PDA

View Full Version : CGC labeling errors


rich
08-23-2012, 12:07 PM
Hey all...curious to get your thoughts on something.

When CGC mis-labels a comic book (here's an example (http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=320968502150&ssPageName=ADME:B:SS:US:1123#ht_1026wt_1190)) or something about the labeling is incorrect, does that make the comic book more valuable in your eyes?

Personally, I do no believe a grading or labeling error makes a comic more valuable or rare - it should be the comic book inside that should determine the value and rarity. While such an error makes for an interesting collectible, I don't believe it turns a $25 comic into a $1,000 comic. As a comic book collector, I'd personally be willing to pay no more than a 25% mark-up over what a non-error copy would go for.

HotJuicyBurgers
08-23-2012, 12:12 PM
That is actually a pretty funny mess up. I can't imagine I would pay a lot for it though.

I'm curious as to how something like this happens, if it is in fact legitimate. At least they got the issue number right though lol

rich
08-23-2012, 12:17 PM
I'm curious as to how something like this happens, if it is in fact legitimate.

Me too. I really find it hard to believe that CGC would get this so wrong. At first I thought it might have been mixed up with the upcoming IDW "TMNT Color Classics" version of #6 since it will have a similar cover but it's apparently a #6 from Mirage inside the slab. Very strange.

pannoni1
08-23-2012, 01:13 PM
Since it was the third party's fault and not Mirage's fault, I wouldn't expect much of a premium with this comic. It still provides an accurate grade, still shows that it is genuine, and still proves that it is signed. Somebody must have been reading too many IDW issues as late whoever inputed that label. It's also possible that there can a typo in the date or spelling, though given how obvious this error is, a premium should be expected for this issue.

This is OT, but here is a football card that used the wrong player's name:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/2000-UD-Graded-MIKE-ANDERSON-SGC-Mislabeled-as-FRANK-MURPHY-RC-Error-Rare-/370568857031?pt=US_Football&hash=item5647a005c7

I've also sold a mislabeled vinyl 45 by the Police before where the same song was printed on both sides of the record.

Mislabeling can also happen to action figures, too! There is also a mislabeled Lord of the Rings figure on eBay that is labeled as Ringwraith. However, given the figure inside the packaging and also the information on the back, it is clear that this acually Eomer on Horseback! I can't say there has never been a mislabeled TMNT figure, but always keep your eye out for errors, not just simply the animation errors!

It seems that mislabelled items seem to come to the most benefit in terms of value to common but popular items or if the magnitude of the error is large, though that's not always the case. For instance, this Star Wars POTF figure is mislabeled with an Emperor Palpatine sticker when it really is just Hoth Chewie, and given the BIN price is under $10, does not appear that there is a premium. Its just in the eye of the beholder, and some fans will pay a premium for such novelties.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Star-Wars-POTF-Hoth-Chewbacca-Flashback-Mislabeled-w-Palaptine-Sticker-Figure-/200721114420?pt=US_Action_Figures&hash=item2ebbe92534

FoxZerro
08-23-2012, 01:28 PM
I can't say there has never been a mislabeled TMNT figure, but always keep your eye out for errors

I can confirm at least on mislabeled TMNT figure my Original Card Backed NECA Raphael I got back in 2004. It was a Donatello figure in a Raphael box.

I ended up opening it and then was surprised since I didn't really pay attention to the expression on face on the turtle before I opened it. I remember talking to the guy at the Toy shop I bought it at and he was all I bet you wish you didn't open it, would have been worth a lot of money

rich
08-23-2012, 01:36 PM
Thanks for the input pannoni...you've given some great examples that demonstrate exactly what I was talking about. To me there's a big difference between an error that occurs on (or with) the actual comic, figure, etc. and an error that occurs in grading or labeling a regular, non-error comic, figure, etc.

I actually have a few mislabeled / mis-packaged TMNT figures in my collection. To me, that is an actual "error" figure. A regular figure that's sent in for grading and gets sent back with another character on the label is an "error label." In the card example you gave it's the same thing...the card inside is exactly like every other card of that type (when separated from the grading encapsulation). However, if the card inside had an error on it then it would always be an "error" whether inside or outside encapsulation.

Plasticplayhouse
08-27-2012, 07:50 AM
An error by the grading company doesn’t mean squat to me. all's it tells me is that they screwed up my book grade that I just spent $X on. It has the potential to detract from resale value. If there is someone, let's just say, a little less savvy, they may assume that that IS an IDW book signed by Kevin. They may think it’s a classic cover reprint that they didn’t know about, but are not interested in. buyers put A LOT into what those little labels say. many will take what that label says over what may actually be the case just because, "but the label says!"

To me it has no more than a novelty value. And a novelty will get you about ten bucks.