and the Splinter micro have received critical acclaim from the fanbase, I think this version of Hamato Yoshi/Splinter is very well received.
About the Neutrinos, it depends on what happens with them. Tom Waltz already assured us they wouldn't be, "hot-rodding teenagers" like the show.
While not incorrect, you're putting the cart before the horse -- we haven't even met IDW Slash yet. Who's to say he won't be closely patterned after Fred Wolf Slash? Or basically just be a Slash in name only, and otherwise be a completely new iteration?
I am certain they will go with the black bandana look for Slash. Its what he's most widely recognizable in. He's probably going to have a widely different backstory in this series anyway, he might be a clone of the Turtles.
"Mirage influence" is a non-statement. Technically, everything TMNT that's ever come out at any point, ever, has "Mirage influence"... Mirage is the source material. As far as Shredder goes, his earliest origins bare no resemblance to his Mirage origins. As far as how he gets to the present? We have no idea yet.
Shredder is neither a comedian running around in a purple cape like the OT Shredder or an Utrom like 4kids Shredder. He's his own entity bearing more similarities to Mirage or Movie 1 Shredder. He's just not being killed off right away because he brings in sales, most likely.
Not really.
April is a lab assistant working for Baxter's company. Other than her being a little younger (around College age) here than Mirage, she's nothing like the April's from the cartoon.
Etc.? You might elaborate. I can't think of much else.
Stuff like the Second Time Around shop, Stocktronics, April's Van, the Foot being human assassin's.
I am also sure as we progress we'll eventually get to the Triceratons, Leatherhead and Rat King.
Lampy
08-22-2012, 01:42 AM
I don't think I would like that at all, but I suppose it is still a slim possibility. I don't understand why so many people want this to be "more Mirage." It's its own universe and clearly draws on influence from all of the others.
okay... so maybe not that angle. and don't get me wrong... i am still enjoying this series and my only complaint is pacing. mirage-like or not i still like it. i just liked the idea of Turtles not knowing who they are (like the movies) as opposed to trying to be a predetermined persona. if not... then nevermind. i'll still read it.
Bobby Curnow
08-22-2012, 02:18 AM
My two cents:
It's probably impossible for me to be objective, but I'll try my best:
I think we had a successful first year. Certainly in sales, and I think also artistically. We covered a lot of ground, told some fun stories, and threw in some solid curve balls along the way.
That is not to say we delivered a perfect comic. I think we've had some hiccups. The comments on pacing, while up for debate, are fair. There's definite room for improvement there. Working on it. I'm really glad we can do the Micros, I think most would agree they help a lot in that department.
I think we could have handled the wrap up to Shredder intro a little bit better too. I'll argue that Shredder and the Foot were not expecting ANYTHING that happened during that story (Hamato Yoshi reveal, TMNT busting in) and as a result were not prepared and got their asses handed to them a bit. They won't make the same mistake again. Now that Shredder knows what's what, he's going to start playing a long game that should be interesting to watch.
...But at the end of the day, that's making excuses and hiding behind "next time will be better!!" I think our Foot intro could have been more effective, and our execution could have been better. Shredder, and the Foot, deserve better. I think you'll see better.
I'm amused that the "How Mirage is it?!?!?" debate is still going on. I'd have hoped that we'd be done with that by now, but it's fair that almost 30 years of TMNT casts a long shadow. We do strive to incorporate from all iterations (Fugitoid will be playing a big part soon— that's a solid check mark in the Mirage column), but let's face it... if you're going to divide it into percentages, OT has the biggest piece of the pie. That's the Turtles that has the most pop-culture reach AND is the most ripe for re-invention. That's a potent mix, and we'd be silly to ignore it.
But just because we're borrowing ideas from OT doesn't mean we're executing them in any way that's close to resembling OT. We're treating those silly characters seriously, and hopefully doing new and fun things with them. And we'll do that with Mirage and Archie stuff too. But again: the aim is to have it all blend into a hearty IDW soup. I know people want more Mirage. So do I. But... we're just not going to be it, and the sooner that's accepted, the better off you'll be. Original Mirage TMNT was the brainchild of two wildly talented dudes who were able to do something completely new, exactly the way they wanted, without monthly deadlines. That combo is so so so rare, and just plain can't be beat, and I don't think we will. I don't WANT to. Those early Mirage books are perfect. We'll have our own fun though, while remaining in their debt.
That wraps up my opinion. We've got awesome stuff coming up, but I'm quite certain we'll continue to have some missteps too. But we'll keep trying to learn from them. I think a debate like this is good, it keeps us on our toes.
Andrew NDB
08-22-2012, 02:37 AM
This new series is basically a reboot, isn't it?
It's a different publisher doing a different iteration/universe of TMNT. When Archie launched "TMNT Adventures," was that a reboot of Mirage TMNT?
Andrew NDB
08-22-2012, 02:52 AM
My two cents:
It's probably impossible for me to be objective, but I'll try my best:
I think we had a successful first year. Certainly in sales, and I think also artistically. We covered a lot of ground, told some fun stories, and threw in some solid curve balls along the way.
That is not to say we delivered a perfect comic. I think we've had some hiccups. The comments on pacing, while up for debate, are fair. There's definite room for improvement there. Working on it. I'm really glad we can do the Micros, I think most would agree they help a lot in that department.
I think we could have handled the wrap up to Shredder intro a little bit better too. I'll argue that Shredder and the Foot were not expecting ANYTHING that happened during that story (Hamato Yoshi reveal, TMNT busting in) and as a result were not prepared and got their asses handed to them a bit. They won't make the same mistake again. Now that Shredder knows what's what, he's going to start playing a long game that should be interesting to watch.
...But at the end of the day, that's making excuses and hiding behind "next time will be better!!" I think our Foot intro could have been more effective, and our execution could have been better. Shredder, and the Foot, deserve better. I think you'll see better.
I'm amused that the "How Mirage is it?!?!?" debate is still going on. I'd have hoped that we'd be done with that by now, but it's fair that almost 30 years of TMNT casts a long shadow. We do strive to incorporate from all iterations (Fugitoid will be playing a big part soon— that's a solid check mark in the Mirage column), but let's face it... if you're going to divide it into percentages, OT has the biggest piece of the pie. That's the Turtles that has the most pop-culture reach AND is the most ripe for re-invention. That's a potent mix, and we'd be silly to ignore it.
But just because we're borrowing ideas from OT doesn't mean we're executing them in any way that's close to resembling OT. We're treating those silly characters seriously, and hopefully doing new and fun things with them. And we'll do that with Mirage and Archie stuff too. But again: the aim is to have it all blend into a hearty IDW soup. I know people want more Mirage. So do I. But... we're just not going to be it, and the sooner that's accepted, the better off you'll be. Original Mirage TMNT was the brainchild of two wildly talented dudes who were able to do something completely new, exactly the way they wanted, without monthly deadlines. That combo is so so so rare, and just plain can't be beat, and I don't think we will. I don't WANT to. Those early Mirage books are perfect. We'll have our own fun though, while remaining in their debt.
That wraps up my opinion. We've got awesome stuff coming up, but I'm quite certain we'll continue to have some missteps too. But we'll keep trying to learn from them. I think a debate like this is good, it keeps us on our toes.
Sounds fair enough to me.
Lampy
08-22-2012, 03:42 AM
My two cents:
It's probably impossible for me to be objective, but I'll try my best:
I think we had a successful first year. Certainly in sales, and I think also artistically. We covered a lot of ground, told some fun stories, and threw in some solid curve balls along the way.
That is not to say we delivered a perfect comic. I think we've had some hiccups. The comments on pacing, while up for debate, are fair. There's definite room for improvement there. Working on it. I'm really glad we can do the Micros, I think most would agree they help a lot in that department.
I think we could have handled the wrap up to Shredder intro a little bit better too. I'll argue that Shredder and the Foot were not expecting ANYTHING that happened during that story (Hamato Yoshi reveal, TMNT busting in) and as a result were not prepared and got their asses handed to them a bit. They won't make the same mistake again. Now that Shredder knows what's what, he's going to start playing a long game that should be interesting to watch.
...But at the end of the day, that's making excuses and hiding behind "next time will be better!!" I think our Foot intro could have been more effective, and our execution could have been better. Shredder, and the Foot, deserve better. I think you'll see better.
I'm amused that the "How Mirage is it?!?!?" debate is still going on. I'd have hoped that we'd be done with that by now, but it's fair that almost 30 years of TMNT casts a long shadow. We do strive to incorporate from all iterations (Fugitoid will be playing a big part soon— that's a solid check mark in the Mirage column), but let's face it... if you're going to divide it into percentages, OT has the biggest piece of the pie. That's the Turtles that has the most pop-culture reach AND is the most ripe for re-invention. That's a potent mix, and we'd be silly to ignore it.
But just because we're borrowing ideas from OT doesn't mean we're executing them in any way that's close to resembling OT. We're treating those silly characters seriously, and hopefully doing new and fun things with them. And we'll do that with Mirage and Archie stuff too. But again: the aim is to have it all blend into a hearty IDW soup. I know people want more Mirage. So do I. But... we're just not going to be it, and the sooner that's accepted, the better off you'll be. Original Mirage TMNT was the brainchild of two wildly talented dudes who were able to do something completely new, exactly the way they wanted, without monthly deadlines. That combo is so so so rare, and just plain can't be beat, and I don't think we will. I don't WANT to. Those early Mirage books are perfect. We'll have our own fun though, while remaining in their debt.
That wraps up my opinion. We've got awesome stuff coming up, but I'm quite certain we'll continue to have some missteps too. But we'll keep trying to learn from them. I think a debate like this is good, it keeps us on our toes.
awesome two cents!:D you win.
Spitfire
08-22-2012, 04:45 AM
Hard to say I lost interest when there wasn't much to begin with. It's not completely horrid but as a fan it does nothing for me. I'm much more excited by the fact that IDW is re-releasing older stories in trades. A lot of which have never been collected. As long as they keep that up they can do whatever with the main series. I'll support it because they respect us older fans enough to treat the classic material with proper releases. They don't even have to that's the best part.
Plasticplayhouse
08-22-2012, 07:00 AM
overall i'm still enjoying the comic. yeah the pacing was so so in some parts, but like BC said, the micros did a good job improving on that (i love the micros!). i have been and always will be a Mirage TMNT fan first and foremost! all other incarnations of them are secondary to me. from early on i have accepted that THIS comic is not Mirage. i have been very happy with the Mirage homage's that IDW has given us and keeps giving us. those little nods make a big difference to me. it shows me that while their goal is to do something new and make progress long term, they still respect the source and it's fans. they didnt have to do that. Nick owns TMNT now. if they chose to merge TMNT and sponge bob together there's not a damn thing we could do (other than boycott the comic ;) ) i believe lessons are being learned, improvements will be made, and this will continue to be a good comic for quite some time.
imagine that...teenage mutant ninja sponges :lol:
CyberCubed
08-22-2012, 11:25 AM
I'm much more excited by the fact that IDW is re-releasing older stories in trades. A lot of which have never been collected. As long as they keep that up they can do whatever with the main series. I'll support it because they respect us older fans enough to treat the classic material with proper releases. They don't even have to that's the best part.
This is a good point too. IDW is respecting the old material by consistently pumping out Mirage trades when in reality they didn't even have to.
I think in the next few years it'll be pretty amazing to have most of the Mirage run collected and re-released, and if we're really lucky we'll get up to Image and Volume 4 as well.
Andrew NDB
08-22-2012, 11:32 AM
This is a good point too. IDW is respecting the old material by consistently pumping out Mirage trades when in reality they didn't even have to.
While I love the hell out of the Mirage trade program they're pumping out... let's not all pretend IDW is just doing it for simply altruistic reasons. Before IDW won the publishing deal for TMNT there were other publishers more than happy -- even eager -- to reprint the Mirage material. In fact, for Dark Horse that was like the main thing that interested them, slamming all the Mirage comics into their omnibus program posthaste.
IDW would be foolish not to get that stuff out there.
CyberCubed
08-22-2012, 12:06 PM
Yes, but its win/win. IDW wants $$$$ by reprinting old comics with little production costs, and the fans get the collections we've always wanted for years.
IDW:
http://i.qkme.me/355ft6.jpg
Jephael
08-22-2012, 02:58 PM
It's a different publisher doing a different iteration/universe of TMNT. When Archie launched "TMNT Adventures," was that a reboot of Mirage TMNT?
Oh yea, I didn't think about that. Silly me.:twink:
Matches Malone
08-22-2012, 03:55 PM
It's a different publisher doing a different iteration/universe of TMNT. When Archie launched "TMNT Adventures," was that a reboot of Mirage TMNT?
While true, there are some rebootish qualities to the IDW series. With Archie and DreamWave, they were their own universes, yes, but they were also spinoffs and tie-ins to successful animated tv shows. With the Mirage universe winding down with the sale and Laird's waning interest, this new IDW series definitely launched with the intention of reinvigorating TMNT's popularity and success by "starting over." Of course it has been said that this was also done to respect what came before them, which is fair too, but I don't think it would be out of place to call the IDW series a reboot.
CyberCubed
08-22-2012, 08:51 PM
The IDW series definitely qualifies for a reboot. This is the first time since 1984 that the comics have had a serious restart.
Obviously Archie TMNT Adventures doesn't count as it was a spinoff of the cartoon. The IDW series is basically like the reboots of Spiderman/Batman, etc. that have happened over the years.
I am pretty sure if/when Peter Laird ever finishes Volume 4...then that'll be it, the Mirage universe will be done.
Samhain
08-22-2012, 10:25 PM
Why do you keep saying that? We have a handful of OT characters (Krang, Bebop/Rocksteady and Traag's Rock Soldiers), a 4kids character (Angel and arguably this version of Karai), an Archie character (Slash is mostly associated with the Archie series), and Mirage influence for Shredder/Baxter/April, etc.
Seriously, WTF are you making a big deal out of nothing?
I would much rather have a bunch of brand new characters created by Eastman than ''re-imagined'' OT characters.
Slade
08-22-2012, 10:31 PM
So far I've been sticking with it. I have slight concerns, but nothing to major. Who knows I may hate what's coming, or I may love it. It's been said before, but these do read way better as TPB's.
Bauer536
08-22-2012, 10:46 PM
Obviously Archie TMNT Adventures doesn't count as it was a spinoff of the cartoon. The IDW series is basically like the reboots of Spiderman/Batman, etc. that have happened over the years.
Oh no. This does not feel like the reboots I've seen with Spider-man or Batman. Batman still has both parents die, and Spider-Man (which I've seen from the new film) is still bitten by this radioactive spider. There's no way this TMNT storyline fits into those worlds. You know why? Because if it did follow their worlds, the turtles wouldn't be reincarnated. The turtles would be going through the same thing Nickelodeon has for us on television: infant mutation on animals who are not Yoshi's sons. Ciro Nieli seems to know what he's doing considering he's made a few changes on other things. Still, the turtles are turtles. This whole reincarnation idea has made the turtles seem less iconic this time. It wasn't needed. I said it before, and I'll say it again. Just like Peter Laird, I feel this new idea is a cop out. There are always other ideas out there that can be done as changes without altering so much to the origin. So far, this one Waltz gave us isn't cutting it anymore. Why do you guys still like it? Some of you hated the fact that the turtles could have possibly been aliens in the new movie, but yet, you don't hate this? I think once a story based on these IDW comics is released as a film, there will be people who hate it because of what has been done so far. Don't agree with me? That's fine. But I just don't get it. This reincarnation thing ruins the franchise.
TheCanadiandrome
08-22-2012, 10:57 PM
I'm loving the comics! I want em all!
CyberCubed
08-22-2012, 11:12 PM
Oh no. This does not feel like the reboots I've seen with Spider-man or Batman. Batman still has both parents die, and Spider-Man (which I've seen from the new film) is still bitten by this radioactive spider. There's no way this TMNT storyline fits into those worlds.
Do you have any clue what a reboot is? It takes a property that has been around for a while and restarts it, using familiar characters but in different ways.
There are what...nearly 20 versions of Batman out there now with all comics, cartoons, and movies combined? Each one can technically be a reboot.
I would much rather have a bunch of brand new characters created by Eastman than ''re-imagined'' OT characters.
Eastman created Alopex.
Bauer536
08-22-2012, 11:16 PM
Do you have any clue what a reboot is? It takes a property that has been around for a while and restarts it, using familiar characters but in different ways.
There are what...nearly 20 versions of Batman out there now with all comics, cartoons, and movies combined? Each one can technically be a reboot.
And you think that's always okay? I don't know. If they changed any of my favorite characters into morons or jerks, that is unacceptable change. My philosophy: stay true to the original origins by adding something new to it, and never change the person that makes the character. You can't say, "Oh! It's Green Hornet!," and he's acting like a bufoon played by Seth Rogen. It's like, "Let's make Captain America without the buff body, and he'll just be a skinny little man who can run fast." That's not Captain America. "Let's make Peter Parker discover he's a reincarnated spider who was born to use his powers in the next life." That's not Spider-Man. "Let's not kill Bruce Wayne's parents, but yet let's still make him Batman." That's not Batman. "Let's have Superman actually be a human that gets this Wolverine treatment who's been getting these powers from a power plant explosion. We don't need Jor-El." That's NOT Superman. If you can't come up with a way to keep the origins the same with a few twists and turns, there is no reason to reboot the franchise. It's better off creating a new superhero group or something like TMNT, which was an original idea by Eastman and Laird, and not a complete copy of Daredevil. If the turtles are reincarnated, to me, they're not the turtles. It should have been done with something else, not the TMNT. You see what I mean?
Slade
08-22-2012, 11:22 PM
My philosophy: stay true to the original origins by adding something new to it, and never change the person that makes the character.
Not to but in here, but that's what IDW did..sorta. Turtles are still infant mutated by ooze along with Splinter. The adding something new is the reincarnation aspect.
CyberCubed
08-22-2012, 11:25 PM
My philosophy: stay true to the original origins by adding something new to it, and never change the person that makes the character.
If you don't like the reincarnation aspect you could just ignore it. As the series progresses it'll be less focused on their origins but on the stories being told afterward.
Samhain
08-23-2012, 12:55 AM
Eastman created Alopex.
True, but a mutant Artic fox isn't exactly my cup of tea. Don't even know her story yet, but I'm sure we will, in 3 to 5 years.
Toby Barrett
08-23-2012, 06:44 AM
You see what I mean?
I see you're strongly afraid of change.
jaymq
08-23-2012, 06:59 AM
Nope. Still enjoying it. As I have most, if not all, the major universes as there is always something I like about them. It also helps I don't tend to compare each new series to it's predecessors.
thelouisguy
08-23-2012, 08:19 AM
I have always put the Mirage comics on a pedestal and have always thought of them as my favorite representation of the Turtles. Every time the Turtles stories are retold or altered, I am worried that they will be butchered. But I have to give it to IDW. They have done a fantastic job this past year. If this series continues for a second and third year the way it has in the first, I could easily say the IDW Turtles are my favorite iteration ever!
I have been doing comparison pieces which originally started comparing Mirage to IDW, but have grown to include Fred Wolf and other versions as all Turtle Universes are influencing the IDW comics. http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=37259
Keep up the great work and here's to another great year!
CyberCubed
08-23-2012, 12:32 PM
True, but a mutant Artic fox isn't exactly my cup of tea. Don't even know her story yet, but I'm sure we will, in 3 to 5 years.
So in other words, you just don't like animal mutants in the comics.
Repeat after me, "This is NOT Mirage." IDW doesn't have to go by Mirage's "rules" of no other mutants and pointless characters like Mr. Braunze, the Justice Force, a Jewish Golem, cat creatures and other one-shot nonsense characters people don't give a second thought to.
Its so funny that because IDW is another serious comic not based on one of the cartoons, you think they have to do what Mirage did.
To be honest most of the Mirage-created characters, outside of the big ones like Baxter/Leatherhead/Rat King/Karai, etc....are some of the worst TMNT characters ever created. When nobody can remember who the hell Mr. Braunze was despite being the driving force of Volume 2, we have a problem.
Powder
08-23-2012, 02:32 PM
Way to take a comment and turn it into a completely different thing. Maybe he's just not a fan of characters who are... dare I say, generic.
Panda_Kahn_fan
08-23-2012, 06:44 PM
Generic is a point of view. I personally find a time traveling valley girl, a cyborg turtle, worm clone shredder, a bunch of dumb justice league and avengers knockoffs, April actually being a drawing, a rat king whose actually dead for most of his appearances, and a whole race of anthropomorphic Triceratops when we're told we can't have more mutants, generic.
And I don't get why so many wish to slavishly retread "City at war" and those first few mirage tales over and over again in different media until the end of time. Why is it every time there is a new comic, movie, or cartoon, Mirage Purists INSIST that any addition of a Fred wolf character will be the DEATH of the Turtles, and ANY deviation from the original comics will destroy TMNT as we know them? Characters CAN be re-invented to be more complex and compelling! Just look as Mister Zero, a goofy character introduced in the silver age Batman comics. He was re-invented as the dangerous and Tragic Mr. Freeze, one of Batman's best villains. It's ridiculous to think a character ctrated as goofy couldn't be re-imagined as a much darker and more interesting character!
Samhain
08-23-2012, 06:44 PM
So in other words, you just don't like animal mutants in the comics.
Repeat after me, "This is NOT Mirage." IDW doesn't have to go by Mirage's "rules" of no other mutants and pointless characters like Mr. Braunze, the Justice Force, a Jewish Golem, cat creatures and other one-shot nonsense characters people don't give a second thought to.
Its so funny that because IDW is another serious comic not based on one of the cartoons, you think they have to do what Mirage did.
To be honest most of the Mirage-created characters, outside of the big ones like Baxter/Leatherhead/Rat King/Karai, etc....are some of the worst TMNT characters ever created. When nobody can remember who the hell Mr. Braunze was despite being the driving force of Volume 2, we have a problem.
I constantly see you making comments into something else. You really should quit that. 80s toon lovers rejoice, this is what the Idw comic is. I'm not saying it's a bad thing, just not for me.
Donnie
08-23-2012, 07:29 PM
I would much rather have a bunch of brand new characters created by Eastman than ''re-imagined'' OT characters.
Don't you think that's a little harsh, though? These Turtles have a background story that far surpasses the OT origin by leaps and bounds. They and their father get freakin' decapitated, and their mother is slain. The IDW Turtles are in ways unique; not only by origin but also in characterization...they borrow more from the 4Kids than the OT in terms of personalities.
I really think the overabundance of OT characters entering the story is throwing people off to the fact that there are unique qualities that belong only to the IDW TMNT, thus in my opinion making it a great and interesting series.
CyberCubed
08-23-2012, 07:51 PM
I constantly see you making comments into something else. You really should quit that. 80s toon lovers rejoice, this is what the Idw comic is. I'm not saying it's a bad thing, just not for me.
So then what exactly do you want? What kind of characters do you want to see?
I already gave you an example of an Eastman created character. What type of characters would you want otherwise? And I am also not seeing why you think a handful of OT characters showing up is bad. For goodness sakes, Bebop/Rocksteady haven't even reappeared since their debut issue!
Samhain
08-23-2012, 08:55 PM
So then what exactly do you want? What kind of characters do you want to see?
I already gave you an example of an Eastman created character. What type of characters would you want otherwise? And I am also not seeing why you think a handful of OT characters showing up is bad. For goodness sakes, Bebop/Rocksteady haven't even reappeared since their debut issue!
Doesn't really matter what I want to see. I don't like all the OT characters being thrown in the book because I just can't take some characters seriously. Alopex is goofy and reminds me too much of Ninjara. Bebop and Rocksteady may be really super duper cool in the book, but all I will see is the 2 idiots from the FW toon. Also the fact that Idw is putting these characters in the book only to pull at the nostalgia nipples of every person out there, instead of trying something completely new.
At first the small nods to the OT were fine. I could take it. But now I'm half expecting for April to get a reporting job at the end of her Micro, due out next week.
CyberCubed
08-23-2012, 09:06 PM
At first the small nods to the OT were fine. I could take it. But now I'm half expecting for April to get a reporting job at the end of her Micro, due out next week.
No. We have stuff like the Second Time Around shop and you seem to ignore it, simply because its Mirage stuff.
Krang will obviously work well for a few reasons:
- He's obviously more menacing than he was in the OT. The Rock Warriors are shown killing the Neutrinos.
- Krang is based on the Utroms, so an evil alien brain falls in line with Mirage.
- He and Shredder appear to be rivals/enemies in this version, which is a refreshing take on the character.
Other than that, you definitely seem to have a problem with animal mutants in the comics. Alopex reminding you of Ninjara is one thing but since Ninjara is not an OT character I don't know why you would consider that close to an OT reference, same with Slash as he's more associated with the Archie series.
Samhain
08-23-2012, 09:14 PM
Thanks Jeebus for the second time around shop!:roll:
rx781a
08-23-2012, 09:15 PM
i for one ove the IDW series and their fresh take on TMNT.
CyberCubed
08-23-2012, 09:24 PM
Thanks Jeebus for the second time around shop!:roll:
My point is what Mirage references/homages there are, you just ignore them and act like there is endless OT stuff being shoved down our throats, when in reality there's very little.
The whole last 5 issues were almost all Mirage and slightly 4kids based.
Heather Breckel
08-23-2012, 09:25 PM
At first the small nods to the OT were fine. I could take it. But now I'm half expecting for April to get a reporting job at the end of her Micro, due out next week.
You have nothing to worry about.
Samhain
08-23-2012, 09:43 PM
You have nothing to worry about.
That's good to hear.
Kevin G
08-23-2012, 10:06 PM
Looking forward to the Micro Series April comic. I am dying to know who or what that thing is behind her:
FoxZerro
08-24-2012, 09:36 AM
"Let's make Peter Parker discover he's a reincarnated spider who was born to use his powers in the next life." That's not Spider-Man.
I don't know if you were joking or being facetious when you wrote this, but this has happened in Spiderman, during the whole the Other storyline/crossover event.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spider-Man:_The_Other
With that in mind considering it is canon and Spiderman died and was reborn. Apparently that is Spiderman
pannoni1
08-24-2012, 10:52 AM
Looking forward to the Micro Series April comic. I am dying to know who or what that thing is behind her:
It seems like April's eyes fluctuate from green in issue #13 to blue on that micro-series cover. I have a feeling that person behind April is threatening to either grab the mutagen from her and/or even kidnap her. And while I'm not paying too much attention to the IDW series currently, focusing on all of those OT recaps and some other great stuff, I feel that the best part of the series is yet to come, especially with the current arc where the ultimate fate of the Shredder/Splinter struggle will result in some dramatic scenes. I'm glad the Old Hob arc is behind us, and there is great TMNT stuff coming in all directions, I may struggle to keep track with all these different incarnations at once!
Bauer536
08-24-2012, 11:08 AM
I don't know if you were joking or being facetious when you wrote this, but this has happened in Spiderman, during the whole the Other storyline/crossover event.
http://http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spider-Man:_The_Other
With that in mind considering it is canon and Spiderman died and was reborn. Apparently that is Spiderman
I couldn't get the link, but it seems that he died, but somehow came back to life, am I right?:tconfuse: I'm sorry. The reason why I mentioned an alternate version of Spider-Man wasn't a joke. I thought I heard Peter Laird talking about an alternate origin for Spider-Man when he was talking about reincarnation in the IDW TMNT comics.:toops: That's why I mentioned it.
FoxZerro
08-24-2012, 11:26 AM
I couldn't get the link, but it seems that he died, but somehow came back to life, am I right?:tconfuse: I'm sorry. The reason why I mentioned an alternate version of Spider-Man wasn't a joke. I thought I heard Peter Laird talking about an alternate origin for Spider-Man when he was talking about reincarnation in the IDW TMNT comics.:toops: That's why I mentioned it.
Link is now fixed,my bad doubled the http. Yeah he dies and comes back to life after being told his life was saved by an outside force that wants him to embrace spider side of being spiderman and not just the man side. Ends with him having to confront the other worldly force. Its a pretty whacked out concept overall and kinda stupid when you boil it down.
No disrespect meant at all man, in fact the fact that you said it without knowing about it is kind of awesome. Especially since you referenced it as a horrible idea and it already happened :tgrin::tcry::tgrin::tcry:
Bauer536
08-24-2012, 11:54 AM
Link is now fixed,my bad doubled the http. Yeah he dies and comes back to life after being told his life was saved by an outside force that wants him to embrace spider side of being spiderman and not just the man side. Ends with him having to confront the other worldly force. Its a pretty whacked out concept overall and kinda stupid when you boil it down.
No disrespect meant at all man, in fact the fact that you said it without knowing about it is kind of awesome. Especially since you referenced it as a horrible idea and it already happened :tgrin::tcry::tgrin::tcry:
Okay. I found it. Interesting. So it's not exactly a change of origin, but rather a rebirth after getting "killed.":twink: Gotcha! So, yeah. It is Spider-Man.:toops:
I'm glad you gave me the synopsis of this. Thanks. Just to let you know, reasons like this make me avoid comic books in today's day and age. Right now, I just stick to movies and TV. Though they can be sort of crazy with their hero adaptations, they're not as bad. I can sometimes accept them.:twink:
FoxZerro
08-24-2012, 01:37 PM
I'm glad you gave me the synopsis of this. Thanks. Just to let you know, reasons like this make me avoid comic books in today's day and age. Right now, I just stick to movies and TV. Though they can be sort of crazy with their hero adaptations, they're not as bad. I can sometimes accept them.:twink:
You really want to hate adaptations in the modern age, just look up Spiderman: India on Wikipedia. I'm sad to say I own every issue. Though bad as it was I'm thankful I read it because it was the eye opener I needed to what is happening in modern comics
Allio
08-24-2012, 01:51 PM
I haven't really lost interest, I mean I'm only on issue eight (only collecting those four issue trades... what's the term) it's alright so far
Samhain
08-30-2012, 10:47 PM
Why do you keep saying that? We have a handful of OT characters (Krang, Bebop/Rocksteady and Traag's Rock Soldiers), a 4kids character (Angel and arguably this version of Karai), an Archie character (Slash is mostly associated with the Archie series), and Mirage influence for Shredder/Baxter/April, etc.
Seriously, WTF are you making a big deal out of nothing?
Here's what you said in the Donny Micro thread.
The series can't rely on old-toon homages forever.
Sometimes I feel like IDW is aiming this series at people who only watched the old show and never picked up a Mirage comic.
So, did you lose your left or right flip-flop?:roll:
CyberCubed
08-30-2012, 11:43 PM
So, did you lose your left or right flip-flop?:roll:
That was half a year ago before things got more balanced out. At that time we didn't even know Karai was going to appear so soon.
corvus
08-31-2012, 01:31 AM
This thread was posted at the end of the first big arc. Of course some people are gonna lose interest if the next story doesn't immediately grab their attention. I feel that sins of the father is going to fail to do that however blood brothers, which seems to begin during the April micro is doing just that. Slash is grabbing everyone's attention from what I've seen. I personally keep reading because of the Baxter Krang bit. I'm really curious.
Kendamu
08-31-2012, 01:46 AM
I certainly haven't lost interest. I don't tend to sit around eagerly awaiting each release with baited breath, but I do grab a digital copy of the new stuff as it comes out and I do enjoy it enough to let the guys at IDW know via Twitter what I think.
Samhain
08-31-2012, 04:01 AM
That was half a year ago before things got more balanced out. At that time we didn't even know Karai was going to appear so soon.
I don't think 'balanced' is the right word when trying to describe Idw's Tmnt.
I certainly haven't lost interest. I don't tend to sit around eagerly awaiting each release with baited breath, but I do grab a digital copy of the new stuff as it comes out and I do enjoy it enough to let the guys at IDW know via Twitter what I think.
And this pretty much sums up my opinion on this. I still get the book every month, but I just not eagerly waiting for it, like I am with other comics at the moment. And that makes me a bit sad. I like this book. But I don't love it. I want to, but I don't.
Vegeta
08-31-2012, 04:11 AM
As much as I love the IDW series..(it got me back into tmnt) the characters still really don't feel fleshed out. I agree with the few people that mentioned this. I feel outside of the microseries their personalities aren't strikingly different. Raphael was always my favorite turtle but he doesn't seem to be a hothead/wisecracker or really much of anything but a slight outsider in the first few issues because he wasn't with his family. The leo and donnie rivarly also makes no sense to me...but that is probably because I am looking back to previous turtle books. I also find casey jones/april boring in this. I prefer casey to be a little edgier and less of a high school drama story.
Part of the problem with the pacing is the books are just so short. Issue 13's letter section was nearly as big as the comic. How long did the splinter kidnapping thing last? Half a year? This is slow even for comics standards. Still love the book though. Just wish it was a little more exciting. I love eastman's covers though. Issue 12 was gorgeous :)
thelouisguy
08-31-2012, 06:52 AM
The series can't rely on old-toon homages forever.
Sometimes I feel like IDW is aiming this series at people who only watched the old show and never picked up a Mirage comic.
So, did you lose your left or right flip-flop?:roll:
They are heavily influenced by the Mirage comics. You should read my IDW/Mirage comparison reviews and you will be surprised.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=37259
EDIT: And no, I have not lost interest in this series, with a little more time, it could become my favorite iteration of the Turtles (Mirage comics are currently my favorite).
Powder
08-31-2012, 03:12 PM
Man, you plug your website in like every post you make... C'mon.
Cowabunga Carl
08-31-2012, 03:44 PM
They are heavily influenced by the Mirage comics. You should read my IDW/Mirage comparison reviews and you will be surprised.
http://www.crossovercomics.ca/category/blog/return-to-the-sewers/
EDIT: And no, I have not lost interest in this series, with a little more time, it could become my favorite iteration of the Turtles (Mirage comics are currently my favorite).
Wait you have a website?:o Really? And you compare the IDW to Mirage? No way! :trolleye:
I still am loving this series. It is going on strong still. The only thing that bothers me is Kuhn's art.
corvus
08-31-2012, 03:50 PM
Wait you have a website?:o Really? And you compare the IDW to Mirage? No way! :trolleye:
I still am loving this series. It is going on strong still. The only thing that bothers me is Kuhn's art.
Who did the art for the April micro again? They should be the new artist.
thelouisguy
08-31-2012, 07:37 PM
Man, you plug your website in like every post you make... C'mon.
I meant to link to the thread.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=37259
Also, many people ask about the Mirage influence and most of the time, that is what they are looking for. I try to only link to it when it is relavent. I have posted the entire contents of my reviews in the thread and they do not need to click.through to the website.
I am just really excited about the IDW series and am happy to have a fresh take on the Turtles to read.
The Purple Dragon
09-07-2012, 12:06 PM
no but i start to get tired of all the variant covers,i think idw coued have done thinks diffrent like i see a some people complaining on the color classic being color(first dont complain you b&w people got the ultimate collection and i cant wait to get passed issue 11 since thae have not been in color before)
now i think idw woued have earn on it on the long run if they hade keept it more simple with just 2 covers one in color and one b&w so if you did buy the b&w cover the book was b&w and if you did buy it in color the book was in color i think this ide hade been good on both the ultimate collection and color classic etc. and everybody woued be happy
hell i think it coued been cool on the ongoing series aswell wath does you guys think of this???
Cowabunga Carl
09-07-2012, 12:49 PM
I'm not sure how people are getting bored with this series. I mean the team has constantly brought their A game each and every issue. They have gotten amazing writers and artist for mini issues, and it looks like they have a lot more coming. I'd love this series to keep going for as long as it can. It is always fun to see different takes. I mean even if I don't like everything going on it is a great new take on a favorite part of my life.
Plasticplayhouse
09-07-2012, 12:52 PM
Who did the art for the April micro again? They should be the new artist.
i didnt care for the art in the april issue all that much. i liked how they drew april but that was about it. i would prefer McCaffrey, the guy who just did fugitoid. i loved his stuff, but he lives abroad (in france i believe) so i dont know how that would play out.
thelouisguy
09-07-2012, 01:08 PM
Reading the Fugitoid issue makes me want to go back and reread the entire series again! They are at their best right now! I do not know how you could be losing interest?!
BentonGrey
09-07-2012, 02:08 PM
Wow...ha, it never ceases to amaze me how much importance folks place on the bandanna colors...ha...anyway, I definitely haven't lost interest. As a matter of fact, I introduced a good friend to this book recently, and he loved it just as much as I do. Reading it along with him lead me to appreciate it even more. This is one of the best books being put out, and I can't wait for each new issue!
This isn't Mirage, this isn't the Fred Wolf Toon, this is something new, a chance to do what Batman: TAS did, to pick from the best, most interesting elements of a wealth of interpretations, and create something really cool.
CyberCubed
09-07-2012, 07:45 PM
This thread was posted before the April and Fugitoid issues came out so it's safe to say people's interest has been rekindled.
When Krang's plot gains full steam I'll be quite excited to see how it plays out.
natecm
09-11-2012, 03:31 PM
Exactly. Again, I don't see the point of worrying about bandana color. But I guess 'to each his own'.
I can see the point about liking the all red for nostalgia sake, but I have to admit it's so much easier to read w/ the 4 color set up.
Powder
09-11-2012, 03:40 PM
I can see the point about liking the all red for nostalgia sake, but I have to admit it's so much easier to read w/ the 4 color set up.
Bull, they each have different colored skin & different weapons. If that's not enough for you, well, you've got bigger problems.
Noah13
09-11-2012, 03:43 PM
Bull, they each have different colored skin & different weapons. If that's not enough for you, well, you've got bigger problems.
You shouldn't judge someone based off the colour of their skin
Jephael
09-11-2012, 03:58 PM
they each have different colored skin & different weapons. If that's not enough for you, well, you've got bigger problems.
You shouldn't judge someone based off the colour of their skin
You shouldn't judge anyone... PERIOD!!!
BentonGrey
09-11-2012, 03:58 PM
Ha! Yeah, the obsession with the red masks never made any sense to me. Sure, it's cool in a nostalgic sense, but it simply doesn't work as well when you're talking about visual story-telling in color. The Turtles' aren't always colored consistently, skin-wise, and if they don't happen to be holding their weapons, you can't tell them apart. Plus, even when the Turtles ARE colored consistently, the differences are fairly subtle. Going back and reading the original series, I was often at a loss for who was saying what, even with the aid of color. I mean, come on, these are comics, they tell stories visually. If you have four characters that, in many scenes are indistinguishable from one-another, that creates narrative difficulty.
Candy Kappa
09-11-2012, 04:10 PM
Sure it is only nostalgia with the red masks, no nostalgia at all with colored masks, technodrome, B&R, Krang... Oh wait.
I did not have any issue seeing the differences between the turtles in the IDW series, its a very strange attitude to want more color coding, when they have different skin tone and attitude. it's a very easy McDonald junk food approach.
Toby Barrett
09-11-2012, 04:44 PM
http://i108.photobucket.com/albums/n35/barrett_toby/1286054089085.jpg
BentonGrey
09-11-2012, 06:07 PM
Sure it is only nostalgia with the red masks, no nostalgia at all with colored masks, technodrome, B&R, Krang... Oh wait.
I did not have any issue seeing the differences between the turtles in the IDW series, its a very strange attitude to want more color coding, when they have different skin tone and attitude. it's a very easy McDonald junk food approach.
Hah, of course those things are nostalgic! I certainly wouldn't argue otherwise, but that doesn't mean that the red masks work well in colored comics. Some people prefer red masks, and that's fine, but let's be honest with one another. The red masks are no more functionally superior to other interpretations than the Fred Wolf cartoon was superior in writing quality to Shakespeare. The fact that this is the way their creators intended them to be counts for a lot, but it doesn't mean that the designs or stories necessarily function best with red masks.
Don't misunderstand me. I'm not arguing for the superiority of the Fred Wolf cartoon, or for red, blue, orange, and purple. I'm just pointing out that it is difficult to differentiate between nearly identical character designs, especially when you are working in a visual medium. You say they have different skin tones and attitudes? Well, that's true in some books, not in others, and like I said, the skin tone differentiation can be pretty subtle. Sometimes it is flat out nonexistent. I've got colored versions of the original comics, and while I love them, they aren't always super easy to follow, characterization-wise. In the early issues the Turtles aren't super well defined anyway, and while the seeds of who these characters would eventually become are there, the differences between Raphael and Michelangelo are, at first blush, primarily connected to their weaponry. When there is a talking Turtle head in a panel, as often as not it's next to impossible to figure out who's speaking if you take that panel by itself. Heck, sometimes its a problem even in a full body shot. Now, Eastman and Laird are excellent storytellers, so you can usually figure it out through context, but not always. Either way, those types of narrative gymnastics hurt the flow of a story. This is a problem that the red masks don't do much to alleviate.
These types of things certainly don't ruin the comics, and the Mirage books are still my favorite interpretations in that medium (though IDW is making headway!). However, it's a minor annoyance that could so very easily be avoided that I simply have a hard time understanding people's bitterness about any attempt to avoid it.
Jephael
09-11-2012, 08:50 PM
I couldn't have said it any better myself, kind sir. Lets face it, people, despite how we each feel about our favorite iterations, there is no right or wrong version! No incarnation trumps another one. The original Mirage books may be the source material that started it all, but that doesn't make them any more or less special than the cartoons or movies. In my opinion, that is what the IDW writers are trying to convey with their interpretation!
Icegaze
09-18-2012, 08:15 AM
From the few previews alone and issue 13 that I read on the TMNT app, I love what IDW did with the following charactera:
- April O'neil
- Splinter (I heard about some reincarnation thing going on... hmm, I don't know for now but it could turn out nice)
- The Shredder (badass incarnate)
- Karai (hottest version)
I still don't know what I think of the turtles. Raphael seems to be the main focus out of the 4. I don't know why media today see the "brash, hot-head" as the most "main hero" worthy type. Leo's way of speaking isn't as refined as I would expect someone as polite/cool-headed would sound like. He says things like "you alright, man"; "I wanna". lol Whut?
Anyway, I can't wait to get my hands on the comics because despite having dowloaded the digital app, I'm still unable to read any of the IDW issues..
I made a thread about that here: http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=39231
CyberCubed
10-18-2013, 11:46 PM
This is an old thread, but I'd rather bump this one then make a new one about the same thing.
Honestly my interest in IDW has slipped over the past few months, and I'm not sure why. I'm still buying the book of course, but I'm not as excited about it as I was around a year ago.
I guess the reason I liked it more in 2011 and most of 2012 was because it was our only fix of new TMNT stories at the time because the Nick show hadn't started yet. But now that it has I just feel indifferent to the comic.
I'll continue following it however.
Interesting... I read through the first half of IDW at one sit, then I started following it. What I think is, the first half was nice, but recent stories like SHotFC and City Fall easily kick them in the ass, considering quality.
So for me, it's much better right now then before.
Cipher
10-19-2013, 01:08 PM
Interesting... I read through the first half of IDW at one sit, then I started following it. What I think is, the first half was nice, but recent stories like SHotFC and City Fall easily kick them in the ass, considering quality.
So for me, it's much better right now then before.
Quite the opposite for me. I miss the energy and verve it had at the beginning of the series, when it really seemed like anything could happen and before it devolved into a series of winking rehashes and Saturday morning cartoon plots.
That said -- 1) I read everything prior to #21 in trade format first, so that may affect the way I view it, and 2) This last issue was a significant step up, in my mind, and if it sets the tone for the next few stories more than the first half of "City Fall," I'll be pretty excited again.
Yorae
10-19-2013, 10:21 PM
I started reading the IDW comics casually and wasn't that into the reincarnation origin, but as the main story and micro stories carried on, I find myself now totally immersed in the IDW universe and very much enjoying it.
Its the Nick toon that I'm losing interest in if anything.
Coola Yagami
10-19-2013, 10:36 PM
You must have a short attention span, or must not like to read much. The series is only getting better from here. We got Bebop and Rocksteady getting into this and the eventual moment whenever Casey finds out his dad is Hun. Plus the fallout of evil Leo. It's just getting better and better.
CyberCubed
10-19-2013, 10:50 PM
I started reading the IDW comics casually and wasn't that into the reincarnation origin, but as the main story and micro stories carried on, I find myself now totally immersed in the IDW universe and very much enjoying it.
Its the Nick toon that I'm losing interest in if anything.
Its the exact opposite for me. I think Cipher says it best above.
Plasticplayhouse
10-19-2013, 10:51 PM
I like it even better now than before :)
Redeemer
10-19-2013, 11:37 PM
I started reading the IDW comics casually and wasn't that into the reincarnation origin, but as the main story and micro stories carried on, I find myself now totally immersed in the IDW universe and very much enjoying it.
Its the Nick toon that I'm losing interest in if anything.
Interesting... I read through the first half of IDW at one sit, then I started following it. What I think is, the first half was nice, but recent stories like SHotFC and City Fall easily kick them in the ass, considering quality.
So for me, it's much better right now then before.
Totally agree with you guys I am really enjoying the stories and I cant get enough of it.
I can only say there was one issue I did not like and that was the prequal to City Fall #21 I believe??
This is an old thread lol What a difference time can make and peoples opinions very well could have changed.
Slade
10-20-2013, 12:48 AM
Think a while back I posted no, I wasn't. Today though, well yeah, I kinda am. That may be because of this new job I have, I don't have as much time to ride by and pick my books up, so when I get them, I may not even read them. So, I can't say it's a story problem, just more of a lack of time to sit down and actually read.
Powder
10-20-2013, 03:37 AM
I'll admit I'm not as excited as I once was, but I'm still very interested in what's to come.
Vicky82
10-20-2013, 04:22 AM
I've never read the Mirage and Archie series but have read all about them.
I love reading the IDW series, I'm getting the trade paperbacks as it's easier for me. i've read up to Vol 5 and got Vol 6 City Fall Part 1 and the Villian Micro Series on pre order. I can't wait to read them.
Shark_Blade
10-20-2013, 04:48 AM
@title: No, are you crazy?
It's getting better and better.
Oculus Orbus
10-20-2013, 08:27 AM
The whole reincarnation thing still upsets me a big deal and made me lose interest during the first year or so, but overall I'm now liking the series better, mainly due to Santolouco.
I feel the opposite on the reincernation, it's the most important element that sets IDW apart from other TMNT versions, and it also has a lot of potential in storytelling, because you can always introduce new things from the past, which ones gonna shape the present, and due to the reincernation thing it won't feel that detached or out of the blue.
Like how it happened with Kitsune. Her inclusion was probably not planned since day one, but still, her role in Shredder's past doesn't feels like a cheap and forced retcon they had to do to advance the story.
Plus, one thing I always liked about the reincernation, is that it still keeps the origin story as kinda "ridicolous". With Splinter and the turtles reborn, and remembering the past, remembering the martial arts, that makes it more logical, but at the same time they are "reincernated feudal ninjas in anthropromorph mutant animal form, and they fights against a feudal ninja lord, who wants to take over New York, and made immortal using a technology by interdimensional aliens". So the backstory is still a lot a madness. :)
CyberCubed
10-20-2013, 08:04 PM
I think a problem is we still don't know these Turtles that well. We really only like them based on their previous incarnations, but if this was the first Turtle universe ever...they really haven't delved into their personalities and individual quirks that much.
That's why we really need another round of micros for each Turtle. The first ones did wonders.
ProphetofGanja
10-20-2013, 09:55 PM
I think a problem is we still don't know these Turtles that well. We really only like them based on their previous incarnations, but if this was the first Turtle universe ever...they really haven't delved into their personalities and individual quirks that much.
That's why we really need another round of micros for each Turtle. The first ones did wonders.
I think if you read all 48 issues in IDW's continuity that have come out so far you start to get a pretty good feel of who each turtle is and what their personality is like. I dunno, its not like I can erase the turtles from my head and read all these comics with a fresh start, so maybe not.
I do agree that another round of micros for the turtles would be great, maybe do them in pairs. Leo/Raph, Raph/Don, Don/Mikey, Mikey/Leo, Raph/Mikey, Don/Leo. that's only six issues, so maybe throw in an April/Casey issue and one with Splinter and all the turtles, going out and doing something. that'd be cool.
marcelangelo
10-21-2013, 09:46 AM
I am commenting on this thread because I have experienced this feeling with the idw turtles repeatedly so far...in between I get the issues(I have a standing order for the ongoing and the micros but sometimes it takes a little longer until the books reach me..(besides ONGOING is a pretty stupid term in my oppinion..thats what I EXPECT when I am following a SERIES..isnt it obvious?I feel like this is just another trend in the scene..didnt see that term in the past)
however, although I get the books together with a whole variety on other books I dont really feel any excitement, an urge to open the idw tmnt books and read them from the get go...to me on a whole this book now feels like its a superhero title from the big ones..where you have a whole tradition and a cast and the writers and artists just have to pick from the established and reform what HAS BEEN DONE before.it doesnt feel like the book could venture out and experience any adventures anymore.that anything is possible, you know?at least to me...dont get me wrong here:there are also issues that I read and I am very pleased with them.for instance the baxter stockman micro with the flyborg monster was really fun to me.I like the care that tom waltz and the others lay into weaving on that huge carpet, too;)...but just in general I think I have come to realize I really dont care that much for these turtles for some reason...
I liked andy kuhn and ben bates very much.I dont really like the way santolouco draws michelangelo or the rest of the guys.I assume I am a very minimal minority there as many people like his work;)...but that is great.I know what it takes to do a comic book, I am doing these myself, so I dont want to knock anyone s chair for no reason at all...I just wanted to contribute my lil story with others here who perhaps feel similarly.
Redeemer
10-21-2013, 10:02 AM
@title: No, are you crazy?
It's getting better and better.
Bud Samhain made this thread, I think he just fell out of TMNT entirely. Haven't seen that guy in forever.
The whole reincarnation thing still upsets me a big deal and made me lose interest during the first year or so, but overall I'm now liking the series better, mainly due to Santolouco.
Amen I love his art, my only complaint is he makes Mike look too child like. but I love his art.
DrSpengler
10-21-2013, 10:37 AM
No, I haven't lost interest in the IDW book.
At times I do feel that the characters get lost in the stories rather than the stories enhancing the characters, though. Everyone's always in such a hurry to get from one setpiece to the next that there's scarcely any time for displays of personality beyond generic witticisms or one-dimensional gimmicks (Raph's the angry one, Don's the smart one, Mikey's the silly one, etc), but most comics are guilty of that from time to time.
And even when the ongoing is getting mired in one epic after another, there's been the micros to offer us character-themed oneshots, so it has evened out in a way. I'd sort of like to see the ongoing use a little more punctuation between its lengthier arcs; separate them with some shorter character-centered stuff. Looking back, the 2-parters "Blood Brothers" and "Fathers and Sons" were enjoyable and a welcomed break between the "big" arcs of "Shadows of the Past" and "Krang War".
But I understand these monthlies are "written for the trades", so everything has to fit into neat little 4-issue arcs whether its conducive to the story flow or not. You can't punctuate two 4-issue arcs with a 2-issue "breather", because then the issues won't divide evenly into 4-issue trades. So if you want a "breather", it's got to be a pair of 2-issue arcs back to back and suddenly that's 4 months of "breathers". But whaddayagonnado, right?
I think there's a lot to look forward to in the IDW series and I don't really see any reason to lose interest in it on a storytelling level. I can fully understand if someone feels "burned out" by the quantity of TMNT titles (we'll be coming up on 4 books a month, at $4 bucks a piece), but not the story.
I just want to get to know the characters a little more, is all. I'm actually feeling wistful for the days when Donnie was the one questioning Leo's authority and it felt like we were getting all new, unexplored character dynamics.
mgambino
10-21-2013, 11:20 AM
No, I haven't lost interest in the IDW book.
At times I do feel that the characters get lost in the stories rather than the stories enhancing the characters, though. Everyone's always in such a hurry to get from one setpiece to the next that there's scarcely any time for displays of personality beyond generic witticisms or one-dimensional gimmicks (Raph's the angry one, Don's the smart one, Mikey's the silly one, etc), but most comics are guilty of that from time to time.
And even when the ongoing is getting mired in one epic after another, there's been the micros to offer us character-themed oneshots, so it has evened out in a way. I'd sort of like to see the ongoing use a little more punctuation between its lengthier arcs; separate them with some shorter character-centered stuff. Looking back, the 2-parters "Blood Brothers" and "Fathers and Sons" were enjoyable and a welcomed break between the "big" arcs of "Shadows of the Past" and "Krang War".
But I understand these monthlies are "written for the trades", so everything has to fit into neat little 4-issue arcs whether its conducive to the story flow or not. You can't punctuate two 4-issue arcs with a 2-issue "breather", because then the issues won't divide evenly into 4-issue trades. So if you want a "breather", it's got to be a pair of 2-issue arcs back to back and suddenly that's 4 months of "breathers". But whaddayagonnado, right?
I think there's a lot to look forward to in the IDW series and I don't really see any reason to lose interest in it on a storytelling level. I can fully understand if someone feels "burned out" by the quantity of TMNT titles (we'll be coming up on 4 books a month, at $4 bucks a piece), but not the story.
I just want to get to know the characters a little more, is all. I'm actually feeling wistful for the days when Donnie was the one questioning Leo's authority and it felt like we were getting all new, unexplored character dynamics.
I'd imagine we are going to finally get a more character based story with the next arc.
Rooish
10-21-2013, 03:41 PM
The stories are keeping me hooked, but I'm eagerly anticipating more character development. The Micros did a little bit for each character, but not enough. I think that Leo and Raph and April need a bit more info on what makes them tick, and Donnie has just been the skeptic so far, with surprisingly little warmth. I wonder if the next arc will focus on one Turtle per issue?
I am going to keep spending money on IDW for a long time. The series is addictive and keeps getting richer.
Casey
10-21-2013, 04:39 PM
However, by the fifth issue (a. k. a. reincarnation origin), I slammed the book onto the floor. I felt, "What's the point? If you're not going to stay true to their origins, don't call it Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles because that's not what this is."
...
Also, hate Dan Duncans artwork. At least Kevin Eastman's turtles look lean, green, fighting machines.
I hear what you're saying, but I feel like who wants to read the same origin story we have read in Mirage, watched in the OT, 23K, Nick and the movies? I have a hard time with the reincarnation thing, but I think they have more up their sleeves than spiritual mumbo jumbo.
Couldn't agree more about Duncan and Eastman. I tried so hard to like it, but I just wanna see the artwork on Eastman's covers rather than the big tooth bloated blobs that Duncan draws. I hate to sound so hateful, but it feels good to let it out haha.
Redeemer
10-21-2013, 05:24 PM
I hear what you're saying, but I feel like who wants to read the same origin story we have read in Mirage, watched in the OT, 23K, Nick and the movies? I have a hard time with the reincarnation thing, but I think they have more up their sleeves than spiritual mumbo jumbo.
Agreed I still think there is more to the re-incarnation thought as well. I think the utroms had something to do with it. I mean think about it. Stockman works for krang. Krang and shredder are enemies. I seriously am starting to think the utrom had a hand in it all some how.
Cipher
10-21-2013, 06:49 PM
I just want to get to know the characters a little more, is all. I'm actually feeling wistful for the days when Donnie was the one questioning Leo's authority and it felt like we were getting all new, unexplored character dynamics.
This is precisely what I've missed and precisely why, #26 aside, I feel my interest has been waning since the end of "Blood Brothers."
I disagree on the micros making up for missing character focus in the main series, as well. Aside from the four Turtles', they've all been too stock, too cliche. Origin stories and monologue boxes are not character-building. Interactions are. I was initially less enthused about the Northampton arc, based on the way the series had been going, but the last issue showed me that these character can still be fun and compelling when we actually stop to see how they're doing.
CyberCubed
10-21-2013, 08:56 PM
Yeah all these big arcs makes this feel like a superhero comic, which is something TMNT never was. I understand IDW doing this...but I just miss the Turtles randomly getting into adventures...not always having this huge arc hanging over their heads.
milesflex
10-21-2013, 08:57 PM
I love it. It's the only comic I'm currently caught up on. More character stories, and less "Infestation" crap, but otherwise, I love the modern updates to the classic characters, I like new characters like Old Hob, and I was initially not cool with the reincarnation, but I accept it now, and think it is interesting (even though it is not my favorite origin for them).
Coola Yagami
10-21-2013, 11:20 PM
Yeah all these big arcs makes this feel like a superhero comic, which is something TMNT never was. I understand IDW doing this...but I just miss the Turtles randomly getting into adventures...not always having this huge arc hanging over their heads.
That's the thing though. The Turtles never had a decent on-going series. Volume 1 was plagued by the guest artist era, and then pick-and-choose adventures in which some issues were canon like Return to New York and other weren't until we finally got to City at War.
Volume 2 was one long story arc but it the series ended before it could move on with another one. In a way, Volume 3 was also one long story arc that never saw an ending (no offense to Andrew of course).
Volume 4 was a long-ass arc divided by four happening all at once that never had an ending... and it was released once every whenever...
And while Tales was more of a monthly thing, their adventures took place whenever so it really wasn't an ongoing story.
And even Archie, once Mary Bones was introduced it became one long-ass story arc after another.
I'm just glad to finally have consistent monthly TMNT comic with ongoing adventures. Like FINALLY. It brings me back to the Archie days.
pingclang
10-22-2013, 02:00 PM
This is the main book I anxiously wait for each month. I'm subbed to a few non-turtles things and I can say, they're nothing compared. When it comes to story archs, I liked how Mirage handled it in the first few issues where the Turtles went off planet. It was an overarching story but at the same time a bunch of adventures like the Fugitoid and the arena sequence. A lot of fun short things inside the arch of them trying to get home. IDW is doing things more traditional with their archs. I like it, it doesn't bother me. Would I prefer the old style, maybe if it was handled well, but I like an over-encompassing story. I think IDW is going big with it, fast. The old stuff, even when all kinds of craziness was happening, still stayed small and focused on the Turtles and the adventure. Maybe that's what's missing? It's still good and my personal favorite current series, but it might be fun to see them do something different. I think Northampton is going to be interesting as the Turtles recoup and if the focus stays on them, it may be great. Plus, Ross Campbell art, tells me it may have a more serious, than action, tone.
Bossanova
10-23-2013, 10:11 PM
I have been a turtles fan since my earliest memories, i was very young when the first movie came out, maybe 5. lost interest in high school and wasn't until just a few months ago i got back into comics because of this new IDW series. I gotta say, I absolutely love it, the nostalgia just bombards me with every turn of the page, and the art kicks ass. I for one wont stop reading.
Powder
10-23-2013, 10:37 PM
the nostalgia just bombards me with every turn of the page,
The absolute biggest flaw of the series right here.
TonySiegel
10-23-2013, 10:55 PM
the series is cool because its a "new" take on the classic turtles... alot of peeps missed out on the original mirage run along with the other turtle iterations...
i agree though with some of the stories being rehashes of the OG stories...
the series still has potential... its like a B grade comic with A grade moments overall so far...
Coola Yagami
10-23-2013, 11:11 PM
the series is cool because its a "new" take on the classic turtles... alot of peeps missed out on the original mirage run along with the other turtle iterations...
i agree though with some of the stories being rehashes of the OG stories...
the series still has potential... its like a B grade comic with A grade moments overall so far...
But the thing is, IDW is even reprinting the original Mirage run. It's not a super-rare obscure 'did you know the TMNT were comicbook character first' thing anymore. If you want Mirage, read that. There's no need to redraw Mirage stories in IDW style. Doing stories based on a serious OT style, mixing in several characters from Mirage, 2K3 and new characters is a way better route that re-hashing comic storylines you can just buy anywhere now.
HeroTurtlesFan
10-24-2013, 05:43 AM
besides ONGOING is a pretty stupid term in my oppinion..thats what I EXPECT when I am following a SERIES..isnt it obvious?I feel like this is just another trend in the scene..didnt see that term in the past)
How long have you been reading comics? The term 'ongoing' has been used at least as far back as the 1970s to distinguish between mini-series, one-offs etc and...well, the ONGOING title.
Bossanova
10-24-2013, 11:13 AM
The absolute biggest flaw of the series right here.
just seeing a turtle period gives the nostalgia feeling, i don't see how thats a flaw. I think its a great new take on the characters, especially the reincarnation aspect. of course this is just my opinion, "my cup o' tea".
TonySiegel
10-24-2013, 11:37 AM
But the thing is, IDW is even reprinting the original Mirage run. It's not a super-rare obscure 'did you know the TMNT were comicbook character first' thing anymore. If you want Mirage, read that. There's no need to redraw Mirage stories in IDW style. Doing stories based on a serious OT style, mixing in several characters from Mirage, 2K3 and new characters is a way better route that re-hashing comic storylines you can just buy anywhere now.
i definitely hear you man...
i guess i enjoyed the first story arc(s) so much with raph's amnesia and his micro, that i was blinded by nostalgia & joy... [esp. with collecting a complete comic series for once]
not saying that the comic hasn't gotten better i've just yet to reach that high of excitement again...
DaVinci
10-26-2013, 05:11 PM
I'd sort of like to see the ongoing use a little more punctuation between its lengthier arcs; separate them with some shorter character-centered stuff. Looking back, the 2-parters "Blood Brothers" and "Fathers and Sons" were enjoyable and a welcomed break between the "big" arcs of "Shadows of the Past" and "Krang War".
But I understand these monthlies are "written for the trades", so everything has to fit into neat little 4-issue arcs whether its conducive to the story flow or not. You can't punctuate two 4-issue arcs with a 2-issue "breather", because then the issues won't divide evenly into 4-issue trades. So if you want a "breather", it's got to be a pair of 2-issue arcs back to back and suddenly that's 4 months of "breathers". But whaddayagonnado, right?
Considering City Fall is already a multi-trade arc, what about a 2-issue break followed by a 6-issue major arc at a later stage?
MaxGoof
10-29-2013, 05:57 AM
I lost interest for several months during the Neutrino arc. I thought that was downright awful and the art didn't seem appropriate to the story at all in it. I'm back on-board with City Fall though.
Whatswiththeheadbands?
10-29-2013, 10:01 AM
Lost interest? I haven't even begun reading it yet!
I know, i should
thelouisguy
10-29-2013, 10:46 PM
Considering City Fall is already a multi-trade arc, what about a 2-issue break followed by a 6-issue major arc at a later stage?
Well, we kinda got that already. Issue 21 was a standalone issue which broke up the Krang War and City Fall. We got a few "breather" micros in that the Krang and Baxter issues did not tie into City Fall. Looking ahead, we have the 4 issue Northampton and 3 issue Utrom Empire arcs. Not exactly what your looking for, but we are done with the 7 issue mega arcs, for now. I like both, in moderation. Wouldn't want all one-and-done stories or all mega arcs either. I enjoy the pacing of the series so far.
CyberCubed
10-29-2013, 11:26 PM
It's comic books. You only get 12 issues a year of the main story besides the specials. Comic books move slowly when you read them as they come out.
People love to forget Volume 4's bi-monthly schedule, or the wait for Image and Tales when they were new.
Coola Yagami
10-30-2013, 02:48 PM
It's comic books. You only get 12 issues a year of the main story besides the specials. Comic books move slowly when you read them as they come out.
People love to forget Volume 4's bi-monthly schedule, or the wait for Image and Tales when they were new.
What did this post have to do with anything? I'm sure everyone here is aware how comic books work.
CyberCubed
10-30-2013, 07:26 PM
What did this post have to do with anything? I'm sure everyone here is aware how comic books work.
because only 22 pages of story every month tends to make people lose interest. We were all 2 years younger back in 2011.
Coola Yagami
10-30-2013, 07:44 PM
because only 22 pages of story every month tends to make people lose interest. We were all 2 years younger back in 2011.
That is how comic books have always worked though. Can't read em at that pace then then I guess you shouldn't bother reading them.
CyberCubed
10-30-2013, 07:49 PM
That is how comic books have always worked though. Can't read em at that pace then then I guess you shouldn't bother reading them.
That's why people lose interest in comics in general. I can see why people wait for the trades as they get a more complete story at once.
Powder
10-30-2013, 07:58 PM
That is how comic books have always worked though. Can't read em at that pace then then I guess you shouldn't bother reading them.
Not necessarily. It's really only true of books clearly written for trades.
Cipher
10-30-2013, 08:01 PM
Yep. I always feel a lot more satisfied with one-off issues, even with the same page count.
Granted, I followed the Hellsing manga as it came out at a rate of like 10-15 pages per month, some months, so I'm generally pretty lenient with decompressed, serialized monthly comics. That said, there's a certain sting to having to pay $4 for, and drive to pick up, the experience.
Coola Yagami
10-30-2013, 08:24 PM
Not necessarily. It's really only true of books clearly written for trades.
But it's always been like that, though not as decompressed. How will Spider-Man escape this mess? Find out next month. Did Joker really kill Robin? Tune in next month. How will the rescue Dark Leo? Tune in next month. You guys act as if comics are weekly or daily and just now started being monthly. At least the micros keep us entertained in the meantime.
MsMarvelDuckie
10-30-2013, 08:34 PM
My interest has not waned at all. If anything, it has only grown with every new trade I get my hands on. So far I have loved almost everything about this series, as it combines what I feel are the best elements of everything that has gone before- and introduced SOO much that is new! I was very much surprised by the reincarnation angle at first, but the further into it I got, the more I loved it- it's a fresh new take on their origins that actually MAKES SENSE in the context of their world and history. Splinter wasn't JUST a lab rat, he IS and WAS Yoshi in another life, and the experiments done on him (and the boys) somehow tapped into that. It's science meets magic at its finest. (See my siggy quotes for a perfect explanation of why I love this....)
Granted there have been some choices in the art that I wasn't quite thrilled with, but I can overlook that when the story-telling has been so consistently good, and the continuity is so tight. Marvel and DC could learn a thing or two from these guys on that score. My favorite parts so far were the reveal of Chet as the Fugitoid, the Neutrinos' re-emergence in Krang War, and the first appearance of Bebop and Rocksteady in Raph's micro.
DaVinci
11-03-2013, 06:42 AM
Well, we kinda got that already. Issue 21 was a standalone issue which broke up the Krang War and City Fall. We got a few "breather" micros in that the Krang and Baxter issues did not tie into City Fall. Looking ahead, we have the 4 issue Northampton and 3 issue Utrom Empire arcs. Not exactly what your looking for, but we are done with the 7 issue mega arcs, for now. I like both, in moderation. Wouldn't want all one-and-done stories or all mega arcs either. I enjoy the pacing of the series so far.
Just meant that they could do it again at some point in the future.
CyberCubed
11-06-2013, 09:45 PM
I'm kinda hoping they eventually get some issues where just random stuff happens like in Mirage, rather than a huge story arc after story arc.
Some of the best Mirage issues were one-shots where just some random stuff happens or it delves into the Turtles personalities. We need some of that in IDW.
Coola Yagami
11-07-2013, 07:04 PM
I'm kinda hoping they eventually get some issues where just random stuff happens like in Mirage, rather than a huge story arc after story arc.
Some of the best Mirage issues were one-shots where just some random stuff happens or it delves into the Turtles personalities. We need some of that in IDW.
Mirage kinda needed that because other than the Shredder/Triceraton related issues and City at War, the series was basically random one shots. Now they have an actual honest-to-goodness on-going series that will hopefully last longer than Volume 2, 3 and 4 and dare I say... the Archie series. The one shots could be saved for more micros.
thelouisguy
11-08-2013, 08:11 PM
I'm kinda hoping they eventually get some issues where just random stuff happens like in Mirage, rather than a huge story arc after story arc.
Some of the best Mirage issues were one-shots where just some random stuff happens or it delves into the Turtles personalities. We need some of that in IDW.
A lot of the micro series issues are serving that purpose in the IDWverse. I am hoping to see a second round of micro series issues focusing on each Turtle in the coming year.
Powder
11-08-2013, 09:33 PM
While the micros are perfect, it would be nice if the main book could just have one offs sometimes.
Redeemer
11-08-2013, 09:35 PM
A lot of the micro series issues are serving that purpose in the IDWverse. I am hoping to see a second round of micro series issues focusing on each Turtle in the coming year.
Agreed, I feel like this is one reason the micro's are special and sets them apart, but for the individual that just wants to see the fearsome four go on a random venture then we need something else besides the micros bc they usually focus on a single individual.
But also IDW only has 22 pg issues and unfortunately just isn't enough to put out a good solid one shot, so I feel maybe the 2 or even 3 issue arcs could work well for some awesome adventures.
VaughnMichael
11-09-2013, 10:45 AM
I buy the trades so I'm patient and wait.
Everything I've been getting is fantastic and I thought the series was crap at first and was like wtf are they doing.
But I'm so hooked at this point and I loved the Secret History of the Foot Clan!
ChaoticGood
11-19-2013, 03:05 PM
I haven't lost interest at all, but I'm finding the micro-series and stuff like Secret History of the Foot Clan to be a lot more engaging than the ongoing series. Maybe TMNT stories just work better with short arcs.
Konchadunga
11-20-2013, 02:44 PM
Sad to say it, but I kind of have. My problem isn't that it borrows from Mirage, or from the OT, or from the 4Kids show--it's that it isn't doing it particularly well. This quote from Curnow, earlier in the thread, elucidates my problem:
I'm amused that the "How Mirage is it?!?!?" debate is still going on. I'd have hoped that we'd be done with that by now, but it's fair that almost 30 years of TMNT casts a long shadow. We do strive to incorporate from all iterations (Fugitoid will be playing a big part soon— that's a solid check mark in the Mirage column), but let's face it... if you're going to divide it into percentages, OT has the biggest piece of the pie. That's the Turtles that has the most pop-culture reach AND is the most ripe for re-invention. That's a potent mix, and we'd be silly to ignore it.
But just because we're borrowing ideas from OT doesn't mean we're executing them in any way that's close to resembling OT. We're treating those silly characters seriously, and hopefully doing new and fun things with them. And we'll do that with Mirage and Archie stuff too. But again: the aim is to have it all blend into a hearty IDW soup.
This series, from up to what I read (which was the Secret History of the Foot Clan) relies entirely too much on nostalgia-baiting. As a very open-minded fan, I really like the idea of a new universe that incorporates something for everyone and then some, but when they try to do it all so quickly, there's no room to develop much of it.
It hurts even more that in a way, they're reversing development. See; "treating those silly characters seriously" isn't necessarily a good idea, Curnow. I was on board for the turtles making jokes, I didn't mind the colored bandanas, I was willing to see where Krang, Rocksteady and Bebop would go, and I will admit, I love what they did with the Fugitoid, but when it came to the Neutrinos as a whole (my go-to example and the first place this book really disappointed me), I'm sorry; it just doesn't work like that, guys. The Neutrinos are an inherently silly concept. I don't mind their being there, and I like that they can fight better now, but they were designed to be silly-looking in order to look like dated beatniks, and you need to keep that sort of character funny, and make their mannerisms somewhat unique, or all you end up with is embarrassment. I can't read a story of heroic freedom fighters fighting an evil dictator and take it seriously when the former look like that. You mean to tell me there's some tactical purpose to wearing flashy clothes and not cutting your hair? Please.
You've got it all wrong if you think that just taking the humor out of Fred Wolf characters brings them up to Mirage standards. Look at Renet; she originated in Mirage and is definitely a silly, goofy character. Mirage Baxter was also a ham, though not stupid or a butt monkey. The Mirage series is far from universally serious, and hence you can have a Mirage-caliber story with this sort of character--the key is knowing which characters work for which mood, and which don't.
What of the Mirage influences themselves? They're similarly neutered by the no-kill policy. We're supposed to buy that these are the reincarnated heirs from an era of cutthroat civil war, they're up against serious threats to themselves and the world all the time, and they tie arms behind their back for some outdated code? No. I don't care how much you try to claim that killing is the way of weak, anger-driven minds; killing happens in war because it can be quick and effective. If avoiding killing was possible all the time in war without sacrificing effectiveness and efficiency , more people would do it. Obviously, that's not the case. I wish all incarnations had turtles willing to kill at times, but in cartoons they at least have an excuse not to and a surreal sense of fun to compensate. Yet here, once again, they beg us to take this series seriously, yet there's this bit constantly preventing it.
That's not a hearty IDW soup in my opinion. I won't say that they try too hard to please everyone, until they don't please anyone, because obviously a lot of people still love it, but my enthusiasm has dimmed. Do I think this could be done right? Yes, but doing so requires more than acknowledgement of past elements that were fun; it requires an acknowledgement of why they were fun. That's the difference between a tasty tomato and beef soup, and a soup made up of tomato stems and hooves.
JoshDA7X
11-20-2013, 02:56 PM
I am still enjoying the series thus far. I agree with points both sides have made such as the killing and such mentioned above but the lack of such topic doesn't really effect the story overall. I think the thought of four children having their heads cut off should be plenty blood thirsty enough without it been shown in all its graphic glory!
Konchadunga
11-20-2013, 04:08 PM
But see; that's the problem. I don't demand buckets of blood, but when villains are that ruthless, the attitude of heroes should be "them or me"; not "holier than thou."
Bobby Curnow
11-20-2013, 08:57 PM
You can call me Bobby, no need to be so formal with the 'Curnow'. Makes it sound like i'm a robot from the future or something. (am I??)
At the end of the day, we're guys trying our best. No way it's going to please everybody, and sorry it's fallen out for you. While I definitely think we have some ways we can improve, I dig what we're doing, and obviously have a different view on some of it than you. But I get where you're coming from. I think it's largely a matter of what kind of story each individual is looking for.
Coola Yagami
11-20-2013, 10:18 PM
I think a problem the turtles are always gonna face when trying to be child-friendly is that they're ninjas. And ninjas kill. And ninjas are usually villains. Or a grey area where they're good and/or bad depending on who hires them. Splinter could send them to kill Shredder today, and rob a rich man tomorrow.
Ninjas are awesome, I get that, but wow, maybe they should have been called karate turtles or whatever so they could keep the martial arts aspect without having to dance around the subject of what they're really supposed to be.
AquaParade
11-20-2013, 10:41 PM
What of the Mirage influences themselves? They're similarly neutered by the no-kill policy. We're supposed to buy that these are the reincarnated heirs from an era of cutthroat civil war, they're up against serious threats to themselves and the world all the time, and they tie arms behind their back for some outdated code? No. I don't care how much you try to claim that killing is the way of weak, anger-driven minds; killing happens in war because it can be quick and effective. If avoiding killing was possible all the time in war without sacrificing effectiveness and efficiency , more people would do it. Obviously, that's not the case. I wish all incarnations had turtles willing to kill at times, but in cartoons they at least have an excuse not to and a surreal sense of fun to compensate. Yet here, once again, they beg us to take this series seriously, yet there's this bit constantly preventing it.
Bobby,
I think the series has done exceptionally great in a few areas. The first arc shines the brightest for me. Issues #1-5 felt wonderous, unpredictable, and a tad dangerous.
That aside, I think there are some really excellent points being made in this post (Not just the section I've quoted). "Konchadunga" has probably hit the nail on a head for a fair amount of fans on this board.
I haven't lost interest. I'm enjoying this story. I think this series can do way better.
HeroTurtlesFan
11-21-2013, 05:42 AM
I would be very put off this book if the Turtles ran round killing the villains. Yes, I know, "Mirage this, Mirage that", but those weren't the Turtles I grew up enjoying. Those aren't the Turtles my 5 and 7 year old son enjoy so much now. Maybe I'm not a "true fan"in some people's eyes, but the Turtles to me just aren't killers.
I am very pleased with how things are progressing, even though I'm a TPB or two behind! I am SO tempted to start with the monthlies, but want to maintain my TPB collection too, and am not fond of double-dipping...
But bottom line, I love this incarnation of the Turtles!
TomWaltz
11-21-2013, 06:46 PM
Nope, I haven't lost interest. Still having fun.
:P
Talk soon...
Tom W.
Coola Yagami
11-21-2013, 07:04 PM
Nope, I haven't lost interest. Still having fun.
:P
Talk soon...
Tom W.
LOL I hope not. If you lost interest, then we're really in trouble. LOL
CyberCubed
11-21-2013, 11:49 PM
LOL I hope not. If you lost interest, then we're really in trouble. LOL
Or something like changing the writers of the series, that's something DC and Marvel do with their ongoings and change the head writers.
Hopefully that doesn't happen here. Both Tom Waltz and Bobby are the reason the IDW series is as good as it is so far, and hopefully they stay with the series up until the time it ends.
And its obvious the series is discovering itself and they're learning from some of the mistakes at the beginning of it. I can only imagine how great IDW will be in Years 3 and 4 and beyond.
AquaParade
11-22-2013, 09:11 PM
I like what Tom is doing but I wouldn't be opposed to another writer taking the torch at some point down the line.
If it were me, I'd destroy the great new origin that Tom has come up with, chalking up all those memories of their past life as hallucinations due to the drugs they were injected with. It's not that I don't adore the new take on their origin, but I just think there'd be a ton of material to mine from that revelation. Yeah, I'm clearly influenced by Alan Moore's run on Swamp Thing.
Don't worry, it won't be me.
Toby Barrett
11-22-2013, 10:23 PM
You'd need an explaination for Shredder possessing the same memories of their lives as them.
Plasticplayhouse
11-23-2013, 12:31 AM
Why on earth would you want to change writers!? In another 3-5 year's maybe...if toms getting burned out by then. He's been doing a fantastic job. That's like turning off a movie during the best part. It's way too early for that kind of thought process.
CyberCubed
11-23-2013, 12:38 AM
Why on earth would you want to change writers!? In another 3-5 year's maybe...if toms getting burned out by then. He's been doing a fantastic job. That's like turning off a movie during the best part. It's way too early for that kind of thought process.
Uh, people were arguing against any writer changes. People want Tom and Bobby in it for the long haul.
If it were me, I'd destroy the great new origin that Tom has come up with, chalking up all those memories of their past life as hallucinations due to the drugs they were injected with. It's not that I don't adore the new take on their origin, but I just think there'd be a ton of material to mine from that revelation.
Heh, yeap, that idea came to my mind too. I mean what if it's really not a reincernation, they just posses those memories because someone organised it for a reason.
I actually think it might be a big reveal in the future (or maybe at the end of City Fall), that Kitsune has a role in their resurfaced memories, and it was intended, not just a coincidence.
Coola Yagami
11-23-2013, 12:17 PM
Heh, yeap, that idea came to my mind too. I mean what if it's really not a reincernation, they just posses those memories because someone organised it for a reason.
I actually think it might be a big reveal in the future (or maybe at the end of City Fall), that Kitsune has a role in their resurfaced memories, and it was intended, not just a coincidence.
Why would Kitsune arrange these memories for them AND Shredder too? And how would Splinter have these memories when he was still a normal rat? He was still saving April and protecting the Turtles before he was mutated.
It's fine as is and adds an extra layer. It works well for Leo in this Cityfall story.
Well, we have no idea about who Kitsune was for Krang, and what are her long term goals, or what she did between Saki going into sleep, and she going into sleep.
What she gained by Shredder is getting rid of Krang (or the unnamed utrom, who's very likely Krang), and reaching immortality by resting in ooze for a few hundred years. Also, seems like she foresee the future, she had knowledge of New York while living in the medieval period of Japan.
I honestly wouldn't be suprised, if she did these things for herself, not for Saki, and if it's the case, she might want to get rid of him later, so she might had a plan for that too, in a way that she influenced the time and place of the reincernation of Yoshi and his sons souls from the past. (remember, she sees the future) How can she do something like that? Magic, maybe.
Now it's just a prediction, but I think it's a possibility.
At the same time, I wonder if she had anything to do with Takeshi Tetsuo reincernating as the son of the man who killed him, was it her revenge?
Vegeta
11-29-2013, 07:15 PM
I don't post here anymore lately but I read the comic discussions often and read every IDW issue as they come out. I just wanted to say thanks to Tom and the team because this ongoing is my favorite turtles series ever. Cityfall has been a blast and the art has been nothing short of spectacular. I like it more than Mirage as there is a lot of Mirage i just don't dig when kevin/peter left. I love the books and thanks for reading our complaints and our reviews!
CyberCubed
12-16-2013, 01:25 PM
My interest comes and goes between issues, but that's basically because only one issue comes out a month and you're not really thinking about the story again till the next issue comes.
I want the IDW series to go on for as long as possible however, because with Mirage being over now its pretty much the only TMNT comic we have going. If Nick decides to terminate their deal with IDW for whatever reason I don't think we'll get much in the way of comics anymore outside of a few based on the cartoon.
Does anyone know how many years the Nick/IDW licensed was agreed for? I assume they did it for at least 3 years and then they renew based on sales?
Mr._Mutant_Man
12-21-2013, 09:16 PM
My interest has been rekindled with issue #29. Looking forward to where things are going with the characters.
I also think that this issue is the best April O'Neil has been drawn in the series so far. I hope they stick with the "pear shape" she had in this issue.
Konchadunga
12-22-2013, 04:19 PM
Bobby,
I think the series has done exceptionally great in a few areas. The first arc shines the brightest for me. Issues #1-5 felt wonderous, unpredictable, and a tad dangerous.
That aside, I think there are some really excellent points being made in this post (Not just the section I've quoted). "Konchadunga" has probably hit the nail on a head for a fair amount of fans on this board.
I haven't lost interest. I'm enjoying this story. I think this series can do way better.
Another thing is look at the Nick series. Not for everything, mind you, but what it does well is play to nostalgia without being a slave to it and without thinking the mere presence of a legacy character is enough to entertain old fans. Again, the Fugitoid is the big example of where IDW got it right; by all means, change something in the mythos and do something unexpected to keep it fresh. However, merely taking away a big part of what characters were before is not the right way to change things; unless you plan to add something else that's really original. So much of the Fred Wolf show was designed for comedy that taking the comedy out of its characters is basically pointless; you might as well not have Fred Wolf characters if you're going to do that.
Icegaze
01-18-2014, 05:51 PM
I love this series. Best arc so far is City Fall, of course. The art style was magnificent. The intensity was great as well.
I'm not a fan of the current art style though. Too cartoony.
CyberCubed
01-18-2014, 08:09 PM
I've lost interest in the single issues and switched to the trades. Buying just one comic a month to continue the story doesn't appeal to me anymore.
I'll stick with the trades so I can read entire arcs at once. I know it hurts sales but I am just one person so it won't make much of a difference.
MsMarvelDuckie
01-18-2014, 09:01 PM
I've been buying them that way all along, Cubed, and the worst thing about them is the wait in between. I have loved every arc so far, as well as the micros. I'm eagerly awaiting the day City Fall pt 2 is available in trades, and the Villains micro volume 2, as well. Even though it means I'm a little behind the current arc (Northhampton), I enjoy getting to read entire arcs at once. And I don't think it hurts sales at all, since we are still buying the series, just put together in a different format. And we get extras that the single issues don't deliver- all that variant cover art that's included in the back! It's win-win, in my book.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.