PDA

View Full Version : Shredder recruiting Leo?


ToTheNines
12-11-2012, 10:30 PM
I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts on this.

I can't say I'm interested (mainly because we won't see anything out of it until April or May), but I am interested in how Tom's even going to make it an interesting plot point. I mean, we all know Leo's not going to turn. It just makes no sense. Unless Splinter pulls some serious sh*t here shortly, Leo has no reason to join forces with the guy who lobbed his head off in his past life and tried to kill his father in this one.

Best way I see it being played is Leo playing Shredder in order to get deep into the Foot clan and then go turncoat on them, but that would just be predictable, ya know?

Can anyone think of any way they could play this that wouldn't be predictable?

Andrew NDB
12-11-2012, 11:30 PM
I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts on this.

I can't say I'm interested (mainly because we won't see anything out of it until April or May), but I am interested in how Tom's even going to make it an interesting plot point. I mean, we all know Leo's not going to turn. It just makes no sense. Unless Splinter pulls some serious sh*t here shortly, Leo has no reason to join forces with the guy who lobbed his head off in his past life and tried to kill him father in this one.

Best way I see it being played is Leo playing Shredder in order to get deep into the Foot clan and then go turncoat on them, but that would just be predictable, ya know?

Can anyone think of any way they could play this that wouldn't be predictable?

I don't really have any guesses, but it's obviously coming or it wouldn't be foreshadowed as heavily as it has. I do have faith that Tom will make it a compelling plot point.

TomWaltz
12-12-2012, 12:03 PM
I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts on this.

I can't say I'm interested (mainly because we won't see anything out of it until April or May), but I am interested in how Tom's even going to make it an interesting plot point. I mean, we all know Leo's not going to turn. It just makes no sense. Unless Splinter pulls some serious sh*t here shortly, Leo has no reason to join forces with the guy who lobbed his head off in his past life and tried to kill him father in this one.

Best way I see it being played is Leo playing Shredder in order to get deep into the Foot clan and then go turncoat on them, but that would just be predictable, ya know?

Can anyone think of any way they could play this that wouldn't be predictable?

Shredder's offering a free toaster and 1.5% interest on a checking account in the Foot Credit Union. How could Leo resist?

CyberCubed
12-12-2012, 12:12 PM
Well Leonardo could say something like, "Well you not only killed me once before, and all my brothers, and my father, and my mother....but I'm willing to give you another chance, Shredder."

OK I got nothing. Leo should hate Shredder for killing his entire family.

AnarkyLantern
12-12-2012, 12:23 PM
I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts on this.

I can't say I'm interested (mainly because we won't see anything out of it until April or May), but I am interested in how Tom's even going to make it an interesting plot point. I mean, we all know Leo's not going to turn. It just makes no sense. Unless Splinter pulls some serious sh*t here shortly, Leo has no reason to join forces with the guy who lobbed his head off in his past life and tried to kill him father in this one.

Best way I see it being played is Leo playing Shredder in order to get deep into the Foot clan and then go turncoat on them, but that would just be predictable, ya know?

Can anyone think of any way they could play this that wouldn't be predictable?

A current dc show is doing the "pretending to be a villain to get intel" bit, so I'd like to see something different too.. My guess is a new spin on the whole "Tales of Leo": Leo gets overwhelmed by Shredder and his forces, but in this version it's a retrieval mission. Leo is taken to foot hq and brainwashed. The others look for him for weeks... And then one night, in April's shop..a legion of Foot Ninja attack! But who's that leading them? Dun dun dun!

FoxZerro
12-12-2012, 12:23 PM
Honestly I can't begin to imagine anything that wouldn't seem almost forced for it. Initially I thought maybe they do the whole Alopex thing again where they play on the whole desire to help others thing, maybe have Leonardo agree to help some down and out mutants or former gang members, begin training them, but its been done and the second it starts you would be waiting for the roof to fall in and the truth to be revealed.

Its kind of why Issue 14 is my least favorite issue of the IDW series as a whole because it introduced that whole thing. It just felt so 2k3 and just didn't make sense. I understand the desire to have your greatest foe as your strongest ally. But even if you hadn't killed him and his family in a past life and kidnapped his father in the present, that moment where he turned your words against you and spared your life that moment isn't when its confirmed that he should be your right hand man, its the moment when you realized you've wasted your opportunity.

I hope beyond hope they find a way to make it cool and new, but of teh dangling plot threads currently present it is my least favorite

spookycookies
12-12-2012, 01:27 PM
This is how I can see it going: Of course we don't expect Leo to turn, but it will most likely happen. What better way for the turtles to collect intel on the foot and their inner workings. Aside from that there is always a chance that Karai's "preparations" for her mission involve finding some kind of leverage to push Leo towards working with the foot.

AnarkyLantern
12-12-2012, 02:14 PM
Ok, who's seen Batman Beyond Return of the Joker?

mrmaczaps
12-12-2012, 02:29 PM
Raph worked as the Shredded in Image vol 3 TMNT.... right?

FoxZerro
12-12-2012, 02:44 PM
Ok, who's seen Batman Beyond Return of the Joker?

Well I have and if you're insinuating that once they ultimately kill off Shredder in the IDW book that he'll have kidnapped and injected his mutated resurrected DNA into Leonardo and then will slowing begin to take over his body as his new host then boy you crazy... in the best kinda way

Raph worked as the Shredded in Image vol 3 TMNT.... right?

Yes... Yes he did. But there is a huge different between being the Shredder and working for the Shredder

Andrew NDB
12-12-2012, 02:59 PM
Raph worked as the Shredded in Image vol 3 TMNT.... right?

Raphael taking over the role of the Shredder in a time when there was an official truce between the Turtles and the Foot is hardly anywhere in the same ballpark as a Turtle becoming the right-hand man of the Shredder during non-peacetime.

TomWaltz
12-12-2012, 03:09 PM
Raphael taking over the role of the Shredder in a time when there was an official truce between the Turtles and the Foot is hardly anywhere in the same ballpark as a Turtle becoming the right-hand man of the Shredder during non-peacetime.

And no free toasters and a great bank rate. Raph got jobbed.

Matches Malone
12-12-2012, 03:23 PM
Ok, who's seen Batman Beyond Return of the Joker?

A computer chip that magically transforms Tim Drake into the Joker weas the only thing I didn't like about that movie... Brainwashed, sure, but a computer chip???

Raph worked as the Shredded in Image vol 3 TMNT.... right?

I actually thought Image pulled that off pretty well. The Foot and turtles had a truce, and Raph thought he could put their resources to good use. An interesting graying of morality to see if the ends justify the means. Basically, season 5 of Angel. Good stuff! If Karai can convince Leo to join their ranks simply by means of philosophy, that would be verrry interesting. Doesn't sound likely though, since Karai is trying to beef up soldiers to soften ol' Leo up first.

AnarkyLantern
12-12-2012, 05:14 PM
Oh no, I wasn't referring to the computer chip at all, just the brainwashing. A spin on the whole "tale of Leo" where instead of talking him out of a coma.. Leo's been missing, a new foot lieutenant leads the attack on April's shop, and the turtles do get away with Leo but a different sort of recovery is needed to get him back.

And I really need to update my profile. I might be a bit crazy but I'm no boy lol

ctt4lfecw
12-12-2012, 05:57 PM
Tom will have to Russo Swerve us.

Turns
12-12-2012, 07:20 PM
The enemy of my enemy is my friend right? Maybe after Krang gets his technodrome built he is too much of a threat for either the Foot clan or the TMNT to handle alone so they decide to call a truce and work together for the sake of the planet. Maybe their ol pal Chet
AKA the Fugatoid proposes a truce and organizes a meeting.

thelouisguy
12-13-2012, 10:38 AM
Tom will have to Russo Swerve us.

Wouldn't mind one or two, if they made sense; but I guess that changes the meaning entirely.

FoxZerro
12-13-2012, 02:30 PM
Oh no, I wasn't referring to the computer chip at all, just the brainwashing. A spin on the whole "tale of Leo" where instead of talking him out of a coma.. Leo's been missing, a new foot lieutenant leads the attack on April's shop, and the turtles do get away with Leo but a different sort of recovery is needed to get him back.

And I really need to update my profile. I might be a bit crazy but I'm no boy lol

I figured you weren't talking about the computer chip, but that was just such an insane part of that film that when I saw Return of the Joker it was the first thing that came to mind. Plus in a weird way it would be a cool way for Shredder to become like the guy from The Fallen and start taking over host bodies in an effort to eventually capture the body of his dreams. Even if technically that's not how I worded it.

Also no gender disrespect meant by the "boy you crazy" it was more just a play on what I've been told my entire life by my father... It was sort of nice being able to use it for myself for once...

Plasticplayhouse
12-14-2012, 09:12 AM
I don't really have any guesses, but it's obviously coming or it wouldn't be foreshadowed as heavily as it has. I do have faith that Tom will make it a compelling plot point.

totally feel the same way.

not to mention free toaster ovens have turned many men against their masters. why do you think the samurai were disbanded?? the western world gave the emperor a free toaster oven. their world hasn't been the same since!

Lampy
12-14-2012, 10:01 AM
nothing better than a free toaster with each new membership, eh Tom? LOL. you're a funny guy.

anywho... i think the most logical way i can ever see this happening is if karai tricks leonardo into thinking she's trying to take down shredder (possibly reasoning shredder's trying to replace her). karai does a few staged fights with the foot maybe even against shredder... leo slowly gains trust... pull off missions that seem good on the at first but with dual motives... TA DA! good, naive leo trying to "take down shredder" working with karai (shredder pulls the puppet strings). sorry guys... that's all i can think of.

but nothing i find more badass than leo wearing slash's bandanna working for the foot. DAMN that would be sooo awesome. evil leo!

AnarkyLantern
12-18-2012, 08:42 AM
I figured you weren't talking about the computer chip, but that was just such an insane part of that film that when I saw Return of the Joker it was the first thing that came to mind. Plus in a weird way it would be a cool way for Shredder to become like the guy from The Fallen and start taking over host bodies in an effort to eventually capture the body of his dreams. Even if technically that's not how I worded it.
I always figured that was more metaphor, the chip thing- kinda sciencish sleeper programming/indoctrination. I'm also reminded of this 2k fanfic where Karai had Raph tortured to the point she got him thinking he was all four turtles.

Also no gender disrespect meant by the "boy you crazy" it was more just a play on what I've been told my entire life by my father... It was sort of nice being able to use it for myself for once...

I didn't think any was intended, how could you know and all... But I'm amused by my online shape shifting sometimes, lol... :tsmile:

grungethemovie
12-18-2012, 10:01 AM
Well Leonardo could say something like, "Well you not only killed me once before, and all my brothers, and my father, and my mother....but I'm willing to give you another chance, Shredder."

OK I got nothing. Leo should hate Shredder for killing his entire family.

"Well you not only killed me once before, and all my brothers, and my father, and my mother....but FREE TOASTERS!? SIGN ME IN!!"

ToTheNines
12-18-2012, 11:17 AM
The most contrived thing about this is that flashback scene at the end of #14, where Saki is spying on them and he says that Leo displayed leadership qualities... at the age of like 4 or 5.

The easy fix would have been to show Shredder creeping on them just before he had them executed, when Leo was closer to 15 or so.

FoxZerro
12-18-2012, 11:37 AM
I always figured that was more metaphor, the chip thing- kinda sciencish sleeper programming/indoctrination.

I get that, not to derail it too much but the chip was kind of the one problem I had with the movie, I think I would have liked it if it were less science fictiony and more of a split personality that had developed as a result of the torturing that Tim Drake had endured. The chip just seemed too futuristic to have existed at the time it would have been placed in Tim. I guess that went that way so that Tim could be cured of the ailment at the end and given a happy ending.

I think it would be cool if Shredder did do something where through mental torture Leo believed he was always a member of the foot clan. Though again because of the status quo needing to eventually be restored I am wary of how it would play out

I'm also reminded of this 2k fanfic where Karai had Raph tortured to the point she got him thinking he was all four turtles.

That sounds like something worth reading, I'll have to fish it out of the depth of the internet. I like that its Raph because it plays into the whole original red bandana thing

I didn't think any was intended, how could you know and all... But I'm amused by my online shape shifting sometimes, lol... :tsmile:

Cool, I was a little surprised when you mentioned it, still it looks like it provided us both with a laugh which is always a good thing :tthumbsu:

ToTheNines
12-18-2012, 12:02 PM
The chip just seemed too futuristic to have existed at the time it would have been placed in Tim.

Not really. Tim's kidnapping happened during or shortly after the events of JLU and we know Joker robbed top secret government facilities every now and then.

FoxZerro
12-18-2012, 12:11 PM
Not really. Tim's kidnapping happened during or shortly after the events of JLU and we know Joker robbed top secret government facilities every now and then.

Now that you say that I know that its just my own personal problems with the timeline of the Animated DC Universe... There are moments when things seem so primative technology wise and then it just seems so advanced... I need to remember to keep telling myself its only a cartoon, fantastic things can and do happen...

Crabfight
12-18-2012, 01:19 PM
Maybe The Shredder will provide indisputable evidence that Splinter's "past life" story has some holes in it where Splinter didn't tell the full truth? It would be a cool way to connect it to the SHotFC!

Matches Malone
12-18-2012, 01:24 PM
I always figured that was more metaphor, the chip thing- kinda sciencish sleeper programming/indoctrination. I'm also reminded of this 2k fanfic where Karai had Raph tortured to the point she got him thinking he was all four turtles.

I like the idea of indoctrination/brainwash, even if it's still cliche, if only because it's one of the few ideas that can make sense at this point.

And I wouldn't say it's very metaphorical when Joker's voice matches the original's exactly according to the bat-computer. He undoubtedly "transforms" into him. You could say it's just that high-tech in that point in the future, which is what I think they were relying on, but it just feels too silly if there's no actual science to extrapolate that from. It just becomes sorcery and silliness to me.

The most contrived thing about this is that flashback scene at the end of #14, where Saki is spying on them and he says that Leo displayed leadership qualities... at the age of like 4 or 5.

The easy fix would have been to show Shredder creeping on them just before he had them executed, when Leo was closer to 15 or so.

Agreed. Bobby offered that another main reason for recruiting Leo is because it hits Splinter where it hurts. That is a far more compelling reason and I wonder why that wasn't mentioned in the issue. If it's because it's less motivating for Karai, well, it's better than leaving the audience shaking their heads a bit, I think. Besides, he can always leave those kinds of comments for later on about how he would make a better second-in-command anyway.

Lampy
12-18-2012, 09:50 PM
I like the idea of indoctrination/brainwash, even if it's still cliche, if only because it's one of the few ideas that can make sense at this point.

And I wouldn't say it's very metaphorical when Joker's voice matches the original's exactly according to the bat-computer. He undoubtedly "transforms" into him. You could say it's just that high-tech in that point in the future, which is what I think they were relying on, but it just feels too silly if there's no actual science to extrapolate that from. It just becomes sorcery and silliness to me.

Agreed. Bobby offered that another main reason for recruiting Leo is because it hits Splinter where it hurts. That is a far more compelling reason and I wonder why that wasn't mentioned in the issue. If it's because it's less motivating for Karai, well, it's better than leaving the audience shaking their heads a bit, I think. Besides, he can always leave those kinds of comments for later on about how he would make a better second-in-command anyway.

the weirdest part of the joker chip was that... you'd think Tim Drake showered enough or scratched enough to FEEL the chip on his neck. but apparently it went unnoticed for decades. and the transforming bit was just as weird. i'll accept that considering i know nothing of future tech... but come on!

tom is a very thorough writer. i'm assuming all will be explained soon i hope. those scenes with saki spying on yoshi's faimly is most likely the same type of teasers you see on tv (scene ends with a dude spying on a clan and roll credits) and then explained much later.

ToTheNines
08-03-2025, 11:32 PM
The most contrived thing about this is that flashback scene at the end of #14, where Saki is spying on them and he says that Leo displayed leadership qualities... at the age of like 4 or 5.

The easy fix would have been to show Shredder creeping on them just before he had them executed, when Leo was closer to 15 or so.

Necroposting because this take popped in my head today.

Now that I’m raising kids I have to take all this back. They absolutely can have very strong personality traits present from a young age.

Also, Bobby Curnow once pointed out that the main goal was to inflict as much misery as possible on Splinter. So turning his oldest son against him accomplished that just and could technically be more advantageous than taking him out. Killing him might motivate all of them to go nuts and wipe the Foot out. The brainwashing plot put them at a disadvantage when they had to fight Dark Leo.

TheLabRat
08-03-2025, 11:48 PM
Now, we've see that Dark Leo is a joke and unnecessary. This is just a misery lit to Leo, and this thing doesn't even help his story development.

I don't care if it's about saving the world or some greater good. He had reason to refuse to become Shredder's student again, and find his own way to fight Rat King in Armageddon Game arc.

ToTheNines
08-04-2025, 12:13 AM
I’m out of the loop on most everything between #100 and the Jason Aaron run. I was just referring to the beginning of it all pre-City Fall.

TheLabRat
08-04-2025, 01:14 AM
I think it would be make more sense if Raph became foot soldier, instead of Leo. He was captured by the Shredder because they heard rumors about a green freak wandering in street. Shredder manipulated his fear and hatred to train him as an assassin. Early in the story, Splinter and other three turtles will forced to fight him. After several encounters, Raph began to awaken memories of his past life, but Kitsune return and brainwashing him again. Until Splinter and other turtles still find a way to break through Raph's brainwashing.