PDA

View Full Version : TMNT First print first issue 1984...question


ZeoRed
12-29-2012, 10:09 AM
Ok so I am new here and to comic book collecting in general but have been a turtles fan since i could talk.

I've recently come across a First print first issue of tmnt number one from 84 its Fine shape with very little ware to it. The pages are a tad yellow but that is expected. the asking price is 800.00 I dunno if its a good deal or what. The only damage to the book is the top corner on the right and the bottom corner on the right, they are kinda bent. 800.00 is a lot to drop on something like this but its something I'd really like to have. So i'm hopping someone with more knowledge on the issue can help me out with this.

Update: Due to everyone in this threads help I have since picked this baby up and am very glad to have it. Here are some pics.
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a128/ZeoRed/BA18AA99-E130-45B2-AAF0-FD380CA2972C-315-00000033059EB54A.jpg
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a128/ZeoRed/48FDE1DD-ED90-45F9-B9FB-1ED135970C9F-315-0000003312928A67.jpg
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a128/ZeoRed/0EEE5592-6A0F-4802-A641-FD0DDC95F04C-315-000000330AACD670.jpg
http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a128/ZeoRed/143E6BAF-C0CE-4D4F-B232-0CA00FF2965D-315-000000330DD7091B.jpg

rich
12-29-2012, 12:00 PM
Welcome to the Drome. If you have pics of the issue I can help you authenticate it.

If it does turn out to truly be a #1 1st printing and in decent shape I think $800 would be a great price (which is why I'm already a bit suspicious). Who is the seller? Is it a local shop or online? You can send me a PM to me too if you want.

Venom
12-29-2012, 12:28 PM
Definitely post pics of the inside front cover and the inside back cover.

Archon_Turtle
12-29-2012, 12:29 PM
Actually $80 is not a lot to spend on that particular book. The primary concern is making sure the book is real, since there are a number of counterfeits out there, and many people try to pass off different printings as #1. If you can post photos of the book there are a few of us here that can easily ID the book for you.

ZeoRed
12-29-2012, 01:25 PM
I will try and get some photos for you guys. What are some signs to look for exactly?

Archon_Turtle
12-29-2012, 01:38 PM
I will try and get some photos for you guys. What are some signs to look for exactly?

Level of cover gloss
Paper quality
Improper tone in the reds and blacks on the cover
Wrong blood splatter patterns in the cover title
Missing Gobbledygook ad in the back
Incorrect or missing address on the inside cover
printing notation
text bleaching
page trimming

ZeoRed
12-29-2012, 01:47 PM
The gobbldy gook ad is in the back that i know for sure. The rest im not sure. Here is the pic of the cover.

http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a128/ZeoRed/64001_10152334124020696_1761891235_n_zps04953d98.j pg

rich
12-29-2012, 02:56 PM
The gobbldy gook ad is in the back that i know for sure. The rest im not sure. Here is the pic of the cover.

http://i10.photobucket.com/albums/a128/ZeoRed/64001_10152334124020696_1761891235_n_zps04953d98.j pg

Please tell me those stickers are not actually on the comic itself. :o

ZeoRed
12-29-2012, 03:01 PM
Lol no it's in a bag.

pannoni1
12-29-2012, 09:53 PM
A CGC 5.5 (approximately the condition of this comic) sold for $1400 recently, so buy it if you can since it looks pretty legit to me!

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Teenage-Mutant-Ninja-Turtles-1-First-Printing-CGC-5-5-Very-Scarce-/190742565856?pt=US_Comic_Books&hash=item2c692493e0&nma=true&si=RenAuxp%2BB93gBsIhpnMEZ3Tx%2BtM%3D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557

prez
12-30-2012, 03:49 AM
If it has the Gobbledy Gook ad in the back it is a first printing, here is a site I found that could help you:

http://www.miragelicensing.com/comics/mirage/volume01/01/printing-info.html

Awesome deal if it's only $800, I wish I could find one at that price!

MrPliggins
12-30-2012, 07:46 AM
Cover looks legit to me. Hard to find any condition for under $1k nowadays. If it's real it's a good deal.

ZeoRed
12-30-2012, 04:56 PM
It makes me feel really good to real all the positive comments on this. Ill definitely be getting this...now I'm off to the sales thread to get rid of some stuff In order to pay for it :D

rich
12-30-2012, 05:57 PM
It makes me feel really good to real all the positive comments on this. Ill definitely be getting this...now I'm off to the sales thread to get rid of some stuff In order to pay for it :D

It sure seems to have all the indicators of a true first printing so that will be an awesome pick up. Not sure if you're into getting comics graded but that would be a good thing to do immediately after purchase. It will help protect it but, most importantly, will validate it 100% as a 1st printing. You don't want to get 10 years down the road and find out it's actually a fake and have no recourse.

If you do get it graded, let us know what it grades at...would be neat to see. Good luck! :)

ZeoRed
12-30-2012, 10:42 PM
I am nervous about having it graded. I know for the sake of it will read it once. But that's it. I dunno I'm a big video game collector and I have thought about having some of those graded as well. Here is a question, if I could get peter and kevin to sign it provided it is 100% first print would that increase the value of it?

Powder
12-30-2012, 11:09 PM
Autographs don't usually add much value to anything & in some cases even lessen it. I wouldn't concern myself with that all too much personally.

rich
12-30-2012, 11:14 PM
I am nervous about having it graded. I know for the sake of it will read it once. But that's it. I dunno I'm a big video game collector and I have thought about having some of those graded as well. Here is a question, if I could get peter and kevin to sign it provided it is 100% first print would that increase the value of it?

Why are you nervous about grading?

As for signatures, it's worth more if the signatures are authenticated. The best option is to do a Signature Series from CGC. However, some of the other big TMNT comic collectors on here can likely speak better to that than me. I'm not big on signatures.

ZeoRed
12-30-2012, 11:23 PM
I've never seen a signature lessen the value of anything before.

As for the grading im not sure about comic book grading but like with video games that are factory sealed a lot of people think that the graders will open the game reseal it to look factory sealed while what they have done is taken out the game and re selling it. I know its different with comics.

Archon_Turtle
12-31-2012, 12:22 AM
It is, none-the-less true. Un-authenticated signatures on a book like TMNT #1, where a MAJORITY of known copies are graded, do de-value the book. The reason being is that if a pre-signed book is graded, it will receive a green "qualified" label from the CGC which esentially states that the CGC recognizes that there is something written on the cover, and will not take it into consideration when grading the book, but that they specifically do not claim the signature as authentic. They look like this:

http://d1466nnw0ex81e.cloudfront.net/n_ii/600/471081.jpg

With a CGC authenticated signature, the book receives a yellow label; signifying that the CGC witnessed the book being signed. They look like this:

http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b192/smeeeeee/DSCF9245.jpg

Green label books are ALWAYS less valuable than yellow labels (and most often, blue labels) of the same grade, unless the book was signed by an artist who passed before the CGC existed.

rich
12-31-2012, 12:34 AM
I've never seen a signature lessen the value of anything before.

As for the grading im not sure about comic book grading but like with video games that are factory sealed a lot of people think that the graders will open the game reseal it to look factory sealed while what they have done is taken out the game and re selling it. I know its different with comics.

Well, it's happened before with comics and there's actually a video that's been around for a while of a guy cracking open his PGX TMNT #1 1st printing to find out it's a 3rd printing. However, the guy didn't take any photos or scans prior to submission to help validate he received back what he sent in. On the issue you are buying there are very distinct things on the cover that you could use to validate you got back what you sent in.
Plus, I use CGC for all my grading (except one). They have established a great reputation and are really the grading standard for comic books.

ZeoRed
12-31-2012, 12:44 AM
It is, none-the-less true. Un-authenticated signatures on a book like TMNT #1, where a MAJORITY of known copies are graded, do de-value the book. The reason being is that if a pre-signed book is graded, it will receive a green "qualified" label from the CGC which esentially states that the CGC recognizes that there is something written on the cover, and will not take it into consideration when grading the book, but that they specifically do not claim the signature as authentic. They look like this:

http://d1466nnw0ex81e.cloudfront.net/n_ii/600/471081.jpg

With a CGC authenticated signature, the book receives a yellow label; signifying that the CGC witnessed the book being signed. They look like this:

http://i19.photobucket.com/albums/b192/smeeeeee/DSCF9245.jpg

Green label books are ALWAYS less valuable than yellow labels (and most often, blue labels) of the same grade, unless the book was signed by an artist who passed before the CGC existed.

I've heard about having them there to witness a signature. Is there any other way to verify that the original authors signed the book without them being there?

I may try that out Rich You're right about the book having signifigant markings. I will most likely get it graded once I can get the money for it. I've got some old turtles playsets that I'm about to post pics of in the for sale section so if you guys know of anyone that wants a turtles sewer playset,pizza thrower,the...neturino car??? cant remember what its called and the news van send them my way. All the money will go to getting the book paid for.

Archon_Turtle
12-31-2012, 12:46 AM
I've heard about having them there to witness a signature. Is there any other way to verify that the original authors signed the book without them being there?


No. I've even had Kevin hand deliver a pre-signed book he signed in 1986 to the CGC table at SDCC. He told them that he signed the book, and they still wouldn't give me yellow label.

ZeoRed
12-31-2012, 12:50 AM
So....wow they really have to watch them do it? That's...retarted to some degree I mean you'd think that Kevin would know his own signature. Well you definitly saved me some time on getting the few issues i got him to sign of the idw comic graded lol.

I'd love to get him and peter to sign the book If i could get them both in the same place. I dunno this may be a complicated task.

Archon_Turtle
12-31-2012, 12:55 AM
So....wow they really have to watch them do it?
I'd love to get him and peter to sign the book If i could get them both in the same place. I dunno this may be a complicated task.

The only exception is for sketch covers done at conventions that the CGC has a witness and facilitator at. Because sketch covers often take a very long time to do, they will allow the sketch to be finished by the artist when they are not present as long as you bring a witness with you to pick the sketch cover up from the artist.


I'd love to get him and peter to sign the book If i could get them both in the same place. I dunno this may be a complicated task.

Your best bet would be to do it twice. You could have kevins signature witnessed and then witnessed again at another time and place for Peter. Of course, Peter isn't doing large cons right now, so getting a witnessed opportunity would be difficult. And the other downside of course is you would have to pay grading fees twice.

rich
12-31-2012, 12:55 AM
So....wow they really have to watch them do it? That's...retarted to some degree I mean you'd think that Kevin would know his own signature. Well you definitly saved me some time on getting the few issues i got him to sign of the idw comic graded lol.

I'd love to get him and peter to sign the book If i could get them both in the same place. I dunno this may be a complicated task.

Actually, although it may be harsh, you want CGC to be so strict with their policy on Signature Series (i.e., signature must be witnessed). If they aren't strict and fakes start getting authenticated it's a huge hit on their credibility for such a prestigious label.

ZeoRed
12-31-2012, 12:57 AM
Oh ya i totally understand the reason for it. It just seems like a huge pain in the ass. I'm sorry for the questions on all this I've got a lot to learn when it comes to this stuff. So how would I go about getting them to witness the signing?

Archon_Turtle
12-31-2012, 12:59 AM
Oh ya i totally understand the reason for it. It just seems like a huge pain in the ass. I'm sorry for the questions on all this I've got a lot to learn when it comes to this stuff. So how would I go about getting them to witness the signing?

You go to a convention where the CGC has a table (most major conventions) at which Kevin or Peter is also attending. Then you go to their table and you can either (depending on the con) have one of their witnesses collect the signature for you, or wait till one of the witnesses is available to accompany you to collect the signature.

ZeoRed
12-31-2012, 01:09 AM
Ah i see i see. Ya this will be hard to get done lol.

So whats up with peter why is he not doing the bigger venue's right now?

Archon_Turtle
12-31-2012, 01:14 AM
Ah i see i see. Ya this will be hard to get done lol.

So whats up with peter why is he not doing the bigger venue's right now?

He doesn't really do anything involving the turtles or the industry since having sold the property to Viacom. He has done a couple small shows as favors to personal friends but that's it.

ZeoRed
12-31-2012, 01:20 AM
That's really unfortunate. Sounds to me like he's laying low. I'd hate it if he just dropped out of the light. I will get a signature by him. Some how...It will happen....lol. Guys I seriously appreciate all the help with this. You guys have made it more than worth while coming here so far. I look forward to posting more on the forum.s I do appreciate the help and I'll keep everyone in the loop on the comic. I'll post some pics once I am able to pick it up. Gonna have to hurry though because the guy wont hold it for me for much longer. Off to make my sales post.

Archon_Turtle
12-31-2012, 01:47 AM
Gonna have to hurry though because the guy wont hold it for me for much longer. Off to make my sales post.

If comic collecting is something you really want to pursue seriously, do NOT let that book get away from you at that price.

MrPliggins
12-31-2012, 07:22 AM
Some good info here. Question: Back before CGC, when I used to go to cons in the early '90s, I used to take a picture of artists signing my books. Would that not even work for authentication? I know that you can photoshop a picture, but these are actual film with negatives. I did this for Stan Lee and Eric Talbot in '94, but didn't do it for the Mirage guys when I met them in '93.

Scanderson
12-31-2012, 08:07 AM
I was able to get Kevin to sign my TMNT #2, #3, and #4 first prints at SDCC this year. They were my first SS yellow labels. I just asked the rep at the CGC booth to walk over to Kevin's booth to authenticate the signature/ sketch. Got a 9.6 on the #2, a 9.2 on the #3, and a 9.4 on the #4, white pages. I will definitely bring more to next years con. It was a fun experience.

rich
12-31-2012, 10:07 AM
Some good info here. Question: Back before CGC, when I used to go to cons in the early '90s, I used to take a picture of artists signing my books. Would that not even work for authentication? I know that you can photoshop a picture, but these are actual film with negatives. I did this for Stan Lee and Eric Talbot in '94, but didn't do it for the Mirage guys when I met them in '93.

This excerpt below is taken directly from the CGC Site (http://www.cgccomics.com/grading/SignatureSeries.asp):

Frequently Asked Questions About CGC Signature Series

What if I get the book signed before submitting the book to CGC?
Unfortunately, if the signing is not witnessed by someone authorized by CGC, then the signature cannot be authenticated for the Signature Series label. Testimonials, photographs, and video recordings are not accepted.

ZeoRed
12-31-2012, 11:22 AM
Ok see i can understand about photographic proof i get that. But if you have friggin video of it...that's a little much. I cant see how that could be faked.

Venom
12-31-2012, 11:28 AM
Ok see i can understand about photographic proof i get that. But if you have friggin video of it...that's a little much. I cant see how that could be faked.

Speaking hypothetically, who's to say the comic in front of the grader is the same one he/she is viewing in the video?

Here's a more visual example:
See my sig below? I own one of those cars, but the one you're seeing is not the one in my garage. Hope that helps. :)

rich
12-31-2012, 11:28 AM
Ok see i can understand about photographic proof i get that. But if you have friggin video of it...that's a little much. I cant see how that could be faked.

How can they validate that the comic in the video is the same as the comic you're trying to get graded? Sure, the video is proof that A comic was once signed by someone but not proof that THE comic in question is the one in the video. I can easily see how someone would use one video to pass hundreds of fake signatures.

EDIT: ^^ or, what Venom said :) ^^

ZeoRed
12-31-2012, 11:59 AM
Lol point proven by the way I am EXTREMELY jealous of you owning that car. It's my dream to own one.

Redeemer
12-31-2012, 02:06 PM
^if you dont buy it, I want to buy it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ZeoRed
12-31-2012, 02:45 PM
Lol trust me I'll have it picked up asap. ;)

ZeoRed
01-04-2013, 06:03 PM
Well everyone at the risk of my wife divorcing me I gave the comic a good looking over based on all the info you guys gave me. The gobbldygook adds are there the dover address is there...this is the real deal and I am now the owner of a first print first issues tmnt. I'll post pics at the top of the thread tonight.

Oculus Orbus
01-04-2013, 07:40 PM
Congratulations, ZeoRed!

Scanderson
01-04-2013, 07:53 PM
Congrats! I picked up an CGC 8.5 a few years back, and it set me back a lot more than yours! Nice find!

ZeoRed
01-04-2013, 08:02 PM
Thanks guys. Yeah its now just a matter of convincing the wife it was a good deal. So now that I'm back in dallas its off to the sellers forums to make some of that cash back.

Update: Pics of the comic added to first post.