View Full Version : IDW color classics or ultimate collections
Redeemer
09-04-2012, 11:06 AM
I wanted to know everyone's opinion. I was wondering if it would be better to pick up the color classics each month or just get the hardcover ultimate collections.
I wanted to know what you guys think of quality when compared to one another.
Price comparison and wich route you guys suggest.
I was born in 91 and only got into comics when the IDW series came around and I have never read the original run of TMNT so I was hoping for some good opinions on which route I should go.
CyberCubed
09-04-2012, 11:20 AM
Ultimate collections, why is this even a question? They're well produced books and in black and white like they were intended to be.
The color classics are all just single issues with coloring errors such as Shredder having a full bodysuit and color bandana mistakes. The color classics are aimed at random people who aren't comic fans.
Matches Malone
09-04-2012, 11:58 AM
Most of the factors are preferences which you can determine for yourself. Ask yourself:
-Do you prefer trade/collected books over single issues?
-Do you prefer color over black & white? Or you can put it as, do you prefer the original presentation over color?
-Do you care about the annotations by Eastman & Laird which are exclusive to the Ultimate Collections?
-Do you prefer the larger size or higher quality paper of the Ultimate Collections?
-Would it be fun for you to follow a monthly "series," or do you want to just get as many issues as quickly as possible?
Naturally, you are a better judge for yourself than any of us regarding these things, but those are some things to think about.
But from a price point, each ultimate collection is $49.99, which, at 7-8 issues per collection, makes it about $6.25-$7 per issue. So from that perspective, color classics is the way to go, but there's no guarantee if these will even cover all the issues covered by the ultimate collections. As CyberCubed pointed out, there are some coloring inconsistencies and errors. However, it's not really for him to judge who is a real comic fan based on if they prefer the color classics, so just decide for yourself.
Redeemer
09-04-2012, 01:25 PM
Most of the factors are preferences which you can determine for yourself. Ask yourself:
-Do you prefer trade/collected books over single issues?
-Do you prefer color over black & white? Or you can put it as, do you prefer the original presentation over color?
-Do you care about the annotations by Eastman & Laird which are exclusive to the Ultimate Collections?
-Do you prefer the larger size or higher quality paper of the Ultimate Collections?
-Would it be fun for you to follow a monthly "series," or do you want to just get as many issues as quickly as possible?
Naturally, you are a better judge for yourself than any of us regarding these things, but those are some things to think about.
But from a price point, each ultimate collection is $49.99, which, at 7-8 issues per collection, makes it about $6.25-$7 per issue. So from that perspective, color classics is the way to go, but there's no guarantee if these will even cover all the issues covered by the ultimate collections. As CyberCubed pointed out, there are some coloring inconsistencies and errors. However, it's not really for him to judge who is a real comic fan based on if they prefer the color classics, so just decide for yourself.
Hmm...well I do prefer color, but the ultimate collections are only going for 27$ or so. and I rather get as many as I can now. http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=IDW+TMNT+ultimate+collection
SO I think I will be getting the IDW ultimate collections. THanks for the help guys.
nelodiavolo
09-04-2012, 07:35 PM
I'm in the same boat Redeemer. I have Colored Classics issues 1-3 thus far and have the Ultimate Collections in my Amazon Wishlist.
I mostly picked up the Colored collections to see if I would get into the series, having never read them before. There are some coloring errors as mentioned, but they do not distract from the overall reading experience. But, I do enjoy the Black and White art as originally intended. I'd say the Ultimates would be the way to go.
Cowabunga Carl
09-04-2012, 07:45 PM
I'm going color classics my self right now. I have a bunch of the old single issues and think it's neat to have the color and black and white together.
Allio
09-04-2012, 10:09 PM
I'll be doing both, Ultimate Collection for the main story, and getting those colored Ninja Turtles classic volumes for the filler...
I have been collecting both. I really like the Ultimate Collection books. But now that the digital copies are available here in Canada, I'll be picking up the Colour Classics that way.
Digital issues are $3.99 when they first come out and then drop to $1.99 the next month. Can save a lot of money in the long run.
~S~
Matches Malone
09-05-2012, 10:18 AM
I'll be doing both, Ultimate Collection for the main story, and getting those colored Ninja Turtles classic volumes for the filler...
FYI the OP was talking about the single issues that are being released monthly. They are the same issues as the Ultimate Collections, only colored. It's a little confusing that IDW is also releasing trade paperbacks called "Color Classics" too...
FYI the OP was talking about the single issues that are being released monthly. They are the same issues as the Ultimate Collections, only colored. It's a little confusing that IDW is also releasing trade paperbacks called "Color Classics" too...
But that is the question. Since they have release issue 13 in a trade, will they re-release it in a single colour classic comic.
I thought I read on other threads there was speculation that the Colour Classics were only going to 11 (like Spinal Tap Amps!!!)
~S~
Matches Malone
09-05-2012, 11:18 AM
But that is the question. Since they have release issue 13 in a trade, will they re-release it in a single colour classic comic.
I thought I read on other threads there was speculation that the Colour Classics were only going to 11 (like Spinal Tap Amps!!!)
~S~
But why not just release #11 and call it #10? But in all serious, yeah, I am curious about that too. Bobby, the editor of the ongoing, said that it looks like they now have plans to go past #11, but at the same time, also said that sales were dropping. So I guess we'll find out soon whether it will be for the guest issues or strictly the Eastman/Laird ones. I'm honestly very curious to see how Return To New York would look colored. So far, besides the occasional mistake or continuity error, I think the coloring looks pretty great so far.
CyberCubed
09-05-2012, 11:32 AM
They probably will then re-release #13 seperately as a single in the color classics line.
Anyway what I am expecting them to do is then collect the color classics, and release a second trade of issues #1-11 (probably split into two or three volumes) collecting the singles. That's why I haven't picked any up yet, I expect a collection eventually.
Overall its been confirmed the only black and white issues will be in the Ultimate Collections, all the other Volume 1 issues will be colorized in the TPB's.
Matches Malone
09-05-2012, 11:59 AM
They probably will then re-release #13 seperately as a single in the color classics line.
Anyway what I am expecting them to do is then collect the color classics, and release a second trade of issues #1-11 (probably split into two or three volumes) collecting the singles. That's why I haven't picked any up yet, I expect a collection eventually.
Overall its been confirmed the only black and white issues will be in the Ultimate Collections, all the other Volume 1 issues will be colorized in the TPB's.
Hard to say at this point, but that's a possibility. Though looking at the first TPB, it's basically #13 with "bonus shorts."
CyberCubed
09-05-2012, 03:50 PM
The Color Classics really aren't worth it, at least not for me.
Allio
09-05-2012, 06:28 PM
FYI the OP was talking about the single issues that are being released monthly. They are the same issues as the Ultimate Collections, only colored. It's a little confusing that IDW is also releasing trade paperbacks called "Color Classics" too...
oops, my mistake
The Purple Dragon
09-06-2012, 02:22 PM
i buy both but i think i depends if you like color or b&w.
i must say i wish idw dident milk tmnt so mutch and cut all the variant cover unless they get the artist to draw the book as well so if you buy the eastman cover you get the same storie but draw by eastman instad of duncan etc and with the ultimate collection you coued buy the b&w cover and get the books in b&w and color cover and get the books in color
same coued they have done with the single issues of the classic.
fore my part since i like color i must say i am happy to get the color classic and hope they do more and do the issues that never has got color before
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.