PDA

View Full Version : Why the strict adherence to four-issue trades?


Cipher
04-14-2013, 09:47 PM
IDW seems to be alone in this among other major comic-book publishers. Why the strict four-issue policy with nearly no variation?

I understand that most of IDW's ongoing series structure themselves into four-issue arcs, which is fine. But it really struggles against the structure of their reprinted material. You have the Tales Vol. 1 issues, which, no question, should have been a single book. You have the ongoing Adventures series and, in the near future, Tales Vol. 2, which are going to be spread out over more than fifteen volumes each.

I have to imagine that puts a dent in sales and discourages people from trying the series, especially the reprints. DC's ongoing trades are 6-8 issues each (many more for older material) and go for the same price at most sellers. And while I think IDW's are physically better constructed and appreciate that, I really have to ask what the philosophy is behind the low amount of content and equal price.

I do realize that IDW sometimes does longer volumes, as is the case for their Marvel Transformer reprints, but that just makes it all the more baffling. Why not more often? Why not with Turtles? I'm guessing someone at the company has determined it to be the most cost-effective route, but again, looking at the competition and buyer preferences, I just can't believe that's true.

CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 09:50 PM
My guess is they think if they put too many issues in a trade, they'll "run out of" issues to collect and have nothing else to do. Which makes no sense, as they could then re-release the collections a few years from now for a new audience.

Even combining all of Mirage together, TMNT doesn't have that many issues compared to DC or Marvel properties that spanned for 25 years.

Volume 2 and Image are extremely short, as is Tales V. 1. And Volume 4 only has 31 issues.

Its really only Volume 1, Tales V. 2, and Archie that were huge...but we've managed to get through Volume 1 quickly thanks to the Ultimate Collections and Classics coming at the same time.

Cipher
04-14-2013, 09:55 PM
My guess is they think if they put too many issues in a trade, they'll "run out of" issues to collect and have nothing else to do. Which makes no sense, as they could then re-release the collections a few years from now for a new audience.
Not sure I buy that. Marvel's Transformers in its entirety is a scant 80 issues, and IDW blew through that in six volumes. They've found ways to keep releases going with further reprints and ancillary material like the UK stories.

And keeping releases going longer doesn't mean anything if the format is off-putting to potential readers.

CyberCubed
04-14-2013, 09:59 PM
There's also the possibility that IDW doesn't actually plan to collect everything, they're just collecting as they go as long as sales are stable, but they could cancel it at any time.

Its why I haven't picked up any of the Archie collections, I keep fearing it'll get canceled somewhere in the middle and then I'll just be stuck with like the first 40 issues collected but none of the others.

mrmaczaps
04-14-2013, 10:09 PM
I've stayed away from the reprinted material because of the four issue format too... I did get the ultimate books, but otherwise....

Tales vol 1 should have been one book.
Tales vol 2 is 70 issues and should be done 6-8 at a time (but isn't, I hear)...
Vol 2 could be done in 2 trades.
No idea if they will reprint vol 3...
Can the do reprints of vol 4? or with that indefinitely on hold from Peter... hopefully a print copy of issue 31 (and soon as its completed, #32) will be released in single format before they get to a trade copy...

KM3K
04-15-2013, 07:34 AM
Its why I haven't picked up any of the Archie collections, I keep fearing it'll get canceled somewhere in the middle and then I'll just be stuck with like the first 40 issues collected but none of the others.

I've done the same. I have all of the Archie individual issues, but I much prefer reading trades. However, four issues per trade at the price they want is really disconcerting. Plus I don't like the prospect of collecting only half the series in four issue trades. I figure if they ever finish collecting them, they'll put out an omnibus edition(s) of some sort like they do with Transformers and their other franchises. I'm more likely to pick up one of those.

liugeaux
04-15-2013, 10:49 AM
Its why I haven't picked up any of the Archie collections, I keep fearing it'll get canceled somewhere in the middle and then I'll just be stuck with like the first 40 issues collected but none of the others.
That's part of the problem. You not buying the trades is what's going to get them cancelled.

Metropoliskid41
04-15-2013, 11:53 AM
Every property IDW takes over they seem to have a learning curve, the first few volumes they collect seem to be lacking in extras, lower quality, less issues, and over priced. Then the 2nd time around they do an absolutely amazing job. Their work with reprinting past Transformers comics proves that. I just wish they'd full skip the dipping their toe in the water low quality step, and jump right into the high quality, bigger issue trades that are better priced and have a few extras included. I'd be all over $24 trades that collected 7 or 8 issues and had a forward by Murphy and/or Lawson. But I'm not going to pick up 20 4 issue volumes at $20 a pop, I could buy at least 2 or 3 copies of every single Archie series single issue comic for that price and have them hard bound into a hardcover myself.

CyberCubed
04-15-2013, 12:13 PM
They're already double dipping.

The color classics of #1-11 are being re-released in a trade, so we have both the Ultimate Collections of #1-11 and now a colorized version of #1-11.


I get the feeling we're going to later on see colorized versions of "Return to New York" and "City at War" because they're popular story arcs and they could make extra money with colorized versions.

gobo
04-15-2013, 12:50 PM
I get the feeling we're going to later on see colorized versions of "Return to New York" and "City at War" because they're popular story arcs and they could make extra money with colorized versions.
:teek: Holy guacamole! :o

Matches Malone
04-15-2013, 02:17 PM
I would say it's more accurately 100-115 page trades, than 4 issues. Look at the Classics TPBs, they only have 3 issues or less, with some shorts to pad it up to about 100 pages. That makes it pretty clear they are simply trying to make a page count quota.

My first gut instinct as to why is that these 100+ page books are the bare minimum to be considered as part of the "trade market" while leaving plenty more content to ration out for as long as possible. Sure there are trades at bigger and better deals, but if they can get away with it, they figure why not. It's possible that even the arbitrary 4-issue arcs is a strategy revolving around this sentiment. Of course this is just guesswork, but those are my first thoughts when thinking about it. Otherwise, why not just let the story arcs be written as short or as long as they need to be and collect accordingly?

It's tough and definitely not what we're used to with Mirage, but I'm willing to compromise a bit where it's not all bad. Even with the UC hardcovers being divided up more than they really need to be, I'm happy enough with the presentation (except for the missing duotones, of course) and extras. On the flipside, those classics trades are just not for me, even though those Dooney covers are amazing.

DK2
04-15-2013, 08:30 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by CyberCubed
Its why I haven't picked up any of the Archie collections, I keep fearing it'll get canceled somewhere in the middle and then I'll just be stuck with like the first 40 issues collected but none of the others.

liugeaux: That's part of the problem. You not buying the trades is what's going to get them cancelled.

I don't think it being cancelled will be one readers fault. Its IDW and their stupid trade philosphy. I'm not buying these either. I want to to try out Archie TMNT comics but not at these 4 issue bits. The sales may drop one day because comics stores and us loyal fans may not order or buy these anymore. Stores will get sick of "another TMNT Archie" trade. If they have no sales then they won't order it again. Simple as that. I too am baffled why IDW has done this. Transformers and GI Joe had big trades of old runs. I've seen Tales of TMNT Vol. 1 trade book 1 and thought it was pretty nice to see in color. If they do it again into one book I'd buy it. Since they split it I didn't buy it. I look forward to any color books if any one day for "Return to NY" and "City at War". Its the same with Next Men. They did 2 sets of trades for it, B&W books and now color tome trades. IDW has a habit of going back and I'll wait for when they come around on TMNT stuff as bigger compilations.

darthsmozers
04-15-2013, 09:21 PM
I find the 4-issues per trade for Archie OK so far, but after volume 5 we're going to see arcs that are some shorter and some longer than 4 issues. I am really hoping they plan these releases smartly. If we're not going to get Mutanimals mixed in (although for the 4 Horsemen arc they SHOULD include that one Mutanimals issue), we should at least not get arcs broken up.

What really stinks is no matter where the question is posted on the forum at IDW or if an email is sent, there hasn't been a reply as to whether or not the 4 issues per trade will continue despite the lengths of arcs. That's annoying.

DK2
04-15-2013, 10:16 PM
I find the 4-issues per trade for Archie OK so far, but after volume 5 we're going to see arcs that are some shorter and some longer than 4 issues. I am really hoping they plan these releases smartly. If we're not going to get Mutanimals mixed in (although for the 4 Horsemen arc they SHOULD include that one Mutanimals issue), we should at least not get arcs broken up.

What really stinks is no matter where the question is posted on the forum at IDW or if an email is sent, there hasn't been a reply as to whether or not the 4 issues per trade will continue despite the lengths of arcs. That's annoying.
I was wondering if anyone asked about this to IDW themselves. Guess they're not replying.

Cipher
04-16-2013, 04:11 AM
My first gut instinct as to why is that these 100+ page books are the bare minimum to be considered as part of the "trade market" while leaving plenty more content to ration out for as long as possible. Sure there are trades at bigger and better deals, but if they can get away with it, they figure why not.
That's the thing, though; I'm not sure they can.

I'm guessing someone at IDW is keeping tabs on sales that indicates this is a good idea, but I've only seen, anecdotally, that it isn't. You can see in this and several other threads that people are holding off on the Classics, Tales and Adventures collections because of the low page-count, and these are the die-hards. Imagine trying to sell a new or potentially curious reader on that.

I guess it applies to me personally as well. I haven't pulled the trigger on any of the Adventures trades yet because it simply takes lower precedence for me than IDW's series or Mirage. But were they to release Transformers and G.I. Joe-sized trades, that'd be a lot harder to ignore.

Maybe the roughly 100-page model works. But I get the feeling that, as far as a lot of potential buyers are concerned, they're selling nothing when they could be selling something.

Allio
04-16-2013, 06:38 AM
Meh, its fine with me... I've never had these issues before, so this is a simple way for me to get them

KM3K
04-16-2013, 07:32 AM
I was wondering if anyone asked about this to IDW themselves. Guess they're not replying.

Yes, that's correct. They don't reply. I emailed them about this (and the fact that they're only reprinting colorized versions of the comics) a couple of times at their [email protected] address that they say to e-mail, but I never received a reply.

Matches Malone
04-16-2013, 11:58 AM
That's the thing, though; I'm not sure they can.

I'm guessing someone at IDW is keeping tabs on sales that indicates this is a good idea, but I've only seen, anecdotally, that it isn't. You can see in this and several other threads that people are holding off on the Classics, Tales and Adventures collections because of the low page-count, and these are the die-hards. Imagine trying to sell a new or potentially curious reader on that.

I guess it applies to me personally as well. I haven't pulled the trigger on any of the Adventures trades yet because it simply takes lower precedence for me than IDW's series or Mirage. But were they to release Transformers and G.I. Joe-sized trades, that'd be a lot harder to ignore.

Maybe the roughly 100-page model works. But I get the feeling that, as far as a lot of potential buyers are concerned, they're selling nothing when they could be selling something.

Oh, I'm definitely not trying to say it does. I'm just saying it's reasonable to say IDW may believe it does. But I'm not crunching numbers or anything, so who knows. Sure they lose some people, but perhaps they have concluded they gain more than they lose with smaller "less intimidating" trades and that they've found a price point that makes up for any potentially lost units that would have been sold. Yeah, everybody loves a deal, but a common obstacle for new comic readers is the perceived "large backstory" they've missed and need to catch up on. A smaller book can make it feel like less of an investment to try a new book out (i.e. "sure it's overpriced, but $20 is a lot cheaper than those huge $49.99 UC books they have too. I'll give it a shot.) Again, not agreeing just exploring a scenario.

It seems like everything IDW does is very calculated (again, molding the very creative process to conform to a 4-issue arc model), so I'd say it's totally possible they've calculated this as well. If they've got hard numbers, that certainly beats any anecdotal evidence we may have on our side. IDW throws the fans a bone a good amount of time, but as I pointed out in an earlier post, they are pretty transparent about their aims to make a profit, which is admittedly a necessary aim to keep the brand well and alive. Hopefully they'll decide in the near future though, that they can afford to throw us a few more bones.

darthsmozers
04-17-2013, 09:10 PM
Yes, that's correct. They don't reply. I emailed them about this (and the fact that they're only reprinting colorized versions of the comics) a couple of times at their [email protected] address that they say to e-mail, but I never received a reply.

Same here. I had posted a thorough list of the Adventures arcs in the IDW forums where it was suggested that I email IDW my idea. I had gone through and suggested how some Adventures trades could be 4, 5, 6 etc issues long depending on arcs and filler issues, which issues of Mutanimals needed to fit in (only a few), etc. Prices could even change with issue counts if need be. It would just be dumb to have certain arcs split up just to retain the 4-issue count per book. No reply from IDW. But, I hope they are paying attention to this detail.

CyberCubed
04-21-2013, 02:44 PM
I just ordered Classics #4 and Tales #2.

Miles
04-21-2013, 03:37 PM
That's part of the problem. You not buying the trades is what's going to get them cancelled.

I can't fault him for that - I'm the same way. The decision to buy or not to buy several trade paperbacks by a handful of hardcore fans is a drop in the bucket. I can't imagine it'll make any difference.

Thing is, I wouldn't want to get stuck with a half-finished set, either. If they can't put out something - have it planned out - and see it through, then I kind of wish they just wouldn't bother at all.

As it is, I've got the whole run in .cbr format on my computer, and that's probably it for me. (Unless IDW can show me they mean business with these releases.)

:ohwell:

DK2
04-22-2013, 07:09 PM
To me in the end theres just no way I see IDW possibly finishing up the run in these 4 issue bits. And if other titles need to be included in some story arcs for TMNTA then lets hope they do it right. I mean from a direct market level I can't see most comic stores supporting this line for so many trades to the end. What would this be 20+ trades or less? So many stores are gonna stop ordering in the future and since it was a kid oriented comic this is more likely less orders. Its the superheroes that drive the market share. Looks like theres a decent few of us who aren't buying until a better gathering of this series occurs.

CyberCubed
04-22-2013, 07:11 PM
To me in the end theres just no way I see IDW possibly finishing up the run in these 4 issue bits. And if other titles need to be included in some story arcs for TMNTA then lets hope they do it right. I mean from a direct market level I can't see most comic stores supporting this line for so many trades to the end. What would this be 20+ trades or less? So many stores are gonna stop ordering in the future and since it was a kid oriented comic this is more likely less orders. Its the superheroes that drive the market share. Looks like theres a decent few of us who aren't buying until a better gathering of this series occurs.

My guess is the Archie trades will be rebranded a few years from now. As of now they're just testing the waters with them.

Its obvious IDW's priority is in collecting Mirage material, they're just putting Archie trades on the side.

gobo
04-22-2013, 07:28 PM
Why the strict adherence to four-issue trades?
Aincha heard? There's blood in them thar stones.