View Full Version : How much influence Nickelodeon have over the comic?
MikLeo
04-23-2013, 12:07 PM
Since Nickelodeon own the right to the tmnt and I know that dark horse publish the comic. I am asking this because I if any one read the origin of the foot, April and the turtles look almost like their TV's counterpart.
MikLeo
04-23-2013, 12:16 PM
dark horse? :teek:
Dark Horse Comics is the largest independent American comic book and manga publisher.
Zulithe
04-23-2013, 12:20 PM
The TMNT comics currently in publication are under IDW, *not* Dark Horse.
Nick seems to let them do their own thing. Maybe they look stuff over to make sure it stays within a certain vision they have for the property, dunno. We have some great IDW staff members here on the forum, maybe they can answer that.
CyberCubed
04-23-2013, 12:23 PM
Considering how VASTLY different the IDW series is from the Nick cartoon, its pretty obvious they're giving them a lot of freedom to do what they want.
@MikLeo: I know about Dark Horse, but yep, it's IDW now. Dark Horse never released TMNT before, except for the Flaming Carrot crossover I think.
What Nick allows for the IDW guys... well, probably the creators can answer it properly, and noone else, but they said in the interviews that Nick gives them a lot of freedom. What is easy to see, is that Nick don't limit IDW, to stay on the childfriendly level of the toon. There's blood and death, which is pretty usual in standard action-driven comics, and Nick seemingly has no problems with these, unlike Archie had with TMNTA when it was ongoing.
Vi11AiN6
04-23-2013, 05:33 PM
Idw and nick are two totally seperate TMNT universes so I would say Nick let's them do whatever they want
***First of Two Latin Kings***
04-23-2013, 06:17 PM
They might let them do whatever they want now, but you can bet that the board met [when they licensed out the comic to IDW] to discuss what direction the comic should go in for optimal sales, and also to discuss where it shouldn't go so that it wouldn't step on the animated show's toes. Bobby even said something along those lines in one of the letter columns.
Powder
04-23-2013, 07:11 PM
Since Nickelodeon own the right to the tmnt and I know that dark horse publish the comic. I am asking this because I if any one read the origin of the foot, April and the turtles look almost like their TV's counterpart.
IDW publishes it, you nimrod.
Nick doesn't have that much say in it, from what a few different artists have told me. They ask for minor edits on posing or coloring, and make sure there's nothing past a PG-13 level of violence or innuendo.
The characters in that book resembling their cartoon counterparts was the sole decision of the artist. He was not asked to make similarities, he chose to.
funatic
04-23-2013, 11:41 PM
I had an artist (to remain nameless) tell me that Nick/Viacom could be a real headache at times. Very lenient about some things, then suddenly extremely nitpicky about seemingly trivial details, like bandana-length.
Cipher
04-24-2013, 12:22 AM
I'm actually more curious about how they stand in regards to the Turtles' violence than I am about how they might interject on design consistencies or plot direction.
The IDW series definitely gets to skew toward an older audience and hasn't shown any compunctions about displaying violence when necessary (hence introducing New Animated Adventures as the all-ages book), but the Turtles themselves still have their Batman edict in effect, and even the one incident in which they thought they killed was revealed to the reader to be a fake-out.
You also have Nickelodeon's "Does not reflect the values of Nickelodeon or IDW" showing up in certain Mirage collections (bizarrely just the Tales books so far, although I'm not sure if it's in Ultimate Collection 4). I know there's debate on what exactly that message applied to -- including the arguable Middle Eastern stereotype the villains in one of the Tales issues presented -- and that maybe it was just slapped on both volumes as an oversight, but part of me wonders if Nick is starting to bring in the reigns for year two and the Turtles taking lives is where they draw the line.
Of course it's entirely possible IDW's no-kill policy is completely voluntary and can be lifted at any time and that Nick is just covering its bases in regards to the Mirage books. Only the IDW staff can clarify.
I had an artist (to remain nameless) tell me that Nick/Viacom could be a real headache at times. Very lenient about some things, then suddenly extremely nitpicky about seemingly trivial details, like bandana-length.
Again, yeah, I'm fine with this. Shouldn't bandana-lengths not be changing within the course of a single series anyway? Honestly, IDW could afford to be a little more consistent with designs between artists. We keep getting different belt styles, mask styles, disappearing wrist and ankle wraps, etc. with no in-universe explanation. Artists should be able to bring their own styles to the table, but I'm generally of the opinion that elements like those shouldn't change.
CyberCubed
04-24-2013, 09:29 AM
They allowed a vastly different origin, the use of apparently any character from the old toon or existing universe, and the series is targeting to an older age group than the show.
I'm sure they don't want gore, heavy sexual innuendo or cursing but everything else seems fair game.
Vi11AiN6
04-24-2013, 01:57 PM
I had an artist (to remain nameless) tell me that Nick/Viacom could be a real headache at times. Very lenient about some things, then suddenly extremely nitpicky about seemingly trivial details, like bandana-length.
I find this hard to believe because they let Kevin Eastman draw them EXACTLY like he did in the original series. Most of the entire series has resembled Mirage TMNT. Honestly Santolouco is the first artist to have ANY resemblance to Nick. However even he has his own spin on the Turtles (and an amazing one I must say)
Does or did they have to report to Viacom/Nick yes. Does Nick or Viacom profit on one VERY specific version of the Tmnt? No! They'd be stupid to dismiss what IDW has done.
Look IDW loves the characters they get to do, they've TOTALLy had an amazing track record with all their series. If anything Viacom is LUCKY to have IDW publish the series. It's the best thing to happen in comics since Valiant reformed.
Vi11AiN6
04-24-2013, 02:03 PM
FyI: I age 100% with cybercubed.
Candy Kappa
04-24-2013, 02:05 PM
Bates turtles also have a Nick flair to their looks, it isn't just Santolouco.
Although, I really enjoy how Bates draw the turtles.
Imo, Bates' turtles were the only Nick-ish so far.
Santolouco's turtles with the custom head bands, and with those head-shapes/body-shapes, it's a lot different from anything we have seen so far. The only step toward Nick-turtles are the fully drawn eyes, but that's not even started by Nick.
Powder
04-24-2013, 04:36 PM
Imo, Bates' turtles were the only Nick-ish so far.
Santolouco's turtles with the custom head bands, and with those head-shapes/body-shapes, it's a lot different from anything we have seen so far. The only step toward Nick-turtles are the fully drawn eyes, but that's not even started by Nick.
Reeeeeeeally?
He took the fat feet, hand/leg wraps, body build, height differences, head shapes, eyes, Donnie's gap, same belts, they're EXACTLY like the Nick designs except made to look more badass (hence the torn masks and belt accessories). He even admitted it himself in the design chart he posted on Deviantart. Don't be delusional.
& for the record, I don't think that's a bad thing. Just saying.
CyberCubed
04-24-2013, 05:29 PM
It's also interesting that Nick isn't forcing IDW to use characters created for the new show. We aren't seeing Dogpound and Fishface showing up, for example.
It's rather obvious its been treated as its own separate entirety as long as the plots don't get too adult or too ridiculous in terms of tone.
Half Sh3ll Hero
04-24-2013, 09:43 PM
IDW publishes it, you nimrod.
Nick doesn't that much say in it, from what a few different artists have told me. They ask for minor edits on posing or coloring, and make sure there's nothing past a PG-13 level of violence or innuendo.
The characters in that book resembling their cartoon counterparts was the sole decision of the artist. He was not asked to make similarities, he chose to.
You're so kind to the newer members Powder! You need to dust that chip on your shoulder off and do something with all this... anger?
The guy made a mistake, you could've gently corrected him but you decided to be a jerk about it. Good thing you're such good friends with the mods, wouldn't want to let your trolling and flamebaiting get you in trouble. Its amazing that anyone actually tolerates you bro.
Oh and for the record its "Nick DOES NOT HAVE That much say in it, from what a few different artists have told me." If people are going to get hassled for making a mistake I might as well call you out.
Powder
04-24-2013, 10:05 PM
If you're that upset over the word nimrod & perceive that to be anger, then you clearly have the perception of a child. Try to be a martyr if you like, but I know you told Obiwan you agree that I'm an 'asshole' who should be properly dealt with, so let he who is without sin cast the first stone, homeboy. I don't 'troll' or 'flamebait', people just don't like it when they're called on their you-know-what most of the time. Not my problem. Thank you for correcting my post, I will have to amend that missing word.
CyberCubed
04-24-2013, 10:16 PM
You also have Nickelodeon's "Does not reflect the values of Nickelodeon or IDW" showing up in certain Mirage collections (bizarrely just the Tales books so far, although I'm not sure if it's in Ultimate Collection 4).
The new Mirage trades also have a "13 and Up" warning on them, when the ones that were published before the cartoon didn't have them.
I think Nick is worried that kids might see the Mirage trades in stores and pick them and see how violent some of the issues are, that now they put warning labels on them. Of course this might mean they don't want IDW's comics to reach that level (where Leo and Raph actually stab and kill Foot Soldiers) but that remains to be seen if it'll continue that way.
Half Sh3ll Hero
04-24-2013, 11:03 PM
If you're that upset over the word nimrod & perceive that to be anger, then you clearly have the perception of a child. Try to be a martyr if you like, but I know you told Obiwan you agree that I'm an 'asshole' who should be properly dealt with, so let he who is without sin cast the first stone, homeboy. I don't 'troll' or 'flamebait."
I didn't call you out here on the boards, my opinion about you stands regardless of what Obi Wan told you pal. About being an asshole, well the shoe fits buddy... you do need a checking of your attitude.
And you not trolling or flamebaiting? What in the hell did you think you did by calling someone a nimrod or berating others on multiple topics? What makes you calling anyone a name acceptable? Oh wait its not... but in Powders fantasy land he's awesome around the 'Drome because of his cutting edge insults and holier than thou attitude.
You're a punk and an internet bully.
Powder
04-24-2013, 11:09 PM
A public profile comment is sufficient enough.
By calling me an asshole/punk/internet bully, baiting me to reply in a hostile fashion, taunting with sarcasm, etc, you're a hypocrite. Good job. :tthumbsu:
I'm done with this off-topic pissing contest. Feel free to put me on ignore and carry on with your life.
Candy Kappa
04-25-2013, 01:49 AM
Not sure how Nick could influence what Dark Horse have done for the TMNT franchise, since their contribution was back in 1986 :P
http://i.ebayimg.com/t/RAPHAEL-DARK-HORSE-MINIATURES-TMNT-NINJA-TURTLES-/00/s/MTIwMFgxNjAw/$%28KGrHqZ,!h!E5oPd%28Z-6BOizF6QjpQ~~60_35.JPG
Zulithe
04-25-2013, 01:57 AM
You're a punk and an internet bully.
A lot of people on this board are very rude and disrespectful to others. The moderation here does not care. Best to just not fight it. They are the ones reflecting poorly on the TMNT fandom, don't let it extend to you as well.
Candy Kappa
04-25-2013, 02:22 AM
Powder, a Internet bully? Please :roll:
Vi11AiN6
04-25-2013, 06:51 AM
Some unsuspecting kid is going to get his/her hands on the Mirage. Classics and be blown away. Parents don't pay attention and will just think of TMNT as a NICK thing.
How many of us had that experience when our initial exposure was the OT.
CyberCubed
05-01-2013, 10:37 PM
I'm sure Nick has much more influence on the animated cartoon comic than what IDW is doing. It'll be interesting to see if Nick allow the animated comic to deviate from the continuity of the cartoon and start doing its own thing.
Metropoliskid41
05-01-2013, 11:04 PM
Some unsuspecting kid is going to get his/her hands on the Mirage. Classics and be blown away. Parents don't pay attention and will just think of TMNT as a NICK thing.
How many of us had that experience when our initial exposure was the OT.
I don't think you're giving kids enough credit, I really don't think kids will be blown away by the "violence" of Mirage like you suggest. Is it darker than the Nick Toon? Yeah sure, but it really isn't that dark. If you were making the case about a collected trade of the Image TMNT series then yes, I think you'd have a point. This is a generation of kids who have grown up shooting zombies on video games & at least in the US, living in a Nation that has been in war for their entire lives, I don't think these kids are the naive, innocent, wet behind the ears saps you think they are. Hell most 10 year old kids probably have their own smart phones & googling God knows what on the internet 24/7. I think they can handle Mirage TMNT just fine.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.