PDA

View Full Version : Does Anyone Else Prefer The Frequent Artist Change?


Powder
02-19-2013, 08:21 PM
At first, losing Dan Duncan was a big bummer for me. It was awesome to have such a dope artist become the face of this new generation, and I was quite used to & into his work. When he had to take a leave I was a bit concerned about what sort of turn the book would take artistically on a whole, as if it would have no signature look. Then after most of us settled in with Andy Kuhn, he too had to be replaced. I noticed a lot of people who were a bit upset by that, too. But now, after having enjoyed those two, and Ben Bates (as well as the many cover and micro-series artists) I think I actually prefer it this way. The IDW crew has such a wonderful assortment of artists, each with a very very unique style, that while staying true to the classic appearance, offers something new. Though I am super happy to have Mateus Santolouco on board to be the mainstay now (quite pleased, in fact, as I hoped it would happen after having read the first issue of SHOTFC) I am at the same time looking forward to who we may see next. We're constantly being introduced to new artists, adding another talent to our sort of rogues gallery (:P) & I really dig that. More folks to commission, more creative influences, more tastes from which to choose. Great stuff all around. & really, if not for the knowledge of schedule conflicts, one would wonder if doing things this way wasn't a nod to the Mirage books. We always had guest artists and alternating inkers, especially in Tales Of The TMNT which similarly to IDW's Micro-series' offered fresh new faces monthly.

So how do you feel about it?

mrmaczaps
02-19-2013, 08:31 PM
I kind of like it more when they stay on for a bit longer. So far it hasn't been too bad. Theres been a few of them that the Turtles heads look odd to me.

Honestly I don't care as long as they tell good stories and you can tell the characters apart. I don't want to just have to read it to know who is in the image, let the art tell me who they are too.

On the flip side, non-turtles stuff, I've seen some artwork out there that people just would die for where I just don't see the attraction to the work. nice clean pencils works.

sorry, that was a bit all over the road.

Venom
02-20-2013, 10:30 AM
I liked it til they got to Mateus. He needs to stay a long time! :D

pannoni1
02-20-2013, 10:36 AM
Another sign that IDW is like the OT, with its frequent animation studio changes (Seasons 3-6 in particular). It just adds more variety and unpredictability, and like the OT, will have better artwork in some issues than others. Its just like myself reading all of the various fanart, with some editing to ensure that the artwork is satisfactory. It does prove that there are many great artists out there who can contribute and opens up the artists base to have a better chance to chat with them.

CyberCubed
02-20-2013, 10:53 AM
I'd prefer a 10 issue run before change.

Plasticplayhouse
02-20-2013, 11:08 AM
The longtime TMNT comic fans were already accustomed to this via Eastman and Laird. Volume one of mirage was pretty sporadic with its artists. I grew to enjoy that aspect of it, though I cherished every bit of E&L art we managed to get.

I will probably always consider Dan Duncan the face of IDW TMNT. His art was huge in the rebirth of the comic and he did a fantastic job illustrating it for a full year. I'm actually hoping that he will be back at some point to draw another arch or micro.

I grew to love Dan's style, but I'm stoked whenever I get to see something by Ross Campbell or other great potential artist. With the exception of the stylized masks (sorry to keep nagging on that point but they just irk me :( ) I am a big fan of Santolouco's style. He is extremely talented and he was one of my top "wants" to take over for Dan.

Kuhn's work grew on me. I liked it. would I want to have him been the new solo artist??? probably not. But in small segments I loved it.

I am cool with switching up artists every so often, as long as they don’t go for any overly crazy style changes. If I start seeing next mutation looking designs or some other funky renditions, it may annoy me enough to drop my subscription and just pick up single issues here and there. Save that stuff for a tales series or the fanart section.

Ideally I think a year is a good tour of duty for the artists.

Matches Malone
02-20-2013, 12:03 PM
I don't know if I prefer it, but I don't mind it since IDW has had a really good eye for interesting and talented artists.

I really like their model of having a (trying, at least) steady artist for the ongoing, and bringing on different artists and writers for their Micro-Series. It lets you have your cake and eat it too, for those who like consistency and variety.

drewizzle88
02-20-2013, 12:30 PM
I prefer one badass artist like Duncan or Santolouco to do the regular issues, when Kuhn was doing them I'm almost cancelled my subscription. When I don't enjoy the art I lose a lot of interest in the story.

Gyt Kaliba
02-20-2013, 01:14 PM
I do kind of wish they'd stick with one artist, because even just looking at panels online, the different styles jumping all over the place is going to be really distracting to me and pull me out of the story some, when I can finally get the trades. But I understand that US comics do this a lot - I'm just more used to manga where it's the same artist for a series entire run, because it is their story plain and simple. So I'm spoiled in that regard I guess.

Master Splinter
02-20-2013, 01:32 PM
I am all for switching up the artists. I would prefer them to stick around for the entire arc and not switch artists during an arc but in all reality it doesn't matter to me. The story is what matters the most to me.

-ms

dkram230
02-20-2013, 01:52 PM
I like consistency within a title, especially for the artwork in a comic. Don't get me wrong, I think Tom Waltz is writing amazing stories and I hope he's around for the long haul. But it is more noticeable to me when the artist changes than the writer. And I almost find it distracting when it occurs.

To me, changing the artist every few issues is like replacing an actor of a TV series every few episodes. Same character, but different actor. That's just silly! I get it in the case of Kuhn where he was brought in as an interim replacement because they needed to keep the series going while figuring out a more permanent replacement for Duncan. But now that Bates has been selected I'm looking forward to my TMNT looking the same again for a bit!

Obviously an artists interpretation will change the more he draws the characters. But I would argue that those changes happen more frequently at the beginning of their tenure as they still figuring out their style. So why keep bringing on new artists only to replace them just as they are finishing their initial fine tuning for the characters? To be honest, if they decided to go on an artist rotation for this title I would probably eventually get frustrated and just stop buying.

Martin
02-20-2013, 02:21 PM
I like diversity but not in the main tittle. That's what the micros are for and, even so, if we could have one guy draw everything, I wouldn't mind.

I mean, don't get me wrong, I love having tons of different artists draw the turtles. Guys like Urro (Raph's micro), Schitti (Don's), Ross (Leo) and Henderson (Casey), completely blow me away with their artwork; any of them would be amazing for the main series. But as I said before I prefer to have just one guy handle the main duties, for the sake of continuity.

Let's hope Matheus sticks around :tsmile:

dkram230
02-20-2013, 02:29 PM
I like diversity but not in the main tittle. That's what the micros are for and, even so, if we could have one guy draw everything, I wouldn't mind.

I mean, don't get me wrong, I love having tons of different artists draw the turtles. Guys like Urro (Raph's micro), Schitti (Don's), Ross (Leo) and Henderson (Casey), completely blow me away with their artwork; any of them would be amazing for the main series. But as I said before I prefer to have just one guy handle the main duties, for the sake of continuity.

Let's hope Matheus sticks around :tsmile:

Ok, I've been away from the drome for a couple weeks. Are you telling me now Bates is being replaced too???

***First of Two Latin Kings***
02-20-2013, 02:48 PM
Ok, I've been away from the drome for a couple weeks. Are you telling me now Bates is being replaced too???

Yes, but he's being replaced by someone who has already done quite a bit of work on this series.

snake
02-21-2013, 01:57 PM
Yes, it keeps the series fresh, I love all the art so far, my favorite being issue 15 16 and the splinter micro

DrSpengler
02-21-2013, 02:29 PM
It's a give and take.

I would like a dedicated, committed artist on the series for a long run, though I understand that sticking to a single title for years can be constraining on an artist, not just in terms of creativity but also personal improvement (hard to get better at drawing lots of different things when you're stuck drawing one thing for years).

The rotating artists do offer variety, which is really good, but it also comes at the expense of consistency. Ideally, I'd like the ongoing to have a single stable artist while new artists strut their stuff for things like the Microseries and various minis (basically, exactly the way IDW was doing things when they started).

Perhaps we were a bit spoiled, getting Dan for 12 issues right out of the gate and now rotating artists for every 4-issue arc seems way too brisk by comparison.

Oculus Orbus
02-21-2013, 02:41 PM
I prefer it when they stick to just one artist. Like others said before, I welcome different artists doing the Micros and alternate covers, but for the main series I enjoy it better if it feels consistent. In this particular case, I prefer Santolouco over Duncan, and Kuhn and Bates have been pretty good, so change hasn't been too bad.

With the exception of the stylized masks (sorry to keep nagging on that point but they just irk me :( ) I am a big fan of Santolouco's style.

This. Seriously, Santolouco's turtles are among the best ever in my opinion, but I really can't get over the bandanas he draws.

ToTheNines
02-21-2013, 03:31 PM
We should count ourselves lucky. Each arc has had its own artist, but look at Red Hood and the Outlaws #17... It had three different artists. And that's a Big Two book, and part of the Bat-family.

CyberCubed
02-21-2013, 04:07 PM
Is there any actual reason the artists only stay for 4 issues now? I know Duncan only left because he quit IDW for something new, and Kuhn wasn't everyone's cup of tea.

But is every artist just going to have a limited run now?

Powder
02-21-2013, 04:53 PM
Well, Bates wants to make sure he can return to Megaman because of the Sonic The Hedgehog crossover arc they're putting together. Can't say for any others.

Cipher
02-21-2013, 07:00 PM
Honestly, I would've preferred Dan Duncan staying on, because his art is fantastic and really defined the identity of the IDW TMNT.

That said, there's nothing wrong with rotating artists either, as long as they stay faithful to the basic designs. Four issues is a bit short though.

thelouisguy
02-21-2013, 09:55 PM
We've been lucky to have amazing artists involved so far.

I like the micro-series model, might prefer it if all four issues being collected were done by the same artist; like SHotFC. It makes a trade easier to flip through. Same thing applies to the ongoing series; makes the trades look more cohesive.

I also loved Dan's 12 isssues. Would have preferred if we could have had Andy on for 8 issues, but at least we got 4. Minimum 4, preferably 8 issues would be my choice; long enough to give the artist a chance to settle in. Glad we are getting Mateus for 7 issues, that's a good run. Hopefully Bobby can get future artists on board for 8 issue runs going forward.

I also love being treated to the occasional issue by Kevin.

CyberCubed
02-23-2013, 11:43 PM
I agree. When I think of IDW TMNT, I still think of Dan Duncan's style and his Turtles for this iteration.

Hope he can come back at some point, even if its only for a single issue or so.

RaphaelsIsolation
03-03-2013, 12:24 PM
I agree. I miss Duncan very much.

I would get somewhat tired of Duncan for every issue though. I would like to have Duncan do 80% of them, and the rest for Eastman/Bates/Kuhn

Kuhn's style is okay, not a big fan. I'm like bates a lot though

ToTheNines
03-03-2013, 11:00 PM
Imagine if #13-20 were drawn by Duncan for a moment...

Donnie
03-03-2013, 11:32 PM
I don't agree with those who would have preferred Duncan to stay. I never really got into his style. His work was nice but seemed somewhat rushed, although I did enjoy him much more during his later issues. It was really his plastron issue that turned me off, and it was hard not to focus on it.

Ross Campbell's Leonardo issue was by far the pinnacle art-wise for me, concerning the IDW series up until that point.

I wasn't a really big fan of Andy Kuhn, but again I appreciated him more during his last stint (that Slash issue was great)...it's a natural thing of course, getting better at drawing characters the more you do it, so that isn't surprising. The biggest problem with Kuhn, for me, was his Turtles. I liked everything else really, but when you're reading a TMNT book you focus mainly on the Turtles, at least I do.

Really, really enjoyed Ben Bates. His style really fit the IDW "mood", in my opinion, I love his blocky Turtles. Plastrons are drawn awesomely. A score all around.

Mateus? Not a single complaint. The man's a beast.

Cipher
03-04-2013, 01:32 AM
I don't agree with those who would have preferred Duncan to stay. I never really got into his style. His work was nice but seemed somewhat rushed, although I did enjoy him much more during his later issues. It was really his plastron issue that turned me off, and it was hard not to focus on it.
For me, it was the sense of movement he imparted to his drawings, which I haven't seen anyone match, IDW or otherwise. Am I remembering right that he left comics to move primarily into television/storyboard work? If so, I can see why. He's made for it.

It won me over on some of the aspects of his Turtles I wasn't big on at first (the square heads, the flexible plastrons) just because they fit the style so well and aided that dynamic quality.

Lampy
03-04-2013, 02:22 AM
i don't mind the rotating artists at all...

however, i do wish that they looked a little similar. the artists we've had recently since day one have been very talented, yes. but their art are so vastly different that the turtles look nothing alike one compared side by side. while i respect each artists work and style... the look of the Turtles with each artist are very inconsistent to me. from duncan's tall gritty turtles, to khun's short and fat turtles with funny faces, to bates's short but lean turtles, and even santolouco's meaner nick-inspired varied turtles, you can spot the differences and inconsistencies right away. i read a lot of comics and i know rotating art duties is standard and to be expected, but i just prefer that each artist stayed a little longer than 4 issues. the inconsistency would've been harder to see. don't get me wrong... i'm very appreciative that we have awesome artists on board (even khun's art is badass... minus the turtles)... but the artists rotate too soon making it too inconsistent for me.

As I've stated before, Duncan's early work was my favorite and still is. Those Turtles were always the way i've pictured them growing up. i've never really favored one incarnation's appearance. and while i respect and love the original mirage turtles... duncan's early Turtles were what i've pictured for years... even before IDW picked the title up. i guess duncan just set the tone for me with [my] perfect turtles... also setting the bar way too high [imo]. while i love santolouco's art... i wish he stuck close to the turtles in that rocksteady page we found or the unofficial designs. those turtles were awesome. not really digging their current look. and the nick-isms just punches me in the face.

in general though... i don't really care if we get new rotating artists. just wish they'd stay longer.

RaphaelsIsolation
03-04-2013, 08:53 AM
nice post lampy, I pretty much agree with that.

I wish duncan would come back at some point...

anyone know something about that?

***First of Two Latin Kings***
03-04-2013, 08:57 AM
I want to say that Duncan will come back at some point if he has time to work on the book again. It kind of seems like he was intended to do it in the long term, and something else got in the way.

I'm confused Lampy, you think Mateus' turtles look more like the Nick TMNT than Ross Campell's TMNT or Ben Bates'?

Jephael
03-04-2013, 12:31 PM
I kinda like it this way. Maybe someday we'll have a permanent artist, but for the moment I really enjoy the change in art style for each new storyarc.

Dirty Blond
03-04-2013, 01:31 PM
I see your real agenda, Powder!

If IDW keeps changing artists, eventually they'll get to you! (And hopefully soon, because your stuff is that good.)

Lampy
03-05-2013, 06:05 AM
I'm confused Lampy, you think Mateus' turtles look more like the Nick TMNT than Ross Campell's TMNT or Ben Bates'?

no it's not that i think they look more like the nick turtles... i just feel that the nick influence on mateus' new turtle designs is very apparent. but again... nothing wrong with that.. i love the nick turtles' designs. i just feel that the idw turtles had this distinct look that looked no where near the nick, mirage, and OT. when duncan first drew them... they had a new look that was refreshing. that look set the tone of the idw series. Mateus' older designs (although they did not look exactly alike) had that same tone as the early idw turtles that i expressly liked. more so than the SotFC turtles. i guess dan just really nailed it for me.

Venom
03-05-2013, 10:55 AM
no it's not that i think they look more like the nick turtles... i just feel that the nick influence on mateus' new turtle designs is very apparent...

Well, Mateus did use the action figures as a point of reference... :tcool:

Lampy
03-05-2013, 12:39 PM
Well, Mateus did use the action figures as a point of reference... :tcool:

true... and it shows.

ToTheNines
03-05-2013, 06:39 PM
Well, Mateus did use the action figures as a point of reference... :tcool:

I think you're thinking of Bates.

shuriken
03-07-2013, 03:45 PM
I was really liking Bates. Probably my fave artist thus far. But I don't mind it. As long as they keep an ongoing story and don't pull a Mirage and get a bunch of random artists and story guys for the next 20 issues I'm good. Although having 1-5 every once in while would be cool.

Icegaze
03-10-2013, 07:06 AM
I just love the art style since volume 17 (Ben Bates). Much much better than the previous ones. I've forgotten the artist's name but his turtles were too "thoothy" and his drawings were extremely inconstitent and too bright in colour. I hope Mr. Bates remains in charge for a long time to come.

liugeaux
03-10-2013, 11:47 AM
I like the rotating artist and as long as the switch is done in conjunction with a story arc I feel like IDW is respecting the work. Having trades with Duncan's issues tehn follow up trades Kuhn and Bates' issues is classy.

When the City Fall trade(s) is(are) released that one issue by Eastman #20 is going to be a weird stand out, but I get it...Chapter 1 of City at War stands out too. It's a possibly intentional throwback.

Personally I think we have the best two TMNT artists that we've had in a long time right now in Bates and Santolouco.

Icegaze
03-10-2013, 02:17 PM
Bates is clearly my favourite now. I hope he gets to do 21, 22 till when the series end. #LOLDREAMER

liugeaux
03-10-2013, 02:52 PM
Bates is clearly my favourite now. I hope he gets to do 21, 22 till when the series end. #LOLDREAMER
Its already been announced that Santolouco is doing the art on Cityfall, the arc after The Krang War.

Toby Barrett
03-10-2013, 03:36 PM
Already been confirmed that that's not going to happen..

Powder
03-10-2013, 03:54 PM
I just love the art style since volume 17 (Ben Bates). Much much better than the previous ones. I've forgotten the artist's name but his turtles were too "thoothy" and his drawings were extremely inconstitent and too bright in colour. I hope Mr. Bates remains in charge for a long time to come.

He's gone, brah. & Andy doesn't color his own work, don't blame him for their vibrancy.

Bates is clearly my favourite now. I hope he gets to do 21, 22 till when the series end. #LOLDREAMER

Eastman is doing 21 & Mateus the rest. Where have you been? #LOLHASHTAGSAREWACK

Icegaze
03-10-2013, 04:09 PM
He's gone, brah. & Andy doesn't color his own work, don't blame him for their vibrancy.
Noooooooo, Ben why???;
Duly noted for the colouring.


Eastman is doing 21 & Mateus the rest. Where have you been? #LOLHASHTAGSAREWACK

I've been away, man. It has been several months. Probably since October. #CANTTOUCHTHIS

Powder
03-10-2013, 05:56 PM
Noooooooo, Ben why???;
Duly noted for the colouring. I've been away, man. It has been several months. Probably since October. #CANTTOUCHTHIS

Fair enough, my bad. Ben has other duties, such as going back to Megman (where they pulled him from) to work on the Sonic crossover. All of these guys seem pretty deeply involved in the comics biz, too much to fully commit to a(nother) book. It's sad on one hand, but cool at the same time.

drewizzle88
03-10-2013, 06:12 PM
He's gone, brah. & Andy doesn't color his own work, don't blame him for their vibrancy.

Bear with me as a long time comic book reader but essential newb in the creation process. How are comics colored, is it scanned then color digitally added along with the words?

Fair enough, my bad. Ben has other duties, such as going back to Megman (where they pulled him from) to work on the Sonic crossover. All of these guys seem pretty deeply involved in the comics biz, too much to fully commit to a(nother) book. It's sad on one hand, but cool at the same time.

Any word on Santolouco? As in after he's done with Cityfall do you think he will be pulled away to other obligations, or might we actually get to keep him with the series for awhile?

Toby Barrett
03-10-2013, 06:51 PM
After Cityfall, I'd be stoked if any of the past artists came back to pencil a story arc!
Bates, Henderson, Campbell, Schiti, they're all awesome. I'd love to see Duncan return as well, even if it were for just one arc.

CyberCubed
03-10-2013, 09:05 PM
I think Bobby hinted about Dan Duncan doing something TMNT related later this year, although its probably just an alternate cover.