View Full Version : GMJ's "What if..." Segment 1... What if... Raph had killed Mikey with the chair leg?
GameMachineJames
10-14-2012, 02:20 PM
In "Meet Casey Jones", Mikey taunts Raph during some sparring, causing Raph's concentration to break and angering Raph. Raph responds after the session by attacking Mikey with a chair leg.
What if... Raph would have killed Mikey in this scene? Imagine the dark turn the series would have taken. Suddenly it would be ONLY Leo, Donnie, and Splinter. Raph would be off on his own. Lost in his own anger and unable to EVER forgive himself for what he had done. He might even join the Foot! Or any one of the Turtles' enemy groups. They never would have inroduced Casey to become Raph's polarizing influence.
Even though Raphael would never be able to forgive himself for what he had done. Donatello might. He'd probably be the first... Splinter would soon follow, his desire to have his son back would overpower any vengeance he'd feel towards him and he'd work with Raph to overcome his anger.
Leonardo would be the last. The most stubborn. Arguably, he'd have his own anger issues to work out, like he did later on. He'd eventually forgive Raphael, but no until after ROYALLY kicking his kiester.
In the end, it wouldn't matter that they do forgive him... Without Mikey around they'd never have survived Shredder's first counter-attack, much less the Battle Nexus or Ninja Tribunal.
TheSkeletonMan939
10-14-2012, 02:34 PM
Then the series would have received lots of hate for killing off a key character 4 eps in.
That's messed up, man. That bit still gives me the chills. I think at the last second Raphael would have just smashed it on the ground near Michelangelo's head if Leo hadn't held him back. I'm sure Raphael would have gone off the deep end if he had killed him, and I don't know if the others could ever forgive him.
Powder
10-14-2012, 08:35 PM
This thread is ridiculous. It never would have went that way. & let's not forget, that story came from the comics originally, not the 4kids show.
Jephael
10-14-2012, 08:51 PM
Okay first of all it was a lead pipe Raph nearly clobbered Mikey with, not a chair leg (in the Mirage version it was a money wrench). Second of all it takes a special brand of sicko to contemplate such a terrible scenario. I'd rather talk about turtlecest than the idea of one of the Turtles killing another!
GameMachineJames
10-14-2012, 09:05 PM
it takes a special brand of sicko
I'm kind of unsure whether I should be insulted or complimented by this.
Raphael was scared. He knew he WOULD have done it. That's what spooked him so bad when the others managed to slow him down enough for him to catch himself and stop. It's also heavily-implied that Casey had been killing before Raph met him.
Just because cartoons have a "Never say die" rule doesn't mean that it never happens. These guys DO practice the ancient arts of assassins after all.
Anyways, I honestly feel that, the series would have taken a VERY dark turn. But it would have been a very interesting one. Remember, these guys are FICTIONAL. It's within the realm of "What sort of stories open up of fratercide is committed on this show?" Not "He should kill his own brother lol!"
Jephael
10-14-2012, 09:14 PM
Remember, these guys are FICTIONAL. It's within the realm of "What sort of stories open up of fratercide is committed on this show?" Not "He should kill his own brother lol!"
Well I get it you were just curious, but still it's not the sort of thing I like to contemplate, especially when it comes to the animated iterations of the TMNT. Now if we were talking about the Mirage comics, that'd be totally different as it's more likely to happen since they actually kill people in that incarnation.
GameMachineJames
10-14-2012, 09:49 PM
Well I get it you were just curious, but still it's not the sort of thing I like to contemplate, especially when it comes to the animated iterations of the TMNT. Now if we were talking about the Mirage comics, that'd be totally different as it's more likely to happen since they actually kill people in that incarnation.
As they do in 2k3. Or was I imagining the sight of Leonardo decapitating Shredder and, thinking him dead, going home.
That's a kill-strike any way you slice it (Pun intended) and Shredder only survived it how? By being a freakish alien in a robot suit. A fact none of the turtles knew. For all intents of purpose, Leo killed.
kzekedaurus
10-14-2012, 10:56 PM
Then, as you say, we would have had a different show than the one we got; certainly a more drama-focused show. And that's not a direction I would've enjoyed. I'll be real with you. I'd be a damned liar if I said I didn't enjoy drama, sometimes even to levels of melodrama. But this just feels wrong for the series it's in.
Yes, it's a more serious show than the OT, and yes, their profession as ninja entitles them to kill when necessary. But there was never a time where I questioned whether they would kill each other. Why? Because there was never any indication that the story needed to go that far, just to deal with Raph's anger issues.
As you pointed out, Casey serves to balance Raph out, which is nice because it provides a middle ground that doesn't require him to completely give up his warrior nature. The show doesn't damn him, and instead offers an interesting message that it's okay to have anger, but also to have balance. Something he was supposedly learning (plural) anyway.
Plus it just seems wasteful of Mikey, who, instead of continuing on as a character in his own right, is relegated to being a plot device.
I think this show had far more entertaining story arcs (I'm not saying ALL of them), and I'm glad the writers moved past the "Raph is angry" theme to get to them. This is, however a valid "What if...", in that it's something Raph could have asked himself during a quiet moment or two.
Okay first of all it was a lead pipe Raph nearly clobbered Mikey with, not a chair leg (in the Mirage version it was a money wrench).Raphael gets knocked into a table and chairs and picks something up. So where did the pipe come from?
GameMachineJames
10-15-2012, 06:58 PM
This is at a point where cleanup and reconstruction of the new den is ongoing so...
pannoni1
10-15-2012, 07:55 PM
It would just be the franchise's own "Death of Superman" moment, though it would be too soon into the series for it to really have an impact; perhaps at the end of Season 1 at the earliest. There would be a funeral episode afterwards, and then the appearance of four TMNT "imposters", only to reveal that one is Michelangelo and another is Raphael. Still, being a publicity stunt, it may have ended the series much sooner when a bunch of fans tune in several episodes later only to see that the Turtles are alive. But, I would have changed that by having just thse "New Turtles" taking part in Turtles in Space, only to have themselves standed until they return until near the end of Season 3 in time to face the Utrom Shredder. It would have been interesting to see Leo, Don, and Splinter struggle to stay afloat from constant retreats, though Donatello may be more inclined to come up with some bright ideas just so the Turtles can hold off enough time until Raph and Mike supposedly return. This series was a bit under the radar anyways, and given that it was a completely different series, may not have been a bad idea, especially since Shredder keeps getting new life in this series.
gzilla46
10-15-2012, 07:56 PM
I don't think he'd kill him. Even RAPH would know that'd be too extreme. I think he'd just beat him up hard and the same thing from "Meet Casey Jones" would happen.
Galactus
10-15-2012, 08:15 PM
When everyone wandered off Mike would get up and walk off. Five or six episodes episodes later it'd be revealed Michelangelo had been an Utrom all along.
Jephael
10-15-2012, 08:36 PM
When everyone wandered off Mike would get up and walk off. Five or six episodes episodes later it'd be revealed Michelangelo had been an Utrom all along.
:tlol: Aw man, that's a good one!!!
gzilla46
10-15-2012, 08:37 PM
:tlol: Aw man, that's a good one!!!
Maybe then it'd be revealed that Splinter is The Shredder.
GameMachineJames
10-15-2012, 10:00 PM
When everyone wandered off Mike would get up and walk off. Five or six episodes episodes later it'd be revealed Michelangelo had been an Utrom all along.
This thread now has a winner! Nothing more to see here, people. Move along...
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.