PDA

View Full Version : What if Eastman was involved in the 4Kids cartoon.?


Keldor1578
11-24-2012, 03:11 PM
If Kevin Eastman was involved instead of Peter Lairs in the the 4Kids cartoon, Would the 4Kids series been as good.

TheSkeletonMan939
11-24-2012, 03:22 PM
If Kevin Eastman was involved instead of Peter Lairs in the the 4Kids cartoon, Would the 4Kids series been as good.

Eastman isn't very involved in TMNT stuff anymore.

CyberCubed
11-24-2012, 04:18 PM
Nothing much except Eastman would probably allow them to bring in some of the characters from the original cartoon.

If the IDW series is any indication we probably would have seen Krang, Bebop, Rocksteady, Slash, etc. all in 4kids at some point.

zodiac brave
11-24-2012, 04:31 PM
Eastman isn't very involved in TMNT stuff anymore.

huh...buh...?

he helps plot the new comic and did a LOT of the layouts for the first year of it. he's also a consultant on the upcoming flick.

i have a feeling that if he'd been there instead of laird, there woulda been less of an emphasis on the sci-fi stuff and possibly more noir style as well as a different type of focus on the martial arts. more 70's kung fu stuff, less psuedo-eastern philisophy.

CyberCubed
11-24-2012, 04:40 PM
Eastman's influence is about the same as his influence on the IDW series. He lets writers do whatever they want with the property within reason.

zodiac brave
11-24-2012, 04:53 PM
the topic is what would his influence on the 2k3 series have been instead of laird's. soooo....its speculation. considering the idw series is now and not then, there's no telling for sure.

plus, the way you worded that, you basically said that his influence is his influence.

Icebot
11-24-2012, 05:29 PM
Maybe they'd talk about that intersection (the corner of Eastman and Laird roads) in more episodes than in Angel's first episode.

k_lala
11-24-2012, 06:23 PM
Well I guess we can assume Saki would have been human, but i'm pretty sure the show wouldn't have been as good. I'm thankful Peter was involved the way he was. We got the definitive ultimate TMNT show!

Keldor1578
11-24-2012, 08:15 PM
I wonder if kevin Eastman would had made Oroku Saki into an utrom or kept him human in the 4Kids cartoon.

CyberCubed
11-25-2012, 11:34 PM
I wonder if kevin Eastman would had made Oroku Saki into an utrom or kept him human in the 4Kids cartoon.

If the 4kids writers came up with it, he would of let them.

Do people not understand that Kevin Eastman actually encourages writers to do new and different things with the Turtles?

zodiac brave
11-26-2012, 05:45 PM
If the 4kids writers came up with it, he would of let them.


did you ask him?

Powder
11-26-2012, 10:40 PM
did you ask him?

It's really not necessary... Think about the things he let and was willing to let others do with the property. Insane stuff, at times.

shuriken
11-26-2012, 10:54 PM
I don't think the series would have been all that different honestly. We Probably would have seen some Complete Carnage and Radical though. Maybe some of the more crazy TMNT Volume one stories (Sky highway anyone?)

CyberCubed
11-26-2012, 10:57 PM
It's really not necessary... Think about the things he let and was willing to let others do with the property. Insane stuff, at times.

Agreed. Eastman allowed:

- Creation of a female Turtle (Venus)
- Allowed IDW to go with the controversial reincarnation origin
- Wrote the ultra-bloody and violent Bodycount
- Is basically fine with whatever direction Nick is going with the franchise
- Is possibly allowing the new movie to change the Turtles from mutants to aliens.


The way I see it Eastman allows people creative-freedom to do almost anything they want with the franchise within reason, (I'm sure he wouldn't allow one of the Turtles or April/Casey to be killed off for example)

shuriken
11-26-2012, 11:35 PM
Yeah giving some creative liberties with your brainchild can be awesome or abysmal depending on those that are taking said liberties.
Ha Bodycount was ridiculous... but i still love it

zodiac brave
11-26-2012, 11:54 PM
Agreed. Eastman allowed:

- Creation of a female Turtle (Venus)
- Allowed IDW to go with the controversial reincarnation origin
- Wrote the ultra-bloody and violent Bodycount
- Is basically fine with whatever direction Nick is going with the franchise
- Is possibly allowing the new movie to change the Turtles from mutants to aliens.


The way I see it Eastman allows people creative-freedom to do almost anything they want with the franchise within reason, (I'm sure he wouldn't allow one of the Turtles or April/Casey to be killed off for example)

not to get into ANOTHER debate with you (not that i mind...) but kevin eastman had NO say in any of those things except the first and third ones as he doesn't own the franchise anymore. yeah idw has him on hand to help with the story and thats awesome and totally obvious that he's allowing things to be changed up, but if nick or idw themselves had wanted (or want to in the future) they could easily cut him out. i hope that doesnt happen, but again my whole point here is about opinions being posed as facts. i actually love that he blesses all these new things and that he always encouraged risks with his stuff. i humbly agree. :)

Andrew NDB
11-27-2012, 12:21 AM
I think it'd be virtually the same, with subtle differences. I would imagine those E-mail script note/bullet points from Laird to the 4Kids people that Laird posts on his blog would be joined by correspondence/feedback from Eastman as well, so I guess that'd be beneficial... maybe he'd catch logic foibles that Laird would miss or something... but ultimately it'd still be written for little kids and would still be a little kids' show designed to sell toys.

Would there be a lot of other wacky mutants and stuff from Fred Wolf that Laird would have said no to had Kevin been involved? No. Laird would have still been saying "No" even if Kevin wasn't against it and it isn't like Eastman would start vetoing Laird.

CyberCubed
11-27-2012, 12:31 AM
not to get into ANOTHER debate with you (not that i mind...) but kevin eastman had NO say in any of those things except the first and third ones as he doesn't own the franchise anymore. yeah idw has him on hand to help with the story and thats awesome and totally obvious that he's allowing things to be changed up, but if nick or idw themselves had wanted (or want to in the future) they could easily cut him out. i hope that doesnt happen, but again my whole point here is about opinions being posed as facts. i actually love that he blesses all these new things and that he always encouraged risks with his stuff. i humbly agree. :)

Tom Waltz still consults with Eastman on the direction of the series. While I'm sure IDW doesn't have to listen to Eastman, I'm sure if he really put his foot down on something they'd probably do what he wanted. In fact Tom Waltz actually said he altered some of his original plans for the story based on ideas from Eastman. Not to mention allowed him to write an annual of about 70 pages.

As for the Nick/movie stuff, again he has no real power over them, but the mere fact that he works with the writers rather than having no contact whatsoever says enough. If Eastman REALLY hated the alien stuff I'm sure the Turtles wouldn't be aliens in the new movie.

frank_one
11-27-2012, 12:03 PM
The 4Kids show was co-produced by 4Kids and Mirage. This means Laird was more than just a consultant for the series and that his opinions and advices was more than just that. If Eastman had been involved as a consultant instead of Laird, with the show fully produced by 4Kids, he would have been a less important role than the one Laird had

pannoni1
11-27-2012, 08:51 PM
I feel that if Eastman was involved, we'd see a more tightly knitted series with respect to their work, but it wouldn't be too different since E&L hardly played a role at all in the OT, and in fact the 4kids series could have been even better since Eastman tends to incorporate the humor/wacky action/more mutants to the franchise better, which would have brought back the OT fans sooner seeing that its still "Their Ninja Turtles". But Eastman also could have created controversy that would make 4kids seem very dumbed down compared to the OT. The bottom line is that it could have been better or worse.

Galactus
11-27-2012, 10:09 PM
I think it'd be virtually the same, with subtle differences. I would imagine those E-mail script note/bullet points from Laird to the 4Kids people that Laird posts on his blog would be joined by correspondence/feedback from Eastman as well, so I guess that'd be beneficial... maybe he'd catch logic foibles that Laird would miss or something... but ultimately it'd still be written for little kids and would still be a little kids' show designed to sell toys.

Would there be a lot of other wacky mutants and stuff from Fred Wolf that Laird would have said no to had Kevin been involved? No. Laird would have still been saying "No" even if Kevin wasn't against it and it isn't like Eastman would start vetoing Laird.

This'd be true if it was a case were both Eastman and Laird were involved but the OP was posing the question of what Eastman was involved instead of Laird in which case I believe the show would have been signifantly different.

I've not read all of Peter's production notes on his blog but I've read most that I feel that we've got a reasonable idea of his contribution to the series. Kevin is a lot harder to call but from little we have to judge he seems to be much more "hands off" or "light touch" kind of guy when it comes to overseeing TMNT related projects. For example we know that in Season 2 the writers wanted Nano to be the turtles butler and Laird argued against the idea. I can imagine Kevin going "sounds good" to that idea.

I also think the differences in their writing styles would obviously affect some of the stories. Laird seem to develop a more logical style were things had to make sense whereas Eastman still seems a bit more of a spontaneous writer. For example if the 4Kids writers wanted to adapt say "You Had To Be There" I can imagine Laird urging the writers to come up with an explanation of who the aliens are and and were they came from and their purpose etc whereas Kevin would be okay with the story as is. On the flipside the sidestory of Touch and Go was an adaption of Raph's story in Challenges but uses continuity from show to make sense of why a mob would be chasing, an idea that if not concieved by Laird seems very much up his alley. I don't think Kevin would mind why a mob would be chasing Raph if not having it be the Foot like in the original.

I also think the overall tone would be different. Despite the fact that Kevin seems to be the darker and grittier of the two (to the point that it's comical...and why not? It is comics afterall;)) It seems that Laird is the one that pushes for at least a superficialy dark tone. Even being a huge fan of sci fi and has fun with sci fi based turtles stories he acknowledges that it's part pf the TMNT's appeal to be somewhat grounded. From his blog he seemed to like the idea that Shredder being an Utrom means they could have scenes of badass-ness as he knew some adults would be watching as well as and give kids at least a temporary shock. In contrast I can't help but look at Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation and think what looked somewhat dark in the few opening scenes degraded into complete slapstick "the rat had a stick".

CyberCubed
11-29-2012, 10:34 PM
Anyone think the IDW comics are what the 4kids series might have been like with Eastman around?

It wouldn't be exactly like it of course, but we'd likely see more mature takes on Krang, the Rock Soldiers, Bebop/Rocksteady, Slash etc. in the show.

In many ways I feel like the IDW comics are what the 4kids series could have been like if Peter Laird wasn't in charge.

Lampy
11-30-2012, 06:34 AM
if what this question is asking is if Eastman had taken Laird's place... then i'd have to agree with those that said Eastman would've given more flexibility. i don't think the show would've been all that different. WITH OR WITHOUT LAIRD. like andrew said... i don't think he'd have vetoed any of Laird's directions. but without Laird involved and eastman in... i'm pretty sure it would've been just a smiiiidge different (probably even with R&B and Krang).

frank_one
11-30-2012, 07:30 AM
Anyone think the IDW comics are what the 4kids series might have been like with Eastman around?

No. I think the biggest part of the story comes from Tom Waltz.

ZariusTwo
11-30-2012, 08:02 AM
Probably wouldnt have been as...cosmic.

CyberCubed
11-30-2012, 08:03 PM
No. I think the biggest part of the story comes from Tom Waltz.

What I mean was I think the 4kids writers would have jumped at the chance to use Krang, Bebop/Rocksteady, the Technodrome, Slash, etc. if they were actually allowed to do so.

I would have loved to see 4kids takes on some of these characters, but I knew good and well they would never appear in this show because PL didn't want them.

Galactus
11-30-2012, 09:14 PM
What I mean was I think the 4kids writers would have jumped at the chance to use Krang, Bebop/Rocksteady, the Technodrome, Slash, etc. if they were actually allowed to do so.

I would have loved to see 4kids takes on some of these characters, but I knew good and well they would never appear in this show because PL didn't want them.

I wouldn't be so sure of that.

It seems from reading some of the email exchanges between Peter Laird and Lloyd Goldfine that the two of them were on pretty much on the same page as to what the show should be and what they felt from the old show they should avoid.

It's quite possible that if Laird had not in the picture the writers of the show might have used those characters and concepts but it doesn't look like anyone was really chomping at the bit to do so.

It doesn't seem like the Nick writers are either. Instead their focusing on new characters.

CyberCubed
11-30-2012, 10:21 PM
I wouldn't be so sure of that.

It seems from reading some of the email exchanges between Peter Laird and Lloyd Goldfine that the two of them were on pretty much on the same page as to what the show should be and what they felt from the old show they should avoid.

It's quite possible that if Laird had not in the picture the writers of the show might have used those characters and concepts but it doesn't look like anyone was really chomping at the bit to do so.

It doesn't seem like the Nick writers are either. Instead their focusing on new characters.

I think both shows wanted to establish their own identity at first with new characters, and after that's established, then they would go back and revive old popular ones.

I mean the Nick show has already brought back Metalhead and we know General Traag is coming. Aside from the usual Baxter/Leatherhead/Rat King/Karai....there have also been sketches of Wingnut and Screwloose. And with Slash's popularity and Playmates liking the character he's bound to show up eventually.

I'll honestly be shocked if we never see Bebop/Rocksteady at all over the entire span of the Nick show. I get the feeling that like Casey Jones, they're intentionally holding back characters for Season 2 so they can promote newer ones like Dogpound/Fishface first. After they're established they can go back.