View Full Version : Question about LGBT characters in the IDW comics.
The Big Bad
06-15-2013, 10:57 AM
Since I'm not reading the IDW books with any sort of regularity--the last arcs I bought were the space arc and the Foot Clan mini--I'm curious: have any gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender characters been introduced in the series since it began? If there haven't been, has there been any word about whether the licensors at Nickelodeon would allow them to do so if they wanted to?
Venom
06-15-2013, 12:42 PM
Who knows, sexuality isn't really a topic of focus when it comes to the Turtles and their associates.
Woody may have been. Possibly Baxter; even Old Hob or Dax - who knows?!
If the mutant frogs do show up, or an iteration of Mona Lisa, they could play with the ability to change sexes due to environment thing, but it would be for kicks, which IDW seems to have more integrity than that.
Cipher
06-15-2013, 01:17 PM
None yet, although, to be fair, we don't really have confirmation of plenty of characters' sexual orientations. Could Baxter be gay? Sure could be! Who knows.
I do know that IDW as a company doesn't have any issue with it, though, as openly gay characters have shown up in other titles (and been treated very well). I also doubt this is anything Nickelodeon would veto, as the backlash for doing so if word got out would be huge.
corvus
06-15-2013, 01:30 PM
Tmnt is the one comic that I don't think is necessary for any LGBT characters to show up or for existing ones sexuality to be discussed because relationships aren't a big part of it. When it comes to things like X-Men, where relationships were a big part I think its important that LGBT see someone they can relate to or admire (Anole, northstar) but unlike most superheroes the turtles being heterosexual has never really been a huge part of the story.
CyberCubed
06-15-2013, 03:27 PM
Does it really matter? It seems both April and Angel have a thing for Casey so I suppose they're straight.
Although I would certainly enjoy Angel flirting with April to get Casey's attention, but it doesn't seem like they're going down that route.
In case they add LGBT characters in the future, I hope they will have a good reason for them, not just because others do it, or for the sake of doing it. And if they gonna do, I hope they won't make them stereotypes.
Vi11AiN6
06-16-2013, 08:29 AM
I do not care nor is there a need for ANY "sexuality" in the TMNT comics.
This is like saying "where are the gay characters in Star Wars or Transformers"
Why does this need to be explored in a comic book?
Why ? What does it matter? If we are going to explore homosexual characters the why not explore jewish characters and handicapped characters.
I don't ever want to see any of the turtles explore romance. April/Casey/Angel is enough to deal with in a comic of mutants, aliens, and ninjas.
Too bad for you, there's already Shredder/Kitsune and Mikey/Neutrino princess. (ah and Victor and the ex-savate boss' woman, but never mind that)
And by the way: Sexuality is about the most determining, and influential thing for humanity, most of mankind's motivations can be tracked back to it, so why should they leave it out, making the story more of an irrealistic fable than it should be? Tho I don't want turtles to be sexually attracted to other species either, that doesn't makes much sense. But I wouldn't mind this thing actually explored in the comics, like how they the only on of their kind, the hopelessness of ever finding their female counterpart, and basically being alone forever for example. In vol.4 Mikey and the dinosaur alien girl, was the border-line case for me: strange, but I could live with something like that.
CyberCubed
06-16-2013, 09:52 AM
Maybe Hun is gay in this version.
Slade
06-16-2013, 11:45 AM
I'm just going to say this and be done with it. I hate this topic in comics and I don't want any of this in the Turtles. I worry that something like this will happen and IDW(I don't think they would) would create another male turtle and have one of the guys turn out gay and I'd have wasted a good bit of money because I'd never finish reading.
Not trying to make that sound like I'm against gay people or anything, I just wouldn't enjoy reading something like that.
Donatello is gay, and will date with Hun.
Vi11AiN6
06-16-2013, 01:34 PM
I have no problem with gay characters in the rights, X-men, WildCATS have had gay characters. I'm simply stating I don't want ANY sexuality gay or straight explored in my TMNT!!!
I don't care if it's simple attraction like Casey and April, but I don't want to know anything sexual about these characters. Go read Vertigo comics for that.
In closing I will say this: You want gay characters in TNNT?
Just go back and watch the OT! Krang and Shredder were the gayest duo who couldn't do anything without each other
I don't want to know anything sexual about these characters.
Why is that?
***First of Two Latin Kings***
06-16-2013, 02:13 PM
How do we know that Angel's tension towards April means that she has feelings for Casey? Couldn't she just care for Casey as a friend, and be frustrated at April because she is interested in HER? Just a thought... by I honestly don't see why this sort of thing is important. We haven't seen any tension of a sexual nature between Raph and Alopex (even though she was obviously created as an homage to Ninjara), nor have we seen the classic "Leonardo likes Karai" motif in this series yet. Not done to the extent it usually is, anyway.
Cipher
06-16-2013, 02:30 PM
nor have we seen the classic "Leonardo likes Karai" motif in this series yet. Not done to the extent it usually is, anyway.
You mean "usually" as in just the last two cartoons, the only places it's ever existed?
Unless you're counting all the romantic times they shared in the comics when she asked him to kill someone.
CyberCubed
06-16-2013, 03:29 PM
How do we know that Angel's tension towards April means that she has feelings for Casey? Couldn't she just care for Casey as a friend, and be frustrated at April because she is interested in HER? Just a thought... by I honestly don't see why this sort of thing is important. We haven't seen any tension of a sexual nature between Raph and Alopex (even though she was obviously created as an homage to Ninjara), nor have we seen the classic "Leonardo likes Karai" motif in this series yet. Not done to the extent it usually is, anyway.
I think its rather implied that Angel at least has admiration for Casey. I can see her having a crush on him, he did protect her after all.
Since this Angel is Casey's age rather than 13-14 like the 4kids one, it isn't wrong to see Angel and Casey together. It might be a welcome change of pace from the April/Casey pairing.
Vi11AiN6
06-16-2013, 04:47 PM
Why is that?
Because it's freakin TMNT! If I want my fill of complex emotional/sexual problems I can read X-men, although lately I've found the new Harbinger comic to be the best written comic out there.
I love comics, adult, horror, etc, I fell in love with the TMNT when I was 8, now my son is 8 and he loves the TMNT. Maybe it's because of Nick or the association with kids but I think the IDW series is great as is.
Also I don't see why there needs to be a LGBT character in a series just for the sake of having a token "gay" in the series.
If Baxter Stockman is gay, why would that need to be addressed?
Is him being gay more importantthan his work with Krang?
My sister is gay and in a same sex family. I love her and support her but I don't feel there has to be a gay character in IDW's TMNT.
Cipher
06-16-2013, 05:27 PM
Because it's freakin TMNT! If I want my fill of complex emotional/sexual problems I can read X-men, although lately I've found the new Harbinger comic to be the best written comic out there.
I love comics, adult, horror, etc, I fell in love with the TMNT when I was 8, now my son is 8 and he loves the TMNT. Maybe it's because of Nick or the association with kids but I think the IDW series is great as is.
Also I don't see why there needs to be a LGBT character in a series just for the sake of having a token "gay" in the series.
If Baxter Stockman is gay, why would that need to be addressed?
Is him being gay more importantthan his work with Krang?
My sister is gay and in a same sex family. I love her and support her but I don't feel there has to be a gay character in IDW's TMNT.
1) The IDW series isn't written for kids (other Turtles series are, and that's fine); it should hold itself to adult standards in terms of characters, writing, etc.
2) How many gay people do you know in real life? How many people do you know who don't know a single gay person?
3) Extrapolating from that, if the IDW series last long enough and the Turtles meet an ever-expanding cast of characters, wouldn't it feel glaring if the series never introduced a single openly gay person?
4) It's important that that starts being something expected in a series with a large enough cast, not just for promoting acceptance and offering decent role models in media, but because it's an aspect of believability
So, yeah. "It's freakin' TMNT" wouldn't justify the series omitting an entire demographic. Sometimes gay characters need to show up not because the series has to say something about social inequality, but just because, hey, some people are gay and we need to get over that. It's not an issue at this point in the series with the cast as small as it is, but it's still worth considering.
The Big Bad
06-16-2013, 06:20 PM
Corvus: Tmnt is the one comic that I don't think is necessary for any LGBT characters to show up or for existing ones sexuality to be discussed because relationships aren't a big part of it.
I would venture to disagree. In more than one continuity, sexuality is a vital part of the entire chain of events leading to the turtles' creation.
Is it "necessary"? No, just as it's not "necessary" to have characters who describe themselves as heterosexual or who are white--and yet, there they are, without anyone asking writers to justify their inclusion. In short, there's a double standard which I think needs to be acknowledged, in which only a limited number of experiences are validated "just because".
And it's not as if they couldn't have easily be included. Yes, there are plenty of characters whose sexuality is as of yet unestablished, but there's also plenty of characters who have been confirmed as straight and cisgendered; absolutely none of them which couldn't have been made gay, bisexual, or trans*, had the creators wanted to.
Say, for example, the Fugitoid, who has a wife and children relegated to backstory limbo. It could have easily been a husband and children, and it would have changed nothing in the actual story.
(Plus, it would piss off homophobes, which while not nearly as worthwhile as the validation of queer people's experiences, still brings me personal pleasure.)
Or heck, take the Yoshi/Tang Shen/Saki triangle. I can easily conceive of a take where it's a bisexual Yoshi who is forced to choose between Tang Shen and Saki, and is made to pay for it. There's unmined ground there, particularly if Yoshi survives as Splinter.
And here's why I think Nick has some say. If we agree that characters' established sexualities aren't vital to their stories, then that means that any character could have theirs changed without compromising them. Leonardo. Shredder. Splinter. And yet, I'm certain there are characters who couldn't be so changed without some pushback from Nickelodeon, starting with the turtles themselves. The question then becomes one of just how far-reaching the directives are. Do they extend to all existing characters, or just the major ones?
Vi11AiN6:This is like saying "where are the gay characters in Star Wars or Transformers". Why does this need to be explored in a comic book?
Because physical attraction is one of the more common human experiences and far more complicated and interesting than most fiction would have us believe? Because there might be stories to tell? Because depicting the world as it is generally makes fiction better? Because doing so may I increase
it's appeal, ergo, its sales?
And yes, I think we should ask ourselves why recent Star Wars or Trasformers stories don't have queer characters. It's a perfectly valid question.
Why ? What does it matter? If we are going to explore homosexual characters the why not explore jewish characters and handicapped characters.
Who says we shouldn't? Orthodox Jewish tradition gave us "Kaddish", one of my favorite stories in the second Tales of the TMNT. And if the creators can develop a disabled character that's half as awesome as Avatar: The Last Airbender's Toph Bei Fong, the why the heck shouldn't they attempt it?
Counter-question: what on Earth do we gain by limiting ourselves to telling stories about the fraction of humanity which already stars in 95% of our popular fiction?
Vi11AiN6
06-16-2013, 07:10 PM
Aside from my sister I have lots of gay friends probably more than normal, I live in a city with a lot of gays. Point is I don't care if someone is gay, what I saying is IDW isn't doing Mirage, they have their own spin and I AM saying there is no need to explore Sexuality period! The Turtles are freakin Ninja's for god's sake and they don't kill. So if they arent cutting peoples heass off then why explore other real life themes like sexuality.
FYI Is IDW catering to an adult audience? REALLY?!?!!!!?
It has the Nikelodeon label on it! If it was for adults it would look like Heavy Metal or ConAn.
Cipher
06-16-2013, 07:28 PM
FYI Is IDW catering to an adult audience? REALLY?!?!!!!?
It might not be the most nuanced thing in the world, but what I meant by that was it's not restricting itself to child-oriented content and writing. By and large, the story doesn't have to censor itself, and it's already gone places no children's series could, in terms of both complexity and violence.
It's at least as 'adult' as any network drama or PG-13 movie, you know? Certainly enough that it doesn't need to shy away from anything besides gratuitous sex or violence.
The "Nickelodeon" stamp doesn't do anything more than identify the company that owns the IP; it's on the Mirage collections as well. New Animated Adventures is their all-ages imprint specifically because the main series is not.
Aside from my sister I have lots of gay friends probably more than normal, I live in a city with a lot of gays. Point is I don't care if someone is gay, what I saying is IDW isn't doing Mirage, they have their own spin and I AM saying there is no need to explore Sexuality period! The Turtles are freakin Ninja's for god's sake and they don't kill. So if they arent cutting peoples heass off then why explore other real life themes like sexuality.
But as The Big Bad pointed out, they already have explored sexuality (which makes sense, because you almost can't have a serious story without it, unless it's about a world of weird, asexual aliens or something). The Fugitoid was straight and had a family. Hamato Yoshi was straight and had a family. Shredder is straight. Casey and April are likely to hook up per the guiding law of the TMNT multiverse. Mike had that weird thing with the Neutrino princess that we're not going to dwell on.
Any of those characters could be gay. If the Turtles keep meeting more and more people, just playing the odds, one of them is going to be gay. I'm sure you don't mean anything by it, but doesn't it seem a little wrong to say that including an openly gay character necessitates a social agenda? It's going to be part of their story, sure, but it could simply be an aspect like a character's race, etc. No need to even get into the bedroom details -- sexuality is also love, and just as we've seen completely nonsexual indications of straight relationships, it wouldn't be crazy to see some for gay relationships.
That's all. I think more and more this should be something we expect from series with expanded casts, rather than the exception. Both because it's the best way to normalize it and, again -- it doesn't matter what kind of story you're telling -- just playing the odds, your characters are likely to encounter a gay person at some point.
Vi11AiN6
06-16-2013, 07:35 PM
Why does sexuality need to be added?
Point is there's a TON of metaphors in this series that doesn't need to be spelled out! I mean do we need to worry if Casey and April are putting ads on craiglist? Does Aloplex service Shredder sexually? Does Splinter masturbate?
Donnie is a computer wiz, what's hos porn collection like? Has Karai been in a Cosplay Bukkake video?!?!?
Why would those things need to be on the surface of a comic book about a cartoon/comic owned by Nick?
CyberCubed
06-16-2013, 07:37 PM
Interesting, am I the only one on this forum who doesn't have any gay family members? I don't even know anyone in real life that is gay (at least, they haven't said anything), so my only exposure is on TV and the news.
People assume others are straight because well....that's the default.
Vi11AiN6
06-16-2013, 07:44 PM
I'm done with this thread. If a talented writer cones along and makes a situation or charachter relevant about sexuality so be it!
However The series is doing enought alone.
I find the conversation between Fugitoid and Donatello to be far more thought provoking than someone being gay.
If a character is gay I don't care honestly. What I care about is how well it's written into the story!
Cipher
06-16-2013, 07:51 PM
Why does sexuality need to be added?
Because people aren't weird, asexual aliens? (Acknowledgement and apologies to anyone reading this who does identify as asexual; I realize that's a thing.)
Because they've already established it for several major characters?
Point is there's a TON of metaphors in this series that doesn't need to be spelled out! I mean do we need to worry if Casey and April are putting ads on craiglist? Does Aloplex service Shredder sexually? Does Splinter masturbate?
Donnie is a computer wiz, what's hos porn collection like? Has Karai been in a Cosplay Bukkake video?!?!?
Did ... did you read my post?
Notice, again, how we've confirmed several characters' sexuality already with absolutely no need for details as to their sex lives. Showing only the romantic side of love is a trope as old as time.
When a character is dating/kissing/married to someone who's the opposite gender, that's a display of heterosexuality. When a character is dating/kissing/married to someone of the same gender, that's a display of homosexuality. There's no reason to go into the bedroom either way.
If you want an example of another IDW title getting this totally right, look to their (unfortunately mediocre) Godzilla ongoing. One of the members of the main team is gay, which we know because in the first issue a monster interrupts his wedding to another man. Nothing about it is made to be a big deal from there; his character would play exactly the same were he getting married to a woman. He's just gay because, hey, some people are, and it's cool to see that represented in fiction alongside straight characters.
Why would those things need to be on the surface of a comic book about a cartoon/comic owned by Nick?
Presumably because:
1) The Nick cartoon and IDW series are targeting different age groups and so far Nick has shown themselves to be okay with that.
And 2) Hopefully Nick isn't a bigoted company.
We need to get over the idea that featuring a gay character is in any way controversial, when it's just how some people are. Unless you're growing up in backwoods Alabama, you will meet openly gay people in your life. I hate to go down this route, because it's a gross oversimplification, but prior to the 1950s (at the very earliest), it would've been controversial or taboo for any media, especially something aimed at children, to feature a positive or casual portrayal of a non-white character. Thankfully people got over that, because, hey, you'll meet plenty of non-white people in your life and it doesn't have to be a huge statement to reflect that in fiction.
I find the conversation between Fugitoid and Donatello to be far more thought provoking than someone being gay.
Why does the inclusion of a gay character have to be "thought-provoking"?
Interesting, am I the only one on this forum who doesn't have any gay family members? I don't even know anyone in real life that is gay (at least, they haven't said anything), so my only exposure is on TV and the news.
I don't have any gay family members (actually, one in my very, very extended family), but I've met lots of gay people through school, work, friends, etc. I think it's more likely that you probably do know someone, but that they just aren't open about it or haven't mentioned it in conversation.
CyberCubed
06-16-2013, 08:02 PM
I don't have any gay family members (actually, one in my very, very extended family), but I've met lots of gay people through school, work, friends, etc. I think it's more likely that you probably do know someone, but that they just aren't open about it or haven't mentioned it in conversation.
Yeah, I suppose this is true. I figure some of the people I have worked with over the years might have been gay, but its not like I go around asking people about their sexuality.
But then again all these people I knew had girlfriends and such, so there's that too.
Weapons@theready
06-16-2013, 10:29 PM
Donatello is gay, and will date with Hun.
I bet Hun likes Donatello's Purple Dragon
CyberCubed
06-17-2013, 12:12 AM
I wonder why The Big Bad is always thinking of this stuff. In the Nick section he kept bringing up feminism and how April wasn't portrayed as a positive lead since she was Don's love interest. And now he's talking about the lack of gay/lesbian characters.
He's dangerously hovering over the line where he's accusing things of being phobic just because he doesn't see something represented.
About 20-30 years ago people did the same thing with the lack of black characters on TV. The show would introduce "a token black guy" to the main cast just to keep people from accusing the shows producers from being racist. Now black people are so common on every TV show that people have moved on from them to gay/lesbian characters and feminism.
Heather Breckel
06-17-2013, 12:26 AM
Too bad for you, there's already Shredder/Kitsune and Mikey/Neutrino princess. (ah and Victor and the ex-savate boss' woman, but never mind that)
But I wouldn't mind this thing actually explored in the comics, like how they the only on of their kind, the hopelessness of ever finding their female counterpart, and basically being alone forever for example.
It's been a while since I've read through it, but I recall towards the end of the Archie series they actually touched on this just a tiny bit. I think it was Raphael was having a discussion with his future counterpart. It obviously wasn't covered in depth, but Raphael said something along the lines of one of the reasons he was so angry all the time was knowing he would outlive Ninjara or any other romantic interest so he would be alone and never able to have children.
Cipher
06-17-2013, 12:38 AM
I wonder why The Big Bad is always thinking of this stuff. In the Nick section he kept bringing up feminism and how April wasn't portrayed as a positive lead since she was Don's love interest. And now he's talking about the lack of gay/lesbian characters.
Because he (she?) is being conscious of the kinds of things more people should be when it comes to popular media. It's easy to not notice this stuff, especially if you're not in the affected demographic, but once you do, it's hard to not want things you love be be better about it.
In all The Big Bad's posts, I don't think I've ever once seen an accusation that the creative teams are actively trying to malign any groups, and I think he (she?) has actually gone out of his or her way to say the opposite. It's important to think about these things specifically because it's so easy to unintentionally fall into problematic patterns.
As for being cautious to avoid tokenism, that's certainly valid, as it actually hurts progress under the guise of helping. Conversely, though, there are a fair number of people who use that logic to avoid doing anything. "Oh, you can't push for the addition of such and such type of character because that's just adding a token," when, in fact, you can add diverse characters simply for the sake of adding them -- because the things that separate us are traits like any other traits, because it's simply an accurate representation of life to do so, and because that's how, over time, you normalize these differences.
It should strike you just from re-reading your own post, but the very reason we no longer have the issue with non-whites in media we did "20-30 years ago" is precisely because people spoke up and became conscious of under-representation. And sure, we endured some ugly tokenism and stereotypes along the way, but the end result is that it's no longer novel to show non-whites in media and, frankly, it's expected. It'd be great if we could have the same for gay characters in less time than that.
CyberCubed
06-17-2013, 01:13 AM
It should strike you just from re-reading your own post, but the very reason we no longer have the issue with non-whites in media we did "20-30 years ago" is precisely because people spoke up and became conscious of under-representation. And sure, we endured some ugly tokenism and stereotypes along the way, but the end result is that it's no longer novel to show non-whites in media and, frankly, expected. It'd be great if we could have the same for gay characters in less time than that.
Look at it this way, it took Disney like 70 years before they created a black princess who was Tiara.
I don't think we'll ever see a Disney movie where the princess is a lesbian and falls in love with another girl instead of "prince charming." Is it because Disney is homophobic? No, of course not. Its just probably not something they ever think about.
Cipher
06-17-2013, 01:29 AM
I don't think we'll ever see a Disney movie where the princess is a lesbian and falls in love with another girl instead of "prince charming." Is it because Disney is homophobic? No, of course not. Its just probably not something they ever think about.
Which is exactly why people need to keep bringing these things up so it becomes something they think about. If seventy years ago, Disney featuring a black princess would've been unthinkable, then there's no reason they shouldn't be able to feature gay characters in less time than that. It's easy to shrug it off, but for an entire group of people who don't get to see themselves frequently or positively represented in popular media, that probably f*cking sucks and there's no reason to be quiet about it.
Also, Disney hardly needs to be used as the yardstick for progressiveness.
zodach
06-17-2013, 10:31 AM
Never have I read an issue of the IDW TMNT series and thought, "you know what this is missing? A homosexual character." I can't see them placing an LGBT character in this storyline without it feeling a bit forced. I would agree with some others that sexuality isn't really explored at all in TMNT. There is no need for it IMO.
I bet Hun likes Donatello's Purple Dragon
Then Donnie gets it in the...
shell. :teek:
It's been a while since I've read through it, but I recall towards the end of the Archie series they actually touched on this just a tiny bit. I think it was Raphael was having a discussion with his future counterpart. It obviously wasn't covered in depth, but Raphael said something along the lines of one of the reasons he was so angry all the time was knowing he would outlive Ninjara or any other romantic interest so he would be alone and never able to have children.
Oooh, I remember now, probably that's where I get the idea from, and I liked those parts from Archie, and I even liked the "Raphael's break-up storyline". Murphy put a lot of personal stuff to thoose issues, and I know a lot of people are not fond of that, but I easily prefer these kind of stories over... well... standard contract works. :P That's why I loved Mirage vol.4 too.
Because it's freakin TMNT! If I want my fill of complex emotional/sexual problems I can read X-men, although lately I've found the new Harbinger comic to be the best written comic out there.
I love comics, adult, horror, etc, I fell in love with the TMNT when I was 8, now my son is 8 and he loves the TMNT. Maybe it's because of Nick or the association with kids but I think the IDW series is great as is.
It's probably the kids assotiation, Mirage had plenty of adult topics in it. In the City at War arc, a nice chunk of it was about how Casey left April, found an other woman to live with, and then later she died in giving birth to a daughter. There's also a story about the origin of why April can't give birth to a child. Oh, and the most important, the whole origin story of the turtles goes back to a love triangle that turns into a tragedy.
Now, about IDW, I also like it the way it is. There's no need to bring in more sexuality, and make it focus more about relationships, if it stays like that how it is now, I'll be happy with that. But if they have a good idea about a storyline, and that involves lovetriangles, or Stockman being a closet homosexual, or anything, I would enjoy that too.
But I'm guessing that IDW won't go too far in these topics anyway...
Archon_Turtle
06-17-2013, 01:56 PM
Even if IDW were interested in inserting more sexuality into the Turtles book, I'm fairly certain Nickelodeon would nuke that from orbit.
AnarkyLantern
06-17-2013, 04:02 PM
TMNT is a franchise. They're going to be very careful how they proceed here. Years back, a movie based on the Authority was a nonstarter at WB because the characters based on Superman and Batman were involved. X-Men toys were removed from a box store (the name wasn't given) when Northstar came out. And a major toy company who will remain nameless had screenwriter contracts forbidding gay characters in the script. Now, things have changed since that. The "loving vs Virginia" parallel is often used in franchise fare for instance. Dumbledore's outing didn't hurt potter's box office. And it could be that Kevin Keller over at Archie breaks the same ground Valerie Brown did with Josie and the Pussycats (Hanna-barbera tried to change her race for the cartoon). And that brings us to Viacom. I don't think it's any accident that Jet, Bumi and Zhao were in the Avatar toyline.
The Big Bad
06-17-2013, 04:04 PM
But as The Big Bad pointed out, they already have explored sexuality (which makes sense, because you almost can't have a serious story without it, unless it's about a world of weird, asexual aliens or something). The Fugitoid was straight and had a family. Hamato Yoshi was straight and had a family. Shredder is straight. Casey and April are likely to hook up per the guiding law of the TMNT multiverse. Mike had that weird thing with the Neutrino princess that we're not going to dwell on.
Any of those characters could be gay. If the Turtles keep meeting more and more people, just playing the odds, one of them is going to be gay. I'm sure you don't mean anything by it, but doesn't it seem a little wrong to say that including an openly gay character necessitates a social agenda? It's going to be part of their story, sure, but it could simply be an aspect like a character's race, etc. No need to even get into the bedroom details -- sexuality is also love, and just as we've seen completely nonsexual indications of straight relationships, it wouldn't be crazy to see some for gay relationships.
That's all. I think more and more this should be something we expect from series with expanded casts, rather than the exception. Both because it's the best way to normalize it and, again -- it doesn't matter what kind of story you're telling -- just playing the odds, your characters are likely to encounter a gay person at some point.
We need to get over the idea that featuring a gay character is in any way controversial, when it's just how some people are. Unless you're growing up in backwoods Alabama, you will meet openly gay people in your life. I hate to go down this route, because it's a gross oversimplification, but prior to the 1950s (at the very earliest), it would've been controversial or taboo for any media, especially something aimed at children, to feature a positive or casual portrayal of a non-white character. Thankfully people got over that, because, hey, you'll meet plenty of non-white people in your life and it doesn't have to be a huge statement to reflect that in fiction.
Why does the inclusion of a gay character have to be "thought-provoking"?
I don't have any gay family members (actually, one in my very, very extended family), but I've met lots of gay people through school, work, friends, etc. I think it's more likely that you probably do know someone, but that they just aren't open about it or haven't mentioned it in conversation.
This and this. Thank you.
Yes, there are pitfalls involved with writing gay characters, just as there are pitfalls involved in writing any character but white men (who get the privilege of not being seen as representatives of their particular group, but as individuals). However, not representing them at all is never the answer; representing many of them are.
To put it in more TMNT-centric ways. Bebop in the original TMNT cartoon is an incredibly problematic character. As the only African American character in the regular cast until Carter, he reinforces stereotypes that portray them as essentially thuggish, stupid, and servile. However, if you were to take that same character and place him, without alteration, in the 2003, most of the problems go away, because that series also has black people who are smart (Baxter Stockman), who are heroic (Silver Sentry, Faraji), or are treated sympathetically regardless of being their low social standing (Angel, although it's worth wondering if that same narrative would have worked if she were a man). The same holds true for queer characters: the more of them you have, the more stories you can tell with them.
I wonder why The Big Bad is always thinking of this stuff. In the Nick section he kept bringing up feminism and how April wasn't portrayed as a positive lead since she was Don's love interest. And now he's talking about the lack of gay/lesbian characters.
He's dangerously hovering over the line where he's accusing things of being phobic just because he doesn't see something represented.
About 20-30 years ago people did the same thing with the lack of black characters on TV. The show would introduce "a token black guy" to the main cast just to keep people from accusing the shows producers from being racist. Now black people are so common on every TV show that people have moved on from them to gay/lesbian characters and feminism.
Why do I do this? Because it's important to me. Just like some fans are passionate about things like Krang or red-colored bandannas and bring them up whenever the opportunity presents itself, I'm passionate about making the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles something I'd enjoy, and it just so happens that seeing sexist narratives or the marginalization of people who aren't white or male really doesn't help. And I'm being completely earnest here: the way the Nick series uses April is a major turn-off for me.
I write because as someone who loves the TMNT—and I think I have more than enough blogposts to prove it (http://nymonsters.wordpress.com/)—I think it would be a disservice to it if I didn't note when it's problematic.
I write about it because people still, with no malice aforethought, say things like “straight is the default”--which has the necessary corollary that not-straight is therefore abnormal or deviant, and I don't think I need to explain the problems with that—and people need to hear just why its harmful and incorrect.
I write about it because people still believe that being inclusive is somehow incompatible with telling great stories and/or the sort of stories the series has always told. It's not, I can and have proven it, and will continue to prove it until people stop using this argument to justify exclusion.
I write about it because I know the comic book creators frequent these boards, and live in the hope that the reason why they haven't included queer characters yet is because it never occurred to them to do so, or were somehow afraid to. If that's the case, I want to let them know that hey, it's something that they can do, that there's an audience for it, and that it's easier than they may think it is. If, it turns out that Nick is behind the book's lack of gay characters, then I'll know to turn my disappointment towards them. And if it turns out that they can include them but won't, I'd like to know why.
I write about it because I know several female, gay, bi, and/or trans* TMNT fans, and I think they deserve to have themselves represented in the work that they love.
And no, I don't have a problem with people who aren't aware of the issues. They're guilty of nothing but living in a very crappy society that constantly sends out very crappy messages. People who don't see the problems and then go on to claim that because they don't see the problems other, less privileged people see, they must not exist? People who claim they don't have a problem with a group but then argue for their exclusion? People who argue that TMNT is important, but then claim it's problematic elements don't matter because suddenly, it's just a comic book/cartoon/movie? Yup, them I have a problem with.
Because he (she?) is being conscious of the kinds of things more people should be when it comes to popular media. It's easy to not notice this stuff, especially if you're not in the affected demographic, but once you do, it's hard to not want things you love be be better about it.
In all The Big Bad's posts, I don't think I've ever once seen an accusation that the creative teams are actively trying to malign any groups, and I think he (she?) has actually gone out of his or her way to say the opposite. It's important to think about these things specifically because it's so easy to unintentionally fall into problematic patterns.
As for being cautious to avoid tokenism, that's certainly valid, as it actually hurts progress under the guise of helping. Conversely, though, there are a fair number of people who use that logic to avoid doing anything. "Oh, you can't push for the addition of such and such type of character because that's just adding a token," when, in fact, you can add diverse characters simply for the sake of adding them -- because the things that separate us are traits like any other traits, because it's simply an accurate representation of life to do so, and because that's how, over time, you normalize these differences.
It should strike you just from re-reading your own post, but the very reason we no longer have the issue with non-whites in media we did "20-30 years ago" is precisely because people spoke up and became conscious of under-representation. And sure, we endured some ugly tokenism and stereotypes along the way, but the end result is that it's no longer novel to show non-whites in media and, frankly, it's expected. It'd be great if we could have the same for gay characters in less time than that.
It's “he”, but thank you for the non-assumption : )
And yes, this.
Matches Malone
06-17-2013, 04:55 PM
Here we go...
I'm sure you don't mean anything by it, but doesn't it seem a little wrong to say that including an openly gay character necessitates a social agenda?
I saw a movie a while back called "Weekend," which is basically like the movie "Before Sunrise," where the entire film is conversations, only the main characters are gay. The difference is, their conversations kept relating back to politics and gay rights and I thought to myself, "can't these two just enjoy being with one another without bringing politics into it?" That's when it hit me: you can't. You can't be gay in countries like England or America without thinking of yourself in the political context. Your life is affected constantly by outside factors because of it. "What are people going to say?" "Do I feel compelled to do something that's illegal?" And one character keeps pushing the other to be more politically involved, but the other resists, wanting to just be happy. But neither of them question at any point whether their lives are affected politically because of their sexual orientation. So in some sense, I think you do have to be politically minded and motivated to include an openly gay character, because our culture is so averse to it, you can't possibly be unaware that there will undoubtedly be a reaction to it. You must be willing to face that if you include such a character in any kind of mainstream media, so yes, it is wrong that that is the case.
It's going to be part of their story, sure, but it could simply be an aspect like a character's race, etc. No need to even get into the bedroom details -- sexuality is also love, and just as we've seen completely nonsexual indications of straight relationships, it wouldn't be crazy to see some for gay relationships.
That's all. I think more and more this should be something we expect from series with expanded casts, rather than the exception. Both because it's the best way to normalize it and, again -- it doesn't matter what kind of story you're telling -- just playing the odds, your characters are likely to encounter a gay person at some point.
Agree with everything.
People assume others are straight because well....that's the default.
Makes you wonder what happened to equality, doesn't it? Not to say there needs to be 50% straight characters, and 50% gay characters, but obviously gay people are not valued equally as people if we can't even suggest including a few without people demanding that we stick with the default. "We don't want those other kinds of people..."
About 20-30 years ago people did the same thing with the lack of black characters on TV. The show would introduce "a token black guy" to the main cast just to keep people from accusing the shows producers from being racist. Now black people are so common on every TV show that people have moved on from them to gay/lesbian characters and feminism.
You say this while failing to note how great it is that black characters are more common in TV now and that there are people who would like to do the same for other under or unrepresented kinds of people.
Is it because Disney is homophobic?
You mean to ask, is the same corporation that made "Songs of the South" capable of reflecting the prejudice in our own country?
Never have I read an issue of the IDW TMNT series and thought, "you know what this is missing? A homosexual character." I can't see them placing an LGBT character in this storyline without it feeling a bit forced. I would agree with some others that sexuality isn't really explored at all in TMNT. There is no need for it IMO.
I used to say the same thing. No, seriously, I replied to The Big Bad on this same forum. But then I thought about why does it feel forced and not normal? And where do we learn what normal is? The answer is culture. Culture is what we teach each other on the playground, what we see in the movies, everything. And that's why it's not a rulebook, because we're talking about 300 million people in this country telling each other different things. But there are things that we learn that are common, however, that is what we call culture. And out of 300 million people, one of those things that is more commonly suggested is that homosexuality is not normal. Agree or disagree, that's what it says. If you disagree with what your culture is telling you, then hey, it's time to face it, challenge it, and change it. So yeah, that's going to feel forced because things don't change without the intention of changing it. When we integrated our schools, do you think everyone was whistling a happy tune and couldn't wait for it to happen? Of course not. I'm sure it felt forced, and I'm glad we did it, because 50 years later, it doesn't.
If you're worried about exploring sexuality, see what Cipher wrote. It doesn't need to happen. Casey thinks April is cute. It's not a meditation and exploration on the plights of the heterosexual lifestyle. Why can't the same happen with a gay/bi character?
Candy Kappa
06-17-2013, 05:30 PM
A simple line as they did in the ParaNorman movie would be enough, or using Mikey's pizza guy friend as an example, having him getting comforted by his boyfriend that he struggles with the after effects of being attacked by a 7-8 foot tall turtle-man.
Not every gay character needs to be a sitcom stereotype with a pink feather bola, as it seems many fears.
CyberCubed
06-17-2013, 05:45 PM
The Big Bad, when did these things start to become an issue for you? I don't remember you making posts like this back on Toonzone 10 years ago when we were back in 2003-2005.
Now I realize we were all a lot younger back then (it was 10 years ago after all), but I never remember you analyzing TMNT 2k3, Justice League, X-men Evolution and all the other shows that were airing at the time like this.
MsMarvelDuckie
06-17-2013, 07:26 PM
You know, He's not the only one who is concerned about these issues. I'll share a little (non)secret with you- I had a little girl who is now almost six, and who lives in Iowa with her adoptive mommies. That's right, I gave her up to a lesbian couple, one of whom happened to be a good friend of mine. When I was considering what to do, (financial/personal issues- long story) she came to me and made an offer to adopt. It turned out to be the best decision I ever made, and ever since, I've had a very personal stake in this issue, seeing how my biological daughter is now living in a family where it is VERY important. I may not see her, but we still keep in touch. And I have grown to feel that equality really DOES mean EVERYONE. Or it should, anyway.
So when I see others asking why there are not more such characters in comics- yes, even in TMNT- I have to stand up and say, "Yeah, why NOT?" I work with, am friends with, and even have them in my family, so why shouldn't these otherwise normal folks (and who decides what "normal" is, anyway?) be included in the media we all enjoy? The short answer is, there is NO reason not to. It shouldn't matter if a character in the Turtles-verse(s) are GLBT or whatever. It SHOULD just be a part of who that character is, not something to point at and say "we don't need that in here!"
Vi11AiN6
06-17-2013, 07:33 PM
It's a complex issue and in America we are in transitional times. I think there are plenty of comics and outlets for this topic.
It's as someone pointed out it's maybe my association with Nick or TMNT in general that I'm fine with the way the series is.
I'm not going to get angry if there's a gay character, but it's going to have to be smart and it's going to have to be well written.
Again I don't expect this to be an issue in IDW, for the complexity of sexuality I will read Vertigo or Dark Horse titles.
If it's that important for sone of you to find validation or connection with TMNT I hope you find it, I just don't think that liking boys or girls is necessary for identification.
One thing I always loved about the TMNT was that they were real modern American heros. Being Mutants and none human they broke barriers where ANY KId (black, whit, latino, asian, fat, skinny, gay, straight, cool, nerdy, etc) EVERYONE could find one turtle or better yet different turtles that you could identify with. I just want that to still be true without having to spell out things like Donnies gay, Leo's black, Raph is a jew, and Mikey is a vegan.
Vi11AiN6
06-17-2013, 07:39 PM
Inclusion is important, but there is the art of metaphores and symbolism in conics. Sometimes to openly spell things out would kill the message right?
MsMarvelDuckie
06-17-2013, 08:00 PM
Not necessarily. Metaphors are hard to convey in a mostly visual medium like comics. Yes, there is dialog, but it's often the image itself that tells most of the story. Having someone simply mention their significant other in passing would go much farther than some "metaphorical" image that indirectly hints at the same thing. Or it could be as simple as seeing a character out on a date with someone of the same gender. It doesn't have to beat us over the head- just occasionally show that it exists.
And I don't expect a deep exploration of any character's sexuality- that's not what TMNT is about- but it would be nice to have it at least acknowledged once in a while, if only in passing. That's what most of us want to see- acknowledgement of the fact that it is a part of life and our culture. We don't need to see Casey and April in the bedroom(or Stockman either for that matter) but just knowing that perhaps Alopex has her eyes on Karai would be an interesting twist. It doesn't even have to go anywhere or be expanded on or explored- just BE there. That's all.
Cipher
06-17-2013, 08:04 PM
Inclusion is important, but there is the art of metaphores and symbolism in conics. Sometimes to openly spell things out would kill the message right?
Why does a gay character have to be metaphorical? Why do they have to have a message, other than that gay people exist?
Matches Malone
06-17-2013, 09:06 PM
It's a complex issue and in America we are in transitional times. I think there are plenty of comics and outlets for this topic.
It's as someone pointed out it's maybe my association with Nick or TMNT in general that I'm fine with the way the series is.
I'm not going to get angry if there's a gay character, but it's going to have to be smart and it's going to have to be well written.
Again I don't expect this to be an issue in IDW, for the complexity of sexuality I will read Vertigo or Dark Horse titles.
If it's that important for sone of you to find validation or connection with TMNT I hope you find it, I just don't think that liking boys or girls is necessary for identification.
Can you imagine saying this if you were talking about race? "We don't need to explore racism, so why is Baxter Stockman black? There are plenty of books about racism, don't need it in TMNT." The logic isn't that we need to talk or explore about it in every comic book, but that it simply adds another layer of reality and normalcy. Baxter Stockman is black because in real life, some people are black. It's not because TMNT wants to "explore racism." Same idea applies in this case, or any other case regarding minorities.
One thing I always loved about the TMNT was that they were real modern American heros. Being Mutants and none human they broke barriers where ANY KId (black, whit, latino, asian, fat, skinny, gay, straight, cool, nerdy, etc) EVERYONE could find one turtle or better yet different turtles that you could identify with. I just want that to still be true without having to spell out things like Donnies gay, Leo's black, Raph is a jew, and Mikey is a vegan.
Totally agree with this is the aspect I love about TMNT, which is why I'm sad that in IDW they are are reincarnated Japanese sons of Yoshi, but that's another topic. But even though you say anyone can identify with them because they are so non-specific, any of the depictions of them having relationships or attractions (Mona Lisa, Radical, Ninjara, Seri, Horridus, Kala) are all specifically heterosexual. Not saying I personally want to see any TMNT relationships in particular, but I'm just pointing out that it's not so inclusive as you claim.
Additionally, you forget there are things such as other characters. Other characters besides the turtles who could be portrayed as something besides straight.
Inclusion is important, but there is the art of metaphores and symbolism in conics. Sometimes to openly spell things out would kill the message right?
So if the message is that there should be more LGBT characters incorporated into comics, the best way to get that message across is not to just do it, but to allude to it? Are you sure your objection isn't that this subject simply makes you uncomfortable? Because it's definitely not coming from a place of logic...
Crabfight
06-18-2013, 03:51 PM
I write about it because I know the comic book creators frequent these boards, and live in the hope that the reason why they haven't included queer characters yet is because it never occurred to them to do so, or were somehow afraid to. If that's the case, I want to let them know that hey, it's something that they can do, that there's an audience for it, and that it's easier than they may think it is. If, it turns out that Nick is behind the book's lack of gay characters, then I'll know to turn my disappointment towards them. And if it turns out that they can include them but won't, I'd like to know why.
I think you do a fantastic job of framing the conversation and articulating the reasons that writers need to stop shying away from using these types of characters. I think it would be a great topic for the creators to address. One of the recent issues of Ninja Notes at the back of the TMNT ongoing had Bobby asking for more questions (as opposed to the usual "You guys rock!" kind of messages). I think actually writing in to the creators directly would be a better way of getting their attention on this issue.
Not that I think you should stop bringing it to the forums. It's great for discussion. On top of that it must be nice to see people reevaluating their stances from past conversations based on those conversations. I just don't think it's the most effective way to get answers from the creators.
So, yeah. Take this issue to Ninja Notes!
Kendamu
06-18-2013, 04:08 PM
Sometimes I feel like the only person who has never wondered who's gay when enjoying TMNT. In fact, relationships in general really never were anything I speculated over with TMNT. Usually it's, "Okay, so are they fighting aliens, ninja, mutants, or a combination of the three this time?"
I wouldn't have a problem with relationships coming up more, straight or otherwise, if it didn't force itself in the way of the more pressing narrative of mutants, aliens, and ninja fighting on rooftops, in alleyways, in the sewers, and in other galaxies/dimensions. "Yes, so-and-so is gay and nobody has a problem with it. What's important right now, though, is the guy covered in blades that's sending his army of martial arts masters after us." Honestly, in any emergency situation I've ever been in, the fact that someone in my group is gay didn't really have any impact on the outcome of that emergency.
Crabfight
06-18-2013, 05:16 PM
Yeah. I don't think anyone's arguing for TMNT to turn into a love-centric story of either straight relationships or any other kind. Of course the focus is mutants fighting other crazy things.
That being said, there has already been a scene where Casey and April almost kissed. I seem to remember a few disagreements with how the love story is being handled, but no major annoyances with it. I wonder if it would have been the same if this almost-kiss were within a different kind of relationship? No difference whatsoever besides the genders/orientations of those involved. Would it be assumed that IDW was "pushing an agenda" on its readers? Would it be deemed "inappropriate for children" by some?
Arguments being made here seem to be that these relationships exist in the real world, so our fiction should reflect this.
CyberCubed
06-18-2013, 05:23 PM
Sometimes I feel like the only person who has never wondered who's gay when enjoying TMNT. In fact, relationships in general really never were anything I speculated over with TMNT. Usually it's, "Okay, so are they fighting aliens, ninja, mutants, or a combination of the three this time?"
I wouldn't have a problem with relationships coming up more, straight or otherwise, if it didn't force itself in the way of the more pressing narrative of mutants, aliens, and ninja fighting on rooftops, in alleyways, in the sewers, and in other galaxies/dimensions. "Yes, so-and-so is gay and nobody has a problem with it. What's important right now, though, is the guy covered in blades that's sending his army of martial arts masters after us." Honestly, in any emergency situation I've ever been in, the fact that someone in my group is gay didn't really have any impact on the outcome of that emergency.
The reason is because there's hardly any relationships in TMNT period. After April/Casey....what else is there?
corvus
06-18-2013, 07:47 PM
Comics are now aimed at people in their teens and twenties. It's important for comics to have role models that apply to all their readers. In a comic like Spiderman, the main character being heterosexual is a big part of the story, so I think its important for the marvel universe to have some gay characters to help their readers relate, which they've done.. Other comics, like tmnt or Hellboy have maybe one relationship that isn't a very big deal. Would I object to it being revealed that Karai or Baxter are gay?(I can just picture those two being) Hell no, but I really never thought about who anyone in TMNT was hooking up with besides Casey and April.
Vi11AiN6
06-18-2013, 08:38 PM
The reason is because there's hardly any relationships in TMNT period. After April/Casey....what else is there?
And whats wrong with that?!?
That's all I'm saying! I'm not interested in anyones sexuality. I'm worried about those Savate, Foot, Stckman freaks.
Lets introduce Irma as a lesbian stalker!
Personally after reading Baxter's micro I believe him to be A-sexual. I think his father warped him that emotions and sexuality are signs of human weakness. Hence his cold emotions for experimentation and affinity for machines.
I maybe reading into it but that's IMHO
The Big Bad
06-18-2013, 08:50 PM
The reason is because there's hardly any relationships in TMNT period. After April/Casey....what else is there?
In the IDW comic alone? Saki/Kitsune. Yoshi/Tang Shen. Fugitoid and Wife. Neutrino King and Neutrino Queen. Michelangelo's...thing with the Neutrino Princess. Some are definitively more prominent than others; all are between people of the opposite sex.
Inclusion is important, but there is the art of metaphores and symbolism in conics. Sometimes to openly spell things out would kill the message right?
Ah, but here's the rub. Establishing that a character is gay, in theory, take little to no effort--you do it in a word balloon or panel. Coding a character so that they come off as queer, without actually ever confirming it, takes vastly more effort, makes for less nuanced depictions, and does absolutely nothing for their visibility.
The Big Bad, when did these things start to become an issue for you? I don't remember you making posts like this back on Toonzone 10 years ago when we were back in 2003-2005.
Now I realize we were all a lot younger back then (it was 10 years ago after all), but I never remember you analyzing TMNT 2k3, Justice League, X-men Evolution and all the other shows that were airing at the time like this.
You're right, I didn't. My greater awareness of these issues have only really come to a boil in the past three years, after the 2k3 series had already stopped airing.
I think you do a fantastic job of framing the conversation and articulating the reasons that writers need to stop shying away from using these types of characters. I think it would be a great topic for the creators to address. One of the recent issues of Ninja Notes at the back of the TMNT ongoing had Bobby asking for more questions (as opposed to the usual "You guys rock!" kind of messages). I think actually writing in to the creators directly would be a better way of getting their attention on this issue.
Not that I think you should stop bringing it to the forums. It's great for discussion. On top of that it must be nice to see people reevaluating their stances from past conversations based on those conversations. I just don't think it's the most effective way to get answers from the creators.
So, yeah. Take this issue to Ninja Notes!
Ooh! I like that! To be honest, I'd be a bit hesitant to approach that particular forum, not being a huge fan of the IDW series (for reasons only partly having to do with my issues with their sometimes problematic representations), which makes the whole thing seem...uncouth? But yeah, I'll definitively think about it!
zodach
06-19-2013, 10:11 AM
Arguments being made here seem to be that these relationships exist in the real world, so our fiction should reflect this.
Agreed, but maybe TMNT isn't really the property to explore these issues of sexuality. Marvel has a huge catalog of titles and very few explore LGBT characters, but there is a place for them. I don't think all comics need to relate to all races, genders, sexual orientations, etc. and I think approaching this issue in TMNT would feel a bit forced and out of place for the property.
Candy Kappa
06-19-2013, 12:49 PM
Would it really be that forced to have a person use a relationship title of their own sex when referring to it's significant other?
corvus
06-19-2013, 01:22 PM
Agreed, but maybe TMNT isn't really the property to explore these issues of sexuality. Marvel has a huge catalog of titles and very few explore LGBT characters, but there is a place for them. I don't think all comics need to relate to all races, genders, sexual orientations, etc. and I think approaching this issue in TMNT would feel a bit forced and out of place for the property.
X-Men has a ton of LGBT characters. Northstar, Anole, Mystique, Daken, Bling
Matches Malone
06-19-2013, 08:51 PM
Agreed, but maybe TMNT isn't really the property to explore these issues of sexuality. Marvel has a huge catalog of titles and very few explore LGBT characters, but there is a place for them. I don't think all comics need to relate to all races, genders, sexual orientations, etc. and I think approaching this issue in TMNT would feel a bit forced and out of place for the property.
Starting to repeat myself here, so I'll probably just let this thread die after this. But again, no one is saying TMNT needs to "explore" these issues or themes. It's a simple matter of including this aspect in characters. You say not all comics need to relate to all races or genders, and yet we see plenty of variation of both in comics, don't we? I'm sure you're not suggesting we should exclude any race or gender from a comic because having an African American in a comic doesn't make it a comic about racism nor does having a woman make it about feminism, so it reasonably follows that having an LGBT character doesn't necessarily make the comic about those issues. We include those different kinds of characters because diversity is more interesting, it reflects the real world, and in turn, supports the idea that LGBT deserve visibility.
If anything, TMNT is the comic to incorporate LGBT because it incorporates everything. This is a series that has historically mashed up mutants, superheroes, ninjas, aliens, time travel, robots, punks and gangs, even straight folks(!), you name it. In that sense, TMNT is about inclusion and diversity, in my opinion.
Kendamu
06-19-2013, 10:17 PM
I think that's what some people are afraid of it becoming, though.
"In this very special issue, we're going to..." bla bla bla. That's the feeling people are afraid it's gonna have if introduced into a series that has very little in the way of relationships to begin with.
Cipher
06-19-2013, 10:28 PM
"In this very special issue, we're going to..." bla bla bla. That's the feeling people are afraid it's gonna have if introduced into a series that has very little in the way of relationships to begin with.
Okay. But when it does, one of them could be gay. And I'm not sure I buy that to begin with -- twenty-some issues in, we've already confirmed the sexual orientations of about a dozen characters, no dwelling on relationships needed. (Splinter, Tang Shen, Shredder, Tetsuo, Kitsune, April and Casey implicit, Michelangelo, the Neutrino king and queen).
A huge number? No. And there are still racial demographics we haven't seen. No one's crying foul on anything other than the idea that this would never be the place to include such a character, or that it shouldn't be conscious of it as it expands its cast.
And there's the fact that when we single out a particular demographic as something that would fundamentally alter the story just to include, we other it in a destructive, hurtful, unrealistic way. I realize that's not an intentional mindset anyone's harboring, but you have to realize it's the same logic that, fifty years ago, would've kept a non-white character out of a series on the principal that it wasn't the place to tackle those issues. It can be as surface level as you want; it can go where the acknowledgement of attraction or a relationship wouldn't impede on the story. But being open to that visibility is what counts.
We need to shake the mindset that including certain groups is the exceptional, disingenuous thing to do, when in fact the choice is to wholly exclude them from any otherwise real-world (demographics wise) setting is the active, unrealistic one. Yet when people say, "Eh. TMNT's not the place," that's exactly what they're arguing for, intentionally or not.
Matches Malone
06-19-2013, 11:14 PM
I think that's what some people are afraid of it becoming, though.
"In this very special issue, we're going to..." bla bla bla. That's the feeling people are afraid it's gonna have if introduced into a series that has very little in the way of relationships to begin with.
Definitely shouldn't try something if people are going to be able to notice that it's different.
People complain that there is no way to introduce LGBT without drawing all the attention to it, even if you have the writers do the exact same thing they've always done with the story and characters. There are people are said the same thing about the Army and even professional sports. But you know what? Homosexuals are allowed to openly serve in the army and Jason Collins plays in the NBA. The Army didn't stop functioning to stare at the gays with their jaws gaped open and neither did basketball players/fans. Give readers a little more credit. It's 2013.
Cipher
06-19-2013, 11:29 PM
Definitely shouldn't try something if people are going to be able to notice that it's different.
People complain that there is no way to introduce LGBT without drawing all the attention to it, even if you the writers do the exact same thing they've always done with the story and characters. There are people are said the same thing about the Army and even professional sports. But you know what? Homosexuals are allowed to openly serve in the army and Jason Collins plays in the NBA. The Army didn't stop functioning to stare at the gays with their jaws gaped open and neither did basketball players/fans. Give readers a little more credit. It's 2013.
Wha' ... I?
Did a post get deleted or were you responding to me for agreeing with you?
Matches Malone
06-19-2013, 11:34 PM
Wha' ... I?
Did a post get deleted or were you responding to me for agreeing with you?
Haha the first line was sarcastic and the second part of the post was just responding to the idea in general that no matter what, any kind of inclusion is going feel disingenuous and be rejected. I didn't want to keep quoting folks and make it feel like I'm picking on everyone, but it just ended up confusing. Sorry about that. I know we're on the same page.
zodach
06-20-2013, 08:58 AM
It can be as surface level as you want; it can go where the acknowledgement of attraction or a relationship wouldn't impede on the story. But being open to that visibility is what counts.
Who's to say the writers aren't open to the idea? Maybe they just don't think it fits the storylines they are exploring. Just because they don't address it doesn't mean they are opposed to that sexual orientation. There is LGBT representation in comics so it's not like it's an unexplored medium, it just hasn't happened in TMNT. I don't understand why you think it has to happen in this specific comic which almost never deals directly with issues of sexuality.
Cipher
06-20-2013, 07:46 PM
Who's to say the writers aren't open to the idea? Maybe they just don't think it fits the storylines they are exploring. Just because they don't address it doesn't mean they are opposed to that sexual orientation. There is LGBT representation in comics so it's not like it's an unexplored medium, it just hasn't happened in TMNT. I don't understand why you think it has to happen in this specific comic which almost never deals directly with issues of sexuality.
We don't know if the writers are open to it or not.
I imagine they aren't opposed to that sexual orientation, just as I imagine you're not.
But when you specifically avoid including it, which is what you're arguing for when you say "it doesn't have to happen in this particular comic" (no aspersions cast on the writers at this point) you're actively singling it out in a negative way. And while we haven't "dealt with issues of sexuality," we've had plenty of relationships, any one of which could've been gay instead.
Remember, again, excluding is the active choice, not the other way around. If, two years into the series, you had never seen a character of a major racial demographic, you'd be like, "Yo, how has this series been set in NYC for two years and we haven't seen a single person of ____ race while we've seen plenty of white people? You should probably think about that and add one." And no one would call that an insane request. It would seem completely reasonable. Why is this any different?
CyberCubed
06-20-2013, 08:40 PM
Nobody is avoiding it, its just that its not something anyone is thinking about. I certainly never thought about the lack of gay characters in TMNT anything until I read this thread.
zodach
06-21-2013, 10:12 AM
Just like real life, I encounter people all the time who I have no idea what their sexual orientation might be. It doesn't come up in casual everyday conversation. In this comic there isn't a lot of internal dialogue and there aren't really any direct situations where the character's sexuality is the subject. I just don't see how you would put it in there for inclusions sake and not have it feel out of place for the story.
Why is this even a conversation, and why are you trying to shoehorn a LGBT character into TMNT? Cause that's exactly what it would be....a forced and fake character.
I have no problem with people of the LGBT community, but lets be real here. We aren't tackling major social issues in TMNT. We are talking about mutants bashing each others heads in and reincarnated turtles from Japan in New York.
The Big Bad
06-21-2013, 01:25 PM
Just like real life, I encounter people all the time who I have no idea what their sexual orientation might be. It doesn't come up in casual everyday conversation. In this comic there isn't a lot of internal dialogue and there aren't really any direct situations where the character's sexuality is the subject. I just don't see how you would put it in there for inclusions sake and not have it feel out of place for the story.
Why is this even a conversation, and why are you trying to shoehorn a LGBT character into TMNT? Cause that's exactly what it would be....a forced and fake character.
I have no problem with people of the LGBT community, but lets be real here. We aren't tackling major social issues in TMNT. We are talking about mutants bashing each others heads in and reincarnated turtles from Japan in New York.
Man, remember that time they shoehorned in Michelangelo's interest in writing into a book about mutant bashing each other's heads? Or when the turtles spent half a book enjoying Christmas instead of fighting? That time we learned that Don plays Guitar Hero, wasting everyone's time? Or, to be overly broad, every character-development moment ever? Remember how faked and forced those felt?
The argument that the series has never had space for anything other than action does not grow more convincing with repetition. Character-building has always been an important part of the comics, which is a huge part of why the series remains popular today. So why is it that stuff like April's story in "City at War" are fine, but allowing one character to display affection for someone of their same gender isn't?
Man, remember that time they shoehorned in Michelangelo's interest in writing into a book about mutant bashing each other's heads? Or when the turtles spent half a book enjoying Christmas instead of fighting? That time we learned that Don plays Guitar Hero, wasting everyone's time? Or, to be overly broad, every character-development moment ever? Remember how faked and forced those felt?
The argument that the series has never had space for anything other than action does not grow more convincing with repetition. Character-building has always been an important part of the comics, which is a huge part of why the series remains popular today. So why is it that stuff like April's story in "City at War" are fine, but allowing one character to display affection for someone of their same gender isn't?
You are a shoehorn...get over yourself and go read what the writers put out. If it's not good enough for you go read something else...sheesh.
Vi11AiN6
06-21-2013, 04:22 PM
Just like real life, I encounter people all the time who I have no idea what their sexual orientation might be. It doesn't come up in casual everyday conversation. In this comic there isn't a lot of internal dialogue and there aren't really any direct situations where the character's sexuality is the subject. I just don't see how you would put it in there for inclusions sake and not have it feel out of place for the story.
Agreed 100%
If you need a character to be gay so you can find some way to identify then I feel sorry for you. I like redheads does that mean my favorite turtle needs to like redheads too? No
TMNT doesn't need any sexuality, I'll take mutants, ninjas, and aliens any day of the week.
CyberCubed
06-21-2013, 04:31 PM
Are there any gay characters in DC?
Vi11AiN6
06-21-2013, 04:40 PM
Man, remember that time they shoehorned in Michelangelo's interest in writing into a book about mutant bashing each other's heads? Or when the turtles spent half a book enjoying Christmas instead of fighting? That time we learned that Don plays Guitar Hero, wasting everyone's time? Or, to be overly broad, every character-development moment ever? Remember how faked and forced
So why is it that stuff like April's story in "City at War" are fine, but allowing one character to display affection for someone of their same gender isn't?
I don't know how old you are or why you feel alienated.
I don't think ANYONE would say that the Turtles interest is shoe horning.
You are missing the point so badly that it's not even funny. It's okay for City at War because that's what the writers had happen.
Not a single person on this thread EVER said that it wasn't fine for a character to be attracted to the same sex. NO ONE said that
All we've said is there's no real reason that TMNT needs to be explored any further than it is.
It is you my friend that is creating this idea that we are against a gay character.
The whole thread is rediculous to begin with. Do we think mutants who aren't a part of a species are going to be overwhelmed with who they wanna hug and kiss?
You can read a gazillion comics that explore all of this, go read The Invisibles which had a great gay character Lord Fanny.
Difference is The Invisibles was on Vertigo which can show tits, sex, etc because it's an adult comic company.
IDW is Transformers, GIJoe, TMNT, etc.
Not to mention Nikalodien label which is FOR Kids.
I don't want sexuality in a kids show explored at any length.
Listen I don't care if my Son was gay, but I'm not going to go into the birds and the bees until he's going through puberty.
He already knows what gay is, it's not really an issue in our house.
The point we are saying is TMNT has plenty do deal with outside of ANYONE's sexuality.
Candy Kappa
06-21-2013, 05:08 PM
Why is this even a conversation, and why are you trying to shoehorn a LGBT character into TMNT? Cause that's exactly what it would be....a forced and fake character.
Man, remember that time they shoehorned in Michelangelo's interest in writing into a book about mutant bashing each other's heads? Or when the turtles spent half a book enjoying Christmas instead of fighting? That time we learned that Don plays Guitar Hero, wasting everyone's time? Or, to be overly broad, every character-development moment ever? Remember how faked and forced those felt?
I don't know how old you are or why you feel alienated.
I don't think ANYONE would say that the Turtles interest is shoe horning.
You are missing the point so badly that it's not even funny. It's okay for City at War because that's what the writers had happen.
Clearly Big bad was sarcastic over Coro's post about character development being shoe-horned if the character is gay
You can read a gazillion comics that explore all of this, go read The Invisibles which had a great gay character Lord Fanny.
Difference is The Invisibles was on Vertigo which can show tits, sex, etc because it's an adult comic company.
here's the issue, April and Casey hooking up is fine, that's a-okay for kids & teens reading comic books, but if it was Casey and Adam. Oh, no that is in the adult section like Vertigo.
Cause gays can't feel love. Only lust, right?
I don't want sexuality in a kids show explored at any length.
Like April and Casey being in a relationship in the 4Kids show?
Raph and Ninjara in the Archie comics, or Raph and Mona Lisa hitting it off in the Fred Wolf series, or Irma's obsession on getting a man.
Are there any gay characters in DC?
Yes, there are plenty of gay characters in DC:
Katherine Kane (Batwoman)
Rene Montoya (The Question)
Nelson Gardener (Captain Metropolis)
Earth 2 Alan Scott (Green Lantern)
Holly Robinson (Catwoman)
Big Thunder
To name a few.
Oh, and don't forget Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy
Azrael Macool
06-21-2013, 07:17 PM
Okay, so, I think there's some confusion going on here. What people are saying (and I agree with), is that we want to see some people of a non-straight orientation appearing in some way, not that we want one if the main turtle characters to be gay, or that we want to see explicit sex acts in the comics. And for the people who seem to think that, I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt that you were simply confused, though frankly its a little insulting to jump from "LGBT characters are underrepresented in comics" to "we want to see Michelangelo engaged in explicit gay sex".
CyberCubed
06-21-2013, 07:33 PM
Oh, and don't forget Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy
Is that really canon though? I know Harley and Ivy teamed up on a lot of occassions but I always assumed that was more of a fan pairing.
Considering Poison Ivy also hates the human race, it doesn't make sense for her to fall for another human even if its female.
Azrael Macool
06-22-2013, 03:18 AM
Is that really canon though? I know Harley and Ivy teamed up on a lot of occassions but I always assumed that was more of a fan pairing.
Considering Poison Ivy also hates the human race, it doesn't make sense for her to fall for another human even if its female.
It's Word of God, if not canon... And anyway, Poison Ivy was in love with Batman, and has had tons of other relationships... She doesnt hate all humans. But either way, this is mostly off topic of the thread at hand.
But if you do want other comic examples, loom no farther than the Sonic the Hedgehog comic by Archie, which has at least one gay main character I can think of, Rotor the Walrus. Or Hell, Archie himself has a gay friend who got married a while back and has (or at least had) his own title. Does anyone really think freaking Archie and the Riverdale fang should be more progressive than TMNT?
Vi11AiN6
06-22-2013, 08:53 AM
Don't make me out to sound like a homophob because I'm not Casey and April is enough and personally I'd be happy with it being platonic, I've had ZERO interest in their relationship in any formation.
CyberCubed
06-22-2013, 09:53 AM
What implication is there that Harley and Ivy are interested in one another? They seemed to just be partners in crime to me after Harley got fed up with The Joker.
What stories were there?
What implication is there that Harley and Ivy are interested in one another? They seemed to just be partners in crime to me after Harley got fed up with The Joker.
They never confirmed it I think, but both of them is kinda oversexed, so it would make more sense if they would have sex with each other, more than if not.
Ivy also has dendrophilia. Also unconfirmed, but very likely.
Btw, if I'd just go with stereotypes, a lot of goth/industrial subculture girls are bi/gay, so I could say, there's a good chance that Angel is too. If there ever will be an Angel Micro, I hope Ross Campbell will write it. He is one of the very few people in this world who can realistically portray goth girls. (just check Wet Moon.)
CyberCubed
06-22-2013, 03:23 PM
They never confirmed it I think, but both of them is kinda oversexed, so it would make more sense if they would have sex with each other, more than if not.
Ivy also has dendrophilia. Also unconfirmed, but very likely.
Btw, if I'd just go with stereotypes, a lot of goth/industrial subculture girls are bi/gay, so I could say, there's a good chance that Angel is too. If there ever will be an Angel Micro, I hope Ross Campbell will write it. He is one of the very few people in this world who can realistically portray goth girls. (just check Wet Moon.)
I'm glad I'm not the only one who got a lesbian vibe from Angel. She would probably be the only bisexual character I can see IDW introducing. Still seems like we're in the early stages of a love triangle between April, Casey and Angel....with perhaps Angel liking them both.
I am still interested in hearing more about the Ivy/Harley relationship in Batman. Are there any comics about this or any summaries I could read?
I'm glad I'm not the only one who got a lesbian vibe from Angel. She would probably be the only bisexual character I can see IDW introducing. Still seems like we're in the early stages of a love triangle between April, Casey and Angel....with perhaps Angel liking them both.
Angel also has a bit of masculine vibe, by leading Purple Dragons, or the way how confidently she treats dangerous situations. Or maybe it's sexist, to identify this with masculineism? Dunno.
I think it wouldn't hurt if they would go with that kind of a love triangle, but only if they'd make it like in Chasing Amy (just an example), instead of a full-on graphical representation for fanservice purposes. You know what I mean, when they insert lesbians, so 14yo boys can catch on the story, by fulfilling their lesbian fantasy.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
06-22-2013, 05:01 PM
I'm glad I'm not the only one who got a lesbian vibe from Angel. She would probably be the only bisexual character I can see IDW introducing. Still seems like we're in the early stages of a love triangle between April, Casey and Angel....with perhaps Angel liking them both.
I don't agree with you on much, but I can DEFINITELY see this being the case... Angel's frustration towards April stemming from the fact that she's got a thing for her, not stemming from the fact that she's her competition, or the possibility of April's interaction with Casey preventing her [Angel] from sleeping with him.
I am still interested in hearing more about the Ivy/Harley relationship in Batman. Are there any comics about this or any summaries I could read?
Perv :trolleye: :tlol:
Angel also has a bit of masculine vibe, by leading Purple Dragons, or the way how confidently she treats dangerous situations. Or maybe it's sexist, to identify this with masculineism? Dunno.
I don't know that it's sexist per se. To say it is rare that a woman would have the capacity to lead men into battle would be sexist, to say it seems rare that it would actually happen? Not really.
I think it wouldn't hurt if they would go with that kind of a love triangle, but only if they'd make it like in Chasing Amy (just an example), instead of a full-on graphical representation for fanservice purposes. You know what I mean, when they insert lesbians, so 14yo boys can catch on the story, by fulfilling their lesbian fantasy.
At 14 I was too busy thinking of myself getting a hold of a girl to think about girls getting a hold of other girls... I think it would be more likely that they'd write that kind of story for their 25 to 35 year old audience.
Vi11AiN6
06-22-2013, 08:59 PM
My god, female gang leader and her being dominant equals she's gay?
What would happen if they wrote a character that was REALLy attractive and strong, and you know what? You liked them A LOT. and then you found out that they didn't like BOYS or GIRLS, they just liked power, or experience in life....
WOW!!! ThAt would crazy!!!!!!
Stop ****ing feeling sorry for yourself!
MsMarvelDuckie
06-22-2013, 09:01 PM
Hmm, Angel being Bi? I could maybe see that- and there hasn't been much development on her yet (AFAIK), so it might work with her. Her interest in Casey seems more like an honor-debt kind of thing to me anyway (like Chewie had with Han) but when se met April and they seemed to hit it off fairly well, I could see that going in a very different direction, with the right kind of development. And yeah, with her being "goth/industrial" it could fit her. I admit I hadn't thought of it before, but honestly, she's really the only character I could see going that route at this point.
I'm not one to shoe-horn ANYTHING into a comic, be it TMNT or otherwise, but I DO like comics to resemble real-life demographics in terms of the kinds of people we see. And we ARE talking about New York, after all- the original melting pot of the US. It would be really weird if we DIDN'T see at least one or two LGBT folks running around- even if it's just some unnamed characters in the background, like that couple Raph and Casey rescued from the muggers in Casey's one-shot! (How would it have hurt that scene for it to be a same-sex couple getting mugged?- Answer: it wouldn't. In fact, it might have even validated the concept, since it would have shown Raph and Casey acting without prejudice against aiding such a couple!)
Vi11AiN6
06-22-2013, 09:06 PM
Let the writers do their thing, I'm SICK and tired of this thread trying to give gay validation... TMNT is a series for ALL people, each turtle displays various traits for ANYONE (gay, male, female, color, religion, etc) to identify with.
If your sexuality is so blinded to the point you can't enjoy TMNT then I feel sorry for you. Your life must be hell is you have to drag a world of magic through mud.
Cipher
06-22-2013, 09:42 PM
Let the writers do their thing, I'm SICK and tired of this thread trying to give gay validation... TMNT is a series for ALL people, each turtle displays various traits for ANYONE (gay, male, female, color, religion, etc) to identify with.
I think that's what everyone here as been saying.
I just can't imagine for the life of me why it's a big deal to want to see a gay character in something.
Azrael Macool
06-22-2013, 11:16 PM
Let the writers do their thing, I'm SICK and tired of this thread trying to give gay validation... TMNT is a series for ALL people, each turtle displays various traits for ANYONE (gay, male, female, color, religion, etc) to identify with.
If your sexuality is so blinded to the point you can't enjoy TMNT then I feel sorry for you. Your life must be hell is you have to drag a world of magic through mud.
Dude... I tried to be nice earlier, I assumed the best, but seriously... ABSOLUTELY NO ONE is saying they want to see the Turtles be gay, or graphical depictions of gay sex. We just want to see that people of many different types (races, religions, backgrounds, colors, nationalities, genders, and yes, orientation) are being represented in our media. Look, I'm a middle class, white, cisgendered male heterosexual, so I get it, its hard to notice the privileges that come with that, but they're there. I mean, come on dude, you're getting this upset over the IDEA of a gay TMNT character?
CyberCubed
06-23-2013, 12:37 AM
So basically everyone agrees if there was a gay or bisexual character in IDW, it would probably be Angel, right?
She's the only one I can see being gay/bi without it feeling like a token inclusion. Plus there are a number of April and Angel scenes in the comic already. They'll probably bond over Casey's trauma.
Cipher
06-23-2013, 12:43 AM
So basically everyone agrees if there was a gay or bisexual character in IDW, it would probably be Angel, right?
She's the only one I can see being gay/bi without it feeling like a token inclusion. Plus there are a number of April and Angel scenes in the comic already. They'll probably bond over Casey's trauma.
Oooooor ... it could be a new character. Or a franchise character they haven't introduced yet.
Is ... is that what people's problems with this have been? That they thought we were arguing one of the current characters would have to come out as gay?
CyberCubed
06-23-2013, 08:37 AM
Oooooor ... it could be a new character. Or a franchise character they haven't introduced yet.
Is ... is that what people's problems with this have been? That they thought we were arguing one of the current characters would have to come out as gay?
I guess its because most of the current characters aren't human. If Old Hob winds up gay wouldn't anyone else find that funny or disturbing?
I mean April/Casey aren't, Shredder/Kitsune aren't, the only available characters to be gay are Baxter or Angel. And since Baxter never has any love interest in TMNT, there's no point there.
At least with Angel we already see her talking with April. I mean why would we have some scenes where April and Angel talk to one another with no male present? I mean look at the way they are drawn too, Angel could have been a kid like in the 4kids cartoon but she was aged up to be the same as April/Casey. It is highly suspicious.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
06-23-2013, 08:40 AM
Baxter had a love interest in the DreamWave books as a high school kid.
At least with Angel we already see her talking with April. I mean why would we have some scenes where April and Angel talk to one another with no male present?
So anytime girls bond without a guy present, it leads to lesbian sex?
CyberCubed
06-23-2013, 08:49 AM
So anytime girls bond without a guy present, it leads to lesbian sex?
That's what the Movie and TV industry would like us to believe.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
06-23-2013, 09:00 AM
I thought enough kids were probably reading this book that even softcore sensuality would be left out. We know Oroku Saki and Kitsune had a relationship at one point, but now that she's back from the dead, he only really seems to be interested in ruling the city. Even with that, we only ever saw one kiss.
I think if it helps the story I'm all for it, but April has only ever been portrayed as straight and I honestly think that would make it hard to pull off. This is a canon universe, even with Krang, Neutrinos, Rock Soldiers, etc. in it. I probably shouldn't say this (because free speech seems to be frowned upon on message boards to an extent), but I feel that trying to include gay or lesbian characters for the sake of representing them is a mistake. If it works in the story, that's fine, but people of different persuasions shouldn't feel like they're entitled to representation in a Ninja Turtle comic book, or any other comic book or form of media for that matter. This is coming from someone who finds it kind of ridiculous that Baxter was made into a white guy for the Fred Wolf cartoon when there were literally NO black characters in that show except in the background. Bebop was black, but later they decided to make him white, did they not? But Baxter was always intended to be black, and that's the difference. He's been black in every medium since. Why make April lesbian or bi when she's always been straight? Even when she didn't wind up with Casey, she was always straight.
Except maybe for that one time that she and Renet were cockroaches in Volume 4. The implication is made that she did "cockroach things" during that time, and the idea of her doing those things with Cockroach Renet makes a lot more sense than her doing them with some random cockroach with an actual cockroach brain. That's just disturbing.
The Big Bad
06-23-2013, 09:30 AM
So basically everyone agrees if there was a gay or bisexual character in IDW, it would probably be Angel, right?
She's the only one I can see being gay/bi without it feeling like a token inclusion. Plus there are a number of April and Angel scenes in the comic already. They'll probably bond over Casey's trauma.
Personally, I'd love it if Angel were revealed as being somewhere in the queer spectrum, and agree that she's the sort of character that would be most likely to be chosen, being prominent enough that her "outing" would have weight but not prominent enough to make waves. That said, I don't think there's anything about her established behavior that necessarily makes her likelier to be gay than any other character from a characterization perspective. In the larger scheme of things, how one performs regarding masculinity or femininity is generally an unreliable predictor of one's sexual orientation, and someone who acts like Angel is no likelier to be queer than someone who acts like April or Leonardo.
***First of Two Latin Kings***
06-24-2013, 10:27 AM
I think it is possible that Angel does in fact look at Casey more like a brother, and is actually interested in April. I agree with what you said about gender roles, Angel being the leader of a gang doesn't make her more likely to be a lesbian, just makes her more likely to be the dominant one in a lesbian relationship if in fact she IS a lesbian. :tgrin:
CyberCubed
06-24-2013, 10:57 AM
Angel can be bisexual which would make more sense. I think she obviously does care for Casey more than just a friend.
Also regarding Bebop, he was always black in the cartoon and Archie comic. Even when they showed his human form again in Seasons 3 and 4 he was still black.
Vi11AiN6
06-24-2013, 08:30 PM
Okay, I've thought about it and while I'm still standing my ground that TMNT is no series to go exploring sexuality, here's my view/ list of characters that could be gay/lesbian.
Angel so far poses a strong potential where everyone COULD think she has a thing for Casey, but in reality it's sheer respect and it's April that could be who she's attracted to.
Baxter: I still stand by my earlier post: he's ashamed of any emotional/sexual connection which he aasociates as weakness, this stems from his dad and his detachment.
Karai: C'mon that's easy.. No repect from male figures
OLD HOB: He could be the type that is unpredictable and he happens to like strong, alpha males.....
There you go, have a fan fiction field day..............
MsMarvelDuckie
06-24-2013, 10:17 PM
Well, that's all good. At least you're trying to be open-minded about it.
Old Hob? Hmmm, I can already see the title for that one- "The Cat's Out of the Bag" LOL!! JK. And I still stand by Angel as the most likely. Just from what I've seen of her so far. Baxter? Not so much. I doubt he even thinks about it one way or the other, much. I could maybe see Karai, though. (*sigh* There goes all the Leo/Karai side-story ideas.... :trazz::tlol:)
CyberCubed
09-29-2023, 04:42 PM
It's funny how much has changed since 2013. There's two openly lesbian characters (Jennika and Sheena) who are a couple. Maybe more.
Jennika even seems to be heteroromantic when it comes to humans, but homosexual considering her own kind (mutants). A bit more complex than what one would expect.
CyberCubed
09-29-2023, 09:30 PM
God reading 2013-era posts of me hoping Angel would be a lesbian. I haven't changed at all in 10 years.
Turtlette
09-30-2023, 01:17 PM
Can’t believe this thread started in 2013, it’s so… modern, if you know what I mean.
CyberCubed
09-30-2023, 02:20 PM
2013 being 10 years ago is literally blowing my mind.
In my mind I have not mentally moved on from around 2005-2008.
Coola Yagami
10-01-2023, 04:44 PM
I haven't changed at all in 10 years.
Not sure that's a good thing, champ.
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.