View Full Version : Duoshade issue in Ultimate Collection Volume 4
liugeaux
04-12-2013, 10:10 PM
So I pointed out this duoshade issue with the old reprint of Mirage's #5 a few weeks back in this thread.
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=41901
Well, that exact shading problem is also in IDW's brand new Ultimate Collection Vol. 4. Check the images below:
http://i160.photobucket.com/albums/t187/liugeaux/2013-04-12202136_zps178f18d7.jpg
http://i160.photobucket.com/albums/t187/liugeaux/2013-04-12202249-1_zps33506fa7.jpg
http://i160.photobucket.com/albums/t187/liugeaux/2013-04-12202517_zpsa7ce8f16.jpg
I basically just picked three random pages from the three books that didn't have the duoshade on them, but its not just those pages. The entirety of issues 49, 53 and 54 have no shades on them. The rest of the books look fine. Can anyone explain this stuff? Bobby? Anyone?
My gut says to blame IDW, but since this happened in a previous Mirage book, could it be possible that Mirage provided IDW with the un-shaded scans of these books? This is getting weird.
CyberCubed
04-12-2013, 10:12 PM
Yikes, this might make me reconsider buying the collection.
Roseangelo
04-12-2013, 10:18 PM
Wow, this is disappointing. The duo shade is pretty important for these books.
Powder
04-12-2013, 10:26 PM
It's cool to see them without the shades but that's not at all how it should be. What the hell...
Bobby Curnow
04-12-2013, 10:32 PM
All I know is that our files are what Nick got from Mirage.
That sounds sort of like I'm blaming Mirage. I'm not. But that's the origin of the files.
Powder
04-12-2013, 10:43 PM
That's really strange... I wonder if they felt they would look better this way? Or are the tones missing/damaged? I guess I must be a noob because I had assumed everything was done on one particular piece of paper.
Roseangelo
04-12-2013, 10:45 PM
All I know is that our files are what Nick got from Mirage.
That sounds sort of like I'm blaming Mirage. I'm not. But that's the origin of the files.
Well, Dan is usually the first to admit that Mirage's archives were never very great in the first place. So it's not incredibly surprising that this oversight exists, but it's still incredibly disappointing. And just weird. Hmm.
CyberCubed
04-12-2013, 11:07 PM
Could you post more photo comparisons of different pages?
Ah, that's not good, I had plans for buying the whole ultimate collection later, but this kinda dissapoints me... :ohwell:
Oculus Orbus
04-13-2013, 08:29 AM
Oh man, that's very very sad. You would have thought that IDW checked the actual issues before making their "ultimate" collections. I've only bought Volume 1 so far (regular edition, LBCC Exclusive and Black Label) and the quality of the scans is just awful. I was planning to get all the others later as a set, but it just keeps getting worse.
All I know is that our files are what Nick got from Mirage.
That sounds sort of like I'm blaming Mirage. I'm not. But that's the origin of the files.
Bobby, I think most of us understand that the files you received are probably far from perfect, but you guys at IDW know how to produce high end books better that anyone else in the business today. Whenever something like this happens, I just feel like it's a missed opportunity. I appreciate all the hard work that goes into making this collections, and they're great, but this little things are very disappointing.
HotJuicyBurgers
04-13-2013, 09:09 AM
Volume 4 is even out? I haven't received mine from amazon yet...
Shreddhead
04-13-2013, 09:44 AM
Ouch, I'll pass.
Though it'd make one hell of a coloring book.
frank_one
04-13-2013, 11:12 AM
Well, at least we are gonna see how the inks look without the duoshade toning, for the first time. I could buy it just for that.
liugeaux
04-13-2013, 11:19 AM
Yeah its a disappointing, but I still really dig the Ultimate Collections. I don't see any other quality problems with them and I totally believe that Nick dumped whatever they had on IDWs desk and basically said, "here, you figure it out." This is definitely not the most disappointing thing to come out of TMNT, and strangely enough works as a greater metaphor for Mirage's independent publishing history and practice more than anything.
We can hope that when IDW inevitably releases a dedicated City at War trade or hardcover, that this issue is fixed, but it would probably be more trouble than its worth.
CyberCubed
04-13-2013, 12:05 PM
The Foot Soldier fight is where the lack of duo shade looks disappointing the most.
Matches Malone
04-13-2013, 12:56 PM
Seems unlikely, but hopefully a recall could happen in the future to replace these if a more complete version is ever acquired and produced? I already purchased mine and I don't think I'll be returning it, but there is no question that this is disappointing for fans who are excited to have City At War collected for the first time only to have an incomplete reading experience when compared to the original issues. There's no denying how important that signature shading is for these black & white books. It's what makes all the difference between black & white art and art that just hasn't been colored.
We can hope that when IDW inevitably releases a dedicated City at War trade or hardcover, that this issue is fixed, but it would probably be more trouble than its worth.
Another thing which would be cool is City at War issues re-released as colored classics.
A nicely done coloring would be an okay replacement of the duo shades, in case Mirage actually lost the duo shaded originals.
Shreddhead
04-13-2013, 01:03 PM
Another thing which would be cool is City at War issues re-released as colored classics.
A nicely done coloring would be an okay replacement of the duo shades, in case Mirage actually lost the duo shaded originals.
I'd like to see that. If IDW actually noticed the lack of shading before they released this collection, then they should have gone with a colored classic collection instead of this.
The more I look at it, the flatter that foot soldier battle looks.
Oculus Orbus
04-13-2013, 02:17 PM
Another thing which would be cool is City at War issues re-released as colored classics.
A nicely done coloring would be an okay replacement of the duo shades, in case Mirage actually lost the duo shaded originals.
Given the lack of attention put into the Color Classics reprints, I wouldn't count on a nicely done coloring replacement.
CyberCubed
04-13-2013, 02:22 PM
Shredder still has an all blue bodysuit in the color reprints, see the #10 preview images.
Cipher
04-13-2013, 05:00 PM
Damn, man. At least I have the original issues. This isn't a deal breaker, but it is a shame. This is the best run of Turtles issues ever published, and it's rough to see them first exposed to a larger audience with anything other than a perfect presentation.
I'm guessing this is on Mirage's end and they didn't have ... what? Toned master copies or something? (Whatever the process is here.) It's too bad it wasn't caught earlier though, so they could have used complete scans.
I'm probably one of three fans who likes the colored editions though, so here's hoping they get to City at War down the road. Whatever the case, I hope IDW isn't discouraged from doing another stand-alone trade for this story arc at some point.
CyberCubed
04-13-2013, 05:25 PM
I wonder if there's any chance of a new re-release.
Demon-Alukard
04-13-2013, 11:11 PM
A few years ago Spain publishing (Norma Editorial) reprinted Vol.1 (with the remake of TMNT vol.1 #8 ). So, there was the same situation - some of the City at War issues was published without duoshade tones.
It was issues #49, #53, #54.
Andrew NDB
04-14-2013, 12:27 AM
Definitely count me out if there's no duoshade. I would guess that either the files sent were just the raw inks pre-duoshade or the duoshade degraded over time (it does) and vanished, but either way this should have been caught and either A) Mirage/Peter/Gary Richardson solicited for the "right" files, or B) Quality scans of the pages with duotones should have been done and used.
Very, very sad and sucks a huge amount of the wind out of the whole "City at War will finally be collected!" balloon.
CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 12:36 AM
I wonder if there is enough complaints we could get IDW to re-release this with the correct duoshade version?
Given how many variants they put out of their collections already, and all the alternate covers....this collection re-released with a duoshade print shouldn't be out of the question.
Shreddhead
04-14-2013, 12:42 AM
I wonder if there is enough complaints we could get IDW to re-release this with the correct duoshade version?
Given how many variants they put out of their collections already, and all the alternate covers....this collection re-released with a duoshade print shouldn't be out of the question.
My question is how many fans new to the mirage city at war are seeing this for the first time and getting the wrong impression. It seriously looks like an adult coloring book... If i didnt own my individual issues and this was my introduction, this would not be my favorite turtle comic story arc,
Andrew NDB
04-14-2013, 01:00 AM
Pretty much a great big "yikes!" on multiple levels. I'm not sure how this could have happened.
Martin
04-14-2013, 01:18 AM
I guess I'll be cancelling my order then. It's a shame since I was hoping for a complete set but this is kind of a deal breaker :S
I guess I'll just have to get the city at war standalone collection that IDW will eventually put out. Still, yikes. I'really dissapointed. Can somebody tell me what other issues were included in this book? So I know what else I'll be missing.
Cipher
04-14-2013, 01:40 AM
I guess I'll just have to get the city at war standalone collection that IDW will eventually put out.
As hypothetical as that already is, I'd be even more concerned about it if enough fans feel the way you do, or are turned off by the sans-duoshade art once they read it.
Hey, IDW guys, are you reading?
Can somebody tell me what other issues were included in this book? So I know what else I'll be missing.The two Shades of Grey issues I believe.
Oculus Orbus
04-14-2013, 05:39 AM
A few years ago Spain publishing (Norma Editorial) reprinted Vol.1 (with the remake of TMNT vol.1 #8 ). So, there was the same situation - some of the City at War issues was published without duoshade tones.
It was issues #49, #53, #54.
I've got those, and it was really bad that they were missing the duoshade, but they're tiny, softcover, cheap trades. It was easier to overlook its many flaws (and they included the remake of issue 8).
All I know is that our files are what Nick got from Mirage.
That sounds sort of like I'm blaming Mirage. I'm not. But that's the origin of the files.
Any chance you could get someone to double-check your files for these kinds of errors before you go to print in the future? O_o I feel cheated.
CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 12:59 PM
So is there any chance for a re-release?
Jay $tarkiller
04-14-2013, 02:35 PM
Wow, this is disappointing. The duo shade is pretty important for these books.
pretty important is actually an understatement..Mirage Turtles bleed duo shade..no duo-shade is an absolute no-no:tsad:
Ah, that's not good, I had plans for buying the whole ultimate collection later, but this kinda dissapoints me... :ohwell:
Me too, buddy, me too. But I'm definitely not buying this crap:tmad: The art simply looks kinda flat, withouth depth
CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 03:47 PM
Is anyone going to try and contact IDW about this? Posting on forums they don't read isn't going to accomplish anything.
Shreddhead
04-14-2013, 04:26 PM
Is anyone going to try and contact IDW about this? Posting on forums they don't read isn't going to accomplish anything.
Back on the first page...
All I know is that our files are what Nick got from Mirage.
That sounds sort of like I'm blaming Mirage. I'm not. But that's the origin of the files.
CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 05:14 PM
Can't they just scan the pages from the individual City at War issues though?
Toby Barrett
04-14-2013, 09:14 PM
http://img6.imageshack.us/img6/5908/buhk.png
CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 09:31 PM
Damn, man. At least I have the original issues. This isn't a deal breaker, but it is a shame.
It is a deal breaker. I really don't see myself purchasing this collection, or the next one, if it isn't how it was originally presented.
Its a shame with how well IDW has handled the TMNT franchise in terms of new stuff, but the reprints of the old Mirage and Archie material just feel like they're handled with little care.
Cipher
04-14-2013, 09:39 PM
It is a deal breaker.
Okay. For you.
But yeah, I hope whatever happens, even if a number of people don't buy this book, IDW still sees fit to return and do a stand-alone trade of this arc. It really needs to get into the hands of more people, review sites, etc.
CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 09:44 PM
Okay. For you.
Well I believe one of the users said it best, "It looks like an adult coloring book."
Most of us already own these issues already, so paying a lot of money for an inferior collection makes little to no sense.
Cipher
04-14-2013, 09:50 PM
Well I believe one of the users said it best, "It looks like an adult coloring book."
Most of us already own these issues already, so paying a lot of money for an inferior collection makes little to no sense.
I own the issues as well, but vastly prefer reading trades and hardcovers. If three-fourths of the issues look fine, I can give it a begrudging pass.
Mostly, though, I'm still just happy to see "City at War" collected in any form. I'll double dip if a complete version comes out, and I really, really hope it does.
CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 09:53 PM
I'll double dip if a complete version comes out, and I really, really hope it does.
If that happens it'll all be water under the bridge, but we have no idea if we'll get the correct version with duotones released. And what about Ultimate Collection 5 that finishes City at War? Will that have duotones?
Mine is already on the way from Amazon, so I guess I'm stuck with this.
What I don't understand is why IDW didn't let people know about this. It's a pretty big defect to the collection. I'll definitely be considering returning this to Amazon since I already have the original issues. I mainly bought these because I really like the Ultimate Collection format for reading. Then again, I already have the first three collections so I'll probably end up keeping the fourth.
And what about Ultimate Collection 5 that finishes City at War? Will that have duotones?
That's a good point. Hopefully someone from IDW can clarify the situation with volume 5.
Plasticplayhouse
04-15-2013, 08:13 AM
i actually think its pretty cool seeing the untoned pages. i'd bet that these were the scans Keith Aiken (the inker) provided mirage with after he inked over jim's pencils. i'm not sure who toned the pages. could've been keith or jim. mirage probably had scans of both the toned and untoned pages at one point and may have deleted the scans of the toned by accident thinking/assunming they had a double copy of the files.
Hardshell
04-15-2013, 09:32 AM
Disappointing but not a deal breaker for me. Bought and enjoyed. A lot of stuff that's new to me in here. Can't wait for Vol. 5.
Not IDW's fault, anyway. This is what they have to work with from Mirage.
Crabfight
04-15-2013, 10:41 AM
Well...crap.
This'll be my first reading of City at War, so I'm pretty disappointed that I'm not going to be getting it in its original form. That being said, I want to read it bad enough and the UC is just too convenient for me to cancel.
Are the pages that are printed without the duoshade seemingly random? Is there any rhyme or reason as to which ones have it left out? Or am I just going to get unexpectedly bashed over the head with a weaker page every so often?
liugeaux
04-15-2013, 10:44 AM
And what about Ultimate Collection 5 that finishes City at War? Will that have duotones?
I'm sure it depends on the files from Nick, maybe its not too late to have them double check with Nick and/or Mirage for the correct ones in #5 but I doubt we'll see an update to #4.
CyberCubed
04-15-2013, 12:11 PM
This might sound like a conspiracy theory, but does anyone think they purposely released it without duotones first, just so they can re-release it with duotones as a "special edition" and cause people to double-dip?
I think, as a big comic publisher they know enough to understand how destructive bad publicity can be. So I'd doubt it.
When it's all said and done. it's definitely IDW's fault that they haven't hired a competent employee to catch these mistakes, and oversee the whole production. But it's a forgiveable mistake, since when you got the files straight from Mirage, and you change nothing, you simple wouldn't suspect that they sent you something wrong.
Still, IDW could hire someone who would examine the release material more deeply, before they send it for printing. This would also help to catch the coloring mistakes in the colored classics series.
Matches Malone
04-15-2013, 02:26 PM
Is anyone going to try and contact IDW about this? Posting on forums they don't read isn't going to accomplish anything.
Bobby has stated before that the best chance of contacting and affecting change in the reprint depart is to write to:
[email protected]. Perhaps someone can start a new thread and take the lead in an organized effort to mass email them letting them know that this issue is disappointing enough to warrant a recall, or at the very least, a corrected version to be made available. I would, but I definitely don't have time at the moment.
Okay. For you.
He tends to forget that part...
This might sound like a conspiracy theory, but does anyone think they purposely released it without duotones first, just so they can re-release it with duotones as a "special edition" and cause people to double-dip?
It is a conspiracy theory. However, we didn't see this with the other issues that have been shown to be missing duotones in previous reprints (like #5), so I'd say it's not likely. IDW so far has been pretty transparent in there willingness to cause people to double dip (see color classics, the works tpb, etc.)
Metropoliskid41
04-15-2013, 10:55 PM
I really can't believe no one has brought this up at all over at IDW's Boards in the TMNT or the Letters section. I'm sure IDW can't comment until they look into it further, and they can't do any finger pointing or throw anyone under the bus, but damn this is disappointing. I'm was going to wait until FCBD to pick up Volume 4 at a huge discount at the sale at my local shop. I'm hoping IDW has some official stance or statement regarding this by then, I'm not going to buy Volume 4 if a new duotone version is going to be produced. I doubt they could do a recall on the books already out there, that's a huge money loss for them to take on Hardcovers.
Major Bummer.
CyberCubed
04-15-2013, 11:08 PM
IDW doesn't have a good track records with trades so far, but this is probably the worst case scenario especially for these issues.
Turns
04-16-2013, 04:20 AM
I gave it a poor review on amazon and said that I intend to return the book and boycott it until the time of a proper release (which is true). Hopefully if enough people do the same IDW will have no choice but to do it right.
Metropoliskid41
04-16-2013, 11:49 AM
IDW doesn't have a good track records with trades so far, but this is probably the worst case scenario especially for these issues.
You need to be a little more specific on that, IDW has put out a lot of great collected editions for their other properties, with both their new stuff & older pre-IDW runs. Their collections of GI JOE and all of the artist editions has been awesome. I wouldn't go say they have a bad track record just yet based solely on Ultimate Collection vol. 4 & the first few volumes of TMNT Adventures.
funatic
04-16-2013, 04:28 PM
Bummer. :tsad: I'm torn on whether or not to get this now. I already have the original issues, so it'd just be for the sake of them being collected together. I doubt they will do a reissue, tho what do you guys think the odds are of these being released collected again in a different format? I wonder if the color classics trades will make it this far?
CyberCubed
04-16-2013, 04:51 PM
Looks like Ultimate Collection #3 is my last collection thus far. Probably won't get this one or the next unless they're reprinted properly.
I just can't see it, because then I know in a few years it'll probably get another re-release and I'll have to sell this outdated copy that nobody will want.
twopinacoladas
04-18-2013, 05:07 AM
Mine came in from Amazon yesterday, I noticed a couple issues lacked tones tho others have them. I thought they all had them originally and this confirms it (I didn't have time to check for sure). Its disapointing, I perhaps Mirage had other files that didn't get sent over. Files for just inks and files for shadded final issues that would have been sent to the printer and they just didn't get the right ones... I do really like Jims artwork in it when flipping through.
liugeaux
04-18-2013, 01:29 PM
The really weird thing is I flipped through my copy of Ultimate Collection 3 and found a few issues that initially looked like they were missing shades, but when I checked them against my original printings they look identical. I think #15 was the best example. I'm not an artist, but it definitely looks like Duoshade was not used on that issue, or at least it was used to a lesser extent.
Metropoliskid41
04-18-2013, 01:46 PM
The really weird thing is I flipped through my copy of Ultimate Collection 3 and found a few issues that initially looked like they were missing shades, but when I checked them against my original printings they look identical. I think #15 was the best example. I'm not an artist, but it definitely looks like Duoshade was not used on that issue, or at least it was used to a lesser extent.
Is your copy of issue #15 a first print? There was another thread floating around here where it was pointed out that a couple of issues didn't have the duo shades in the 2nd printings of the single issues, even though the 1st printings did. Issue #5 was the issue I believe in the thread, but #15 might fall into that category as well.
liugeaux
04-18-2013, 02:46 PM
Yeah I actually started that thread about #5...lol. #15 only had 1 printing, so its definitely not a print run issue on the original.
Matches Malone
04-18-2013, 06:53 PM
The really weird thing is I flipped through my copy of Ultimate Collection 3 and found a few issues that initially looked like they were missing shades, but when I checked them against my original printings they look identical. I think #15 was the best example. I'm not an artist, but it definitely looks like Duoshade was not used on that issue, or at least it was used to a lesser extent.
I think part of the reason for that is this was a Peter Laird solo issue, and Laird's style is much less "sketchy" than Eastman's. Probably even more so now.
CyberCubed
04-18-2013, 09:35 PM
Hm, maybe when Ultimate Collection 5 comes out they could re-print more copies of the fourth were with duotones, as that might be the only chance.
Don't they still put out copies of Ultimate Collections 1-3? Or do they stop printing them after a certain time?
Matches Malone
04-19-2013, 12:24 AM
Bobby's comments on the matter. I'll be taking 10 seconds to send an email; we all should! A really good fan with extra copies of the issues in question could even mail them in to IDW!
I think they're selling well. Vol. 1 has had a couple printings I think. But a Vol. 1 is very different from a Vol. 4. Lots of people might get a Vol. 1 to dip their toes, or get as a present, etc. I don't recall anyone talking about a Vol. 2 second print, but maybe there has been.
Not to say that Vol. 4 WON'T get another print. But I wouldn't count on it. Even if there was another print, I can't say the issue would be fixed— we'd need to buy and scan the issues, which is fair investment of time on a packed production schedule.
Writing some letters to
[email protected] would certainly help. I've brought the issue up, but if there's a good bunch of letters, showing that fans really care about this, that could have an impact, maybe.
funatic
04-19-2013, 01:13 AM
Sent my email, and included a link to this thread to see the differences in art (and our disappointment).
Sent my email, and included a link to this thread to see the differences in art (and our disappointment).
I did the same. Even though they typically don't reply, I hope that Bobby Curnow is right that these emails are being read and considered.
TonySiegel
04-19-2013, 10:01 AM
this is bullsh*t! I have the first 2 volumes and am planning to get the 3rd don't know about the 4th now...
Grrrr....
liugeaux
04-19-2013, 12:01 PM
My email is sent, with an explanation, link to this thread and an offer to provide them with the original books. I don't really expect it to go anywhere, but as a fan, I'm kinda obligated to send that email. Otherwise why even mention it on this forum.
Matches Malone
04-19-2013, 03:00 PM
Keep sending them! Bobby says they've already received some emails, and I think this is an issue that may actually be heard as opposed to the whole 4-issue trades thing.
CyberCubed
04-19-2013, 03:19 PM
Well since it was an honest mistake I hope they would rectify it with future printings. Not sure if this would cost them more money or not but it goes to show you, you should double check everything to make sure its right before sending it off to the printer.
Matches Malone
04-19-2013, 03:37 PM
Well since it was an honest mistake I hope they would rectify it with future printings. Not sure if this would cost them more money or not but it goes to show you, you should double check everything to make sure its right before sending it off to the printer.
Yeah, I think Bobby was saying that they may not do another printing because it may not sell enough. But since this mistake is significant, I suggested in my email that even a limited reprinting would be greatly appreciated by fans. It's also possible that IDW limited will continue releasing their labels of Ultimate Collection volumes, so it may be corrected there. However, those are obviously a whole different price range, so here's hoping a corrected version will be available and affordable.
CyberCubed
04-19-2013, 11:18 PM
Perhaps a later edition can be called, "Ultimate Collection #4 duoshade collectors edition" or something, lol.
As you said given how many versions there are of Ultimate Collection already with alternate covers or labels, something like this could happen.
twopinacoladas
04-20-2013, 01:06 AM
I believe I pre ordered mine in the late fall and I think the release date just kept getting pushed back. I was assuming it was taking so long because they wanted the quality to be very good, I thought they might actually have to scan the books and clean up pages or something to that effect. It shows that I guess that wasn't the case.
I thought book 1 was not printed dark enough but the first 3 books I had been pretty happy with. I haven't read the City At War arc since 2004. It is annoying that the issues are not presented properly. I had double checked and it seemed more issues than I originally thought were lacking tones. E&L's #50 looks great tho in contrast to the ones lacking.
I still enjoy Jims work as I said before its to bad the tones are absent... at least they are collected I suppose but if they reprint it I don't know that I want to buy another book when the first one I got has the errors. I do wonder how no one at IDW noticed it tho, I noticed it right away and I haven't looked at the issues in almost 10 years. I would have thought at least someone there would be a little more familiar with the comics to catch it during quality control. IDW is a comic company after all you would think someone there would pick up on it or at least wonder why some issues had them and some do not.
CyberCubed
04-20-2013, 12:03 PM
The reason I'm not ordering yet is just so I don't have to double-dip.
If I order it how do I know the corrected version won't come out a few months from now, and I'll be stuck with an obsolete copy?
liugeaux
04-20-2013, 12:13 PM
The reason I'm not ordering yet is just so I don't have to double-dip.
If I order it how do I know the corrected version won't come out a few months from now, and I'll be stuck with an obsolete copy?
No one is forcing you to double dip, but I wouldn't hold my breath dude. A corrected printing is long shot at best.
Actually...saying its a long shot is lending too much credence to the possibility of them fixing the problem. Its not going to happen in this run of books.
If you want a complete Ultimate Collection you will buy this version.
darthsmozers
04-23-2013, 07:29 AM
I gave it a poor review on amazon and said that I intend to return the book and boycott it until the time of a proper release (which is true). Hopefully if enough people do the same IDW will have no choice but to do it right.
Sounds a little dramatic ... "boycott"?
These books are old. If its all IDW has to work with, then what else can ya do?
Though I suppose since the original books are floating around out there, there isn't much of an excuse. But would people really just want scans of existing old books if that's all that were available?
Cipher
04-23-2013, 08:09 AM
But would people really just want scans of existing old books if that's all that were available?
Yes.
10char
zodach
04-23-2013, 09:57 AM
Maybe they can correct it for the IDW Limited Ultimate Collection volume 4 sets. They won't be available for quite some time since they're just wrapping up volume 2, but it would be nice if they made the changes by then.
Allio
04-23-2013, 04:23 PM
I went ahead and picked it up, the duoshade issue doesn't bother me much...it gives those issues...a different look
Abnormal Freak
04-24-2013, 06:15 AM
All I know is that our files are what Nick got from Mirage.
This has been IDW's mistake from the very beginning of the Ultimate Collection reprints. Mirage's scans are lousy and it's really too bad IDW didn't do their own scans and cleanup work. Relying on ancient and poorly-done scans for lavishly-packaged reprints doesn't make any sense.
Issue #1 from the first collection has missing/faded tones and a general blurriness; other issues have pixelated line art; now there are issues with missing tones altogether. This isn't the way to treat the material.
Bobby, is there any way you can tell the reprint guys to get their s*** together? :S I want so bad to own all the Ultimate Collections, but not when the reproductions are so poor. They oughta go back and do a totally revised line with proper quality control, though I guess that won't happen any time soon.
Navin Johnson
04-24-2013, 07:56 AM
I just cancelled my order....
Cipher
04-25-2013, 05:51 PM
Got it today.
Guys, buy this book. Buy this book. Buy this book.
I can honestly say the missing tones, while disappointing, don't horribly matter outside #53. They're sorely missed in that one, as the inking during the action scene gets pretty sparse. The other issues they're missing from happen to be more heavily inked though, so outside of a few panels, you'd never know they were there in the first place.
If you've never read it, double-super-buy this book, because you're depriving yourself of the single best piece of writing to ever bear the TMNT name. Every time I come back to this storyline I'm worried it won't hold up, and every time I'm proven dead wrong. The writing is still so good you'll be able to overlook the tone flaw. And the bonus content is as great as ever. I am incredibly happy to finally own this in collected form and be able to point new readers toward this arc. Because anyone looking to try the Mirage TMNT -- forget Vol. 1 #1. This is where they should start.
IDW needs to reprint this thing as a standalone book down the line, because it really does make a great hook for potential readers. They can and should fix the tone mistakes then as well, depending on the level of scans they can drum up.
But guys, until then, give this book your hard-earned money. It deserves it.
CyberCubed
04-25-2013, 05:57 PM
I already have the individual issues so I am in no rush. I just can't justify spending $30 or so on an inferior copy.
Hell I would have taken these issues colored over this.
Abnormal Freak
04-25-2013, 11:11 PM
I'll keep my hard-earned cash in my pocket rather than spend it on mediocrity. I, too, have the original comics and won't support a poor product.
CyberCubed
04-25-2013, 11:15 PM
I'll keep my hard-earned cash in my pocket rather than spend it on mediocrity. I, too, have the original comics and won't support a poor product.
Agreed, supporting it kind of gives the impression that people "don't mind" these releases and are what they're fine with. I am not blaming anyone at IDW as I know they were unaware of this, but its still a shame.
I do have the first 3 Ultimate Collections but now its going to look really odd with the first 3 but not the last two. Hopefully #5 is printed properly.
twopinacoladas
04-27-2013, 01:54 AM
CyberCubed, I hope they print #5 properly as well they know of the issues from this print and there should be no excuses. I think I have 5 preordered allready. Had I known in advance I may have cancelled my preorder on book 4. While its disapointing I am not overly PO'd. This certainly shouldn't happen again tho.
CyberCubed
04-27-2013, 08:36 AM
I just wish they could do a limited re-print of Collection 4 for hardcore TMNT fans.
Its not like the casuals know any better so it doesn't make a difference to them.
Allio
04-27-2013, 12:50 PM
let me just ask this, something that gets on my mind with stuff like this
if you already have the original issues, why do you want to get the ultimate collection? you get the exact same thing...I see it as just a waste of money
CyberCubed
04-27-2013, 01:06 PM
let me just ask this, something that gets on my mind with stuff like this
if you already have the original issues, why do you want to get the ultimate collection? you get the exact same thing...I see it as just a waste of money
People buy collections for reading, better quality paper and ease of storage.
frank_one
04-27-2013, 01:36 PM
let me just ask this, something that gets on my mind with stuff like this
if you already have the original issues, why do you want to get the ultimate collection? you get the exact same thing...I see it as just a waste of money
These books are oversized hardcover and contain new notes by Eastman and Laird.
mgambino
04-27-2013, 02:40 PM
Just got my copy today. The lack of shading doesn't really bother me that much. Sure, I'd like to see the issues as they were intended, but the story/art is the same either way and I don't have the original issues.
CyberCubed
04-27-2013, 03:07 PM
I don't see how anyone who actually owns the original issues can say it doesn't look much worse.
Without the duoshades the art has no depth, the story loses its impact and it looks like an adult coloring book. It is inferior and ruined.
Doesn't matter for casuals who never read it before but for us its disappointing.
Abnormal Freak
04-30-2013, 01:44 AM
let me just ask this, something that gets on my mind with stuff like this
if you already have the original issues, why do you want to get the ultimate collection? you get the exact same thing...I see it as just a waste of money
As mentioned, ease of readability/access/storage, higher quality paper stock, multiple issues in one book (no opening and sealing an individual bag and putting that back in the comic box), extras, sleek hardcover format, oversized print.
It would be the perfect format if only the actual issue scans were any good, and I don't just mean this problem of missing tones from one issue. There should have been better quality control from the get-go, especially since this is supposed to be a prestige reprinting of these issues.
Cipher
04-30-2013, 07:35 AM
I don't see how anyone who actually owns the original issues can say it doesn't look much worse.
Without the duoshades the art has no depth, the story loses its impact and it looks like an adult coloring book. It is inferior and ruined.
Doesn't matter for casuals who never read it before but for us its disappointing.
Worse? Yes.
Ruined? Nah. That's what I was trying to say in my earlier post; it's everyone's own prerogative, but, while disappointing, we all know the story behind what happened and it reads as well as ever.
You also, I'm assuming, haven't actually seen the three issues without tones in full, so let's be fair.
let me just ask this, something that gets on my mind with stuff like this
if you already have the original issues, why do you want to get the ultimate collection? you get the exact same thing...I see it as just a waste of money
Pretty much what Abnormal Freak said, both the positives and the negatives.
At the end of the day, though, it's a product that will hold up much longer than individual issues and is much easier to read. I wouldn't do it for everything, but I'm a big enough fan of the Mirage series that I don't mind double-dipping.
CyberCubed
04-30-2013, 11:39 AM
You also, I'm assuming, haven't actually seen the three issues without tones in full, so let's be fair.
It reminds me of how worse the later Volume 4 issues looked art-wise without the duotones. Remember how in early Volume 4 people were fine with the art, and around halfway through people started complaining that it looked worse?
ctt4lfecw
04-30-2013, 12:59 PM
Woot! My UC 4 came in the mail today!!
Cipher
04-30-2013, 09:01 PM
It reminds me of how worse the later Volume 4 issues looked art-wise without the duotones. Remember how in early Volume 4 people were fine with the art, and around halfway through people started complaining that it looked worse?
With the exception of #53, which I admit really does suffer without its tones, they look considerably better than latter-day Volume 4. The inking here is just a lot more detailed.
Again, side-by-side, yeah, it's a noticeable loss. But other than #53, you probably wouldn't guess they had tones in the first place, if you didn't know better.
funatic
05-02-2013, 05:52 PM
Irony:
http://s23.postimg.org/ef9ibxse3/photo.jpg
CyberCubed
05-02-2013, 05:56 PM
Man whoever first said it looks like an adult coloring book really nailed it, I can't help but think about that everytime someone posts a scan.
Perhaps IDW wants us to get out our crayola crayons and color in the classic City at War issues like we're in the early 90's again?
Cipher
05-02-2013, 07:23 PM
Man whoever first said it looks like an adult coloring book really nailed it, I can't help but think about that everytime someone posts a scan.
Perhaps IDW wants us to get out our crayola crayons and color in the classic City at War issues like we're in the early 90's again?
Really? I think that page in particular looks fine without the tones. Look at the shadows. It's striking, and honestly, I'd dare anyone to guess without prior knowledge that the page was originally intended to have any shading.
There are plenty of indie comics that use very sparse, strict black-and-white, and aren't any less appealing for it. (Scope a Love and Rockets preview on Comixology, for example. Or, hell, several issues of Tales of the TMNT Vol. 2.) Not all TMNT art works without them, but '92-'93 Lawson is in good company either way.
Yes, it's a flaw. But I think how much the art suffers without them is being blown way out of proportion.
funatic
05-02-2013, 07:42 PM
I think that page in particular looks fine without the tones.
Maybe the irony wasn't as apparent as I thought, but I shared that particular page because its an issue of Shades of Gray... without any shades of gray. :twink:
Cipher
05-02-2013, 08:04 PM
Maybe the irony wasn't as apparent as I thought, but I shared that particular page because its an issue of Shades of Gray... without any shades of gray. :twink:
Oh, no, I got that. I wasn't responding to your joke; just the "it looks like an adult coloring book" idea.
CyberCubed
05-02-2013, 10:03 PM
I hope you guys know I'm not being totally serious. I haven't ordered the book, but this is only because of a slight hope it gets re-released in a smaller print run special edition for Mirage fans.
I just hope they make sure Ultimate Collection 5 has the duotones before they go to print.
Allio
05-03-2013, 09:03 AM
Irony:
http://s23.postimg.org/ef9ibxse3/photo.jpg
Irony?
or symbolism?
XP
RaphaelsIsolation
11-25-2015, 12:19 PM
So I'm looking at getting Vol 4. for Christmas.
Has this been correct? This duoshading issue? I've never read City at War or "Shades of Grey".
I don't want this to F up my experience. The duoshading is only missing in 3 issues right?
Any insight in the last 2+ years on this would be helpful.
Mayhem
11-25-2015, 01:13 PM
Tom has already said in another thread it's not being corrected.
RaphaelsIsolation
11-25-2015, 01:44 PM
Oh well. Thanks man.
I'm still going to get it. It is still official Ultimate version. Oversized and nice.... with annotations.
So basically 2 issues in VOL 4 have some shading issues the other one isn't a problem it sounds like.
Might be kinda cool to see the pencils being inked without shades over them...? It will be alright.
I'm just happy IDW is doing all of this.
myconius
11-25-2015, 11:28 PM
Oh well. Thanks man.
I'm still going to get it. It is still official Ultimate version. Oversized and nice.... with annotations.
So basically 2 issues in VOL 4 have some shading issues the other one isn't a problem it sounds like.
Might be kinda cool to see the pencils being inked without shades over them...? It will be alright.
I'm just happy IDW is doing all of this.
i have to admit i purchased this edition when it first was released even though i have the original comics i am still happy with this edition.
the oversize is a great reading experience and the annotations definitely enhance the experience! :)
do you have vol 5 as well?
RaphaelsIsolation
11-26-2015, 09:54 AM
No I have 1-3. Just finished vol 1 for the first time.
getting 4 and 5 for christmas
ScOULaris
02-21-2018, 08:02 AM
Sorry to bump this old thread, but I was recently revisiting my Ultimate Collection books and got depressed when I hit Vol. 4. It's such a shame that there was never a re-release with the shading added back in. I know that a re-release of that scope for a big hardcover book is not trivial, but damn it this taints what is supposed to be the definitive collection for Mirage TMNT.
Man, I just can't get over it. No matter how hard I try to get over it I can't help but feel annoyed every time I see those coloring book-esque pages. It's even worse that this oversight occurred within the City at War series, arguably the best arc in all of Mirage TMNT comics.
funatic
02-21-2018, 10:03 AM
I think the ultimate collections are being re-released in TPBs now, right? Maybe you should ask Bobby if it’s a possible opportunity to fix the error.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.