PDA

View Full Version : TMNT #17 Preview and Review


strugler
12-11-2012, 04:01 AM
Releasing tomorrow TMNT #17 will sure please fans of of the original Mirage series the and the OT series.

check out a preview of the book on the link below:

http://www.tmntlair.com/2012/12/11/preview-of-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-17/

A review will be posted in the next 24 hours.

Powder
12-11-2012, 04:37 AM
I dunno how you get to do reviews when you have such a poor grasp of grammar.

Toby Barrett
12-11-2012, 05:25 AM
Bates' rendition of April is adorable.

shuriken
12-11-2012, 05:45 AM
# 17? Neutrinos introduced and befriending the TMNT, while I'm still over here with Casey moving in with the TMNT. Gotta catch up before i"m 10 issues behind. So is Kuhn not the artist for the series anymore or has Ben Taken over?

Jester
12-11-2012, 05:48 AM
Kuhn was a place holder between Dan and Ben.

ToTheNines
12-11-2012, 08:01 AM
Here's another preview if you don't wanna go to his site lol: http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=preview&id=14537

God bless Ben Bates!

strugler
12-11-2012, 09:00 AM
I dunno how you get to do reviews when you have such a poor grasp of grammar.

not sure why all the hate for me and my site, while all i try to do is contribute. Meh whatever!

I have two more sites, marveltvnews and the oldest one, hadoken.net, all the communities i deal with are forgiving, and respectful, i am so shocked to how some of the TMNT community behave against itself.

ToTheNines
12-11-2012, 09:03 AM
I don't really care, but the reason people don't like what you do is because you don't actually contribute here. You just show up pimping your site without discussing anything or getting to know anyone.

strugler
12-11-2012, 10:43 AM
moving on

Anyway, i was so happy to see the art for this issue. HUGE improvement from the previous artists.

I think Bates arts fit the TMNT even better than Duncan.

While i respect Khun's work, i felt his style never worked for the book.

Anybody knows if Bates is in for the long run ?

CyberCubed
12-11-2012, 11:05 AM
Wow, Tom Waltz has done his research!

The Neutrino leaders name was, "Zenter," just like it was in that one episode, "Four Turtles and a Baby" from Season 4.

I am impressed.

Dirty Blond
12-11-2012, 11:12 AM
I don't really care, but the reason people don't like what you do is because you don't actually contribute here. You just show up pimping your site without discussing anything or getting to know anyone.

This. So effing this.

We ought to really troll the hell out of you, but we're better than that.

Aren't we?

:tcouch:

frank_one
12-11-2012, 11:32 AM
I really like how this Bates draws the turtles, somehow they remind me of Mirage turtles, a bit of Lawson and a bit of Laird or Eastman, maybe. Mmmhh, more Eastman than Lawson. I still have to get used to his April.

Venom
12-11-2012, 11:47 AM
Very impressive artwork! Very clean and "mainstream", so hopefully folks who may not have cared for the previous art will come back to the title, and new folks will be more enticed to give Turtles a try.

Personally I disagree with TMNT being lumped in with "comics for kids" even though kids can read it without finding offense.

TonySiegel
12-11-2012, 11:56 AM
the comics have been getting progressively better again... was getting bored with the series, felt that they were in a semi slump, but things have been on the up and up...

cant wait

okguy456
12-11-2012, 12:12 PM
super excited for this! Thank you Ben Bates!

Matches Malone
12-11-2012, 12:20 PM
Lookin' good! It's really nice to see the Dan Duncan model of Splinter return! And other little things, like the return of the knee and elbow pads. They always felt a little naked with just wraps instead of those pads, so I'm glad to see them back. I also like the addition of the little holders for Don and Mike to keep their weapons on their belts. That kind of thing has always kind of bugged me, even back in the Mirage days.

HotJuicyBurgers
12-11-2012, 12:22 PM
The reason why people hate on you is this.

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/search.php?searchid=553372

Look at your posts, and I would say almost every single one is ,

"hey check out my site I posted something"

"Hey i'm going to post something on my site soon so check it out"

etc.

You say you contribute here but do you really? I'm not trying to be confrontational or anything, but it's rude to say hey I contribute when all you do is promote your site.

Coro
12-11-2012, 01:26 PM
not sure why all the hate for me and my site, while all i try to do is contribute. Meh whatever!

I have two more sites, marveltvnews and the oldest one, hadoken.net, all the communities i deal with are forgiving, and respectful, i am so shocked to how some of the TMNT community behave against itself.

The reason why people hate on you is this.

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/search.php?searchid=553372

Look at your posts, and I would say almost every single one is ,

"hey check out my site I posted something"

"Hey i'm going to post something on my site soon so check it out"

etc.

You say you contribute here but do you really? I'm not trying to be confrontational or anything, but it's rude to say hey I contribute when all you do is promote your site.

OK I literally just spent 45 minutes going over all 60 of strugler's posts as of today.

Of those 60 posts he linked and/or promoted his website in 48 of them, not including the links in his signature.

I would have to say this is a good portion of his posts. Many of them are things like "Hey I just read this issue and posted a review here <link to his website>". This is what people are saying. It doesn't really bother me all that much but it obviously pisses alot of people off.

Tinus
12-11-2012, 01:42 PM
Wow! :o Love the art in this one! Wasn't a huge fan of Kuhn but that's just personal taste.

Dirty Blond
12-11-2012, 02:07 PM
OK I literally just spent 45 minutes going over all 60 of strugler's posts as of today.

Of those 60 posts he linked and/or promoted his website in 48 of them, not including the links in his signature.

I would have to say this is a good portion of his posts. Many of them are things like "Hey I just read this issue and posted a review here <link to his website>". This is what people are saying. It doesn't really bother me all that much but it obviously pisses alot of people off.

It's pure spam, plain and simple. A lot good Dromers have TMNT blogs and dedicated TMNT pages on the Web; Jester, Roseangelo, Powder, Andrew, Jephael, to name only a few, but they don't post for sake promoting themselves. (That reminds me, everyone go read my comic strip, LOL, and bump the thread with praise while you're at it!)

He really should just be banned.

Zulithe
12-11-2012, 02:25 PM
I do not feel he should be banned, but he should cool it on the advertising. Just put it in your signature, maybe name drop when appropriate (just not every-other post) and try to be a part of the community here.

I too looked at his post history and while the # of links is overkill it wasn't as quite as bad as I was expecting based on the replies here. I did see *some* effort to engage but that's something he should really work harder at.

He is a fan trying to run a fan blog, I respect that. I feel the people in the TMNT community tend to enjoy lashing out at one-another and it's something that bothers me, I wish people would tone it down. When I visit my favorite comic book forums or video game forums I don't see this kind of behavior. His site only has two small ads on the right-hand side, nothing excessive.

TomWaltz
12-11-2012, 02:30 PM
Yeesh -- rough crowd.

But, yeah, TMNT #17 -- gonna be awesome! Can't wait for y'all to see it! Neutrinos be packin' some serious heat -- you'll see. And what's that sneaky Karai up to...?

Talk soon...

Tom W.

ToTheNines
12-11-2012, 02:32 PM
And what's that sneaky Karai up to...?


Does her "undercover mission" tie in to the events of Secret History of the Foot Clan at all?

TomWaltz
12-11-2012, 02:39 PM
Does her "undercover mission" tie in to the events of Secret History of the Foot Clan at all?

It's a secret.

Raph's Girl
12-11-2012, 02:49 PM
Princess Tribble's a teenager?! :o

Just seems like yesterday that she was causing all sorts of mischief with her telekenetic powers....

ToTheNines
12-11-2012, 03:04 PM
It's a secret.

Haha, got me.

MikeandRaph87
12-11-2012, 03:13 PM
So Dask was not killed in #14? Maybe it was his look-alike twin. :P Its time to make something out these guys so its fine. Even King enter's name stuck! Glad to see he is no elvis impersontor!

Leo thinking he killed Slash because of his mistake I think will lead into Leo considering working for Shredder in Karai's place. That has to play into it though I have feeling something that happens in Dimension X will only seal the deal of his temporarily thinking it would be a good idea.

ToTheNines
12-11-2012, 03:20 PM
Leo thinking he killed Slash because of his mistake I think will lead into Leo considering working for Shredder in Karai's place. That has to play into it though I have feeling something that happens in Dimension X will only seal the deal of his temporarily thinking it would be a good idea.

How do you figure?

AlZarkovski
12-11-2012, 03:33 PM
Krang, Rock Soldiers, War in Dimension X, Technodrome, Turtles... This is not comics... This is my dream!:o

And Zenter, Gizzla and Tribble! I'm impressed!

http://s40.radikal.ru/i089/1212/74/4b450e3da0e6.jpg (http://www.radikal.ru)

http://s019.radikal.ru/i608/1212/97/61f12e0c2964.jpg (http://www.radikal.ru)

http://s018.radikal.ru/i506/1212/ad/94c7c066b18f.jpg (http://www.radikal.ru)

CyberCubed
12-11-2012, 03:40 PM
LOL, princess Tribble grew up a lot from the time her episode aired back in 1990. :lol:

MikeandRaph87
12-11-2012, 03:46 PM
How do you figure?

Its just a theory. If Shredder wants Leo on his side then Leo will have to be broken down to consider such a thing. The way he feels about the Slash encounter I believe will cause him to consider it,but something else I suspect will have to happen before Leo is approached. The Dimension adventure is in the interim so I thought something MIGHT happen in that plot to further the plot about Leo being tempted to join Shredder. Like I said its just a guess.

strugler
12-11-2012, 04:00 PM
Yeesh -- rough crowd.

.

Tell me abt it LOL

Good job on the story mate. Really, the perfect blend between Mirage, OT, and original stuff.

Is bates in for the long run Tom, his Artwork is awesome, especially the action stuff.

strugler
12-11-2012, 04:04 PM
He really should just be banned.

LOL why don't you find my house burn it down, and then crucify me in front of the masses.

Dude chill! :lol:

i post something exclusive (like an early review, or interview) and i inform the people here that i did so. If i was JUST pimping my site i would post here every time i post something on my website, WHICH I DON'T.

Coola Yagami
12-11-2012, 04:08 PM
Maybe you do... but the hate on this forum seems to be so strong for some reason. I don't know. I'd hate to say TMNT fans are the worst, since I am one too, but guys... please don't make that statement true. Chill.

Andrew NDB
12-11-2012, 04:26 PM
"He is a warlord, a genius, and a squishy pink brain."

But only one of those things is true.

oldmanwinters
12-11-2012, 04:27 PM
Krang, Rock Soldiers, War in Dimension X, Technodrome, Turtles... This is not comics... This is my dream!:o

And Zenter, Gizzla and Tribble! I'm impressed!

http://s40.radikal.ru/i089/1212/74/4b450e3da0e6.jpg (http://www.radikal.ru)

http://s019.radikal.ru/i608/1212/97/61f12e0c2964.jpg (http://www.radikal.ru)

http://s018.radikal.ru/i506/1212/ad/94c7c066b18f.jpg (http://www.radikal.ru)

Excellent attention to the source material. I'm impressed, IDW crew! :tsmile:

Toby Barrett
12-11-2012, 04:36 PM
"He is a warlord, a genius, and a squishy pink brain."

But only one of those things is true.

http://i108.photobucket.com/albums/n35/barrett_toby/1330314071606.jpg

Andrew NDB
12-11-2012, 04:47 PM
Leo thinking he killed Slash because of his mistake I think will lead into Leo considering working for Shredder in Karai's place.

http://api.ning.com/files/ZhObUOF9jp79GPwIiaD0SkGQoymFZX0F3OfrvmTDpgicn11Jpf IoDGPbjTwCIgFM2tUDYLHZR2JgEgb5SEcuYyQl26JrbzTG/dickjones.jpg

I had to kill Slash because I made a mistake. Now it's time to erase that mistake.

Dirty Blond
12-11-2012, 05:14 PM
LOL why don't you find my house burn it down, and then crucify me in front of the masses.

Dude chill! :lol:

i post something exclusive (like an early review, or interview) and i inform the people here that i did so. If i was JUST pimping my site i would post here every time i post something on my website, WHICH I DON'T.

Yeah, you don't flood the forum, you just spam it.

Going on my Ignore List now . . .

Venom
12-11-2012, 05:25 PM
. If i was JUST pimping my site i would post here every time i post something on my website, WHICH I DON'T.

Maybe you do... but the hate on this forum seems to be so strong for some reason.

To be fair, if you look at strugler's posting history, he/she typically posts three or four time a month updating everyone on the newest reviews and commenting on a couple of snarks before disappearing until the next month when the cycle begins anew.

If he/she actively posted like Spengs, Rich, and others, then the perceived "hate" would be a non-issue as it wouldn't exist.

TomWaltz
12-11-2012, 06:19 PM
Tell me abt it LOL

Good job on the story mate. Really, the perfect blend between Mirage, OT, and original stuff.

Is bates in for the long run Tom, his Artwork is awesome, especially the action stuff.

Ben will be on for issues 17-20 for certain. Beyond that, you'd have to talk to Bobby about what is planned (you may have to water-board him to get the answer, though).

But, I can honestly say that I've been a lucky, lucky guy -- first Dan, then Andy, now Ben (and let's not forget that crazy rascal Eastman on the Annual). What comic book writer wouldn't feel blessed to be associated with such uber-talented artists?!

CyberCubed
12-11-2012, 07:10 PM
I'd love to see Ben get a 12-issue run like Dan Duncan did. His art is really good.

Lampy
12-11-2012, 09:37 PM
^ or more...

you know... the knee/elbow pads are nice to see again. at first, the bandages made more sense ("where'd they get the pads?"). but now, i like seeing a change in... wardrobe? don't really care if they explain the change or not though. it's nice to see them look more equipped.

as for the art... finally! been waiting for Bates to do his thing. i don't hate khun's art as much as i used to in his first ongoing issue. he's definitely improved. but having Bates on board is a definitely a sight. not so much cringing at the Turtles' faces. actually none at all. khun's talented but bates draws amazing turtles, which is where the art should shine.

as for the dask in #14... the two neutrinos that stormed krang's lair looked more like dask's and kala's fathers? the orange hair matched more of kala's than zaks. so possibly? just a guess.
p.s. i want to see leonardo wear slash's headband while working for the shredder.

Andrew NDB
12-11-2012, 10:51 PM
Good storytelling but I just didn't really care for the Neutrino bonanza in the issue. I think we've veered far enough into Fred Wolf country for a good while... I'm ready for other stuff. I'm cool with things going cosmic for a while, though.

Ben's art is awesome, he's easily the strongest ongoing talent I've seen on the IDW book. I don't think the somewhat flat coloring style of Ronda does him a lot of favors, though... a really lavish digital colorist could make Ben's stuff pop bigtime.

CyberCubed
12-11-2012, 11:11 PM
I can't help but think after the Neutrino war ends, the Triceratons will catch word of the Fugitoid from Neutrino battles, and then launch a full scale invasion to get him back.

Krang's army will fill the role the Federation did, and will be fighting two wars at once.

ToTheNines
12-11-2012, 11:18 PM
What the **** would they want the Fugitoid for? This ain't Mirage.

Jester
12-11-2012, 11:20 PM
Don't you know? He is CyberCubed the All-Knowing. Question him not.

Coola Yagami
12-11-2012, 11:21 PM
Good storytelling but I just didn't really care for the Neutrino bonanza in the issue. I think we've veered far enough into Fred Wolf country for a good while... I'm ready for other stuff. I'm cool with things going cosmic for a while, though.

Ben's art is awesome, he's easily the strongest ongoing talent I've seen on the IDW book. I don't think the somewhat flat coloring style of Ronda does him a lot of favors, though... a really lavish digital colorist could make Ben's stuff pop bigtime.

True, but you have to admit using the Neutrinos and Rock Soldiers makes for a different story than just the Federation VS the Triceratons. As cool as that story was... we have the Mirage comics for that. I'm all for a different adaptation via a different medium (the 2K3 version of the Triceraton/Fugitoid arc) but having IDW comics copy the Federation story from the Mirage comics would just be lazy.

This is a new comic, so let's see new stuff. And even though the war between Krang and the Neutrinos was from the OT, we actually never got to see it, except a casual mention here and there. Here's a chance to see it. As long as they're not yelling out 'hey yo daddyo' it's all good.

CyberCubed
12-11-2012, 11:27 PM
What the **** would they want the Fugitoid for? This ain't Mirage.

Do they have transmat technology? The Triceratons are such a big part of TMNT lore, and they have always been connected to the Fugitoid in some form, that it would be cool if we get small tidbits towards them in this arc.

Andrew NDB
12-11-2012, 11:29 PM
True, but you have to admit using the Neutrinos and Rock Soldiers makes for a different story than just the Federation VS the Triceratons. As cool as that story was... we have the Mirage comics for that. I'm all for a different adaptation via a different medium (the 2K3 version of the Triceraton/Fugitoid arc) but having IDW comics copy the Federation story from the Mirage comics would just be lazy.

You're suggesting that, not me. I'm just saying right now it seems like IDW is arranging predominately different Fred Wolf pieces on the chess board... and that a better eye toward balance beyond the Fred Wolf spectrum of nostalgia should be taken.

ToTheNines
12-11-2012, 11:30 PM
I take it you haven't read the Fugitoid micro, cybercubed. I can't jump your **** for that, but just take my word for it that Tricerton's won't be after the 'toid for teleportal plans.

Jester
12-11-2012, 11:40 PM
Do they have transmat technology? The Triceratons are such a big part of TMNT lore, and they have always been connected to the Fugitoid in some form, that it would be cool if we get small tidbits towards them in this arc. So it's another case of "Well they've always done it THIS way!" then, huh?

Come on Cubed, don't you get bored re-reading the same old stories over and over again? Change keeps things fresh. breathes new life into old franchises and stories.

As to the FW heavy nature of the IDW series, Andrew, it almost feels like Tom is answering all those nagging questions the FW universe left out there about the war with the Neutrinos and the brain warlord that was banished to earth and how he teamed with Shredder.

CyberCubed
12-11-2012, 11:47 PM
I take it you haven't read the Fugitoid micro, cybercubed. I can't jump your **** for that, but just take my word for it that Tricerton's won't be after the 'toid for teleportal plans.

Well the Triceratons are probably going to be introduced eventually anyway, can't really think of much else to do with them to be honest. Mirage never developed them much after the Fugitoid arc and 4kids just had them come to peace with the Federation and Earth.

Coola Yagami
12-11-2012, 11:59 PM
You're suggesting that, not me. I'm just saying right now it seems like IDW is arranging predominately different Fred Wolf pieces on the chess board... and that a better eye toward balance beyond the Fred Wolf spectrum of nostalgia should be taken.

What if IDW is basically making a more bad-ass version of the OT, while sprinkling elements of Mirage and 2K3 here and there? It does kinda seem that way... and if you look at some of their other series it does seem to be all about nostalgia, and nothing is more nostalgic to outside media than the OT. It's like you said several times before... the scales are tipping heavily with OT stuff compared to other TMNT series.... but it kinda seems that's the way they wanna do it and we're gonna have to accept it.

Coola Yagami
12-12-2012, 12:00 AM
Well the Triceratons are probably going to be introduced eventually anyway, can't really think of much else to do with them to be honest. Mirage never developed them much after the Fugitoid arc and 4kids just had them come to peace with the Federation and Earth.

Kinda rather they don't. Besides, this time the Fugitoid was a Neutrino and is heavily linked with Krang and his forces. And is now working with the Foot. I kinda think all of that leaves the Triceratons out of the equation.

Andrew NDB
12-12-2012, 12:04 AM
What if IDW is basically making a more bad-ass version of the OT, while sprinkling elements of Mirage and 2K3 here and there?

Seems like it. Just wish they were more up front about it from the start, as that kind of approach just isn't for me. Nothing inherently wrong with it, though.

Coola Yagami
12-12-2012, 12:07 AM
Seems like it. Just wish they were more up front about it from the start, as that kind of approach just isn't for me. Nothing inherently wrong with it, though.

I kinda see it as a way to make all-new stories. The OT had alot of concepts with awesome potential like making the feud between Yoshi and Saki more personal since Splinter IS Yoshi, Krang and the whole Dimension X thing, making Slash awesome where the OT failed, and other things here and there, as well as throwing in Karai, Baxter, Angel, and new characters like Old Hob and Apolex, all in one interesting mix. Sure it's an OT heavy mix... but it does lead to new and interesting stories.

Matches Malone
12-12-2012, 12:07 AM
Well the Triceratons are probably going to be introduced eventually anyway, can't really think of much else to do with them to be honest. Mirage never developed them much after the Fugitoid arc and 4kids just had them come to peace with the Federation and Earth.

You can't think of anything different or find a previous incarnation that did. Well, that's kind of the point everyone is making. Writers write for a living. You know, come up with new things. I'm sure most of us didn't see the reincarnation angle coming, at least in the way they approached it. Let's enjoy not knowing and let the folks at IDW do the plotting, especially if you personally can't think of anything different yourself. Let's remember and be glad there are those who can.

Jester
12-12-2012, 12:11 AM
Matches, I love you! Couldn't have said it better myself.

Bobby Curnow
12-12-2012, 12:12 AM
Gentleman's wager: if anyone still thinks we are leaning too heavily towards the OT in exactly one year's time from now...

..then you will have won the gentlemen's wager.

zodiac brave
12-12-2012, 12:14 AM
Well the Triceratons are probably going to be introduced eventually anyway, can't really think of much else to do with them to be honest.

good thing you're not writing it, then.

while i personally dont mind all the fw stuff being reimagined and "badassidized", i would like to see more radical changes along the lines of the reincarnation stuff. as a matter of fact getting into what thats all about has been one thing i've been really looking forward to. but also, the IDW version of the cosmic stuff in this tmnt-verse would be equally exciting!

great job, btw, tom! this book is one of the only comics ive recently kept up with and part with my $$ for! :D

CyberCubed
12-12-2012, 12:17 AM
Regarding the OT thing, I see the whole Krang/Neutrino stuff obviously being from the original cartoon, but the other story with Shredder/Karai and Leonardo reminds me of the 4kids series.

I'm excited to see the Turtles in Dimension X however.

Coola Yagami
12-12-2012, 12:19 AM
Gentleman's wager: if anyone still thinks we are leaning too heavily towards the OT in exactly one year's time from now...

..then you will have won the gentlemen's wager.

Mucho si!!!!!!!

Powder
12-12-2012, 12:28 AM
Much yes? wat

Matches Malone
12-12-2012, 12:36 AM
Regarding the OT thing, I see the whole Krang/Neutrino stuff obviously being from the original cartoon, but the other story with Shredder/Karai and Leonardo reminds me of the 4kids series.

I'm excited to see the Turtles in Dimension X however.

IDW definitely has a nice blend of the universes going, which obviously creates certain expectations, to which Tom, I'm sure, loves to play on said expectations!

I'm excited for Dimension X as well. I just keep thinking Turtles In Time and all the cool things I imagined as a kid. I think of IDW as the cool and badass turtles I remembered, as opposed to how goofy they really were in the cartoon.

ToTheNines
12-12-2012, 01:31 AM
So this arc might be a slight Fred Wolf overdose... But it is running currently with Secret History of The Foot Clan.


I'm excited for Dimension X as well. I just keep thinking Turtles In Time and all the cool things I imagined as a kid. I think of IDW as the cool and badass turtles I remembered, as opposed to how goofy they really were in the cartoon.

Haha, I know exactly what you mean.

Lampy
12-12-2012, 02:01 AM
IDW definitely has a nice blend of the universes going, which obviously creates certain expectations, to which Tom, I'm sure, loves to play on said expectations!

I'm excited for Dimension X as well. I just keep thinking Turtles In Time and all the cool things I imagined as a kid. I think of IDW as the cool and badass turtles I remembered, as opposed to how goofy they really were in the cartoon.

definitely... the Turtles were more badass in my head than they were in both incarnations. i guess my childlike rebellious mind unconsciously merged the two incarnations. and for some reason, i'm getting that same feeling with the IDW Turtles. so i must say... these turtles are definitely how i imagined them growing up.

Metallicabmc
12-12-2012, 09:34 AM
Looks like we got a hint at the future transformations of Bebop and Rocksteady in this issue! Im not offended at the use of OT characters at all. I cant wait to see whats in store.

I am absolutely in love with Ben Bates artwork. 4 issues will not be enough. MAKE HIM PERMANENT!

NinjaMan
12-12-2012, 09:41 AM
Looks like we got a hint at the future transformations of Bebop and Rocksteady in this issue! Im not offended at the use of OT characters at all. I cant wait to see whats in store.

I am absolutely in love with Ben Bates artwork. 4 issues will not be enough. MAKE HIM PERMANENT!

What was the hint?

Metallicabmc
12-12-2012, 09:45 AM
What was the hint?

Karai telling Shredder that she plans on "Enhancing" their army and Shredder making a comment that they dont have enough of the alien ooze to do that yet.

NinjaMan
12-12-2012, 10:11 AM
Karai telling Shredder that she plans on "Enhancing" their army and Shredder making a comment that they dont have enough of the alien ooze to do that yet.

Ah cool. Thanks!

okguy456
12-12-2012, 12:48 PM
These issues just fly by...one more month! can't wait to see what happens. and again, love the artwork.

Andrew NDB
12-12-2012, 01:05 PM
Karai telling Shredder that she plans on "Enhancing" their army and Shredder making a comment that they dont have enough of the alien ooze to do that yet.

Which makes the earlier comment with Bebop and Rocksteady in the Raphael issue a little odd, since that implied that Bebop and Rocksteady were readily aware of the Shredder actively mutating people into mutants and here in #17 it's like Karai and Shredder are just now considering getting into the mutation market.

Perhaps Alopex was the first and only effort and that expended their whole prototype mutagen.

Matches Malone
12-12-2012, 03:27 PM
Which makes the earlier comment with Bebop and Rocksteady in the Raphael issue a little odd, since that implied that Bebop and Rocksteady were readily aware of the Shredder actively mutating people into mutants and here in #17 it's like Karai and Shredder are just now considering getting into the mutation market.

Perhaps Alopex was the first and only effort and that expended their whole prototype mutagen.

That's what I figured. Since they got that mutagen from that Stockgen break-in, which resulted in most of it getting lost in that alleyway and the sewers, they probably didn't have much left over. Plus, it seems that a proper mutant (sound body and mind) is still relatively difficult to come by.

Which reminds me of a dangling plot thread which has yet to be answered since issue #3. How exactly is the Shredder a competitor to Krang? He doesn't seem to have his sights on the Neutrinos. Hmm...

Andrew NDB
12-12-2012, 03:34 PM
Which reminds me of a dangling plot thread which has yet to be answered since issue #3. How exactly is the Shredder a competitor to Krang? He doesn't seem to have his sights on the Neutrinos. Hmm...

My bet is because Shredder's benefactor is Ch'rell... and Ch'rell and General Krang probably don't see eye to eye.

Matches Malone
12-12-2012, 03:38 PM
My bet is because Shredder's benefactor is Ch'rell... and Ch'rell and General Krang probably don't see eye to eye.

I'm kind of hoping to see Shredder stand on his own a bit more, and motives more grounded, but I guess we'll see.

TomWaltz
12-12-2012, 04:44 PM
That's what I figured. Since they got that mutagen from that Stockgen break-in, which resulted in most of it getting lost in that alleyway and the sewers, they probably didn't have much left over. Plus, it seems that a proper mutant (sound body and mind) is still relatively difficult to come by.

Which reminds me of a dangling plot thread which has yet to be answered since issue #3. How exactly is the Shredder a competitor to Krang? He doesn't seem to have his sights on the Neutrinos. Hmm...

All shall be revealed...

MikeandRaph87
12-12-2012, 04:47 PM
I'm kind of hoping to see Shredder stand on his own a bit more, and motives more grounded, but I guess we'll see.

Same here. Chet is already unwittingly playing double agent. That should be enough of a link to the science. What do we know of Shredder's other enemy, the Savante ninjas?

I was expecting an encounter with General Krang before they go to Dimension X. Nicely executed though.

Too bad King Zenter is the Neutrios leader. I was hoping General Blanque would be or some time of dictator fighting against Krang.

Say,the microseries returning in the spring,it seems to be done in sets of four. Villains will most likely be the next spotlight but narrowing it to four? Any chance we could get six one shots instead? PLEASE! I will buy ten if you say "yes"!Hear than Mr. Curnow?

Plasticplayhouse
12-12-2012, 05:06 PM
Bates' rendition of April is adorable.

really? when i first saw her face, i thought for sure that there would be lot of complaints about it. i didnt really care for it. her face looks kinda chubby.

Coola Yagami
12-12-2012, 06:56 PM
My bet is because Shredder's benefactor is Ch'rell... and Ch'rell and General Krang probably don't see eye to eye.

Kinda thought the Savate ninjas were Shredder's competitors. Would rather not have Ch'rell here. Leave something exclusive to the 2K3 series there. Since Ch'rell is basically Shredder/Krang, it's kinda redundant to have him here since we already have a bad-ass Krang and a bad-ass Shredder.

DrSpengler
12-12-2012, 07:41 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #17 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/12/tmnt-idw-17.html)

Alright, as a lifelong hater of the Neutrinos, I've gotta admit this was pretty great. Keeping the neo-pompadors and ridiculous outfits whilst simultaneously trying to portray them as badass commandos was just hilarious. And slipping in Zenter, Gizzla and Tribble was an obscure bit of fanwank, but not a distracting one either (the fanwank in IDW's Transformers comics can't say the same thing).

I do kinda hope we get an explanation as to how Dask and Zak survived getting shot in #14, though.

What I really loved were Ben Bates's pencils. Dude's really good. I was skeptical, as I'd only ever seen him on Sonic and Mega Man, both of which employ highly cartoony art styles, so I wasn't sure how his take on the TMNT would look. It's great stuff and he's shaping up to be my favorite of the three regulars the ongoing has had thus far. Loved the smug look on Karai's face and little touches like Stockman's reflection in Krang's cockpit window or Mikey goofing off while dodging lasers. And he gets basic fundamentals like perspective and scale better than either Duncan or Kuhn did when they first started.

I hope he sticks around.

CyberCubed
12-12-2012, 07:49 PM
I wonder how Tom Waltz knew about Zenter the Neutrino leader. Unlike Zak, Dask and Kala who appeared in Season 1 and then returned for many episodes, the Neutrino leaders were only ever in a single episode, and in early Season 4 to boot. They're very obscure.

Is Tom Waltz having a marathon of TMNT cartoon episodes over at the IDW offices at lunch break? :D

TomWaltz
12-12-2012, 07:56 PM
Here's my review of TMNT #17 at TMNT Entity. (http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2012/12/tmnt-idw-17.html)

Alright, as a lifelong hater of the Neutrinos, I've gotta admit this was pretty great. Keeping the neo-pompadors and ridiculous outfits whilst simultaneously trying to portray them as badass commandos was just hilarious. And slipping in Zenter, Gizzla and Tribble was an obscure bit of fanwank, but not a distracting one either (the fanwank in IDW's Transformers comics can't say the same thing).

I do kinda hope we get an explanation as to how Dask and Zak survived getting shot in #14, though.

What I really loved were Ben Bates's pencils. Dude's really good. I was skeptical, as I'd only ever seen him on Sonic and Mega Man, both of which employ highly cartoony art styles, so I wasn't sure how his take on the TMNT would look. It's great stuff and he's shaping up to be my favorite of the three regulars the ongoing has had thus far. Loved the smug look on Karai's face and little touches like Stockman's reflection in Krang's cockpit window or Mikey goofing off while dodging lasers. And he gets basic fundamentals like perspective and scale better than either Duncan or Kuhn did when they first started.

I hope he sticks around.

Nice review! For the record, however, that wasn't Zak and Dask killed in issue #14 -- just some other Neutrino Resistance Fighters with sweet haircuts.

Thanks!

Tom W.

DrSpengler
12-12-2012, 08:00 PM
Nice review! For the record, however, that wasn't Zak and Dask killed in issue #14 -- just some other Neutrino Resistance Fighters with sweet haircuts.

Thanks!

Tom W.

I have obsessive-compulsively updated my Turtle Tips with this vital factoid. Thank you!

oldmanwinters
12-12-2012, 10:03 PM
I wonder how Tom Waltz knew about Zenter the Neutrino leader. Unlike Zak, Dask and Kala who appeared in Season 1 and then returned for many episodes, the Neutrino leaders were only ever in a single episode, and in early Season 4 to boot. They're very obscure.

Is Tom Waltz having a marathon of TMNT cartoon episodes over at the IDW offices at lunch break? :D

I likewise am curious as to just who alerted the IDW creative team to such obscure characters who only appeared in one mid-series episode of the old cartoon and in a few panels of the vintage Japanese Super Turtles #1 manga!

ToTheNines
12-12-2012, 11:17 PM
Ahhhhhhh, gotta love Ben Bates! Although, I have to agree with what Andrew said about Ronda being kind of flat... I think that hurt Kuhn's art a good bit. I was very high on her in the beginning, but Ronda isn't quite killing it like she was. The way she colored the glow of the moonlight was ace earlier in the run.

(Disclaimer: I can't draw or color worth a damn and really shouldn't talk crap on professional artists)

The story was pretty much all set-up for the rest of the arc, but it needed to happen. There were plenty of easter eggs and subtle moments to tide me over till next month though (plus Secret History will be here before long). I somehow loved the idea of Zak being a stoic bad-ass though lol, I'm really excited to see him in the next 3 issues.

The Shredder stuff was... interesting. Still don't see how Saki thinks this is gonna be a simple operation. Oh, and one bad thing I will say about Bates: I do not prefer his Karai to the two previous ongoing artists.

Anyways, this is the most excited I've been for this book since Summer, so I can't wait to see what 2013 has in store!

Redeemer
12-13-2012, 12:03 AM
Yeesh -- rough crowd.

But, yeah, TMNT #17 -- gonna be awesome! Can't wait for y'all to see it! Neutrinos be packin' some serious heat -- you'll see. And what's that sneaky Karai up to...?

Talk soon...

Tom W.

Good job Tom, great work and please pass my thanks along to Ben Bates really loving his art.

So Dask was not killed in #14? Maybe it was his look-alike twin. :P Its time to make something out these guys so its fine. Even King enter's name stuck! Glad to see he is no elvis impersontor!

Leo thinking he killed Slash because of his mistake I think will lead into Leo considering working for Shredder in Karai's place. That has to play into it though I have feeling something that happens in Dimension X will only seal the deal of his temporarily thinking it would be a good idea.
That is a good point, I am wondering how or what will persuade Leo.....

ToTheNines
12-13-2012, 09:03 AM
My bet is because Shredder's benefactor is Ch'rell... and Ch'rell and General Krang probably don't see eye to eye.

I don't think so. It's been hinted at that the only reason Shredder is going after what Krang has is because Chet came to the Foot Clan and told them what all was going on at Stockgen. I remember Krang scoffing at the use of the word "competitor" when Baxter used it in #6.

FoxZerro
12-13-2012, 10:12 AM
Great read, some really really great art. I loved the breathe that hung in the air during April and Chet's late night coffee date in the park. What was even better was the fact that only April had it, which makes complete sense considering Chet is a robot. It showed great attention to detail and the cold air breathe just looked amazing.

I'm also really glad that they just had the Turtles disappear and show up in Dimension X mid-battle. I was a bit nervous that Chet would reveal everything to April and then the Turtles would willingly go to assist. That would have gone against my favorite aspect of the Turtles, that they are just always in the wrong place at the wrong time, and I have to give my compliments to Mr. Waltz for being able to organically lead me one way and then still completely surprise me.

I still take issue with the whole "I want Leonardo as my second-in-command" storyline I'm sure it will be done in a cool and exciting way, but not as the groundwork is being laid it just doesn't interest me. Shredder just assuming that Leonardo will agree to be his second-in-command seems so out of character. I honestly can't think of an argument that would make him bail on his Brothers and Team Green and I think that's why Shredder's unwavering belief that he will get what he wants is throwing me off. Not only that but now it seems like they will be kidnapping him as a method of completing their goal and I don't see the value in having a great fighter on your side and leading your troops if they are brainwashed, doesn't that sort of defeat the purpose if you are superceding their thoughts and actions with your own.

Again I'm sure when it starts to pick up I will be able to live with it, but in the small snippets we've seen so far it just feels like an unwanted distraction from the action going on elsewhere

Anywho I am waiting in anticipation for issue 18 and love what Ben Bates has brought to the book. Knowing his work I was nervous that the Turtles might be cartoonesque, but instead he delivered the best looking turtles yet, they just look so badass

Seems like it. Just wish they were more up front about it from the start, as that kind of approach just isn't for me. Nothing inherently wrong with it, though.

I have to agree with this statement. It really felt like a bait and switch when you have the first four issues you have the turtles in all red bandana's and a pretty dark storyline to set the stage and then by issue 17 it seems like its only taking its cues from the OT. Its not that what they are doing is bad, I have really enjoyed a majority of the modifications they have made to some of the existing material in order to make them their own. Still when it started I felt like this would be more in line with the Mirage stories and now it's more like the Fred Wolf series and while I'm not necessarily upset by the shift I definitely understand why and how people would be.

Toby Barrett
12-13-2012, 02:31 PM
The first four issues' storyline was no more dark than the other twelve issues and eight micros have been.

Coola Yagami
12-13-2012, 04:54 PM
The first four issues' storyline was no more dark than the other twelve issues and eight micros have been.

yeah. the tone hasn't changed. it's not like their personalities changed the second they put on different colored headbands. I do wonder (since I haven't been able to get this comic) if the Turtles mention them now using knee pads and such all of a sudden, or if we just have to take it as a style choice and overlook it. I wonder if the next artist wlil use them.

FoxZerro
12-13-2012, 09:24 PM
The first four issues' storyline was no more dark than the other twelve issues and eight micros have been.

Having just reread the furst four issues, they were full of really graphic fight scenes, actually showed Casey getting beaten by his father instead of splash cut from him threatening Casey to Casey beaten to a pulp at the Antique shop, and there was a lot of just intense and heavy moments.

After rereading these issues after your statement I definitely think those four issues are much darker than the other 13 issues in the ongoing, but there have been micro series that were definitely on the same level of intensity as well as both of the Infestation 2 books.

Its so much that the storyline is dark, but the feel of the book is very Mirage, the hopelessness and the tone of the first four issues just feel like the original series, it made a lot of fans of the original comic books happy because it felt like we were going to be getting a book that was like the original. Then the mask switch came and with that switch came a switch in tone it became a lot lighter and started to rely more on nostalgia than on telling a new compelling story.

Do I hate that they did that? No, if I hated it I wouldn't rush out to buy each new issue when it comes out. However, I do think that the first four issues felt more in tune with the original mirage universe so seeing the book become so dependent on thoughts and ideas from the OT can be wonky at times. It is this wonkiness on which I as commenting on

Powder
12-13-2012, 09:53 PM
I agree with everything Tothenines said, short of his dislike for Bates' design of Karai (which I like more than the previous two). Solid issue, really great art style. The OT stuff is a bit overboard, but it's being done in the most likeable/tolerable way possible per my tastes, if that makes sense. I'm definitely interested and eager to see how things progress. Triceratons will definitely take the edge off, and i know they're coming. ;)

Andrew NDB
12-13-2012, 10:18 PM
Yeah, I agree the tone has been pretty consistent.

Lampy
12-13-2012, 10:23 PM
i honestly get what you're saying, FoxZerro. and to some extent i have to agree. but let's not forget that there are some scenes that aren't as light-hearted as you think. there's nothing light about four children getting decapitated in front of their father, or neutrinos getting wasted with one blast and chucked back into the portal like garbage, or splinter literally holding a sai to casey's dad's throat just to teach his son a lesson, or the hopelessness splinter felt when he was seconds from death at shredder's hands. hell... nothing light about Leonardo brooding over an accidental "kill". but i still think the tone is pretty consistent. i believe the grit is still there... all the OT stuff just distracts from it.

you have a point though. the mirage-ness was very distinct during the beginning of the series. maybe it was the duncan's crude art that eventually started fading with experience?

Venom
12-13-2012, 10:24 PM
Nice review! For the record, however, that wasn't Zak and Dask killed in issue #14 -- just some other Neutrino Resistance Fighters with sweet haircuts.

Thanks!

Tom W.

Aw Tom, you could've made them "important" by saying they were decoys so Krang would think those two were dead when the feces flings on the fan!

CyberCubed
12-13-2012, 10:45 PM
you have a point though. the mirage-ness was very distinct during the beginning of the series. maybe it was the duncan's crude art that eventually started fading with experience?

The Mirage-ness were that the Turtles were often depressed and struggling to hold together as a family, its a theme explored in City at War, Volume 2 and Volume 4. The search for Raph in the first 4 issues I guess was similar to that.

Otherwise its the same. I mean this series started off with the Turtles fighting a mutant cat of all things. That should have let you know right from the start it was going to be a nice mix of TMNT mythology.

Lampy
12-13-2012, 10:55 PM
I didnt say it wasnt a nice mix of tmnt's universes. I was merely saying that it felt very mirage in the first 4 issues as FoxZerro said. And I agree. They had to get the origin out of the way. The hopelessness they felt looking for raph without any leads was similar to the hopelessness they felt looking for splinter without a home in later issues. So its pretty consistent and duncan's early art reflected that hopelessness just fine. I never said it wasnt consisent.

ToTheNines
12-13-2012, 11:03 PM
I agree with everything Tothenines said, short of his dislike for Bates' design of Karai (which I like more than the previous two).

Upon reading it again, I think his Karai is really cool. Still the "least attractive" of the IDW renditions, but who ever said Karai had to be good looking?

Also, I didn't really notice upon my first read through, but that last page of the story was just freakin awesome.

Lampy
12-13-2012, 11:13 PM
Upon reading it again, I think his Karai is really cool. Still the "least attractive" of the IDW renditions, but who ever said Karai had to be good looking?

the 2007 movie. she was very pretty. :tlol:

Powder
12-13-2012, 11:20 PM
Upon reading it again, I think his Karai is really cool. Still the "least attractive" of the IDW renditions, but who ever said Karai had to be good looking?

Also, I didn't really notice upon my first read through, but that last page of the story was just freakin awesome.

Well I actually find this one to be the cutest, personally. She has a sort of spoiled goth chick look to her.

DrSpengler
12-14-2012, 09:03 AM
Bates's Karai is great, I thought.

That smug, superior knowitall look on her face during her conversation said more about her character than anything else, which is a great accomplishment for the artist. She looks like someone who has her crap together and knows it.

As far as her physical appearance goes, I'm glad Bates isn't trying to play her up as "drop dead sexy" or whatever, but she still looks cute. One thing I hate is when an artist only knows how to draw pinup girls and so every female character looks vaccuous and provocative for no good reason.

FoxZerro
12-14-2012, 10:26 AM
i honestly get what you're saying, FoxZerro. and to some extent i have to agree. but let's not forget that there are some scenes that aren't as light-hearted as you think. there's nothing light about four children getting decapitated in front of their father, or neutrinos getting wasted with one blast and chucked back into the portal like garbage, or splinter literally holding a sai to casey's dad's throat just to teach his son a lesson, or the hopelessness splinter felt when he was seconds from death at shredder's hands. hell... nothing light about Leonardo brooding over an accidental "kill". but i still think the tone is pretty consistent. i believe the grit is still there... all the OT stuff just distracts from it.

you have a point though. the mirage-ness was very distinct during the beginning of the series. maybe it was the duncan's crude art that eventually started fading with experience?

Yeah that's basically what I was saying Lampy... that when the OT references happen it kind of pulls me out of the comic experience. Thanks for the reminder of all the intense stuff that has happened it was nice to see it all laid out. Though I still have a problem with the way that Leo took accidentally stabbing Slash in the shoulder, seriously at that point based upon the placement of the sword and it sticking straight down I hadn't considered it a killing blow.

I also agree that the cruder art definitely gave the book that bit of an edge as I was rereading last night it was a nice surprise to be reminded of what they had looked like earlier in the series.

Oculus Orbus
12-14-2012, 11:14 AM
One thing I hate is when an artist only knows how to draw pinup girls and so every female character looks vaccuous and provocative for no good reason.

I agree 100%. Mainstream comics should get over it already. Not that every artist does it, but it happens way too often for my taste.

Andrew NDB
12-14-2012, 11:27 AM
the 2007 movie. she was very pretty. :tlol:

And was beat up by April O'Neil. F that movie...

Lampy
12-14-2012, 11:40 AM
And was beat up by April O'Neil. F that movie...

not my point. besides... it was a joke.

Andrew NDB
12-14-2012, 11:41 AM
not my point. besides... it was a joke.

I know. I just feel compelled to point that out every time TMNT Part Four's Karai is brought up in any kind of a positive light.

Lampy
12-14-2012, 11:52 AM
I know. I just feel compelled to point that out every time TMNT Part Four's Karai is brought up in any kind of a positive light.

yea i know, she was a chump. at least she looked good getting her ass kicked? hahah

Yeah that's basically what I was saying Lampy... that when the OT references happen it kind of pulls me out of the comic experience. Thanks for the reminder of all the intense stuff that has happened it was nice to see it all laid out. Though I still have a problem with the way that Leo took accidentally stabbing Slash in the shoulder, seriously at that point based upon the placement of the sword and it sticking straight down I hadn't considered it a killing blow.

I also agree that the cruder art definitely gave the book that bit of an edge as I was rereading last night it was a nice surprise to be reminded of what they had looked like earlier in the series.

no problem =].
the silliness of the OT may not be present in this universe... but it's easy to get distracted by all the OT references and completely forget that this universe is trying to take them seriously. IMO, the OT's silliness doesn't apply here.

CyberCubed
12-14-2012, 02:07 PM
Why does it matter? The OT's silliness worked because it was a kids show, this series is taking the characters and doing a more adult take on them.

Granted I know Viacom probably doesn't want things to get too hot and heavy.

MikeandRaph87
12-14-2012, 03:32 PM
I only picked up the series out of relunctance and the first five issues just were not for meas it was too depressing and dark,too much a black and white comic retread,and then there were the eye mask. I see now that some like that stuff and that is cool. Throwing in the '87 cartoon influence with other Other Media elements has really brought this comic into Ninja Turtles Ultimate style, no version barred from influence! Its not too much black and white comics or '87 cartoon. Its something for everyone and its own thing. The comics is running 4 and half stars these days. Keep it up!

Andrew NDB
12-14-2012, 03:46 PM
Why does it matter? The OT's silliness worked because it was a kids show, this series is taking the characters and doing a more adult take on them.

Then again, just about any take on the OT that doesn't involve heavy doses of camp or slapstick could be technically considered "more adult."

Lampy
12-14-2012, 05:39 PM
Why does it matter? The OT's silliness worked because it was a kids show, this series is taking the characters and doing a more adult take on them.

Granted I know Viacom probably doesn't want things to get too hot and heavy.

dude... are you even reading my posts? i wasn't referring to the OT's success. i recognize that the OT's silliness is meant for a kid's show and where that show shined. i'm fairly aware of the audience it was intended for.
what i was referring to is... we (or at least i) tend to forget that this series' OT related characters and concepts is trying to be serious for once. that it's so easy to think that since one character (or concept) is so silly in the OT, it'll be silly in this universe as well. somewhat blinded by what our general opinion of such characters are in the OT that IDW's version of that character inherits our negative opinion. that's why it matters.

CyberCubed
12-14-2012, 07:27 PM
I don't see it that way. How many incarnations has Shredder, Karai, Baxter, Rat King and Leatherhead been in now? They've been in almost all of them and people can easily distinguish between each take on the character.

And yes, I'm sure Rat King and Leatherhead will appear in IDW eventually.

Granted for characters like the Neutrinos who were only ever in the original cartoon, who only had ONE pre-existing incarnation, I can see.

Lampy
12-14-2012, 08:05 PM
yes... that's why character's like the neutrinos get shunned right off the bat even before they get any chance to redeem themselves. we tend to forget that Tom is trying breathe new life into them just because they were annoying in one incarnation.

Powder
12-14-2012, 09:27 PM
Bates's Karai is great, I thought.

That smug, superior knowitall look on her face during her conversation said more about her character than anything else, which is a great accomplishment for the artist. She looks like someone who has her crap together and knows it.

As far as her physical appearance goes, I'm glad Bates isn't trying to play her up as "drop dead sexy" or whatever, but she still looks cute. One thing I hate is when an artist only knows how to draw pinup girls and so every female character looks vaccuous and provocative for no good reason.

You totally nailed it, as usual. :)

Andrew NDB
12-15-2012, 05:39 AM
I do like the depiction of Karai here. Not sexualized at all, but definitely deadly... as she should be.

liugeaux
12-16-2012, 12:06 PM
After the 4Kids show, which is still a pretty recent memory, it feels great seeing secondary characters from OT. The mixture of new characters (Old Hob) and characters we haven't seen in a LOOOOONG time (Slash and the Nuetrinos) is much more exciting than yet another Triceratons retread would be. Not to mention, the quality of the stories is top notch.

Also, there's nothing more "Mirage" than the TMNT being transported to another planet/dimension into the middle of an intergalactic war accidentally. The balance is there, it just might not be in the characters.

Lampy
12-16-2012, 07:36 PM
I do like the depiction of Karai here. Not sexualized at all, but definitely deadly... as she should be.

Definitely. Despite my earlier comment, id rather have a karai with exceptional skills than a karai with a pretty face. Though... it wouldnt hurt to have a mixture of both. shes been training longer than the Turtles. So it doesnt make sense (unless a handicap arises such as fatigue or other contributing factors) for the turtles to beat her easily. I want a badass karai that doeant need the foot to kick ass.

Coola Yagami
12-16-2012, 08:45 PM
yes... that's why character's like the neutrinos get shunned right off the bat even before they get any chance to redeem themselves. we tend to forget that Tom is trying breathe new life into them just because they were annoying in one incarnation.

Exactly my point to anyone that fights tooth and nail to not have a more bad-ass Bebop and Rocksteady in this.

Lampy
12-16-2012, 08:57 PM
Exactly my point to anyone that fights tooth and nail to not have a more bad-ass Bebop and Rocksteady in this.

Yes yes and yes! I think bebop and rocksteady would be awesome if done right and miles away from their OT counterparts in terms of competence and ferocity. Especially when theyre together. Just because they were lame and stupid in the OT doesnt mean they have to be that way in this incarnation. I say Tom is doing an awesome job taking away the weaknesses of the OT and making something out of them.

CyberCubed
12-16-2012, 08:58 PM
Exactly my point to anyone that fights tooth and nail to not have a more bad-ass Bebop and Rocksteady in this.

Bebop and Rocksteady still need to retain their overall stupidness though. They can be competent fighters, but not too bright. Considering they're just random street punks as humans you wouldn't expect them to be bright anyway.

Lampy
12-16-2012, 09:09 PM
Im all up for consistency... but come on. Their stupidity is what made them so easy to beat. Nonthreatening at all. Like fighting a child. Average sure... but stupid? Reading through the other thread, that was one of the reasons why people hate the two.

Coola Yagami
12-16-2012, 10:50 PM
There's stupid... and there's braindead stupid. The human Bebop and Rocksteady we saw in the Raph mini might have been called idiots, but they weren't saying 'duhhhh' every few seconds and tripping over themselves. They were the average intelligence of any street punk, who as we know are bound to have a lot of street smarts and savvy when it comes to weapons and down and dirty street fighting.

I say they can already prove to be dangerous foes once mutated. We'll have to wait and see.

CyberCubed
12-16-2012, 11:30 PM
Im all up for consistency... but come on. Their stupidity is what made them so easy to beat. Nonthreatening at all. Like fighting a child. Average sure... but stupid? Reading through the other thread, that was one of the reasons why people hate the two.

They're steet punk stupid, which makes them still a threat.

Since when were gang members ever known for their intelligence? That's essentially what Bebop/Rocksteady were as humans, petty street/gang criminals.

Its obvious they'll be a threat in this series, they're not going to be push overs but rather mountains of muscle.

TheCollector
12-16-2012, 11:45 PM
I can't believe no one else feels this way, or at least hasn't mentioned it, but I am ecstatic to see Dask, Kala and Zak, I loved them in the OT, especially Kala, she was like my first animated crush. Glad to see they've included them. And Kala's pretty badass in this. Woo!

Lampy
12-17-2012, 12:07 AM
They're steet punk stupid, which makes them still a threat.

Since when were gang members ever known for their intelligence? That's essentially what Bebop/Rocksteady were as humans, petty street/gang criminals.

Its obvious they'll be a threat in this series, they're not going to be push overs but rather mountains of muscle.

Gang members arent all stupid. Stereotypically... maybe. But Ive seen some smart gang members as well as stupid ones.
Before we both get this thread derailed even further... ill stop with the bebop/rocksteady talk for now. Weve lost the point if this discussion.

Marksenad
12-17-2012, 12:16 AM
I can't believe no one else feels this way, or at least hasn't mentioned it, but I am ecstatic to see Dask, Kala and Zak, I loved them in the OT, especially Kala, she was like my first animated crush. Glad to see they've included them. And Kala's pretty badass in this. Woo!


I got my hands on the issue last night, Far out the Neutrinos are off the chain! I thought Zak would have been the Alpha male between him and Dask but i'm loving the fact Dask is. The Neutrinos have always been cool IMO but now they act agressive (due to the war..) I don't picture them with chipmunk voices. Is it bad i had Sam Worthington play Dasks voice in my head? As for Ben's artwork soooo crisp and clean, major improvement, hopefully he stays on for the long run. Next issue looks INCREDIBLE!!!

TomWaltz
12-17-2012, 04:59 PM
Releasing tomorrow TMNT #17 will sure please fans of of the original Mirage series the and the OT series.

check out a preview of the book on the link below:

http://www.tmntlair.com/2012/12/11/preview-of-teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-17/

A review will be posted in the next 24 hours.

Hey, amigo -- let me know when you post your review. Thanks!

Tom W.

Coola Yagami
12-17-2012, 06:05 PM
Gang members arent all stupid. Stereotypically... maybe. But Ive seen some smart gang members as well as stupid ones.
Before we both get this thread derailed even further... ill stop with the bebop/rocksteady talk for now. Weve lost the point if this discussion.

Exactly. When it comes to hustlin and down and dirty street smarts, gang members can out-think the tie-wearing office types. And of course, where brains fail, brawn prevails, which is the advantage Bebop and Rocksteady should have over the Turtles.

thelouisguy
12-18-2012, 02:23 PM
It's a secret.
You're the best Tom!
... you'd have to talk to Bobby about what is planned (you may have to water-board him to get the answer, though).
So, are you giving us permission?
Gentleman's wager: if anyone still thinks we are leaning too heavily towards the OT in exactly one year's time from now...

..then you will have won the gentlemen's wager.
Great... what about two years from now? :twink: Seriously, you guys made me like the Neutrinos so I have complete confidence in your adaptation of the OT.


Did anyone else go nuts when they did redid the last few pages of Mirage's Vol 1 #4 and Fugitoid?
http://i.imm.io/PBqW.jpeg

Ninjinister
12-21-2012, 12:37 PM
Is it bad i had Sam Worthington play Dasks voice in my head?

Looking at his IMDB, I have never seen anything he's been in... so I have no idea lol

Honestly I was thinking more like another Sam's voice... Sam Witwer.

corvus
12-22-2012, 09:46 AM
I really hated this art. Especially the way Karai and April are drawn. I'd rather have Kuhn back.

oldmanwinters
12-22-2012, 10:04 AM
I really hated this art. Especially the way Karai and April are drawn. I'd rather have Kuhn back.

Haters gonna hate. :trolleye:

Toby Barrett
12-22-2012, 03:30 PM
I really hated this art. Especially the way Karai and April are drawn. I'd rather have Kuhn back.

Never take anything you post seriously ever again? Can do.

Donnie
12-23-2012, 12:27 AM
Tom,

Any doubt about the direction of IDW TMNT I had was virtually erased with issues #16 and #17. Compelling, awesome characterization of each Turtle. I love brooding Michelangelo and pensive Leonardo. The Chet surprise was not expected but makes total sense. Looking forward to Krang Wars.

I have to commend Ben Bates - this man knows how to draw Turtles! Although I'm speaking more exclusively about issue #17, #16 was (in my opinion) Andy Kuhn's best and I readily enjoyed his artwork. Oh yeah, and the coloring has been consistently beautiful looking...but exceptional merit should be given to #17. Go Ronda!

Keep it coming Tom & co!

Slade
12-23-2012, 11:15 AM
I hate Hastings. It's the only place thy sells TMNT comics and I have a subscription, but every time I go their stuff isn't in order and now they don even have my copy of this issue.

ZeoRed
12-29-2012, 09:59 AM
I really hated this art. Especially the way Karai and April are drawn. I'd rather have Kuhn back.

Gotta disagree with you on that one. When Khun first appeared with his art work It almost made me not wanna finish the comic. It was just...awful. I'm digging the way 17 came out though. Much better than Khun's work. But that's just me.

Raph, hasting is the worst place to pre order anything. I cant tell you how many time's ive seen people go up to where the preordered dvds are and if they find something weather it belongs to them or not they will pick it up and pay for it and walk out without a single person saying anything.

I can only guess the same would be with the comics.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
12-30-2012, 10:27 PM
I finally read this issue today and was blown away. I love the artwork, especially the way Bates draws Kala. I don't care for his Karai, I could take or leave Kuhn's artwork for the most part, but I did like his Karai for some reason.

Working on a draft of a letter to Ninja Notes right now, hoping to mail it in time that it will be eligible for print in #18.

Venom
12-31-2012, 09:57 AM
Working on a draft of a letter to Ninja Notes right now, hoping to mail it in time that it will be eligible for print in #18.

Head over to the IDW Forums and post it in the Ninja Notes thread, it's faster, it's gets seen, and stands a chance of getting in an issue sooner!

MikeandRaph87
12-31-2012, 10:22 AM
Head over to the IDW Forums and post it in the Ninja Notes thread, it's faster, it's gets seen, and stands a chance of getting in an issue sooner!

I already spread myself thin on the net and don't want to have to register on there just to post letters. Though,I have sent in a letter three times so far and have yet to see print. Is registering on there the trick to see print? I had emailed the letter and labled it such in the message title.:ohwell:

Venom
12-31-2012, 10:27 AM
I already spread myself thin on the net and don't want to have to register on there just to post letters. Though,I have sent in a letter three times so far and have yet to see print. Is registering on there the trick to see print? I had emailed the letter and labled it such in the message title.:ohwell:

There isn't really a trick to it, posting in the thread has just as good a chance as someone who mails a physical letter or emails one.

Just be sure you place the phrase "okay to print" somewhere so Bobby knows it's, well, okay to print your letter. :tsmile:

MikeandRaph87
12-31-2012, 10:51 AM
There isn't really a trick to it, posting in the thread has just as good a chance as someone who mails a physical letter or emails one.

Just be sure you place the phrase "okay to print" somewhere so Bobby knows it's, well, okay to print your letter. :tsmile:

"Okay to print" is somethng this fella did not know. I thought it was impiled that I wanted it to see print. Thanks,dude.

Bobby Curnow
12-31-2012, 12:48 PM
"[email protected]" is the most surefire way for me to see, but I check the IDW forum too.

No real trick to getting published. Every issue we get a fair amount of letters that say the same thing, so the best way to get included is to ask a unique question, or tell a unique story.

For what it's worth, the letters column for TMNT#19 was finished last week. Anything now would be going in possibly for TMNT#20.

FlawedCoil82
01-01-2013, 10:44 PM
I am definitely liking the new artist over what we had before. I just was not a fan of Andy Kuhn's artwork. All of my comic book money is now going solely to IDW for both their TMNT and Godzilla titles (which has also become another huge improvement over what we had before). Sorry Marvel, you entirely slaughtered the X-Men's appeal for me when you robbed them of their flawless 90's uniforms and team lineups/interesting villains. Now IDW are the only ones giving me what I want.

CyberCubed
01-01-2013, 11:22 PM
^ And screwing up Spiderman.

Xav
01-02-2013, 01:33 AM
Granted for characters like the Neutrinos who were only ever in the original cartoon, who only had ONE pre-existing incarnation, I can see.Weren't they in the Archie books?

MikeandRaph87
01-02-2013, 07:25 AM
Weren't they in the Archie books?

Yes,they were in the adaptation of the fourth episode,but that was it. Like Baxter Stockman they were only present because the first seven episodes were adapted into the begining of the Archie comic.

CyberCubed
01-02-2013, 08:27 AM
I always wish Murphy did at least one story arc with the Rock Soldiers and the Neutrinos instead of just pushing them to the side and ignoring them as if Krang had no army and had to beg Malinga for help.

Panda_Kahn_fan
01-04-2013, 11:38 AM
Awesome seeing the Neutrnios back, and this story is actually what I could have seen the 'turtles in space'- fugitoid arc being like in a serious version of the Fred Wolf universe. I wonder if we'll get any Mikey/Kala stuff? (I know, I can already hear half of you becoming enraged at the suggestion! :x )

CyberCubed
01-04-2013, 11:52 AM
I wouldn't be surprised to see Kala flirt with Michaelangelo.

ToTheNines
01-04-2013, 03:28 PM
I feel like a lot of people haven't picked up on this, but I'm pretty interested in who Krang is actually at war with here. Currently he's taking over the planet Neutrino, but only because he wishes to occupy it as his base since Utominon went kablooey. There really hasn't been a single hint towards who his real enemy is, I don't think.

Obvious pick is the Triceratons. I'll be pretty pissed if the identity isn't revealed by the end of the Krang War arc.

MikeandRaph87
01-04-2013, 04:02 PM
I thought it would have a cool twist if General Blanque was the dictator of Nuetrino. The nuetrino royal couple in the cartoon never sat well with me since they seemed to contradict what the nuetrinos were all about.Though their surprising usage in IDW looks to be handled better.I still think General Blanque would be a worthwhile opponent to Krang and perhaps blocking him from conquering a specific solar system he rules. I note Andrew's theory of Chr'ell being involved somehow. It has merit but its just this feeling that Ch'rell is not involved. I just don't see it though I could be wrong. This sense that Blanque is involved somehow may be entirely incorrect. I actually guessed right on Slash so one never knows. We should know something by the end of part 2 of 3 of the uncoming arc and have thru 22 is teaser summary by then which will open the massive 7 parter Tom revealed that will follow on the heels of Kevin's oneshot art issue.

Andrew NDB
01-04-2013, 04:22 PM
I thought it would have a cool twist if General Blanque was the dictator of Nuetrino. The nuetrino royal couple in the cartoon never sat well with me since they seemed to contradict what the nuetrinos were all about.Though their surprising usage in IDW looks to be handled better.I still think General Blanque would be a worthwhile opponent to Krang and perhaps blocking him from conquering a specific solar system he rules. I note Andrew's theory of Chr'ell being involved somehow. It has merit but its just this feeling that Ch'rell is not involved. I just don't see it though I could be wrong. This sense that Blanque is involved somehow may be entirely incorrect. I actually guessed right on Slash so one never knows. We should know something by the end of part 2 of 3 of the uncoming arc and have thru 22 is teaser summary by then which will open the massive 7 parter Tom revealed that will follow on the heels of Kevin's oneshot art issue.

Krang's "war," what really happened on the Utrom homeworld... and then we have Ch'rell and the Triceratons. Those two are the variables, the chess pieces... but I'm just not sure how IDW is going to place or play them on the board. I just know that they will.

MikeandRaph87
01-04-2013, 05:11 PM
That is one of the things I am enjoying about this series. The variety of different characters that could return in a new form.Our guessing game keeps things interesting.Its just would Zandramon be Krang's subordinate that fees Krang's intergalactic army like conquered countries/city-states did for Rome or would they have a planet of their own and their savagery yet ingenuity take a bite out of Krang's attempt conquest nd Zandramon be this enemy Krang speaks of that is not Shredder and assumingly not Zenter either. Ch'rell another utrom overlord be this enemy? Possible!Where does General Blanque fit or perhaps he does not at all. I do believe we will know for sure by #20's conclusion whom Krang was referring to.

Jester
01-04-2013, 05:22 PM
I really hope you're wrong about Ch'rell. Outside of being the 4Kids Shredder he wasn't really a very well conceived character.

Andrew NDB
01-04-2013, 05:25 PM
I really hope you're wrong about Ch'rell. Outside of being the 4Kids Shredder he wasn't really a very well conceived character.

He's just as well conceived and valid as Krang ever was.

ToTheNines
01-04-2013, 05:28 PM
Having Krang, Ch'rell and Saki around makes at least one of them expendable. So maybe the book could show some teeth outside of the feudal Japan setting and off one of them.

Jester
01-04-2013, 05:34 PM
I anticipated you'd say that, Andrew...

Krang at least had a personality. Ch'rell was just... "MUHAHAH! I'z eval!"

I'd take goofy but "likeable" Krang over the obviously mustache twirling Ch'rell any day of the week.

As for maybe making Ch'rell expendable.... I could get behind that.

Andrew NDB
01-04-2013, 05:40 PM
Having Krang, Ch'rell and Saki around makes at least one of them expendable. So maybe the book could show some teeth outside of the feudal Japan setting and off one of them.

Maybe. So far it doesn't seem like anybody ever dies in IDW TMNT unless you're talking about a character from Feudal Japan... and even then, there's a good chance they've already reincarnated anyway.

MikeandRaph87
01-04-2013, 07:00 PM
Having Krang, Ch'rell and Saki around makes at least one of them expendable. So maybe the book could show some teeth outside of the feudal Japan setting and off one of them.

That could work. I'm for that. Just as long as its that Shredder/Krang amlagam,Chr'ell! Shredder and Krang can work together to remove him from the chess board then slice and dice and blow him up!:D Those more drawn to the non-Archie comics have a dead villain and for those of us that don't want the big bad dead, Shredder(Krang too!) can carry on as reoccuring threats that oppose the TMNT and each other! That seems compromise enough and in a way Shredder is dead while the Shredder of this version lives on to strike terror as a reincarnated warrior clansman and learder of an evil army. The last issue hopefully a decade or so away can see Shredder's demise.

Panda_Kahn_fan
01-05-2013, 12:47 PM
Not insulting anyone, just a legitimate question;

There has been no indication in the text anywhere, that C'herell will show up in IDW, I don't get why people keep expecting him. :-? His only purpose was in 4 Kids, to tie the origins of the turtles and the shredder character together, and to makes the 4kids shredder diffrent. What purpose would he serve in IDW? And where are the clues he will appear? :-?

ToTheNines
01-05-2013, 01:28 PM
There's been nothing super concrete, but the writing's on the wall.

I mean how else could Shredder be considered Krang's competitor when Krang doesn't seem to give a **** about anything related to Earth? Not to mention Shredder being resurrected, and not by means of reincarnation like the turtles.

The biggest thing for me was in #6, when Splinter is recounting his early days at Stockgen, he says "... I also began to realize the our reunion had a purpose, the scientists were working toward evil ends - a kind of secretive military domination that felt disturbingly familiar to me". I took that as Krang's direction of Stockgen gave Splinter a weird vibe similar to Ch'rell's own puppeteering of Saki and the Foot Clan all those years ago.

More recently in the preview for Secret History of the Foot Clan, Tatsuo gets his leg chopped off, then reapplied by a cloaked stranger who appears to be using the ooze to heal him. Then Dr. Miller refers to the Foot being involved with a witch and her patron "The Iron Demon". My money's on Ch'rell.

Plus there's been a few small things like Alopex's hideout at the end of "Raphael" looking particularly alien. That had to have been on purpose, the art team wouldn't go out of their way to make it anything other than "standard abandoned warehouse bad guy hideout" unless directed to do so.

That could work. I'm for that. Just as long as its that Shredder/Krang amlagam,Chr'ell! Shredder and Krang can work together to remove him from the chess board then slice and dice and blow him up!:D Those more drawn to the non-Archie comics have a dead villain and for those of us that don't want the big bad dead, Shredder(Krang too!) can carry on as reoccuring threats that oppose the TMNT and each other! That seems compromise enough and in a way Shredder is dead while the Shredder of this version lives on to strike terror as a reincarnated warrior clansman and learder of an evil army. The last issue hopefully a decade or so away can see Shredder's demise.

If anything, it would be Shredder and Ch'rell vs. Krang. But I was talking more along the lines of the Turtles getting rid of one of them. If there's one thing I want out of this comic, it's for Splinter to get his revenge on Saki.

Venom
01-05-2013, 02:08 PM
There's been nothing super concrete, but the writing's on the wall.

I mean how else could Shredder be considered Krang's competitor when Krang doesn't seem to give a **** about anything related to Earth? Not to mention Shredder being resurrected, and not by means of reincarnation like the turtles.

What if Krang learned of Saki's resurrected nature and took an interest in capturing him to learn how he was brought back to life so Krang could use that to bring back the Utroms (remember, apparently he and his kin are the only remaining Oots).

ToTheNines
01-05-2013, 02:20 PM
What if Krang learned of Saki's resurrected nature and took an interest in capturing him to learn how he was brought back to life so Krang could use that to bring back the Utroms (remember, apparently he and his kin are the only remaining Oots).

That's very interesting, and could possibly be a cool storyline line in the future, but Krang isn't too familiar with Saki right now. He referred to him as a bug who could be swatted a whiles back.

Panda_Kahn_fan
01-05-2013, 02:22 PM
Really, I think the witch and the Tengu bit- along with Shredder's ressurection- will have more to do with the supernatural causes than anything to do with aliens. There doesn't seem to be any hint of C'hrell there.

Also, Krang didn't consider Shedder his rival, he dismissed Shredder and the conflict he was in (Which we now know is with the Savate ninjas)as 'meaningless'compared to Krang's mission. And it never said Krang and Shredder were rivals, Baxter called him his 'competetor'. I believe Baxter was referring to the fact that both are using mutagen to create mutants- remember, from Baxter's point of view at the time, Krang was some human warlord with a lot of money and tech, who was paying him to make soldiers and wepons. His natural assumption about the ninjas who stole the mutagen was that thy worked for some competeing warlord,/general, who wanted mutant super soldiers of his own. Again, no Ch'rell.

ToTheNines
01-05-2013, 02:24 PM
Really, I think the witch and the Tengu bit- along with Shredder's ressurection- will have more to do with the supernatural causes than anything to do with aliens. There doesn't seem to be any hint of C'hrell there.

I must have missed the Tengu part you're talking about... but someone dubbed "The Iron Demon" could certainly be an Utrom in an exosuit.

ToTheNines
01-05-2013, 03:49 PM
Also, I don't know if you have seen the cover for #4, but I'd say this beast (complete with design sensibilities that are strikingly similar to Krang's own exo suit) is the one called The Iron Demon:

http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/TMNT_SecretHistoryoftheFootClan_04_rich.jpg

Seeing this cover a few weeks ago was actually the first thing made me seriously consider to possibility of Ch'rell.

darthsmozers
01-05-2013, 06:45 PM
To be fair, if you look at strugler's posting history, he/she typically posts three or four time a month updating everyone on the newest reviews and commenting on a couple of snarks before disappearing until the next month when the cycle begins anew.

If he/she actively posted like Spengs, Rich, and others, then the perceived "hate" would be a non-issue as it wouldn't exist.

Forgive the veering off course ... I began reading this thread at the beginning. Just wanted to comment...The fact that people are using the word "hate" (not you Venom) in a forum about comic book and cartoon characters means some take things a little too seriously. This person enjoys their site, thinks its great, and is sharing it with fans. A few posts per month is hardly anything. Folks should Ignore it and move on instead of being cranky.

In other news, the cover ToTheNines posted above is ridiculous. How cool! He mentioned krang's android body. Kinda looks like it..??

darthsmozers
01-05-2013, 06:46 PM
Also, I don't know if you have seen the cover for #4, but I'd say this beast (complete with design sensibilities that are strikingly similar to Krang's own exo suit) is the one called The Iron Demon:

ToTheNines, who is the man in the middle of that picture? (i havent read this miniseries yet).

ToTheNines
01-05-2013, 06:50 PM
Dr. Patrick Miller. He's a historian who uncovers some information about the Foot clan's early days. Check out the preview for #1: http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=preview&id=14763

frank_one
01-06-2013, 10:23 AM
Plus there's been a few small things like Alopex's hideout at the end of "Raphael" looking particularly alien. That had to have been on purpose, the art team wouldn't go out of their way to make it anything other than "standard abandoned warehouse bad guy hideout" unless directed to do so.
Good point, I've never noticed that before. The walls and the lights in those final pages seems to refer to some kind of alien technology. They don't look like a standard abandoned warehouse like the place where the turtles fought Shredder or the place where Karai and Shredder discussed in #13.

Lampy
01-08-2013, 02:14 AM
That looks so much like krang's OT suit that you can just about visualize it even with the heavy shadows. The resemblance in the outlines is just too uncanny

Slade
01-29-2013, 09:25 AM
Finally picked this up. Glad I haven't read anything yet. I feel left out!