View Full Version : Why aren't there any Japanese actors cast for this movie?
CyberCubed
05-31-2013, 07:14 PM
For a movie based on a franchise where the main villain and hero mentor are Japanese and are supposed to be fighting ninja's, there don't seem to be any Japanese actors cast for this movie.
snake
05-31-2013, 07:16 PM
Because Micheal Bay.
Shreddhead
05-31-2013, 07:25 PM
http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mab3ki1Rvv1rpuj1d.gif
chrisdude
05-31-2013, 07:28 PM
Why would you ask this question? Nobody here knows.
snake
05-31-2013, 07:30 PM
Why would you ask this question? Nobody here knows.
Because Cybercubed.
CyberCubed
05-31-2013, 10:05 PM
Its really bizarre given how deeply TMNT is surrounded by Japanese mythology.
And the main villain is supposed to be Japanese, in fact he's ALWAYS been Japanese excluding the Utrom Shredder who still pretended to be Japanese when he was in his human disguise. And Splinter should be Japanese as well no matter which origin they go with.
Refractive Reflections
06-01-2013, 12:46 AM
It is a good question to ask, but I don't know if you will find an answer for it since we are still unsure of who exactly is being cast for Shredder (or if Shredder will be appearing, separate from Col. Schrader), or if Colonel Schrader will be Shredder. I can see your point CyberCubed that the actors playing Splinter/Hamato Yoshi and Shredder should at least have some Japanese ethnicity since the whole TMNT premise is based in Japan. But I think the casting could get away in hiring an actor outside of the race for Splinter/Hamato Yoshi, because I don't think you could visually portray human race on an animal, or rat in this case.
http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mab3ki1Rvv1rpuj1d.gif
...And yes Shreddhead, it is a somewhat fair question to ask. Hollywood has a tendency sometimes of racially "whitewashing" characters to be Caucasian to make a movie more profitable. One notable example is the movie 21 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/21_%282008_film%29#Casting_controversy), even when that was produced in 2008 and didn't mirror the races of the actual story.
Shreddhead
06-01-2013, 01:18 AM
...And yes Shreddhead, it is a somewhat fair question to ask. Hollywood has a tendency sometimes of racially "whitewashing" characters to be Caucasian to make a movie more profitable. One notable example is the movie 21 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/21_%282008_film%29#Casting_controversy), even when that was produced in 2008 and didn't mirror the races of the actual story.
It was a somewhat fair question to ask the first 100 times cc brought it up. Face it, not you or any of us know much about this film. Just hush up and wait till it comes out before you make these asinine threads
Refractive Reflections
06-01-2013, 01:34 AM
It was a somewhat fair question to ask the first 100 times cc brought it up.
...Well, I don't notice/pay attention to every question/response/thread CyberCubed makes...so that's why. :lol::roll:
NYShell
06-01-2013, 02:19 AM
This is what directors, producers, and Hollywood always do. They just go for somewhat big name ppl and cast them instead of using the ethnicity from source material. It always ends up being the newest or longest, notable white dudes who get the roles for no apparent reason, even if they're not the right match. This has always been the case, and it doesn't surprise me. I hate it.
Powder
06-01-2013, 02:35 AM
Whitewashing is one of the crappiest things hollywood ever came up with. Believe me, I hate it. We don't have the answer to that question, though.
Candy Kappa
06-01-2013, 03:31 AM
To be fair, the ninja do stay in NY, they could be American recruits. Splinter don't need to be played by any specific ethnicity, he is a rat, unless you go for the Fred Wolf origin, which then you should have a guy that at least can go for being Japanese in flashbacks when Yoshi was human. And have Shredder even been cast?
As for now only Burne have gotten a ethnicity change and a gender bender.
chrisdude
06-01-2013, 08:30 AM
...And yes Shreddhead, it is a somewhat fair question to ask. Hollywood has a tendency sometimes of racially "whitewashing" characters to be Caucasian to make a movie more profitable. One notable example is the movie 21 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/21_%282008_film%29#Casting_controversy), even when that was produced in 2008 and didn't mirror the races of the actual story.Whitewashing happens, but the opposite happens far more often, these days. (Hello, black female Burne)
Personally, I don't care if Shredder turns out to be Japanese. Especially if he doesn't even turn out to be a ninja...
alliance
06-01-2013, 02:30 PM
http://www.47reviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/tv_avatar_last_airbender_cast_comparison.jpg
perhaps it could be worse guys..
CinematicESP
06-01-2013, 02:36 PM
So the actor playing Splinter isn't Japanese, so it's safe to assume they aren't going with the cartoon origin of him being Hamato Yoshi, unless they just have a flashback where he doesn't speak or something. Will they stick to the original comic/movie origin where he's Yoshi's pet rat that picks up ninjitsu by watching him?
If Shredder isn't Japanese and there is little to no Japanese element in this movie, how do the turtles become ninjas?
Shreddhead
06-01-2013, 02:45 PM
Because Kevin clash is soooo Japanese, and his origin in the first film was nothing like the cartoon....
TigerClaw
06-01-2013, 03:26 PM
Because Kevin clash is soooo Japanese, and his origin in the first film was nothing like the cartoon....
Well actually, Master Splinter in the original black and white comics was a pet rat.
Galactus
06-01-2013, 03:29 PM
Because Kevin clash is soooo Japanese, and his origin in the first film was nothing like the cartoon....
Kevin Clash was a voice of Splinter. He needed to sound old and vaguely Japanese and he did.
I suppose Woodburn could do the same although based on what I've seen him in (which admittedly isn't much) he hasn't played anything but a crotchety American. I'm guessing it's pretty much his "thing".
I think we can all agree he wouldn't pass for a human Hamato Yoshi. It'd be weird if we got so much from the Fred Wolf show and didn't get Splinter's origin from the show.
Then again for all we know Splinter's origin in this movie could be that he was once 'Harry' the janitor in The Foot military base and didn't didn't get along with Schrader so in a hilarious tug of war with a mop goes careening into the closet were the ooze is kept. He trains the TMNT to get revenge on Schrader for taking his favourite bucket.
Shreddhead
06-01-2013, 03:54 PM
Well actually, Master Splinter in the original black and white comics was a pet rat.
Uuuuhh ya, I know...
Kevin Clash was a voice of Splinter. He needed to sound old and vaguely Japanese and he did.
I suppose Woodburn could do the same although based on what I've seen him in (which admittedly isn't much) he hasn't played anything but a crotchety American. I'm guessing it's pretty much his "thing".
I think we can all agree he wouldn't pass for a human Hamato Yoshi. It'd be weird if we got so much from the Fred Wolf show and didn't get Splinter's origin from the show.
I understand what you're saying, but imagine yourself back in 1990. You're a diehard fan of the mirage books and you find out that ELMO is going to be voicing splinter! It's the exact same sort of disbelief/ confusion that everyone is experiencing now. Just take a deep breath and wait until the thing actually comes out before ripping it apart for being "racist".
And I'm not really addressing you when I say that, you actually seem to have a sense of humor about it, I'm talking to these other people who are up in arms a out the whole thing. And remember, you loved Japanese Elmo!
jestermon
06-02-2013, 10:07 AM
The only 2 people that needed to be Japanese would have been Shredder and Splinter, but Splinter technically didn't learn to speak until he was in NY which would have made him have a New York accent if anything, even though he remember Ninja moves, usually your accent is determined by who you are around recently.
Shredder has been replaced in the story by an army guy that I am sure is an American soldier since it happens in NY as well, so I don't see who else would need to be Japanese?
I never understood people complaining about Avatar, it never says anyone is Asian or Eskimo in the entire cartoon, they were certain tribes never said they were Asian, Eskimo, African American, Indian.
Saying Splinter should talk as if he is Japanese in the story arcs where he is a rat and doesn't learn to talk until he is mutated in New York is the same as in Weeds when Kevin Nealon thinks the Hispanic baby should speak Spanish just because he is half Mexican.
Andrew NDB
06-02-2013, 01:38 PM
There is no reason for Splinter to be Japanese outside of the children's spinoffs where the mutagen is a "touch this become that" farce and he has a Japanese man hiding inside of him.
zak_the_neutrino
06-02-2013, 05:45 PM
Who cares if no Japanese actors are cast. What's the big ****ing deal anyways? This is an American film
CyberCubed
06-02-2013, 06:47 PM
Who cares if no Japanese actors are cast. What's the big ****ing deal anyways? This is an American film
Is this a joke post? The main villain of the franchise is Japanese, why the hell shouldn't there be a Japanese actor cast for him?
xChri5x
06-02-2013, 07:25 PM
America. **** Yeah!
Drose18
06-02-2013, 08:23 PM
America. **** Yeah!
*Murica **** YEAH!
Powder
06-02-2013, 09:55 PM
Who cares if no Japanese actors are cast. What's the big ****ing deal anyways? This is an American film
As an American citizen you should be well aware that nobody in America is "American". We're a culturally diverse nation and there's no reason our pop culture shouldn't reflect that. & for Christ's sake, the character is Japanese & as such should always be portrayed that way visually. Try to respect heritage.
NYShell
06-02-2013, 11:21 PM
Who cares if no Japanese actors are cast. What's the big ****ing deal anyways? This is an American film
Is this a joke post? The main villain of the franchise is Japanese, why the hell shouldn't there be a Japanese actor cast for him?
As an American citizen you should be well aware that nobody in America is "American". We're a culturally diverse nation and there's no reason our pop culture shouldn't reflect that. & for Christ's sake, the character is Japanese & as such should always be portrayed that way visually. Try to respect heritage.
CyberCubed and Powder are right, zak_the_neutrino. Why the hell wouldn't these actors be Japanese? Even if it's an "American" film, it still takes from other cultures and ethnicities that weren't "American" in the original material. Who cares? Everyone who knows that anything other than Japanese would be deviating from the real, true TMNT mythology, and doesn't want a crappy, white-washed American film, like many franchises end up getting nowadays.
Foot Soldier Clang
06-02-2013, 11:28 PM
For a movie based on a franchise where the main villain and hero mentor are Japanese and are supposed to be fighting ninja's, there don't seem to be any Japanese actors cast for this movie.
I only wondered this when I saw who they found to play Shredder. It really is a shame, but it's also not surprising in the least. I'm not sure if its "whitewashing" in Hollywood, or if there were any Japanese/Asian actors who even auditioned for the role and didn't get the job. It also leaves you wondering what the state of the Foot Clan will be in the new film, like, will they even be ninjas at all?
Zulithe
06-02-2013, 11:58 PM
I'm flexible on who portrays who in TMNT except for Shredder. He needs to be Japanese or at least east-asian. If they cast a Chinese or Korean actor to play him, while still messed up, at least it's better than him being white. (BTW, I am white, but I, like many, just want as much authenticity as possible). I think TMNT (1990) Shredder was awesome. Anyway if you look at the casting for the new film, outside of April they aren't casting big stars I guess you can count Whoopi but I can't see her playing a big part in this... so that may be a good sign that they'll go for a Japanese actor, because clearly here in the west we have very few actors of Japanese heritage who could fill the boots of a star if they were going for that.
While the turtles aren't voiced or mo-capped from Japanese actors, I think it's a fair bet that some (or most) of the stunts/martial arts will be performed by asians, so there's that.
Cipher
06-03-2013, 12:09 AM
Whitewashing happens, but the opposite happens far more often, these days. (Hello, black female Burne)
http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lhrw2ctYDo1qajffpo1_500.gif
TurtleTitan97
06-03-2013, 12:17 AM
Who cares if no Japanese actors are cast. What's the big ****ing deal anyways? This is an American film
So because it's an American film, it should just be ignoring the Japanese elements that are a part of TMNT? :trolleye:
Andrew NDB
06-03-2013, 01:42 AM
Because 1 of the 4 words in the title is inherently... you know... Japanese. And every member of the group of their most infamous rogues' gallery is supposed to be.
Matches Malone
06-03-2013, 02:28 AM
Whitewashing happens, but the opposite happens far more often, these days. (Hello, black female Burne)
You're right, in the one example you gave, the opposite did happen 100% of the time. A larger sample pool would only support this assertion... I can only assume.
Cryomancer
06-03-2013, 02:32 AM
Here's hoping for no white girl Karai at least. On the plus side, if no one's Asian, they can't make them into terrible Asian stereotypes? Nah, they'll find a way to work that in probably.
I still don't get why they whitewash movies so heavily, especially movies that have anything at all to do with martial arts. They've made a bunch of fighting game movies over the past decade and pretty much made the stars be white characters or white actors, and big shock they are all awful. You know what fighting-game-into-movie was the most successful ? Mortal Kombat. The one with an Asian lead.
chrisdude
06-03-2013, 08:24 AM
You're right, in the one example you gave, the opposite did happen 100% of the time. A larger sample pool would only support this assertion... I can only assume.I'm sorry. I'm over here looking at black female Burne, black Kingpin, black Heimdall, black Perry White, female Jimmy Olsen, black Electro. I'm looking at Miles Morales and Nick Fury. Comics and comic book movies have been working to compensate for the "whitewashed" casts they were created with. This isn't new. There aren't black people in OT. Obviously they're going to make someone in there black.
Andrew NDB
06-03-2013, 10:43 AM
There aren't black people in OT.
http://legacy.shadowlordinc.com/media/T/TMNT/rocksteady-rhino2-02.jpg
Bebop looks thoroughly black to me.
plastroncafe
06-03-2013, 10:57 AM
Wait what? Hollywood failing? Again?
To hell you say!
CyberCubed
06-03-2013, 12:20 PM
http://legacy.shadowlordinc.com/media/T/TMNT/rocksteady-rhino2-02.jpg
Bebop looks thoroughly black to me.
I always thought they made Bebop black to compensate for whitewashing Baxter. But since they both turned into mutants shortly it didn't make too much a difference.
OrokuYoshiFilms
06-03-2013, 12:56 PM
I've wondered this same thing myself. They need to inject some Japanese in here quick. Maybe no Japanese actors are willing to work with the folks doing this movie.
(...and people who rationalize it by saying it's an American film probably won't mind if Michael Bay changes the turtles into hermit crabs. I mean they both have shells right. Pff...)
I figure:
Movie Title: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Ninja: Japanese word
Seems like there'd be cultural Japanese elements abound throughout every incarnation since it's partially named after something fully Japanese. Especially a movie.
They even speak a lil Japanese in the new show. The new show totally gets it.
Shredder and Splinter have always been Japanese...to my best knowledge. Whether you're a Japanese man with a Japanese name or the pet of a Japanese man or the rival of a Japanese man with a Japanese name you should be Japanese looking and/or sounding in a movie adaptation. I'll even take Japanese-ish.
...as far as I'm concerned to impress me you have to be better than the first movie's Shredder.
chrisdude
06-03-2013, 03:30 PM
http://legacy.shadowlordinc.com/media/T/TMNT/rocksteady-rhino2-02.jpg
Bebop looks thoroughly black to me.I will not hesitate to admit that I forgot all about him.
Refractive Reflections
06-03-2013, 03:42 PM
Comics and comic book movies have been working to compensate for the "whitewashed" casts they were created with.
That's no surprise, I mean most of those classic comics were made in the mid 1900s (1930s-1960s), and we all know how racial attitudes were around that time. :roll: If those comics were ever going to be profitable and not be banned by harsh public criticism, they had to be "whitewashed". I mean African-Americans during that time were struggling to get into the mainstream and were very lucky to do so.
The issue is, why is it still happening today? ...If the USA is supposed to be a much more racially tolerant nation. It would be problematic and go too far if Shredder and Hamato Yoshi, were "whitewashed" and would be perceived by some that Asian looks aren't "photogenic" enough for the film, even though the whole TMNT story was founded in Japanese culture. Almost as if the movie was implying, "Yeah...thanks Japan for the cool ninja fighting skills, and code of honor, and your weapons that we will all use, but your Asian appearance just isn't bankable enough for this movie."
CyberCubed
06-03-2013, 06:14 PM
I will not hesitate to admit that I forgot all about him.
How could you forget about one of the main villains in a show you liked?
sgtfbomb
06-03-2013, 06:31 PM
Who cares if no Japanese actors are cast. What's the big ****ing deal anyways? This is an American film
That's some wonderful, broken logic you have there. :roll:
chrisdude
06-03-2013, 07:21 PM
How could you forget about one of the main villains in a show you liked?Because he was human for like 30 seconds. Or do you consider the warthog black?
CyberCubed
06-03-2013, 07:50 PM
Because he was human for like 30 seconds. Or do you consider the warthog black?
Bebop was human for 2 episodes, and then we saw his human form in another 2 episodes (Shredderville and Plan 6 from Outer Space).
And everytime I saw Bebop I remembered he was a black man.
jestermon
06-04-2013, 09:04 AM
If they did cast an Asian actor then some organization would poke up it's head and complain that the bad guy was the only Asian in the movie.
What was worse was in the second movie when the random New York Asian guy was just supposed to be a token martial arts expert.
It's also makes no sense because it has ninja in the title that it is inherently Japanese, that's just as racist as saying that a basketball team should be all black, there are plenty of non Asian martial artists worldwide.
And I am sorry but even if you are from other places when you are an American citizen you are indeed American, that's one of the problems that perpetuates racism in our country no ones will ever see people as Americans but their different races.
Shredder was James Saito a Californian Tatsu was the only Japanese actor in a main role in the original movie.
Shredder was Cambodian in Secret of the Ooze, Keno was a Californian, Tatsu was the only Japanese actor in a main role, so that's one for Secret of the Ooze.
Lord Norinaga was another Californian, Kenshin was Californian, Mitsu was Chinese so not loads of Japanese people in the third movie either, I am sure most of the "Japanese" warrior extras were hired in America as well.
Not seeing the previous use of tons of Japanese actors on the movies so why would this one be any different?
plastroncafe
06-04-2013, 11:15 AM
Yes, better to make everyone white, less chance of being called racist that way.
...
Oh wait.
zodiac brave
06-04-2013, 12:41 PM
It's also makes no sense because it has ninja in the title that it is inherently Japanese, that's just as racist as saying that a basketball team should be all black, there are plenty of non Asian martial artists worldwide.
mmmmmnope. ninja is a japanese word. a word from japan. from another country. describes something that originated in japan. yeah...so, not racist. (you're right about the basketball thing, though, but there's no connect between the two examples.)
And I am sorry but even if you are from other places when you are an American citizen you are indeed American, that's one of the problems that perpetuates racism in our country no ones will ever see people as Americans but their different races.
"american" is a nationality, not an ethnicity.
Shredder was James Saito a Californian Tatsu was the only Japanese actor in a main role in the original movie.
Shredder was Cambodian in Secret of the Ooze, Keno was a Californian, Tatsu was the only Japanese actor in a main role, so that's one for Secret of the Ooze.
Lord Norinaga was another Californian, Kenshin was Californian, Mitsu was Chinese so not loads of Japanese people in the third movie either, I am sure most of the "Japanese" warrior extras were hired in America as well.
every time you point out that someone is "californian", it doesn't change their ethnicity. james saito is still japanese...he's just from california.
Not seeing the previous use of tons of Japanese actors on the movies so why would this one be any different?
true enough, though it would be nice to not have a white-washed film.
The Stryker
06-04-2013, 01:02 PM
Where all the black people at?
chrisdude
06-04-2013, 07:21 PM
What if in this movie, the fictional Shredder character himself, is a caucasian man named Oroku Saki, who was born and raised as a ninja in Japan?
Does it meet your standards if the character is a white Japanese man?
CyberCubed
06-04-2013, 08:26 PM
No, he's either Japanese or bust.
You either do things right or you don't do them at all, that's my motto. I don't mind white Baxter, but a character like Shredder better be the nationality he's supposed to be.
Shark_Blade
06-04-2013, 09:14 PM
Cause they don't need Japanese actors?
Shreddhead
06-04-2013, 09:33 PM
Not that it really adds anything to the thread, but could you imagine if we got pirme Toshiro Mifune as the Shredder? That would be such a dream come true! You know he was offered the role of Darth Vader, but turned it down? Granted he IS my favorite Japanese actor of all time, but sitll.... He would have been AMAZING!
http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3799/8955382680_d82d23545e.jpg
NYShell
06-05-2013, 12:49 PM
Here's hoping for no white girl Karai at least.
Hoping Karai isn't a white girl. She isn't even necessary in this film.
And where is all this talk of racism coming from? We're just saying that they should be Japanese because that was the original source material, and they shouldn't make another garbage, whitewashed film. Stay true to the TMNT origin.
Cryomancer
06-05-2013, 10:07 PM
What if in this movie, the fictional Shredder character himself, is a caucasian man named Oroku Saki, who was born and raised as a ninja in Japan?
Does it meet your standards if the character is a white Japanese man?
In what way would this improve the movie at all? If the answer is "it doesn't", then why do it at all?
I don't have a problem with it conceptually as long as it has some sort of importance or relevance.
chrisdude
06-05-2013, 11:10 PM
In what way would this improve the movie at all? If the answer is "it doesn't", then why do it at all?
I don't have a problem with it conceptually as long as it has some sort of importance or relevance.I'm not saying there's a reason. Just a hypothetical.
Although, it could be a way to salvage Colonel Schrader.
shell4brains
06-06-2013, 01:13 AM
Hey everyone, I'm new here, and I found something kinda interesting a while ago that I wanted to share.
While doing some research on IMDB for the new movie, I came across a mysterious actress named Minae Noji under the cast and crew page. The interesting part is that she has a stunt double, but I can't seem to find any articles mentioning her as part of the movie itself. Perhaps Karai? Or maybe, we're getting a female Shredder? (nah, only kidding on that last one :tlol: .......)
Shreddhead
06-06-2013, 01:58 AM
Possibly a stunt double for Fox. Although stunt doubles can really be any sex. I remember in the film Catwoman, Halle Barry had a male stunt double.
chrisdude
06-06-2013, 07:55 AM
According to IMDB, it's Minae Noji who has a stunt double. And Minae Noji is 40 years old. Although this does all remind me of the female Foot, from the photos, I kind of doubt they'd have 40 year old play Karai. It's not that they can't, but why would they?
Candy Kappa
06-06-2013, 08:11 AM
I kind of doubt they'd have 40 year old play Karai. It's not that they can't, but why would they?
because not every character need to be Hollywoodized to a 20-something-year old we see almost every damn movie made?
Honestly, I'd love to see James Saito return as Shredder, but more screen time as Business man Oroku Saki and not over dubbed.
chrisdude
06-06-2013, 08:21 AM
because not every character need to be Hollywoodized to a 20-something-year old we see almost every damn movie made?
Honestly, I'd love to see James Saito return as Shredder, but more screen time as Business man Oroku Saki and not over dubbed.A 60 year old Shredder is the reason I wouldn't expect a 40 year old Karai. But hey, this actress does have a stunt double. It could mean as little as her character taking a hit at some point, or it could mean she's a full-blown ninja. Who knows?
jestermon
06-06-2013, 11:50 AM
No, no I am afraid if some one is from California they are Californian, the ceased being Japanese when they were born or gained American citizenship, as I said people will never stop being racist until everyone is viewed as an American not their specific races.
So I guess if I am born in Africa since I am a white man it makes me not African even though I would indeed be an African.
He is not Japanese, he has Japanese ancestors but is indeed and American from California.
Yes saying all ninjas have to be Japanese is racist, anyone can be a ninja.
Powder
06-06-2013, 12:45 PM
Your ethnicity doesn't change when you move out of the country. :trolleye:
Candy Kappa
06-06-2013, 12:55 PM
Yes saying all ninjas have to be Japanese is racist, anyone can be a ninja.
well, the Ninja does not exist, so no one can be a Ninja.
NYShell
06-06-2013, 01:04 PM
Possibly a stunt double for Fox. Although stunt doubles can really be any sex. I remember in the film Catwoman, Halle Barry had a male stunt double.
Good thing I didn't watch that movie. My eyes would've burned seeing an elderly man in a skintight, skimpy lady costume, even if it was for a couple of seconds.
TheOracle
06-06-2013, 01:39 PM
No, no I am afraid if some one is from California they are Californian, the ceased being Japanese when they were born or gained American citizenship, as I said people will never stop being racist until everyone is viewed as an American not their specific races.
So I guess if I am born in Africa since I am a white man it makes me not African even though I would indeed be an African.
He is not Japanese, he has Japanese ancestors but is indeed and American from California.
Yes saying all ninjas have to be Japanese is racist, anyone can be a ninja.
I obviously don't post here, just lurk a lot but your white male privilege is showing and starting to troll the forum with your ignorance. If you are not a POC, please stop posting about what racism is or isn't or how it affects you. Strong hint, pretending race shouldn't matter is something a non-POC says because race obviously bothers them and seeing racism around is an inconvenience. That in itself is being willfully ignorant and hiding racist tendancies. You have to start acknowledging that race and ethnicity do matter and whitewashing the world will obviously not ever work or happen. So please stop. We'd like to get back to a real discussion.
Matches Malone
06-06-2013, 01:48 PM
No, no I am afraid if some one is from California they are Californian, the ceased being Japanese when they were born or gained American citizenship, as I said people will never stop being racist until everyone is viewed as an American not their specific races.
So I guess if I am born in Africa since I am a white man it makes me not African even though I would indeed be an African.
He is not Japanese, he has Japanese ancestors but is indeed and American from California.
Yes saying all ninjas have to be Japanese is racist, anyone can be a ninja.
My parents moving here from China doesn't mean I stopped being Chinese, but I am now Chinese American. Saying we should all be viewed as American is a nice gesture, but do not imply that means we need to erase our cultural and ethnic heritage, because that is not something I want nor should do. Instead of pretending we have no differences, we should celebrate them. Recognizing cultural origins is not the same as being racist, though there are some who get that confused. The fact that it's already a rarity to find minorities in leading non-villain roles (except in "minority ethnic" movies, and maybe you should think about why that is), white-washing a good opportunity to utilize a minority is not something we should be advocating or act indifferent about.
shell4brains
06-06-2013, 05:19 PM
because not every character need to be Hollywoodized to a 20-something-year old we see almost every damn movie made?
Honestly, I'd love to see James Saito return as Shredder, but more screen time as Business man Oroku Saki and not over dubbed.
That's true. There's been plenty of times that they cast a 20-30 year old to play someone 5-10 yrs younger then what they really are.
What I find the most interesting is that if Minae Noji was in fact cast as Karai, we could possibly not have seen the full cast yet. After all, wasn't it supposedly an ''accident'' that Whoopi Goldberg was seen during filming?
sgtfbomb
06-06-2013, 05:24 PM
No, no I am afraid if some one is from California they are Californian, the ceased being Japanese when they were born or gained American citizenship, as I said people will never stop being racist until everyone is viewed as an American not their specific races.
So I guess if I am born in Africa since I am a white man it makes me not African even though I would indeed be an African.
He is not Japanese, he has Japanese ancestors but is indeed and American from California.
Yes saying all ninjas have to be Japanese is racist, anyone can be a ninja.
Oh man, people really need to pay attention in school. :roll:'
Japanese isn't just regarded as a nationality; it's also ethnicity. Technically, whether a person is Chinese or Japanese, he would be referred to as Asian American, but there is still a difference in ethnicity between Chinese and Japanese. A Japanese person born in the United States would be "American," but his ethnicity is still Japanese.
That is not racist. Stating the color of someone's skin or their ethnicity is not racist. Now, aggressively calling somebody a slur or judging them by a stereotype is racist. But to not be racist is not to ignore the ethnicity or color of one's skin; it's just simply a way to describe one's self. Ethnicity, race, and culture aren't things that should be wiped clean, but things that should be respected, admired, and recognized, as heritage.
But, that is neither here nor there. At the end of the day, if a Japanese family moves to California and have a baby, their baby is American by birthright, but of Japanese decent. That's just common sense. ;)
jestermon
06-06-2013, 05:39 PM
So other people and the person who started the thread can bash the franchise for being racist but after I point out that they traditionally haven't cast many Japanese actors and that they are not racist just because they didn't pick Japanese actors because the word ninja is in the title?
Whitewashing is very racist towards white people obviously people can throw that around since no one seems to care if it offends anyone.
Acknowledging your ancestry and throwing it in someone's face are 2 different things people can see very well what you are and just because you are a different ethnicity doesn't mean you should be any different from any other American.
I am sure for every person you find that takes offense to the notion that we can be one people and live together in a racist free environment, that there will be plenty of people that are minorities that will tell you they are proud to be Americans.
Maybe I should start a thread about why there are no Japanese actresses being cast for roles either?
And I don't know what a POC is but apparently you do and you have your own issues with whatever or whoever they are, and you speaking of my white male privilege is very racist not just to me but to yourself as a fellow American.
plastroncafe
06-06-2013, 05:53 PM
It seems to me that you are very new to being a part of the anti-racist movement, and that you might be better served listening rather than speaking.
It's the very definition of disrespectful for someone who is not in a minority position tell people who are how they should be identifying, and what their life experiences entail.
For people who don't understand why it's distressing that it appears as though characters of color are being white-washed in Platinum Dunes Turtle movie, I submit this explanation from Tumblr:
It all started with Donald Glover and Spiderman... (http://rurone.tumblr.com/post/51928068860/raptorific-timecannotberewritten)
jestermon
06-06-2013, 06:28 PM
Yet you can dictate that since I am a white American male that I can't possibly understand things, fantastic compromise there.
It seems you brought up and are trying to gauge my involvement/rank in a fictional "anti-racist movement" this would go great in the fan fiction section.
I simply don't think a movie is racist because it doesn't decide to cast certain actors.
There are tons of characters that are definitely white in established fiction that are turned to another race just to do it for no good reason.
Matches Malone
06-06-2013, 06:42 PM
Yet you can dictate that since I am a white American male that I can't possibly understand things, fantastic compromise there.
It seems you brought up and are trying to gauge my involvement/rank in a fictional "anti-racist movement" this would go great in the fan fiction section.
I simply don't think a movie is racist because it doesn't decide to cast certain actors.
There are tons of characters that are definitely white in established fiction that are turned to another race just to do it for no good reason.
I think there needs to be a little clarification of terms here, because I think many of us were raised in a time when "racism" or "sexism" were defined primarily as intentional and hateful acts towards people because of their race of gender ("I don't like you because you're black!"). However, while we have made some progress in these areas, racism in general, the unequal treatment of a race because of their race, is still ubiquitous. The concise explanation given in the link that plastron put up merely points out that, in media representation, there is an undeniable over-representation of whites and under-representation of minorities. Out of the movies you saw this year, how many had lead protagonists of color? Or were female? You say there's no good reason, but for some, helping to better represent different kinds of people so we don't all grow up identifying with primarily just one race or gender is a perfectly good reason. Those who are offended by this practice probably feel that way because it's change, rather than thinking about if this is a change for the better. Those who make these casting decisions most likely are coming from a similar position. Not out of malice for any race, but what feels normal. But if what feels "normal" is white males in everything, then there's something wrong.
By the way, POC stands for "person of color."
Candy Kappa
06-06-2013, 06:47 PM
I would love some examples where Caucasian characters are turned into other ethnicities for no good reason, and the character need to be ethnicity specific, like Blank Panther actually being a native African, Oroku saki being a Japanese man Or Max Manus being an actual Caucasian Norwegian.
Different guy under the superhero mask doesn't count, and remember Movie Nick Fury is based off Ultimate comics Fury, who had his likeness based of Sam Jackson, only a idiot would not cast Samuel if he wanted the part.
because, if ethnicity isn't a core thing for the character, like Perry in Superman, why not have him as a person of different color.
So other people and the person who started the thread can bash the franchise for being racist but after I point out that they traditionally haven't cast many Japanese actors and that they are not racist just because they didn't pick Japanese actors because the word ninja is in the title?
No actors of Japanese or even Asian decent have been officially released as cast. there is that one image of a lady with black hair that might be Asian, a Asian stunt actor is allegedly on the movie.
There are several characters within the TMNT story that are key essential to be Japanese, and again ninja is a japan thing, it's where it originated and if it would still exist, they would be primarily from Japan. Unless new recruits are taken from local areas the operate from.
Whitewashing is very racist towards white people obviously people can throw that around since no one seems to care if it offends anyone.
White washing is a thing, and have been going on for a long time.
heres a cute little list that shows but a few examples of white washing
http://www.complex.com/pop-culture/2013/03/25-minority-characters-that-hollywood-whitewashed/
The Avatar the last Airbender is a great example of white washing, where the main cast is dominantly Caucasian, while the background characters are more akin to the proper ethnicity the different peoples are based off.
chrisdude
06-06-2013, 07:06 PM
What I find the most interesting is that if Minae Noji was in fact cast as Karai, we could possibly not have seen the full cast yet. After all, wasn't it supposedly an ''accident'' that Whoopi Goldberg was seen during filming?That's what I keep saying. There's too much sound stage work. There's no telling who all is going to be in this movie, when new actors pop up on set every other week. Whoopi, Abbie Elliot, Daniel Bernhardt(sp). Those actors made it all the way to filming without being discovered, and were only discovered by filming in the open streets of NYC. Any actors or characters could have shot soundstage or other indoor scenes, and we'd have no idea.
And any of them could be Japanese.
zodiac brave
06-06-2013, 07:26 PM
I would love some examples where Caucasian characters are turned into other ethnicities for no good reason, and the character need to be ethnicity specific, like Blank Panther actually being a native African, Oroku saki being a Japanese man Or Max Manus being an actual Caucasian Norwegian.
cloud atlas. the cast each played between 4-6 characters throughout each of the 6 storylines that interwove in this flick.
specifically, one storyline was set in a korea of the future, in a city called neo seoul. (seriously...if it had taken place on a mountain, would they have called it alternative rock???)
The make-up was horrendous.
It's bad enough trying to make hugh grant, hugo weaving, jim sturgess and james darcy etc look korean, but keith david and halle berry? it was a stretch.
and ethnicity and country of origin are two totally different things. i'm a mexican-american born and raised in texas. when i apply for jobs, under ethnicity i choose "hispanic", but i am still an american.
is it really that hard to grasp?
oh! and maybe minae noji is tang shen?
jestermon
06-06-2013, 07:47 PM
Kingpin Daredevil, Captain James West in Wild Wild West, Django in Django, Heimdall in Thor
Off the top of my head in fictional movies.
Kingping was clearly a stereotypical New York Italian mob type character originally.
Captain James West was a Captain in the United States army in the tv show, the US army didn't integrate until 1948, so there would have been no black captains at that time period.
Django was a white cowboy in the west, ironically the new movie got rid of the Mexican element completely.
Heimdall was a god in Norse mythology he would have been well Norse.
The thing about the Avatar movie is that there were no races in that show, it was not based in our world and thus where were no eskimos, asians, whites, etc. they were either fire, water, earth, or wind nation, they never refer to anyone in an "ethnic" subgroup.
If anyone knows of any show that specifies anyone's race let me know.
Jester
06-06-2013, 08:16 PM
GeixtYS-P3s
TheOracle
06-06-2013, 08:24 PM
What Morgan Freeman or any other POC says regarding their own frustrations with how race is handled by others is well..they're own. He sure doesn't speak for all POC and it sure isn't something that should be used by anyone that's white to justify their racism.
Seriously, the ignorance and white privilege being shown by at least one here is disturbing.
TheOracle
06-06-2013, 08:30 PM
Kingpin Daredevil, Captain James West in Wild Wild West, Django in Django, Heimdall in Thor
Off the top of my head in fictional movies.
Kingping was clearly a stereotypical New York Italian mob type character originally.
Captain James West was a Captain in the United States army in the tv show, the US army didn't integrate until 1948, so there would have been no black captains at that time period.
Django was a white cowboy in the west, ironically the new movie got rid of the Mexican element completely.
Heimdall was a god in Norse mythology he would have been well Norse.
The thing about the Avatar movie is that there were no races in that show, it was not based in our world and thus where were no eskimos, asians, whites, etc. they were either fire, water, earth, or wind nation, they never refer to anyone in an "ethnic" subgroup.
If anyone knows of any show that specifies anyone's race let me know.
Those poor misrepresented white people. :P I thought this was covered already as to the hows and whys some very old stories with all whites have been updated to add in some POC. Its implied that if those stories were written today, we'd have a more diverse mix of races and not the limited, segregated world it used to represent.
There was a nice example of how many assume a character is white when the author clearly said they weren't, when Hunger Games came out in the theaters. There was this huge outcry when Rue was cast and way too many people were shocked to see this little black girl being cast. They just assumed she was white.
plastroncafe
06-06-2013, 08:30 PM
Yet you can dictate that since I am a white American male that I can't possibly understand things, fantastic compromise there.
You don't need any participation on my part for that.
It seems you brought up and are trying to gauge my involvement/rank in a fictional "anti-racist movement" this would go great in the fan fiction section.
So you don't believe there's an anti-racist movement in the United States.
I simply don't think a movie is racist because it doesn't decide to cast certain actors.
Bully for you?
There are tons of characters that are definitely white in established fiction that are turned to another race just to do it for no good reason.
I disagree. There are tons of characters that are defaulted to white in established canon.
Kingping was clearly a stereotypical New York Italian mob type character originally.
A racist depiction.
Captain James West was a Captain in the United States army in the tv show, the US army didn't integrate until 1948, so there would have been no black captains at that time period.
You're forgetting the Buffalo Soldiers.
The thing about the Avatar movie is that there were no races in that show, it was not based in our world and thus where were no eskimos, asians, whites, etc. they were either fire, water, earth, or wind nation, they never refer to anyone in an "ethnic" subgroup.
There are no white people in Avatar. Not a single one.
jestermon
06-06-2013, 09:25 PM
Again with these POC you keep talking about them or it like they are super cool though glad you think they are above normal Americans.
From the responses on this thread alone if there is a anti-racist movement none of you are part of it or actively trying to sabotage it by being very racist towards a particular group.
There are plenty of movies as well that feature an all or predominately black cast and they even have a separate section at some stores, these movies must be unrealistic as well, since they should be included in the rest of the movies not separated.
Indeed the Italian mobster stereotype is racist just as racist as every ninja having to be Japanese, there are multiple crime syndicates around the world of all races.
The people that wrote many of those Marvel characters lived in New York during times where these stereotypes were not just fiction.
Buffalo Soldiers were not part of the official US Army, look it up they were established under the The Bureau of Colored Troops, it was a separate entity that operated under the Army's control.
They were not recognized as part of the US Army until after the civil war and were still segregated, so don't quote history if you have no clue of the reality.
People can assign as many racist views to the fictional characters in Avatar as they want, it is a fictional universe with 4 tribes, never once mentions any race or shows racism.
The only thing they seem to hate/fear is people of the other tribes/nations they never once care about any one persons" race".
They clearly value their patriotism and unity as a single tribe and nation rather than their individual "race".
Candy Kappa
06-07-2013, 06:03 AM
It's bad enough trying to make hugh grant, hugo weaving, jim sturgess and james darcy etc look korean, but keith david and halle berry? it was a stretch.
Read my post I wrote character, not actor. Clearly I meant the other way around
.Kingping was clearly a stereotypical New York Italian mob type character originally.
Originally, originally Nick Fury is Caucasian, he does just fine as a African-American in the movies (his character is a terrible person in the Ultimate comics, so I'm glad he's more akin to the 616 version personality-wise)
There isn't really much that states Kingpin needs to be Caucasian, his back-story is that he rose from poverty to power at a fairly young age fueled by being bullied as a child. it is a very basics back-story that he could be of any ethnicity.
Captain James West was a Captain in the United States army in the tv show, the US army didn't integrate until 1948, so there would have been no black captains at that time period.
Right, that pile of dog crap. They also made the villain (Loveless) that was a dwarf into a completely different character, as a southerner that had lost his legs and sought vengeance on the North. The movie had a lot of wrongs, but by having a black protagonist they did showcase the racism going on during the times.
Django was a white cowboy in the west, ironically the new movie got rid of the Mexican element completely.
Django Freeman is a very different character then Django from the 1966 movie. Django Unchained is inspired from mroe then just the 1966 movie, but also from other films such as Mandingo,
Heimdall was a god in Norse mythology he would have been well Norse.
I am Norwegian, I care a lot for my ancestors deities. So I was intrigued and weirded out by that.
Now, Heimdall is a interesting god, he is the father of all social classes (slave, commoner, jarl) and is the god who guards Bifrost from the Jotunns. he is titles the whites of the gods and was specifically chosen to guard Bifrost because the was awesome. he barely needed sleep, could see 50 miles in the dark, could hear the grass grow and the wool in the sheep grow.
In short Heimdall is unique.
And what better way of visually show that by having him be different then the other gods, he is the only non white Asgardian (among the real Asgardians) clad in gold armor. Which is very complimentary and good looking on someone with such a dark skin color Idris Elba have, his eyes are gold, I don't think is teeth was gold though (which is something they should be)
In short I love the designs of Movie Heimdall. And, it is not far fetched that a Norse god can be of a different skin color the the Scandinavians. A lot of old depictions of the Norse gods show them with Asian characteristics, primarily their eyes, having historians muse that the people the Norse gods where based off could have come from Mongolia.
And the Norse people have met Africans, as well as Native Americana and Persians, since the Vikings did sail to many places.
The thing about the Avatar movie is that there were no races in that show, it was not based in our world and thus where were no eskimos, asians, whites, etc. they were either fire, water, earth, or wind nation, they never refer to anyone in an "ethnic" subgroup.
But the nations are based off various ethnicities, such as the Water tribe being based off the Inuit and of what I've gathered are Ethnically homogeneous. So isn't it a bit weird that Katara, Sokka and their grandmother is the only Caucasians in the entire tribe in the Live-action movie.
Smells a bit:
http://tinyheroes.files.wordpress.com/2010/07/avatar_the_last_airbender_r1.jpg
If anyone knows of any show that specifies anyone's race let me know.
The show Shinsengumi!. Would be wrong if Okita Sōji was played by a white guy or Harada Sanosuke played by a black guy. And TMNT, Oroku Saki, Hamato Yoshi and Karai are all Japanese natives
And then theres Shaft, granted a movie, but still.
Speaking of movies, Fist of Fury. Bruce lee plays the role of Chen Zhen, dealing with the death of Huo Yuanjia, set in China and the characters are native Chinese. The movie Fearless where jet Li plays Huo Yuanjia. Or Seven Samurai, all characters are Japanese and played by Japanese people.
How odd would it be if The Magnificent Seven was a complete Remake of Seven Samurai but just with actors of wrong ethnicity (a Samurai movie instead of a gunslinger movie)
jestermon
06-07-2013, 08:13 AM
So I named several examples of movie characters that were changed then you make up a reason that explains how they could have been changed anyways that nullifies you asking me to name several characters that were changed for no good reason.
You said Nick Fury got re-written into a black guy so I couldn't mention that example, so I do say someone that was not re-written and then you say it could have been changed to anyone, but logically I that was a reason for Fury not to be black in the movie by your own logic it makes no sense why they changed Kingpin.
It doesn't matter if it's a pile of dog crap I am sure some people have no love for Ninja Turtles, didn't mention Loveless because they didn't change his ethnicity and wasn't relevant to the conversation,I was specifically referring to the character that was changed as requested by you.
None of those make any sense to change, and of course Vikings knew of different races but it still makes no sense they picked a black guy for the movie, since Norse Gods were Norse heroes.
Of course Django was a different character but it was still a fictional character that was changed for no good reason, and as I said they got rid of the Mexicans all together.
Again Katara,Sokka,Zuko are never named as a certain race in their fictional world, and if you do try to assign any races to these characters it's projecting our racial views onto a blank canvas.
If anyone knows of any show that specifies anyone's race let me know. I meant any of the Avatar episodes, they never once mention race in it, of course some show somewhere has mentioned a character's race.
Again someone took something that was not racist and skewed it towards their own agenda.
Candy Kappa
06-07-2013, 09:33 AM
Again Katara,Sokka,Zuko are never named as a certain race in their fictional world, and if you do try to assign any races to these characters it's projecting our racial views onto a blank canvas.
But the characters comes from specific tribes, that have specific looks and appearances modeled after real life cultures and ethnicities.
All the background characters more or less fits the tribes based-off appearances, so why not most of the main cast?
plastroncafe
06-07-2013, 10:52 AM
Shh. No one mention that Chinese is the written language, or that http://atla-annotated.tumblr.com/ exists.
And maybe, just maybe, if we're lucky someone will find White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack
by Peggy McIntosh (http://ted.coe.wayne.edu/ele3600/mcintosh.html) on their own.
zodiac brave
06-07-2013, 01:10 PM
Read my post I wrote character, not actor. Clearly I meant the other way around.
ah, i misread.
how bout john leguizamo as luigi in the mario bros movie?
Candy Kappa
06-07-2013, 01:23 PM
oh, good one.
Reading up on him, apparently his grandfather was of Italian decent...
jestermon
06-07-2013, 05:42 PM
So just because some one writes in Chinese that makes them Chinese?
Ok, so I took Spanish in high school I must be Hispanic, that's a fantastic argument there.
It was a fictional universe with a writing style picked by the creators of the show, that must mean by your logic if everyone in all the nations and tribes read the same language they were all Chinese.
And I refuse to read any of this white privilege stuff, minorities assume there are no poor white people and it's just not true, guess they don't believe in trailer parks and other low income white people.
It's not my issue that you have to make up a fictional ideal to perpetuate hate on another race so you can make yourself feel worse about your own people for no reason, that is counter productive to this anti-racism movement you guys have founded.
Ok, so now Hispanic people can't be plumbers in movies either, being well established as Italian plumbers in all the media prior to the movie, maybe if they had made one black it would make it more realistic somehow?
Even John Leguizamo who was very vocal and proud of his ethnicity had no issue in playing an Italian plumber in a game movie, since it's just a movie for entertainment and not a major earth shattering even in history as you people make things out to be.
And no in many of the nations on Avatar they were people of different colors and no one seemed to view them as anything but one of the 4 nations, there were people of all skin tones and no one once mentions race, well except for everyone that complains about it in the real world.
Yeah, I don't get the white guilt thing, either. I've never been unable to relate to someone because they weren't Hispanic. I've even been able to relate to females.
zodiac brave
06-07-2013, 06:29 PM
Ok, so now Hispanic people can't be plumbers in movies either, being well established as Italian plumbers in all the media prior to the movie, maybe if they had made one black it would make it more realistic somehow?
Even John Leguizamo who was very vocal and proud of his ethnicity had no issue in playing an Italian plumber in a game movie, since it's just a movie for entertainment and not a major earth shattering even in history as you people make things out to be.
i was just answering candy kappa's question. i didnt say anything like "Hispanic people can't be plumbers". i simply offered a response to his question about what characters had been changed ethnically for no apparent reason.
keep ranting, though. im sure eventually you'll accidentally stumble onto something that doesn't make you sound kinda ignorant.
...or you wont.
:trolleye:
Shreddhead
06-07-2013, 06:46 PM
I dont know if calling the Mario Bros film a "movie for entertainment" is really the way to go...
The Stryker
06-07-2013, 07:02 PM
Yeah, I don't get the white guilt thing, either. I've never been unable to relate to someone because they weren't Hispanic. I've even been able to relate to females.
I agree with you there. I never worry about 'racial quotas' like it actually matters.
No black people in the movie? Okay then. Cool.
jestermon
06-07-2013, 07:03 PM
I didn't say you sad that Zodaiac, but I was talking aobut cappa according to him if there isn't a specific reason some one has to be a certain race it's fine to replace them with whatever you want.
So in his reasoning even thought they are supposed to be Italian plumbers in the fiction since they are plumbers it means that it's fine to have a Columbian born actor with a small percentile of his ethnicity being Italian ok.
Even after he asked me for examples he was not happy when I actually listed them.
I thought it was good (Super Mario Brothers) I don't know what people expected it was a game movie, people knew they would make up things to fill out the movie, they wouldn't just go hitting boxes and have had a silent movie with the music in the background.
I grew up poor in the middle of a field the son of a brick mason and it sickens me to think there are people that think I am keeping them down with my white privilege even though they perpetuate these ludicrous white stereotypes and putting down their own people.
The Stryker
06-07-2013, 07:07 PM
I grew up poor in the middle of a field the son of a brick mason and it sickens me to think there are people that think I am keeping them down with my white privilege even though they perpetuate these ludicrous white stereotypes and putting down their own people.
I agree with this too. You kinda crazy sometimes dawg but yeah. It's alittle nuts.
TheOracle
06-07-2013, 08:12 PM
I grew up poor in the middle of a field the son of a brick mason and it sickens me to think there are people that think I am keeping them down with my white privilege even though they perpetuate these ludicrous white stereotypes and putting down their own people.
No one said putting them down. No one is implying or assuming that you are openly and willingly being this overbearing white guy. That's not what white privilege is. White (and male) privilege is a set of privileges what you have as a white man that someone of color doesn't have. You are the majority. Argue with that and you are being willfully ignorant. You might be poor, but that is a result of your circumstances, not your race. All too often, people's status are a direct result of their sex, race, sexual orientation, etc. This is why we have the EEOC. It was needed because the US government recognized that people were purposely not given jobs based on their minority status. You are a white male, have the best possible advantage when it comes to someone not judging you based on something you can't control. Add Christian in there and you have the trifecta of privilege.
If you were applied for the same job as a black Muslim woman, you'd be more likely to get the job and have less judgements passed on you than your competition. Its unfair, it sucks but its honestly still happens...frequently.
Acknowledging this white privilege you have doesn't make you a bad person or a racist, it is in fact acknowledging the unfairness and bigotry in the world that still exists. We have been trying to show you in that in the media, it still very much exists. When confronted with this fact, denying make you look like a racist bigot. You choose to not see what in right in front of you because you believe ignoring it or being blind to it will make it better. It doesn't. It negatively affects the plight people of color by ignoring them and what they still have to deal with on a daily basis.
You are not a racist. I honestly believe that. However you have to stop denying what is actual fact. People can be closet racist a-holes, or of course openly racist or bigoted. Don't ignore it. Don't play it off as something that happened years ago. Its still happening.
Jester
06-07-2013, 08:24 PM
Talk to me about "Male Privilege" when selective service requirements for men are repealed or equally applied to women. Or when men can work with kids without fear of them being a pedophile. Or men have equal custody rights to their children. Or when rape and domestic violence laws are equally applied to both genders.
TheOracle
06-07-2013, 08:37 PM
Talk to me about "Male Privilege" when selective service requirements for men are repealed or equally applied to women. Or when men can work with kids without fear of them being a pedophile. Or men have equal custody rights to their children. Or when rape and domestic violence laws are equally applied to both genders.
You're right on some of those matters but don't bring rape into this and how you poor guys are so oppressed in that matter. Seriously, I'm starting to rethink my last paragraph or at least rethink that you're willfully ignorant and blind. Please give me an example of how YOU have been treated unfairly because of your minority status and I'll rethink that. And no, being poor is not a protected minority status. People might treat you like turd, I get that but that's not the same as being a woman, gay or a POC.
If you can't, then you're talking about hypotheticals you have no experience with and are talking out of your butt. No experience = not qualified.
Jester
06-07-2013, 09:01 PM
Well listen to you! Telling me I can't do something because of the color of my skin! You're the racist!
That quote may be hyperbole, but this whole thing is getting out of hand. The last post was mostly devil's advocacy, but by constantly seeing things as keeping you down because you're a "protected minority" is a crutch. I'm sure if Oprah or Dr. Ben Carson or heck President Obama had felt they were victims they wouldn't be a successful media mogul, a gifted neurosurgeon, or a the flippin' president of the most powerful nation on earth.
thebrownranger
06-07-2013, 09:04 PM
It upsets me that the movie seems whitewashed, especially with The Foot clan. Would love to see the new movie have a bit more "ethnic spice". Hoping some things at least will change before the release.
My parents moving here from China doesn't mean I stopped being Chinese, but I am now Chinese American. Saying we should all be viewed as American is a nice gesture, but do not imply that means we need to erase our cultural and ethnic heritage, because that is not something I want nor should do. Instead of pretending we have no differences, we should celebrate them. Recognizing cultural origins is not the same as being racist, though there are some who get that confused. The fact that it's already a rarity to find minorities in leading non-villain roles (except in "minority ethnic" movies, and maybe you should think about why that is), white-washing a good opportunity to utilize a minority is not something we should be advocating or act indifferent about.
:tthumbsu: +1
Katie
06-07-2013, 09:20 PM
I think pointing out quotas is way more racist/sexist than people who make a film and don't make sure they cover their quiltbag quota.
Ending racism and sexism starts with the parents making sure the kid knows that skin color and gender have nothing to do with abilities. After people realize that, who cares what an actor in a role looks like.
Also, privlege has much more to do with your socio-economic background than your race. True, minorities tend to be lower down that ladder than anglos on average because of generational passing of wealth, but let me tell you that living in Alabama today, poor white and poor black....poor woman, man, latino, whatever. Same issues. Wealthy of any of the same classes. Same issues.
Opportunity exists if you are willing to work for it. I'm a perfect example of a lower class poor female who chose not to stay in my socio economic situation and am going to be much better off than my parents even dreamed was possible.
Jester
06-07-2013, 09:23 PM
:tthumbsu: Jester likes this.
TheOracle
06-07-2013, 09:34 PM
I think pointing out quotas is way more racist/sexist than people who make a film and don't make sure they cover their quiltbag quota.
Ending racism and sexism starts with the parents making sure the kid knows that skin color and gender have nothing to do with abilities. After people realize that, who cares what an actor in a role looks like.
Also, privlege has much more to do with your socio-economic background than your race. True, minorities tend to be lower down that ladder than anglos on average because of generational passing of wealth, but let me tell you that living in Alabama today, poor white and poor black....poor woman, man, latino, whatever. Same issues. Wealthy of any of the same classes. Same issues.
Opportunity exists if you are willing to work for it. I'm a perfect example of a lower class poor female who chose not to stay in my socio economic situation and am going to be much better off than my parents even dreamed was possible.
So your experience speaks for all women? I'm pretty sure the numerous studies current and past show you're wrong. I'm pretty sure the fact that women working in the Silicone Valley currently make 70% less that their male counterparts. I'm pretty sure that numerous actions taken against employers by women (and then they've won) show you're experience while awesome, doesn't speak for the female sex on a whole.
Because Zachary Quinto is a gay man making millions of dollars as Spock and has had the work ethic to get there doesn't mean all gay males who have been abused, bullied and afraid are slackers and have no work ethic. Women who are subject to harrassment just need to STFU and take it because that's poor work ethic to speak out.
That is what you're implying. Work hard and it means you won't be discriminated against. Working hard and getting a job means you worked harder than someone else and that person in obviously lazy and angry. That's all it boils down to. STFU and be a team player, right?
Jester
06-07-2013, 09:42 PM
So.....I can't speak, because I am a white, Christian, male and have that privilege blinding me...
...and Katie can't speak because, "results not typical"?
What a joke...
TheOracle
06-07-2013, 09:48 PM
Because no one was saying positive movement isn't happening. Your examples of Pres. Obama and Oprah are examples of what couldn't happen 50 years ago. Super cool. However that isn't the benchmark that should be applied. When a black president doesn't get this "holy crap it finally happened!!!" response, we're getting closer. When we don't see a huge investigation into the US Military and the sexual assaults that are happening, we're getting closer. When we don't have to have a 6 page long thread of why there aren't more POC in movies, we are getting closer.
We aren't there yet. Agreeing that we aren't there yet is that step. Wanting to stop taking steps...you don't move forward. You remain stagnant.
Katie
06-07-2013, 09:51 PM
My whole point is that anyone can choose to change their situation in life. Regardless of color gender sexual orientation creed or any other factor that people use as an excuse as to why they aren't successful. That's really all it is. An excuse.
No one is entitled to be a success. It takes work. Maybe you run into some idiots along the way. Can't change that. There's always gonna be idiots that think you can't do something because of color gender whatever. Know what you do? Ignore them cause they are idiots. If you prove you are worth your stuff, people notice.
Jester
06-07-2013, 09:55 PM
Constantly stamping victim hood on any and all minorities is what stagnates. If we stop seeing people as black or gay or male or female and just see them as someone who is capable of doing a job, we're there. But what's the point of striving to be the best you can when you can "cop out" and claim victim status and be handed things.
TheOracle
06-07-2013, 10:12 PM
Constantly stamping victim hood on any and all minorities is what stagnates. If we stop seeing people as black or gay or male or female and just see them as someone who is capable of doing a job, we're there. But what's the point of striving to be the best you can when you can "cop out" and claim victim status and be handed things.
You're missing the point and I have no idea when anyone was saying minorities wait for hand outs and blame everything on being a minority. I think that's your resentment speaking out. We're talking about equality, that's the theme of the thread. And people ARE gay, black, asian, indian, transgender, etc. You should not ever NOT see that in someone. That is their identity and many take pride in that, even if it make them a minority. However, what you do expect them to do? Pretend they aren't gay? Pretend a woman doesn't ever get judged or looked up and down like a piece of meat when they walk into a male dominated room? Pretend things aren't happening when they clearly are? At what point do you realize things aren't right and need to stop? You cannot pretend something doesn't exist and it will magically go away. I as a woman would have never gotten the right to vote or get a job that means anything if someone down the line didn't stand up and make a stink. Obama would have never gotten to be president if 1,000's of steps hadn't been taken before him.
And Katie, as much as that applies to everyone, it doesn't work for everyone. No one should have to work harder than another just so they can make it in the world. No one should have to over compensate. I think that's where it gets messy. There have been studies that show in white collar professions that require a degree, women have more Masters than men. Meaning men can get by with a BA or BS when women will have to "prove" themselves by getting a higher education just to compete.
Katie
06-07-2013, 10:23 PM
Maybe.....but so what? I have my masters. I'm about three classes away from finishing a doctorate. Not because I felt that I needed that to compete....but because I wanted to better myself.
I worked my ass off to get where I am and I am not some atypical female. I'm rather run of the mill. If I can achieve success any woman can.
If a gay man becomes a multimillionaire by creating his own business, why on earth is he somehow atypical of any other gay man in the world? He made an opportunity for himself....why can't anyone else?
IMHO it is much more derrogatory to insinuate that successful females....minorities.....GLTB....whatever are exceptions to some rule rather than accepting the fact that anyone has the choice to make their own success in life.
Jester
06-07-2013, 10:31 PM
I'm not saying people shouldn't be proud of who they are, I'm just saying in an environment where equality is expected, like employment, qualifications should matter over anything else. You are not going to take the necessary steps to meet those qualifications if you constantly see yourself as oppressed. It's self defeating on it's face. Things like affirmative action would seem to be just as offensive because it says, "You 'protected minority' would never be able to succeed on an even playing field, so we put in place quotas so that X number of Y are represented." That's ridiculous.
chrisdude
06-07-2013, 10:38 PM
I'm not saying people shouldn't be proud of who they are, I'm just saying in an environment where equality is expected, like employment, qualifications should matter over anything else. You are not going to take the necessary steps to meet those qualifications if you constantly see yourself as oppressed. It's self defeating on it's face. Things like affirmative action would seem to be just as offensive because it says, "You 'protected minority' would never be able to succeed on an even playing field, so we put in place quotas so that X number of Y are represented." That's ridiculous.It's only ridiculous if you assume the even playing field exists. And that qualifications would matter over anything else, without outside regulation. I don't think affirmative action is fair, but unless you're willing to claim racism and sexism are dead, it's probably more fair than the alternative.
Katie
06-07-2013, 11:20 PM
And I'm not saying that racism sexism etc don't exist, I'm saying that people absolutely have the means to be successful despite those idiots out there. You can't just ruminate on why a company hired a 21 yr old fratboy over you....you gotta laugh at them for their dumb mistake and go apply with their competition.
So many of the people who beat the drum of inequality are people who are looking for someone other than themselves to blame for their failure to succeed. Also people fresh out of (or still in) women's studies or black studies or gay studies classes in college who have ZERO experience in real businesses or managing the idiots. All they have is stories and the idea that everyone in the world is out to see them fail.....but it's ok. Not your fault. The man is keeping you down.
Get a entry level job...get out there and work...come back in 10 years and tell me how that lawsuit you filed about pay inequality helped advance your career better than hard work did.
Powder
06-08-2013, 02:11 AM
Those with green skin are quite obviously privileged. They get to eat all the pizza they want, play with weapons, wear very little clothes, and get no flack for any of it! :tmad:
jestermon
06-08-2013, 10:37 AM
In the first movie all the foot were teenagers from NY, pretty sure Tetsu was the only one that was "ethnic" in those scenes in the skate place and dojo and according to Danny they were all random kids from the streets.
I think it was like when Toyata or other foreign company has their American branches they have a Japanese boss and outsource the workers instead of bringing them over.
I think I wasn't handed any special privileges I worked hard in middle and high school went to college (still up to my eyes in student debt) failed out the last class in my 3-d animation ran out of hope grant money and sill managed to get a graphic design/3-d art job.
If you are a minority it is keeping your own self and your people down by saying that their are other groups better or more entitled than you.
Also, when applying for college trying to find the white male scholarship programs was impossible, now if you were a black/latino woman you could get free everything.
And yes if you imply all white males have special white privileges to succeed at any aspect of life you are saying that there are no poor whites since we can bat our white eyelashes and over come any socioeconomical issues, you can't have it both ways and say one thing is 100% true then take it back when you find a case that doesn't fit your criteria.
Also living in Alabama, originally from Georgia there is little difference between poor black, hispanic, and white areas, I don't see anyone having any special privileges in those areas but just a lot of hard times.
Even though it is sexist I think the ultimate idea behind the male only selective service is the fact that in a long term war we would need more babies to fill the empty spots in the ranks.
Powder they also don't get the large man gut issues that people get, I don't want to be speciesism, it could be due to their youth and athletics or just good genetics.
NYShell
06-08-2013, 11:28 AM
My parents moving here from China doesn't mean I stopped being Chinese, but I am now Chinese American. Saying we should all be viewed as American is a nice gesture, but do not imply that means we need to erase our cultural and ethnic heritage, because that is not something I want nor should do. Instead of pretending we have no differences, we should celebrate them. Recognizing cultural origins is not the same as being racist, though there are some who get that confused. The fact that it's already a rarity to find minorities in leading non-villain roles (except in "minority ethnic" movies, and maybe you should think about why that is), white-washing a good opportunity to utilize a minority is not something we should be advocating or act indifferent about.
This statement holds the most truth out of anything anyone has ever said on this forum. I agree with this completely. Much respect for this truth. :tsmile:
Matches Malone
06-08-2013, 05:21 PM
Well this thread went into some deep territory! While I don't know if anyone's minds will be changed, I do want to try and bridge the gap a bit and focus on what we can all understand, if not agree. The whole affirmative action stuff just complicates stuff, so I'm just going to focus more on what I think the reality is, and not the best means to solve them.
I can't speak for anyone but myself, so to me, the concept of white privilege is the suggestion that we live in a society that institutionally favors white folks (straight and male are even better). Again, institutionalized racism (or sexism, or homophobia, etc) is a complex thing and it isn't to imply that this only happens maliciously or intentionally. It just means it is part of our society, whether it be our legal system (i.e. Chinese Exclusion Act, segregation, etc.) or in a culture of marginalization. We may no longer have laws that persecute minorities, but we, as a culture, still ignore and marginalize them. Just one example, look at the leader of our society: the president. For 230 years, every single president of our country has been white, straight, and male. Now, he's half-white, straight, and male, and not without controversy, might I add. That's not to say there is anything wrong with being any of these traits, especially since I am 2 out of 3 (I'll let you guess which 2!). What's wrong is when we are limited to these traits. But ask yourself, why is it there is so little variation when our country is the melting pot of races, religions, etc.? There may be a different opinion, but you're only kidding yourself if you suggest it's a coincidence. I honestly can't think of a better explanation than it is because this reflects our collective values: that we value these few traits more and are only beginning to think of a good leader outside of someone who is white, straight, and male (WSM). The other traits, we have yet to even see in 2013. Looking at our track record, can you even imagine an LGBT woman president? Neither can an LGBT woman, most likely, and that's the problem. In entertainment there is a bit more diversity, but even there, how many famous actors or musicians are Asian, LGBT, etc? It's not the source of all of their problems, but it's a problem if we say we value equality (not sameness) but our actions do not reflect it. Growing up primarily seeing WSM role models, we are unspokenly passing on the idea that this is what looks normal. We need a new normal. Ever hear of Plato's cave allegory? (Yeah, as if I haven't earned enough pretense cred) It's the story of people who lived in a cave their whole lives and only saw shadows from the fire. They believed the shadows were actual people because they never saw any real people. That was their reality, and this is ours when what we see is so narrow and focused on WSM. This is a learned value, albeit implicitly, that we need to challenge and look at in ourselves to see if we are contributing to this trend. If you see individuals who buck the trend, that's great, but that doesn't mean the trend no longer exists.
It's intrinsically easier to say, "who cares" when it doesn't or no longer affects you. That's the definition of privilege. The rich person says the poor person doesn't have it so bad. The straight person says the gay person doesn't have it so bad. It doesn't mean those who are privileged don't have valid opinions. It just means it's important to acknowledge that certain opinions are certainly easier to have. It's not to make you feel bad, but to put things in perspective for those who may not be suffering or marginalized the way others are. I have no idea at what point we can say "x% of senators/film stars are minorities, we've made it!" We may never get to say that, I don't know. An arbitrary quota makes me uncomfortable too, so I won't say we need x more minorities seen, but I can say that we can stand to have more. In the 90's we had all these token minorities, and it felt really awkward and contrived, even disingenuous. But you know what? It sent us a message that diversity is normal, and now diversity doesn't feel nearly as awkward to integrate into a story, because it's being written by those kids who grew up, and that's progress. But we're not there yet.
EDIT: Also wanted to address the idea that there is a suggestion of double standards here. Am I advocating something for one group of people over another? Yes, but we're also talking about one group of people who have problems that another group doesn't. Again, speaking in broad strokes here, so this is not to say WSM don't have any problems, just that they are much less likely due to an institutionalized prejudice.
It upsets me that the movie seems whitewashed, especially with The Foot clan. Would love to see the new movie have a bit more "ethnic spice". Hoping some things at least will change before the release.
:tthumbsu: +1
This statement holds the most truth out of anything anyone has ever said on this forum. I agree with this completely. Much respect for this truth. :tsmile:
Thanks friends!
Candy Kappa
06-09-2013, 03:35 AM
But in the end, Oroku Saki/Shredder should be played by an actor that could pass for Japanese, or better yet be Japanese descendant. ;)
NYShell
06-09-2013, 04:47 AM
This thread got into deep conversation somehow. I can only speak for myself too, and I have to agree with what Matches Malone said. This video talks more about everything that was said. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8SIINVfqnxw&feature=youtube_gdata_player You guys should watch the whole thing.
And yeah, I think it would be better if Shredder and the Foot were asian/ninjas and all that good stuff just like in the comics. :tsmile:
jestermon
06-09-2013, 12:32 PM
In the original comic were there just the foot clan ninja or did they also have other random local thugs doing things for them?
I didn't know in the comic how established the Foot were in America since I had got into turtles from the cartoon.
Didn't know if Shredder was in charge of the ninjas then the ninjas had more ninjas under them or local guys.
Matches Malone
06-09-2013, 01:51 PM
And yeah, I think it would be better if Shredder and the Foot were asian/ninjas and all that good stuff just like in the comics. :tsmile:
Or you know, even having "normal" people played by Asians in the movie would be neat. I know you didn't mean it that way, but just want to point out that there doesn't always have to be a reason to cast an Asian.
In the original comic were there just the foot clan ninja or did they also have other random local thugs doing things for them?
I didn't know in the comic how established the Foot were in America since I had got into turtles from the cartoon.
Didn't know if Shredder was in charge of the ninjas then the ninjas had more ninjas under them or local guys.
In the original Mirage comics, the Foot clan was strictly a clan of ninjas. I want to say they may have occasionally utilized thugs for certain tasks, but I honestly can't recall that ever actually happening. And even if they did, I'm sure those thugs were in no way considered part of the clan. They did use wacky guns and machines in Return To New York, and City At War, though. Always thought that was neat since TMNT has always been a hodge podge of stuff.
CyberCubed
06-09-2013, 06:05 PM
No, in Mirage the New York branch of the Foot weren't all Japanese ninja's. They were kids who used guns and grew up in NYC like Movies 1 and 2 showed.
Read Tales #46 where it shows a Foot initiate tell his story of joining the Foot.
Matches Malone
06-09-2013, 06:23 PM
No, in Mirage the New York branch of the Foot weren't all Japanese ninja's. They were kids who used guns and grew up in NYC like Movies 1 and 2 showed.
Read Tales #46 where it shows a Foot initiate tell his story of joining the Foot.
I guess you're right, but up until Tales vol 2, there's was never any insight into how the Foot were recruited. But even then, those recruited became ninjas. They were thugs from the Purple Dragons or anything.
NYShell
06-09-2013, 08:37 PM
Or you know, even having "normal" people played by Asians in the movie would be neat. I know you didn't mean it that way, but just want to point out that there doesn't always have to be a reason to cast an Asian.
Yeah that's true. I'm Indian, and I don't see many indian actors/actresses cast as "normal" people in television and movies. If they're casted, its always an Indian specific role, or something that points to their "Indian-ness".
Candy Kappa
06-10-2013, 01:38 AM
If Shredder, establishes a Foot unit in NY it would be natural if he had some Foot members with him, and the over time expand the numbers when he is in NY by recruiting locals with a interest for the Clan.
Did that in Mirage it seems, as well as in the movies and in the Nick show most of the Foot in NY are indicated to be the guys Bradford trained before Shredder came to New York.
jestermon
06-10-2013, 12:16 PM
If you mean the sub continent in Weeds there is and Indian guy that's in there he talks about Indian beliefs but it's just when he's talking to people about personal things.
I don't feel like the guy in the Big Bang Theory is there to be the token Indian, he is an Indian from India, so it makes sense his parents are Indians so obviously he would talk about some of his beliefs/being Indian at some point.
Also, both guys are main characters, the guy on BBT more so.
plastroncafe
06-10-2013, 01:35 PM
Talk to me about "Male Privilege" when selective service requirements for men are repealed or equally applied to women. Or when men can work with kids without fear of them being a pedophile. Or men have equal custody rights to their children. Or when rape and domestic violence laws are equally applied to both genders.
If you want to, I'll totally take you up on this, Jester.
:D
Not here, as that'd be a derail of the thread. But anywhere else, just let me know.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.