PDA

View Full Version : Mirage V1 fourth print cover art


Plasticplayhouse
07-31-2013, 12:41 PM
i saw this pop up on CAF and it raised a mental flag for me, so i wanted to ask around to see what other tmnt comic art fans have to say.
http://www.comicartfans.com/GalleryPiece.asp?Piece=1037037&GSub=144740

first off, the original painted cover is belongs to Steve Lavigne. it was given to him as a gift from kevin and it hangs in Steve's studio. i've seen it in person and Steve touched on it in our conversation when i mentioned that it was my all time favorite cover. i have a photo of the original painting and i also have this issue. comparing the two, they are virtually identical. the painting does have ever so slightly more detail. for example, the brick face of the building contains additional nooks and cranies that the b/w drawing does not. same with the shading on shredder's helmet and the back of his shirt.

i dont want to start rumors, but my gutt is telling me that the black/white inked art shown (as lovely as it is) is a recreation or worse yet, a fake.

i suppose it's possible that kevin did the original drawing and had the lines transferred to artboard so he could paint them, thus creating the painting used for the cover from an original drawing.

or maybe it was vice verse, kevin had the original image transferred to paper and inked over it creating a recreation of the original. but why would he do that? would he do it now, making it appear that it was done years ago knowing he could make a ton of money off it? my heart wants me to believe that he would never do such a thing.

i find it hard to believe that this is legit. it looks practically identical to the original painting which leads me to believe that this is a very good recreation by someone.

my gutt is telling me no go, but i'm not exactly an art expert either, so i am holding onto the thought that there is a possibility that there is truth to this piece. what do you guys think?

Mayhem
07-31-2013, 01:31 PM
There is, of course, another possibility... Steve is the one who consigned it for sale, and thus it is the original. But you're right to be suspicious because of the nature of the cover and that its current ownership IS known.

Plasticplayhouse
07-31-2013, 02:18 PM
There is, of course, another possibility... Steve is the one who consigned it for sale, and thus it is the original. But you're right to be suspicious because of the nature of the cover and that its current ownership IS known.

the one steve has is a painted picture. these are definitely two different pieces of art.

Rockvoanjd
07-31-2013, 03:08 PM
Wow, just wow, time to sell the boat truck and bike!

Roseangelo
07-31-2013, 03:11 PM
I think it's very possible that this is either a duplicate of the original or the original, but either way I do think it's legit.

If you look, this piece is signed by Kevin twice. Once dated 85, once dated 86. It is not unusual for Kevin to have penciled something and then inked it later (the very first turtle ever drawn is dated as such). So Kevin either painted onto a copy of his pencils and inked the original later, or vice versa. At least, that's hat it looks like to me.

OA
07-31-2013, 03:44 PM
This cover was offered to me a few years ago, before I knew about Laird's finished painting. My understanding at the time was that it was bought from Kevin way back in the day. I have no reason to believe that this is not the real deal. There are a few finished/inked pieces that were lightboxed then painted on a separate board. So in the end there are 2 covers. I much prefer the painted Laird piece myself, but this is definitely no slouch.

Mayhem
07-31-2013, 03:57 PM
So the painted Laird cover IS the actual cover on the fourth printing itself, as is?

Sofistocat
07-31-2013, 04:24 PM
This is a pic of the painting upstairs at Shellback Artworks. The bottom left corner has the info for who did what on the art. I also included a pic of a cover proof I picked up for reference and the B&W art Playhouse is referring to. There are a few differences, mainly the ones Playhouse was talking about. Another difference is that Laird's name is not below Eastman's on the B&W as it is in the comic cover.

I tend to agree with Roseangelo. IMO this most likely is a recreation of the original that Eastman inked. My best advice would be to ask Steve Lavigne via the Shellback FB page. He has answered some similar questions for me before.

I do acknowledge the second, silver, signature. As you look at the whole B&W pic, is it me, or does this not seem like Eastman's inking style. I feel it's VERY clean for Eastman...

Powder
08-01-2013, 12:20 AM
I'm with this guy. It looks way too clean. Plus for it's age it looks remarkable, and most of the works from back then were not stored in the best of conditions so I doubt it would have held up this well. Just my 2 cents. Try sending an email to Kevins assistant, she may be able to run it by him.

Archon_Turtle
08-01-2013, 04:17 AM
Has anyone thought to ask one of them?

OA
08-29-2013, 08:10 PM
Sold for a cool $13,085! :o Turtles are hot right now

Plasticplayhouse
08-29-2013, 09:02 PM
What?! That's crazy. It wouldn't have made it over $5k this time last year.