View Full Version : How many people do you think are reading IDW TMNT who never followed TMNT before?
CyberCubed
07-07-2013, 11:48 PM
I've been thinking about this a lot, and how most of the people reading IDW TMNT are already established TMNT fans who have followed the franchise for decades and were fans of Mirage and the previous cartoons.
But how many people are reading IDW TMNT who never liked the Turtles before, or just didn't get into them?
joefsas
07-08-2013, 06:21 AM
I'm reading the IDW ongoing series now but have never read any other tmnt comic in my life. Main reason is i have only just become a fan once again all these years later and wasn't too interested in the comics when i was a kid. Also comics aren't as easy to get hold of here in the UK as they are in the US. You guys have got comic book shops everywhere! :)
Sewer Turd
07-08-2013, 05:31 PM
I second that.. in the uk all i got was a couple of issues borrowed, brought back from a school friend from america in the mid 80's.. then all we had was the dam "hero turtles cartoon" which i enjoyed being a kid.. But i wanted that violent comic i had borrowed years earlier "ninja turles" then low and behold i can get them all collected on amazon and a new series as well "Good times":D
***First of Two Latin Kings***
07-08-2013, 05:47 PM
This should have had a poll, where we could have voted for percentiles of people who are reading IDW and never picked a TMNT comic prior. TMNT is and was pretty mainstream though, I can't imagine that there are many people between the ages of 25 and 35 who like comic books and cartoons and had never read a TMNT comic book prior. So I'm guessing only about 25% of the people reading it aren't diehards. I'd guess a lot of people who write into the letter columns are members here, and have had letters printed in Archie, Image, and Mirage in the past.
Redeemer
07-08-2013, 07:09 PM
I currently read the IDW series and love it!, I was never into comics until then, I read a 2nd printing of Issue 1 and 2, got hooked to say the least.
I became a fan from the Original Toon and then I saw the darker and edgier 4kids Mirage series, found out about the Mirage comics and TMNT's dark origins and then tried the IDW seres. Love it.
CyberCubed
07-08-2013, 07:43 PM
Well when I posted this thread I was mainly thinking about DC and Marvel comic book fans who never followed TMNT.
Does anyone know if this series has attracted any of those DC or Marvel fans?
mgambino
07-08-2013, 08:56 PM
This is the first TMNT comic I've read and I'm a longtime comic fan. It got me into the classic TMNT comics too. I've always read Marvel, DC, Image stuff, but by the time I was mature enough to expand out past the superhero genre, the the Ninja Turtles comics were pretty much over. I picked up the IDW comic because I found out Ross Campbell was drawing an issue and I love his art. I ended up picking up the the previous issues, then I got hooked and started tracking down the old Mirage trades. Once I saw Jim Lawson's art, I completely went over the moon for Ninja Turtles.
I did watch the old cartoon a bit when I was a little kid, but I was never what you'd call a diehard fan. So I guess the point of this overlong post is that I fit the bill.
How many people do you think are reading IDW TMNT who never followed TMNT before?
My guess is somewhere in the range of none to hardly any.
Donatello19
07-08-2013, 09:43 PM
I don't know, maybe like 7?
Cipher
07-08-2013, 10:08 PM
My guess is somewhere in the range of none to hardly any.
I mean, I don't know about "never" followed the Turtles before (as in even avoided the '90s craze), but my experiences on other comics forums, review sites, and even the 'Drome have turned up quite a few new fans who've never followed the comics or shows in any serious way before.
This is the first TMNT comic I've read and I'm a longtime comic fan. It got me into the classic TMNT comics too. I've always read Marvel, DC, Image stuff, but by the time I was mature enough to expand out past the superhero genre, the the Ninja Turtles comics were pretty much over. I picked up the IDW comic because I found out Ross Campbell was drawing an issue and I love his art. I ended up picking up the the previous issues, then I got hooked and started tracking down the old Mirage trades. Once I saw Jim Lawson's art, I completely went over the moon for Ninja Turtles.
I did watch the old cartoon a bit when I was a little kid, but I was never what you'd call a diehard fan. So I guess the point of this overlong post is that I fit the bill.
Like this. This is cool to see.
Heather Breckel
07-09-2013, 12:29 AM
I read the Archie comics back in the day but didn't do Mirage until after I decided to check out the IDW series.
snake
07-09-2013, 12:36 AM
I've never heard of anyone reading the IDW series who hasn't been a fan of turtles before.
So it's probably a small percentage.
Vi11AiN6
07-09-2013, 07:53 AM
I'd say MAYBE 10% of the market is new. Those are probably young comic collectors who are just discovering TMNT. Comics aren't like they use to be where you could pick them up at the corner store (like I did with Archie Series Number 1)
IDW isn't readily available except in comic stores/online. Also it's a label for franchise fans to get their fix. I'd say as a company IDW is writing GREAT comics for comic fans who love these characters. So in short they are marketed towards pre-existing fans of comics.
dragonside
07-13-2013, 04:45 PM
LOL i started all the comics simulatenously... since i started off with the shows....
So when IDW began, that was my first time reading TMNT comics. and now I'm reading it along side Mirage in the the hardcover editions.
I think its pretty awesome to see the original and IDW's simulatenously, as they release them.
Leo656
07-13-2013, 06:12 PM
Comic books themselves are getting more niche, to say nothing of TMNT. I don't think a single person in the past two years has walked into a comic book store, saw an issue of TMNT and said "Y'know, I've heard of TMNT but never watched the cartoons or seen the movies. This looks like a great place to start." The shops around here also only carry a small number of issues of it, almost entirely just for those who have TMNT on their pull lists. So that means pretty much everyone reading the book specifically asks for it, nobody's just walking in and picking it up on a whim. If you're not already a TMNT fan, you don't care.
Generally speaking, there is still a significantly large number of people who call themselves "TMNT fans" who have never read a single issue of ANY of their comics. They've never been popular as a comic book property, which is why casual fans and the general public always calls them a "cartoon show" rather than "comic book" property. The Mirage books, especially, are ridiculously obscure; I was the ONLY person at my comic shop who was getting Volume 4 and Tales. It was disheartening to hear the owner say "Nobody even knows it exists, it's not popular and nobody buys it", but it was true, nonetheless. TMNT are always going to be known for, and have more pop culture penetration, as a cartoon show.
So generally speaking, the only people who read TMNT comics are/were already big fans, the way it's been since 1988. Now, if you want to talk about people buying the TMNT book who simply never read comics in general before they started reading TMNT, that's an entirely different topic of conversation...
CyberCubed
07-13-2013, 07:28 PM
A lot of people just don't read comics period, and I'm an example of that.
I'm a huge Batman fan, yet I have not read a single Batman comic outside of browsing through some pages from time to time at a local comic shop. I've seen all the Batman TV shows, cartoons and movies yet I've never gotten into the comics.
TMNT is the only comic series I've followed. I have all of Mirage and Archie and am up to date on IDW so far. I've actually run out of room to store the issues, I don't know where people who also follow DC and Marvel have space to fit their comics. I only buy TMNT and I have over 200 issues!
Leo656
07-13-2013, 07:51 PM
Comics are awesome and everyone should read them.
Where you put 'em depends entirely on what kind of place you live in and what else you collect. You gotta prioritize. Most of mine have been in storage since I've had to move often in the last few years, so that's "lucky" I guess, but I'd still have room for them here, factoring in closet space, empty corners, etc. Right now I have 7 tightly-packed long boxes worth currently at my house; there's about 12-15 more boxes in storage. I stack 'em 4 high and they don't take up much space. Moving boxes around to get to the books you want, well, that can be an issue, but collecting comics "seriously" requires a variety of sacrifice (space, time, money, a certain degree of sanity). But it's so much fun.
I lost count of mine a few years ago (though I do have a comprehensive list of everything I own, as well as what I still need, cataloging absolutely everything is mandatory for collecting), but after inheriting my Dad's collection when he passed away, it's definitely in the 8,000 range. The "jewel" of my collection would be my Superman run, including almost every single issue of every Superman book published from "Man of Steel" in 1986 until 2010, and a good number of other issues, the earliest being from the early 1960s. Second, would be my complete Sonic the Hedgehog run from 1993 up until 2010 (when moving made me stop collecting for an entire year and a half), including every mini-series and Special. Third would be my TMNT run; I'd estimate I have about 95% of everything, not counting reprints and alternate covers, etc. Those are my three largest and most complete runs.
I'm not someone who just collects to store 'em, though; I actually read most of what I own (not all at once and not very often, obviously). I only buy stuff I'm going to read, never ever just to own a "hot book". I just happen to have very, very eclectic tastes. And I love to read. Like, more than a little bit.
200 is a nice-sized collection for anyone, though, especially someone who generally doesn't follow comics. There sure have been a lot of TMNT books over the years; it's just that they weren't all very well-received. Let me know if you have any multiple issues of Mirage or Archie; I'm still missing a small handful. It's cool you were able to get those complete; that's something I'm still struggling to do.
Coola Yagami
07-14-2013, 02:41 PM
Comics are awesome and everyone should read them.
I agree. To me comics should work in one of two ways. You should read em and be a fan of whatever series, which helps you get excited whenever there's a new movie or cartoon based on that property.
Or two, if you like said movie or cartoon so much, check out the comics where they came from and I'm sure you'll love them too.
As for the original question... probably 0.01%? I don't think anyone is gonna see this comic and have never heard of the TMNT before in any way, shape or form. I doubt anyone would take the risk and check it out for the hell of it.
CyberCubed
07-14-2013, 03:06 PM
The problem with comics in general is after a new series begins its hard to keep track of. It's no problem for fans like us who know the property, but casuals who check out the comics because of a movie or cartoon will likely be confused.
How many people only know that Dick Grayson is Robin, and none of the others? Many people don't even know there's more than one Robin, and Dick hasn't been Robin in the comics since the 80's.
MikeandRaph87
07-14-2013, 03:13 PM
The problem with comics in general is after a new series begins its hard to keep track of. It's no problem for fans like us who know the property, but casuals who check out the comics because of a movie or cartoon will likely be confused.
How many people only know that Dick Grayson is Robin, and none of the others? Many people don't even know there's more than one Robin, and Dick hasn't been Robin in the comics since the 80's.
Problem is the comics are not like the cartoon. If they were we would be buying boght and left. I much before watching Ninja Turtles on tv then ever reading a comic. That is the problem.
Heck,I grew up with Dick Grayson and Barbara Gordon as Robin and Batgirl and was very disappointed to learn they had replacements and were some other costumed alias that was not nearly as cool as who I knew them as. I have a nice sized classic run of Batman related materials due to that discovery and preference just as TMNT Adventures is by far the superior of the black and white comics especially Image because its closer to what I knew growing up. If the comics and other media coordinate and show the same things than I think comics would be better off as far as sales success and interest.
Coola Yagami
07-14-2013, 03:30 PM
Problem is the comics are not like the cartoon. If they were we would be buying boght and left. I much before watching Ninja Turtles on tv then ever reading a comic. That is the problem.
Heck,I grew up with Dick Grayson and Barbara Gordon as Robin and Batgirl and was very disappointed to learn they had replacements and were some other costumed alias that was not nearly as cool as who I knew them as. I have a nice sized classic run of Batman related materials due to that discovery and preference just as TMNT Adventures is by far the superior of the black and white comics especially Image because its closer to what I knew growing up. If the comics and other media coordinate and show the same things than I think comics would be better off as far as sales success and interest.
The problem also is, cartoons and movies have to keep up with the comics and go forward. With reboot after reboot after reboot, we'll never see Batman have a Robin in a movie past Dick Grayson.
The final seasons of the first Batman cartoon came real close with the Tim Drake Robin and Nightwing. Young Justice also featured the modern Superboy, Blue Beetle, Nightwing and Tim as Robin. I would LOVE to see a new Batman series with Damian, Batgirl, Red Hood, Nightwing, Red Robin and Batwoman. We also need an Avengers cartoon that has the current members, including The Thing, Spiderman, Spiderwoman and Wolverine as permanent members, not guest stars.
Superman with the new Man of Steel movie will hopefully continue forward as well and show characters like Braniac and Metallo that have yet to be shown on the big screen.
Pro tip: it's probably more than the 10% quoted earlier. Myself and 2 others who love DC and other IDW series got into the Turtles ongoing by word of mouth. Funny what happens when a company puts out a good series. None of us have ventured out much more into other TMNT series (besides the Nicktoon, it's amazing).
Cipher
07-15-2013, 07:16 AM
None of us have ventured out much more into other TMNT series (besides the Nicktoon, it's amazing).
Okay, but read Mirage.
Go do it.
Stop reading this post and go get Ultimate Collection 4.
Zulithe
07-15-2013, 07:38 AM
The series has been getting good reviews and positive buzz for a while now. It probably saw a boost in readership after Nick TMNT started to gain awareness. However when you look at its sales from both Diamond and Amazon compared to other licensed books it's selling so-so.... I suspect not many of those readers are all-new, mainly because new TMNT fans probably skew younger and young people don't read comics in significant numbers. They are (perceived to be) expensive compared to other forms of entertainment.
The new Cityfall storyline definitely provided a boost in sales... hopefully it will stick, but with comics it seldom does. Readers are fickle.
If neither Nick's popularity or Cityfall's acclaim can build readership gains, the next big chance is when the live action film comes out.
I would suggest any curious potential new readers to pick up the collected editions that you can find on amazon for about $13-15 each. This is the best value you can find. Search for "ninja turtles idw" -- easy!
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.