View Full Version : What are your thoughts on IDW's Karai?
CyberCubed
10-02-2012, 06:38 PM
I don't really see people talk about her too much. So what do you think?
Once again Karai is related to Shredder and seems loyal to him. Leonardo already bested her in a fight, (which is unusual, Karai is almost always shown to be better than the Turtles the first time they meet her), and Shredder deems her to be incompetent.
On the other hand Karai is the one who brought Shredder back to life, and we saw flashback scenes of her killing mobsters and politicians who proved to be threats to the Foot Clan, so we know she's still the capable fighter she is known for.
With Karai sent to get Leonardo, I imagine we're in for the usual, "Leo trusts Karai for awhile" storyline where Leo also tries to get her to betray Shredder. What do you think?
Plasticplayhouse
10-02-2012, 06:44 PM
She's ok so far. Young, sassy, and over confident.
Dirty Blond
10-02-2012, 06:47 PM
She's rough around the edges. My kind of woman.
I don't know how she expects to recruit Leo, though.
Slade
10-02-2012, 06:50 PM
Haven't read much about her in Mirage or anything and only know her from TMNT Tournament Fighters, 4kids, 2k7 and IDW. Honestly, the only opinion I've ever had about the character at all was from Tournament Fighters, to where I could NOT stand her.
In IDW though, she hasn't done anything yet for me to really form a solid opinion. She just seems there and is taking crap from Shredder.
MikeandRaph87
10-02-2012, 06:51 PM
She's ok so far. Young, sassy, and over confident.
This. Its too early in the game to form much of an opinion,but i do like what I see. Its been confirmed that she is the contemporary descendant of Shredder not third gen. so it clears up some,but adds to the mystery to how Karai helped launch The Shredder's modern mission.
I would add that I know her as Shredder's step-daughter and subordiante. I think its the way it should be in order to have them both around at the same time and while it can be tricky it work her that way it brings alot of interesting characterization to the table for her. Shredder needs to be around and if he is here to stay then its tricky to bring Karai in the picture. I don't want to read about Karai if Shredder is dead and gone for good,but if he is and she is invovled too I welcome the chance to read about her. 4Kids made me enjoy the character aside from perhaps one pothole along the way with her character between season 3 and 4.
Edit: Dirtyblonde,I suspect she will threaten his family if he does not join and Leo is forced to play along until the turtles get suspicious and help him out of it the predicament setting up round 2 and Karai securing her place as #2,but Shredder adds to his forces just who and how.
Jester
10-02-2012, 06:52 PM
In IDW though, she hasn't done anything yet for me to really form a solid opinion. She just seems there and is taking crap from Shredder.
I've gotta agree with the chap from my birth town...
ToTheNines
10-02-2012, 07:28 PM
I hope she isn't just a pawn for Shredder for long. I hate how she's been pegged as such ever since the 4kids show.
TheCollector
10-02-2012, 07:29 PM
I don't know how she expects to recruit Leo, though.
I don't think she's knows how either, did you not see the look on her face when Shredder suggested it? lol
But personally I'm loving her, I've always loved Karai, and was worried she wouldn't be handled well in this, still am when it comes to the nick Karai, though not so much now that it's shown the show is so good.
But now I'm happy she's been written so well, or as well as anyone with as limited page time as she's gotten can be written.
And I gotta say, at first I wasn't to thrilled with her design, much more happier with it now that the design has evolved. Just goes to show you, even when the book starts the character designs still aren't finished.
Jester
10-02-2012, 07:35 PM
I hope she isn't just a pawn for Shredder for long. I hate how she's been pegged as such ever since the 4kids show.
Though I know little about Mirage Karai, I can understand the feeling to take a strong, independent character and make them little more than a side kick of the "big bad" kinda sucks.
Vegeta
10-02-2012, 09:44 PM
Hasn't done much for me. Can see why shredder is looking to leo instead of her. She's just too needy. No Karai, you wont be the leader because shredder says so. Get over it
Lampy
10-02-2012, 11:40 PM
Hasn't done much for me. Can see why shredder is looking to leo instead of her. She's just too needy. No Karai, you wont be the leader because shredder says so. Get over it
What are you talking about? She hasn't shown any trait that says she's needy. If you're talking about her wanting to be top soldier... She was simply defending her place in the clan. You'd be pissed off too if you lost your promotion to someone else at work. She's a little overconfident yes. But what has Leo done that Karai hasn't? Slice shredder? Yes. Anything else?
Jephael
10-03-2012, 04:35 PM
We really haven't seen much of this Karai yet, so it's too soon to make an opinion. I'm kinda hoping she has a better grasp on reality than her animated counterpart with Daddy issues did!
The Big Bad
10-04-2012, 11:24 AM
A non-entity, so far; I hope the upcoming arc helps her break out of the "generic second-in-command" role she's filled until now.
Cowabunga Carl
10-04-2012, 10:24 PM
In IDW though, she hasn't done anything yet for me to really form a solid opinion. She just seems there and is taking crap from Shredder.
I'm at this point too. I mean it's neat they decided to include her and make her a n early edition to the Turtle lore, but she needs to do more before I make a formed opinion.
Jester
10-04-2012, 10:35 PM
To be fair, the Shredder side of the story seems to have progressed a lot slower than the Krang/Baxter/Hob side.
Candy Kappa
10-05-2012, 01:56 AM
I find her better then 4Kids Karai, but we haven't seen much of IDW Karai. I really hope she becomes a great character
MikeandRaph87
10-05-2012, 04:19 PM
To be fair, the Shredder side of the story seems to have progressed a lot slower than the Krang/Baxter/Hob side.
However,it took 17 isssue to confront Krang and 12 for Shredder,Splinter meets Shredder in 10. Its the pacing which lucky for us is the worst problem. The incarnation thing as stupid as it is has eased into it fine.
pannoni1
10-05-2012, 05:12 PM
Its too early to see how far IDW will take her, but it looks like a nice mix of tradition with a few new adjustments. She may be torn between honoring Leo and her grandfather much like 4kids, but it seems like she may be softer to Leo ala Lotus Blossom in the OT. I find Karai an unpredictalbe character as she can play a key role in the fate of the clan since she can switch back and forth between the Turtles and the Foot depending on the situation.
Panda_Kahn_fan
10-11-2012, 11:08 AM
I like this version so far. She seems to have all of the good qualities of the 4kids Karai, without the "Oh daddy Shredder! I'll do whatever you say! Even though I rant about honor and not hurting innocents, but I have no problem helping you kill people!"
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.