PDA

View Full Version : IDW: Reincarnation


Vi11AiN6
04-06-2013, 05:09 PM
Okay so maybe this is me thinking way to much about the series as a whole. However I have to ask...(First of all I like the idea and as a Buddhist I believe in karma and the transfer energy, also Tool's Lateralus is the sound-track to my reading of the comic)


Anyhow; the Question. If Splinter, and the TMNT are reincarnations of Hamato Yoshi and his sons, can we by default expect other mutated characters to be reincarnations of other previous people?

In other words: Splinter and the Turtles make sense to be human-like because they were in past life. They came back as mutant animals.

My question: if an animal is in contact with a human and get mutated (without a human soul) wouldn't they be like a mutant caveman? Old Hod seems to set in his way to not be reincarnated as well.

My argument is that is these characters a "people" then is there more to the IDW story? Doesn't make sense that Splinter/TMNT are human and emotional because they are reincarnated.

It makes sense for a human to mutate to an animal and have their power/instinct along with human intuition,/

But if an animal was was an animal first then mutated they would have no concept of language or morals or "sides" they would be "monsters"

As smart as IDW is I would like them to make this theme more relevant.

(okay no more listening to Tool and reading the comics)

:teek::trolleye:

Andrew NDB
04-06-2013, 05:19 PM
I wouldn't mind seeing the reincarnation thing be revisited with other characters... but extremely sparingly and not in ways that make the Turtles' world seem smaller (i.e., everyone in the whole cast is somehow a reincarnation of people who crossed paths and knew each other over the course of a few years in Feudal Japan at exactly the same time).

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-06-2013, 05:39 PM
See, I think that kind of thing could be avoided by having diffrent mutants from difffrent times and places in thier past lives, most having no connection to feudal Japan. Such as Leatherhead being a Cajun knife fighter from Louisana before the civil war, or Ace Duck being reincarnated from a World War II pilot that got shot down, or Jagwar (hypothectically assuming he's be a mutant in IDW) would be reincarnted from an aztec Jagwar knight, slain by a Conquistador during Cortez's invasion of Mexico. We could get some awesome historical falshbacks, and as a history major, I'd love that sort of thing! :D

corvus
04-06-2013, 08:31 PM
I'd hate to see other reincarnated characters: god, karm, Brahmin, fate or whatever you wanna call it reincarnated them for a reason. A theological world where everyone is reincarnated as a mutant is just stupid.

Martin
04-06-2013, 09:19 PM
Actually they weren't reincarnated as mutants. Their souls were there even before being mutated, they just lacked the mental ability to realize it. You can see that when April names the turtles, they are all doing stuff that relates to their human personalities, thus implying that some of their human traits were already there. There is also the psychotropic drug: Splinter knew about his past life and sons because he was able to think like a human (you might wanna look for a panel in one of the earlier issues in which one lab assistant explains to April what the drug was for).

I have some catching up to do in my buddhism, but I don't think that every animal out there is a reincarnated human. So it's not really necessary for every mutant out there to be one, but that doesn't mean that they can't be.

Now I'd like to get a little bit into the whole preset knowledge that all these mutants seem to have. As you said, if one animal that gets mutated wasn't a human in a past life, once they become humanoids they should be mutant cavemen. But we really don't know how the mutagen works, do we? For all we know there could be something in there that provides the mutated animal with some fundamental knowledge to help it survive or adapt better to their new form. After all, the mutagen was being developed to be used in Krang's war, and he probably wanted his soldiers to know what they were doing from the get go. The main example that comes to mind is the fact that Splinter and the turtles speak english right off the bat. If there wasn't some kind of information attached to the ooze then they should be speaking in japanese, not english. I even believe that some of this information is what's blocking their past memories (eg english suppresses japanese), but let's not get into that.

I'm pretty sure that the guys at IDW will tie all this up at some point in the future. Heck, we might even get an answer in Krang's micro :tsmile:

Raph's Girl
04-06-2013, 09:40 PM
I have some catching up to do in my buddhism, but I don't think that every animal out there is a reincarnated human. So it's not really necessary for every mutant out there to be one, but that doesn't mean that they can't be.

Hindu believe that when you die you are reincarnated into a rat (sacred animals to them) and when a rat dies they are reincarnated back into humans. It's a never ending cycle.

Vishnu has various forms of incarnations (turtle, rhino, ect).

TMNT Adventures dealt with reincarnation when Splinter's Dalhi Lama friend Charley the Llama died and was emediatly reborn as a human.

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-07-2013, 10:57 AM
I didn't mean every animal used to be somebody. I meant that some are reincarnations, while others (with no memories) are not. For those who did have a past life, the mutagen restores those memories as they mutate 'up'. At least, that's how I see it.

Shredded
04-07-2013, 02:03 PM
That would be sort of interesting to see other mutant animals being re-incarnations from other places and eras.

"I used to be a norse viking!" .. yeah.. that would actually be kind of cool.

How-ever, I think in the case of Hamato Yoshi in this, it's because he was a buddhies and believed in all of this stuff, thus knew how to use it and bend it, that he could will his wish forward. Simply, will that he would stay together with his sons even in the next life. Because he has that big a self control in the zen energies and whats not.

He explicitly says. "I will see my sons again! And I will have my revenge on you!" right as he dies, thus willing that to actually happen due to his control.

That's just my take on it.

Also because, it's not always budhism believes that the soul remains intact upon re-incarnation. Hinduism does, but a part of Budhism is to accept the flow of the world and the constant change of the world.
Think of it, as the entire world is a big flowing ocean, and the souls inside of our human bodies are made from the same substance as the big ocean, drops of water taken out of the ocean for a while. And then when we die, we don't sieze to be as much as we are let back into the big ocean, and form compleately new connections, in a ever changing circle where nothing remains the same.
Unless you are a very powerful zen master so you can manipulate these energies.. like Splinter perhaps?

corvus
04-07-2013, 02:36 PM
It was fate or whatever that put them into the bodies of turtles that were going to be mutated so they could fulfil their purpose of stopping Saki. I've heard a lot of "Alopex is reincarnated!!!" In theory, Sure maybe everyone is, but not everyone has the memories and it'd be weird if they did.

NinjaMan
04-07-2013, 02:50 PM
The reincarnation angle is what turns me off of this series. I prefer the turtles to just be mutants. Reincarnation really takes away from that :(

Warboss74
04-07-2013, 02:50 PM
The psychotropic serum is key to all of this. It's effects were discussed in the naming of Splinter. The exact quote is "The drug's effect is like splitting-or splintering-the animal's nature in two. Basically, separating out a capacity for human-like cognition from the instinctual animal state. In theory, at least." Even if mutants like Old Hob, Alopex, and Slash aren't reincarnated, we're shown through Slash that they do have memories of their pre-mutation lives with his palm tree. Would it be that much of a stretch to say that they're finally able to understand/comprehend all the human speech they heard pre-mutation because of the psychotropic serum.

Martin
04-07-2013, 03:12 PM
The psychotropic serum is key to all of this. It's effects were discussed in the naming of Splinter. The exact quote is "The drug's effect is like splitting-or splintering-the animal's nature in two. Basically, separating out a capacity for human-like cognition from the instinctual animal state. In theory, at least." Even if mutants like Old Hob, Alopex, and Slash aren't reincarnated, we're shown through Slash that they do have memories of their pre-mutation lives with his palm tree. Would it be that much of a stretch to say that they're finally able to understand/comprehend all the human speech they heard pre-mutation because of the psychotropic serum.

Not every test subject was injected with it. As a matter of fact the serum was being developed through splinter, so he was the only one who got the shots; that also explains why he was the only one who remembered his past life from the start. Something that I mentioned in an earlier post, is that there is probably something in the ooze that's giving these mutated creatures some basic knowledge (eg. speech, basic fighting skills, etc). The mutagen was specifically being developed to create mutant soldiers for krang's war, so it's understandable that they would want to preset some things in the minds of their subjects. Also, since the mutagen wasn't yet finished when a lot of these creatures were exposed to it, it's probable that only basic information was attached to the ooze, but more complex things like: 'I love krang' or 'I'll obey krang', weren't yet there. They were kind of beta testing it at the time of all the break ins and break outs.

Warboss74
04-07-2013, 03:40 PM
Not every test subject was injected with it. As a matter of fact the serum was being developed through splinter, so he was the only one who got the shots; that also explains why he was the only one who remembered his past life from the start. Something that I mentioned in an earlier post, is that there is probably something in the ooze that's giving these mutated creatures some basic knowledge (eg. speech, basic fighting skills, etc). The mutagen was specifically being developed to create mutant soldiers for krang's war, so it's understandable that they would want to preset some things in the minds of their subjects. Also, since the mutagen wasn't yet finished when a lot of these creatures were exposed to it, it's probable that only basic information was attached to the ooze, but more complex things like: 'I love krang' or 'I'll obey krang', weren't yet there. They were kind of beta testing it at the time of all the break ins and break outs.
The Turtles and Old Hob were both exposed to the psychotropic serum at the time of their mutation. Krang even asks Stockman why they can't just extract what they need from Old Hob, and Stockman points out that they need Splinter because his exposure to the psychotropic serum wasn't contaminated. He even suggests there is going to be mental instability consequences for Old Hob and the Turtles. Slash is actually shown to have recieved injections of psychotropic serum created from Old Hob's blood. It isn't expressly stated how they program his Psy-control to hunt, but they were already exposing him to mutagen before they initiated it. There's a scene where Slash is taken down in the labs that looks like he's wearing headphones. The super soldier mutagen seems to be just the thing that mutates the animals/creatures. We'll see what happens to his mind now that Old Hob has Splinter's blood or psychotropic serum created from Splinter's blood.

Martin
04-07-2013, 05:54 PM
The Turtles and Old Hob were both exposed to the psychotropic serum at the time of their mutation. Krang even asks Stockman why they can't just extract what they need from Old Hob, and Stockman points out that they need Splinter because his exposure to the psychotropic serum wasn't contaminated. He even suggests there is going to be mental instability consequences for Old Hob and the Turtles. Slash is actually shown to have recieved injections of psychotropic serum created from Old Hob's blood. It isn't expressly stated how they program his Psy-control to hunt, but they were already exposing him to mutagen before they initiated it. There's a scene where Slash is taken down in the labs that looks like he's wearing headphones. The super soldier mutagen seems to be just the thing that mutates the animals/creatures. We'll see what happens to his mind now that Old Hob has Splinter's blood or psychotropic serum created from Splinter's blood.

If that's the case, then my bad, but looking through the earlier issues I can't seem to find a mention of a stolen canister of the serum. If there was some of it among what was stolen then that would explain how the turtles and hob became in contact with it but as I said I'm not sure that's the case. Old hob did get his eye chewed off by splinter so he might have been exposed to it that way but wouldn't explain how the turtles came in contact with it.

Anyway, it's a valid explanation but it doesn't completely rule out my theory... though looking at my record, I'm not very good at the predicting stuff :trazz:

Btw I had completely forgotten about slash. From what I just read they were injecting some mutagen refined from hob's blood. I wanna point out that they specifically used the word mutagen and not psychotropic serum, though it might all been mixed up in there, so who knows? Also, I've gotta admit that if it's true that the others were exposed to the serum, the fact that slash received an impure dose would explain his lack of cognitive abilities

edit: I though of something else not five minutes after posting... as usual. Anyway, one question: if in fact there is no conditioning attached to either the serum or the ooze (this would be an slash scenario, where they have to teach the animal things through sounds -slash was wearing headphones- or some other method), then how does hob know english? He was just a random cat in the middle of the street that got exposed to the ooze, there was no previous injections, no nothing. Even better, how did he know how to walk? or even stand? if you are an animal and you were just turned into a humanoid, even with human cognition, how are you able to stand? Another thing I realized is that if the serum wasn't necessary for the mutants to function then why would it have been developed in the first place? so, silly me

Warboss74
04-07-2013, 09:05 PM
If that's the case, then my bad, but looking through the earlier issues I can't seem to find a mention of a stolen canister of the serum. If there was some of it among what was stolen then that would explain how the turtles and hob became in contact with it but as I said I'm not sure that's the case. Old hob did get his eye chewed off by splinter so he might have been exposed to it that way but wouldn't explain how the turtles came in contact with it.

Anyway, it's a valid explanation but it doesn't completely rule out my theory... though looking at my record, I'm not very good at the predicting stuff :trazz:

Btw I had completely forgotten about slash. From what I just read they were injecting some mutagen refined from hob's blood. I wanna point out that they specifically used the word mutagen and not psychotropic serum, though it might all been mixed up in there, so who knows? Also, I've gotta admit that if it's true that the others were exposed to the serum, the fact that slash received an impure dose would explain his lack of cognitive abilities

edit: I though of something else not five minutes after posting... as usual. Anyway, one question: if in fact there is no conditioning attached to either the serum or the ooze (this would be an slash scenario, where they have to teach the animal things through sounds -slash was wearing headphones- or some other method), then how does hob know english? He was just a random cat in the middle of the street that got exposed to the ooze, there was no previous injections, no nothing. Even better, how did he know how to walk? or even stand? if you are an animal and you were just turned into a humanoid, even with human cognition, how are you able to stand? Another thing I realized is that if the serum wasn't necessary for the mutants to function then why would it have been developed in the first place? so, silly me
You're correct in saying they used the word mutagen when talking about the injections, but that's from a completely different timeframe. (13 months prior to current day) The injection of stuff from Old Hob's blood occured a month before that scene. The whole point of Old Hob tracking down Splinter in the present day was because they needed his blood to recreate the psychotropic serum. Krang even asks Stockman why can't he use Old Hob's blood to recreate the serum, and Stockman says he can't use it because Old Hob and the Turtles were exposed to a contaminated ssrum while Splinter received controlled injections of uncontaminated serum. In the 14 months prior scene, Chet says he doesn't like testing an impure sample. We know the super soldier mutagen is created from the Utrom ooze, so the injection from Old Hob's blood has to be the recreated psychotropic serum.

As for the Psy-Control programming, that was so they could brainwash him into hunting the Turtles and Splinter while still maintaing control over him. From what we see on the page, it doesn't have anything with them learning to function. (It really does look like Slash is wearing headphones in those two panels) Without the reincarnation of the Turtles, there has been nothing to suggest that Raphael should have been wandering around on 2 legs for 15 months. Like what I posted earlier, we see through Slash and his palm tree that they do retain their memories before mutation. Old Hob is a stray cat in New York City. He probably crossed paths with humans on an everyday basis. When he suddenly takes a humanoid shape you'd think his new human-like cognition would draw on those past experiences to walk upright. He's probably heard english/human speech everyday before the mutation as well, but he's finally able to draw from it now he's been exposed to the mutagen and the serum. That's just my opinion and it could be wrong when Old Hob's micro comes out.

miru
04-07-2013, 10:27 PM
Bebop and Rocksteady were once accomplices of Al Capone, who were killed on a vacation to Africa.

Ninjara was once a female warrior who defied her parents and fell on her own sword.

Mondo Gecko was once the inventor of the skateboard

Quarry was once an entomologist who died in a famine caused by locusts.

Venus was once the daughter of Tang, who did not live long compared to her brothers.

Mona Lisa was a scientist killed in Hiroshima.

Martin
04-07-2013, 10:47 PM
The whole point of Old Hob tracking down Splinter in the present day was because they needed his blood to recreate the psychotropic serum. Krang even asks Stockman why can't he use Old Hob's blood to recreate the serum, and Stockman says he can't use it because Old Hob and the Turtles were exposed to a contaminated ssrum while Splinter received controlled injections of uncontaminated serum. In the 14 months prior scene, Chet says he doesn't like testing an impure sample. We know the super soldier mutagen is created from the Utrom ooze, so the injection from Old Hob's blood has to be the recreated psychotropic serum

Yep, you are right. I just remembered that conversation that Krang had with Baxter and it all makes sense now. Although I'm still hoping for some redemption with my ooze theory xD

Bebop and Rocksteady were once accomplices of Al Capone, who were killed on a vacation to Africa

Bebop and Rocksteady were humans before being mutated in this run :trazz:

miru
04-12-2013, 04:18 PM
Tokka was a mountain climber who fell.onto spikes.


Dogpound was a karate master who lost his arms to.pirates.

Fishface was a marooned pirate.


Newtralizer was a nerdy vigilante who.killed himself when he found his favorite character from some show would not be getting a toy.

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-16-2013, 02:53 PM
Tokka was a mountain climber who fell.onto spikes.


Dogpound was a karate master who lost his arms to.pirates.

Fishface was a marooned pirate.


Newtralizer was a nerdy vigilante who.killed himself when he found his favorite character from some show would not be getting a toy.

Some of those are downright silly. Not every mutant has to have a past life. I just think it could make an interesting backstory for some of them. :tgrumble:

And no, I do not believe the turtles being reincarnated makes them 'less special', or 'takes away from them' in any way. They are still teenagers, they are still mutant turtles transformed on an alley floor by a strange green glowing ooze, and trained by a rat named Splinter. Failing to see how being reincarnations ruins that.

miru
04-27-2013, 10:06 AM
Dirtbag: Prospector killed by bandits.

Groundchuck: "black knight" who fell.to a bovine.

Snakeweed: 1930's adventurer who fell.victim to poisonous plants.

Pterobat
04-30-2013, 06:16 PM
I haven't read the IDW comics yet, but the concept of the reincarnation bugs some because one of the cool things about the Turtles was the way they formed their own family of unrelated people and species.

When so much of media focuses on biological family being the only "real" family, it's nice to have an alternative that tells you a family can come from the strangest of circumstances and be no less strong, that it can be formed across species lines.

The reincarnation origin would run headfirst into that cliche...that Splinter and the Turtles become family because they were a biological human family in a past life, and not because they formed a bond out of whole cloth.

However well IDW pulls that off, the principle remains for some readers, because it's not just a matter of how well something is written or portrayed.

Andrew NDB
04-30-2013, 06:32 PM
And no, I do not believe the turtles being reincarnated makes them 'less special', or 'takes away from them' in any way. They are still teenagers, they are still mutant turtles transformed on an alley floor by a strange green glowing ooze, and trained by a rat named Splinter. Failing to see how being reincarnations ruins that.

Well, the idea is that by proceeding with that angle, somehow being teenaged mutant ninjas that are turtles growing up in a sewer somehow must not be "enough" for TPTB at IDW, that a whole layer of a past life and the grandfathered memories therein must be caked on top of it to make the Turtles compelling. I get the argument, but I largely appreciate the angle and as long as it doesn't get out of hand.

Galactus
04-30-2013, 07:25 PM
Well, the idea is that by proceeding with that angle, somehow being teenaged mutant ninjas that are turtles growing up in a sewer somehow must not be "enough" for TPTB at IDW, that a whole layer of a past life and the grandfathered memories therein must be caked on top of it to make the Turtles compelling. I get the argument, but I largely appreciate the angle and as long as it doesn't get out of hand.

Well quite a few remakes and reimaginings temd to try and come up with some new compelling twist.

Not to mention the two new twists are neatly shuts down the "how can a rat know ninjitsu?" crowd.

Panda_Kahn_fan
04-30-2013, 11:36 PM
Well, the idea is that by proceeding with that angle, somehow being teenaged mutant ninjas that are turtles growing up in a sewer somehow must not be "enough" for TPTB at IDW, that a whole layer of a past life and the grandfathered memories therein must be caked on top of it to make the Turtles compelling. I get the argument, but I largely appreciate the angle and as long as it doesn't get out of hand.

I can agree it shouldn't get out of hand, but I don't think it 'needed' to be added, but it does add something to the mythos while not changing it to the point of, asy, another turtle suddenly having been there at the mutation, washing downstrem, and found and raised by another ninja master.

Personally, I think if they had just made Splinter the reincarnation and not the turtles, a lot of people would be a lot less upset about it. It's a nice meger of the OT/Archie orgin with the Mirage/2k3 one (being a ratpre-mutation and Yoshi at the same time), plus, as the previous poster stated, it kills the 'rat knowing martial arts' quandry.

Cipher
05-01-2013, 12:20 AM
I haven't read the IDW comics yet, but the concept of the reincarnation bugs some because one of the cool things about the Turtles was the way they formed their own family of unrelated people and species.
I completely agree with this. The adopted family aspect has been one of the larger and more charming parts of other Turtles media, particularly later Mirage, and it's one I feel is more central to the concept than a lot of more superficial pieces of the origin. I was actually hoping for a while that IDW would reveal Splinter's memories to be false, and they'd have to deal with the idea that they weren't, in fact, reincarnated or even related.

Secret History of the Foot Clan all but put that theory in the ground, though, and that's okay too. The reincarnation angle is something I can live with, and it's definitely being used interestingly. It just isn't something I'd ever favor and I'm not sure that, plot points aside, it adds anything meaningful to the story.

ShindoNinja
05-03-2013, 02:42 PM
I like the twist in the origins. I've been away from comics in general for the last 20 years! I had some original books as a kid and then collected until my early teens. For me, I am loving the art and the story of the IDW books. They've put some thought into it and it shows.

My wife is not a comic person and she thinks the re-incarnation make it "more believable"... but still not! haha.

TomWaltz
05-03-2013, 04:02 PM
I like the twist in the origins. I've been away from comics in general for the last 20 years! I had some original books as a kid and then collected until my early teens. For me, I am loving the art and the story of the IDW books. They've put some thought into it and it shows.

My wife is not a comic person and she thinks the re-incarnation make it "more believable"... but still not! haha.

Please tell your wife she made me smile!

:tgrin:

CyberCubed
05-03-2013, 08:14 PM
I love the reincarnation aspect with Splinter and Shredder, and I imagine most feel the same there.

Its only with the Turtles that people feel slightly bothered. Simply because the Turtles never had anything to do with humans in any past series, and the Turtles being mutants were always animals turned intelligent, rather than humans turned into animal mutants (like Bebop and Rocksteady, etc.)

Obviously at this point I've accepted it, but I still kinda wish the reincarnation only dealt with Splinter and Shredder...but the Turtles origins were the same as we're used to from Mirage/4kids/Original toon even Nick.

dawwe
05-04-2013, 08:30 PM
I don't really mind the whole reincarnation thing, it's a fresh new take on the back story and opens up alot of possibilities. Not saying it's my favorite version or anything but it does work well.

Cryomancer
05-04-2013, 08:37 PM
I like that the turtles themselves at least have mixed feelings about it, different levels of believing it / caring about it. If they were all totally into it unquestionably it would be pretty grating.