PDA

View Full Version : What Is Everyone Collecting From IDW??


Redrumh2o
11-14-2012, 02:53 PM
I was not expecting the number of books IDW has been pumping out. When it first came out I thought I was going to be a complicit. That lasted for 4 issues. I also thought I was going to buy all the TPBs...that did not happen. Here is what I am collecting from IDW..,

1) All hardcover books

2) All Eastman covers (not the b&w covers though)

3) Color classics to have signed by Kevin & Peter.

4) Probably all red of all black IDW limited books

5) Sketches on IDW Detroit blanks

What are you collecting??

dkram230
11-14-2012, 03:26 PM
1. All IDW TMNT ongoing comic variants including retailer exclusives

2. All IDW TMNT micro/mini series comic variants including retailer exclusives

3. Color Classics, regular and Jetpack exclusives

3. Digital versions of ongoing and micro/mini from comixology when on sale

4. All HC and PB trades for IDW TMNT main series, micro/mini, and classic reprints. These, however, are taking a back seat as I catch up with the actual comics

5. IDW Limited- all labels and all offerings!

I'm a completist, but quality isn't as important. I'll take a lower VF over NM if the price difference is significant enough.

Chris
11-14-2012, 03:35 PM
From IDWs current line;

Ongoing TMNT (Just one cover, normally Kevin Eastman's)
Micro Series (Peterson's A covers)
One shots, specials, mini series, etc.

Classic Reprints;

Ultimate Collections Vol. 1-5 (more if they do them, but I like the idea of ending them at CAW)
Classics Vol. 1+
Tales Vol. 1+
Color Classics (but won't bother with the trades unless the single issues stop and the trades go further)
Adventures Vol. 1+ (and the original special)

Basically one of each, if I have the comic I won't (as a general rule) buy the trades and vice versa. The only place I've gone against this is getting the Color Classics as well as the Ultimate Collections. Figured everything else is being reprinted in colour so I may as well have a complete run. The Ultimate Collections have pride of place on my shelf though. They're definitely the best thing IDW have put out from all the classic material.

John Pannozzi
11-14-2012, 03:39 PM
For now I'm just buying everything they release in singles (except Color Classics and similar reprints), and the Ultimate Collections.

CyberCubed
11-14-2012, 03:42 PM
All the new issues, but only 1 of each.

All the collections. Why hope for IDW to collect everything if you're not even doing your part in buying them?

Lampy
11-14-2012, 06:15 PM
1. ongoing series (cover a and Eastman's variants)
2. micro-series (a & b)
3. ultimate collection

that's about it... still contemplating if i should get the other tpb's. i prefer single issues. not really into the bundling when it comes to comics... unless of course they have additions to it (not just layouts and additional pin-ups). not sure why though.

Abnormal Freak
11-14-2012, 06:17 PM
I've decided just to get the TPBs for the ongoing series, including micros and that, and skip on the individual issues, excepting one-off specials like Eastman's annual. Not interested in their collections of Mirage issues and that because I don't like the quality in their reproductions. I have the original issues in a box, I can read those.

Heather Breckel
11-14-2012, 08:31 PM
I've been grabbing the trades of the ongoings, micros, and ultimate sets.

LeoNerdo
11-14-2012, 09:08 PM
I've been getting One cover of every issue in the ongoing/micros, but they're all random..whatever TFAW decides to send me. It seems like I've got a lot of Eastman covers though.

I also have all of the Ultimate Collections and TPBs released so far except for the Archie series. I just finished collecting that series 100% in singles last year, so it isn't a priority for me.

rich
11-14-2012, 09:45 PM
Everything...with one exception. I decided to only buy the Red Label edition of the TMNT Vol. 1: Change Is Constant Deluxe Limited Edition. I'll do the same for future IDW Limited sets since it's the comics and books I collect, not the art.

Powder
11-14-2012, 09:53 PM
All of their original content, sometimes a variant here & there. None of the reprinted stuff. Some of it has appeal but not to my wallet at this time.

HotJuicyBurgers
11-14-2012, 10:43 PM
I've been getting the ongoing (covers a and b, sometimes RI when I really like it)
The micro series (same as ongoing)
color classics (no jetpacks)
Hardcover collections of Vol 1 (Speaking of these what is the deal with Vol 4 of these? It keeps getting delayed)

rich
11-14-2012, 11:32 PM
Hardcover collections of Vol 1 (Speaking of these what is the deal with Vol 4 of these? It keeps getting delayed)

About a week ago Kevin was finishing up his annotations and cover and the estimate for release was mid-January.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
11-15-2012, 08:45 AM
All of their original content, sometimes a variant here & there. None of the reprinted stuff. Some of it has appeal but not to my wallet at this time.

This is how I feel. I decided not long ago to replace my individual issues with the trade paperbacks and then sell off the individual issues, which I was able to sell off very quickly on eBay because of the success of this series (and best offer format). I have a few of the Infestation 2 issues and would like to have the trades for that at some point since there IS some TMNT material and I don't like doing anything half-assed. I have two different variant covers of #15 and will keep them at least until the trade paperback containing that issue is released.

bjaxx87
11-15-2012, 09:03 AM
Mirage-stuff only:

- TMNT Ultimate Collections
- TMNT Classics
- Tales of the TMNT

I'm reading the digital versions of the IDW series though (shipping to Germany is too expensive for an ongoing series).

Crabfight
11-15-2012, 10:44 AM
I'm kind of new to the TMNT comics, so I'm trying to get every story. Don't really care about which variant, color vs B&W, or bound vs. individual though.

Ongoing single issues
Miniseries single issues

Classics Trades
Adventures Trades
UC Hardbacks

And I had planned on getting the Tales of... trades, too, but I thought they had been delayed. Have any Tales of... trades been published by IDW yet?

thelouisguy
11-15-2012, 12:52 PM
Trades for the IDW original stuff. Very interested in the Ultimate Collections but the price tag making it difficult...

Matches Malone
11-15-2012, 01:10 PM
-Ongoing and mini singles to keep current.
-Ongoing and mini trades to read as they were intended.
-Ultimate Collection to finally get issues that have never been collected for easier reading, primarily City At War.

Above is the exact reason why I'm not buying the classics trades since the coloring is not that great and it's not being collected in a way that makes reading particularly easier as it only potentially saves yourself from pulling out 1 or 2 extra issues that you probably wouldn't have read anyway. Exceptions would be for actual collected story arcs like the Mark Martin stuff, but I don't really want to buy one volume and not buy the others; it's just a pet peeve of mine. I'm just waiting for them to do it right.

Lordmylar06
11-15-2012, 01:44 PM
Ongoing
Micros
Ultimate Hardcovers
Classics TPBs
Adventures TPBs

Jephael
11-15-2012, 02:59 PM
I'm collecting the Mirage Color Classics and IDW's ongoing original story. I really have no need for the Archie reprints since I already have the entire series collected.

TomWaltz
11-15-2012, 03:16 PM
I'm collecting a paycheck (as long as they'll keep giving 'em to me)...


:tgrin:

LeoNerdo
11-15-2012, 03:34 PM
I'm collecting a paycheck (as long as they'll keep giving 'em to me)...


:tgrin:

:rolling::lol: That cracked me up.

CyberCubed
11-15-2012, 04:09 PM
I'm collecting a paycheck (as long as they'll keep giving 'em to me)...


:tgrin:

And hopefully sales continue well so you guys can keep writing the series for at least 5+ years. :D

Venom
11-15-2012, 07:40 PM
Everything save IDW Limited items, #1 1:50 sketch, newsstand issues.

Archon_Turtle
11-16-2012, 02:04 AM
*sigh* everything.

pannoni1
11-16-2012, 07:27 AM
The rarest variant of each issue, since I don't want to conserve space. I still don't have a physical copy of an issue and have only read digitally up to this point, waiting for a fire sale of back issues. But I prefer vintage when collecting, so IDW is currently on my back burner.

raphfan85
11-17-2012, 03:49 PM
I try to buy the ultimate collections on amazon as soon as they come out. I also collect the monthly Ghostbusters comic.

ctt4lfecw
11-17-2012, 08:19 PM
I hope to get back to collecting the comics again soon. Im behind on 3 books. I think I need to get the 3rd Hardcover UC. I also need TMNT Adventures 2 and Classics 2. Oh and the Casey Jones micro.

Cheesebrush
11-23-2012, 02:27 PM
I try and get everything within reason. The retailer exclusives are difficult to get or just too expensive with international delivery costs, and the recent limited hardbacks I just can't justify the cost when I'm trying to save for a new house!
I started falling behind on buying the TPBs, so ordered a load of them a few weeks ago. My postman was not very happy when they all arrived at once, each sent individually!

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8482/8193510192_80e5c0d9c6_z.jpg

DrSpengler
11-23-2012, 10:09 PM
One of each story is my rule of thumb.

I don't go for variant covers and I haven't been buying the trades since I already own that material once over.

The only thing IDW's put out that I haven't bought are Infestation II #1-2 (I got the TMNT mini, naturally). I just couldn't rationalize paying $4 bucks for a book where the Turtles either only appear in one panel or on the cover.

If they release any trades with bonus material, like a short comic or something that I don't already own, then I'll probably double dip. Beyond that, though, it's just one of each issue for me.

Dirty Blond
11-23-2012, 10:20 PM
All the Eastman covers, although I've missed a few.

The Purple Dragon
11-24-2012, 02:32 PM
one of all exsept idw limited just dont have the $$ fore it

Slade
11-25-2012, 10:15 AM
The ongoing, doesn't really matter which cover. Though I'd prefer to have all Eastman. The micros. The Ultimate collection vol 1 and will get 2 and 3.

liugeaux
11-25-2012, 06:55 PM
Pretty much everything. I'm only getting covers A and B of the ongoing title, and I'm staying away from the Limited stuff. Everything else is getting bought.

SoundBlaster7
11-26-2012, 09:19 AM
Hardcovers and Paperbacks only.

Coro
11-26-2012, 01:26 PM
So far I have managed 1 copy of everything. Variant covers, hardcovers, TPBs. I have them all. The 1 exception was that I just got the Blue label from the limited. Everything else is 1 copy of everything. I also have all the action figures from the new cartoon. So far I have 2 long boxes full of IDW and figures.

rich
11-26-2012, 01:31 PM
So far I have managed 1 copy of everything. Variant covers, hardcovers, TPBs. I have them all. The 1 exception was that I just got the Blue label from the limited. Everything else is 1 copy of everything. I also have all the action figures from the new cartoon. So far I have 2 long boxes full of IDW and figures.

Nice! Exactly what I have except I got the Red Label (which hopefully arrives today or tomorrow). I was just looking back the other day over all the IDW TMNT stuff since August, 2011 and it's just simply unbelievable how much has been issued in 15 months. I'm not even going to attempt totaling up the cost as I simply don't want to know. :)

Coro
11-26-2012, 01:37 PM
Nice! Exactly what I have except I got the Red Label (which hopefully arrives today or tomorrow). I was just looking back the other day over all the IDW TMNT stuff since August, 2011 and it's just simply unbelievable how much has been issued in 15 months. I'm not even going to attempt totaling up the cost as I simply don't want to know. :)

HAHA I am with ya Rich...no desire to know what I have tied up in this stuff. I collect the figures as well and have a boxed and displayed set of all the figures and playsets. I really like the figures this go round. Not looking forward to the LEGO stuff starting up soon:/

rich
11-26-2012, 01:47 PM
HAHA I am with ya Rich...no desire to know what I have tied up in this stuff. I collect the figures as well and have a boxed and displayed set of all the figures and playsets. I really like the figures this go round. Not looking forward to the LEGO stuff starting up soon:/

I collect just the first wave of all the figures released (typically 4 Turtles, Splinter, April, Shredder, Foot). Anything else just gets too much (both in cost and storage space). I won't "collect" the Legos but I'm sure as heck getting them for my kids. ;)

Coro
11-26-2012, 02:24 PM
I collect just the first wave of all the figures released (typically 4 Turtles, Splinter, April, Shredder, Foot). Anything else just gets too much (both in cost and storage space). I won't "collect" the Legos but I'm sure as heck getting them for my kids. ;)

For clarification I collect figures loose. They are displayed or stored but kept 100% complete. The same will be true of Legos.

Toby Barrett
11-26-2012, 09:00 PM
I went from tracking down a cover A of each issue to just ordering all of the TPBs online. Just easier that way.

Panda Khan
11-30-2012, 11:05 PM
As of now I'm only collecting the hardcovers, TPBs of the ongoing series and classic reprints, and I have an annual.

Mayhem
12-01-2012, 04:35 PM
I'm collecting all the versions of the regular IDW comics, but that's it pretty much, no collections or colour rereleases and the such. I own all the original comics in first printing, so I don't feel the need. I may treat myself to a Black label of the Ultimate Collection #1 though.

Oculus Orbus
12-01-2012, 07:08 PM
For the first year or so I got a few variants, but then I moved back to Spain and they don't sell those around here, so it's become a lot easier for me to get the TPBs from Amazon. I haven't really started getting them yet, but that's what I'm planning to do. I quite enjoyed going to different comic shops looking for the variants just for the fan of it, but I'm not a completionist at all. Also, I've been gradually losing interest in the IDW run, but I like what they're doing with the classic material.

I might give up on the Ultimate Collections and go for the Black or Red Labels whenever I've got the money. This time around I got the Black Label Leo.

Jay $tarkiller
12-11-2012, 05:55 AM
Mirage-stuff only:

- TMNT Ultimate Collections
- TMNT Classics
- Tales of the TMNT

I'm reading the digital versions of the IDW series though (shipping to Germany is too expensive for an ongoing series).

Hi, if you want to collect the ongoing IDW series, there's a good comic store in Bonn...I actually get my IDW stuff from those guys, they even hook me up with the Eastman covers. Very nice guys, you should talk to them. 5€ for the comic & 2€ for shipping in Germany. Maybe this helps you.

http://www.comicshop.de/advanced_search_result.php?keywords=turtles&page=1

Viel Glück & schönen Tag noch:twink:

Allio
12-11-2012, 07:55 AM
Ongoing series - TPB
Ultimate Collection
Classics TPB
Adventures TPB
(haven't decided if I want Tales... I'm okay with the Classics being colored, but not sure on Tales)


yeah, I don't have a near by comic shop (aside from my own that I run... and it doesn't feel right to buy from my own store) and I don't wanna order something as small as a regular comic online, so I'm just doing tpb. sure I'm behind like 2 chapters a release of TPB, but what can I do

RaphaelsIsolation
12-11-2012, 08:12 PM
Basically anything. I can't find issue #3, I've read 1 and 2, looking for #3, I have 4 already

I got #4 in the dollar bin here.

I'm trying to get #3 at any cost. I'll be able to get 10-17 easily, but 5-9 and 3 are tough to find in shops around here.

Looking to get the Micros this christmas.

HugeBadWolf
12-12-2012, 04:33 AM
Collected editions for me,
No comics shop near to me, so individual issues wasn't working out for me.
Is nice knowing I'm not going to miss anything, not so nice being so far behind and trying to dodge spoilers :lol

Getting the classics reprints as paperbacks too, as well as the hardback collections. Mrs HBW is getting me vol. 1 for Christmas :)
Up until now the only classics TMNT I've had acces to is the four First Publishing collections.

Just started to read vol. 2 of the classics paperback, man, that's a weird story!

Cheers,
Doug

Theli
12-31-2012, 08:50 PM
I've just started to collect the ongoing Series... It is awesome, dudes! I've read a lot of Marvel Comics before..but a lot of them are some kind of confusing..This is here totally not the case.. The modern Issues hit the Turtle-Topic right on the spot if you ask me...Well telled story that really makes the reader curious about what will happen next...

Love it, never thought they would such a good job with it.

I wanna buy the ultimate collection soon..it is a must have for turtle fan...But 40 Euros is still pretty much for me...any used books to get ?

Powder
12-31-2012, 10:08 PM
Considering how costly shipping is from the US to Australia you'd be better of getting collected books like that instead of single issues.

Mayhem
01-01-2013, 09:30 AM
Maybe that's the difference... I get my TMNT comics from an online place here in the UK, who order thousands of titles from the US in bulk, and they charge £3.29 per regular cover issue (around $5).

Theli
01-01-2013, 10:40 AM
Considering how costly shipping is from the US to Australia you'd be better of getting collected books like that instead of single issues.

I live in Austria, not Australia, thats a big difference (I would rather live in Australia than in this crap european country)

Powder
01-01-2013, 03:12 PM
Whoops, I misread. Still, shipping costs could made collecting single issues a far more costly endeavor.

Theli
01-01-2013, 05:26 PM
Whoops, I misread. Still, shipping costs could made collecting single issues a far more costly endeavor.

I agree mostly.. Have seen a shop from germany issues about 3+ euro without shipping.... maybe i will get on 5 euros for an issue with shipping thats about 7 dollars or so..

Oculus Orbus
01-01-2013, 06:08 PM
When you come to think of it, it's ridiculous the amount of money fans outside the US spend in shipping costs. I don't even want to think about it.

Donatello_ftw
01-01-2013, 06:49 PM
I'm just getting the new series (some variant issues but I'm not looking for them specifically, just whatever my local comic shop gets) and I'm also collecting the color classics, they're nice to read instead of having to break out the originals.

theClintro
01-01-2013, 06:52 PM
Been getting the ongoing series just one cover each, the ultimate editions and that been about it. My shop was having an xmas sale and I picked up Tales vol 1. I Been on the fence about the adventures and just the regular trades of the Mirage stuff.

Cipher
01-01-2013, 06:54 PM
As of now I'm only collecting the hardcovers, TPBs of the ongoing series and classic reprints, and I have an annual.
This is me exactly. I still need to grab "Classics" volumes 2 and 3 though.

I'm still debating whether or not I should go for the two Tales trades or the Archie trades. I already have the 2007 Tales book and the old Tundra Archie trades. And, in general, the Archie series is just a much lower priority for me. Maybe once I'm more caught up on the IDW and Mirage trades, as well as old Mirage issues, I'll give them a go.

I don't think I'll be following the new cartoon-based comic unless I hear amazing things about it. Too many things taking precedence over it.

CyberCubed
01-02-2013, 08:29 AM
I'm still debating whether or not I should go for the two Tales trades or the Archie trades. I already have the 2007 Tales book and the old Tundra Archie trades. And, in general, the Archie series is just a much lower priority for me. Maybe once I'm more caught up on the IDW and Mirage trades, as well as old Mirage issues, I'll give them a go.

The Tales trade is in color, which is the only real benefit. If you want to see those classic Tales issues in color, that's the only reason to go for it if you already have the 2007 collection.

gobo
01-02-2013, 09:24 PM
I'm only collecting the trades for the Mirage titles and their own series ATM. After the Archie trades get to Future Shark, I'll start collecting them. If they ever release a collection or two of the daily strips, I'll be first in line for that. Danny Burger FTW! :P And, when they're nearing outta-print status and I have nothing better to do, I'll probably collect the NickTMNT trades. I imagine the only single-issues I'll ever have will be the ones it looks like they aren't going to collect in trades, should that ever happen.

Redeemer
01-02-2013, 09:56 PM
I wanna buy the ultimate collection soon..it is a must have for turtle fan...But 40 Euros is still pretty much for me...any used books to get ?

I bought TMNT ultimate collection 2 an 3 off Amazon for 61$ for the set, both books brand new and the shipping was also included in the pricing as well.

HugeBadWolf
01-04-2013, 05:22 AM
Just got the first Ultimate Collection in the post yesterday, it looks like an amazing book!
It's the first time I've seen the original art in black and white, previous readings have been from the First collections, and it looks great. Really impressed with the size and quality of the book itself too, I should be getting vol 2 delivered soon and am going to have to order the remaining three volumes too...

Cheers,
Doug

zaktheneutrino
01-04-2013, 06:09 PM
Ongoing Series (love it so far!)
Micro-Series
All of the Ultimate Collection books (really nice looking and love the annotations)
Probably will pick up the Tales of TMNT volume 1 eventually
Still kicking the tires on the color classics (might just pick up the micro series)
Infestation

Turtle Freak88
01-05-2013, 02:33 AM
Just collecting anything I can get my hands on. Went to a local comic book shop today and found a lot of stuff I needed. Finally found the infestation 1+2 today in the $1 bin, they had alot of those in there. Not really big on collecting every cover variant for each issue. I just usally go with the cover I think looks the coolest.

John Pannozzi
04-23-2014, 02:48 PM
Bump.

I stopped collecting singles about two issues into Cityfall because I wanted to wait for deluxe hardcovers like the Transformers and G.I. Joe IDW Collection lines. Now that they'll finally be giving that treatment to TMNT starting this fall, I'll definitely be collecting them (even if it may not be until the third collection that they get to the stuff I haven't read/bought yet).

Joey Kamikaze
04-23-2014, 08:16 PM
I've been buying the current book in singles and have everything bagged in chronological order. I've been holding off on all the trades because I wanted the issues collected in reading order--this book works so much better with all the one-shots inserted where they belong--so I'll be getting the hardcovers coming out soon. I've already re-read the series three times as it's been going... having it collected in reading order will be handy.

I want the Works books and I'll eventually nab the Archie books in some form... I grew up on those issues and there are later storylines I missed. But right now I'm too poor for anything beyond the main line. :P