View Full Version : Who do you think Ch'rell will be in IDW TMNT?
Andrew NDB
12-15-2012, 02:20 PM
To me, as soon as Krang was confirmed to be an Utrom it's just been a matter of waiting for the other shoe to drop on when Ch'rell will be showing up.
My personal guess is that he's going to turn out to be Oroku Saki's benefactor, hence explaining the Foot Clan's faction's interest in mutagen and their rivalry with General Krang (i.e., Krang and Ch'rell have some sordid past and -- for whatever reason -- don't see eye to eye).
ToTheNines
12-15-2012, 02:27 PM
Up until seeing a certain cover recently, I would have disagreed with you. But I could definitely see this working.
Shredder being "brought back to life" could have been more like being awaken from stasis. But as evil as Krang appears to be, I wonder if they'd try to paint Ch'rell in a more noble light...
Can't wait till March to find out.
Andrew NDB
12-15-2012, 02:30 PM
But as evil as Krang appears to be, I wonder if they'd try to paint Ch'rell in a more noble light...
I don't think so... Ch'rell's whole thing is that he's just eeeeevil for evil's sake, where Krang is more methodically diabolical (even if it's for equally no reason). I'm sure Tom will give them sound backstories and motivations for the first time for either character.
Keldor1578
12-15-2012, 03:42 PM
I am hoping that Oroku Saki is Ch'rell's host, This way the Shredder would still be human in IDW. I would prefer if was a symbiotic possession so Oroku saki can have control over his body.
CyberCubed
12-15-2012, 04:19 PM
The problem is Krang acts too much like Ch'rell in IDW so far. What set Krang apart was his humor, banter, and whininess that made him appealing.
Even in the Archie series Krang had a humourous side to him. Like when Bebop/Rocksteady get startled and say, "Aliens really DO exist!?" and Krang covers his eyes with his tentacles like he was face palming. That was great.
I want to see Krang throw a tantrum and jump up and down inside his robot body.
Andrew NDB
12-15-2012, 04:34 PM
What set Krang apart was his humor, banter, and whininess that made him appealing.
Even in the Archie series Krang had a humourous side to him. Like when Bebop/Rocksteady get startled and say, "Aliens really DO exist!?" and Krang covers his eyes with his tentacles like he was face palming. That was great.
I want to see Krang throw a tantrum and jump up and down inside his robot body.
I think the kind of things you describe, while are certainly indicative of the Fred Wolf/Archie Krang, are the kinds of things that stopped him from ever being a credible threat beyond the sphere of a children's cartoon. I'm not against Krang having a (twisted?) sense of humor, but IDW would do well to veer far clear of that kind of stuff.
Coola Yagami
12-15-2012, 05:12 PM
Kinda hope Ch'rell isn't in this. Leave him in the world of 2K3 Turtles and go for something new.
Powder
12-15-2012, 05:46 PM
I'm with Coola on this. I wouldn't mind a Krang/Ch'rell rivalry that much, but, eh, like Andrew said, they're sort of the same character now. Plus, it was essentially done already, in Turtles forever.
Andrew NDB
12-15-2012, 06:28 PM
I don't think they would necessarily be the same. Krang can be the more calculating one while Ch'rell can be more of the hot-blooded "RAHHHH!!! KILL THEM ALL!" type.
Matches Malone
12-15-2012, 10:02 PM
While there are definite possibilities for reinvention, it would still feel way too redundant to me to have two Utrom villains, at least concurrently, regardless of the attempt to distinguish their separate personalities. To me, one would ultimately diminish the other since comparisons would be unavoidable.
Andrew NDB
12-15-2012, 10:20 PM
While there are definite possibilities for reinvention, it would still feel way too redundant to me to have two Utrom villains, at least concurrently, regardless of the attempt to distinguish their separate personalities. To me, one would ultimately diminish the other since comparisons would be unavoidable.
Even when something called "The Krang Wars" is looming and things are about to get very interstellar?
And besides, it's kind of like saying two human villains diminishes each one's value because they're both human.
CyberCubed
12-15-2012, 11:06 PM
The problem with Ch'rell is other than taking over the identity of Shredder, he has really nothing else in terms of backstory. Its not like with Krang who brings in tons of concepts with him like Traag, the Rock Soldiers, Dimension X, the Technodrome, the Neutrino war, the mutagen, etc. and pretty much everything that ever happened in Dimension X was associated with him.
In fact as soon as we knew Krang was introduced in this series back in 2011, I knew it was inevitable we'd start seeing Dimension X, Rock Warriors, Neutrinos, the Technodrome, mutagen, etc. It sorta comes as a package deal with the character.
Krang comes with a lot of history and baggage and IDW is using ALL of it, Ch'rell is just an evil Utrom who took over Oroku Saki's identity.
Andrew NDB
12-16-2012, 01:05 AM
The problem with Ch'rell is other than taking over the identity of Shredder, he has really nothing else in terms of backstory.
But that's where Tom comes in. This is a new universe.
It's not like Ch'rell doesn't bring concepts with him too. Hun, Foot Tech Ninja, Foot Mystics, The Guardians, Mortu, Foot Mechs, Dr. Chaplin, Yukio Mashimi, Cyber Shredder and Kahn.
Turns
12-16-2012, 02:53 AM
In issue 14 Krang says that all that is left of the Utrom race is in his command headquarters on Burnow Island. I'd say that rules out the possibility of Ch'rell appearing. Unless of course Krang doesn't know he's alive yet.
Either way I think having another evil Utrom who's bent on taking over the world would be pretty redundant. I would be content if we didn't see Ch'rell make an appearance in this series.
Andrew NDB
12-16-2012, 04:08 AM
In issue 14 Krang says that all that is left of the Utrom race is in his command headquarters on Burnow Island. I'd say that rules out the possibility of Ch'rell appearing. Unless of course Krang doesn't know he's alive yet.
Good point. Though if Ch'rell is the same kind of outcast renegade he was in 4Kids then perhaps Krang doesn't really consider him cut from the same cloth as the fellow Utroms he saved.
Like, what if Ch'rell was the one that sold the Utroms out to the Triceratons (if the Triceratons are who wiped out the Utroms)? It's all about story.
Matches Malone
12-16-2012, 05:49 AM
Even when something called "The Krang Wars" is looming and things are about to get very interstellar?
And besides, it's kind of like saying two human villains diminishes each one's value because they're both human.
Not really since I said the main reason they would diminish each other is because of the comparisons they would invite. Two humans wouldn't invite comparisons to each other as heavily since that would be among the less notable traits (hopefully). It's not to say its an obstacle that can't be overcome, simply recognizing that it is there. I just don't personally see enough potential to see it overcome at the moment, but I can be wrong. As usual, if the writing is strong enough, most any concept can work. I just don't see it working easily and not really rooting for it, that's all.
Lampy
12-16-2012, 07:34 AM
Ch'rell IS KRANG's FATHER! DUN DUN DUN!!!!
CyberCubed
12-16-2012, 08:58 AM
Ch'rell IS KRANG's FATHER! DUN DUN DUN!!!!
Didn't they already show Krang's father in that flashback? He already had a name I think.
ToTheNines
12-16-2012, 10:08 AM
Yes, Krang's father was named Quanin.
Matches Malone
12-16-2012, 12:26 PM
Ch'rell IS KRANG's FATHER! DUN DUN DUN!!!!
"BUT IF HE'S THE REAL FATHER, HOW DO I KNOW IF I'M THE REAL MOTHER?!"
Maybe if Splinter was writing this comic... :P
Lampy
12-16-2012, 07:24 PM
Didn't they already show Krang's father in that flashback? He already had a name I think.
Hahah. CH'RELL IS KRANG'S UNCLE!! DUN DUN DUN!!!
ctt4lfecw
12-16-2012, 07:30 PM
I was never crazy about Ch'rell. I hope they don't include him.
Lampy
12-16-2012, 07:53 PM
Im okay with chrell being included. Although it might seem resundant to include him with krang AND shredder there, he did play a major role in one of the Turtles incarnations. And since Tom seems to be taking pieces from all universes, it makes sense to include him. However, all the hate for chrell is understandable. Wouldn't want the same logic to apply to venus.
As for what I really think chrell has the potential to be in idw... he could be an ancient demon utrom from dimension x who was banished from dimension x to earth centuries ago and taught saki ways to achieve his longevity (how ever tom and team approaches it). Id prefer if he was killed off in feudal japan though by saki. I hope saki is as human as possible.
Coola Yagami
12-16-2012, 08:43 PM
I don't think they would necessarily be the same. Krang can be the more calculating one while Ch'rell can be more of the hot-blooded "RAHHHH!!! KILL THEM ALL!" type.
Krang doesn't seem all too far from that actually. he seems like a calm maniac, cold and calculated but really piss him off and it all goes to hell with him. I'd say have the Turtles get in his way enough times, he'll also enter RAAAH!!! KILL THEM ALL!!! mode.
CyberCubed
12-16-2012, 11:31 PM
Krang doesn't seem all too far from that actually. he seems like a calm maniac, cold and calculated but really piss him off and it all goes to hell with him. I'd say have the Turtles get in his way enough times, he'll also enter RAAAH!!! KILL THEM ALL!!! mode.
I think it also depends if Shredder and Krang somehow start working together down the road. I know they see themselves as competitors now, but they've never actually met face to face and things could change.
ToTheNines
12-17-2012, 09:24 AM
Here's a few interesting bits from back-issues, with this theory in mind:
In #6, when Splinter is recounting his early days at Stockgen, he says "... I also began to realize the our reunion had a purpose, the scientists were working toward evil ends - a kind of secretive military domination that felt disturbingly familiar to me". So Krang's direction of Stockgen might remind Splinter of Ch'rell's own puppeteering of the Foot Clan all those years ago.
The hideout used by Alopex, and B&R in the Raph issue looks suspiciously extra-terrestrial.
I had another one that I can't seem to remember right now... I think it was from #13 or #14. I'll check back in later and see what I got.
Andrew NDB
12-17-2012, 08:58 PM
The hideout used by Alopex, and B&R in the Raph issue looks suspiciously extra-terrestrial.
Yup. That jumped out at me like a sore thumb.
Jester
12-17-2012, 09:06 PM
Kinda hope they don't use Ch'rell. Was never a huge fan of the Utrom Shredder because he was too much the mustache twirling villain.
ctt4lfecw
12-17-2012, 09:35 PM
To me Ch'rell was like Peter Laird crapping on Krang. So he derped the fans of Krang by making him and Shredder one.
Lampy
12-17-2012, 09:40 PM
I think this qustion begs the question, "how long do utroms live in this universe?"
ToTheNines
12-17-2012, 10:24 PM
Kinda hope they don't use Ch'rell. Was never a huge fan of the Utrom Shredder because he was too much the mustache twirling villain.
Operative word being "was". I say give him a chance.
I think this qustion begs the question, "how long do utroms live in this universe?"
I may be wrong, but there was never any hint about their longevity in the Mirage books. They live well over 1,000 years in the 4kids universe though.
Jester
12-17-2012, 10:30 PM
Operative word being "was". I say give him a chance.
Does every character have to get an IDW rehash, though?
ToTheNines
12-17-2012, 10:37 PM
Does every character have to get an IDW rehash, though?
If the title never gets cancelled, then why not? :P
I like the idea of Ch'rell in the book because it's an amicable way to keep a Shredder in the picture after Splinter (hopefully) kills Saki.
CyberCubed
12-18-2012, 12:33 AM
Does every character have to get an IDW rehash, though?
Tom Waltz said right from the beginning the IDW series is going to be a mix of all previous universes of TMNT and their characters, while adding a new twist to things.
I'm pretty sure that Angel isn't going to be the only 4kids character they use. Hun is probably likely and I think Tom Waltz already said in an interview that he really liked the character of Bishop. Ch'rell is a strong possibility.
Cryomancer
12-18-2012, 01:52 AM
If he does show up, I want there to be a no-suits Krang vs Ch'rell knife fight or something. Krang always seemed pretty useless outside of his machines, but I always enjoyed how Ch'rell would keep fighting the turtles even if he was "on foot".
Lampy
12-18-2012, 06:30 AM
I may be wrong, but there was never any hint about their longevity in the Mirage books. They live well over 1,000 years in the 4kids universe though.
yea... i don't recall either. but i clearly remembered the 4kids utroms living for centuries, including ch'rell. which is why i brought it up. still... i'd prefer a human shredder learning ways of immortality and secrets from ch'rell then slaying him. keep saki a human.
If he does show up, I want there to be a no-suits Krang vs Ch'rell knife fight or something. Krang always seemed pretty useless outside of his machines, but I always enjoyed how Ch'rell would keep fighting the turtles even if he was "on foot".
yea... i'm sure ch'rell would destroy krang in a no-suits-no-arms fight. headbutt after headbutt! ch'rell bites... he plays dirty.
AnarkyLantern
12-18-2012, 08:30 AM
To me Ch'rell was like Peter Laird crapping on Krang. So he derped the fans of Krang by making him and Shredder one.
I was kinda reminded of Archie TMNT 25, where Krang took over Shredder's body. :tlol:
corvus
12-19-2012, 11:09 AM
Why do people still think he's gonna show up? There's absolutely nothing to suggest he will. That'd be like Tokka and Slash appearing. In other words: bad story telling.
thelouisguy
12-19-2012, 12:49 PM
Why do people still think he's gonna show up? There's absolutely nothing to suggest he will. That'd be like Tokka and Slash appearing. In other words: bad story telling.
Like this?
http://media-cache0.pinterest.com/upload/236016836692936634_uBYELGI2_b.jpg
Andrew NDB
12-19-2012, 03:04 PM
Why do people still think he's gonna show up? There's absolutely nothing to suggest he will. That'd be like Tokka and Slash appearing. In other words: bad story telling.
There's plenty to suggest he will. And I'm a bit oblivious to what connection you feel there is to characters and storytelling within stories you haven't read yet.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
12-19-2012, 03:59 PM
I think he will on the basis that they are trying to get in EVERY "significant" character from EVERY TMNT universe into this series. It may be further along, and it may be like the "Shredder Wars" in BTTS. I could just see a war further along where Krang, Oroku Saki, Karai, and Ch'rell all fight for the Shredder mantle...
corvus
12-19-2012, 04:25 PM
You don't think it'd be bad story telling if they introduce an ancient ninja warlord named slicer who lead a clan of ninja thieves? Or how about a scientist named Brockman who sent Ratters to kill the turtles?
CyberCubed
12-19-2012, 04:38 PM
I think the fact that nether Tom Waltz nor Bobby commented in this thread to avoid slipping potential spoilers says a lot.
I've noticed they did the same right before Slash made his debut and again for the Neutrinos.
corvus
12-19-2012, 05:12 PM
I think the Neutrinos are Shredders Benefactor. That's why Honeycutt went to shredder. Makes things less black and white.
Bobby Curnow
12-19-2012, 05:36 PM
Us not commenting has zero bearing, trust me. That's a complete no win for us. If we comment and say "he won't appear" then that's spoiling the fun of guessing. If we say nothing, then that equals he definitely IS appearing?
There's been plenty of times where you guys have guessed at someone appearing, and they have indeed not appeared, with no plans to.
There's plenty of threads where we don't comment. Doesn't mean we're hiding something.
What I will say is that you guys have guessed things I never would have thought in a million years (Fugitoid=chet), but you've also been completely off the base at other times. As it should be, I suppose!
Matches Malone
12-19-2012, 06:30 PM
Translation: "You kids think you're SO smart!"
Lampy
12-19-2012, 08:56 PM
Why do people still think he's gonna show up? There's absolutely nothing to suggest he will. That'd be like Tokka and Slash appearing. In other words: bad story telling.
introducing ch'rell doesn't necessarily mean a bad story. idw has proven time and again that they can and already have the ability to make unfavorable characters into something amazing. and i believe that ANY character has that potential... it just takes the right team. and idw has done a great job making krang and the neutrinos into respectable characters... reception of these characters have changed. so i don't see why you think this cannot apply to ch'rell.
Andrew NDB
12-20-2012, 12:37 AM
To make my position clear: I don't care either way about Ch'rell. I think he was a shallow, 1-note character devised to 1) Marry the idea of Krang and Shredder together (AKA, "4Kids: Let's appease what Fred Wolf fans might be expecting on some level") in an amicable enough fashion to Peter Laird, and 2) Allow Shredder to be decapitated on-screen. There was little to no foresight or overall character arc to the character beyond that that I can discern. If he was banished from existence or never showed up again in any incarnation or form I couldn't be bothered in the least.
That said, IDW TMNT has Krang as an Utrom and is cooking up some major interstellar plans. They've made no bones about using stuff from the other TMNT universes. To me, it doesn't take that many burned calories to discern that maybe, probably, the only Utrom that the average TMNT fan could probably identify by name is probably going to show up at some point down the road.
To me, the stage already seems set.
CyberCubed
12-20-2012, 04:34 PM
introducing ch'rell doesn't necessarily mean a bad story. idw has proven time and again that they can and already have the ability to make unfavorable characters into something amazing. and i believe that ANY character has that potential... it just takes the right team. and idw has done a great job making krang and the neutrinos into respectable characters... reception of these characters have changed. so i don't see why you think this cannot apply to ch'rell.
Since when was Krang not a respectable character? Even after nearly 30 years, Krang is still the second most recognizable and popular TMNT villain after Shredder.
And this is taking into consideration the huge gap in appearances where he last appeared in 1996 and didn't appear again till 2009's Turtles Forever.
Andrew NDB
12-20-2012, 05:04 PM
Since when was Krang not a respectable character?
I would venture: "Since... ever?"
Now is he memorable? Sure. Iconic to the Fred Wolf show? Sure. But he had no depth, no character arc to speak of... he's just a wacky, cackling alien brain-like thing that is 0 for 300 on actually accomplishing any villainous acts.
That is, of course, Krang as we've known him. IDW Krang shows promise if Tom can create some believable motivation for him beyond "I want to rule the universe! Just cuz!"
Jester
12-20-2012, 05:13 PM
Archie Krang was at least a (though not shown in the comics themselves) genocidal warlord....I mean he was known there to have destroyed whole planets...and still be goofy and watch intergalactic wrestling.
Andrew NDB
12-20-2012, 05:16 PM
Archie Krang was at least a (though not shown in the comics themselves) genocidal warlord....I mean the was known there to have destroyed whole planets...and still be goofy and watch intergalactic wrestling.
Right. But even there there was no character arc, no "meat" to him. No motivation offered, nothing.
Jester
12-20-2012, 05:20 PM
Save the Turnstone, you are correct. That's about the only "motivation" he ever really got.
I dunna, I trust Tom could use Ch'rell in an awesome way....but my own personal bias against him makes me hope you're wrong, Andrew.
But hey, Bobby and Tom haven't said anything so that means....they want the story to be a surprise.....CURSE YOU AND YOUR "NO SPOILERS" BUSINESS MODEL! :D
Matches Malone
12-20-2012, 05:38 PM
I think we've started to get a little snippet of Krang's motivation with his background as dictators that were eventually overthrown. Sounds like revenge for family might be on the menu. Hopefully it's more than that, but we'll see.
While I think Tom has done a great job, he still hasn't quite won my complete faith just yet. Old Hob, for example, has no arc other than "you made me lose my eye, just because I was trying to eat your turtle son!" It really seems like his main motivation is... being annoyed about that. Sure, there's still time for more development, but sometimes I think things are played a little too close to the chest in this series, leaving things unsatisfying. While I'm all for plotting ahead, there should be some effort into making sure the characters are compelling here and now. Pretty sure Krang has been thought out far more than Old Hob, so here's hoping we get a lot in these next few issues.
Lampy
12-20-2012, 10:23 PM
Since when was Krang not a respectable character? Even after nearly 30 years, Krang is still the second most recognizable and popular TMNT villain after Shredder.
And this is taking into consideration the huge gap in appearances where he last appeared in 1996 and didn't appear again till 2009's Turtles Forever.
Id be repetitive if I answered that. Personally... I have never thought much of krang as a villain. All he ever did for the most part was argue with shredder in the OT. im only comparing him to the old toon because thats where he was most prominent.
Coola Yagami
12-22-2012, 01:16 PM
I still disagree and hope he doesn't appear in the IDW comics. I feel that every version needs its own unique thing that stays there. April as a reporter, Canjun Leatherhead and the more wackier characters like the Punk Frogs and such in the OT, Ch'Rell and Bishop in 2K3, Bradford and Xever in Nick2012, Old Hob and Apolex in this comic series.
Also, Ch'Rell was the major villian in the 2K3 series. Done wrongly he might pull the carpet out from under IDW Shredder and Krang and take over as the big bad... and we already had him as the main villian in 2K3. We don't really need him here. Just like I'd rather see a Dimension X battle between Neutrinos and Stone Warriors instead of just the whole Triceraton/Federation battle all over again.
Keldor1578
12-22-2012, 05:17 PM
I still disagree and hope he doesn't appear in the IDW comics. I feel that every version needs its own unique thing that stays there. April as a reporter, Canjun Leatherhead and the more wackier characters like the Punk Frogs and such in the OT, Ch'Rell and Bishop in 2K3, Bradford and Xever in Nick2012, Old Hob and Apolex in this comic series.
Also, Ch'Rell was the major villian in the 2K3 series. Done wrongly he might pull the carpet out from under IDW Shredder and Krang and take over as the big bad... and we already had him as the main villian in 2K3. We don't really need him here. Just like I'd rather see a Dimension X battle between Neutrinos and Stone Warriors instead of just the whole Triceraton/Federation battle all over again.
I do think major 4kids characters like Bishop and Hun, Ch'rell are just as deserving to be in IDW. There are all ready too many Fred Wolf characters and elements, Krang and The Rock Soldier, Rocksteady and Bebop, The Technodrome and Dimension X, The Neutrinos. I feel that IDW are relied on the Fred Wolf cartoon too much. Splinter being a grey rat and Angel is the only the element and character from 4Kids cartoon.
ToTheNines
12-22-2012, 05:25 PM
This Karai is mostly based off of the 4kids version so far. Baxter is closer to his 4kids self rather than Mirage, too.
CyberCubed
12-22-2012, 11:42 PM
Tom Waltz already said he really likes the character of Bishop. I take it as a meta-hint that he'll be involved.
If Krang decides to invade Earth for example, like a full scale invasion, its an easy way to bring in Bishop since he works for DARPA and Area 51.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.