View Full Version : 10 Year Anniversary of the 4kids TMNT Cartoon
Icebot
02-06-2013, 07:27 PM
As you may or may not know, it's been almost 10 years now since the 4kids TMNT cartoon aired the first episode Things Change for the first time ever (February 8, 2003). After 10 years, what are your thoughts on this cartoon? Are you planning to watch a marathon of the show or just Things Change to celebrate the 10th anniversary?
CyberCubed
02-06-2013, 07:49 PM
Its hard to believe its actually been 10 years. I still remember when this was the, "new" TMNT cartoon. Back then it was just so surprising to see TMNT return to TV with a new series after so long. I watched "Things Change" back in its debut on Feb. 8th in 2003...my god I was still in High School at the time.
The series really went well above and beyond what anyone could have ever thought a new Turtles cartoon could be at the time. Aside from the show being a bit weaker in the final seasons, it was a very high quality production.
Peter Laird working with Lloyd Goldfine through the series certainly shows. And it introduced some new major characters to the lore like Ch'rell, Hun and Bishop.
pannoni1
02-06-2013, 08:02 PM
I was never aware of a new Ninja Turtles series at the time, since I was preparing to graduate from high school, and saw any cartoon except for adult swim/Fox Sunday evening as "just for kids", meaning that only the blue moon movie or video game was all TMNT I enjoyed at the time. That said, 10 years for something not in the first generation is a long time, and its fun reading the back posts on this forum leading up to the premiere. It was a simpler time online before social media, with streaming video still not fully established. That said, with a new Nick episode airing and since I have an off day from work, I'll be watching a few episodes this Friday. This series aired in network Saturday Morning's twilight on FoxBox, and despite the cable competition, did quite well and remains the most faithful to the original creators' premise of the Turtles.
Machias Banshee
02-06-2013, 08:15 PM
I so enjoyed the 2K3 series... the animation was top notch, the characters were good. I just wish it could have ended better. But it's what Really got this place up and moving at full speed.
shuriken
02-06-2013, 08:16 PM
I think I'll have a little TMNT marathon in the near future. Considering I haven't seen a lot of the episodes in a good 3-5 years it'll be nice trip down memory lane. Also really wanna watch the OT show in it's entirety too. Although considering there are 197 episodes I might go insane...
TurtleTitan97
02-06-2013, 08:25 PM
Hard to believe it will almost be 10 years since this show premired. I actually started rewatching this series earlier this week. Other than the change of animation and tone in Fast Forward and Back to the Sewers, I really enjoyed this show.:tsmile:
Lethal Lullaby
02-06-2013, 08:28 PM
I still watch this series every now and then. :tgrin: Even if I've seen every episode more then once. :trazz: Still I'm surprised it's been 10 years. :lol:
Jephael
02-06-2013, 08:28 PM
Boy, where does the time go? Feels like just yesterday I was recording those episodes. I gotta start watching them again sometime.
CyberCubed
02-06-2013, 09:21 PM
Agreed, I feel like it was just yesterday when new episodes of the 4kids cartoon were still airing. (Although the last episode aired in 2009, so it was about 4 years ago now)
Turtles Forever was also an excellent finale for the series. Its great had they wrapped up all the major villains by the end.
Garfield
02-06-2013, 09:57 PM
Ten years!?
man where does the time go...
I remember being a Junior in high school when this was begining to air.
I vocalized how excited I was and I got made fun of for it by some of my peers. I didn't even care.
I was a badass back then.
Cheers. :tcool:
Orisue
02-06-2013, 10:31 PM
I remember waking up excited, making a bowl of cereal and watching this. Crazy to think I was only ten:O. Feels so long ago. I loved this show so much lol. Didn't care for anything else on 4kids though. Once turtles was over it was time to change the channel.
Vegeta
02-06-2013, 11:42 PM
I was also a junior in high school. I ignored it because I was interested in girlfriends and music much more. However I am in the third season right now and am enjoying most of the show. Splinter in the battle nexus tournament and him having his own statue was just awesome. Really made me respect Splinter in the 2k3 series, I love this guy even with his horrible voice acting!
Yorae
02-07-2013, 12:03 AM
Oh, wow. Ten years! Where does the time go!
I started watching the show when it started airing on TV over here, which was in 2005, so I've been aquainted with this show for about 7 years. Till this day I rewatch it and love it to bits. To me this is THE TMNT show. The Nick show is amazing in its own right, but the 4kids show holds a very dear place in my heart :)
....So, when are we getting a DVD boxset again? :D
Vegeta
02-07-2013, 01:28 AM
....So, when are we getting a DVD boxset again? :D[/QUOTE]
That's what I'm saying.
TheCanadiandrome
02-07-2013, 01:56 AM
Yeah as I was watching disc one of season 4 I was thinking holy crap, it's been 10 years since the show premiered. I never got into it during its initial run (crazy I know eh?) but now that I've watched a few eps, and own the whole series on DVD and since Turtles Forever, I found a new love and appreciate this show
TheBlueTurtle1
02-07-2013, 05:27 AM
10 years, I can't believe it. It is still a great show, and the first season always reminds me of the movie universe.
TheSkeletonMan939
02-07-2013, 05:46 AM
This was the best TMNT series possible, mainly because Laird went out of his way to help the writing team out.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
02-07-2013, 06:05 AM
....So, when are we getting a DVD boxset again? :D
That's what I'm saying.[/QUOTE]
Maybe in a Battle Shell collection? Since the 1987 one was in a Turtle Van collection.
tmntpower1988
02-07-2013, 07:41 AM
10 years already :o Time does fly alright. The 2003 series was the best, it's been almost a year since I've watched the episodes, must watch them again soon.
Shredded
02-07-2013, 08:09 AM
We can't deny though, it had an incredible run!
Four full seasons people whom has seen the show agrees is the best.
Fifth season up for debate, but I am not ever going to deny that the season finale of that one was made out of epic.
six and seventh season which are also much up for debate, but they exist.
And one seriously awesome special direct to DVD movie pairing the turtles with the iconic past incarnation.
It's a seriously solid long running show, it did well! it did really well! You deserved your retirement show.
Happy anniversary show! have a slize of pizza, it's on me!
ToTheNines
02-07-2013, 08:18 AM
Since tomorrow's the day, I'm going to watch my VHS recording of the original "Things Change" airing. I'm pretty pumped since I haven't popped that tape in since like 2004, probably.
I don't know if you guys remember or not, but the FoxBox had this "24" style countdown to the premier that would have multiple TMNT clips going on at once. I hated most everything they aired back then, but I'd watch anyways just to catch the countdown... it got me so pumped. When if finally hit 0 it was like the most exciting moment of my 11 year old life. I got the last 5 seconds of it on my recording thankfully.
CyberCubed
02-07-2013, 08:34 AM
I actually remember staring in shock when, "Things Change" aired for the first time.
For some reason it reminded me like an actual action-oriented version of the Red Sky seasons of the OT, which was the last TMNT animated thing we had back then.
The thing that got me the most was the action sequences. Not only were the Turtles actually hitting the enemies with real moves, (something the OT rarely did), but as the show progressed some of the fights with the Foot, Shredder, Hun, Bishop, Rat King, etc. were incredible. The fights never got stale due to how well choreographed they were.
TheBlueTurtle1
02-07-2013, 08:44 AM
I remember thinking, this is gonna be awful compared to the 80s show, then I watched and was like wow that was awesome!
CyberCubed
02-07-2013, 08:48 AM
I just can't believe its been 10 years. The early 2000's don't feel that long ago yet they were.
Its really hard to believe I was still in High School back then. It actually made me feel old since I was a kid when the OT was airing and a mid-teen when the 4kids show was airing, and now I'm in my mid-20's as the Nick cartoon is airing.
Not just that, but its amazing how much the state of animation in general changed since then, how much videogames changed and movies and all other entertainment media. They were still making VHS tapes of the 4kids series back in 2003. VHS TAPES!
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
02-07-2013, 09:02 AM
I just can't believe its been 10 years. The early 2000's don't feel that long ago yet they were.
Its really hard to believe I was still in High School back then. It actually made me feel old since I was a kid when the OT was airing and a mid-teen when the 4kids show was airing, and now I'm in my mid-20's as the Nick cartoon is airing.
Not just that, but its amazing how much the state of animation in general changed since then, how much videogames changed and movies and all other entertainment media. They were still making VHS tapes of the 4kids series back in 2003. VHS TAPES!
The last VHS release was 26 April 2005!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teenage_Mutant_Ninja_Turtles_(2003)_DVD_releases
TheCanadiandrome
02-07-2013, 11:46 AM
Maybe in a Battle Shell collection? Since the 1987 one was in a Turtle Van collection.
That'd be awesome
I'll watch some episodes tommorow, and then maybe go out searching for new TMNT toys. I might get pizza for dinner too.
WOW I can't believe it's been 10 years! I feel so old.
I remember that day just like it was yesterday. I was in University and me and my friends watched it together in our dorm. Those were the good old days...everything was so awesome.
Ahem. Anyways. I loved the series.
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
02-07-2013, 02:26 PM
I recall this around late 2003-2004. This was the time I was learning everything about TMNT, from only knowing the Archie Comics, UK Hero Turtles Comics, the 1987 cartoon and "those three movies, who weren't really TMNT".
Longview01
02-07-2013, 05:11 PM
I remember clocking onto these very well.
In 2005 I was 24 and had lost my full time job and had no interest in doing anything except drinking and smoking....my girlfriend at the time had no problems with this and we used to download all manner of films to watch during our sessions.
This is when I decided to give the first couple of seasons of the new TMNT show a watch and I was blown away completely. I never looked back and pretty much loved the entire run of shows.
When I decided to quit smoking I used the dvd's as a way to encourage me to stop, for every week I didn't smoke I ordered another dvd from the US (I live in the UK) and kept going right upto the BTTS releases from Australia...I still look at those dvd's and remember why I stopped smoking and how much they helped me.
Now i'm 31, i'm still with the same girl and we have a 6 month old girl (who will be a TMNT fan) alot has changed but my love for this series has never gone away.
Raph's Girl
02-07-2013, 05:42 PM
Geesh. It's really been 10 years?! Seems only like yesterday. I do remember the year before all the hype leading up to it. I even purchased a build-a-bear turtle and named him Raphael. *lol*
CyberCubed
02-07-2013, 05:56 PM
It's stuff like this that makes you realize how old we've all become. The days of being a teenager are long over.
TheSkeletonMan939
02-07-2013, 08:18 PM
It's stuff like this that makes you realize how old we've all become. The days of being a teenager are long over.
Old and fat. Yep.
dragonside
02-07-2013, 09:30 PM
oh man, 10 years, i didn't even realize.
I've been working a lot of long hours... and time just seems to pass me by.
Happy 10 Years 4kids TMNT (the faithful to the original source material series).... LOL and now 4kids is bankrupt
CyberCubed
02-07-2013, 09:59 PM
I remember when this show first started I wished it went on for 10 seasons and made 200 episodes.
Oh well, now I'm hoping the Nick cartoon does just that. One day I feel there will be a TMNT cartoon that breaks the 200 episode milestone barrier. The original series missed it by just 7 episodes.
TheCanadiandrome
02-08-2013, 01:38 AM
WOW I can't believe it's been 10 years! I feel so old.
.
You feel old, just how old are you?
LeoNerdo
02-08-2013, 02:25 AM
Man now I'm feeling old. I wasn't into it when the show first aired. Partly because most of my Saturday mornings were occupied with other things and I was also highly skeptical of the show without seeing or reading anything on it (how could anything have compared to turtlemania?!?). I wasn't into the comics yet then and none of my friends were giving the show a chance, but the first time I watched it I got hooked! The 2k3 show was really my gateway into the Mirage comics because it got me interested again as a 15-16 year old kid.
Powder
02-08-2013, 02:49 AM
Gonna have to commemorate today by watching "Things Change". :)
Yep, time for another marathon. :twink:
CyberCubed
02-08-2013, 08:42 AM
Today is Feb 8th, the 10 year day! I watched the first episode at 10:30amEST today exactly 10 years ago.
My god, it doesn't even feel that long ago.
Icebot
02-08-2013, 10:43 AM
Well, today's the day so now I'm getting ready to watch Things Change.
Also, has anyone noticed that February 8 hasn't been on a Saturday one time since 2003, when the cartoon began? I was looking at my calendars and figured it out. It's supposed to be on Saturday next year in 2014 though and I think I'm gonna watch Things Change on that day to celebrate the day being on a Saturday.
tmntpower1988
02-08-2013, 01:38 PM
When I decided to quit smoking I used the dvd's as a way to encourage me to stop, for every week I didn't smoke I ordered another dvd from the US (I live in the UK) and kept going right upto the BTTS releases from Australia...I still look at those dvd's and remember why I stopped smoking and how much they helped me.
I done something similar to this only it was alcohol I gave up, so I'd like to thank the TMNT 1980s and 2k3 DVD's for keeping me off the drink :D I'd also like to thank the Dragonball, Dragonball Z and Dragonball GT DVD's as well for having a part to play in it. :D BTW Happy Birthday TMNT 2k3 :)
ToTheNines
02-08-2013, 03:48 PM
Just watched, it was awesome. Watching on VHS really took me back. The commercials were just as entertaining too, but they reminded me of how bad FoxBox was. Ultraman Tiga... Ultimate Muscle... Fighting Foodons!
Also dug up an old Toy Fair magazine from '02 that you guys might like taking a peak at.
http://i727.photobucket.com/albums/ww280/craig-5/IMG_1286.jpg
Pterobat
02-08-2013, 08:24 PM
For me, it hasn't been ten years--I just started watching the series a few months ago, and finished it just very recently. At the time it was airing, I was no longer interested in TMNT period, and I don't think we got any Canadian channels with it, either.
However, these days I love the 4Kids series. When it was good, it was good. :tcool: I'm glad they had Peter Laird on board to whip the series into shape and bring in the Mirage comics lore, and the end result was one of those great kids' cartoons that can capture adults.
When it hit the fifth season my interest lost steam in a big way, but despite that cliche I manged to finish it. It's a great show, and I will remember it for the good bits.
snake
02-08-2013, 10:12 PM
Nice find tothenines!
"do we still say tubular?"
" I hope not"
:lol:
TheCanadiandrome
02-08-2013, 11:04 PM
I've been watching all my DVDs lately. I'm on the Ninja Tribunal season
CyberCubed
02-16-2013, 10:30 AM
It's great how Season 1 moved so quickly with storylines and Shredder fights. The Nick show is very slow in that regard.
Matches Malone
02-16-2013, 12:06 PM
It's great how Season 1 moved so quickly with storylines and Shredder fights. The Nick show is very slow in that regard.
Not sure what you mean by this... The turtles actually fought The Shredder earlier in the Nick show (episode 9) than this series (episode 10). Maybe it only feels very slow because you have to wait episode to episode and you've forgotten how slow it felt when you had to do that when the 2K3 episodes were first coming out.
CyberCubed
02-16-2013, 12:08 PM
Not sure what you mean by this... The turtles actually fought The Shredder earlier in the Nick show (episode 9) than this series (episode 10). Maybe it only feels very slow because you have to wait episode to episode and you've forgotten how slow it felt when you had to do that when the 2K3 episodes were first coming out.
By the 16th episode we had The Shredder Strikes back. By the end of Season 1 we had Return to New York.
Spitfire
02-16-2013, 12:14 PM
I haven't watched the series in years. Last thing I watched was the first Aussie BTTS DVD and I didn't even bother with the second. That was a long time ago. I want to rewatch it I've just seen it so many times I want to forget it as best I can so I can watch it fresh. I'd also like a BR release but I foresee me having a chance to watch the whole thing and then forget it a second time before that happens.
Guitar_Raph
02-16-2013, 12:32 PM
Liked the 2K3 show. There are 6 reasons I liked this version.
1).
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/Theall-AmericansuperheroTurtleTitan.jpg
Turtle Titan
2).
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/WayneMikeyGrayson.jpg
Wayne Grayson
3).
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/raphbike14.jpg
Raph on a motorcycle
4).
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/CombatCrusiers.jpg
Combat Cruisers
5).
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/CodyJones.jpg
Cody Jones
6).
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/TuxedoTMNT.jpg
TMNT in tuxedos!
Happy 10th anniversary &..
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/PCenter/Ninja%20Turtles%20The%20Next%20Mutation/HappyMikey.jpg
Party on, dudes!
Matches Malone
02-16-2013, 04:13 PM
By the 16th episode we had The Shredder Strikes back. By the end of Season 1 we had Return to New York.
But is this really a fair comparison when you're bringing up the end of the first season of 4Kids and Nick hasn't even gotten there yet? Just saying you can't really say Nick has introduced Shredder fights at a slower pace when they actually did so at an earlier episode and the rest of the first season remains to be seen.
CyberCubed
02-16-2013, 04:18 PM
But is this really a fair comparison when you're bringing up the end of the first season of 4Kids and Nick hasn't even gotten there yet? Just saying you can't really say Nick has introduced Shredder fights at a slower pace when they actually did so at an earlier episode and the rest of the first season remains to be seen.
True but as I said, I feel like more happened in the first 16 4kids episodes than the first 16 Nick episodes. The Garbageman ep was the only filler in this batch.
ToTheNines
02-16-2013, 04:42 PM
True but as I said, I feel like more happened in the first 16 4kids episodes than the first 16 Nick episodes. The Garbageman ep was the only filler in this batch.
Nano? Turtle Titan?
CyberCubed
02-16-2013, 04:48 PM
Nano? Turtle Titan?
Forgot about those, so I guess 3 fillers even if they all have sequel episodes.
Also I feel being 2D instead of CG allowed is to see so many more locations and characters. The Purple Dragons in Nick are a grand total of 3 people, whereas in 4kids they had like 20 different designs for them as seen in Angel's episode.
Gonstead
02-16-2013, 07:33 PM
Hard to believe it's been 10 years. Time just flies by so fast!
Every now and then I've been watching some episodes here and there from the different seasons and I still love the heck out of this show!
Happy Anniversary 2K3 TMNT.
TheCanadiandrome
02-16-2013, 09:51 PM
yes Happy Anniversary 2K3 TMNT
Matches Malone
02-17-2013, 12:39 AM
True but as I said, I feel like more happened in the first 16 4kids episodes than the first 16 Nick episodes. The Garbageman ep was the only filler in this batch.
I don't know about "more happened," so much has had stronger continuity. I definitely appreciate that, but I'll take the stronger writing of Nick's show (at least, so far) over continuity any day. Filler or not, at the end of the day, it comes down to how good the show is.
Still, I think Nick has been doing a good job with at least showing what Shredder and the Foot are up to here and there, even if the episode doesn't revolve around them.
Spitfire
02-17-2013, 02:50 AM
The Nick show does not have strong writing.
Shredded
02-17-2013, 03:31 AM
The Nick show does not have strong writing.
yes it does.
In some aspects stronger than the 2k3 show, but also their writing style is so very different that it's hard to compare them.
What I find to be the main difference is that the 2k3 is mostly focused on events!
The big events, building up to events and then having one event after the other.
While the Nick show is mostly build around characters, and spends it time focusing on the characters, whom will eventually meet some kind of event.
So well, one has "Primary focus is events." and the other. "Primary focus is characters."
Which means the 2k3 show has better events but the nick show has better characters.
The 2k3 show has a world that feels way bigger and more complex, but the nick show has way sharper humour.
It's two very very different show, and the only thing they really seem to have in common is the main presence.
Also me and my friend watched almost all of season one of the 2k3 show last night, we ended up riffing it quite a bit, and we realised how ridicoules the show can be, and how weak some of the writing is compared to the nick show. (Some of it.)
Like... all-ready in episode two they have a hoover car Donnie apparently just build for them, with no explanation what so ever.
Where in the hoot did they get that from?
Stockman is also so wonderfully over the top evil from the first second on screen, he even has an evil laugh... which we laughed over.
And some of Mikeys puns.. most of them.. are pretty terrible, only a few of them actually hits home-run.
I'm not saying the show is bad! me and my friend agreed it's probably the most action orianted show we could think off, that the action does look cool, and serious. But well, it has its silly moments.. a lot.
ToTheNines
02-17-2013, 07:51 AM
The Nick show does not have strong writing.
And the 4kids show does?
I love this show to death, but most episodes are littered with plot holes.
Also it's not nearly as funny as the Nick show.
ZariusTwo
02-17-2013, 08:28 AM
Everything ever made has plot holes.
Nick show is admitedly funny, but that's all it ever manages to be. Everything else is pretty cliche about it. I doubt people will look on it fondly in years to come, they're just saying it's good now because it's the only show we've got at the moment and we don't want it to tank.
CyberCubed
02-17-2013, 08:31 AM
The Nick show definitely has better characterisation of the Turtles and humor, but I feel the 4kids series trumps it in everything else.
The 4kids Turtles were basically the Mirage Turtles just slightly exaggerated in personality traits. The plotlines of Seasons 1-4 especially were handled extremely well, and the Tribunal arc was fun for me and I don't even like anime.
And by the first 16 episodes I was more impressed with the 4kids series. I remember back in 2003 both, "The Shredder Strikes" and "Shredder Strikes Back" completely blew me away when I was them as a teenager. I never thought we'd get a TMNT series that reminded me of Bruce Timm or Greg Weisman superhero cartoons.
Avatar Yuffie
02-17-2013, 08:35 AM
My only complaint with the 2k3 is that 4Kids tries to make it mature... but it feels restrained at the same time.
For example, when Leo was angsting about Splinter not understanding how he values his swords in that Shredder debut episode, he threw a bunch of newpapers in the air and cut them into paper stars.
I didn't see that as a show of Leo's control and skills with his weapon, all I saw is Leo making paper stars, and it is so narm-y it destroyed the gravity of that scene. The show really has a bad habit of doing that.
CyberCubed
02-17-2013, 08:46 AM
I didn't see that as a show of Leo's control and skills with his weapon, all I saw is Leo making paper stars, and it is so narm-y it destroyed the gravity of that scene. The show really has a bad habit of doing that.
It was still a kids show. This is probably what caused 4kids to ramp up Mike's personality to the annoying factor as the show progressed, they were desperately trying to get kids to watch it as toy sales started declining around Season 3-4.
ToTheNines
02-17-2013, 08:59 AM
My only complaint with the 2k3 is that 4Kids tries to make it mature... but it feels restrained at the same time.
For example, when Leo was angsting about Splinter not understanding how he values his swords in that Shredder debut episode, he threw a bunch of newpapers in the air and cut them into paper stars.
I didn't see that as a show of Leo's control and skills with his weapon, all I saw is Leo making paper stars, and it is so narm-y it destroyed the gravity of that scene. The show really has a bad habit of doing that.
Leo's awful that whole episode. Splinter tells him he's the best martial artist out of his brothers, then runs away crying because Splinter doesn't have the same hard on for swords that he does?
Avatar Yuffie
02-17-2013, 09:03 AM
Been awhile since I watched that episode, but IIRC Splinter was berating Leo for boasting about his swords are the best weapons at his brothers.
... OK, now I remember why I don't like 2k3 Leo, he was also pretty ridiculous in City at War too...
ToTheNines
02-17-2013, 09:18 AM
OK, now I remember why I don't like 2k3 Leo, he was also pretty ridiculous in City at War too...
Don't get me started on that.
He loses confidence because he missed stabbing a bullseye on a billboard? I'm pretty sure even I could stab a target that gigantic.
Then he goes on and on about putting a stop to the violence, but just prolongs it by risking his life to save like 15 mafiosos.
And then by the end, even though he was wrong, Raph and Splinter just show up and totally kiss his ass for no good reason.
Jephael
02-17-2013, 11:26 AM
Leo's awful that whole episode. Splinter tells him he's the best martial artist out of his brothers, then runs away crying because Splinter doesn't have the same hard on for swords that he does?
Yea looking back Leonardo was kind of a whiner throughout the course of the series. Don't even get me started on his behavior in season 4!
Matches Malone
02-17-2013, 04:50 PM
The Nick show does not have strong writing.
We'll probably just have to disagree on that, and I think a good deal of the voice acting is what sells the humor for me. Anyway, I more meant stronger writing as compared to 4Kids.
I know I've said this before, but by good writing, I mostly refer to the characterization. I appreciate that Nick explores each character and their flaws realistically, even if punctuated by humor. Raph doesn't narrate to himself like in 4Kids, "oh man, this guy is out of control!" He makes realizations, but it feels organic.
Plotwise, 4Kids does a good job, but it's kind of too early to see where Nick is going with the Kraang's plot, and the Foot's plans. The individual episodes and their plots are starting to fall a little flat for me, though, but at least it's still relatively fun.
I definitely don't mean to disparage the series, especially on this thread. In fact, it's still my favorite TMNT cartoon. I just openly wish it had the stronger writing of Nick along with the vision and tone of 4Kids. Plus, I definitely prefer traditional animation over CGI.
tmntpower1988
02-17-2013, 06:54 PM
Yea looking back Leonardo was kind of a whiner throughout the course of the series. Don't even get me started on his behavior in season 4!
Splinter should have kicked Leo's butt for hurting him.
CyberCubed
02-18-2013, 12:12 AM
Yea looking back Leonardo was kind of a whiner throughout the course of the series. Don't even get me started on his behavior in season 4!
4kids Leonardo was the best disciplined and had the most struggles to go through.
OT Leo did a lot of whining when he went solo, like in the second Rex-1 episode, the finale of Season 4 with that upstate NY plot where they enlarged food, or "Snakes Alive."
zodiac brave
02-18-2013, 01:50 AM
10 years and 10 days! i continued season 5 on the actual anniversary day and had a few slices of pepperoni and mushrooms (which i do for any turtle occasion, despite pizza not being a big thing in the 4kids show).
maaaaan...i remember the lead up to the premier, as most have said, like it was yesterday(or at least not at all like a decade ago.) i'd graduated high school in '01 and was only working retail, so i had a lot of time to look forward to it and be obsessed, lol! anyone remember the actual foxbox "box" that they gave away for free at toys r us? i still have the theme song cd that came with it around somewhere...
i, too, have a couple VHS tapes that i filled up (on EP) with season 1 eps back then.
well, here's to the 4kids show...warts and all...still tmnt, therefore awesome!! happy 10th!
Ryanator008
02-18-2013, 05:30 AM
I remember waking up excited, making a bowl of cereal and watching this. Crazy to think I was only ten:O. Feels so long ago. I loved this show so much lol. Didn't care for anything else on 4kids though. Once turtles was over it was time to change the channel.
Anime hater. :tcry:
Ryanator008
02-18-2013, 05:34 AM
A couple times I came close to screaming STFU at my TV because of 4-Kids Leo. :tmad:
Original TMNT Cartoon Fan
02-18-2013, 06:40 AM
4kids Leonardo was the best disciplined and had the most struggles to go through.
the finale of Season 4 with that upstate NY plot where they enlarged food"
Unidentified Flying Leonardo. Silly title. Awesome episode. Love the rural setting.
Martin
02-18-2013, 09:00 AM
Wow I feel so awkward now, I actually liked 4kids Leo haha. Though I gotta admit that sometimes he would get on my nerves.
Something that I loved and also hated about the show was the fact that donnie could build ANYTHING. I mean, seriously, where did he get the parts to build the plasma drill? I gotta start hanging out at the junkyard where he collects these things more often, sheesh.
Another thing about don was that he felt a bit overused. He always knew what to do or how to make stuff, and the writers tended to use his expertise too often as a key element of the plot, instead of coming up with a different way to solve things and push the story forward (that's why I liked so much the episode when donnie gets turned into vol 4 raph).
The 4kids series was my favorite (probably because it was the one I grew up with). I love the hard edge they tried to put into the show. Being a kid toon, they couldn't go full dark and gritty, but I believe they stroke a nice balance between the original tone of the franchise and the young audience to which they were aiming their product to. That being said, the series did not lack it flaws, but what ever does?
So happy birthday(?) 4kids toon, and thank you for making my childhood a better place :tgrin:
Spitfire
02-19-2013, 04:03 PM
4Kids Leo has depth. He acted like a baby over things when Splinter didn't take his side because he's a teenager. It makes perfect sense. Teenagers are not rational and get overly upset about little things. Leo's behavior during season 4 is actually some of my favorite Leo material because his reaction to what happens works from a psychological standpoint. He was betrayed by someone he saw as a friend and responsible, in his mind, for the injuries and near death of his family. He believed he should have been able to save them and all he could do was watch them almost die. His over the edge attitude mirrors yet again his age, he's a teenager, and how someone that young would handle a tragedy like that. As dumb as it seems the Ancient One works so well because he's a fat silly man who farts a lot, teaching him not to take life so seriously, but he's also one of the most skilled martial artists. He teaches Leo a very important lesson and while veiled it works.
4Kids hardly had perfect writing but it nailed somethings, for the most part character consistency. The only thing I disliked was the arc they started with Mikey and his Battle Nexus hubris that had a great climax but the effects weren't lasting. He had to be humbled once again in the episode where his brothers graduated and he didn't.
Voice actor performances are not writing. That's called directing. Liking lines of dialogue is all well and good but it's stories that matter the most. Which is why a lot of us like the old Marvel toons from the 90's. The voice acting was mostly garbage and the dialogue cheesy as hell but the stories were rich and strong with continuity, like the comics they were taken from, so you accept it. Not saying that stuff is gold standard either but there's a lot to be said about good story arcing.
In all fairness I'd have to watch more of the Nick show to really deconstruct it's writing but of what I saw I'm not impressed. And what I read about the shows monster of the week style I'm not looking forward to a deeper analysis.
CyberCubed
02-19-2013, 04:30 PM
Wow I feel so awkward now, I actually liked 4kids Leo haha. Though I gotta admit that sometimes he would get on my nerves.
Something that I loved and also hated about the show was the fact that donnie could build ANYTHING. I mean, seriously, where did he get the parts to build the plasma drill? I gotta start hanging out at the junkyard where he collects these things more often, sheesh.
Another thing about don was that he felt a bit overused. He always knew what to do or how to make stuff, and the writers tended to use his expertise too often as a key element of the plot, instead of coming up with a different way to solve things and push the story forward (that's why I liked so much the episode when donnie gets turned into vol 4 raph).
The 4kids series was my favorite (probably because it was the one I grew up with). I love the hard edge they tried to put into the show. Being a kid toon, they couldn't go full dark and gritty, but I believe they stroke a nice balance between the original tone of the franchise and the young audience to which they were aiming their product to. That being said, the series did not lack it flaws, but what ever does?
So happy birthday(?) 4kids toon, and thank you for making my childhood a better place :tgrin:
If you thought Don could build anything in the 4kids series, you should see OT Don.
Don actually built a time stopping device in that series. Just think for a second, Don created something that could actually freeze time and disrupt the natural space time continum.
Matches Malone
02-19-2013, 04:34 PM
All fair points. And voice acting not being part of writing was actually what I was trying to point out, as an acknowledgement on my part.
And you're right that story arcing can go a long way, and it does for me in this show. Again, I prefer 4Kids still for this reason, albeit most of the good story arcs were lifted from the comics and not written on their own.
Regarding Leo, and everyone else's characterization, I see and understand the reasoning you mention, but I just felt like things were written or delivered kind of forced. Irrational teenagers, sure, but we all know writing and acting isn't exactly like real life, so while the realistic motives are there, I just thought it could have been done more subtly or thoughtfully. Same goes with the Ancient One. I appreciate the left turn by making him an old farting man to highlight a lesson, but one can't deny the farting and silliness was a pretty low brow attempt at injecting humor into the situation. It works for some, which is fine, but not for me.
Spitfire
02-19-2013, 04:43 PM
Well that's where you make exceptions because at the end of the day you're watching a series made for kids. Spider-man didn't punch anyone, no one has guns, Batman fights a giant cow, we have to watch Harley and Poison Ivy go clothes shopping, and so on.
4Kids entire issue was Laird trying to make Batman TAS and the creators trying to make the OT. It struck a weird balance because bits of both are exaggerated and at times it's more like what Laird wanted and others more like what Fox wanted. Again far from perfect but you take what you can get because adult themed animated entertainment is rare and the DC animated films are really as close as you can get without any compromises.
Matches Malone
02-19-2013, 05:21 PM
Agreed here as well. I understand and accept the limitations of being a kids show, but I still think my criticism is fair to a degree because I don't think every case of weak writing is a result of those limitations. Probably a great deal, though. There are plenty of ways to appeal to both kids and adults, and sometimes 4Kids just failed to meet the adult side of it. It certainly didn't ruin it, it just saddens me that it was close to achieving the kind of greatness of B:TAS. Still, I know a show like B:TAS just had all the right stars aligned (ambitious creators, new and more flexible network, etc).
I think what it comes down to is that you are less bothered by the 4Kids flaws than I am, but that's fine. That just comes down to personal taste. It's still my favorite turtles show and hope I can do a full series marathon once it finally gets re-released! At least, I hope it does.
Spitfire
02-19-2013, 05:41 PM
Well Batman TAS was made in the early 90s before restrictions on cartoons were as hardcore and spent a fair bit of it's run in primetime being marketed at adults. I can't speak to how 2K3 would play to me now. I haven't laid eyes on it since maybe 2010 and the earlier episodes since before that. I may view it a lot differently now then I did then.
CyberCubed
02-19-2013, 05:51 PM
B:TAS greatest strength was it got all the villains right. They were all sympathetic and entirely entertaining.
Still some parts of it are dated. You'll notice in the earlier episodes Batman doesn't even throw a punch in most episodes. He usually just tosses over a bad guy over his shoulder. The fight scenes in B:TAS were extremely brief and short lived...very similar to the original TMNT show.
In a way I prefer that. Today's modern cartoons have these long action sequences that take up 10 minutes of the episode whereas there's only 10 minutes of story.
Meanwhile B:TAS and the original TMNT show focused on the story first and then the fight scenes.
Coola Yagami
02-19-2013, 09:30 PM
I'm glad Batman TAS didn't have characters swing a knife or sword at Batman and then have him react as if he was punched. Hated when the 2K3 show did that.... and that one scene in the 2012 TMNT was painful to watch too.
shuriken
02-19-2013, 11:14 PM
Yeah always thought that was wierd. BTW what scene in 2012?
4Kids Leo has depth. He acted like a baby over things when Splinter didn't take his side because he's a teenager. It makes perfect sense. Teenagers are not rational and get overly upset about little things. Leo's behavior during season 4 is actually some of my favorite Leo material because his reaction to what happens works from a psychological standpoint. He was betrayed by someone he saw as a friend and responsible, in his mind, for the injuries and near death of his family. He believed he should have been able to save them and all he could do was watch them almost die. His over the edge attitude mirrors yet again his age, he's a teenager, and how someone that young would handle a tragedy like that. As dumb as it seems the Ancient One works so well because he's a fat silly man who farts a lot, teaching him not to take life so seriously, but he's also one of the most skilled martial artists. He teaches Leo a very important lesson and while veiled it works.
4Kids hardly had perfect writing but it nailed somethings, for the most part character consistency. The only thing I disliked was the arc they started with Mikey and his Battle Nexus hubris that had a great climax.
I agree with this. All of it. Although I do enjoy Mikey's and Raph's characterization better in the Nicktoon as well as the brothers' dynamic a bit more. 2k3 isn't perfect, but I'm currently marathoning (that a word? well now it is) through it. Some really cheesy parts here and there but overall it makes me happy and takes me back to when I was a freshmen in high school getting reaqcuianted with my 4 green buddies. And 2k3 had a much sloer buildup than the Nicktoon.
CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 05:30 PM
I think the very best episodes of the 4kids series are some of the best TMNT animated experiences we've had.
The show really was just one notch below a Bruce Timm or Greg Weisman directed cartoon.
Leofan26
04-27-2013, 12:22 PM
Hope that means 2012 Nick series will crossover with the 2003 series soon than :D
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.