PDA

View Full Version : When you think about the IDW Turtles, what artist do you most identify their look?


CyberCubed
05-20-2013, 11:09 AM
Each universe of TMNT has an established look to the Turtles. The original cartoon, 4kids series, and Nick cartoon all have a standard look for the turtles that's immediately recognizable. When you see pictures of the Turtles for those 3 cartoons online you immediately know which series they're from.

When it comes to the Mirage Turtles, people usually picture them looking like either Laird's, Eastman's or Jim Lawson's art. In fact I mostly associate them with the way Lawson draws them because he did City at War, Volume 2, Volume 4, and a lot of Tales. The Archie series is also mostly associated with Chris Allen. So even in terms of the comics, they have a recognizable look.

But when it comes to the IDW Turtles they look fairly different depending on which aritst is drawing them. For me I still associate Dan Duncan's look to how I see the "IDW Turtles" in general. Its likely because he did the first 12 issues and was our first exposure to this universe, but also because the other artists (aside from the current one and History of the Foot Clan) don't seem all that unique. (Ben Bates purposely made them look like the current Nick Playmates figures for example)

So for me the IDW Turtles are still most recognized by the way Dan Duncan drew them.

Metropoliskid41
05-20-2013, 12:13 PM
Yeah I'd say Dan Duncan, but I really think that's going to have to be a question that is answered down the line years from now. I'm sure during Mirage Volume 1 there was a definitive look for the turtles that was classified as the Laird/Eastman combo look from the first few issues, but you can really see how much that design and look changed throughout the series, even when Kevin and Peter were the artists bringing the turtles to life. Based on that I'd say Duncan for now, but even his style and turtles design changed during his 12 issue run. Who knows, Mateus or another artist could end up having a 2-3 year solid run on Turtles, which I think down the road would definitely set them up as the defining artist and look of the IDW Turtles.

Tazi
05-20-2013, 12:33 PM
After Santolouco finishes drawing City Fall, he will have almost as much issues drawn as Dan Duncan, and to be honest I really hope he will stay with TMNT as regular artist, because his work is so awesome, that I can even forgive him doing thoose stylised masks.

Btw, what happened with Duncan's art in the last issues he have drawn? Does he got tired with TMNT, and rushed it? I'm asking, because his last issues are somehow not as good looking as his earlier works. Just look at their head shapes:
http://4thletter.net/wp-content/uploads//tmnt12b.jpg
They're not looked like this at the beginning.

Plasticplayhouse
05-20-2013, 12:59 PM
Yeah I'd say Dan Duncan, but I really think that's going to have to be a question that is answered down the line years from now.

totally agree with this.

Candy Kappa
05-20-2013, 01:00 PM
I'd love to say Cambell, but I don't even own the one issue he have done (so far) It never came to my LCS :(

I really, really like Bates work, it's well balanced and fun to look at. when I think of the IDW turtles, Bates art is up first, then Ross, cause he's just too awesome.

The Gunslinger
05-20-2013, 01:21 PM
I would say Dan Duncan as well. I've liked almost every artist that has been on the series except for Kuhn, but Dan was amazing when he was at his best early on in the series. I was sad to see him go but welcome the amazing talents of Mateus to the series. It would be great for him to be the ongoing artist for a long time to come and not just 12 issues. That, to me, would solidify him as the definitive artist for the series.

DrSpengler
05-20-2013, 01:23 PM
At this juncture?

Duncan.

While he completed his run at 12 issues and we haven't seen him in a while, he was the first artist on the series and directed the look of the title; character designs and atmosphere and so forth. His contributions will linger long after he's left the book.

But, whose to say things will stay that way? At 21 issues, I'm sure everyone had Ken Mitchroney pegged as the quintessential TMNT Adventures artist. But then a couple issues later, Chris Allan showed up, completely redefined the look and feel of that title and became the artist most associated with that book.

If IDW could just nail an artist's feet to the floor so they can't run away after four issues, maybe another artist will come along and redefine the look of the series for a healthy run?

Until then, though, I think Dan Duncan has had the most important effect on the vidual end of the book.

ToTheNines
05-20-2013, 01:37 PM
Right now, Duncan. I expect Mateus-san to take his place though.

After Santolouco finishes drawing City Fall, he will have almost as much issues drawn as Dan Duncan

Actually, they'll both be tied with 11.5 since they split art duties for #5.

Cipher
05-20-2013, 02:33 PM
At this juncture?

Duncan.

While he completed his run at 12 issues and we haven't seen him in a while, he was the first artist on the series and directed the look of the title; character designs and atmosphere and so forth. His contributions will linger long after he's left the book.

But, whose to say things will stay that way? At 21 issues, I'm sure everyone had Ken Mitchroney pegged as the quintessential TMNT Adventures artist. But then a couple issues later, Chris Allan showed up, completely redefined the look and feel of that title and became the artist most associated with that book.

If IDW could just nail an artist's feet to the floor so they can't run away after four issues, maybe another artist will come along and redefine the look of the series for a healthy run?

Until then, though, I think Dan Duncan has had the most important effect on the visual end of the book.
This.

It also helps, though, that Duncan brought what I think has been the single most unique, idiosyncratic style on the book so far. A great one, at that.

xChri5x
05-20-2013, 02:58 PM
I'm reading through the series for the first time now and after the Michelangelo issue I just read, I am not looking forward to Andy Kuhn. His designs are ugly and his art is sloppy. The proportions of the characters are constantly off and inconsistent. Overall it just looks rushed. I know the other artists don't have perfect drawings in every panel, but geez... Kuhn's could show a little more love.

corvus
05-20-2013, 03:04 PM
I'm reading through the series for the first time now and after the Michelangelo issue I just read, I am not looking forward to Andy Kuhn. His designs are ugly and his art is sloppy. The proportions of the characters are constantly off and inconsistent. Overall it just looks rushed. I know the other artists don't have perfect drawings in every panel, but geez... Kuhn's could show a little more love.


I gotta disagree. Kuhn reminds me of Mike Mignola and Hellboy is one of my favorite comics. I really like Kuhn. Imo, Bates is the worse. Unless you like expressionless anime type characters and a Karai with a Jay Leno chin

Tazi
05-20-2013, 03:24 PM
Kuhn's style is very minimalistic, and that's not a problem, and he has also no problems with keeping the proportions, imo. I could be okay with how he draws, but his turtle faces are just not right, and this kinda destroys it for me.

Talking about proportions, I love Eastman's art, but it's not rare for him, that he draws a character's face different for each panel...
Even Santolouco has some mistakes, like when he draws April with tights twice as big as her head.

But I love Santolouco's art, tho Lawson is still my favourite, when it comes to TMNT. It would be so nice, if he'd draw a few issues for IDW. :)

Powder
05-20-2013, 06:02 PM
I'm reading through the series for the first time now and after the Michelangelo issue I just read, I am not looking forward to Andy Kuhn. His designs are ugly and his art is sloppy. The proportions of the characters are constantly off and inconsistent. Overall it just looks rushed. I know the other artists don't have perfect drawings in every panel, but geez... Kuhn's could show a little more love.

I felt the same way you did after reading his micro, but don't worry, his 4 issue run halfway into the series is muuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuch better.

Jester
05-20-2013, 07:23 PM
Dan Duncan. As the initial artist on the series he was instrumental in the early designs of some characters he's my mental go-to-guy.

MikeandRaph87
05-20-2013, 08:13 PM
Dan Duncan. As the initial artist on the series he was instrumental in the early designs of some characters he's my mental go-to-guy.

This! When I think IDW I think Dan Ducan's concept because he started the book. Unless an artist stays on for say two years its his art i think of when one says IDW.

Slade
05-20-2013, 09:27 PM
I agree it could change later on, but I'm going with Duncan too.

TheCollector
05-20-2013, 10:58 PM
I gotta say, now when I think TMNT, no matter what character I see Santolouco's art, I mean damn, that art in Secret History of the Foot Clan is just gorgeous, and everyone in my eyes looks perfect.
I mean, I prefer Nick Karai over IDW Karai, but there is no way I'd ever replace this absolutely gorgeous pic of Karai from Santolouco in my avi.

Uki
05-23-2013, 02:53 PM
All I know is that I am LOVING Santolouco's stuff.

Redrumh2o
05-23-2013, 05:32 PM
Does Santolouco sell his pages anywhere?