PDA

View Full Version : Isnt about time Donatello got a metal bo staff?


RskimB
05-03-2013, 12:43 AM
Issue #21, two(i think) episodes of the Nick show where his staff has been broken. Is there any practical reason for him to continue to use a wooden staff?

Powder
05-03-2013, 01:05 AM
Bamboo & oak are supposedly the most durable, so yeah. There you go. It would just be change for the sake of change, which often gets peoples knickers in a twist. Donny did have one in Next Mutation, but still.

DrSpengler
05-03-2013, 08:04 AM
Honestly, his staff is only as weak or as strong as the writers want it to be in any given situation.

Sometimes he can use it to bash a robot to pieces. Sometimes it splinters and breaks across a metal surface for dramatic effect.

I don't think changing it to metal is the solution, as the only reason it ever breaks is because the writers want it to. And if the writers want it to break, it'll break, regardless of what it's made from.

CyberCubed
05-03-2013, 08:23 AM
I wish Donatello would say, "Aw, that was my favorite bo." when he smashes it like in the original cartoon.

Candy Kappa
05-03-2013, 08:57 AM
I don't think a metal Bo would work very well.


besides Bo staffs have to be of wood, that is their name :P

Lord Nightwalker
05-03-2013, 09:03 AM
Look, a metal staff isn't a practical idea. Weight alone is an issue. (potential for electricution, lol, )the Bo was traditionaly made of strong woods, but.....you can purchase acrylic staffs nowadays, I've yet to see an acrylic naginata, but bo, tapered bo, and hanbo I have seen.

Martin
05-03-2013, 09:15 AM
Honestly, his staff is only as weak or as strong as the writers want it to be in any given situation.

Sometimes he can use it to bash a robot to pieces. Sometimes it splinters and breaks across a metal surface for dramatic effect.

I don't think changing it to metal is the solution, as the only reason it ever breaks is because the writers want it to. And if the writers want it to break, it'll break, regardless of what it's made from.

Completely agree, though the fact that some staffs break under certain circumstances and others don't can be easily explained by the composition of the bo itself. When you are buying any weapon made out of wood you gotta pay attention to how the grain of the wood runs along the stick. Ideally, it should be parallel to the length of the it, however, wood isn't perfect and you'll come across with quite a few sticks in which the some of the grains are transversal to the length of it (what I mean is, that if you look at a transversal cut of the stick, the grains run into the edges). In those points exists a structural weakness that makes the staff easier to break. Sometimes it's impossible to determine if these points exist, so what looks like a perfectly good staff might actually break if you hit something strong enough.

Edit: changed the word 'carving' with 'grain'

Redeemer
05-03-2013, 09:30 AM
Look, a metal staff isn't a practical idea. Weight alone is an issue. (potential for electricution, lol, )

I hate to point out, but wood carries electricity too, just not as well. :P

Finally school was useful :P

Plasticplayhouse
05-03-2013, 11:32 AM
i like the traditional wooden bo. the nick toon version does have a retractable blade, but the writers don't seem to implement it all that often.

Lord Nightwalker
05-03-2013, 09:22 PM
I hate to point out, but wood carries electricity too, just not as well. :P

Finally school was useful :P

LOL. well said. *smiles*

Martin
05-03-2013, 10:01 PM
I hate to point out, but wood carries electricity too, just not as well. :P

Finally school was useful :P

You do realize that there are 20 guys out there who now believe wood is a conductor, right? :trazz:

Venom
05-04-2013, 09:34 AM
Don's an inventive chap, he should craft one from carbon fiber!

LH
05-04-2013, 11:02 AM
In today's free Comic Book Day issue...

The guys switch weapons and Raph breaks Donnie's staff to use it for two seperate hits. After which he tells Donnie "I wonder if these come in aluminium?" :tlol:

Andrew NDB
05-04-2013, 03:09 PM
I think he should have an adamantium bo.

But seriously, I've always liked the blade-mounted bo he picked up and was rocking in TMNT Vol. 1, #20. Best of both worlds.

Sword Slicin' Leo
05-04-2013, 03:23 PM
no, hell no, wouldnt look right

http:SlashSlash
05-04-2013, 05:44 PM
Because it's completely under the writers' control how durable the staff is, you'd have to assume it's for character-development. Maybe because Mikey and Don are the more compassionate/innocent turtles of the group, that's why their weapons are knocked away or broken more often. Just a guess though.

Lord Nightwalker
05-04-2013, 07:42 PM
You do realize that there are 20 guys out there who now believe wood is a conductor, right? :trazz:

LOL. Also well said.

Cryomancer
05-04-2013, 08:05 PM
Am I crazy or was there some thing with Don in Mirage where it was explained or implied that he preferred a wooden weapon because it kept him grounded or connected to the earth or something? Despite being the techy one he often seemed to enjoy nature and staying at the farm and so on. I feel like the connection was made somewhere but it's possible my brain invented this, I have a terrible memory.

Candy Kappa
05-05-2013, 05:46 AM
Would also like to mention that a metal staff isn't needed as a proper Bo can fracture bone, shatter skulls and break a Katana blade in half.

A Bo made of the proper wood such as hard wood white oak is not as easy to break as the cartoons like to show.

Rooish
05-05-2013, 02:49 PM
Would also like to mention that a metal staff isn't needed as a proper Bo can fracture bone, shatter skulls and break a Katana blade in half.

A Bo made of the proper wood such as hard wood white oak is not as easy to break as the cartoons like to show.

I know! I have a bo and it is rock solid. I hate how the shows make it break all the time.