PDA

View Full Version : Anyone wish the 2003 cartoon was darker?


TurtleFan2012
01-12-2013, 01:37 PM
I mean rated-pg and rated-r type dark like GI Joe Resolute. I wish it was on HBO or adult swim. They could show the turtles stabbing their enemies and shredder killing his own henchmen on screen.

CyberCubed
01-12-2013, 01:38 PM
Dude it was a Saturday morning cartoon. What did you expect?

TurtleFan2012
01-12-2013, 01:51 PM
Dude it was a Saturday morning cartoon. What did you expect?

Well duh lol. I was saying they should make the series for HBO or adult swim. It will be more darker.

TheSkeletonMan939
01-12-2013, 02:04 PM
There's a difference between a show being "more darker" and being realistic. You probably don't know the difference.

In my dream TMNT show, there'd be some blood, but the turtles wouldn't be walking around looking for reasons to chop people's fingers off. It'd look something like Young Justice, where you can see faint traces of blood, but it's all tame yet still feels realistic.

Xav
01-12-2013, 02:34 PM
There's blood in Young Justice?

Blossombrooks
01-12-2013, 02:47 PM
I think considering the supposed target audience we were pretty lucky, yeah there was no blood but 'Insane in the membrane' was definitely dark. They did a good job in my eyes, it's not like some cartoons where a character was injured one week and fine the next, there were scars and recovery at least.
The animation was great though and seeing that put into a more mature concept would be cool I grant you.

TheSkeletonMan939
01-12-2013, 03:09 PM
There's blood in Young Justice?

Kinda-sorta. Scratches are red.

Powder
01-12-2013, 03:13 PM
2edgy4me man

pannoni1
01-12-2013, 03:27 PM
It was dark enough for me and alot of us compared to pre-Red Sky OT to really set this series apart to make it interesting. I think if it got even darker, it would have alienated so many more fans that the series wouldn't have last as long. The comics are special since they weren't marketed to kids and allow only the mature to discover.

Icebot
01-12-2013, 04:00 PM
If it was darker, 4kids probably would have cancelled so many more episodes, like they did with Nightmares Recycled.

So no, I don't think it should be darker. However, I do wish they kept the dark animation for Fast Forward and Back To The Sewers.

Candy Kappa
01-12-2013, 04:05 PM
must be more darker and broodier and edgier!

makes it better!

Yorae
01-12-2013, 10:31 PM
I think it was dark enough. I mean just look at "Insane in the Membrane" and "Same as it Never Was"!

And although there's no blood or excess violence, to me the overall feel of the series is dark. There were many episodes that ended on a grim note and very few had the "all's well that ends well" type of ending. You don't get the kiddy feel that the OT and 2K12 series have in this series. It feels more sober.

Tomoshibi Amatsu
01-12-2013, 10:55 PM
Why? It was plenty dark. Having Raphael yelling "f*** you!" while gouging someone's eyeballs out with his sais wouldn't make the show any better. Which is pretty much the only difference if Adult Swim had it.

Jester
01-12-2013, 10:58 PM
Andrew Modeen.

zkarlette
01-12-2013, 11:06 PM
I mean rated-pg and rated-r type dark like GI Joe Resolute. I wish it was on HBO or adult swim. They could show the turtles stabbing their enemies and shredder killing his own henchmen on screen.

HBO? So...you would like it to be as edgy as game of thrones?

Pterobat
01-13-2013, 12:07 AM
No, it was fine.

I think sometimes you get this weird elegance out of modern action cartoons that are dramatic but held back by children's television laws, so that writers and animators are forced to test boundaries, to work harder to create effective atmosphere, and the results can be, on some levels, better than if they lacked restraint.

...and then, sometimes, they still should get to bust out with something shocking. Just to liven things up.

Refractive Reflections
01-13-2013, 01:21 AM
There's a difference between a show being "more darker" and being realistic. You probably don't know the difference.

In my dream TMNT show, there'd be some blood, but the turtles wouldn't be walking around looking for reasons to chop people's fingers off. It'd look something like Young Justice, where you can see faint traces of blood, but it's all tame yet still feels realistic.

I agree with TheSkeletonMan939, "darker" is somewhat ambiguous. You have to differentiate it from: more gore/violence OR more angst/tragedy/heavyhearted OR more crass/profanity.

Considering 2K3 was for children, the staff did as much as they could in the cartoon and pushed it too far for censors with "Nightmares Recycled". I think they properly pursued the angst/tragedy/heavyhearted aspect of it without making it too depressing, but as TheSkeletonMan939 said above, sometimes having more violence doesn't really contribute to the story/plot.

I guess it depends on people's individual preference and experience with violence.

While I would be curious about an R-rated version of TMNT from a production/directing perspective, I don't think I would fully enjoy it because, at least for me, it seems awkward to make a story/plot increasingly more "real" with darker elements but at the same time using cartoon imagery. To me, the more "real" or darker you are making a movie/film/episode, the more the environment/premise should be based upon reality so that it makes a much more profound impact on the viewer and that viewer can easily relate or apply themselves to that situation. ...Usually when people watch/read TMNT its usually to escape reality and for entertainment, not to make them feel even more heavyhearted.

prophecy718
01-13-2013, 08:47 AM
for a children's program at the time, it was as dark as it can get

with that said, i think the show was ok.

Spitfire
01-13-2013, 10:12 AM
Well duh lol. I was saying they should make the series for HBO or adult swim. It will be more darker.

It'd have lasted about 1/12th the amount of time too. We'd have maybe for 1 season. Not that I wouldn't enjoy a series more like the comics I'm just a realist.

Coola Yagami
01-13-2013, 10:43 AM
Andrew Modeen.

I think he wants it more to be just like the comics being brought to life, not just darker for darkness sakes. You do NOT cram a 13 issue saga into 3 episodes.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
01-13-2013, 11:08 AM
Usually when people watch/read TMNT its usually to escape reality and for entertainment, not to make them feel even more heavyhearted.

Yeah, or just re-create their childhood.

DarkLightDragon
01-13-2013, 11:59 AM
Not really. Because,


1. Darker =/= better.

2. Like someone has said already, the term 'dark' is rather ambigious and could mean anything without giving it proper context.

3. It had to keep in mind that it's still a kid's show. While it's possible to show dark stuff in kid's shows (Avatar: TLA comes to mind mostly) there's usually a limit as to how much "dark" stuff you can get away with.

Matches Malone
01-13-2013, 01:36 PM
While I agree that dark does not equal better, I think some have missed the point of the initial post (or maybe I did). Many have pointed out that it's a kids show, but I think what was implied was that the "darker show" being suggested would not be a kid's show.

So yeah, I wish we could get a show that was not held back by the restraints of a kids show or audience, like actually being able to use their weapons or kill. However, like many pointed out, I think the show was still pretty good at tackling the darker stuff without always watering it down too badly. What I would have liked more than anything else was better writing. A lot of the characterizations were pretty forced, and the attempts at humor were often cringe-worthy, especially the shell puns. Granted, humor wasn't the focus of the show, but there are plenty of action/drama shows that are still able to write comedic moments well.

TurtleFan2012
01-13-2013, 08:31 PM
While I agree that dark does not equal better, I think some have missed the point of the initial post (or maybe I did). Many have pointed out that it's a kids show, but I think what was implied was that the "darker show" being suggested would not be a kid's show.

So yeah, I wish we could get a show that was not held back by the restraints of a kids show or audience, like actually being able to use their weapons or kill. However, like many pointed out, I think the show was still pretty good at tackling the darker stuff without always watering it down too badly. What I would have liked more than anything else was better writing. A lot of the characterizations were pretty forced, and the attempts at humor were often cringe-worthy, especially the shell puns. Granted, humor wasn't the focus of the show, but there are plenty of action/drama shows that are still able to write comedic moments well.

When I was talking about "darker", I meant blood, gore, swearing, and more violence like stabbing foot ninjas and bleeding from a wound. Another company could make a series similiar to the 1996 Spawn series.

CyberCubed
01-13-2013, 11:10 PM
Your best bet is a DTV movie based on Mirage #1 or something.

I doubt it'll ever happen though with Nick in charge of the property.

TheWarrior97
01-13-2013, 11:14 PM
I agree, I personally wanted it darker...which it was. But I was wanting it even more.!

Vivi
01-14-2013, 09:20 AM
Very little things could have made the tone seem more serious than it came across without changing the level of gore or the rating of the dialogue...things like music (ambient sound etc), VA direction and even the color saturation (which was a little garish for my taste). If some of the editing was a little tighter it could have made grand difference in many a scene.

Consider the tmnt in turtles prime (Turtles Forever) compared to the 4kids set. Same show, big difference in tone.

ToTheNines
01-14-2013, 09:49 AM
You do NOT cram a 13 issue saga into 3 episodes.

Arrrrgghhh. Don't remind me.

To be fair, since they weren't adapting the Casey, April or Splinter portions of CaW, it didn't have to be a super long multi-parter. But yes, 3 is just ridiculous. Then again, so was the 4kids version of the Mafia, Leo's random loss of confidence and his foolish handling of "fixing things" (not to mention how Raph and Splinter decided to kiss his ass just to wrap up to story), and the fact that Karai has to be Shredder's daughter.

And let's not forget that horrible song. Barf.

CyberCubed
01-14-2013, 11:35 AM
City at War also couldn't have Rat King because he wasn't introduced in the show yet.

I felt they made up for City at War with all the further Foot fights afterward. Remember in the comics this was pretty much the "end" of the Turtles fighting the Foot with a few exceptions in Tales or Image. But 4kids had many more Foot battles afterward which made up for it.

Coola Yagami
01-14-2013, 01:44 PM
City at War also couldn't have Rat King because he wasn't introduced in the show yet.

I felt they made up for City at War with all the further Foot fights afterward. Remember in the comics this was pretty much the "end" of the Turtles fighting the Foot with a few exceptions in Tales or Image. But 4kids had many more Foot battles afterward which made up for it.

Then they should have introduced Rat King sooner...? Even back then I was a little confused how they made 'Return to New York' when they haven't shown the Triceratons yet. The 'Rouge in the House' thing was a poor sloppy attempt to keep the coolest part of Return to New York.

CyberCubed
01-14-2013, 01:47 PM
Then they should have introduced Rat King sooner...? Even back then I was a little confused how they made 'Return to New York' when they haven't shown the Triceratons yet. The 'Rouge in the House' thing was a poor sloppy attempt to keep the coolest part of Return to New York.

Rogue in the House was the best 2-parter of Season 2, what are you talking about?

TheSkeletonMan939
01-14-2013, 02:40 PM
Then they should have introduced Rat King sooner...? Even back then I was a little confused how they made 'Return to New York' when they haven't shown the Triceratons yet. The 'Rouge in the House' thing was a poor sloppy attempt to keep the coolest part of Return to New York.

What are you talking about?

Coola Yagami
01-14-2013, 03:07 PM
What are you talking about?

Just that the show could have been darker if they kept the stories closer to the Mirage comics, without changing the order or events and such. Zog was supposed to be in Return of New York, but wasn't since the show didn't show the Triceratons yet. Rogue in the House was a 'whoops... we left out this awesome scene when a Triceraton helps the Turtles take down the Foot from the comics... let's make up a quick 2-parter and toss that in there!'

ZariusTwo
01-14-2013, 03:47 PM
Being faithful to the comics wouldnt neccersarily made the show "better". The Mirage stuff really is boring and overrated.

zodiac brave
01-14-2013, 04:46 PM
Being faithful to the comics wouldnt neccersarily made the show "better". The Mirage stuff really is boring and overrated.

well...some is.

TurtleTitan97
01-14-2013, 05:18 PM
Not really. I though the tone for the show was alright.

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
01-14-2013, 05:28 PM
If you seriously talk about "dark" in kids stories, maybe dark like the Archie Comics, and still dark. Archie dark (peaking with the death of the Mutanimals) and Mirage dark isn't the same. 2003 show was sometimes darker than Archie.

Lethal Lullaby
01-14-2013, 06:15 PM
I thought it was pretty good. Personally I would have liked to see some blood, or even blood stains, but I think they did a good enough job to make it enjoyable.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
01-15-2013, 12:03 PM
I wouldn't have wanted to see blood, I liked that it was just gritty enough for adults while still being suitable for kids.

Powder
01-15-2013, 01:52 PM
Being faithful to the comics wouldnt neccersarily made the show "better". The Mirage stuff really is boring and overrated.

Yay for opinions & hypocrisy.

Dane E5R
01-16-2013, 12:35 AM
Why do people act like the Mirage comics had turtles swearing like Sam Jackson while murdering people in every panel? Seriously, those comics were never that grim, nor gritty. A rated R Turtles is, and always will be, an asinine concept.

Coola Yagami
01-16-2013, 10:44 PM
Why do people act like the Mirage comics had turtles swearing like Sam Jackson while murdering people in every panel? Seriously, those comics were never that grim, nor gritty. A rated R Turtles is, and always will be, an asinine concept.

Agreed. It wasn't a matter of being dark for darkness sake. It was just more 'real' with stuff cartoons shy away from like blood, death, pregnant women that die upon childbirth, Casey being drunk, and stuff like that.

Hell, to this day Wolverine still can't be shown smoking and drinking beer in a kids cartoon. Watching him drink bottled water in X-Men Evolution made me roll my eyes.

gobo
01-17-2013, 01:25 PM
I mean rated-pg and rated-r type dark like GI Joe Resolute. I wish it was on HBO or adult swim. They could show the turtles stabbing their enemies and shredder killing his own henchmen on screen.
I'm glad we didn't get contrived **** like that. Even had it been like "Same As It Never Was" every ep, that still would have been lame. Granted, there were a few eps I thought weren't dark or at least serious enough, but it's just the inconsistency of them that bugs me.