PDA

View Full Version : TMNT: City Fall


Matches Malone
02-14-2013, 02:12 PM
Oh man, I got on the computer at the right time! Haven't finished reading this, so why don't you all join me. New regular artist Santoloucco (as I had hoped!) and story arc where apparently Shredder successfully turns Leo! The title Cityfall obviously inspired by City At War, but I definitely like the idea of the turtles having to actually go against Leo.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=43769

thelouisguy
02-14-2013, 02:15 PM
I am still reading. Looks promissing!

HUN!

Whoa! Just finished. 2013 is going to be amazing!

Matches Malone
02-14-2013, 02:25 PM
Subservient mutants? I'm thinking Bebop & Rocksteady...

And that RI cover is so good!

snake
02-14-2013, 02:26 PM
I cant wait for this! This is going to be AWSOME!

DrSpengler
02-14-2013, 02:33 PM
While it's a bummer to know Ben Bates will be leaving us so soon... SANTOLOUCO! DOOOOOOD!

CyberCubed
02-14-2013, 02:34 PM
Lol @ Bobby name dropping Mondo Gecko as a mutant they don't have any plans to use. Poor Mondo will be trapped in the 80's like the stereotype he was. :)

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 02:36 PM
Sounds good on paper but they've got an uphill battle at making the IDW Shredder a credible threat at this point.

Master Splinter
02-14-2013, 02:36 PM
I just started reading this too and came here to see if it's posted yet. Good to see someone beat me too it. This is exciting stuff!

-ms

Zulithe
02-14-2013, 02:39 PM
I hope they have a very strong and believable reason for leo turning... because that is totally out of character... I don't care if splinter slapped him in the face and told him to GTFO I could never imagine him doing this.

anyway the whole channeling of 'city at war' is really cool

Matches Malone
02-14-2013, 02:44 PM
Sounds good on paper but they've got an uphill battle at making the IDW Shredder a credible threat at this point.

It's true. The line the "villains never lose" actually made me a little skeptical. I know what Bobby means by it, but if that is really true, in some ways that lessens the dramatic tension, as we know that there isn't really anything at stake, since we know that the turtles can never lose either, because then they would have to change the name of the series! Still, even if it turns out that way, the best I can hope for are some entertaining stories, even if it doesn't take it all the way. However, if IDW were to finally take something to the point of finality, it sounds like it would be in this series! Plus, The Shredder successfully taking over New York would definitely give him some credibility. I don't think this is the same Shredder who got ambushed and embarrassed in #12.

TomWaltz
02-14-2013, 02:55 PM
It's true. The line the "villains never lose" actually made me a little skeptical. I know what Bobby means by it, but if that is really true, in some ways that lessens the dramatic tension, as we know that there isn't really anything at stake, since we know that the turtles can never lose either, because then they would have to change the name of the series! Still, even if it turns out that way, the best I can hope for are some entertaining stories, even if it doesn't take it all the way. However, if IDW were to finally take something to the point of finality, it sounds like it would be in this series! Plus, The Shredder successfully taking over New York would definitely give him some credibility. I don't think this is the same Shredder who got ambushed and embarrassed in #12.

Hmm... about issue #12. That's where the first seeds of Cityfall were planted, actually. Page 12, Shredder had an epiphany. And, then, on page 19, in an instant, his epiphany became a plan.

All I'm gonna say about that.

Thanks, everyone, for your continued support and interest! Cityfall is gonna be lots of fun! But, in the meantime, issues #19 and #20 are still coming your way and, friends, what Ben Bates and Ronda Pattison do in those two issues will knock your socks off! Before you dive into Cityfall... don't miss the grand finale of the Krang War!

ToTheNines
02-14-2013, 02:57 PM
I hope they have a very strong and believable reason for leo turning... because that is totally out of character... I don't care if splinter slapped him in the face and told him to GTFO I could never imagine him doing this.

That's honestly been bugging the piss out of me for a long time now. I hate to gripe prematurely, but I just can't see Leo turning that quickly for any reason, and if I understood Bobby correctly, he goes over to the Foot in the first issue of Cityfall. I know they've been "leading up to it" with his shaken confidence over Slash, but it's not clicking for me yet.

Now if he's joining the Foot as a mole, I'd love that. I've eaten up Aqulad's storyline in Young Justice: Invasion and almost sh*t my pants after watching "Depths". But I just don't know... I'm definitely anxious to see what happens though.

Anyways, cool article. Very nice of Bobby to not correct him about "The Hun" lol, but it's cool that Hun is showing up. I honestly hadn't suspected him since these Purple Dragon's are total chumps. I hope they go Mirage with it and have him fresh out of prison and ready to eff **** up.

Very happy to hear about Santolouco taking art duties, he'll be perfect for this just as Bates is for "Krang War". Speaking of that arc, I'm already excited for Krang's eventual return, since it looks like the turtles and NRF totally wreck him. He's gonna be pissed once he gets back on his feet.

This cover is nuts!
http://www.comicbookresources.com/assets/images/articles/1360870863.jpg

Can't tell if that's Ronda's work or not... but I kinda hope that Vieira from Foot Clan takes over. No offense to her of course.

Raph's Girl
02-14-2013, 03:10 PM
Is that Usagi on the cover?!

DrSpengler
02-14-2013, 03:18 PM
Is that Usagi on the cover?!


Do you mean in the yellow panel reading "City"? I'm pretty sure that's just Splinter.

ToTheNines
02-14-2013, 03:21 PM
I guess he looks a tad different from the way he's drawn in Secret of the Foot, but yeah, that's totally Splinter.

Bobby Curnow
02-14-2013, 03:24 PM
That article is filled with typos. It was a phone conversation, and I said i'd be happy to fix the typos when I read the transcript, but they said they would do it. :ohwell:

CyberCubed
02-14-2013, 03:26 PM
Leo falling for the dark side does seem odd even with this being a new universe and all. I hope the writing is strong enough to make it work.

DC and Marvel do this with a lot of their characters and fans cry foul until it gets fixed. Hopefully whatever happens here is done well.

Bobby Curnow
02-14-2013, 03:42 PM
Re: Leo. The fact that it would be "out of character" is 100% correct.

Seriously, I wouldn't worry about that aspect. You won't think twice about it when it's executed. I'm pretty confident about that. Very tempted to just tell it here, but that's no fun.

Matches Malone
02-14-2013, 03:46 PM
Hmm... about issue #12. That's where the first seeds of Cityfall were planted, actually. Page 12, Shredder had an epiphany. And, then, on page 19, in an instant, his epiphany became a plan.

All I'm gonna say about that.

Thanks, everyone, for your continued support and interest! Cityfall is gonna be lots of fun! But, in the meantime, issues #19 and #20 are still coming your way and, friends, what Ben Bates and Ronda Pattison do in those two issues will knock your socks off! Before you dive into Cityfall... don't miss the grand finale of the Krang War!

Thanks Tom, for the input! One of the best things IDW is doing for TMNT is having such a huge vision for them and always looking behind, as well as ahead, to make the best story possible. On the other side of that, I also appreciate how well you take constructive (some less so than others) criticism, since it would probably drive a normal person crazy! Regardless of my concerns, I am really happy with IDW TMNT right now.

Chris
02-14-2013, 03:52 PM
That's really reassuring, thanks Bobby :tgrin:

Leo is my fav so I'm a bit sad to see him "going to the dark side", but as long as it's well done and the pay off is good (who doesn't love a good redemption story, plus, when it does come, it'll make the final battle with the Shredder even more personal for him) then I'm more than happy to be taken along for the ride.

I noticed in the interview you called this the halfway point of a bigger story. Are you guys really planned out to almost issue 60?! That's awesome! It's nice to know things are being planned out that well and you have a real plan for how things are going to go rather than just making it up on the fly/lurching from event to event as other companies tend to do.

HotJuicyBurgers
02-14-2013, 04:00 PM
So does anyone know if mateus's work is all digital or if he does "traditional" art. Would love to own a page of his stuff

Martin
02-14-2013, 04:15 PM
Good lord, I just geekgasmed all over the keyboard. SUPER excited :)

I was already happy when I read that Santolouco was the new regular (awesome artist; only thing I don't dig are Mikey and Donnie's faces, they look kind of weird but that might just be their bandanas). But when I kept going and read all the other stuff... wow, just wow. I can totally see this working soooo well! Can't wait till may :D

CyberCubed
02-14-2013, 04:17 PM
Would it be too early to ask if IDW is already planning out year 3?

Sounds like IDW could very well have the basic ideas down for the first 50 issues or so of this ongoing.

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 04:19 PM
Would it be too early to ask if IDW is already planning out year 3?

Sounds like IDW could very well have the basic ideas down for the first 50 issues or so of this ongoing.

Not unreasonable. I'm positive Tom and company would at least have the broad strokes for the next 3 or 4 story arcs with some other story arcs "up in the air" as far as when they could happen/where they could go... and given that each story arc is averaging about 6 or 7 issues anyway, yeah, "basic ideas down for the first 50 issues or so" is to be expected.

snake
02-14-2013, 04:20 PM
Not unreasonable. I'm positive Tom and company would at least have the broad strokes for the next 3 or 4 story arcs with some other story arcs "up in the air" as far as when they could happen/where they could go... and given that each story arc is averaging about 6 or 7 issues anyway, yeah, "basic ideas down for the first 50 issues or so" is to be expected.

That is if the series lasts for 50 issues, I really hope it does though

ToTheNines
02-14-2013, 04:30 PM
It's consistently in IDW's top 3 best sellers. It'll be around for a long time considering we've got a movie coming up.

strugler
02-14-2013, 04:43 PM
SO EXCITED!!!!

MAteus Santalouco YESSSS! the dude is awesome

Thank you IDW!

snake
02-14-2013, 04:47 PM
It's consistently in IDW's top 3 best sellers. It'll be around for a long time considering we've got a movie coming up.

Anyone think idw might adapt the movie into the comics,

Venom
02-14-2013, 05:02 PM
We're going to see Raphael at his most angry and impulsive. We'll see Donatello struggling for a logical response to all this. And Michelangelo is going to be super bummed and depressed because his family and his happy-go-lucky lifestyle is endangered.

Sounds like the IDW Turtles will briefly reflect their original Mirage counterparts! :D

The interview makes me wonder who the Turtles will look at to lead: Don, being the most logical, or will Raph take a familiar cue and try to take over the reigns?

One character aspect I would *love* to see develop out of this is Michelangelo take to writing as a means to vent his inner frustrations, whether it be in a journal or on a blog; Michelangelo is often times cast aside as the "dumb, goofy kid" of the Turtles, yet those of us who have followed the Turtles throughout the comics know Michelangelo holds much more depth than mainstream pop culture allows him.

On another note, I'm curious to see how sales will be for the upcoming issues, as Santolouco taking over art duties on the ongoing will finally see the Turtles being the most "mainstream" they've ever been in comics and having a book where the inside looks like the cover.

Master Splinter
02-14-2013, 05:33 PM
Very tempted to just tell it here, but that's no fun.

My wife loves to ruin surprises. Please don't be like her.

:P

-ms

ctt4lfecw
02-14-2013, 05:35 PM
A Leo heel turn. Wow.

Powder
02-14-2013, 05:57 PM
An article full of good news! I'm excited for all of this (though not so much the idea of Bebop & Rocksteady being shoved into what is essentially going to be IDW's City At War).

frank_one
02-14-2013, 06:03 PM
Great news! I'm glad to see Santolouco as the new artist (Bates was doing well too), I only hope he has changed his mind about those weird superhero bandanas we've seen in the Foot clan mini-series.

Triceraton Jones
02-14-2013, 07:51 PM
This is the best bit of news I've heard all week. I am absolutely loving IDW's TMNT more and more. Its been so long since I've been excited for a comic and I don't think I've ever got more and more excited as a series has gone on. Thank you IDW, sincerely.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-14-2013, 07:56 PM
Sounds like an Adele song, "CityFall..."

Cipher
02-14-2013, 08:19 PM
While any similarity to "City at War" sounds like it will be in name only, I'm very excited for this. Sounds like the kind of shot in the arm the IDW series could use, and they're definitely far enough in for a big shake-up.

Also, Shredder employing more as-of-yet-unrevealed mutants? They couldn't tease Bebop and Rocksteady harder if they mentioned horns and tusks.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-14-2013, 08:35 PM
While any similarity to "City at War" sounds like it will be in name only, I'm very excited for this.

Not just in name, that article/interview with Bobby pretty much stated/cited other similarities other than "city" being in the name.

CyberCubed
02-14-2013, 08:38 PM
Didn't the TMNT Annual already kind of do this? It had the Foot, Savate, the police, the Turtles and Purple Dragons all caught up in a huge fight.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-14-2013, 08:40 PM
Didn't the TMNT Annual already kind of do this? It had the Foot, Savate, the police, the Turtles and Purple Dragons all caught up in a huge fight.

Yeah, but they were fighting over jewels, not power over the city. I have no idea how to rationalize Leo joining up with Shredder, despite Bobby asking us to trust him (no offense, Bobby).

spookycookies
02-14-2013, 08:43 PM
Didn't the TMNT Annual already kind of do this? It had the Foot, Savate, the police, the Turtles and Purple Dragons all caught up in a huge fight.

But that was mainly just one really hectic incident. Cityfall sounds like it will be the calculated execution of many thought out plans.

snake
02-14-2013, 08:46 PM
I'm guessing elevendy billion varient covers for part 1 of this arc;)

Machias Banshee
02-14-2013, 08:48 PM
This sounds really good... :o

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 08:52 PM
It can't be an adaptation of City at War. That was about warring factions of the Foot resulting from the death of Shredder, the coming of Karai to clean up the mess and kill Foot Elite loyal to Shredder, Casey becoming an adoptive dad to another woman's baby and dealing with his feelings for April, and the Turtles coping mentally and otherwise with a lifetime of growing up being trained to kill Shredder for Splinter and the resulting circle of blood vengeance.

1. Shredder isn't dead.

2. Karai is Shredder's "granddaughter" and isn't going to be killing any Foot anytime soon.

3. Casey isn't going to be meeting any Gabrielles or raising any Shadows anytime soon. Or probably ever.

4. The Turtles weren't raised to kill Shredder and again, he isn't even dead. And in fact they are specifically taught not to kill by Splinter, period, and haven't killed anybody except Slash (they think)... and he didn't even die.

So how can this be in any way an adaptation of City at War?

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 08:57 PM
All of this said, far be it for me to begrudge a long, sprawling urban ninja action TMNT story arc. After the last "ninja action" arc, though, I can only be cautiously optimistic.

ToTheNines
02-14-2013, 08:58 PM
I was gonna type up something like that. Thank you Andrew.

On top of what you said, CaW came after years of story material, like 4 years worth, in-universe. Cityfall is taking place in a yet young IDW universe.

That being said, the fact that this isn't City at War is NOT a mark against it. I can already tell that I'm going to get annoyed by constant comparison between the two.

snake
02-14-2013, 09:00 PM
I was gonna type up something like that. Thank you Andrew.

On top of what you said, CaW came after years of story material. Cityfall is taking place in a yet young IDW universe.

That being said, the fact that this isn't City at War is NOT a mark against it. I can already tell that I'm going to get annoyed by constant comparison between the two.

I'm having a feeling this will be like comparing nick and 2k3.
Why can't we keep things seprate,:ohwell:
I'm not treating it as city at war, I'm treating it as a new arc:)

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 09:00 PM
I was gonna type up something like that. Thank you Andrew.

On top of what you said, CaW came after years of story material. Cityfall is taking place in a yet young IDW universe.

That being said, the fact that this isn't City at War is NOT a mark against it. I can already tell that I'm going to get annoyed by constant comparison between the two.

I agree. And even if IDW decides to borrow cues from the Mirage material, it would be pretty weird to arrive at their equivalent of "City at War" if we haven't even gotten their equivalent of "Return to New York" yet. Or even their equivalent of issue #1, for that matter.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-14-2013, 09:02 PM
An article full of good news! I'm excited for all of this (though not so much the idea of Bebop & Rocksteady being shoved into what is essentially going to be IDW's City At War).

So this is the post you were responding to?

I don't think anyone is implying that it will be IDW's adaptation of City at War; it is IDW's answer to City at War. There is a BIG difference. Even the 2003 series' City at War story arc was SIGNIFICANTLY different from the Mirage storyline from whence it took its name...

ctt4lfecw
02-14-2013, 09:03 PM
How will Leo turn heel? What will be the final straw?

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 09:04 PM
I don't think anyone is implying that it will be IDW's adaptation of City at War; it is IDW's answer to City at War.

But an answer to which part? Karai killing Foot to ease tensions? Casey raising another woman's baby? The Turtles coping with being raised to kill Shredder?

I don't get it...

Even the 2003 series' City at War story arc was SIGNIFICANTLY different from the Mirage storyline from whence it took its name...

That was "City at War" in name only. "Return to New York" even more so, embarrassingly so.

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 09:09 PM
How will Leo turn heel? What will be the final straw?

In coping with his killing of Slash, it'll probably go down in one of a few ways when he is officially offered the job:

A) Splinter and/or the Turtles tell him to, to get closer to Shredder or at least learn more about the inner workings of the Foot and their operation and take them all down later on.

B) Leonardo goes rogue, against orders, but his intentions remain honorable, to again, get closer to Shredder or at least learn more about the inner workings of the Foot and their operation and take them all down later on.

C) Leonardo is brainwashed or drugged somehow by the Foot.

D) Someone is kidnapped or threatened with mortal harm by the Foot, or possibly the Foot offer Leonardo unequivocal peace between the Foot and Leonardo's family as long as he plays ball. Meanwhile, he still is planning to, you guessed it, get closer to the Shredder or at least learning more about the inner workings of the Foot and their operation with designs on taking them all down later on.

I think it's probably A or B.

Weapons@theready
02-14-2013, 09:09 PM
I might be reading into the cover too much, but if that's Leo falling through a glass ceiling, ala Mirage, one can only wonder if perhaps he gets amnesia and Shredder fills him with lies, which could explain this
Re: Leo. The fact that it would be "out of character" is 100% correct.

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 09:11 PM
I might be reading into the cover too much, but if that's Leo falling through a glass ceiling,

It's Raph. IDW has them all with the rainbow bandannas now and Santolouco covers never show them with the all-reds.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-14-2013, 09:12 PM
I actually think that is Raphael, and that it is a reference to the first movie. So far they seem only to have referenced the second and third movies in this series. So I wasn't surprised at all when I saw that cover.

ctt4lfecw
02-14-2013, 09:13 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeumyOzKqgI

CyberCubed
02-14-2013, 09:14 PM
I just remembered this is probably also going to involve Old Hob's gang. I know he only has Slash with him now but I expect 2 or 3 more.

thelouisguy
02-14-2013, 09:23 PM
It can't be an adaptation of City at War. That was about warring factions of the Foot resulting from the death of Shredder, the coming of Karai to clean up the mess and kill Foot Elite loyal to Shredder, Casey becoming an adoptive dad to another woman's baby and dealing with his feelings for April, and the Turtles coping mentally and otherwise with a lifetime of growing up being trained to kill Shredder for Splinter and the resulting circle of blood vengeance.

1. Shredder isn't dead.

2. Karai is Shredder's "granddaughter" and isn't going to be killing any Foot anytime soon.

3. Casey isn't going to be meeting any Gabrielles or raising any Shadows anytime soon. Or probably ever.

4. The Turtles weren't raised to kill Shredder and again, he isn't even dead. And in fact they are specifically taught not to kill by Splinter, period, and haven't killed anybody except Slash (they think)... and he didn't even die.

So how can this be in any way an adaptation of City at War?

I was gonna type up something like that. Thank you Andrew.

On top of what you said, CaW came after years of story material, like 4 years worth, in-universe. Cityfall is taking place in a yet young IDW universe.

That being said, the fact that this isn't City at War is NOT a mark against it. I can already tell that I'm going to get annoyed by constant comparison between the two.

You do know I'm going to try and shoehorn the comparisons between the two, right?

How will Leo turn heel? What will be the final straw?

"I did it for The Rock." -Leonardo

Actually, I could see him turning this early on because they have not had years of family time and bonding. It becomes less likely the longer they wait as the family dynamics would be strengthened.

ToTheNines
02-14-2013, 09:36 PM
That was "City at War" in name only. "Return to New York" even more so, embarrassingly so.

I gotta disagree there. 4kids Return To New York is, admittedly, a poor adaption tonally, but it's still pretty fun in the context of that show and they hit most of the major beats at least.

4kids City at War... I can't even sit through it. Totally half-assed half-hearted "attempt". I honestly wish they'd never even tried doing it.

I was literally shocked to see Peter's season 2 and CaW production notes from his blog. He put up like zero fuss about it.

B) Leonardo goes rogue, against orders, but his intentions remain honorable, to again, get closer to Shredder or at least learn more about the inner workings of the Foot and their operation and take them all down later on.

I'd like this one. Leo's line early on in Secret History of the Foot kind of points to this, when he said something about anything you learn about your enemy will help you defeat them or whatever.

I actually think that is Raphael

I know it's Raphael. It could be black and white and it's plainly Raph, because of the way Santolouco draws them all differently.

But speaking of mask colors, I kinda hope that Leo puts on Slash's black mask when he works for Shredder. That would be cool.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-14-2013, 09:37 PM
Actually, I could see him turning this early on because they have not had years of family time and bonding. It becomes less likely the longer they wait as the family dynamics would be strengthened.

Yes, but second to Splinter's, his memories of their past life and Tang Shen are most vivid.

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 09:49 PM
"I did it for The Rock." -Leonardo

Your obscure Rikishi reference is not lost on me, sir.

CyberCubed
02-14-2013, 10:08 PM
Leonardo has to be pretty screwy to team up with the guy who not only killed his father, but also killed him and his 3 brothers as kids.

Unless he's just hypnotized/drugged/put under a magic spell, etc....it really will have to be some damn good writing to pull this off.

Redeemer
02-14-2013, 10:14 PM
Really looking forward to this arc and I think this has my new favorite cover :D

Andrew NDB
02-14-2013, 10:17 PM
It's a very striking cover.

Thorneyeagle
02-14-2013, 10:23 PM
While I am not a very vocal member of the board but I just really have to express my excitement.

I am thoroughly enjoying the comics current direction. I look forward each month to every ongoing related comic. I am nervous about the "betrayal" but I honestly have to say I foresaw something of the sort happening.

it feels slightly cliche to have a betrayal and return of a team member. If done well [which i have high hopes that it will] It can still be fun to read and tell us a lot of about the characters.

I am rooting for this and excited for every up coming comic.

rpd123
02-14-2013, 11:24 PM
This looks like it'll be awesome. I can't wait for it to start.

Matches Malone
02-15-2013, 12:56 AM
In coping with his killing of Slash, it'll probably go down in one of a few ways when he is officially offered the job:

A) Splinter and/or the Turtles tell him to, to get closer to Shredder or at least learn more about the inner workings of the Foot and their operation and take them all down later on.

B) Leonardo goes rogue, against orders, but his intentions remain honorable, to again, get closer to Shredder or at least learn more about the inner workings of the Foot and their operation and take them all down later on.

C) Leonardo is brainwashed or drugged somehow by the Foot.

D) Someone is kidnapped or threatened with mortal harm by the Foot, or possibly the Foot offer Leonardo unequivocal peace between the Foot and Leonardo's family as long as he plays ball. Meanwhile, he still is planning to, you guessed it, get closer to the Shredder or at least learning more about the inner workings of the Foot and their operation with designs on taking them all down later on.

I think it's probably A or B.

While I think you're probably right, I would love it, and be most impressed, if The Shredder could legitimately find a way to convince Leo that his side is right, with some kind of ideological persuasion.

I could see him using the Slash incident as "proof" that the strong survive in this world. "Did not you yourself use your strength to strike down an enemy when your life was threatened?" You know, that sort of thing. Seems fitting to outside Leo with ideology too. We'll see. IDW has proven before that they think these things through.

Keno
02-15-2013, 01:35 AM
I am so so so so so so so so excited about this!!!

I trust the IDW crew that this will be fabulous!

Sophie Campbell
02-15-2013, 02:09 AM
SOOOOOOO PUMPEDDDDDDD FOR MATEUS ON THE BOOK FULL-TIME. OHHHHHHHHHHH MAN. cannot wait.

Tinus
02-15-2013, 04:00 AM
Looking forward to this! Sounds like it could be epic. Wonder how they will turn Leo...it better be something good! :)

VaughnMichael
02-15-2013, 07:58 AM
Sounds really great! But Leo's probably just going to join the foot to betray them or try to get close to Shredder.
I can't wait to see what Karai does because I believe she will become upset with Shredder choosing Leo over her.

ToTheNines
02-15-2013, 09:05 AM
Sounds really great! But Leo's probably just going to join the foot to betray them or try to get close to Shredder.
I can't wait to see what Karai does because I believe she will become upset with Shredder choosing Leo over her.

Yeah, she's been taking a lot of crap from him lately... Maybe Karai and Leo devise a plan on their own.

Venom
02-15-2013, 09:17 AM
I echo others who predict Leo's turnabout is in actuality a ruse to infilatrate the Foot and learn more anout the enemy.

"Keep your friends close and your enemies closer." But I can't help but feel like he would at least told Splinter so his brothers wouldn't try to kill him in battle!

Oculus Orbus
02-15-2013, 09:26 AM
I'm very happy to see Santolouco taking over the book. Bates' work is fantastic, but I feel like Santolouco's style fits the Turtles better. I only wish he didn't do that with their bandanas.

As I've said before, I'm not liking the IDW run very much, but I believe that, if done right, things could get a lot better after this arc. We'll see.

ToTheNines
02-15-2013, 09:33 AM
"Keep your friends close and your enemies closer." But I can't help but feel like he would at least told Splinter so his brothers wouldn't try to kill him in battle!

Eh. They wouldn't kill anyone else in the Foot, why would they start with Leo?

Plasticplayhouse
02-15-2013, 09:43 AM
That is if the series lasts for 50 issues, I really hope it does though
oh idw's tmnt is going to last well after 50 issues. the art has been good and the stories have been very entertaining thus far. i lost the scepticism by the end of the duncan era.



The interview makes me wonder who the Turtles will look at to lead: Don, being the most logical, or will Raph take a familiar cue and try to take over the reigns?


i have a feeling the decision making will be a team effort with raph or donnie having more weight in the end result.


While I think you're probably right, I would love it, and be most impressed, if The Shredder could legitimately find a way to convince Leo that his side is right, with some kind of ideological persuasion.


"human" emotions are very powerful. even in the best of "people" they can be swayed like grass on a breezy day.



I can't wait to see what Karai does because I believe she will become upset with Shredder choosing Leo over her.
ditto. that alone will make for some very interesting writing.


I echo others who predict Leo's turnabout is in actuality a ruse to infilatrate the Foot and learn more anout the enemy.

"Keep your friends close and your enemies closer."
very possible and it wouldnt surprise me if it panned out that way. but it wouldnt be as powerful of a story if it were to come about this way vice Leo actually deciding to turn.

Toby Barrett
02-15-2013, 09:57 AM
Oh good. We get to keep the derpy looking batman masks ;p

CyberCubed
02-15-2013, 10:13 AM
Yeah my only problem with this art is the stylized bandanas. I wish he would just draw all the bandanas looking normal.

Redeemer
02-15-2013, 11:50 AM
this may be a stupid question but why i s Ben Bates leaving?????

MikeandRaph87
02-15-2013, 12:00 PM
I saw the article this morning. Last night seeing this topic I thought it was a James Bond crossover that should be in the fan-fiction section! :tlol:

So now, we have a title for the mega arc andthis is where Leonardo will flirt with the darkside. City At War deals with criminal factions fighting over ho is the top dog in the underworld with The Shredder dead. This seems to be the rise of The Shredder as the top dog of the underworld. Tristan Jones said he knew nothing of plans for HUn, but it loks like Hun will be included afterall. As for the yet to be known mutants, Bebop,Rocksteady, and Leatherhead. Come on,who else would that refer to? :trazz: Do we see Agent Bishop,Rat King or any ally fitting into this mega arc?

MikeandRaph87
02-15-2013, 12:05 PM
i have a feeling the decision making will be a team effort with raph or donnie having more weight in the end result.

ditto. that alone will make for some very interesting writing.



Hey why can't Michelangelo make decisions for the team for a change?:P He has so much untapped potential in that department!


Interesting writting is an understatement. This writting will define the series as we look back and I perdict amazing to all turtle fans alike. Can it match the potential that Forever War had and be as amazing as The Future Shark Trilogy or be as impactful as Return To New York? I say yes to all three questions!

The Big Bad
02-15-2013, 12:08 PM
this may be a stupid question but why i s Ben Bates leaving?????

Scheduling reasons, apparently. He is (thankfully, in my opinion) penciling one fourth of the Mega Man / Sonic the Hedgehog crossover that's scheduled for April.

Andrew NDB
02-15-2013, 12:14 PM
Scheduling reasons, apparently. He is (thankfully, in my opinion) penciling one fourth of the Mega Man / Sonic the Hedgehog crossover that's scheduled for April.

Mega Man meets Sonic the Hedgehog? :roll: Who wouldn't walk away from a TMNT book for that...

Martin
02-15-2013, 12:41 PM
While I think you're probably right, I would love it, and be most impressed, if The Shredder could legitimately find a way to convince Leo that his side is right, with some kind of ideological persuasion.

I could see him using the Slash incident as "proof" that the strong survive in this world. "Did not you yourself use your strength to strike down an enemy when your life was threatened?" You know, that sort of thing. Seems fitting to outside Leo with ideology too. We'll see. IDW has proven before that they think these things through.

I think that we should also account for the whole 'mental instability' thing that Baxter mentioned a while back when he was talking with general Krang.

In his oneshot, at least to me, Leo came across as a bit unstable at best. He kept having all these flashbacks that threw him off constantly. So it wouldn't be too crazy to assume that due to this fact he might not be thinking straight. Also, in this continuity he is clashing heads with don constantly, as well as the occasional hostility towards raph. So, basically, he is involved in a lot of conflict with his family. That, I think, is already starting to pile up and may be what ends up overwhelming his already unstable mind.

Another thing to consider is the current series, Secret History of the Foot Clan. In issue #1, Leo clearly stated that he wished to learn more about the foot. Could it be that, in his quest for knowledge, the mysterious book that is featured in that story ends up turning him?

There are a lot of ways to look at this. It may just turn out to be a typical infiltration tactic, or maybe something else. Only time will tell.... how long till may?

Plasticplayhouse
02-15-2013, 01:14 PM
Yeah my only problem with this art is the stylized bandanas. I wish he would just draw all the bandanas looking normal.

this is my only quip with his style. everything else i love. i mentioned it to him that while i love his work, i really didn't care for the stylized masks. they already have their own identities...and mask colors, so it seemed purposeless to have individual style masks.

frank_one
02-15-2013, 01:15 PM
Oh good. We get to keep the derpy looking batman masks ;p
Someone should really tell him about it. Those bandanas are just silly, it seems no one like them here. Am I wrong?

In issue #1, Leo clearly stated that he wished to learn more about the foot. Could it be that, in his quest for knowledge, the mysterious book that is featured in that story ends up turning him?
Interesting. After all we still don't know WHY that book is so important. What does it contain? There's a variant cover by Ross Campbell on which we see the Turtles and the Foot fighting for the book. Why they both want it?

ToTheNines
02-15-2013, 01:24 PM
Someone should really tell him about it. Those bandanas are just silly, it seems no one like them here. Am I wrong?

I like them, but he has so be careful with them. Leo's looked like he was at a masquerade ball on page 6 or 7 of Foot Clan #1. But normally they look pretty cool, especially Raph's.

Sophie Campbell
02-15-2013, 01:43 PM
the stylized/differently-shaped masks are awesome, you guys!!!! come on!!

Martin
02-15-2013, 01:44 PM
I like them, but he has so be careful with them. Leo's looked like he was at a masquerade ball on page 6 or 7 of Foot Clan #1. But normally they look pretty cool, especially Raph's.

Raph's bandana looks badass and Leo's is great too. But mikey's, and especially donnie's, look kind of dorkish...

Venom
02-15-2013, 02:05 PM
the stylized/differently-shaped masks are awesome, you guys!!!! come on!!

It would be more awesome if they were all red. :twink:

I would love to see the IDW Turtles adopt the red again for a few issues, and their brother leaving the family would have been a perfect moment for them to once again take one one color to signify the broken family again (even thought it was "Raph's color").

Say, someone here should do a quick shoop showing Mateus's Turtles with red bandannas!

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-15-2013, 02:06 PM
Maybe when Leo joins the Foot, they'll all wear blue? :tlol:

turtlefan27
02-15-2013, 02:07 PM
i am so excited about this..
im ready to see what happens,and how it all goes down:tsmile:

Venom
02-15-2013, 02:14 PM
Maybe when Leo joins the Foot, they'll all wear blue? :tlol:

I was deliberately trying not to say that :trazz:

I'd like to see all black for a stint, though.

Xav
02-15-2013, 02:55 PM
4kids City at War... I can't even sit through it. Totally half-assed half-hearted "attempt". I honestly wish they'd never even tried doing it.

I was literally shocked to see Peter's season 2 and CaW production notes from his blog. He put up like zero fuss about it.He actually did though, he wanted the Foot broken up into different factions. He also didn't like the idea of Karai being a pawn of the Shredder.

CyberCubed
02-15-2013, 04:42 PM
Maybe when Leo joins the Foot, they'll all wear blue? :tlol:

This was the funniest thing I read all day.

ctt4lfecw
02-15-2013, 05:02 PM
By the sound of it, Leo won't be drugged or anything. But that's the only way I see this happening. But it will probably be as a double agent.

Matches Malone
02-15-2013, 05:53 PM
He actually did though, he wanted the Foot broken up into different factions. He also didn't like the idea of Karai being a pawn of the Shredder.

Do you have a link of his comments on this? I'd like to see. Kind of wondering what his rationale would be to have the Foot broken up if, in this continuity, the Shredder never actually perished.

TMNTChris1980
02-15-2013, 06:14 PM
I love Mateus' masks on the turtles. Hell, I love his turtles!!! When I picked up the first issue of SHoFC, that was one of the first things I noticed. I'm really excited to see where this series is going. My only gripe with IDW is, I wish that they would have some of the Mirage guys do a Cover or Micro. I would kill to see artists styles mixed in one issue. Maybe, one doing a cover the other doing the pages or pencils/inks combo, or colors. Campbell/Talbot, Kuhn/Lawson, or Berger/Duncan...Damn that would be good.

Sorry I just realized I went totally off topic..kind of.

Cipher
02-15-2013, 07:38 PM
Not just in name, that article/interview with Bobby pretty much stated/cited other similarities other than "city" being in the name.
Like ... ? People forget that less than a half of "City at War" deals with the Turtles' interactions with the Foot, and even that's wrapped in a lot of moral ambiguity/end-game feelings that IDW isn't going to touch, certainly at this point, possibly ever. Also the plots just don't sound remotely similar?

Still looks good though. The IDW series needs more tension as a whole if it's going to live up to its action-serial format (which I feel has never quite been realized), and this seems like a step in the right direction.

That all sounded pretty negative, but I really am excited.

oldmanwinters
02-15-2013, 07:41 PM
Mega Man meets Sonic the Hedgehog? :roll: Who wouldn't walk away from a TMNT book for that...

I would.
:tcouch:

Redeemer
02-15-2013, 07:44 PM
Scheduling reasons, apparently. He is (thankfully, in my opinion) penciling one fourth of the Mega Man / Sonic the Hedgehog crossover that's scheduled for April.

So Ben Bates will no longer be the main artist on the books? Correct??? Is he just gone for this arc?

the stylized/differently-shaped masks are awesome, you guys!!!! come on!!

Agreed

Andrew NDB
02-15-2013, 08:16 PM
the stylized/differently-shaped masks are awesome, you guys!!!! come on!!

In a universe where they all have (inexplicably) different colored skin, different rainbow colored bandannas, and different weapons and heights and body types... actually making the bandannas in different shapes and styles on top of that just seems too metrosexual of the Turtles.

CyberCubed
02-15-2013, 08:18 PM
In a universe where they all have (inexplicably) different colored skin, different rainbow colored bandannas, and different weapons and body types... actually making the bandannas in different shapes and styles just too metrosexual of the Turtles.

Another problem is the other artists didn't draw them with that, so it feels odd to see the IDW Turtles with these weird random bandanas when they don't really have them.

Lampy
02-15-2013, 08:39 PM
a few weeks off the drome and come to this... SO FKN AWESOME!

can't wait for this arc. and Santouloco on art duty (hehe duty) is going to be a real treat. his art on the foot clan mini series is just amazing. can't wait to see how he draws the Turtles in the ongoing... most likely he'll be drawing them similarly. don't see why he would change his designs anyway. as for the bandannas... not big of a fan of the stylized bandannas but i'll live with it. not big a deal.

looking forward to who that "supporting character fighting for their life" person will be. surprised no one brought that up. if april or casey or even splinter will be fighting for their lives... i'm curious as to how? ninja threat? illness? looking forward to that.

the leo turn is something i'd like to see happen willingly and not the cliche double agent bit. i'd like to see shredder convince him to join and that his brothers have to beat the crap out of him to open his eyes and see who he's fighting. also... i want to see leo in that slash bandanna. total badass status. glad to see this story arc will set the stage for the usual leo/raph tension. as refreshing as the leo/don conflict was... i was a little leaning toward leo because of don's condescending attitude in the beginning. but the leo/raph conflict is something i've always liked because i could never choose a side. so i'm looking forward to that. we saw a tiny glimpse of raph's rage before (towards casey's dad) and i actually cannot wait to see him aim that rage at leonardo for an epic brother showdown.

anyway... too much to say about this. can't wait. super stoked!

Martin
02-15-2013, 09:00 PM
It would be more awesome if they were all red. :twink:

I would love to see the IDW Turtles adopt the red again for a few issues, and their brother leaving the family would have been a perfect moment for them to once again take one one color to signify the broken family again (even thought it was "Raph's color").

Say, someone here should do a quick shoop showing Mateus's Turtles with red bandannas!

Here you go good sir

http://i.imgur.com/oGg0xsf.png

ctt4lfecw
02-15-2013, 09:11 PM
a few weeks off the drome and come to this... SO FKN AWESOME!

can't wait for this arc. and Santouloco on art duty (hehe duty) is going to be a real treat. his art on the foot clan mini series is just amazing. can't wait to see how he draws the Turtles in the ongoing... most likely he'll be drawing them similarly. don't see why he would change his designs anyway. as for the bandannas... not big of a fan of the stylized bandannas but i'll live with it. not big a deal.

looking forward to who that "supporting character fighting for their life" person will be. surprised no one brought that up. if april or casey or even splinter will be fighting for their lives... i'm curious as to how? ninja threat? illness? looking forward to that.

the leo turn is something i'd like to see happen willingly and not the cliche double agent bit. i'd like to see shredder convince him to join and that his brothers have to beat the crap out of him to open his eyes and see who he's fighting. also... i want to see leo in that slash bandanna. total badass status. glad to see this story arc will set the stage for the usual leo/raph tension. as refreshing as the leo/don conflict was... i was a little leaning toward leo because of don's condescending attitude in the beginning. but the leo/raph conflict is something i've always liked because i could never choose a side. so i'm looking forward to that. we saw a tiny glimpse of raph's rage before (towards casey's dad) and i actually cannot wait to see him aim that rage at leonardo for an epic brother showdown.

anyway... too much to say about this. can't wait. super stoked!

^
Yeah I hope it's a willing turn. Im ready for it.

snake
02-15-2013, 09:53 PM
Here you go good sir

http://i.imgur.com/oGg0xsf.png

Sorry for the off topic post, but is the pic in your sig from a real comic, it's hilarious:lol:

Xav
02-15-2013, 09:57 PM
Do you have a link of his comments on this? I'd like to see. Kind of wondering what his rationale would be to have the Foot broken up if, in this continuity, the Shredder never actually perished.
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2010/04/blast-from-past-297-more-notes-from.html

Martin
02-15-2013, 10:29 PM
Sorry for the off topic post, but is the pic in your sig from a real comic, it's hilarious:lol:

It is! it's from Tales Vol 2 #61 :tgrin:

Sophie Campbell
02-15-2013, 11:22 PM
In a universe where they all have (inexplicably) different colored skin, different rainbow colored bandannas, and different weapons and heights and body types... actually making the bandannas in different shapes and styles on top of that just seems too metrosexual of the Turtles.

it's SYMBOLIC, Andrew!!! ;)

snake
02-16-2013, 12:02 AM
It is! it's from Tales Vol 2 #61 :tgrin:

I'm guessing it was referencing the new movie?

Martin
02-16-2013, 05:44 AM
I'm guessing it was referencing the new movie?

mmm don't think so, #61 came out before the sale to viacom. Probably just some light humor the writer threw in there. Still, pretty damn funny, especially considering #61 was published back in 09, just a few months before the sale.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-16-2013, 09:31 AM
mmm don't think so, #61 came out before the sale to viacom. Probably just some light humor the writer threw in there. Still, pretty damn funny, especially considering #61 was published back in 09, just a few months before the sale.

I don't think Viacom would allow a joke like that in an IDW comic or anything else that had their seal on it.

Donnie
02-16-2013, 10:12 AM
I like them, but he has so be careful with them. Leo's looked like he was at a masquerade ball on page 6 or 7 of Foot Clan #1. But normally they look pretty cool, especially Raph's.

the stylized/differently-shaped masks are awesome, you guys!!!! come on!!

Agreed. I have no quips with Mateus's bandanas.

Even when given such a high quality product people will nit-pick sometimes just to complain about something, it seems.

frank_one
02-16-2013, 11:11 AM
About the stylized bandanas, it seems that more people than I expected like them. No problem then. I thought no one here liked them. I personally find them useless, like Andrew said, not a HUGE problem, anyway.

Here you go good sir
http://i.imgur.com/oGg0xsf.png
Why you do this to me. Good old red days :(
Santolouco is great, I love this panel.

Xav
02-16-2013, 11:17 AM
I don't think Viacom would allow a joke like that in an IDW comic or anything else that had their seal on it.I would think the people at Viacom would have a sense of humor, they do own Comedy Central after all.

Ninjinister
02-16-2013, 11:21 AM
I would think the people at Viacom would have a sense of humor, they do own Comedy Central after all.

Have you seen Comedy Central?

Xav
02-16-2013, 11:24 AM
Yes, and they have made fun of Michael Bay on South Park.

Martin
02-16-2013, 11:33 AM
Why you do this to me. Good old red days :(
Santolouco is great, I love this panel.

Considering the fact that they put out like a thousand variant covers for each issue, would it be too much to ask for a version of the comic where the bandanas are all red? Maybe make it a pre-order only thing?

MikeandRaph87
02-16-2013, 11:54 AM
Where is the narrow hallway they are fighting supposed to be?

Matches Malone
02-16-2013, 12:02 PM
this is my only quip with his style.

Agreed. I have no quips with Mateus's bandanas.

Sorry to nitpick, but do you mean "qualm?"

http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot.com/2010/04/blast-from-past-297-more-notes-from.html

Thanks! I guess I forgot that this "City At War" took place before they brought Ch'rell back into the picture. It's too bad they didn't listen to any of Laird's concerns, especially regarding Karai... This really was one of the worse adaptations in this series.

Spitfire
02-16-2013, 12:11 PM
Claiming it wasn't meant to be a City At War reference is hilarious. Then don't put city in the title. Anyways the artwork is...well I like everything but the turtles. The Turtles look horrid. I don't know why people feel the need to over stylize them. It works fine for a pin up but not a whole book. I'll give the series till the end of this arc to impress me and then it's getting dropped. I've been pretty patient with it so far and it hasn't done anything for me.

CyberCubed
02-16-2013, 12:12 PM
The art style is fine I just don't get the different masks.

MikeandRaph87
02-16-2013, 12:13 PM
Sorry to nitpick, but do you mean "qualm?"



Thanks! I guess I forgot that this "City At War" took place before they brought Ch'rell back into the picture. It's too bad they didn't listen to any of Laird's concerns, especially regarding Karai... This really was one of the worse adaptations in this series.

Really? I thought it did a heck of a job condensing and streamlining it for everyone to appreciate. It also introduced Karai to a wider audience including myself beyond a video game appearance. Chr'ell does appear in the final scene in a private chamber getting healed by the clone worms where Karai shares a little dialogue with him.

Martin
02-16-2013, 12:16 PM
Where is the narrow hallway they are fighting supposed to be?

It's probably the office complex of some sort of front company of the foot. Remember when Karai contacted the professor guy? She gave him a business card that said 'Assistant Director', and below followed the name of a company that is casually blocked by Miller's hand.

Spitfire
02-16-2013, 12:19 PM
The art style is fine I just don't get the different masks.

Maybe in your opinion it's fine. I don't like it. The masks are dumb as you mentioned, as are their facial expressions. No clue why their skin is multi-colored. Eyes look off, I hate when they have pupils. Skinny to fat limbs is disturbingly reminiscent of the horrid TMNT movie designs.

frank_one
02-16-2013, 12:21 PM
Considering the fact that they put out like a thousand variant covers for each issue, would it be too much to ask for a version of the comic where the bandanas are all red? Maybe make it a pre-order only thing?
Yes, that would be TOO MUCH. I mean, even if I'm really nostalgic about the Mirage era, we must accept that the turtles have rainbow bandanas in IDW's universe. I can't see two different version of the comic coming out at the same time, it would be confusing. After all they was able to give a reason for the multicolored bandanas and I thought it was a good one.

Martin
02-16-2013, 12:32 PM
Maybe in your opinion it's fine. I don't like it. The masks are dumb as you mentioned, as are their facial expressions. No clue why their skin is multi-colored. Eyes look off, I hate when they have pupils. Skinny to fat limbs is disturbingly reminiscent of the horrid TMNT movie designs.

I agree that the facial expressions are a bit weird. The only one I really dig are raphael's (the artist really nailed him down). As for the others, well... not so much. A panel comes back to mind when they were sitting in the back of the van and mickey's face looks pretty awful. I also don't dig the bandanas designs (raphael's excluded). Leo's bandana is a bit weird but I can live with it, mikey's ain't that bad either. Donnie's though, ugh. Also Raph and Leo's eyes are quite thin, giving them quite the menacing look, but for donnie and mikey's is quite the opposite. They have big round eyes which make them look kind of childish (especially when compared to their brothers). Also I don't know if it's only me, but mikey and donnie seem to have very round shaped heads, and that kind of puts me off.

That being said, the art is still amazing. This is just me nit-picking. As for the good things, the fight scenes look great, raphael looks totally badass, the human characters are great, etc etc etc. I also love how Santolouco incorporated little pouches in the belt design of the turtles. And let's not forget the feudal japan stuff! those panels are awesome.

So, overall, I'm really happy that he is the new regular :tgrin:

Yes, that would be TOO MUCH. I mean, even if I'm really nostalgic about the Mirage era, we must accept that the turtles have rainbow bandanas in IDW's universe. I can't see two different version of the comic coming out at the same time, it would be confusing. After all they was able to give a reason for the multicolored bandanas and I thought it was a good one.

Yeah I know, it's just the old mirage fan speaking from the dark recesses of my soul. The explanation they gave for this universe is pretty coherent after all and it's not that I'm against it, it's just that miss the all red team D:

MikeandRaph87
02-16-2013, 12:34 PM
It's probably the office complex of some sort of front company of the foot. Remember when Karai contacted the professor guy? She gave him a business card that said 'Assistant Director', and below followed the name of a company that is casually blocked by Miller's hand.

Good call! Just like that lost plot thread in "Turtle Tracks"! What was the issue number so I can go back and look?

Artist-wise I have no problem with the current or the next, I just wish we could get the main artist tied down to the title for a while since we got a new main artist for only about 5 issues.

The Purple Dragon
02-16-2013, 02:50 PM
have i missed something? some time a go i did read eastman was gone draw this arc.well i cant complain he is one of the best of the idw crew. just kevin,ross ,urru and posseble kuhn are better

Martin
02-16-2013, 03:00 PM
have i missed something? some time a go i did read eastman was gone draw this arc.well i cant complain he is one of the best of the idw crew. just kevin,ross ,urru and posseble kuhn are better

He is just gonna draw #21 if I'm not mistaken.

The Purple Dragon
02-16-2013, 03:14 PM
He is just gonna draw #21 if I'm not mistaken.

ok thanks fore telling:tgrin:

rpd123
02-16-2013, 04:23 PM
He is just gonna draw #21 if I'm not mistaken.

That's a shame. I like Eastman's style a lot. Mateus Santolouco is pretty good, but the faces they make are kind of weird sometimes.

The Big Bad
02-16-2013, 07:26 PM
Mega Man meets Sonic the Hedgehog? :roll: Who wouldn't walk away from a TMNT book for that...

You should give them a shot. The regular Sonic book has been treading water for the past year after a streak of awesome issues, but Sonic Universe and Mega Man are rather great, and make better use of Bates' sensibilities. He's good here; he's great there.

Redeemer
02-16-2013, 07:45 PM
I love Ben Bates!!!!!!!!!!!!he needs to stay!!!!!!!!!!! Why do the turtles keep getting abandoned!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:tcry:



I am just going to hide behind my couch....:tcouch:

thelouisguy
02-16-2013, 08:46 PM
I was deliberately trying not to say that :trazz:

I'd like to see all black for a stint, though.

All black could work. Something I like about Mateus' bandanas are that they look like ripped pieces tied over they eyes, except with too much styling. I really dug Slash's bandana.

Slade
02-16-2013, 08:51 PM
So ready for this! Can't wait an I think Leo is going to go willingly.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-16-2013, 08:57 PM
All black could work. Something I like about Mateus' bandanas are that they look like ripped pieces tied over they eyes, except with too much styling. I really dug Slash's bandana.

They reminded me of the Next Mutation turtles' bandanas IMMEDIATELY for some reason.

MikeandRaph87
02-16-2013, 09:05 PM
So ready for this! Can't wait an I think Leo is going to go willingly.

One thing mentioned is "one of the supporting cast is struggling with life and death" so lets say Splinter is injured by Shredder leaving Leo a choice to either join him as his no.2 or he will kill Splinter out right. Leonardo goes along with the demand for Splinter's sake and gathers intel on the Foot Clan's operations in the mean time until he can find the right moment to turn the tables on the Shredder. Though by that point Leonardo would have unwittingly helped Shredder dominate the underworld. Maybe even forced to come to blows with the other three turtles. I would like to see Leonardo training these surprise mutants,Bebop,Rocksteady, Leatherhead, or whoever else is being eluded to.

In reference to coincidence or not of the title Cityfall compared to City At War, I automatically thought of the last James Bond film Skyfall instead. Storywise it does seem to be the opposite. Instead of baddies trying to grab power in the underworld with Shredder gone its Shredder coming to power.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-16-2013, 09:18 PM
It is the inverse of "City at War."

CyberCubed
02-16-2013, 09:29 PM
The titles are exactly what they sound like:

City at War: A City caught in the turmoil of fighting between the Foot Clan and the Turtles

Cityfall: Most likely NYC's control falling under the weight of the Shredder.


I'd like to see something similar to the 4kids series where Oroku Saki makes deals with the Mayor and has public appearances.

Andrew NDB
02-16-2013, 09:52 PM
City at War: A City caught in the turmoil of fighting between the Foot Clan and the Turtles

Actually that was really more... a city caught in the turmoil of fighting between the Foot Clan and... the Foot Clan.

rpd123
02-16-2013, 09:55 PM
The title just makes me think of Skyfall. I can picture a psychologist doing the word association thing with Leo.

Bobby Curnow
02-17-2013, 12:01 AM
It's a small point, but I just want to say the title is City Fall, not Cityfall. Too separate words.

I specifically said that I was willing to do a typo check of the interview, but they said they had it handled... and it was riddled with typos!! Blerg!

Eh, I'm the guy who missed "bother" in the TMNT annual dedication. I guess I can't throw stones.

CyberCubed
02-17-2013, 12:20 AM
Between the previous "Turtles in Space" arc (although here it was Krang War), and City Fall, it almost seems like the IDW universe is being a more condensed version of Mirage with some cartoon characters thrown in.

I like how they're taking Mirage arcs and putting their own twist on things, it is refreshing. I just hope the stuff they're skipping over (Triceratons, Rat King, Leatherhead) all find their way into the series eventually.

Matches Malone
02-17-2013, 12:26 AM
Really? I thought it did a heck of a job condensing and streamlining it for everyone to appreciate. It also introduced Karai to a wider audience including myself beyond a video game appearance. Chr'ell does appear in the final scene in a private chamber getting healed by the clone worms where Karai shares a little dialogue with him.

Not really sure why streamlining was necessary though when they were willing to expand a 3 part issue arc, Turtles In Space, into 7 episodes, including the Secret Origins episodes. It also felt like it was adapted for adaptation's sake, rather than trying to live up to the significance of that storyline.

I'm certainly thankful that Karai hasn't fallen into complete obscurity, sure, but her reasoning was never very sound. I sort of liked some of the ideas they had for her character though, but they didn't quite pull it off as intelligently as I would have liked. We probably won't agree on this, but that's okay.

It's a small point, but I just want to say the title is City Fall, not Cityfall. Too separate words.

I specifically said that I was willing to do a typo check of the interview, but they said they had it handled... and it was riddled with typos!! Blerg!

Eh, I'm the guy who missed "bother" in the TMNT annual dedication. I guess I can't throw stones.

Fixed!

rpd123
02-17-2013, 12:45 AM
It's a small point, but I just want to say the title is City Fall, not Cityfall. Too separate words.

I specifically said that I was willing to do a typo check of the interview, but they said they had it handled... and it was riddled with typos!! Blerg!

Eh, I'm the guy who missed "bother" in the TMNT annual dedication. I guess I can't throw stones.

Haha, that makes more sense, and makes me not think of Skyfall as much. You'd think at the very least they'd make sure they got the title right. :tlol:

MikeandRaph87
02-17-2013, 11:52 AM
Not really sure why streamlining was necessary though when they were willing to expand a 3 part issue arc, Turtles In Space, into 7 episodes, including the Secret Origins episodes. It also felt like it was adapted for adaptation's sake, rather than trying to live up to the significance of that storyline.

I'm certainly thankful that Karai hasn't fallen into complete obscurity, sure, but her reasoning was never very sound. I sort of liked some of the ideas they had for her character though, but they didn't quite pull it off as intelligently as I would have liked. We probably won't agree on this, but that's okay.



Fixed!

I guess when it came up to that point in plotting the season there x episodes left to work with and knew where they wanted to be at season's end. I agree when it comes to her sudden jump to taking up The Shredder mantle after the utroms stating she was sent to prision without any development inbetween.Aside from that particular two parter she was great especially with characterization.As far as disagreeing,it comes from personal preferences and as long as cordial its what makes franchises so great.

Are you the same Matches Malone user from the former dccomics.com message boards by chance?

I see the Dark Knight Rises poster with the crumbling buildings but instead the shape of the foot symbol opposed to a bat. Maybe its silly but that is image this storyline has planted in my brain.

CyberCubed
02-18-2013, 12:20 AM
Anyone get the feeling Rat King might make his IDW debut in this arc, given he was in City at War?

Xav
02-18-2013, 02:35 AM
Not really sure why streamlining was necessary though when they were willing to expand a 3 part issue arc, Turtles In Space, into 7 episodes, including the Secret Origins episodes. It also felt like it was adapted for adaptation's sake, rather than trying to live up to the significance of that storyline.They turned issue 4 into the two part Search for Splinter. Turned issues 5, 6, and the Fugitoid issue into the five part "Turtles in Space Part", and turned issue 7 into the three part Secret Origins. So they sorta turned a 5 part arc into a 10 part one.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-18-2013, 11:01 AM
I see the Dark Knight Rises poster with the crumbling buildings but instead the shape of the foot symbol opposed to a bat. Maybe its silly but that is image this storyline has planted in my brain.

As t0kKa would say, "->>i think yer just b@tty!! :tlol:"

MikeandRaph87
02-18-2013, 05:57 PM
As t0kKa would say, "->>i think yer just b@tty!! :tlol:"

Or as Riddler would say, "Riddle me this,what kind of a man has bats on the brain?"

We have punks involved under the Purple Dragon label and The Hun heading them up. We have the Savante ninjas,but are they actually evil or will they play a role similar to the guardians? Will Krang be involved or sit this out as well as any role Old Hob and Slash may play? Gueses?

frank_one
02-19-2013, 09:32 AM
Will Krang be involved or sit this out as well as any role Old Hob and Slash may play? Gueses?
I guess Krang doesn't care about NYC. Don't know about the whole planet Earth. :P

Venom
02-19-2013, 10:32 AM
I guess Krang doesn't care about NYC. Don't know about the whole planet Earth. :P

Krang has his own agenda, which is centered in Burnow Island. IIRC, the only time we've seen him in New York was when he paid Baxter a visit.

If he launches a full-scale attack, I'm sure NYC would surely be a target being the largest in the US and a hub for so much.

ToTheNines
02-19-2013, 11:32 AM
I picture Krang sitting this out for the most part. I could be wrong, but I'm thinking the Turtles and NRF thrash him pretty good, and it looks like Karai is gonna cause a bunch of problems on Burnow Island. So it should be a while before he's back on his feet again.

MikeandRaph87
02-19-2013, 05:13 PM
I picture Krang sitting this out for the most part. I could be wrong, but I'm thinking the Turtles and NRF thrash his pretty good, and it looks like Karai is gonna cause a bunch of problems on Burnow Island. So it should be a while before he's back on his feet again.

One thing to consider is the oneshots this time will focus on him,Baxter Stockman, and Old Hob. Only the last one, Alopex do we know know for sure has any connection to the City Fall arc. So while this is going on they may not participate aside from Alopex which might explain the role she might play in the storyarc as well as give us the origin that Secrets of The Foot Clan will start and it finish. The other three might be preparing for the next arc like Secrets is now while we are getting Krang War in the title or how City Fall effects Krang, Baxter Stockman,and Old Hob. Food for thought.

CyberCubed
02-24-2013, 11:19 PM
Krang just got his huge arc. I'm sure he won't be involved in this one, or we'll only see him in limited capacity.

This arc looks to bring this back to a more urban and realistic story after the sci-fi arc of Krang/Neutrinos. The amount of Foot Clan fighting and Purple Dragon stuff is a nice balance to the sci-fi we just had previously.

Redeemer
02-25-2013, 10:39 AM
Krang just got his huge arc. I'm sure he won't be involved in this one, or we'll only see him in limited capacity.

This arc looks to bring this back to a more urban and realistic story after the sci-fi arc of Krang/Neutrinos. The amount of Foot Clan fighting and Purple Dragon stuff is a nice balance to the sci-fi we just had previously.

Agreed, they might have Krang in the background but if he is in there at all he will only be there in a limited capacity.

ToTheNines
02-25-2013, 12:01 PM
You guys know what I just realized I'm mother ****ing psyched to see?

Santolouco's take on Slash! That's gonna be awesome.

CyberCubed
02-25-2013, 12:41 PM
I wonder if Slash will look more like he did in the April micro, rather than the Tokka-ish design he had in the Kuhn issues. I'm fine either way though.

JoshDA7X
02-25-2013, 02:18 PM
I wonder if Slash will look more like he did in the April micro, rather than the Tokka-ish design he had in the Kuhn issues. I'm fine either way though.

I'm just happy he's in it at all! I can't wait for some new characters!

snake
02-25-2013, 02:59 PM
I wonder if Slash will look more like he did in the April micro, rather than the Tokka-ish design he had in the Kuhn issues. I'm fine either way though.

To be honest Im not too fond of the tokka-esque design, it leaves out the chance of tokka appearing.

ToTheNines
03-01-2013, 03:27 PM
Anyone else having trouble caring about the Savate ninjas? They've pretty much been nothing but lame so far.

Only thing I'm really digging about them is the chance that they bring in the IDW version of Mr. Touch and Mr. Go.

Powder
03-01-2013, 03:41 PM
Yeah I haven't cared for them at all, personally. I think the savate ninja had a cool design, but that's about the extent of my interest.

MikeandRaph87
03-01-2013, 03:42 PM
Anyone else having trouble caring about the Savate ninjas? They've pretty much been nothing but lame so far.

Only thing I'm really digging about them is the chance that they bring in the IDW version of Mr. Touch and Mr. Go.

I don't really have an opinion on them because we have only seen them appear twice and only know so much about them as its a nw character set no seen in TMNT before. If given more panel time I could develop an opinion on them. Its just two and too few appearances to really judge at this point so I am nuetral on them.

thelouisguy
03-01-2013, 08:38 PM
Claiming it wasn't meant to be a City At War reference is hilarious. Then don't put city in the title. Anyways the artwork is...well I like everything but the turtles. The Turtles look horrid. I don't know why people feel the need to over stylize them. It works fine for a pin up but not a whole book. I'll give the series till the end of this arc to impress me and then it's getting dropped. I've been pretty patient with it so far and it hasn't done anything for me.
Sad to hear you might drop the book. The longer it goes, the more I like it and am preferring it to the Mirage run (hard to believe).

You guys know what I just realized I'm mother ****ing psyched to see?

Santolouco's take on Slash! That's gonna be awesome.
:teek:

Anyone else having trouble caring about the Savate ninjas? They've pretty much been nothing but lame.
I hope they regroup and come back stronger than ever. I would like them to return with a Kingpin-type character who could single-handedly manhandle the turtles.

corvus
03-16-2013, 01:11 PM
My only complaint is that Santolouco will inevitably leave us. The details on the turtles shells, the way he includes pouches on their belts, Casey's hockey mask looking like a real hockey mask and things like the sleeve on Dons back for holding his bo-staff are details that will be missed. I also love the masks, in most panels the stylized features are subtle enough to still look like the tmnt.

Martin
03-16-2013, 03:45 PM
My only complaint is that Santolouco will inevitably leave us. The details on the turtles shells, the way he includes pouches on their belts, Casey's hockey mask looking like a real hockey mask and things like the sleeve on Dons back for holding his bo-staff are details that will be missed. I also love the masks, in most panels the stylized features are subtle enough to still look like the tmnt.

True, true and true. I love the level of detail he includes in his work! I wonder if he takes longer to finish up his work than the other artists.

Btw new covers are out:

http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/TMNT_23-CvrA_rich.jpg

http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/TMNT_23-CvrRI_rich.jpg

My heart and wallet are ready...

Powder
03-16-2013, 04:42 PM
Daaaaaamn, dat Splinter cover. I don't mean to disrespect the Mirage guys, it's blasphemy to, but nobody draws Splinter like these new IDW dudes. He always used to look like a dog, now these new guys are killin' it, and he's totally a rat.

corvus
03-16-2013, 05:18 PM
I'm gonna have to get A and B covers for this arch. These are all too awesome to say no to.

Martin
03-16-2013, 09:09 PM
Probably not relevant but I found this t-shirt that reminded me of someone we know

http://d3gqasl9vmjfd8.cloudfront.net/90f71922-34be-4f83-82ad-6ac59271e5b9.png

Panda_Kahn_fan
03-16-2013, 10:59 PM
I'm really, really looking forward to this story. It's not 'City at war', but a nice homage/story in the same vein that could give up some nice, gritty ninja action!

That being said, I really, really hope this is the point we get back to Rocksteady and Bebop. That plot thread has been dangling for a really long time now, and I'd like to see a follow up soon (at least show them in the background with the foot clan or something.)

CyberCubed
03-17-2013, 12:01 AM
I can see this being considered IDW's most popular story arc for years to come. Between the, "Secret history of the Foot Clan" mini, the Krang war arc, and this, IDW really is hitting their stride.

The series has moved passed the "growing pains" of Year One and is now getting really good.

Lord Nightwalker
03-17-2013, 01:10 AM
To be honest Im not too fond of the tokka-esque design, it leaves out the chance of tokka appearing.

I agree. I liked his appearence in the April micro better. However, I had assumed that it was just artist interpretation in the ongoing series.

corvus
03-17-2013, 02:03 PM
I'm really, really looking forward to this story. It's not 'City at war', but a nice homage/story in the same vein that could give up some nice, gritty ninja action!

That being said, I really, really hope this is the point we get back to Rocksteady and Bebop. That plot thread has been dangling for a really long time now, and I'd like to see a follow up soon (at least show them in the background with the foot clan or something.)

Well we get to see Hun, that's one cool thing. We get to see modern Kitsune, that's another. We'll get a taste of just how threatening Shredder based on his actions and not just splinter saying so, we get a new mystery opponent(in the prelude) and several new mutants, likely bebop and rocksteady. In one of the ninja notes they said "we'll see those two again" referring to bopsteady. If It's not here, I don't know when. I think after this arch the story ll start moving faster and get more intense. I'm stoked.


I hope they regroup and come back stronger than ever. I would like them to return with a Kingpin-type character who could single-handedly manhandle the turtles.

You mean a character like....Hun?

Powder
03-17-2013, 09:10 PM
"Issue 23 also includes cool flashbacks drawn by other awesome TMNT artists such as Dan Duncan, Andy Kuhn, Ben Bates and Ross Campbell."

http://fav.me/d5yd91y

Hell yeah.

turtlefan27
03-18-2013, 09:05 PM
i really hope bebop and rocksteady are in the mix of things they are bringing in here

Redeemer
03-19-2013, 09:48 AM
"Issue 23 also includes cool flashbacks drawn by other awesome TMNT artists such as Dan Duncan, Andy Kuhn, Ben Bates and Ross Campbell."

http://fav.me/d5yd91y

Hell yeah.

Wow thats pretty awesome!!!!!!

Vi11AiN6
03-19-2013, 09:52 AM
Okay I predict that Leo turning is a result of magic/ foot mind control which will probably be Kitsune's power (The fox witch from Secret History)

I have a feeling that the secondary character fighting for their life will be from the hands of Old Hob and Slash.

corvus
03-19-2013, 11:18 AM
Okay I predict that Leo turning is a result of magic/ foot mind control which will probably be Kitsune's power (The fox witch from Secret History)

I have a feeling that the secondary character fighting for their life will be from the hands of Old Hob and Slash.

I'm just using spoiler tags to be safe but

My guess is secret history of the foot clan will end with Shredder getting that book thing and then somehow use it to get in touch with Kitsune in order to turn Leo, if you didn't notice on the A cover she's holding Leos mask

Bobby Curnow
03-19-2013, 06:50 PM
I just came across this randomly, and found it interesting (though perhaps it's just interesting to me to hear what was going on with Mateus when I first contacted him!)

http://www.flickeringmyth.com/2013/03/turtle-power-conversation-with-comic.html

frank_one
03-19-2013, 08:20 PM
I'm just using spoiler tags to be safe but

My guess is secret history of the foot clan will end with Shredder getting that book thing and then somehow use it to get in touch with Kitsune in order to turn Leo, if you didn't notice on the A cover she's holding Leos mask

This sound very likely and.. I didn't notice that "little" detail on the cover! I bet you are right then.

Kisune will turn Leo's mind with magic.

thelouisguy
03-19-2013, 09:21 PM
I'd rather they stay away from "magic" as an explaination, usually comes across as unimaginative. That being said, I trust Tom to make it work, if that is the direction we are headed in.

Martin
03-19-2013, 09:57 PM
Another thing about the A cover is that the turtle that appears in the yellow tape seems to be leo, thus implying that his turn to the other side won't be as seamless as we think.

Btw, I really dig the kitsune theory. It seems very likely that that's what's gonna happen. Though as I mentioned before, the A cover also features a beat up leo (at least I think it's leo... the mask seems to fit). Kitsune holding his mask might just be a signal that she was the one that took him down and nothing else. But if leo's snap is due to magical/supernatural reasons though, I think there is no doubt that Kitsune will be involved with it.

Powder
03-19-2013, 10:01 PM
I'd rather they stay away from "magic" as an explaination, usually comes across as unimaginative. That being said, I trust Tom to make it work, if that is the direction we are headed in.

Well, I'd appreciate it. The Foot Mystics (among others) used magic all the time. Hell, it's a big part of the Mirage turtles mythos.

corvus
03-20-2013, 04:34 PM
I'm thinking Kitsunes magic is more ooze based. She may have learned from Krang how to manipulate it or perhaps she got very lucky in her own mutation. The only magic we've seen is reincarnation which is a theological thing. I hate to sound like Donatello but we don't really know magic exists in this universe