View Full Version : Why didn't IDW produce a proper Shell Shock trade?
Venom
01-15-2013, 11:55 AM
Something I've wondered since Classics Volume 1. The book only had one actual issue and a smattering of shorts from Shell Shock.
Since the IDw philosophy is to separate things into several volumes, there is enough shorts in Turtle Soup, Plastron Cafe, individual issues and of course Shell Shock (which collected a lot of the shorts up to its publication), to have pulled together a couple volumes of a collection and dub it like "Turtle Power: a Shell Shocking Collection of TMNT Shorts" or something different.
Shoot, the ones in Turtle Soup is already colored, too!
Just a thought.
Matches Malone
01-15-2013, 12:13 PM
I definitely would have liked to see the Mirage reprints collected in a more logical way, but unfortunately it seems they would prefer to use the shorts as back-up padding material for when their trades don't reach a certain page count with issues alone. Along with the coloring, it just seems like IDW doesn't have all that much faith in the non-Eastman/Laird stuff selling well. Seeing as how Mirage was losing money on their issues and TPBs, maybe with good reason. However, with the increased presence on the public radar and Nick/Viacom backing it up, who knows.
FoxZerro
01-15-2013, 12:26 PM
Something I've wondered since Classics Volume 1. The book only had three issues and a mattering of shorts from Shell Shock.
Since the IDw philosophy is to separate things into several volumes, there is enough shorts in Turtle Soup, Plastron Cafe, individual issues and of course Shell Shock (which collected a lot of the shorts up to its publication), to have pulled together a couple volumes of a collection and dub it like "Turtle Power: a Shell Shocking Collection of TMNT Shorts" or something different.
Shoot, the ones in Turtle Soup is already colored, too!
Just a thought.
The book only had ONE issue and the rest was all shorts from Shell Shock... It was a huge disappointment considering I had just bought a copy of Shell Shock and then received the highly debated and question Classics Volume One in the mail that same day. Owning both I'm glad to have Shell Shock because the original art is preserved, but the fact that IDW led with one issue and some shorts was not smart to me
CyberCubed
01-15-2013, 12:56 PM
Originally that first trade was supposed to be #13, #16 and #18.
Then they decided to just put the Mark Martin trilogy together, and for some reason #18 was totally skipped. I still don't understand why #18 was skipped as it was a Mark Bode story.
Venom
01-15-2013, 12:58 PM
The book only had ONE issue and the rest was all shorts from Shell Shock... It was a huge disappointment considering I had just bought a copy of Shell Shock and then received the highly debated and question Classics Volume One in the mail that same day. Owning both I'm glad to have Shell Shock because the original art is preserved, but the fact that IDW led with one issue and some shorts was not smart to me
You know, I had originally put one but I thought, "Nah, I'm not remembering correctly - 1 issue is ridiculous".
I dunno, perhaps IDW is hesistant to test the waters with the Turtle trades because of Mirage's performance, but on the other hand Mirage's books was a very focused, niche product with long-term supporters welcome along for the ride.
Honestly, I'm rather surprised the old stuff isn't selling more than it does because when you would bring up Turtles on a more general comic forum you would gets folks who would blatantly say they were curious about them but never touched them due to them being B&W. Granted, the Color Classics sell in the upper thousands range, so it's doing pretty well for a colorized 1980's comic.
CyberCubed
01-15-2013, 01:00 PM
I though the Ultimate Collections and Trades were selling well.
Its only the individual color classic issues that are selling poorly, mainly because they're the same issues in the Ultimate collections.
Venom
01-15-2013, 01:40 PM
I though the Ultimate Collections and Trades were selling well.
Its only the individual color classic issues that are selling poorly, mainly because they're the same issues in the Ultimate collections.
I sor tof segued in my last post. The floppies is what I was talking about toward the end. Which, like I mentioned, 7500-9500 copies of a nearly-30 year old book isn't too shabby.
Going back to trades, who wants to bet that somewhere down the line we'll see the Color Classics collected into a trade similar to the First Graphic Novels?
By the way, I don't wish for my opinions to come across as griping, I'm glad IDW is investing in getting the old TMNT material out in the public's eye, but I wish they would spend a little more time and care organizing the materials into a format that satisfies those of us who buy the books to support them (I also agree the TMNT Adventure tpbs are poorly executed).
FoxZerro
01-15-2013, 01:40 PM
You know, I had originally put one but I thought, "Nah, I'm not remembering correctly - 1 issue is ridiculous".
I think the way they justified it to themselves, and I hope I'm not now the one remembering incorrectly, is that Volume Two with the Mark Martin Trilogy released on the same day. Still if I'm a casual and I see Volume One and Volume Two on the shelf, my instinct will be to pick up Volume One. As much as I love the people's choice and some of the Shell Shock stories, that is not something that would entice into buying more.
Powder
01-15-2013, 02:01 PM
Something I've wondered since Classics Volume 1. The book only had one actual issue and a mattering of shorts from Shell Shock.
Since the IDw philosophy is to separate things into several volumes, there is enough shorts in Turtle Soup, Plastron Cafe, individual issues and of course Shell Shock (which collected a lot of the shorts up to its publication), to have pulled together a couple volumes of a collection and dub it like "Turtle Power: a Shell Shocking Collection of TMNT Shorts" or something different.
Shoot, the ones in Turtle Soup is already colored, too!
Just a thought.
Now THAT is a book I would buy. They need to put out that obscure/hard to find stuff.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.