PDA

View Full Version : Did this series seem similar to a Bruce Timm or Greg Weisman cartoon to anyone else?


CyberCubed
02-13-2013, 05:24 PM
Does anyone else think the 4kids series is the closest thing we'll ever get to a Bruce Timm or Greg Weisman TMNT cartoon? For those who don't know Bruce Timm created the DCAU (Batman, Superman, Batman Beyond, Justice League) while Greg Weisman created such hits as Gargoyles, Spectacular Spider-Man and Young Justice.

While this show wasn't as good in the areas of character depth as those, I felt it came the closest compared to the other two more comedic TMNT cartoons. The actual tone, continuity and action in both series resembles a Bruce Timm or Greg Weisman superhero cartoon.

Episodes like "Insane in the Membrane" could have for into most DCAU or Weisman shows quite easily.

Does the 4kids TMNT cartoon feel like its just one notch below a Bruce Timm or Greg Weisman cartoon to anyone else?

TheSkeletonMan939
02-13-2013, 06:27 PM
Certainly. What I like about this show is the rigid continuity it had (ignoring FF and BttS), something that mirrors a Weisman-written production. The character depth - especially for Raph and Leo - was just as well done as any Bruce Timm show.

I'm sure Laird's proofreading is what made the show like it is. Otherwise we would have gotten 7 seasons of goofiness.

Also, that's the dumbest thread tag I have ever seen. :P

gobo
02-13-2013, 07:01 PM
It was better than either of those guys. I still find the Timmverse DCAU hard to sit through (cuz it gets boring) and Weisman's Gargoyles is something I've never been able to pay attention to (dreadfully boring darkness for darkness' sake). 2002 He-Man and 2003 TMNT thankfully blended these more mature means of storytelling with a bit of silliness.

k_lala
02-13-2013, 07:42 PM
Imagine if we had Greg Weisman for FF and BTTS.

Ryanator008
02-13-2013, 07:43 PM
It was better than either of those guys. I still find the Timmverse DCAU hard to sit through (cuz it gets boring) and Weisman's Gargoyles is something I've never been able to pay attention to (dreadfully boring darkness for darkness' sake). 2002 He-Man and 2003 TMNT thankfully blended these more mature means of storytelling with a bit of silliness.

Agreed. Although Spec Spidey didn't have that problem.

ABrown
02-13-2013, 08:52 PM
It was better than either of those guys.

While I am a fan of the DCAU shows, I've gotta agree that I like the 4Kids TMNT cartoon more than any of the DCAU shows. It was a very special cartoon, quite possibly my favorite action cartoon of all time.

Pterobat
02-13-2013, 09:15 PM
TMNT 4Kids is similar, yeah, but it can't quite reach those heights for me. A majority of the filler, and the last three seasons, bring it down too much. When the TMNT 4Kids was good, it was good, and I focus on those things about it, but when taken as a whole....

Also, Gargoyles is wonderful.

Matches Malone
02-13-2013, 09:34 PM
I would agree it's one notch below Batman and Superman. It might actually have better animation, but the writing wasn't as strong, and B:TAS had a unique soundtrack for every EPISODE (or so Timm says in the DVD commentary). Even if 4Kids didn't have a terrible/mediocre soundtrack, you can't really compete with that. It's probably at about the same level as Justice League, which is when the DCAU also started to have a pretty uninspired soundtrack.

Avatar Yuffie
02-13-2013, 10:03 PM
Not really.

If I have to choose watching TMNT 2k3 over Justice League, I have to go with JL. Unlimited is when I frankly lost interest though (which is sad because the other heroes, though solid characters, I'm not familiar/ignorant with because I grew up with Marvel comics/tv series more).

CyberCubed
02-13-2013, 10:23 PM
Well I don't mean its as good in every single way, (Batman: TAS is almost a masterpiece besides some dated animation), but it comes close in style, writing and action.

The only difference is none of the main characters on TMNT had as much character depth as some of the characters in the Timm-verse or Greg Weisman shows, but it didn't really need as much to be honest.

Avatar Yuffie
02-13-2013, 10:39 PM
Well I don't mean its as good in every single way, (Batman: TAS is almost a masterpiece besides some dated animation), but it comes close in style, writing and action.

The only difference is none of the main characters on TMNT had as much character depth as some of the characters in the Timm-verse or Greg Weisman shows, but it didn't really need as much to be honest.

If it makes you sleep at night, dude, whatever.

CyberCubed
02-13-2013, 10:41 PM
If it makes you sleep at night, dude, whatever.

What are you referring to? I was pretty much agreeing with you.

ToTheNines
02-13-2013, 10:54 PM
Pretty fair comparison, I guess. The 4kids show had a few scripts that lacked logic and were riddled with plot holes though, even season 1. I'm not so sure I'd put the 4kids show quite on the DCAU's level, or anything Weisman's done.

Avatar Yuffie
02-14-2013, 12:49 AM
What are you referring to? I was pretty much agreeing with you.

No you aren't.

TheSkeletonMan939
02-14-2013, 05:32 AM
... and B:TAS had a unique soundtrack for every EPISODE (or so Timm says in the DVD commentary).

This is true.

CyberCubed
02-14-2013, 10:20 PM
Even the sci-fi episodes of the 4kids series remind me of Justice League a lot. All the Triceraton episodes, the Battle Nexus eps, some of Fast Forward's episodes, etc.

sdp
02-14-2013, 11:19 PM
I've always considered 2k3 to be the equivalent of BTAS for the turtles and that it's as good as BTAS is.

miru
04-14-2013, 07:07 PM
It felt more like a Toei Anime to me.