PDA

View Full Version : Is TMNT, Vol. 3 essential to have?


mrjafunk
05-22-2013, 05:47 AM
I am really debating whether or not I want to invest into TMNT, Vol. 3 from Image. Looking around the majority of the issues are quite expensive. For those who have read or own this volume, is it good and worth having?

CyberCubed
05-22-2013, 06:10 AM
Its worth reading for some good storylines and it directly continues from Mirage Volume 1 and 2.

I'm not sure if you want to track down the issues now or wait to see if IDW releases trades next year.

ToTheNines
05-22-2013, 06:31 AM
Is it essential to the whole Mirage story? No.

However, I consider it essential to any TMNT fans comic collection. Very good story and really cool art.

DrSpengler
05-22-2013, 08:32 AM
If you're concerned with whether it "counts" or not, then no, it can be skipped in the grand scheme of the Mirage universe with no loss to storytelling cohesion.

However, if you don't mind seeing an alternate splinter continuity from Vol. 2 where things could have gone very differently, then I'd recommend it, as some of the ideas are quite interesting. There's stronger characterization and better character development in Vol. 3 than in Vol. 4, I think.

It's very much a 90s superhero book and full of all the cliches of the era, so it's very different in tone from the Mirage stuff. If you can adjust to the different take, there are great story threads to appreciate. Some aren't so hot and Carlson is pretty rough out of the gate (hate the opening Warlord Komodo arc, personally), but once he settles into the title it really starts going places. Characters actually feel like they grow and change (mainly Raph and Mikey, who have the best arcs) and aren't forever trapped in the limbo of blandess that you'll encounter during Vol. 4.

And if you're so inclined, the independantly published #24 and #25 issues, which were completed with consent and participation from the Image creators, paste Vol. 3 back into Mirage continuity. So concern over whether it "counts" should no longer be an issue, I would hope.

The Image series is a hard thing to recommend, as it's very different and everyone seems to react very differently (and very strongly) toward it. I... don't think I could recommend it at the current prices the issues go for, honestly. At the very least, I'd say save it for last, which might give you time to see if IDW reprints the series at a more reasonable cost.

mrmaczaps
05-22-2013, 08:47 AM
Great advice. I've been trying to find it myself, but without having to unload $300 bucks for it all at once.
Hopefully IDW can reprint it just as it is and then I can also track down 24 & 25!

If you're concerned with whether it "counts" or not, then no, it can be skipped in the grand scheme of the Mirage universe with no loss to storytelling cohesion.

However, if you don't mind seeing an alternate splinter continuity from Vol. 2 where things could have gone very differently, then I'd recommend it, as some of the ideas are quite interesting. There's stronger characterization and better character development in Vol. 3 than in Vol. 4, I think.

It's very much a 90s superhero book and full of all the cliches of the era, so it's very different in tone from the Mirage stuff. If you can adjust to the different take, there are great story threads to appreciate. Some aren't so hot and Carlson is pretty rough out of the gate (hate the opening Warlord Komodo arc, personally), but once he settles into the title it really starts going places. Characters actually feel like they grow and change (mainly Raph and Mikey, who have the best arcs) and aren't forever trapped in the limbo of blandess that you'll encounter during Vol. 4.

And if you're so inclined, the independently published #24 and #25 issues, which were completed with consent and participation from the Image creators, paste Vol. 3 back into Mirage continuity. So concern over whether it "counts" should no longer be an issue, I would hope.

The Image series is a hard thing to recommend, as it's very different and everyone seems to react very differently (and very strongly) toward it. I... don't think I could recommend it at the current prices the issues go for, honestly. At the very least, I'd say save it for last, which might give you time to see if IDW reprints the series at a more reasonable cost.

mrjafunk
05-22-2013, 09:24 AM
Will IDW be releasing these at all, ever? Trying to find the whole collection has been hard and what I can find is quite $$$

DrSpengler
05-22-2013, 09:56 AM
Will IDW be releasing these at all, ever? Trying to find the whole collection has been hard and what I can find is quite $$$

We had a thread about it recently. IDW editor Bobby Curnow basically said that it's low on the totem pole, but they intend to get around to it in due time.

That could be a few years, unfortunately, as they still have quite a bit of Mirage material to collect, first.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
05-22-2013, 10:42 AM
I would think as well as this series sells complete, it would be higher up on the totem pole. Why wouldn't you make it a priority to reprint material that people are CONSTANTLY trying to find and willing to pay top dollar for? They're already reprinted a lot of material that is easily accessible. The Image books are *different* but they're no worse (or better) than most of the canon Mirage stuff. If they're not being reprinted right away you can bet it has more to do with having to work out the legalities since they don't own characters like VanGuard, Savage Dragon, Knight Watchman, etc. I bet if someone here contacted Erik Larsen he might have some juicy information regarding Nick trying to strike a deal with Image for rights to re-print what they don't technically own.

Cipher
05-22-2013, 07:25 PM
Confession time: To this day, I still haven't read all of Volume 3. I pick up issues any time I find them, but I haven't made it a priority to finally hunt the rest down.

I'd honestly just wait until IDW gets around to it, however far out that might be. Especially if you haven't read the Mirage material they're currently reprinting.

Lord Nightwalker
05-22-2013, 07:41 PM
Simply put, Yes.

CyberCubed
05-22-2013, 07:43 PM
We had a thread about it recently. IDW editor Bobby Curnow basically said that it's low on the totem pole, but they intend to get around to it in due time.

That could be a few years, unfortunately, as they still have quite a bit of Mirage material to collect, first.

Volume 1 will be almost done by the end of this year. Since the Tales collections are going on at the same time as the Mirage collections, they don't interfere.

They'll probably collect Image right after Volume 2 I imagine. And since Volume 2 is only 13 issues, I'd probably say by mid-2014 is when we might see the first Image trade from IDW.

sawcesome
05-22-2013, 09:00 PM
Waiting on IDW to collect it is probably the best move. You can also hunt around in antique stores, flea markets, etc. for random issues. I found issue 1 in a grab-bag a few years ago at a flea market for $5 and issues 3-7 last week in a game store for $2 each.

DK2
05-23-2013, 12:28 AM
I loved this series overall and it really was the closest to being the same as the best canonical issues of Vol. 1 from Mirage. Vol. 2 and Vol. 4 just never had that flair of action and "New Yorky" thing to them. I met Erik Larson at the Calgary Fan Expo in late April and I told him this too and he was glad I liked this run and was kinda mocking to me that he's glad "at least one person liked that series". I got him to sign the TMNT Image Vol. 3 trade. I tried to get Body Count signed by Simon Bisley but he wasn't there at all by Sunday of the show. He was there on the Friday and I wished I'd gotten him then. But the other creators around his table told me he's a loose cannon kinda guy. Made me wonder when Bisley says on his sign name to "please give me money", "Get me a beer" and even something about "hookers". Some of these were written on his table too. So makes one wonder about Simon Bisley. Oh well.

***First of Two Latin Kings***
05-23-2013, 06:42 AM
That's funny about Simon Bisley wanting hookers in exchage for autographs, or even beers. You can really tell just from his name that he is probably a real loose cannon, even the name "Simon Bisley" sounds like a notorious punker or clansman. But I think what is more likely is that the other creators wrote all that stuff while he was away from the table as a prank and then started telling people what they told you to scare them.